 Nga pun po at magandang umaga, magandang gabipirin po sa kahit saanman po kayo sa partin ng mundo, welcome to the 75th installment of the Stop COVID That's Webinar Series brought to you by the University of the Philippines. Thank you for being part of our credible online community and to all those who have just discovered us for the very first time today, welcome po at sana po masayahan po kayo sa pag-join sa ating online community. Ang salita po ang infodemic that has been used by the World Health Organization, eto po ay tumutukoy sa mga perials and traps of misinformation during a disease outbreak kagaya po ng COVID-19. Ang malipong information, it can influence ang mga ugali, behavior po ng mga tao and the overall social response that could result in the worsening of disease transmission. Kasi po yung mga tao, pwede po silang magpanik, pwede po nilang makalimutan yung mga health protocols, misinformation can also undermine legitimate efforts of the government and the health community to keep people safe. Dahil po meron po magtataling po ng mga agam-agam, mga doubts, discontent, frustrations baga, yun po ang nadodulot ng wrong information. Kaya naman po, if you want to be armed with the skills on how to determine if something you've received in your inbox, yun pung nakikita po ninyo sa inyong feed, sa inyong social media accounts, kung ito po ba ay totoo, hindi, fact po ba to, or fake, then please stay tuned. I'm Dr. Raymond Francis Sarmiento, director of the National Telehealth Center, National Institutes of Health, University of the Philippines Manila. Always a pleasure to be with all of you during our regular Friday lunch date and I always look forward to Fridays because I get to share hosting duties with my partner and our adjunct research faculty at the UP Manila National Telehealth Center po. She is also the special envoy of the president for global health initiatives. Dr. Susie Pineda Mercado. Dr. Susie. Aro po sinyan lahat, san man kayo na ron and we have people from all over the world and all over the country watching Raymond. We hope you're all doing well and as promised, we have a very interesting format for today and we'll try to make it work. I hope you will enjoy it. We wanted to talk about, sabi ng Ali Raymond, maraming mga information na lumalabas kayo na hindi natin, alam kung totoo hindi. So pano natin malalaman kung totoo hindi totoo? Di ba mayirap pe, kasi minsan pinagahalo yung totoo, tsaka hindi totoo. Anyway, we have a very interesting session today. We also have really very interesting guests. So our speakers today are well known for their work in media and their social media presence. So marunong sila noon. Kaya para sabi namin siya, bitahin natin tung mga baguets na pagagaling sa social media. So ano, anta ba yan nyo po? Maganda po mga pag-uusapan natin ngayon. And Raymond, we're going to later show them how to use the Mentimeter, right? So anyway, Raymond, 75 episodes na nga pang may good. Yes, yes. Encounting, Dr. Susie. Encounting. Sige. Okay. So sige, to be mon na natin Raymond. I think we have something from TVUP. Raymond, go ahead. Yes. Thank you, Dr. Susie. Gaya po na nasamin ay Dr. Susie and para na rin po for the benefit of those who are joining us for the very first time. We usually start with a person on the street video created by TVUP para lang po mailagay po sa konteksto ang ating pag-uusapan for today. Ang mga katanungan po, General, katanungan po na aming tina-nong sa aming mga persons on the street. Ay paano nyo po ba malalaman? Kung totoo o hindi ang inyong nababasa at napapanod sa social media. So please watch this. Na-verify ko yung factual, yung pagiging factual ng nakagita ko sa social media if it comes from trusted sources and you can search then sa Department of Health na sa totoo ba yun? Sa kapanahan kasi ngayon, marami talaga yung fake news layo napot sa COVID. Na-una lahat, sa lahat, hindi gignan ko yung source, saan ba to ng gale? Sino nag-post, hindi gignan ko yung profile kung opinion ng tao yun. Sino siya? Kung organization naman, anto. Usually naman, pinagkatawala ako naman yung name speed ko given the echo chamber and the algorithm. Parang alam naman na siguro ng Facebook na I'm only interested in looking at trusted sources. So rarely talaga ako nakakita ng fake news. I think niko siya ba hanap with other like two sources siguro. I'm not really going to believe that it's true. Experience ko siya sa province namin, sa room don. Kasi meron don na nakakovidaw yung kaibigan ko na binalita nila through Facebook na may covid daw yun. Tapos nung tiyan nang ko siya, nung kinamusta ko siya, wala naman daw, wala siyang symptoms na kahit, na symptoms na ibang covid, wala naman daw. Welcome to my barang guy, ang source of information ko na talaga siyong Public Information Office page ng barang guy, ng city namin. Yung narili ko ngay, hindi parang ako niniwale kasi sinasabi lang kumukwanti yung cases ng Philippines about covid. Bakit congested ang hospital, at bakit hindi report kung ano yung nagkocongjes, mild symptoms or severe or moderate symptoms? Masusabi ko nalang sa mga tao na nagpapakalat ng fake news. Don't do na itulay. Nakasamayon. Kailangan yung mga naniniwala sa tutoong news, kailangan maging laging updated online. I have to spend time online para tumulong. It's really hard to combat misinformation on social media given our echo chamber. So we really need to tell at the platforms that we're using, what we want and the content that we want and how we're going to interact with that platform because it really matters. The information that you see is more likely our reflection of you. Thank you so much TVUP. It's always great to get the pulse of people or ordinary people what they think of things. And Ramon, ano nga ba yung echo chamber? Echo chamber is if you are in a chat group or in a page and you're just seeing confirmation bias kung baka, Dr. Susie. Ang Englishin mo. Ano ba yung? You are essentially being surrounded also by people with like-minded opinion. So how will you know if paray-parayon na mapalakayon ng opinion or ng mindset how will you know na ito bang conceptong ito o pinagusapan ay talagang totoo po ba kung wala po kayong counterfactual at the beginning. Ka, of course, if you are a friend mo yung talong gusto mo. So you probably think in the same way and have the same opinions. Ano ba yan? That's correct. That's why in let's say in Facebook there are pages that maybe pro X, Y, and Z drug or pro sa district of treatment that may be sort of controversial in treating COVID-19. So may mga ganun po. Okay, well, teka mo na, alam mo Raymond may nag-detect sakin na hirapan daw silang pumahasok sa na hirapan silang pumahasok. So sa webinar but maybe they can join us through Facebook. That's correct. Dr. Susie we are being live stream po sa YouTube channel na TVUP as well as the Facebook pages of University of the Philippines top COVID-19 and TVUP po. As mentioned in previous webinars this webinar can accommodate up to a maximum of 3,000 participants. We are just numbering less than 700. So we hope that those who have registered at least for our webinar for today ay makasali to. We have very, very first time po ito po nating pakulo for today in terms of the webinar. We hope we'll be able to see all of your friends, your colleagues, your families po who are joining saan na po sa Zoom and if you are watching po sa inyong mga watch parties please give a shout out po sa chat ng inyong mga social media accounts po and we hope what we'll be able to greet you during this webinar. We'd also like to invite everyone to participate in what we are calling a fun game not a squid game but a fun game po which will be held only in Mentimeter for today in order to include our viewers in Facebook and YouTube. So everyone pakibuksan po ang inyong mga internet browsers naigita nyo po sa harapunin nyo pakitay po on www.menti.com and use the code 1-8-0-3-9973 that's 1-8-0-3-9973 para po kayo ay makapag-participate at dun po sa ating mga nakapakinig sa ating last webinar last week meron po tayong special prizes sa mga mananalo po sa ating pakulo for today po Okay, over to you Dr. Suzie. I don't know, may price po lakari, mo nag-bibirulang ako may price tayo. Yes, we do have a price. We do have a price Dr. Suzie. Thank you so much to the office of the vice president for public affairs and to TVUP for arranging this. If you know this is a big money price. Ay, so ang price po natin ay meron po tayong shirts. We have shirts hindi ko lakong TVUP do you have a picture of mga t-shirts po kasi we have that. Kamiyan pa natin natin. Ayan may food pack pa daw food pack. May food pack, may food pack pa. Okay. Great, great. Kasi gaya, Raymond. Tako mo na. I think people want to know how they're going to do the Mentimeter. Paano ba yan? So you'll step by step step by step kung paano lang gagawin kasi I'm sure the millennials use it, right? Okay, yes. Pero it pa ka-edad go medyo. Alam mo na. Millennial then. Okay, game, game. So we uliting ko lang po, we request everyone to open your internet browser and then type in www.menti.com if we could have TVUP flash on the screen again. There we go. Yung code. Uliting ko lang po, wala po tayong poll na may kita po sa zoom. Lahat po nang magpaparticipate po for today. Ayanan dito po sa www.menti.com. Paano po kayo mga kasale? Pag meron po kayo nakitang box don or field na empty. You just type in the code 1-8-0-3-9973. That's 1-8-0-3-9973. We are also putting in the chat yung poong very, very quick link para pumakapunta po kayo doon. And for today's very special format which we are calling a game show format. There will be two rounds. So dun po sa first round, obviously we'll have questions coming in from our guest speakers for today. Dun sa 2 rounds po na yun. Magpapalo po ang isang Q&A session where we will entertain questions from zoom, facebook and youtube audience. Pero paano po ba kayo sa sale sa ating game show? So for each round meron po tayong questions kung saan po yung mga top scorers may kita nyo po kung sino po yung mga top po na mabilis na naka sagot po doon sa particular na question they will their names will be flash on the screen para po alam po natin kung sino po ang makakatanggap ng ating very very special prize and for all those who are meron na Raymond meron ng mga no eh meron ng mga nakapasok sa mental takah kulitin lang nating no. So our guests will show something they will say ito galing sa social media fact or fake tapos sa scootin nyo kung fact or fake yung unang naka-sagot yung first first five or first ten I think it's first ten because we have five questions per round the first ten get the prize tama ba yan Raymond yes that's correct that's correct the first to see anong unang anong unang tamang sagot ok uwan nyo and then for for our audience po we will only be flashing you will have twenty seconds dalo wang nasingundo po para lang kung makasagot at makapapapapapapapapapapapapapapapapapapapapang game quiz or fun quiz po for today before baka baka makalimut ako lang po for those who are asking especially those who have received their certificates for some and maybe not for some we are issuing certificates utolito-utolay lang po ito certificates will be issued to those who have attended Those who have attended at least 50% of the Webinar duration and for those who are still asking bakit pa hindi po silang nakarisew ng certain certificates. I think we have already sent out at least for the last 73 webinars po. We are still checking for Webinar 74 if we have sent out all of the certificates for that webinar. And hopefully wala na po magkatanong, but if there are still those who are asking for their certificates of attendance, please don't hesitate to contact us at stopcovid debts at up.edu.ph. Meron din po mga nagtatanong, maybe we could ask our team to put it on the chat. Paano daw po kasi may mga hindi daw po naka, or having trouble registering, that's one of the questions that we are receiving in the email. We will put in the chat po so that you could share also with your friends, families, and colleagues po, how they could register and then they could enter po sa ating zoom. We are still numbering a little, well less than 750 which is quite unusual and hopefully we could invite some more para po makapag-attend sa ating... Kung kailan po tayo may anong special, po isa na po ay dumami po ang mga makalangalong ng prize. Yes, I got, po sinisilang mahapasok sa zoom. So I think if you really can't enter zoom and you're watching on Facebook, just think on Facebook. Kasi the mantimeter can be done even if you're not on zoom. So stay put lang kayo. Okay na tayo Raymond. Yes, okay. I did na ako. Okay. So thank you very much Raymond. We were thinking about, this is a very important topic kasi lalo na sa inyo mga front-liner. Kailangan tama yung minibigay nyo information pag tinatanong kayo, di ba? Eminsan, napakahirap alameng kung tahama ba or mali, so today we thought we'd have a fun way of doing it. And wag na makayin mag-pre-pressure di ba kung mali. Sakot nyo, okay lang ngun kasi lahat ay lang kaamali pagda ting sa ganyan ay pero itong mga guest natin dalubahasa silang they're very good in social media. So they're gonna give you some tips and they're gonna tell you what to be careful about. And to open our program, it is just fitting that we have somebody who is really our guide. Hindi po makakaroon ng webinar na ganito, kung hindi po dahil sa ating Vice President for External Affairs ng University of the Philippines, who is also the reason why you will have a food bag. So, welcome Vice President Nanny Burnia. Nanny, welcome. Hello, good morning. Good afternoon napala. Yes. Okay. Oh, Nanny. Go ahead, Nanny. Okay, so, wait, I am a little okay. There I go. Yeah, welcome to the Diamond episode of Stop COVID Dips. Being a communication person and someone who uses social media, I find today's topic and format especially important. Distinguishing between truth and falsehood in all forms of media, whether the conventional mass media or the social media is an important literacy skill that all audiences must develop. When the COVID-19 outbreak was declared a pandemic, it spawned an infodemic. With large numbers of people relying on online and social media to access real-time updates on COVID-19, even well-meaning people spread misinformation, shared false claims and erroneous warnings with false cures or remedies as a treatment for COVID-19. The social media actually helped, but it also hurt a lot in the dissemination of information. So, I thought by way of opening today's webinar, I will give you some context about COVID-19 discussions on social media. Thank you, TVUP. Okay, so, I would like to share, to show you a few graphs that depict a year's worth of COVID-19 conversations in the public social media. This graph represents only part of the data that from a study on communicating COVID in post-quarantine Philippines, which was a research study conducted by a multidisciplinary team from the social sciences, from the health professions and from media and communication. Next slide, please. COVID-19 figured as the topic of public conversation until now, but beginning on February 26, 2020, we started tracking conversations on public social media. In this time period that I'm showing you, this is a year's worth. So, from February 2020 to January 2021, there were in total 156,000 conversations about COVID-19 and they clustered around six topics and their color coded in this graph. They were about the IATF, the new strain, vaccines, testing, DOH, and health protocols. Okay, so you'll notice that in the bottom of the X-axis, you'll see a brown line and those brown zigzag lines indicate discussions about the IATF. Conti lang. There were also some discussions about the new strain and you'll notice that they are also just a little bit, but towards the end of the graph, which is just about December to January, December 2020 to January 2021, There were slightly more discussions about it, but notice that there were really three topics that drove the conversations and these were the health protocols. So, you know what they are, mask, shield, wash the hands, keep safe distancing, and then about the DOH and testing. The green shaded areas here are health protocols. The purple ones are DOH and the ones in yellow are testing. It was in the early days of the pandemic until the lockdown. So, this was about February to the end of March that had the highest number of conversations. Then they slowly tapered away, but you will notice that there are spikes nonetheless. And these spikes were normally around those areas that I talked about. These social media postings also provide valuable information because we can determine the feelings behind the posts. So, in the past 18 months, since the start of the pandemic and the consequent community quarantine levels, we the Filipino people have gone through various emotions of fear, anger, loss, compassion, and hope. Next slide, please. This slide shows you the emotions behind the posts. So, what we found were five general feelings, emotions behind the posts. So, the purple ones are anxiety and fear. The blue ones are empathy. The red ones are anger. Yellow is hope and green boredom. You'll notice that, well, there really is a mix of emotions all throughout the year. But of these emotions, anxiety is the most dominant. And among the main triggers of anxiety were government's handling of the pandemic, demands for concrete solutions, particularly for valid information, to increase their awareness and to reduce stress. Fear also showed in expressions about the increasing numbers of COVID cases, panic-buying. And there were also profanities and swear words that were addressed to the president and to the government for inconsistencies, for the perceived slowness of responses. I'd like to point out this spike of anger towards the end of the graph. This was around November. And this was anger mixed with some empathy. Because this one was about the time that there was a big typhoon in the north. And the rescue teams that were going to go there could not leave because of the lack of testing kits. At the same time that there was anger, people wanted to help, but then they couldn't help because they couldn't get access to testing kits. There was also expressions of empathy. Now to give you context of these various emotional spikes, I put in some events that the social media posts referred to. Next slide please. This graph shows you what were the events that triggered that number of spikes in posts and the emotions along with them. So in March 12, May 5, the main triggers were for, I'm sorry, in March 12. This was about the anxiety because of the impending lockdown. But look at that. Now just a few days later, the spikes in conversations were empathic. As people pointed out that organizations and individuals were raising awareness for donations particularly for our frontliners. There was anxiety as well towards May with the closure of ABSCBN. And then there was anger. On June 17, this was about the all-time high of COVID cases which caused panic and put SIBO in ECQ. There was also a spike in anger around the time that the president delivered his state of the nation address. And then on October 8, those of you who know SB 18 and follow them, there were posts that pointed out gratitude that SB 19 offered proceeds from their concert. November 14, that's the red spike which I told you about earlier. And then towards the end of 2020, there was anxiety which explained the spike in around the time of December 28 when the new variants arrived in the Philippines. You'll notice through these graphs that despite negative feelings, our struggles with COVID-19 awakened our innate ability to empathize and to be compassionate. This is shown in all the graphs and in the other graphs that I'm not showing you. Next to anxiety, empathy is the second most dominant emotion. And these were a lot of them from the start and towards the end of that year, the year 2020. These were calls from private individuals and groups, from companies and networks to support our frontliners via donations in cash and in kind and which were readily heeded by the online public. So the data here are only for the first 12 months of the pandemic. I'm sure that a continuing analysis, a continuing social listening will reveal even greater shifts and spikes in topics and emotions. This analysis that I showed you sought to determine topics of conversations and the sentiments that accompany them. And I think that this is a perfect foil for the discussion that we're going to have this afternoon on recognizing how factual or how false contents of social media are. So I will end here. And like everyone else, I'm excited to find out from our resource persons what are facts and what are fake and also to join the contest. Thank you very much. Okay, thank you very much. That's UP Vice President Nany Perna who is a moving force behind our webinar series kung wala po siya, wala po tayo dito. And napakaganda po ng kanyang mga pinakitas sa atin. Parang may anger, may empathy, may anxiety. So sa bingan nila, I was just in another meeting the other day Raymond where someone said to me communication is the best vaccine. Parang if you're able to communicate well, we can help people not get sick. So I'm not saying let's not get vaccinated and get me wrong. But I think we have had a number of episodes on communication because it's so, so, so important as VP Nany has showed us. And we really have to understand where our patients are coming from when they have anxiety, we should know how to deal with it. And when they ask us questions, kung fact or fake, dapat alam natin. And on that note, start na tayo sa game Joe. Raymond, okay, Raymond. Yes, okay po. So mga nakatanong po kung bakit wala pa po kayo na ikita sa ating mente dahil di pa po tayo nag-start, kaya po di pa po siya lumalabas pero pag nag-start na po tayo, lalabas na po yung mga katanungan. Before we proceed po, ulitin ko lang po ang ating game show ay nasa www.menti.com lang po. Patirin po sa lahat po nang nasa Zoom. So dung po sa mga nakatanong kung may lalabas po dito sa Zoom, wala po dahil lahat po talaga ay sa www.menti.com. So buboksan niyo lang po ang inyong browser. After you type in the URL, you will key in the code. Again, ulitin ko lang po ang code po natin. 1803 9973, that is 1803 9973. And I think yun po ang ating queue to start round one of our game show. Pero para po sa ating nakatanong sa mga prizes we will be giving away gift packages po generously sponsored by San Miguel Foods, the Food Division of the San Miguel Food & Beverage Incorporated. Binang pasalamat po sa lahat po na naging party o party po ng ating credible online community. Ang ating gift packages includes an assortment of products, Magnolia Cheesy Spread, Magnolia Milky White Spread, canned goods from Pure Foods, Protect Plus Gold, disinfectant powder na nasa sachets. Maraming, maraming, maraming po. So and the winners, ulitin nila po lamin, will have to pick up their prize-elected UP Constituent Units. Ulitin ko lang po ang mga nanalo po, they have to pick up their prizes at selected UP Constituent Units. For winners who are watching us from Facebook and YouTube, please fill up po the Google form at the link being shown sa screen po mga maya po. Remember you can choose to pick up your prize at any of our locations, Diliman, Los Baños, Manila, Baglio, Visayas, which is in Ilo Ilo City, Cebu, Mindanao, and Open University in Los Baños. So ulitin po, please pick up your prizes sa mga nanalo po at your selected UP Constituent Universities po. At para po makapakapakapakapakapapikap yung po, please fill up the Google form shared on the screen. Tandaan lang po. Maraming-maraming salamat and let's get the ball rolling Dr. Suzy. Sir Raymond, yung mga nanonod from abroad. Raymond? Ah yes. So yung mga nagtatanong po kung nasa abroad po sila, whether Italy, Canada, etc. Pwede daw po ba silang manalo para sa ating game show for today? Ang maari po ninyong gawin, you can nominate someone na nasa Pilipinas po who will receive the prize instead. So in this case, please fill up the Google form. Dun po sa link na naipakita po kanina. Again, yung nomini po ninyo should pick up the prize at any of our selected UP constituent universities. Dr. Suzy? Okay. So now we're going to call in our very special panel. I think almost all of them have been nanaton. Okay so let's call in Robbie Alampay who is founder and chairman of PUMA Public Productions. An nakikita nyo rin yan sa Channel 5. And then we have Joy Flaviere Alampay who is Executive Director of Asia Society Philippines. And we have Dr. Jason Ace Migot who you have met before. He's an International Health Promotion Specialist and Director for Development Communication with Organic Intelligence. And then we have Siege Tantenko who is the Head of Communications of PUMA Podcast. And then we also have Familiaries. Anyo ito, our Health Systems Specialist, Dr. Albert Domingo. Okay. So you can see them all. Agaganda, di ba mga guapot magaganda? Taka-showbiz tayo today, Raymond. Okay, game. So let us go to our first round, round one. Okay. And round one will be Robbie. But Robbie, before we start, Raymond and I were talking earlier about the echo chamber kasi napagusapan kanina yun. Yung bang echo chamber na yan Robbie, do people know that na yung mga naglalikes sa kanila, usually yung mga katulad din nila? Ano bang explanation mo dyan Robbie? Nag-adang hali po sa kanil na lahat. Very happy to be here. Yung explanation ni Raymond kanina, maganda na. I think ang mahalaga lang naman na example na alam natin lahat is yung Facebook friends mo. Dyan nyo, if you're looking for an example of echo chamber, yung Facebook friends mo. Hindi pangayong ano, hindi pangayong mga family group mo. Par misan niya, hindi mo pa echo chamber yan, yung gong angka niyo, sama-sama sa isang anang, mag-discover mo na hindi pala kami pare-pareyong mag-isip, hindi pala kami pare-pareyong ng ibo-boto, iba-iba pala mag-isip tung mga kapakako. And what dito? Minomute mo yung chat ng pamilya mo. Or hindi ka tumitingin araw-araw kasi na susuya ka na. And then you stick to kung sa angka komportable. Ito, Facebook, friends ko lahat yan. Kung ano yung pinapanood ko na k-drama, aba yung din niyo rin yung recommended na k-drama, kung ano yung type ko na pagkaya, aba yung din ang type nila. Tapos, pagdating sa politika, pagdating sa mga nababasa mo, mga sinusundan niyo na garyo, sinusundan niyo na kung ano, pare-pareyo kayo. Now that's the echo chamber, hindi lumalawak yung pananao mo, hindi lumalawak yung exposure mo sa iba-ibang information, lalo na yung mga taliwa sayo precisely because as we say you're in a bubble, you're in an echo chamber, pare-pareyo kayo mag-isip. Okay, so Robbie nag-ugulat ba sila? So nag-ugulat sila pag merong ibang opinion? Oh, siyempre. Pero dahil kaibigan mo yun, yun naman din ang kagandahan ng being in your bubble. Kung may nakakapasok na lihis yung pananao, parang mas bukas ka sa, pala-isipan na yun, mas bukas ka sa pag-ung mga opinion. Kasi hinala ko to eh, may alam ko, mautak naman yun, mas mautak pa sa akin yun na sa high school kami. So ang problema, and to get into this I think in the course of this conversation, that can become a disadvantage also. Because if you assume na itiwan na ako dito eh, pinos niya. So siguro baka ako yung mahina-hina. And then you start opening yourself up and that's why we're in this conversation because you need to become resilient also. You need to become open but you also need to become what I want to call information resilient in yourself. Okay. So mamaya pagusapan pa natin ang information resilient na. Sige Robbie, ikaw una. Sige go, what do you have for us? At pakita niya, meron ako sample dito. Ito, ito, ito. Natanggap ko to sa isang messenger group. So meron ako ang isang group ko, like all of you, marami time group. Meron ako mga kapatid ko, meron yung mga kasama na mga pinsan ko, meron yung mga high school patchmate ko, meron yung mga nakasama ako sa trabao, and so on. This is one group. Hindi ko nalagay dito yung source. Kasi kanina dun sa isang binanggit ng isang nagsarita sa video, tiniting ng ko kung ane yung source. So ito, hindi ko kayo Robbie o hindi ito. This is from the New York Times. Para lang malino yung context itong balita, so the New York Times reported vaccinated travelers from abroad can enter the U.S. starting November 8. Nung sinerto dun sa messenger group, yung naka-outtime, Pfizer-moderna vaccine, tanggapin ng CDC, Johnson & Johnson, kinaikilalan ng CDC, AstraZeneca. Tapos yung comment, look at the comment. Pansinin nyo yung brands. And then therefore that comment. Walaong sign of a. So question, ito yung first question sa game natin. Is that real or fake? There, fact or fake o game. Umulitin ko, ane yung time siyan. That's legit in the Indianian. Okay, let's go. Sige na, sagutin nyo na fact or fake. Tignan natin kung sinong mananalo dito. O cute naman itong mga to. Thank you Robbie. On tipo, uti-utipo talin ay kita yung mga nagpaparticipate po. Gaya po nang nasabi sa menti.com, enter nyo po ang code 1-803-9973 and you have 20 seconds to answer if this is fact or if this is fake. Canami ano nang mga itunog na parang. Mayan may to na. Ang pinapobotoan natin dito yung conclusion na sinera na pansinin nyo walaang sign o ba? Robbie walaang sign o ba? Okay, I think time's up. Ano po ba ang resulta ng ating first question? Tignan natin ang mga sumagot. Mano malabasa? We're still waiting for the 267 na sumagot po na lumabas sa ating menti.com ma-display. Marami rin po sa ating mga viewers are entering their answers in that chat. So marami-marami salamat po, but hopefully para po manalo po kayo ng ating prize ay nandito po kayo sa menti.com. May mga nagtatonong din po bakit hindi po tayo gumamit ng kahut ay dahil para po mas marami ang makasali para sa ating fun quiz for today. Ako ba? Medyo na bibitin tayo. TVUP ano po ang ating resulta for fact or fake? Ang stress na ko. Ang meron tayo pa pa kita? Medyo mabagal po ang ating menti, pero hopefully that's something that will be shared at least for our first question Habang naging tayo po sa ating question. I'd like to greet those who are watching us from DEPED, SDO in Ilocosur, Abra de Ilog, Municipal Hospital in Occidental Mindoro, Corazon Locsin, Monteliba, Memorial Regional Hospital in Bacualod City, Drug Abuse Treatment and Rehabilitation Center in Bukidnon, and Southern Philippines Medical Center in Davao. So TVUP is, yun, okay. So 167 po ang pumile ng fact and 100 ang pumile ng fake. Okay. So ano po ba ang tamang kasagutan, Robbie? I-flash natin orit ang senior ko. Fact, I-flash orit natin. We'll break it down. So gaya na sinabi ko. This is New York Times. Wala pambabora yan. That's New York Times. Legit yan. So this is a real article. It's a real article. Pero nung shin air, yung conclusion na yan. And that's why a lot of my friends read it because of this comment. Grade walang sign of that. For purposes of our game, dahil alam ko magbidibati kayo kung nakakalito naman yung tanong ni Robbie Alampai. But for purposes of our game, let's call this a fake conclusion. Fake yan. Yung walang sign of that. And I have another slide there na if you could flash. This naman is from USA Today. Another news organization major. Legit yan. People can debate whether it's more sensational than New York Times. Pero legit yan. And as you can see here, malinao na the US has two categories here. Yung approved ng CDC and ng FBA. At the same time, yung recognized by the WHO with EUAs. And sinabi ng US ano yan. Either approved by the FDA or recognized by the WHO. And that actually includes sign of harm and sign of back. Anyway, so what's the point here? Very often, many of us, kanina sinabi, tiniting nang ko yung source ko. And that's a good practice. Kailangan meron kang legitimate sources. Alam mo mainstream media yan, matagal na ang reputation yan. That's professional journalism. Backstop ko yan. So tiniting nang ko talaga yan. Kung hindi alam alabas yan, hindi ak maniniwala. So all of us need that. So bahala kakong sini yung source mo. If inquirer is credible to you, rappler is credible to you, GMA, interaction, pumapadcast, lahat yan. So mamili kakong aning na. But you need those sources. The problem is sometimes we will rely 100% on the source. And in this case, what happened with the New York Times is, clearly it's just a lapse in editorial call. It was also, I think, the New York Times hedging because there was still some confusion at the point that we shared that article. And so unless ang satanist, one source is not enough. One source is not enough. You have to rely on more than one source, ideally a baby of sources because nobody's perfect. And sometimes we also equate a not a negative. The absence of information. As confirmation of information. In this case, hindi binanggit ng New York Times. Therefore wala. But that's a leap in logic. And also you can imagine kanina sa presentation ni Mamnene, the anxiety of people. Di naman hindi satin lahat yan. There was anxiety over Chinese-made vaccines at the start. This was also playing into that. And people use the absence of information or any excuse they have to validate their own anxieties, to validate their own biases, even. So nakakita yung isa ng isang article na, ha ha, hindi binanggit ang sign of a, sabi ko nang aba, tama ako. And then they stopped there. But all you have to do is Google search, go to your other sources, validate this, go to primary sources, U.S. Embassy, and so on. Travel sites and so on. And it's very easy to see na, actually hindi, your conclusion was fake. And very often yan yung pumakalap sa circles natin. Because not only do you trust in your times, but you trust your bubble, you trust your friend. At Tony's New York Times imperfect, our friends are imperfect. So we have to, as I said, we have to enable ourselves and then trust our better judgment. Nice, okay. So bukod dun, sineropan nila, Robino. Okay, sinong nanalo Re1, patingyan natin sinong mga ako ng food pack. Okay, sinong po ang sampo na na, una po na mananalo po, makatanggap pala ng special prize. Ang kalilang mga pangalan are as follows, Rika Leneresta Maria Teresa Boto, Mary Anne C. Uy Lara Lintau, DeCevi Patrick Pepa, Mayly Jill, Ashley Lauren Avaricio, and Simba. Kayo po ay mga katanggap ng ating special prize at hopefully mas marabi ako po ang makasali sa mga subsequent questions. Okay, congratulations to everybody. Okay, let's go to our next. Let's call on Joy Flaviere Alampay. Go Joy, kaw naman. Yes, magandangpo na Joy. Yes, good afternoon. Salamat Mam Nene and Susie for inviting me this afternoon. So ako na. So my slide, Vaccines Turning Us Magnetic. So sino na bang bakonado sa inyong lahat? Kung bakonado ka na magnetized ka na kaya, or magnetic ka na. So nakita ko tong unang letterato at yung pangalawa, she nears sa isang messenger group ng Christian Youth Movement. So siyempre medyo iisipin mo sa groupong ganoon. Puro tuto lang yung pwede nating pagusapan o dahil anja ng joy, si Di tayo pwede magsabi nang hindi tuto. Anyway, big lang, mga mayo yung kumalap na to. Nagkaroon na mga videos, viral videos at nagkaroon pa sa Tik Tok ng game or ng mga palabas na sinasabing magnet test challenge. Then from there, dumami na yan. So ang gusto kong isipin yung ngayon, tignan nyo sa isang figure naman, videos kasi ito pero screening shot ko nalang. Dun sa isa naman, matipunoyong nagkakwento na tayo yung magiging magnetic pag nag-vaccinate tayo. So is this fact or fake? Okay, nice. Arayman go. Question number 2 of round 1 pa lang po tayo. 10 questions all in all. We are in second question of round 1. You now have 20 seconds to answer correctly dito po sa ating question na ito, is it fact or is it fake? So we appreciate those who are putting in their answers po sa chat but hopefully you'll be able to put them yamen. That's 1-803-9973 That's 1-803-9973 Maraming salamat po sa mga sumasang alien. Question ok, Joy habang sumasagod sila. Joy is an alien. Parang didikit yung magnet sa katawan mo. Yung nang sabi nila dahil mam baka mabigay ko yung answer mo. O mga muna, o sige mong muna kasi parang ok, game, o sige. Atapis na naman ok Manag po kayo na ikita na na nag-enjoy, nakakapresured daw but very, very makayar Sana po marami po ang makasali makadadi mo sa mente po We are still less than 300 na sumasali po but hopefully marami po po ang makapasok po sa ating www.menti.com Can we show on the screen the results round one, question number two ok, medyo naglalag lang po dahil marami po sa atin yung mga infographic kasi may mga icons po tayo habang nagihin tayo, I'd like to greet ang ating mga attendees outside of the Philippines naman po, those from Nagasaki University in Japan from Ho Chi Minh City in Vietnam from Jakarta, Indonesia and from Pulaupe ng Malaysia So I will greet yung pung mga iba po na ating mga attendees outside of the Philippines marami-rami po sila and hopefully we'll be able to get all of you hindi naman po, ah, samgup sal daw po ba ang food pack na ipapadala medyo po yun nag-ulat po ako pero that's brought a smile to our faces po marami-rami salamat po at tvup may we have the results of the mentee on the screen medyo naglalag lang po kasi mentee po na excited din po dahil sa takadami-dami sumasali dito mo sa ating game ang ating code po ulit na ulitin ko lang po ang code po natin 1-803-9973 marami-rami salamat po sumali at doon po sa mga nagtatatong pa rin po kung ano po yung prises po it's a, well, special package po ito hindi po siya samgup sal but it was generously sponsored by San Miguel Foods the Food Division of San Miguel Food and Beverage Incorporated po so maraming salamat po sa inyo. Do we have the results na? Can we have the results? Mentee is having a problem kung makulang So, habang nag-intay po doon Yes, po. Why don't we answer it now, Raymond? Yes, can we have it? Can we have the card po ulit on the screen yung pumpinakita ni Joy? Yes, there we go. Mam Joy, what's the answer po to your question? Yes, the answer is Masigabong fake. Okay, of course sometimes we just want to to still share even if we feel that it's hilariously fake and we see it that we just want to ask bakit nabaki na share pa obviously may mga bagay dun sa image and dun sa pagka-explain na hindi naman toto. So, ang isang problema yan, yung mga nag-share actually hindi maramiyan, hindi rin nila alam nabali yung siya nila share nila and in the spirit of information spreading they just do it without fact checking again as we've been mentioning. So, the problem is when we see things like this we assume it's absurd pero yung nga parang hindi na rin nag-check baka rin naman malay natin may katutohanan kasi may visuals So, people assume na output is equal to input tutong tao yun videos to. So, if you google ang dami-daming videos if you see a real person for that matter a medical professional a media person talking and very credible people be asking to talk moving and talking on these videos then it must be real reputation and experience nila on the line so, it's impossible ma-salita sila ng ganyan and ito alam ng mga taga TV UP if it is well produced people assume well produced e di siguro mahaba ang research to maganda ang pagkakagawa na daan sa high production value So, sa viber groups naman and messenger kung sand po siya unan nakita ano yun e quality equals quantity is equal to quality siguro ang haba-haba ng explanation ang haba-haba ng mga sinasabi therefore may bearing yun on the other side of this, imagine yun naman yung consequence of having very good input and research but yun production or the way it was presented is so bad then yan ang hindi ito to So, that's the dismay of some of our campaigns kasi the way things said e ba and ito iniisip ko rin na for many people in fact dahil masyado tayong maraming ano tawag dito the truth becomes boring kasi ano ba naman ang laban mo nakita nyo naman yung figure nung mama andaming kung ano nakadikit sa kanya So, yung nabakonahan walang nangyari so obviously exciting ba yun magnetic siya so it's also a function of a long running problem yung vaccine hesitancy and distrust natin for so long the reality is we forget from the very start the fear of the product has also lingered and the fear of the vaccines has become also widespread pero ngayon good news is people are yun na getting to know more and informing themselves but this is not coming from nowhere alam natin yung nangyari sa dingbak siya and all the other vaccines a lot of misinformation came around but it's also taking a lot of time for the health sector or the sectors that need to discredit the misinformation to happen in so that's why parang continuous parin yung process so yung absurdity tuloy-tuloy parin malayo ang nararating ng experience ng data but some people took faster some people took longer to get convinced up to now marami pa tayong gusto yung convince so ang ending ko lang dito there is a constant instinct to try to validate oneself including our fears and misconceptions alam ko mag neto sa ano yung nisa marvel sa avengers dinayon natin ko sino Raymond, sino winner natin naku kanina thank you so much ang pupilin ng fake we are seeing the names po i'll just read off the list of leaders po na sumagot ng tama Lenereza, Lara Lintau Desevi, Maria Teresa Boto Ashley Lauren Avaricio Christine C. Corpus Leslie Chepes, Mary Ann C. Uy and Ish. Maraming maraming salamat po as we move on to question number 3 of round 1 okay let's go it's the turn of A's A's ko naman baka naman pang phd dissertation yan na siya, ito na what do you have for us A's? di naman doc, unang muna sa lahat wala naman ako phd okay actually I wanted to share my screen para lang mapakita na yung typical yung typical na message na tatangap natin sa mga chat groups si Robbie and Joy mentioned earlier that they received their examples through chat groups and I think that's a very common experience for many of us now for me my personal experience has been I get a lot of messages I don't get as often now as before pero there was a time almost every day I would get a message like this and it's always parang doc ka ma ba ito and the message so unang unang-unang sa lahat na parang sabi ni Joy napakahaban yan, daming sinasabi na ito mga viber forward na ito it usually starts with some kind of ominous message about really telling us how bad the situation is this is what's happening elsewhere it could happen here and then it kind of segways what you would expect in terms of symptoms of COVID if you have this naku baka may COVID ka na and then it proceeds to dispense all sorts of different advice on how you can prevent COVID-19, protect yourself etc. and very smart whoever crafted this message palagi may call to action do not keep this information just for yourself, ibigay mo if forward mo sa mga ka-familia mo mga kaibigan mo that's how it happens that's how it starts these chain messages on these chat groups and i used to receive this so often so masalat nyo uluho kasi whenever i get this because to be fair if you read the entire message there are bits and pieces of it that are helpful so i'm gonna start with that so it's not all parang just fake news some of it is actually helpful information but it's very hard it becomes very difficult for people to discern what is fact and what is fake so let's take an example from this message one of the many pieces of advice that was shared through this message is para daw hindi ka magkaroon ng COVID lahat ng pagkain na kinakain mo ay dapat mainit baawal yung malaming na pagkain so question to our viewers today is this fact or is this fake okay Raymond orasan na natin sila okay thank you so much we apologize for the lag but it goes to show na very very excited and very active ang ating audience we are still number less than 1,000 but never mind that every question at ask mo ang nagpapartipit Raymond may mga nag-reclamon sila ng menti kanina nga nangdash daw nagdash ba nagdata ka siguro yung mga taga menti ano bang nangyari ngayon sa Pilipina sa tiglang ang daming sumasagot na kailangan po iri-start nil po maraming question okay uliten actually doc susi ang daming sumasagot na sa chat natin okay so we have for 22nd pa kaya hindi mo man darong menti titigin ako nalasinoin na una sa chat baka masabihin tayo na fake news tayo doc susi bidabida pa tayo sa menti masang maraming salamat po okay may results ba tayo? I think we have a result but I think we need to restart po yung browser to make sure that we are seeing the results maraming po sa atin ang mga okay okay so balikan natin to so kung yung topic natin today ay yung special recipe ng doc susi na nilagang baka or yung paelia ni Albert definitely mas masarap yung kung mainit pero kung ang tanong nyo sa akin is kung sa pagkain ang palaging pagkain that will prevent me from getting covid unfortunately that is not a fact it is fake however so officially yung nasagot natin it is not a fact it is fake however is it bad to keep your food warm in the first place no actually di ba okay ngayon for food safety that's what we say kailangan na sa tamang temperature ang pagkain pwede siyang magkaroon ng it reads an environment where it can spoil and it can be very dangerous even for you di ba it can get food poisoning so the follow up question i always get whenever i say actually this is not true is pero doc what's the harm baka naman okay lang if i do it di ba maybe as the evidence is not there or the conclusion is that it's not really going to help prevent me from covid what if i do it anyway and the danger with that kind of thinking is it gives people a false sense of security people think that by following these pieces of advice that are not based on evidence that are not facts that they are protecting themselves then they let their guard down when we know that it's still the same basic public health measures di ba that will protect us from covid 19 keeping our hands clean wearing a mask wearing a face shield maintaining physical distance and of course getting a vaccine yun naman paulit ng paulit natin sinasabi that will protect you from covid 19 so that is the harm actually and to be frank i don't know who composed the original message baka naman that person had good intentions but the fact remains that this kind of information it can be very confusing and frankly communication professional i feel there is a certain element in the design of the message that is really meant to be confusing wunan wunan napakahaba ang daming sinasabi tapos may very sensational pain pagkasulat sa kanya di ba if you don't do this now baka magkakovid kabukas kaya sundin mo tong advice at padalamos sa mga ka-familia ka-idigan mo that can be very confusing so later on in round 2 docs i'll share a bit more insight to prevent them from i guess reacting too much and following this kind of advice okay so siino na nalo Raymond? so marami po ang nakapili ng fate which is the correct answer for today sa ating leader board which shows community's correspondent these are the names Lara Lintau, Lene Reza Desevi Ashley Lauren Avaricio Maria Teresa Leslie Cheps H.R.V. so for those who have answered 337 po sila papapansin nyo po every question may naladagdag po na mga nakakapasok po so try lang po tayo ng try dahil po nang nabangit po namin ang mga katanggap po ng special prizes hindi lang po itong sampung ito pero marami pa po mga katanggap Raymond maraming nagagalit nyo sila nakapasok di ako nang bibiro may magkakaround tayo na unahin natin ang unang sampo sa chat okay may unfair okay let's go to the next and Ace alam mo sa akin fake yun e kasi di pwedein ko may nang haluhalo na ma-init tama naman Dok Susi talo na ngayon di ba ha ma-init ang panawan okay thank you so much okay thanks Ace siege over to you what do you have for us hi magandang umaga sa lahat ng naninood at ito nga meron ako nakikitang article na ipadala ito sa amin sa pamilya namin earlier this year panuhong lahat kami magtakawid so this article pinadala ng kainigan and it's said that hi-revectin is highly effective as I say propilaxis and treatment for COVID-19 comprehensive review do siya nakasulit dito na it was peer-reviewed mag-exercise siya ng sources merong book for down na si Pierre Corey na presidentipan ng isang organization at kung piting na nyo yung picture ang source pa ng picture i-filping FBA so meron siya kina-quote down na paper and it seems the language in which it's written is very formal anong si tingin nyo bakto oba ito o fake okay oh Raymond magbilang kaulit okay so again we have 20 seconds para po kayo po ay makapasok we are now in question number four of round one countdown starts now we are also seeing a lot of our attendees putting in their answers sa chat, dahil po sa frustration, hindi lang po sa misinformation pero sa pagpasok po sa atingmenti.com hopefully that could be fixed po dahil po it's a more of an internet thing more than anything else before we proceed, I'd like to greet those who are joining us all the way from the Middle East Dubai, United Arab Emirates Saudi Arabia, Lunichi Ali University of Bleeda 2 in Algeria po maraming-maraming salamat po sa inyong lahat at we know that this has become part of your regular habit and we hope that you could continue to join us for each and every webinar for stop COVID deaths po for out for okay so for this question can we have po ang mga pumilit ng kanilang there we go 282 ang pumilipo ng fake and 46 ang pumilipo ng fact Siege, ano ang tamang sagot? fake po at very happy na maraming ako ng tamang sagot now I want to explain a little bit more about that article and kung pwede balikin natin yung slide because I think this is a great example of how easy it is for fake news to spread around because I think we have to approach infodemic from a place of empathy na the people who share these articles with us do not have bad indentions they are not out here saying my friends who share this with me are not trying to hurt me or my family they are trying to share information to support them pananaw nila tama ito nakakaloko ng mga tao because even though the idea is ridiculous, the packaging isn't so if you are all of the things we tell our friends to check ay kailangan pereviewed simulat sa po ng article by medical experts so it's as if the fake news was written na pinapangunahan nila yung mga possible rebutals nabay mo sa kailiganong ay di naman yan kotoong source pwede niyang isagut sa hindi hindi otig na mo may tao dito may doctor na nagsabi merong pangasyang picture galing sa philippine FDA sabi dito merong manuscript may 27 controlled trials merong randomized controlled cast parang binabataman ka ng lahat ng jargon para magmakang toto ko and so I feel like people can verify yung information and it's just a matter of the language being used is intentionally created para lokohing kahit yung mga taong nag-attempt mag verify and so ano yung dapat natin go in? I feel like whenever we're sent a link from someone always start from a place of skepticism na hindi porket may nakasulit na news sa URL ay news site siya limbawa yung kanina it came to my website called Outbreak News Today o di ba? So ninsan yung din nasagot na sa mga tao it's news site ba yan? May news sa kait na yung news daw yung ho, news daw ganunan di ba? So kait may news sa URL yung sabi na news site siya ganyang sabi ni sir Robi kanina filangan Trusted news organization talaga siya yung talaga kilala siya mainstream track Pangalawa Igubil natin the people that we cite and not just check for their existence but also their reputation So ginubil ko yung doktor na na sa article niyan and kutuosyong tao kaya nakakaloko kutuosyong tao ngunit na si Santin na siya mula sa hospital niya kasi ayong yung pinigit na to sa Ivernet Lane So di ba? Check natin yun at pangatlo maghanat tayo ng proses na trusted anong may ilisabihin ng trusted Alam kung nakakalit ko ngayon kasi halimbawa naititan natin nangyong news personalities na nagpura-promote ng mga fake news or dubious practices hindi po yung blogs hindi po yung influencer na nakita lang natin sa social media and even personal accounts of TV and news personalities One of the things that went viral a few months ago was si Corina Sanchez was sharing about Ivernet and saying na nakapad-dialysis siya kasi trip lang niya magpad-dialysis yung ganon So I feel like tayo din let's never take things as we are even if we see them on TV even if we see people na they're very famous let's not believe right away let's not trust in that one source right away and always try to look for more supporting evidence Oh, thank you very much Siege that was a great example Okay, so what are we doing next? Okay, can we show kung sino na po ang bagong leaders may anong po bang bagong leaders sa ating leader board medyo umi-ikot po There we go Uy, nakawin na na po si Teddy Bear siyong icon si The Seven Marami na siyang food Yes na, ano lang po yun Sabi nga po these are cumulative scores and more than kung sino na po yun na papakita on the screen may marami po ang mananalo na ating premyo for today's game show At least for question number four our leaders are The Sevi Lene Reza Lara Lintao Leslie Ashley Lauren Avaricio Maria Teresa Boto Christine C. Corpus Cheps Harvey Villa and Ish Marami-maraming salamat po Okay, thank you Raymond sabi nung isang kasama natin ay ganun dop pala yung pakiramdab na mga mabagalang internet na sadya Okay, what we're gonna do Okay, I think we can start it now right, what we're gonna do para fair ang kukunin natin sa Mentimeter yun top five tapos kukunin natin yun top five sa chat, natama, okay para fair kasi maraming may riniklamo mabagal doy internet nila So, pumasok ay ganun siyempre mabilis kayo sa chat pero na gihay na yung mga iba Okay, so from this question onward we will get five from the Mentimeter the top five pano ba yan, adjust ba natin yun Raymond ten yung nakanoin We'll figure it out Dr. Suzy siyempre, we'll be in the room So, we'll... Tapos, top five ng unang sa chat so we're gonna need a little help from TVUP and from your team Raymond who the five are Ikaw na magbasa Raymond top five at chat natama Okay, punta tayo kay Dr. Albert Domingo Albert what do you have for us? Thank you ma'am Suzy and hello again maraming salamat sa ating mga kubago organizers and ating viewers advice lang po wag muna kayo magtype kagad ng fact or fake kasi parang anangyari alam niyo yung parang sa game show talaga yung kailangan nakagarumpayin kamay mo tapos hindi pa natatapos yung question gina ganun kagad ay pag na una kayo tas mali yung answer sayang, di ba so wait lang kasi ililevel up natin ng konde yung ating powers of discernment look at the screen meron tayong screencap actual screen capture na pinos ng isang kaklasi namin ni Dr. Sarmient sa Facebook pinos niya to at sabi sa New York post isang actual periodical not as prominent as the New York Times but still a periodical no si Dr. Anthony Fauci na sa ating mga doctor dito at mga nagbabasa ng Harrison's internal medicine sa mga authors at siya ang chief medical advisor pero siga fokus tayo sa article Fauci says the US FDA panel concluded that the J&J shot should have been two doses ay nakoyan na may nangang nakifake naman kagad hindi ko patiratapos yung question kayo talaga mali nyo reverse yung question but anyway siga so ang sinasabi dito is it listen carefully merong interview na nagsalita si Dr. Fauci at sinabi niya na dapat two shots yung J&J that is what you are voting on malaking hint na po yun malaking hint na po yun alright sige fact or fake okay thank you very much Albert okay let's go Raymond ikaw ang countdown eh okay marami-marami salamat po let's start our countdown this is round one round one pa rin po of our game show for today the last question for round one buti na lang po hanggan two rounds lang po tayo kung hindi abutin po tayo ng gabi maraming-maraming salamat po sa mga na participate as mentioned malapit na po tayo sa 400 na mga participants po at least for our fact or fake game show I'd also like to thank my classmate po a good friend Dr. Albert Domingo for taking the time out to join us for today hindi ko po kilala yung classmate po namin nag-post po nung on so I'd like to I will ask him offline kung sinon po yung nag-post po nung on but in the meantime bang nag- ah yun ah di na pala in the meantime dahil lang dito lang po ang kasagutan 159 viewers po natin na sumagot ang nag-sabi na fake ko ito at 137 ang nag-sabi na fact po ito so kung kayo po isirit na tanungin po natin si Dr. Albert Domingo kung ano po ba ang tamang katagasagutan Well, Dr. Raymond it's a fact oh my goodness it's a fact hindi ba, Dr. Albert fake news yun pa kita natin nuling slide pa kita natin yung slide sabi sa inyo wag kayong mag nagay kagay sobran dami ko na okay this is an illustration of how we should process the information we see kasi maaring fact the answer to the question is this is a fact meron talagang interview and how did I verify this tulad na sabi ni Robbie kanina pang nagbukaskan ng ibang sources ang dali-dali diba sabi nga i-google mo makikita mo meron talagang interview nagsasilita si Dr. Fauci at si nabi niya meron siyong observations from a technical standpoint ang bagil na siyong observations niya but I bet I bet hindi ko kaya masisisi kasi ganyto rin yung pag-iisip kung unokon nakita yung article sa sabi list ng ating pag-iisip anong sabi niya sa Pilipino advanced mag-isip sabi niya sa meme advanced kasi tayo mag-isip tumalon yung bias ng brain natin kasi parang nag-alit tayo did yung feel a little anger lalo na kung J&J yung nabigay sa yun na bakuna nagkarong ka ba ng pag-nana is na parang maniwala nakita nyo na dapat dalawa bakit isa lang yung binigay sa akin and that same bias I forgot what you call it in research pa tulong nila sa mga researches pero may bias na ganun na gusto mo maniwala ka agad but next slide please but actually how do you verify look at the official sources and if you are talking about the U.S. in particular si Dr. Anthony Fauci sa U.S. tumingin tayo sa Centers for Disease Control CDC.gov if you're talking international look at WHO.ind if you're talking Philippines DOH.gov.ph bakit po I bet you wanted to think na may effect na yun dun sa authorization so ibig sa dyan si Nabi pala ni Dr. Fauci na dapat 2 doses edi petila na ako dapat may second dose na ako lalo na kung na sa U.S. ako actually sabi ng CDC dun sa naka yellow nagsisimula pa lang sila in certain populations for a single booster shot for Moderna and Johnson & Johnson so it's actually a fact pero it's very nuanced anong ibig sabi na nuanced napaka napaka specific napaka tupok na dun lang sa mga certain populations pinapayagan yung second shot so kung ang tanong dun sa game natin ay talaga bang may sinabi si Dr. Fauci yes may sinabi talaga siya pero ay bet nag-advance yung pag-iisip nyo at tumalun kagad kayo sa pipilan naba ako para sa second shot ng J&J check nyo muna kung yung conclusion na iniisip nyo ay tama o malit Bapu, Dr. Raymond ok, thank you very much Albert ako tumalun ako kasi J&J ako Raymond, si Kessy nubang makananalo 5 from here and 5 from the chat box ok so bilayin ko rin masabagating ko ba yung mga pangalan kahit po dito po muna sa ating leader board na ay pinapakita ok uy, ma napakataspo nilessly siya po ang ating leader kapos po ng round one marami-maraming salamat sa yung active participation followed by Ashley Lauren Avaricio, Ishmel Nolly, Eunice, Lorna, Halog RVO, Ella B, and Nora Cruz Billionweba for the ano po ano for that chat sinusundang pa po ng ating ng aking team kung sino po yung mga tumawang yung sagot medyo marami po kasi sila pero marami-marami salal po sa inyong pagsagot at pag-participate po as we move on to our round number two for our game show for today ok, so, bi-belisa na natin ngayon na sigyep, punta tayo ngayon balik tayo ok, Robbie alam pa Robbie would you have for us ok hi, can you hear me? Ito, ito yung second na is a share ko naman yan ito, the only clue you need here is that obviously this is from Twitter tiba, so yung mga sanay sa Twitter yan, alibit at that do you think that is a a fact or is this is this fake ok, ay kamuna Raymond mayroong bagong Mentimeter Code daw ah that's correct Dr. SuzieTVP can we have on the screen ang ating bago there we go, ok bago na po ang ating code our code for round number two is as follows 6530996 that's 6530996 so pak-input lang po ito pag-when you go to www.menti.com all of your answers po ay do na po, mapupunta sa code na gumagamit ang 6530996 we are still waiting for it to open but the very least very very simple po at direct po ang ipinakita ni Robbie na midyakard ko natin balik natin, ok let's show it again and then we'll do the same we'll get five from the Mentimeter and five from the chat box ok ok, so dito po tinat ang this is a snapshot po I think from Twitter with the title from an article sa government site why you should not use ivermectin to treat or prevent COVID-19 medyo playful po caption ni USFDA you are not a horse you are not a cow seriously y'all stop it silap po pala ok thank you so much sana po ay nakapasok na po kayo sa ating menti.com ok, think medyo mababa lang ay ko ayon pa, 215 mas marami po po sana ang makapasok we are starting the countdown siyay ok, while we are waiting for the countdown po and for the answers to come in I'd like to greet po those who are joining us para po dito sa ating webinar para naman po sa I think this is from North America naman po na mga attendees po natin from London, Ontario, Canada from the Washington Hospital in California and those from FPO Diego Garcia in the United States so maraming-maraming salamat po so we are ok, ang quote po ulet as follows 6530996 that's 6530996 interactive po ang ating menti.com for today so maraming-maraming salamat po gusokong avatar Raymond yung donut hindi ako yung 8 ball pero ok po ok, siyay so let's get the answer from Robbie, Robbie what's the answer? wana pa yung results ok, i-flash lang natin ulet and then i-break down natin ok, so first of all this is from Twitter ngayon yung mga marunong mag Twitter immediately they look siyay na yung ano ba yung nakalagay na logo na pangalan dyan USFDA di ba na alam ko kong USFDA pero madaling dumawa ng fake na account di ba pwede ganaw so tiring na mo yung yung handle nya yung US underscore FDA oh, tama yan alam ko that's dyan o people who follow Twitter also you look at the followers of the USFDA ako usually I look at sinusundan ba yung mga media na I trust sinusundan ba yung mga journalists and experts that I trust pita ko ay they trust it yung blue seal di ba yung blue seal na yan so again it tells us okay that's the real account and then the article FDA.gov legit I click on it it's a real article goes to the actual website and so on so this article is real and the conclusions of the article are real but the reason I wanted to share this is the text the caption that goes with it that goes with the tweet you are not a horse you are not a cow di ba so stop it tapos may picture pa na ng bit na hawak yung kabayo so despite everything that I said just for purposes of this game wala na masana mag-got it but for purposes of this game I personally would call this a fake di ba if you take the context of hoy hindi ka kabayo and what is the premise there the premise there is kaya yung mga uminom ng ibermectin na tao ang ininong nyo kasi yung ibermectin na panghayok di ba and we all know that that's a fact na ang ibermectin karamihan panghayok and so on the problem is mayarang talaga ang ibermectin as angry as we are with everybody that's been pushing and let's be very clear ibermectin for humans patiyon doesn't do anything for covid patiyon doesn't help there's no evidence to that effect that is fake news everybody says that if anybody says that but the problem is there is in fact in reality ibermectin for humans the problem also is there is in fact ibermectin na riniriseta ng lihiti mong doktor sa lihiti mong paciente and the fact also is that when these pro ibermectin people and anti-vaxxers say billions of people have taken ibermectin and the test not term there is also the reality too is you can't just dismiss that fake news now what's the disadvantage here because you oversimplified the account just last week another name that's credible to you sanjay gupta doctor sanjay gupta the resident health expert of CNN was cornered in an interview on one of the on the most popular podcast in the world ay Joe Rogan one-on-one he was cornered into admitting categorically CNN should not have should have used that story and should not have framed it that way it was wrong for the FDA to frame it that way to impute na lahat na uminom na ibermectin ay uminom ng veterinary medicine he was cornered into admitting that it was wrong so what is the what is the take away here lahat tayo na kakainting robbie na wala ka robbie na wala ka okay lahat na lahat na nagkakainting din tayo na lahat nang sinasabi ng FDA sa tweet na iyon was factual on the article itself but when they crossed over into not just opinion but what is essentially trolling when they crossed over into trolling the anti-vaxxers and the people who use ibermectin the effect was not only to create reason to call it fake news the effect was also to lose the moral to lose the moral high ground and as I always tell people never lose the moral high ground if you are already standing on truth resist all temptation nakailangan gumabaka pa din mga insulto ka pa the other thing is we know for a fact that insulting does not work so you try it in your family in the next time your Lola post something about ibermectin try calling your Lola a horse and you know for a fact that will not work in fact one of the things that we know about fake news and trying to counter it is that even facts will not automatically work even just throwing all facts it does not work because there's a lot of things that you have to get passed you have to get passed emotion you have to get passed the ego of someone that's why sa family groups natin nakikita nyo na nagpupos tito si titan ng mga unang anong tagaguhan but nobody calls them gago and nobody knows magkakalabita kayo gagawa kayo ng separate chat group kayo kayo magtepinsan sabi nyo ay sinong magsasabi kay tito na madari nyo naman siya mouto sinong magsasabi kay tito and then eventually wala wala magsasabi and if you swing the other way at meron pomontaria ako na, ako na magsasabi sabihin niya tito, pangkabayo lang yan the effect on tito is not to be convinced in fact the effect on tito is batuhang na ng arctic and ikaw pa yung magbumukantangan nalbab pa rin kasi hindi tito hindi to FLCCC this is not quarry this is a real eting raceta ng doktor ko pangtao si nasa atin of fake news ikaw ngayon ng fake news just to make the point that even though we are all in agreement and our values are aligned and even our level of intelligence are correct when we consider how do we fight fake news you should not fight fire with fire you should not fight trolling with trolling and you should be very careful and be very conscious on when am I crossing over and taking my foot away from standing on facts and in this case the FDA itself did not consider the fact that you are no longer standing on science they always say let's just stand on science but you will agree with me that tweet does not stand on science when it outright basically imputes na wala akong wala sa buhay mo but I'm assuming veterinary medicine yung yung union naman and so that is in fact what happened since last week since that interview with Sanjay Gupta on the Joroban podcast pinapiesta ngayon na mga pro-Iver McTinyan and they have legitimate video catching Sanjay Gupta admitting that CNN was wrong they should not have used that story they should not have framed it that way and you can then now this now fuels another round of fake news that's very hard to counter okay, thank you so much Robbie Sige, so we are looking at the leader spot for our round 2 bumalik mo tayo sa umpisa ng umpisa MDD was the fastest for round number 2 question number 1 followed by R.A. Rosanes Camille Abundo Eunice Lenereza Jamasinto, Elmer Mr. John, Doc West The Fifth and Noel G. Sabino So maraming-maraming salamat po and as mentioned po marami-marami pa po ang mananalo, mga tangkapo pala ng premio para ko sa ating game show. Over to you Dr. Susie Okay, so you know we're kind of running out of time so I don't think we'll be able to do 2 full rounds we'll probably have joy and ace and then we'll have to close but maybe Raymond let's compute na lang mas maraming mananalo dito for the next one Okay, so let's go Joy, over to you Sige, ko naman Yes, okay So para mo bilis tayo okay we'll just show the screen and then tell me okay the channels are the same umikot din ulit to bumalik yung issue dahil last year may dalawang big telcos that we're gonna roll out their 5G tapos nung ito ngang nagkapandemiya tayo nirelate pagkakalabas nito ng 5G sa ating efforts sa vaccination so fact or fake Okay Okay, so we started the countdown na po no we are having trouble flashing ang ating menti.com but hopefully that's something that we'll be able to fix we'd like to greet I think from Pacific Islands University of Fiji from Laotoka Fiji marami-maraming salamat po we are seeing hopefully it will be maintained ating what we see on the screen is it fact or fake Okay, Raymond Pwede siguro ang 10 ang manalo sa menti 10 yung sa chat we'll have to do ace and then we'll have to close it so we will have 20 winners for this question No problem, Dr. Suzy bakalang po may mga hindi pa po kasi na yung mga sumali po outside of zoom that we may need to consider din po but anyway, our 20 seconds are up we'll go to joy for the correct answer is it fact or fake na sinasabi ay inimplant ni Bill Gates Yes, yes, yempre fake po tayo, fake yan so let me just emphasize itong particular visual na ginamit namin legit yan, it's from a wire and I just want to say na again just like what I was emphasizing earlier there is still this need to blame or distrust to someone and the easiest way to do this is the bigger you are in this case Mr. Gates the easier target because people distrust big people associate big with evil like the big pharma, the big tobacco so maybe because of that people find it easier to blame other people rather than invisible microbes or invisible science like natural mutations so ang gusto ko lang din sabihin dito people also fear the unknown and new technology usually does that to us and in many cases pag may bago there are many things that we cannot anticipate hanggang ngayon some people are still afraid actually of having their own cell phones kahit na ang argument nila is malay mo mag-brain damage ako yun naman yung isang si dasabi nilan doon. Now yung isang punto ko dito na sabi naman nung ating mga pannelists yung tungkol sa detecting what is fake and the red flags kasi dito naman is a value of new say in this case yung image nibil gates dinamit siya at the very least it creates an impression that it is an important item and because it creates that value clickbait siya and there's nothing wrong with clickbait even legit news clickbaits actually but it just is a trick for all of us to put more value to what it's trying to impart and lastly if a famous person's advocacy in this case kailala kasi si Bill Gates in vaccine research vaccine technology he's very supportive so yung cost niya is while it's being questioned it just adds to the conspiracy theories and thereby making it more believable so yun yung clickbait ko dito sa example ok, thank you very much Joy, Raymond let's go to our winners may mga cute na komen dito sana may ganiturao sa presidential balls puwede, puwede pero baka bolting na tayo ng four na na two hours allotted for this one dapat daw yung speakers natin may online course on communication I think a lot of our attendees will be very very interested in signing up for those courses on communication and how to handle yourself using social media our community scores po are up and our leaders are as follows MDD, Michael Cheng, R. A. Rosanes, Lene Reza, Jama Sinto, Kelly, Elmer, Doc West na fifth Mr. John and Aribel thank you so much and these are for the 216 who attended in the chat Dr. Susie medyo our team is still gathering ko sino po yung yung sampo na nanalo po ok, so later we'll announce it na ok so let's go to the next I'm gonna apologize to Siege and Albert kasi we won't be able to do more I think we'll have to do the last one which will be Ace but we'll have you another time kasi alam ko kina-renew to mga kina-renew to ma-question mo ok Ace, over to you, ikaw na ok, thank you Doc Susie ok, this one really made the rounds not just on vibrant chats but on social media for various reasons and if I could share my screen again ko sa I have some slides also I'd like to share after that so steam inhalation is a practice that we grew up with we do it to relieve you nasal congestion to make us feel and breathe a little better and there was a time during the pandemic that this really spread like wildfire and that steam inhalation was a way to quote-unquote kill the virus and protect you from COVID-19 ok, so ladies and gentlemen is this fact or fake? ok, go ok, go Raymond ok, thank you so much countdown starts now 20 seconds marama Raymond po, at least sa chat no kasi hindi ko po nakita sa mentimeter fake ang sinasabi na kasagutan para po rito we hope we'll be able to know kung sino po pumilipon ang fact or fake para po dito sa ating question number three round two of our game show for today so while we are waiting I just wanted to reiterate po baka kung nakalimutan po ninyo na yung pung ating winners sila po ay kailangan po magsabi kung saan po nila ipipick up yung kanilang prices as mentioned that was generously sponsored by san miguel foods the food division of san miguel food and beverage incorporated again winners will have to pick up their prices at selected u pico situate universities you can choose to pick up your price in u pico diliman los baños, manila, bagyo pisayas in ilo ilo city, sebu minta now and los baños and if you are based abroad you can nominate someone in the philippines kung kong ino mo sunyong man po ang makatanggap kong price please accomplish the google form in this short and link bit.ly forward slash stop covid deaths winner so thank you po and can we, dear team can we have the breakdown kung sinopo ang pumili ng fact at sinopo ang pumili ng fake sa ating question number three okay okay wala pa okay so similar to the earlier example as far as covid-19 is concerned unfortunately this is fake so there is no evidence to show that steam inhalation is a way to kill the virus so to speak or prevent you from getting covid it may help relieve nasal congestion it may help you breathe better especially if you have some other respiratory problems as far as covid is concerned it is not helpful and in fact some of our experts have said it may even make it worse because by doing steam inhalation if you have covid mas lalamong kinakalat yung virus particles by doing the practice now siguro as a final point na lang for me I just want to pick up on something that Siege and Robbie mentioned earlier and it is about empathy and communication when we see this kind of fake news and we hear or we learn of people believing it sometimes the reactions or bakit naman nagpapaniwala obvious naman na fake news yun actually I agree with what Robbie said that's not a good starting point for having a genuine conversation about what is fake and it actually is fake to say that people who believe fake news are not thinking na hindi sila nagiiisip and this is actually based on science 2002 Daniel Kahneman won the Nobel Prize for Economics and he's a psychologist and his expertise is on decision making how our minds make decisions and according to his work which is the basis of behavioral science our minds have two ways of thinking na sinasabi nga the mind has a fast or a system one way of thinking and a slow or a system two kind of thinking whenever we react to social media whenever we share things without even thinking about it that is the fast or system one way of thinking operating and it usually it operates on the basis of reflex of emotion, intuition but unfortunately it's also subject to so many biases it's only when we switch on our slow or type two way of thinking to properly process information so the practical question now is how do we switch from type one to type two thinking the hack so to speak is to pause you allow your mind your brain to switch into a different mode of thinking by giving it time to process the information so if anything my main advice to all of you who are watching us today for you to be able to discern what's not or fake you have to give yourself time to discern in the first place and that's actually the topic of a new campaign that we just launched in the UN called hashtag pledge to pause and the call traction is very simple if you see something on social media from whoever it is whether it's the New York Times or New York Kubao you pause and you allow yourself to properly digest the information to process it and always to share verified information at www.shareverified.com I hope you can join us in this campaign so yun na lang po siguro na Doc Suzy and Raymond that's my only piece of advice let's not assume that people who follow fake news or who fall for fake news are not thinking we're thinking all the time we just need to give ourselves time to think thank you thank you very much Ace I think you've seen the chat a lot of people appreciate that little message we are winners for this round Raymond okay, well we are waiting oi thank you, thank you po sa comment na nakakalio po ito thank you so much we apologize for some technical difficulties but if given the time para po mas marang ame pa po mga join we will have done that more often than not we would like to at least for round number two ang ating pinakamarami po puntos acerim po ang pinakamabilis for question number three Michael Cheng followed by M.D.D. R.A. Ron Rosanes Lienereza Mr. John Elmer Jamasinto Lorenzo Aribel N3M lahat ng ating winners we will be releasing a list po of those who have won ang ating mga special prizes thank you po sa lahat po na na participate sa ating very very fun game show for today at sana po I will be able to do something very very similar in our future webinars over to you Dr. Suzy okay thank you very much at this point we are going to have our public service announcement from TVUP and then we are going to call on Chancellor Padilla for the closing go ahead TVUP mahalaga ang lahat na ito si Gassin ka ba? mahal ba si Commander? mahal na mahal pare, mahal mo ba ako? ko naman ano mahal mo ba ang tropa? po ba? naran na ang papakuna na tayo dahil mahal ko kayo magpapapakuna ako well thank you so much for the public service announcement I think that the first time that I've seen the tropang tigasin version of our PSA the COVID communication PSA po is one of the many outputs of the UP research and titled communicating COVID-19 in post quarantine Philippines is headed by our UP Vice President for Public Affairs Dr. Elena Perna who also was our open remark speaker for today and it is funded by the DOH and the Department of Science and Technology through the AHEAD HSPR project Dr. Suzy may time though tayo for one question from the audience you want to pick up the question? mute ka okay sorry sorry ang question po ito is consolidation of all of the questions that are related po dito pagsasamasamayin ko lang po maybe we could ask yung po ating dalawang guest speakers na hindi po nakapagtanong ang question po ito ay patungkol po sa mayroon po bang madaling paraan or pagverify ng news or post at ano po ang inyong masasabi tungkol po sa bagari ko na po ha so facebook bilang lugar kung san po marami po ang mga fake news at nagdudulot po ng iba't ibang behavioral manipulation and this in light of the testimony of one of the whistle blowers for facebook and all of the other comments coming in about facebook po let's go to seeds before going to albert hindi ko pag-share nang aking last one no just answer the question that was posed about facebook and how it has become sort of a place kung san maraming mga fake news seeds actually may pinaponod the home youtube talk a few days ago it was by a science communicator sa uk's name is Tom Scott ang sabi niya the problem with our social media platforms is that merong fundamental butas in how they were built and that is there is no algorithm for truth ibig sabihin the algorithms are meant to show us what they call authoritative voices so ang pangapos natin ng facebook whenever facebook has been grilled about fake news they always say na our algorithms are designed to put forth authoritative voices and therefore be credible however how do you measure what is authoritative their only measurement is engagement how often something is shared how quickly it gets your actions when something is false it snowballs because you have the people who believe it and then you also have the people who are against it and they are trying to correct it and it all counts as engagement and lalo siyang kumakalat malaki talagang palaisipan ang social media platforms it's very hard i don't know what's happening internally but i do know what you and i can do as individuals and that's for people like you and me to be responsible in how we use our social media and make it a haven for truth so ibig sabihin yan that thing ginagamit na itong slogan but thank you for your click let's share infographics from trusted sources share easy to digest content something miss joy was saying while we were talking before was that the truth is not always entertaining the falsehood is often more entertaining than what is true hanit tayo ang mga infographics make it easy for people to understand at kumapodcast our news podcast and it's specifically designed and created para maging engaging and para nung di siyang news broadcast na talking at you kundi it like a friend talking to you so we have that podcast we also have a sub-podcast within it called covid corner where doctor dj bandoy explains the science in a very easy to understanding so i feel like yun let's be empathetic understand na like other people we respond to content that is engaging and easy to understand so other people too if you want to convince other people let's put in the time be patient, be engaging and lead from a place of empathy thank you sige doctor albert sige siguro doctor yun yung first question yung sasagutin ko mayro ba talagang paraan para actually may sagutin mayroong website na pinasokan na din sa chat I'm also going to say it snopes.com isas siyang 1994 pa nung pampanahon nung mga e-mail chain kasi yung pag-millennial natin Raymond lumarabas na nipauso na sa Friendster pa lang ko kami noon, na sa Myspace pa lang kami noon and even earlier dial up pa lang yung internet namin nagagalit pa pag inangatme yung telepono ng internet, otomawa si sige ah, alam ko nang age moseech ngayon naabutan namin yun pag kayong mga finoforward na malimaling e-mail snopes.com yung pinupuntahan namin now, kung masyadong complicated yung snopes meron lang isang simpleng tip pumili lang kayo sa 3 ahens na pagkakatiwalaan para sa COVID-19 and health information kasi ba kayong isa, wala kayong tiwala kayo nabahalo kong alin sa tatlong yun DOH, USCDC and WHO why did I say USCDC kasi mga mga CDC niragpapangap na CDC na hindi naman talaga CDC yun lang po, I'll leave it at that back to you Thank you very much Albert So we are at the top of the R and I'm going to ask all our speakers to give their permission to give their permission to give their permission to give their parting words So just a short message before we close So let's start with Robbie Robbie, go ahead Maraming salamat Sorry You're on mute, Rob You're on mute Maraming salamat I'd like to end na kontraing ko si Doc Albert lang sabit ko kasi usually yung day It's really up to you When people keep saying hindi pa pwede ng gawin ng media na ang lahat ng fake news hindi pa pwede ng walang nagpipo hindi pa pwede kong ano yung nai-gita ko, yun na yung reliable The answer to all of that is wala po So rin na lang Wala talaga You cannot You cannot I like this I I want to somebody ask the master Why can't we just carpet the whole of the earth and sabi niya because it is easier to just wear slippers So the reality is protect mo sarili mo kesa yag nagalik ka sa mundo na mas hindi nyo ako protectahan The real answer is there's no way to protect you from the deluge of information For that matter, the technology that we cannot anticipate Hindi panganat na lang And then that will be another platform for fake news also So tama si Doc Albert Sib di lang naman right now Ang diyan naman yung Google Ang dami-damin naman yung source diyan You should do that But at the same time you should adapt the mentality That the only way to be information resilient is really to you I'm not a fan of fact-checking programs I'm not a fan of fact-checking consortia I am a fan of media and information literacy I think that long term and sustainability wise the only real intervention is in the education system And it is not in it is really not in media It is really that the only solution is to each kids to look for information on their own to build their own circle of trust When I say circle of trust you're their own circle of brands that they can trust And there's only one way for you to do that which is sa school dapat pagtawanan ka na classmates mo sa school dapat ibangsakan ng teacher mo sa quiz ka ilangan may ang penalty grade one pa lang binawasa na ang grade pinagtawan na nang classmates ko kasi nagshira ko na fake news That's the only way all of us remember Ganyan tayo na at nagkanda and for me that's the only way the only real solution is in the education system that's the one thing we can control the entire information environment we cannot actually anticipate but we can't control our education Okay, thank you very much Robbie, how about Joy? Yes, briefly lang po ang gusto kong stress is let's have patience let's not loose being empathetic kaya nga po nang sinabi siege, needle case and Robbie especially for those that are victims really and yung nang bibictiman for all this fake news that are moving around no matter how dismaying let's just have patience in explaining and continuing to educate and yun nga let us empathize especially to our loved ones and friends because yun yung, dun na go umpisa yung circles natin sa pagpapalaga na plitong fake news so the disinformation now becomes correct information Thank you po for the opportunity Okay, thanks a lot Joy, Ace Thank you again to U.P. for this invitation I always enjoy these discussions and congratulations on your 75th episode and thank you everybody for spending your lunch hour with us I think this has been a very interesting conversation for me I I agree now with Robbie There's really I think the best way for you to protect yourself from all of this fake news is to educate yourself and to give yourself time to discern the different pieces of information we don't have time obviously to get into it but there are so many iterations of fake news people now are able to mimic videos mimic voices to make it real so there is a very real threat that is out there I suppose my message to everybody here is that be aware and yes, build that circle of trust no certain sources that you consider reliable people you can turn to doctors who you can ask or health professionals you can ask and use that to discern the information and to all of us who are working in communication in health promotion responsibility to call out and to educate people to help them navigate this very dynamic but also very uncertain media and information environment so thank you UP for having these forums I think it's very important that we continue to have these discussions Thank you very much Ace Let's go to Siege Thank you very much also to UP and sa lahat ng everyone in the audience I hope that this session renews your drive and your patience with others to educate them Let's always keep in mind the people who create bad news may create fake news may have bad intentions but our loved ones to share them with us today Let's always create an open space for discussion Another curious, how do I learn what is correct and what is not but if we always try to put them down or we express it we're so frustrated with them who be sila magdapatin sa atin So ayon, let's be patient fighting, thanks Thank you very much Siege Albert Thank you Doc Susi na pressure ako parang Miss Universe na kasi ako yung last candidate na magbibigay na sa good para tayo nag-o online shopping kapag tayo ay kumukuhan ng information kayo, I'm sure marami ito kung di lahat nag-online shopping okay lang mag add to cart kung may nakita ka may parang gusto kong basahin siga yung add to cart mo pero bago ka mag-check out Iko connect natin sa sinabi ng Dr. Ligot kailin na yung kay Daniel Kahneman actually system 1, system 2 thinking wag kang mag-check out sa online shopping mo ay ideas kung ikaw ay good kung ikaw ay nag-habul ng food pack may nakitaong comment kanina hindi do sila mag-pag-isip kung fake or fat kasi nga naman yung food pack yung na yung isip nila so system 1 thinking yun so do not check out, do not believe if you're hungry, if you're tired if you're angry mag-monimuni muna sabi nga ni Dr. Ligot at sabi ng UN post mo na tayo para pumasok ng system 2 mag-mereyanda ka medyo nasa sa yun na yun connected to what Robby said dapat ready tayo we have to be educated and then you finally check out your idea and I thank you Thank you very much Albert so we're going to launch the evaluation poll Raymond you want to do that while we're getting mentioned on board to do the closing remark so Raymond I'd like to take this opportunity to thank our really excellent set of panelists for today Maraming-maraming salamat po for taking the time out to share your skills and your expertise to our audience as mentioned po if you or any of your colleagues or part of your network are offering communications workshops or anything how to handle yourself in social media please let us know nakapagplag na po pag-cast din po kanina si Siege so maraming salamat din and to Sir Robby also so for anybody who will want to learn more about communication please just put it on the chat and we hope that a lot of our attendees will be able to reach out to you for our evaluation there are five questions the answers po is in a likered scale I'll just read off the list and afterwards we'll move on to our closing remarks the first question the panelists demonstrated thorough knowledge of the topic the panelists were well prepared and organized the panelists spoke clearly and audibly the panelists used appropriate language with technical medical jargos adequately explained and finally the panelists contributed to new perspectives and knowledge on managing virus key COVID-19 health issues for today we tackled about misinformation disinformation din po sa social media trying to determine ano po ang fact or fake to be able to gain some sense of how to become social media smart uliting ko lang po wala po kaming ilalabas na mga evaluation polls eto na po yun eto na po yung evaluation na yun so we hope that those who are still in the zoom will be able to participate in this evaluation paul over to you dr. Susie ok thank you very much let me introduce someone you know Chancellor of the University of Phillipines Manila Dr. Menchik Padilla to give our closing remarks go ahead Menchik now after 74 webinar episodes of serious discussion TV UP takes a lighter fun way of discussing our topic today be a COVID-19 social media smart Vice President for Public Affairs Dr. Elena Purnia welcomed our audience to the Diamond episode with COVID-19 came infademic with large numbers depending on real time updates it is unfortunate that even well meaning people shared the news shared false news Dr. Purnia said that social media help but it also hurt society Vice President Purnia presented the data from one year analysis of 156,000 conversations from various platforms from February 2020 to January of 2021 the top topics were IATF new strains vaccine testing DOH and health protocols but what is even more interesting are the emotions behind the post and the following the word emotions that were reflected anxiety and fear the most dominant empathy anger hope and boredom the other important thing to note is that events trigger the post and emotions so I urge you to watch the replay and take a look at the trigger events again in closing VP Purnia said that all of these awakened our ability to empathize now here is a summary of the take away messages from our speakers today I glean them from the cases that they are presented so here they are number one be careful with real messages with additional personal comments that may be fake number two check the source of the information we heard this again and again one source is not enough number three be warned we sometimes equate the absence of information as confirmation number four always validate the source use trusted sites CDC WHO FDA and of course in the Philippines DOH number five for travel questions go to travel sites and embassies number six do not be deceived by good visuals good production and long explanation number seven check the reputation of the personalities in the news you can google them number eight for tweets look at the followers trust the followers you must know your circle of trust number nine be open for discussion number ten a message we've been getting from almost all our webinars always follow advice that is science-based following advice that is not science-based is confusing and gives a false sense of security so let me end with a message shared by Dr. Jason Ligot the message is from Daniel Kahneman 2002 Nobel laureate for economics on one mind to systems of thinking open quote a reliable way to make people believe in falsehoods is frequent repetition because familiarity is not easily distinguished from truth close quote indeed food for thought for all of us for the weekend let us stop and discern ingat mo tayong lahat back to you Susie thank you very much that's our chancellor for UP Manila Menchik Padilla and thank you everyone thank our speakers for being so game and for our audience for being so game I know you want the prices right so Raymond's going to Raymond's going to Raymond's going to announce this but I think more over we're here to learn and we're just so grateful that you've always been with us for 75 75 webinars my goodness okay so ayamon next week next week agandapan topic natin I am also very excited about this it is about work bubbles creating COVID-19 safe workplaces kasi yung bukas na yung mga yung mga iba ngayon so antanong how can we stay safe in the workplace and we have experts in occupational health who will be joining us don't miss it next week join us Raymond over to you so maraming maraming salamat po let thank you to our chancellor UP Manila Dr. Menchik Padilla for that excellent recap for our game show I'm sure marami po po ang talagang nagaabang na makarumput tayo ng game show type of format para sa ating webinar we hope that you'd be able to continue to join us for SAP COVID-19 webinar series for today we are showing on the screen at the very least yung results po ng ating evaluation poll as you can see at least 90% of the attendees have indicated that they strongly agree sa ating questions po for each of our evaluation poll we would like to thank again our excellent set of panelists and we look forward to another exciting topic for next week on workplace bubbles so please stay tuned po this formally closes our webinar for this week we look forward to your company again next Friday for our regular Friday lunch date from 12 noon to 2 pm it's a date together we can stop COVID-19 so keep safe keep healthy and see you online I'll keep your hand in mine Let's say a prayer one more time I know you long for home But I am here, you're not alone Let's stay with you until the coast is clear The other's pain before my fears The other's laughter before my tears But right behind the mask I look into myself and ask Do I have strength to carry on My God, our Lord, what's this going on And leave you here to keep me strong I'm here to hold the line I'll keep my hand until my His name to realize It's fine to be afraid Just hold on to the word he gave This time we'll come to pass Let's say a prayer one more time I know you long for home But I am here, you're not alone Let's stay with you until the coast is clear The other's pain before my fears The other's laughter before my tears But right behind the mask I look into myself and ask I'm here to hold the line I'll keep my hand until my His name to realize It's fine to be afraid Just hold on to the word he gave This time we'll come to pass Let's say a prayer one more time I know you long for home But I am here, you're not alone