 Yr Gŵr yma, cymdeithaswn i'w gwaith i'r peth i'r 12 mlynedd ar yyouro, ac yw y cymdeithaswn i'r Lory form ac yn appointment y gyllewch cwestiynaeth a'r mê 76e. A'r gŵr yma, 1 ddaeth yr afrwff22 mae'r brifeddu sy'n cymdeithaswn i ddin iawn. Mae o chefrwff deariau ar y dynnu ymddangosiau yn ydu rhai o yr afrwff22 mawr i'r ichaw sy'n cymdeithaswn i ddynnu i'r cyfwyr yma. Yr pasegin ymddangoseth gyda'r bwysig? Y cwmddor ar y ddweud i ddweud yn y byd. Fy ffeithio'r cwmpas o'r Sgol Llywodraeth Cymru, Yn Ysgrifennu 2014, SSI 2014-109. Mae'r ddweud hynny, yng Nghymru, yn y paragraf 11c o'i ddweud o'r llunio yn yr ardal. Yn y ddweud hynny, mae'r ddweud yn ddweud, ond mae'r ddweud yn ddweud yn y ddweud yn y ddweud. Yn y paragraf 11c o'r Llywodraeth Cymru, yw ddweud? Mae'r ddweud ti o'r ddweud yn gorau o'r llun i'r paragraf 11a-4 o'r llunio yn yr ardal. Yn hynny'n y ddweud yn yr ardal, mae gennymStartu Gymroeg. Yn y paragraf 10 o'r llunio o'r ordur, yw'n cyfrifwyr 1 y nôr Mwng 6a yn yr ysgrifennu 11 o'r llunio 1 o'r ddweud 2007. Rule 6A2A4, 5 and 6 contain references which are not gender neutral. Similar references appear in the new Rule 6B7 as inserted into Part 11 of the Schedule 1 to the 2007 order, and in the new Rule 185 and 186B as inserted into paragraph 11 of the order into Part 12 of the Schedule 1 to the 2007 order. The references to Part 14 in paragraph 12 of the Schedule to the Order should be to Part 13. Paragraph 1A7 of the Schedule to the Order is surplus and should be omitted. The order fails to revoke the definition of the Scheme Actuary, which is intended to be replaced by a definition of Scheme Actuary inserted into Rule 2 of Part 1 of Schedule 1 to the 2007 order by 1A11 of the Schedule to this Order, and the reference to Rule 513 in the new Rule 11A in Part 12 of Schedule 1 to the 2007 order should be Rule 5A13 of Part 11. Does the committee therefore agree to draw the instrument to the attention of the Parliament and the general reporting ground as it contains drafting errors? Agree. The committee may wish to note that the Scottish Government has agreed to lay an amending instrument which will correct the errors identified with the present instrument prior to its commencement on 23 May 2014. Does the committee agree so to note? Agree. John. I welcome the fact that the Government has agreed to lay an amending order which will correct the errors, but I have to say that I am a bit disappointed at the overall level of drafting in this committee. I am sorry to say that the word that springs to mind is sloppy and I am surprised given the assurances that we were given by Minister Joe Fitzpatrick on in this regard that there seems to have been such a failure here both at the Scottish Government level and at drafting level to bring forward an instrument of this quality. Thank you. Members have any other comments? I am sure the committee wholeheartedly agrees with your comments and I am sure the Government will note that. Turning now to the Children's Hearing Scotland Act 2011, Modification of Subordinate Legislation Order 2014, SSI 2014-112. The instrument contains a drafting error in paragraph 2-3 of the schedule which provides for the substitution of text in paragraph 6 of schedule 4 to the looked after Children's Scotland Regulations 2009. The text has already been substituted by virtue of paragraph 1116b of schedule 1 to the Children's Hearing Scotland Act 2011, Modification of Subordinate Legislation Order 2013, SSI 2013-147. The committee may wish to note that the Scottish Government considers that given the duplication of provision paragraph 2-3 of the schedule has no practical effect. The Government has also indicated that in light of that it has no plans to rectify this error by laying an amendment. The committee may consider however that paragraph 2-3 is a superfluous and confusing provision and so the error should be rectified if an opportunity arises to amend this order for other purposes. Can I say that I actually entirely agree with that? Those of us who have studied the law do not want to find it in two different places. It just doesn't help. Does the committee therefore agree to draw the instrument to the attention of the Parliament under the general reporting ground? Agree. Thank you. No points have been raised by our legal advisers on the Firemen's Pension Scheme amendment 2, Scotland Order 2014, SSI 2014-108, nor on the National Health Service free prescriptions and charges for drugs and appliances, Scotland Amendment Regulations 2014, SSI 2014-115, is the committee content with these instruments. Thank you. A gender item 3 is instruments not subject to any parliamentary procedure. No points have been raised by our legal advisers on the Victims and Witnesses Scotland Act 2014, commencement number 1, Order 2014, SSI 2014-117, nor on the Marriage and Civil Partnership Scotland Act 2014, commencement number 1, Order 2014, SSI 2014-121, is the committee content with these instruments. Thank you. Gender item 4 is the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Bill. This item of business is consideration of the Scottish Government's response to the committee's stage 1 report on the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Bill. Members have seen the briefing paper and the response from the Scottish Government. Do you members have any comments, please? John. Thank you, convener. I would welcome the fact that they are going to not extend the corporate plan beyond three years. I would also welcome the fact that the Government intends to bring forward an amendment at stage 2 under section 54. The remaining piece of work about penalties is obviously a piece of work still in progress, so I doubt that we will hear in due course what they propose. Are we content to know what we have before us and look forward to what comes further? We are, thank you very much. It is necessary to reconsider the bill at stage 2. That completes agenda item 4. At which point I move the meeting into private. Congratulations to the leaders. Thank you.