 Is it just me or is there something seriously wrong with Joe Bynes nominees who over and over again are proven to be severely underqualified for the positions that they've been nominated for well today Senator Kennedy had a chance to question one of these judicial nominees Kato Cruz and it did not go well for him I don't think this guy is gonna get confirmed much less able to get a job anywhere ever again Judge Cruz you handled a case Called v. Annette operating group v. Maurice. Is that right? That's correct senator, and you were reversed in that case Is that right? Yes, sir You handled a case called Mooden the University of Colorado. Is that right? I believe so senator. Yes, and you were reversed in that case, right? I believe a portion of my recommendation was reversed Yes, okay. Did you did you handle a case called Vreeland v. Vigil? Yes, senator, and you were reversed in that case to portion of that was reversed as well. Yes, okay Did you handle a case called Vreeland v. Olsen? Yes, senator, and were you reversed in that case a portion of that was reversed as well. Yes, holy crap We still got four minutes of this video. How many of these are there? Okay? You handled a case called Key Bank National Association v. Williams. Is that right? Yes, senator Were you reversed in that case senator? I've issued over 1500 recommendations and orders over the course of my Mansion that is one that was partially reversed. Yes, okay You handled a case called Renault V Cardenas Do you remember that case? Yes, senator, and you were reversed in that case too a portion of that was reversed as well Okay, I think this is all leading up to something. I'm not a lawyer Okay, so I'm not a hundred percent on this if any of you know you have to let me know But I think this is all leading up to a question that Kennedy's gonna ask at the end of this Do you remember a case called Janie? v. Gomez Yes, and were you reversed in that case portion of that was reversed as well Is this normal about a case remember this case judge? shorts v. City of Denver The name is familiar senator right for all the cases. I've handled on not recalling particulars about that Okay, do you remember being reversed in that case? Senator I not specifically recalling that case Okay, you remember a case called Lucas v Board of commissioners. He's just kids Larimer County The name is familiar senator the details of the case Do you remember being reversed in that case, sir? I don't recall off hand. I'll see I told you Do you remember I had actually watched all the should be? Colorado Department of Corrections Yes, senator were you reversed in that case? I'm not recalling off hand if that was one where I had a partial reverse Okay, do you remember a case called ACV Jefferson County School District? Yes, senator Were you reversed in that case? It was partially reversed in that case as well. Okay. You remember a case called Blake? the United States The name sounds familiar senator, okay, do you remember being reversed in that case? I don't specifically recall that Okay Well, I've got others here in cases that you Handled in which you were reversed. I wonder why he was reversed Tell me why you've been reversed so often judge well senator as I indicated I've issued over 1500 recommendations and orders over the course of my career when I Approach any of these cases. I approach them all in the same fashion which is to Analyze the law analyze the Supreme Court intense circuit precedent that bears on those cases And I apply those cases to the law as a or to the facts of that case as a magistrate judge Many of those are recommendations that are made which are reviewed in Novo I respect the decisions of those district judges who viewed those circumstances differently. Okay. Thank you judge I wonder why tell me how you analyze a Brady motion How I analyze a Brady motion Yes Senator in my Four and a half years on the bench. I'm not don't believe I've had the occasion to address a Brady motion in my career Do you know what a Brady motion he is? Senator in my time on the bench I've not had occasion to address that and so it's not coming to mind at the moment what a Brady motion is good Do you recall the US Supreme Court case Brady v. Maryland? I do recall the name of the case senator Yes, and what it did hold I Believe that the Brady case in well senator. I believe the Brady case involves something regarding the second amendment It is not I've not had occasion to address that if that issue were to come before me I would certainly analyze that Supreme Court precedent and apply it As I would need to to the facts in front of me. Thank you. Mr. All right So he doesn't actually say why he mentioned all those reversals and then finished with that question So it turns out that what he was talking about the Brady motion has nothing to do with the second amendment has nothing to Do with Brady laws according to Bloomberg law Kato Cruz a magistrate judge in Denver who's been selected for a district court seat there Couldn't define a Brady motion and how to analyze it at his confirmation hearing on Wednesday The motion enshrined in a landmark Supreme Court ruling is a request by a defendant to compel prosecutors in a criminal case To turn over potentially favorable evidence when Cruz was asked how he comes to his decisions He said that he analyzes the constitutional precedent. I Approach any of these cases. I approach them all in the same fashion, which is to Analyze the law analyze the Supreme Court intense circuit precedent that bears on those cases But he doesn't even know this basic constitutional precedent now like I said, I don't know anything about this stuff I'm not a lawyer, but it seems to me all those cases that Kennedy was listing off may have been reversed because this guy didn't know anything about the Brady law Wait, no, I'm sorry the Brady motion Anyway, just a humorous look at another one of these Biden nominees that just seems like they were put up there for reasons other than their Qualifications. Thanks a lot. I hope you enjoyed it If you did please share subscribe hit that like button and make sure to leave a comment to continue the discussion. Thanks a lot I'll see you on the next one