 Let me try it. You're able to do. All right, great. So hi, good morning. Good evening, everyone. This is Ritu from Hyperledger Hyderabad chapter along with me is Karthike. We collate the Hyperledger Hyderabad chapter together. And we are very pleased today that Bettina is with us. It's an honor Bettina. I had been your fan. All this while the kind of work that you do. And I'm super excited with this topic because this is something very unconventional. And not many people have talked about it. It's a blend of, you know, how blockchain meets the generated work. And this is super amazing. And people who know Bettina, I think she has got so much of buried kind of experience, be it finance, be it creative field, be it blockchain, Bitcoin, you know, helping young ladies and, and I mean, it's a, it's, it's a mix of almost everything which is, which is why, you know, and so we are very honored to have her on this session today. Before she goes ahead and introduces herself, I want to tell everybody that, you know, this is going to be a really cool session. Please keep your questions on the chat. And what we will do is take up your questions at the once Bettina is done with her presentation. But just in case if you have any pressing questions, of course, you can just message down to me personally, we will take them, take them up at that particular time only. So Bettina floor is all yours. Thank you so much for taking time and coming here. I would let you introduce yourself. Yes. Thank you so much for having me. Again, I hope everybody can hear me clearly. I am Bettina. I am the founder and CEO of Betty Media, which is a studio in a creative studio that I started in 2008. Basically, a year after I had left the world of finance, I used to work in Wall Street, I used to work with big names, Lehman Brothers, JP Morgan, Credit Swiss, you name it. And I spent my time there for over maybe about eight years. I went straight from high school, went to the world of finance, and I was a financial analyst. I always thought I would get stuck in that world. And so, but I did. And then, but I was never happy around at all, because, you know, really, my core has always been, I have been a creative person, pretty much all my life. When I was younger, I was doing painting and music and acting and you name it so. Around maybe mid 2000s, that's when I was playing around with my space and I used to basically hack the front end. Back then they, you know, they allowed us to customize the front page and at the time we all didn't know what coding is we didn't know what HTML is, but we were just doing it so I am a self taught. And, but as time went on, I would go back to college I would go to college for graphic design, all concentration and animation. And I don't know who that is. Kevin, can you please keep your eye. Give me a second. Sure. I would. Bettina you have to unmute yourself now. Yes, I did. Perfect. And, and before that, just a quick note everybody request everyone to please keep yourself on mute unless until you have a question. Thank you. Thank you Bettina please go on. No problem. And so just long story short, I would, you know, get into the world of design and UX design and I never thought I would be in a world of blockchain and crypto was around the time of 2013. I was asked to redesign city, the actual bank, one of their trading portal. In my time there, I would basically learn of Bitcoin. At the time it went over my head I really didn't think of anything I just thought it was a silly idea. Five years later, I'm watching a program on Andrea Centenopoulos in regards to the future of Internet, and the future of money. And I had my aha moment, I would get into the rabbit hole of blockchains and one of the first crypto event that I went to happens to be the world of crypto art crypto artists group. And I saw, you know, how smart contracts work how artists were using the smart contract. So it's very at the time it just made it all made sense they don't came together. So the last six years I've conducted independent research in the world of blockchain conducted due diligence to, you know, for various companies. And while my day job is still running my own creative agency with my team. And so, like, let's get started. What I've been doing also is that, which is interesting the last year or so. I got into AI filmmaking. Because a few years ago, I started really getting into the to filmmaking, but not an AI nothing related to blockchain but I really loved directing films so I was directing a lot of films and overseas and the conversation of blockchain was often talked about in the world in Europe, and how to protect a lot of these works. And something that was interesting to me. And many in the film industry has been talking about it the last couple of, you know, we may about last two years really. So if you're in the world of film three, if you follow the hashtag film three on Twitter, you'll see quite a number of well known filmmakers even Al Pacino's daughter is in the world of film three so let's get started. But before, yeah, before I delve into, you know, AI filmmaking, it's understanding what blockchain is. Oftentimes people get it, you know, confused. What I will say is that, you know, just full disclosure, full disclaimer is that you know me and whatever I say is not, you know, my company as well. No, we're not affiliated or in any way shape or form with hyper ledger so my thoughts and what I say here is my own. And again, thank you for having me Ritu. I am in a group called the Phoenix Guild a group of women where we basically, including the non binaries. They mostly based out in India, where women help and mentor the women in tech and non tech, learn about blockchain web three coding solidity rust dowes you name it including finding jobs so I was invited to speak with you in regards to this topic and she had informed me you all generally cover tech topics and more details around hyper ledger but haven't done much talking on public chains and layer two. And so before I had accepted this talk. I did inform her my views on hyper ledger and that there is a misunderstanding sometimes on hyper ledger and that it's blockchain that really in fact it is a distributed ledger and there are pros and cons to it just like blockchain technology which is blockchain technology is a decentralized ledger, which is permissionless and censorship resistant so I wanted to make that clear because of what we're going to be discussing regarding the smart contract and blockchain based layer two products that could help alleviate some of the situations that we are having. And again, each have their own benefits depending on what one or a business is trying to achieve that that's, you know, that you have to do careful research on. So, in regards to the space blockchain space, often we are at what's brought up is the equity and fairness whereas often I see many including companies reverting back to the old ways and not embracing what actually works to combat the equity and the inequality. And often it's due to fear the government man shareholders lack of education, and the powers that be you name it. And so, one of the recent events is the AI generated works many have been worried about whether they will have jobs in the future right. Today I'm here to give you a little bit of peace of mind. AI will not replace humans again repeat after me AI will not replace humans, but what it will cause is major income and equality. So far it has caused about 50 to 70% decrease in wages, just in the US alone, according to the US National Bureau of Economic Research alone. And so worldwide it's getting harder. I thought what could help is to show that there are equitable solutions to alleviate or minimize this problem. And so creators such as artists, designers filmmakers photographers writers journalists and so forth and so on. Oftentimes they get the short end of the stick and have it worse. And so the reality. And I thought long and hard on this. The reality is I put true equity to work. It requires decentralization. It's by making adjustments to the imbalances. So think of it. Think of equity as like picking apples from a tilted tree or curve tree for it to be fair you need to customize tools to identify and address any quality for one to reach the apple tree. If one is not tall enough right so you see in this image there's a curve tree one is able to easily pick the apple with a shorter ladder, while the other one had to have an adjusted. A ladder that's a bit taller to reach the apple, and no one is interfering from them picking the apple. All they have is a customized tool to help them reach the apple tree. And so the tools that we have, these are not new tools for some reason the media have demonized the space so much the blockchain and cryptocurrency space and it has portrayed it as some big scam. And what I will tell you is that blockchain and cryptocurrency that idea has existed for what about three four decades. So almost for Satoshi Nakamoto decided to do develop Bitcoin and the godfather of blockchain and cryptocurrency is David Chom he had written his paper on this distributed ledger and you can read it online, feel free to do so back in the 80s. And so he had stated from the get go that blockchain will decentralize power that was what it was meant to do. In his research laid out the technological basis for blockchain and Bitcoin. Small contracts for some reason many think it's metallic who created smart contract and I'm, and it's not it's Nick Sabo, who is one also computer scientists back in 90 in 94 he had written a paper regarding smart contract he was the one who coined the term. So, recently I saw someone on LinkedIn. After I guess the, the department of the United States Department of DOJ, I guess, indicted another group of scammers for basically stealing $350 million. This person on LinkedIn had basically stated it was smart contracts fault. And I wanted to be answer him but I just didn't feel like it because you know and do time people will know. And what I will say is that he stated that smart contract is not a smart nor contracts and something he's correct because the term should never have been stated called smart contract it really is a scripted string of language code, but again. So, I mean, it is what it is. And so he did stated that it he thought it was mindless grossly misleading and foolish web three catchphrase but again at some point he will know that smart contract is not a new thing it's existed since 90s in the 90s and and it actually can work. It's been working for many artists, the last two decades. And so, in regards to AI generated works right. AI generated works is really deep learning algorithm trained on data sets of millions of millions of images descriptions and writings variations of works scraped from the Internet. And how people have been introduced with AI generated works is through AI generated art. And what I will say is, love it or hate it. They are here to stay. And AI, it will change what company companies create. It's changing how companies create content. Some have stated it will replace stock photography and imageries. Yes and no, most likely they will work hand in hand with stock photography and images that you see that many have collected online. And it will be similar to how we see music. And if you know that music today has been, you know, have used past works and samples to create something new. It's similar to this for AI generated art. It's basically a taking works of art and coming up with new work through basically users entering prompts to try to come up with a new idea. And another AI tool that most many, many have gotten involved in and completely mesmerizes the chat GPT and chat GPT is a powerful AI bot developed by open AI. And the GPT stands for Generative Retrained Transformer. So basically, it's when you enter a prompt or a command or an action sentence, it's basically used to communicate with the AI and other AI language models such as chat GPT. And so you will see that from this example, that there are limitations. And, you know, there, the limitations can vary. So it can right now as chat GPT the way it is right now, it has generated incorrect information. It has also produced harmful instructions and bias content. And much of the data is all from the Western areas. And so just to keep that in mind, you know, and so, and for years, AI researchers and those who work closely with AI have been sounding the alarm in regards to the bias content and how when working with AI and companies ought to have diverse workforce to build these types of AI and there was a reason for that. And this is what's going on. And so far, it's been both awesome and also chaotic and crazy, but know that it's limited with knowledge of the world and events from what it said, it's only taking information from after 2021. And so chat GPT is not in, you know, all the other generated art tools are not the first bots. And so the history of chat bots is interesting because it dates back to 1965. And the first one happens to be Eliza and Eliza is basically interesting. It was created by Joseph Weissenbaum. The bot was designed in a way to mimic human conversation. And so if you read here, it's very similar to how you see chat GPT. And so how he built it was Eliza worked by passing the words that users entered into a computer, and then pairing them to a list of possible scripted responses in the script that they use was the simulated psychotherapist script. And so here you will see Eliza mocks the role of Rogerian on psychotherapist work. And so the original program was described by Joseph Weissenbaum in 1966. And so it was implemented by the Norbert Landstein in 2005. And so this is what you will see. You can feel free to check back the recording to read it so we can move on. What's interesting about Eliza and it's very similar to what's happening now is that Mr. Weissenbaum also was disturbed of how many users were confiding their most profound thoughts on Eliza. And it's similar to chat GPT where I've noticed friends who are basically asking chat GPT, many things I'd never thought they would. But you know, and when I checked Eliza, it was pretty much very similar, right? And Weissenbaum stated as well. He rejected the idea that machines or AI could replace human or human intellect. So similarly, he did notice that many of the users were anthropomorphizing AI. So what I will say is that humans for centuries have always anthropomorphized things from deities to statues to cars, you know, when you know I have no friends who name their cars. And so it's all because, you know, of connection. They have faith in and it's human nature. But AI is not human. And I know this because I too built a robot back in 2012 and 2013 for my piece of statement for my bachelors at a fashion Institute of Technology, where I got my graphic design and design degree. And so I my thesis was on human robot interaction and artificial companionship. And so what I did notice is that the children, my friends kids this is them. And the stories and did seem to see the bot as like a little human. And while you, you know, the adults were kind of mesmerized and yes they did ask lots of questions about the weather and music and all that. But at the time, the software that I did use and programming it wasn't as efficient as what we have now. So all of us have to remember AI is just a tool, and that AI is a processor, and that you know, kind of like a blender. And so how I can explain to people in regards to AI. It's basically like you have a concoction or an idea to make an amazing dish in the kitchen right in mind that you want to make. And it's, you know, a dishes like a art, or piece of work to as well. But to do that you got to either make it all make all the ingredients from scratch, or be organic by growing your own veggies fruits and spices. Think of that as the sources of where the AI is pulling from to create the new concoction or art. However, you decide if it's too much. And if it takes too much time, you can choose to go to the market to get all the ingredients that the farmers have grown themselves right and now. Do you take all the ingredients from the sources, quote unquote the market and walk away without paying the market or the farmer. Or do you buy the ingredients and the sources that you need to make your concoction. And why I'm saying is there is that there has been debates whether AI works are similar to human work and whether AI works can be copyrighted. When it comes to recipes. They are not protected by copyright due to the idea expression dichotomy it's basically this legal doctrine and the US and Europe have adopted that as well. I differentiate from an idea versus an expression, and I will say that I am not a copyright lawyer, but I do have works that are trademarked and copyrighted. And what I will say to you is recipes, right. Can they be protected. While they can't be copyrighted. Yes, they can be patent but it has to be, again, incredibly unique. A novel process or a manufactured recipe, not obvious to anyone. It must be a utility with full disclosure. This is what the court stated. A way to remember is like Coca Cola. You know, that beverage or that should agree soft drink very distinctive drink. It's like no other. It's interesting because Coca Cola had pat in their recipe back in the 1800s, but as time went on they decided to not because they changed the recipe through the years that they decided to not pat in it to basically to ensure the recipe remains undisclosed so it's a trade secret. Just keep that in mind. And so why I'm saying all this, it comes back to the whole inspiration versus imitation. And so many seems to be confused about the difference between between them. Take for instance, my favorite chef and then he bought a rest in peace. And he once said there is no lying in the kitchen and no God there either. He couldn't help you I anyway, you either can or can't make an omelette. You can or can't chop an onion, shake a pan keep up with other cooks, replicate again and again perfectly the dishes that need to be done. There is no credential no amount of BS, no well formed sentences or please for mercy will change the basic facts. And so what he's trying to say is that I have his cookbook. And when I want to spruce up his signature dish, the birth bogeyman imitating him. I'm copying what he wrote in his book. Does it make this doesn't make me a three, four, five star Michelin chef. I'm not a world renowned chef. And so, why is that because these are people who are professional who have been doing this for all their lives they have studied. They have studied spices they have studied every food in the world, you name it. They know how to grow they know what people love. They know this art more than anyone else. And so, can I get inspiration from them. Yes, can I take what Anthony did and try to make a twist out of it. Absolutely. But it has to be distinctive to the point where it's not so recognizable like Anthony's birth bogey knew. And so, going back to AI generated art. The last few months, a lot of artists and designers have recognized a lot of these AI generated art instantly. And why is that it's because it turns out most of these art were coming from the deviant art which is a website that has what over 300 something million I forgot the number but they have such an insane amount of art from artists who had uploaded their works for years and years and years. And each of them have their own style. Each of them have their own interpretation. And so, a lot of the AI generated art was basically, let's just say anyone who was prompting the the AI. What it was doing it was blending works, scraping things from the internet to blend it and come up with quote unquote something new but problem is it wasn't so new, because people were recognizing the written signature of the original artists. So, similarly to what I was saying about Anthony Boudin's birth bogey knew which is his basically beef. It's a beef stew, just so people know what it means. But, you know, if I was to imitate it's imitation, but if I was to make a little twist it has to be so distinctive of a very different from his, where people do not recognize it is his. I could say yes, this was inspired by the Anthony. And because of all of this attention of many artists had to call this out. There is now a class action lawsuit for basically these AI generated tools scraping and collaging the works without consent. And so, Deviant Art, for some reason was in November had basically stated they had a new tool as a way for creators to take back control and turns out they were had partnered with stability AI. And so that was interesting. And this was before the lawsuit. And Getty Images is the biggest stock photography company in in maybe maybe the world right and they too had to sue stable diffusion AI stable diffusion in the US for copyright infringement and you can see right here is a perfect example where you see that Getty Images pretty much modeled one of their images without permission and without compensation. And so I'm saying all this because this is interesting. This year. Last year. I get, yeah, Beyonce came out with a new album for you be hives, you know, I guess I did this for you be hives but I'm not a major fan or anything like that but it just was one this one was very interesting because there her new album Renaissance had from what I understand almost over 100 samples of artists. One of the biggest question in the music world. Many have asked whether or not this amount of sample is really original work. And because when it comes down to quote unquote these awards shows these award ceremonies. They often want to provide that award to people who actually, you know, did create a new work of art. So there's been a lot of debate what is new and what is not. But it's a successful album, and the fans love it. And so, when it comes to the world of music. Because in the past in the early 2000, when the internet, many were getting on it music was being stolen it through illegal downloading and peer to peer file transfers you name it. And so the music industry and Apple would come up with a solution to protect artists music artists. And so, today, you know, it's not unheard of now like now if you want to upload a piece of music with your content, you have to go through clearance. And these are some of the copyright clearances that you have to go through around the world. And, you know, line wire came back. It was the defunct file sharing website that basically was shut down back in 2010 for, you know, a legal file transfer. And they went through a lengthy legal battle with the recording industry. And so they were accused of allegation of music piracy and sort of federal judge found the platform cause copyright infringement on a massive scale. So they came back, and they decided that, you know, they want to get into the world of digital collectibles so they have partnered and strike the deal with the world of universal music group to help with music NFT licensing. Which is interesting because this is what this is the one of the original platforms that was really doing decentralized peer to peer transactions. And so, now, in regards to one of my passion the last year has been the AI filmmaking. And I just showed you a lot of like what the music business have done and what's been going on with the world of art. The AI filmmaking which is interesting. They've embraced AI. Now, one of the things we had seen the last couple of years were deep fakes because initially their intent was to deceive. They are incredibly in terrifying at first glance, but a lot of people in me included saw some use to it. And what I mean by that is that, for instance, you know these are two night show host. I put it in because this is interesting because they switch they swap on John Oliver's face with Jimmy Fallon's face. And you could see how incredible it has become. And why I'm showing this is because in the film industry reshoots are expensive and what that means is when you're making a film. Sometimes you may have missed something or missed a scene or miss part of a scene miss something that's in the scene that didn't needs to be there and you need to shoot. And oftentimes you can't the art of the actor is not available, or maybe there are another film set or across the country, what do you do. So now they are solutions in regards to, could there be a model or they're stunt double to be able to, you know, take them in place, and to do these type of, you know, swapping. And again, the actor can actually license their imagery, their, their voice and likeness in their contract and status. And so, recently, the Mark Adrian from, he's a VC, and the rocket scientist, I'm not kidding you, Aaron Hamner, his name is, they decided to go on Twitter and create a movie. They did a full script on chat GPT they had chat GPT write a full script and come up with 100 story ideas. This is not too long ago. Write 100 story ideas and 50 scripts, including the pre production, the shot list, and this is what we do. And it was pretty incredible because I was like, this is really awesome. It's pretty simple. And because, you know, yes, creating scripts takes time. So, coming up with ideas sometimes takes time. And so, when it came down to chat GPT it was able to provide all these shots, one detail the details of the shots, the props, the outfits, you name it, the outfit details. And through prompts. You know, the user have to ask questions and really try to get their answer that they want. And so, the full script was able to, they plug in Dali to, which is another AI tool AI art generated art tool and mid journey to get some of the imagery and filmmaking this would be basically the story board we would either draw it out or come up with imageries to kind of get the store what the look and feel would be for the story. And so they were able to get all of that by plugging in all these various tools. And they brought in actors and these actors were able to memorize the script. You can see it online it's called AI writes a directs a movie it's crazy. Now the bad part of this is, it wasn't a great script. It was really bad and funny and awkward and somewhat cold. So, that's one thing about the AI. So what's good. Again, it's efficient. It does help with gathering your thoughts, but oftentimes, it's not the best tool to rely you have to make sure you are proofreading you are editing you are fact checking it. And the thing about chat GPT a lot of the outputs are so generic. So they're not too interesting. So you got to keep that in mind but as time goes on I can see it being more interesting as more people start playing with it. And what's that about it. Again, we were talking about what I mentioned earlier was the can, will people lose their jobs. Yes, will, will there be any quality income inequality. Yes, but more jobs will be created that we will need researchers and editors and fact checkers. And another thing that I recently noticed some a lot of people started using it to clone websites are very dangerous because some of these websites being cloned and a lot of people mistook the website for for another website the real one and so you got to be very careful with them because they are they can be risky and so they are scammers out there actually cloning by using these AI tool chat GPT to clone websites and identical. So if you're buying something from those websites, you may need, you may end up getting robbed. So you have to check if this is a legitimate website and that's where we come in as where that job will be needed to provide that kind of verification and trust tools may need to be built. And so what's ugly about it like I said is generic for now on it still needs people on again lots of scammers so we keep that in mind. But what's also awesome about these AI tools, particularly in AI filmmaking, we do see that there's going to be a lot of personalization and CGI licenses so this is a perfect example. So there was this app in China, where users could like swap that put their face on actual movies. And so this is a perfect example, where you can see yourself as the actor. And so I do see that, you know, down the line that, you know, through smart contracts and blockchain that let's say, you know, Mr. DiCaprio will license his his himself, and I could see that the, you know, you know, he can be paid through the smart contract through his wallet and that's that. And so, and that is what we have to remember when it comes to AI technology. It's, it's a technology and technology is a tool. And it's not human. But there are pros and cons on to the AI, just like anything, you know, just like any web. Is it a weapon? Can it be weaponized? Can it be used as a weapon? Absolutely. Anything can be used as a weapon, but just, I think one of the things that we need to be calling for is regulation. For years, many who work closely with AI we've been calling for regulation for so long, but it did not happen. And then full control of security and privacy. This is so important because right now there's a lack of security and privacy and many from what I from last a few months ago, somebody's medical records was found inside on one of the AI tools. So that's just one of the example where, again, it's scraping information. We don't know where everything and that these tools, these softwares, these companies need to be basically providing where they're getting the source and it's happening more and more where they are starting to do so and open AI did partner with, you know, well, Microsoft took over. So it's now no longer quote unquote open source. It's now closed. So it's a subscription based application software. So it'll be interesting. Now, the takeaway is that AI is like a blender. Keep that in mind. And that AI will need fact checking and edit and proof read. And I will say research and research and research. Don't stay dependent on it's not something that is far fetched. And it's not that it's not difficult at all. It just requires patience and willingness. And so I guess we will chat a bit more and you know this is my contact information. Definitely do feel free anytime to reach out to me. And then now, yeah, I'll take any questions. Right. Thank you so much, Bettina. I just love the fact that how creatively you have, you know, taken this session and helped all of us understand in a very simple terms. I just loved all the pictures you added, be it the apple tree, the ladders are the other ones like the blender blenders and other pictures. Thank you so much. We have one question to answer. So the question is that do you think the chat GPT will take over the educational tools? Will it stop people from relying on formal education? Well, this is interesting when it comes to chat GPT right now a lot of schools are are banning it. I am not surprised. Because YouTube is, I didn't realize also YouTube is kind of banned in many schools and YouTube has been one of the greatest platform for education, but a lot of school has banned it. There is, there was a developer programmer who actually did create a tool to verify whether or not students are using the chat for if they were to plagiarize. So there are now tools that are popping up to verify if one use chat GPT. Now, I think it would be great for schools to take on chat GPT. Because why it, like I said, it does help one to gather someone's thoughts. But if you notice it's so generic. So you have to kind of think. I think right now schools are not teaching students how to critically think we were I was having a chat with a few people on a business group, the critically thinking part is going to be vital for the future. For now and going in the future. And so that's really how one can break free from the AI. We can't just take it as is. And so those who do think outside of the boss box, those who do think critically will win. And especially if you think critically you're able to create create you, you're able to come up with things creatively. And so that's how I think about chat GPT and all these AI will it stop people from relying on formal. That's what I'm concerned I do think that many will be dependent on it. Like, recent, like the developer of Eliza he did notice many did take what Eliza was saying as is and and did think of it as a human. And so I'm not surprised and I did see that through my own research. Are the schools banning YouTube and chat GPT because they will lose their importance in the education industry as clearly the education system is lacking to prepare for the future. I don't think so I think. Yes and no. Because here's the thing, even though YouTube has amazing content. There's still certain things that it lacks. You know, I mean, when I'm conducting research, I don't only depend on YouTube, I'll go through the archives and you know medical journals and books and all of that it, you know, if you were to go through YouTube, you know, it doesn't have a comprehensive information in regards to our history and mathematics, you'll get a general idea but really education. Does I will say the education industry right now what's really it's going on is it's costly. And so that's another reason why people have relied on the, on the free services and what's online, it's because it's costly and so the, the industry may need to start looking at new models and, and, and thinking how to not make it affordable for the sake that's the you know should people are in debt because of education. So did not pass. Okay chat GPT did not pass the test and oversee I thought I'm sorry. Okay. Maybe put I'll ask the other I'll, I'll look at the other question. I'm not sure what overseas I thought okay what kinds of jobs you for see popping up in the come upcoming five years with AI without being an AI engineer. Yes, I do see, for example, I brought up websites right someone have brought up websites to me he was like, Oh, it's going to get rid of all these jobs and web design and all of that no longer UX. That's not true, because what AI is doing is just vision, it's just a trying to mimic and scraping visual designs. And so you still need behavioral science scientists, yeah you still need psychologists and researchers. There's going to be a lot of fact checking. So, I do see that's what's going to happen. Cyber security is going to be needed. Just because things on, you know, on the front end is looking great and look, you know, perceived to look great but under the hood it's not smart contract a programmer is going to be vital. So, start spoofing up your smart contract because that's, you know how people are going to get paid, you know, as more of the courts basically saying, um, you know, making their thoughts known that AI generated works are not can't be copyrighted but that, you know, how can you protect your work if you're an artist, start copywriting your, your work. If anyone out there other than just lawyers, start thinking outside of the box so what solutions you can offer in regards to copywriting. Right now, copywriting isn't the, you know, the way to go about it isn't great. I had to go through a lawyer and all of that it's just so cumbersome and if someone can make it simple. That would be great. And so yeah, that's one of them can we test smart contract using. There are those who are testing it. For what I remember there was a WYSIWYG tool smart contract tool that I was testing a while back and I had revisited the person who was selling it and I thought, this is a great idea but this was like, but two years ago. And I don't know if the company is still doing it because they had a platform where they can help artists and creators write their own smart contract very easily. And so you could use AI to test the smart contract but you would have to make sure you understand the code. You don't want to have the AI create the smart contract and not know it could be it could be bad code so there's a lot of bad code. So that's something you have to remember. Government will put an AI ethics related guidelines. I hope so that's been one of the things that many been calling for for years. And it should be out there. I really, we need an overall regulation. That's big time. That's what we really need AI. Especially what you saw earlier where the deep fakes, I could see deep fakes happening more and more when it comes to the politicians. So what's great, what's going to happen, because more and more deep fakes are going to be popping up in the world of the pop in the world of the political sphere. I just think that more and more people are going to be showing up in person to hear this if they're their official their elected officials, just to confirm who if what they say and are real legitimately real, instead of watching TV. I don't watch TV I don't even have a TV but this is just a perfect example. But younger people are going to be going to events more and more and they are your, I do see print coming back to, you know, high quality prints. People are going to want to, books did make a massive comeback for some reason, I think people wanted to feel a bit of connected to paper and not be so much on the screen so that's another thing you got to keep in mind. We're going to be reverting back to certain things. And yeah, let me see what else am I many powerful tools require a license yes, don't you think I will eventually a license for anyone to be able to use it it would be great. Yeah, that would be great. For example, can anyone fly a plane or drive a car. Exactly. Well, anyone who gets the license can your thoughts. Yeah, I think. Right now chat GPT is a perfect example so subscription base so from what I understand the free version is not it gives you a limited. The larger one is not limited so you have to pay for it. So I could see in some ways that that could be. Yeah depends on what it is and how what they are trying to do. But yeah, I could see that too. Thank you for wonderfully insightful presentation I have a question regarding a comment you may, if an AI like job upt is great be from unknown sources how can an artist know their work creations being used by an AI. Like I said, the written signature people's written signature their actual name. They were seeing the, it was coming off. It was coming on it. The output was showing that similarly to the that's how getting images was able to catch it they were able to see on their name on on the actual image so it was collecting that that's how they were able to identify that that the chat GPT. The art generated works were stealing that now for a chat GPT a little bit different because it's text based. It's, it's, it's kind of, it's basically similar is scraping information off the internet. And so the company is states the same thing so it's not. It's really the art, the AI art works that were more likely to see it instantly know that it's someone else's work. Cheers Bettina you to cheers. Just a hypothetical question. If I use this previously made AR to produce new art. Will there be a point in like two decades that the art made from AI steam or pet yes repetitive and less creative as a number of original art made is reduced significantly absolutely. Now, a lot of the works if you see it's super stylized work in nothing that is, you know, at all a little bit outside of the box. I think that's what's going to happen I think it's going to be extremely repetitive, homogenized, and just boring, as was, as like what we see with online if you notice a lot of people use stock photos the free stock photos I've you I use free stock photos for placement as before I, you know launch I don't know if I decide to buy an actual work work, but, but yeah you free stuff you have to be very careful and then with AI generated art it will be repetitive it's just going to everything's going to look alike and you can't remember anything. And that's where you guys come in you you create something new and different. Thanks Bettina for such informative presentation. Thank you. Thank you, massage. Thank you for the lovely session. Yep. Don't know why but decentralized. He should irritating me because there is something hidden in that what you say about that. No, it's because it's basically so think of similar to if you were to come to me and buy a piece of actual paint painting. You give me cash for it. That's the centralizations between you and I, there is no banks involved with no one to to stop us from transacting. That's what decentralization there's no middle man. It's just the differences is that with decentralized blockchain is that it's online. You know, and, like I said, that has existed for a very long time. But there are amazing tools like I didn't bring up Bitcoin on smart contracts. That's pretty cool too because there are people who are working on Bitcoin smart contracts and the more and more people trust Bitcoin more than ever. And, you know, it's been though, oldest now over a decade. Cryptocurrency so if you were to create an NFT. Now there's NFT Bitcoin to that I'm still wrapping my head on, but they on the protocol. Yeah, I mean, I don't see why not. What are the current alternatives to chat GPT. There's a company called you.com. You.com is one. It's a browser. They actually had a I think they are using chat GPT or something else but yes, chat GPT. The you.com is pretty cool. They were first to kind of show what how to use the browser. Obviously, Google had theirs was did not go well of again their AI researcher had warned them not to release it but they did and their stock portfolio. And so now they end the $80 USD. Yeah, they really did a mess because it wasn't. It was. Yeah, it was bad. You can read up on the Google lambda, or I forgot the name of it but what opportunities and Web three and AI do you see coming up the horizon for entrepreneurs. As I stated in AI filmmaking is huge is growing. So that's film three so if you follow the film three hashtag that's a big one. You can see that more and more AI generated works is going to be the use more and more people are going to be using create web pages but again at the end of the day are going to need developers and some programmers to ensure that the test. That's the actual site if you were to launch. Anything from AI. What else for entrepreneurs. I'll get back to you. Well, that's the lot will bar be the most advanced. Yeah, that's the Google bar. That's the what I was saying the alternative chat GP three. The most be the most advanced and chat GP T I have no idea I don't think so. Because so much is happening with Google. There will always be some think that's going to come out of nowhere remember I said Eliza was one of the first they were other bots. I do think there is a little bit of hype with chat GPT. I think it's going to die down a little bit it's kind of almost similar to Alexa when there was so much hoopla with Alexa now it's nobody really not saying no one cares but it's not it's going to die down. But what's going to really stay is the AI generated art AI generate film milking on chat GPT will advance a little a lot more but it's going to die down. This session was very insightful thank you for for you welcome do you mind sharing your Twitter handle so participants can. Yes, my handle is but Tina. And then my other handle for my business in Betty media so but Tina is my personal Betty me as my, and I'm on LinkedIn. I'm mostly on LinkedIn, but feel free to add me if you want. Oh, what else. Don't know why but the central okay got that. I'm a blockchain, but I still I found a lot of vulnerabilities and smart contract absolutely. There's a lot of vulnerabilities and smart contracts of major projects I do agree. Again, until more and more people get into smart contracts and build and test. It's better it's similar to what websites used to be they were really buggy back then, and people just kept, you know, trying new things, but I will say is that do try to work with others ask around. So many people are doing so many great projects and they might have thought of something that you may not have thought about so keep a lookout that's why I don't think so that every normal can study it. Yes and no yeah it's kind of like websites, you know, not everyone can be web designer not everyone can be website design but not everyone can be construction workers so it's similar to that. And I think I got everything. Everyone. Yeah. Thank you so much. Thank you this was really amazing and see how comments are coming in on the insightful presentation and of course the questions also were very good and help us understand more. Thank you so very much. Not everybody knows that it is past midnight for Bettina a lot of gratitude from us, taking time off, and you know working, working through showing us the presentation. Thank you really, and thank you everybody to, you know, come in here ask your questions making it more interactive. Any questions you can also post in on the meetup page. And since this is being recorded the YouTube video would be uploaded on the official high potential channel. I'll put the link on the meetup group. I'll also put Bettina your credentials of Twitter and LinkedIn, so that people can follow you and keep that knowledge coming through irrespective of the sessions. Thank you so very much. And thank you again so much. I, again, if I sounded long winded it was it's been a long night. But yeah like I tried to keep it simple. There's a lot going on. Again, and what I say now just remember what I say now will change tomorrow, as you know, like just remember it just verify so much is happening every single day. It will also get organized as a so yeah. Okay, well feel free to ask me any questions and again really do join film three I would really love to see you guys on there as well. And so it, you know, it's so much exciting things are going to happen in the space. Thank you again. Thank you. And can you go to in sick to get one on one meeting what is that I don't know what that is. That that's okay I think that's. Okay. Okay. See you all. Thank you.