 Book two, chapter nine, of Fruit of the Tree. But justine. Mrs. Harry Dressel, seated in the June freshness of her oak-street drawing-room, and harmonizing by her highlights and hard edges, with the white and gold angularities of the best furniture, cast a rebuking eye on her friend Miss Brent, who stood arranging in a glass bowl the handful of roses she had just brought in from the garden. Mrs. Dressel's intonation made it clear that the entrance of Miss Brent had been the signal for renewing an argument which the latter had perhaps left the room to escape. When you were here three years ago, Justine, I could understand you're not wanting to go out, because you were in mourning for your mother, and, besides, you'd volunteered for that bad surgical case in the Hope Hospital. But now that you've come back for a rest and change, I can't imagine why you persist in shutting yourself up. Unless, of course, she concluded in a hierarchy of reproach, it's because you think so little of Hannaford Society. Mrs. Dressel met it with an unrelenting turn of her plump shoulder murmuring, oh, if you take that tone, and on Miss Brent's gaily rejoining, isn't it better than to have other people take it for me? She replied with an air of affront that expressed itself in a ruffling of her whole pretty person. If you'll excuse my saying so, Justine, the fact that you were staying with me would be enough to make you welcome anywhere in Hannaford. I'm sure of it, dear, so sure that my horrid pride rather resents being floated in on the high tide of such overwhelming credentials. Mrs. Dressel glanced up doubtfully at the dark face laughing down on her, though she was president of the Maplewood Avenue Book Club and habitually figured in the society column of the banner as one of the intellectual leaders of Hannaford there were moments when her self-confidence trembled before Justine's light sallies. Brent was absurd, of course, given the relative situations of the two, and Mrs. Dressel, behind her friend's back, was quickly reassured by the thought that Justine was only a hospital nurse who had to work for her living and had never really been anywhere. But when Miss Brent's verbal arrows were flying, it seemed somehow of more immediate consequence that she was fairly well connected and lived in New York. No one placed a higher value on the abstract qualities of wit and irony than Mrs. Dressel. The difficulty was that she never quite knew when Justine's retorts were loaded or when her own susceptibilities were the target aimed at, and between her desire to appear to take the joke and the fear of being ridiculed without knowing it her pretty face often presented an interesting study in perplexity. As usual, she now took refuge in bringing the talk back to a personal issue. I can't imagine, she said, why you won't go to the Gaines's Garden Party. It's always the most brilliant affair of the season, and this year with the John Amhersts here and all their party, that fascinating Mrs. Eustace Ansel and Mrs. Amherst's father old Mr. Langhope, who is quite as quick and clever as you are, you certainly can't accuse us of being dull and provincial. Miss Brent smiled. As far as I can remember, Effie, it is always you who accuse others of bringing that charge against Hannaford. For my part, I know too little of it to have formed any opinion, but whatever it may have to offer me, I am painfully conscious of having, at present, nothing but your kind commendation to give in return. Mrs. Dressel rose impatiently. How absurdly you talk! You're a little thinner than usual, and I don't like those dark lines under your eyes. But Westie Gaines told me yesterday that he thought you handsomer than ever, and that it was intensely becoming to some women to look overtired. It's lucky I'm one of that kind, Miss Brent rejoined between a sigh and a laugh, and there's every promise of my getting handsomer every day if somebody doesn't soon arrest the geometrical progression of my good looks by giving me the chance to take a year's rest. As she spoke, she stretched her arms above her head, with a gesture revealing the suppleness of her slim young frame. But also its tenuity of structure, the frailness of the throat and shoulders, and the play of bones in the delicate neck. Justine Brent had one of those imponderable bodies that seemed a mere pinch of matter shot through with light and color. Though she did not flush easily, a rural lights ran under her clear skin, were lost in the shadows of her hair, and broke again in her eyes, and her voice seemed to shoot light too, as though her smile flashed back from her words as they fell. All her features being so fluid and changeful that the one solid thing about her was the massing of dense black hair which clasped her face like the noble metal of some antique bust. Mrs. Dressel's face softened at the note of weariness in the girl's voice. Are you very tired, dear? She asked, drawing her down to a seat on the sofa. Yes and no, not so much bodily, perhaps as in spirit. Justine Brent drew her brows together and stared moodily at the thin brown hands interwoven between Mrs. Dressel's plump fingers. Seated thus with hallowed shoulders and brooding head, she might have figured a young civil bowed above some mystery of fate, but the next moment her face, inclining toward her friends, cast off its shadows and resumed the look of a plaintive child. The worst of it is that I don't look forward with any interest to taking up the old drudgery again. Of course that loss of interest may be merely physical. I should call it so in a nervous patient, no doubt. But in myself it seems different. It seems to go to the roots of the world. You know it was always the imaginative side of my work that helped me over the ugly details. The pity and beauty that disinfected the physical horror. But now that feeling has lost and only the mortal disgust remains. Oh, Effie, I don't want to be a ministering angel any more. I want to be uncertain, coy and hard to please. I want something dazzling and unaccountable to happen to me. Something new and unlived and indescribable. She snatched herself with a laugh from the bewildered Effie and, flinging up her arms again, spun on a light heel across the polished floor. Well, then, murmured Mrs. Dressel with gentle obstinacy, I can't see why in the world you won't go to the Gaines's Garden Party. And caught in the whirlwind of her friend's incomprehensible mirth, she still persisted as she ducked her blonde head to it. If you will only let me lend you my dress with the Irish lace, you'll look smarter than anybody there. Before her toilet mirror an hour later, Justine Brent seemed in a way to fulfill Mrs. Dressel's prediction. Though mirror-like herself, she could no more help reflecting the happy effect of a bow or a feather than the subtler influence of a word and look. And her face and figure were so new to the advantages of dress that, at four and twenty, she still produced the effect of a young girl in her first good frock. In Mrs. Dressel's festal raiment, which her dark tints subdued to a quiet elegance, she was like the golden core of a pale rose illuminating and senting its petals. Three years of solitary life following on a youth of confidential intimacy with the mother she had lost had produced in her the quaint habit of half-loud soliloquy. Fine feathers, Justine, she laughed back at her laughing image. You look like a phoenix risen from your ashes, but slip back into your own plumage and you'll be no more than a little brown bird without a song. The luxurious suggestions of her dress and the way her warm youth became it drew her back to memories of a childhood nestled in beauty and gentle ways before her handsome prodigal father had died and her mother's face had grown pinched in the long struggle with poverty. But those memories were, after all, less dear to Justine than the gray years following when, growing up, she had helped to clear a space in the wilderness for their tiny hearth fire when her own efforts had fed the flame and roofed it in from the weather. A great heat kindled at that hearth had burned in her veins, making her devour her work, lighting and warming the long cold days and reddening the horizon through dark passages of revolt and failure, and she felt all the more deeply the chill of reaction that set in with her mother's death. She thought she had chosen her work as a nurse in the spirit of high disinterestedness, but in the first hours of her bereavement it seemed as though only the personal aim had sustained her. For a while after this her sick people became to her mere bundles of disintegrating matter and she shrank from physical pain with a distaste the deeper because mechanically she could not help working on to relieve it. Gradually her sound nature passed out of this morbid face and she took up her task with deeper pity if less exalted ardor, glad to do her part in the vast impersonal labor of easing the world's misery, but longing with all the warm instincts of youth for a special load to lift, a single hand to clasp. It was cruel to be alive, to be young, to bubble with springs of mirth and tenderness and folly, and to live in perpetual contact with decay and pain, to look persistently into the gray face of death without having lifted even a corner of life's veil. Now and then when she felt her youth flame through the sheath of dullness which was gradually enclosing it, she rebelled at the conditions that tied a spirit like hers to its monotonous task, while others, without a quiver of wings on their dull shoulders or a note of music in their hearts, had the whole wide world to range through and saw in it no more than a frightful emptiness to be shut out with tight walls of habit. A tap on the door announced Mrs. Dressel, garbed for conquest and bestowing on her brilliant person the last anxious touches of the artist reluctant to part from a masterpiece. My dear, how well you look! I knew that dress would be becoming, she exclaimed, generously transferring her self-approval to Justine, and adding as the latter moved toward her. I wish Westie Gaines could see you now. Well he will presently, Miss Brent rejoined, ignoring the slight stress on the name. Mrs. Dressel continued to brood on her maternally. Justine, I wish you'd tell me. You say you hate the life you're leading now, but isn't there somebody who might give me another with lace dresses in it? Justine's slight shrug might have seemed theatrical, had it not been part of the ceaseless dramatic play of her flexible person. There might be, perhaps, only, I'm not sure, she broke off whimsically. Not sure of what. That this kind of dress might not always be a little tight on the shoulders. Tight on the shoulders? What do you mean, Justine? My clothes simply hang on you. Oh, Effie dear, don't you remember the fable of the wings under the skin that sprout when one meets a pair of kindred shoulders? And as Mrs. Dressel bent on her a brow of unenlightenment—well, it doesn't matter. I only meant that I've always been afraid good clothes might keep my wings from sprouting. She turned back to the glass, giving herself a last light touch such as she had bestowed on the roses. And that reminds me, she continued, how about Mr. Amherst's wings? John Amherst? Mrs. Dressel brightened into immediate attention. Why, do you know him? Not as the owner of the Westmore Mills, but I came across him as their assistant manager three years ago at the Hope Hospital, and he was starting a very promising pair then. I wonder if they're doing as well under his new coat. I'm not sure that I understand you when you talk poetry, said Mrs. Dressel, with less interest. But personally I can't say I like John Amherst. And he is certainly not worthy of such a lovely woman as Mrs. Westmore. Of course she would never let anyone see that she's not perfectly happy, but I'm told he has given them all a great deal of trouble by interfering in the management of the mills, and his manner is so cold and sarcastic. The truth is, I suppose he's never quite at ease in society. Her family have never really reconciled to the marriage. And Westie Gaines says— Ah, Westie Gaines would, Justine, interposed lightly. But if Mrs. Amherst is really the Bessie Lang Hope I used to know, it must be rather a struggle for the wings. Mrs. Dressel's flagging interest settled on the one glimpse of fact in this statement. It's such a coincidence that you should have known her too. Was she always so perfectly fascinating? I wish I knew how she gives that look to her hair. Justine gathered up the lace sunshade and long gloves which her friend had lent her. There was not much more that was genuine about her character, that was her very own, I mean, than there is about my appearance at this moment. She was always the dearest little chameleon in the world, taking everybody's color in the most flattering way, and giving back, I must say, a most charming reflection, if you'll excuse the mixed metaphor. But when one got her by herself with no reflections to catch, one found she hadn't any particular color of her own. One of the girls used to say she ought to wear a tag because she was so easily mislaid. Now then I'm ready. Justine advanced to the door and Mrs. Dressel followed her downstairs, reflecting with pardonable complacency that one of the disadvantages of being clever was that it tempted one to say sarcastic things of other women than which she could imagine no more crying social error. During the drive to the garden party Justine's thoughts, drawn to the past by the mention of Bessie Lang Hope's name, reverted to the comic inconsequences of her own lot, to that persistent irrelevance of incident that had once made her compare herself to an actor always playing his part before the wrong stage setting. Was there not, for instance, a mocking incongruity in the fact that a creature so leaping with life should have, for Chief Outlet, the narrow mental channel of the excellent couple between whom she was now being born to the Gaines Garden Party? All her friendships were the result of propinquity or of early association, and fate had held her in prison in a circle of well- to-do mediocrity, peopled by just such figures as those of the kindly and prosperous Dressels. Effie Dressel, the daughter of a cousin of Mrs. Brents, had obscurely but safely allied herself with the heavy blonde young man who was to succeed his father as the president of the Union Bank and who was already regarded by the solid business interests of Hannaford as possessing talents likely to carry him far in the development of the paternal fortunes. Harry Dressel's honest countenance gave no evidence of peculiar astuteness, and he was in fact rather the product of special conditions than of an irresistible bent. He had the sound Saxon love of games, and the most interesting game he had ever been taught was business. He was a simple domestic being, and according to Hannaford's standards, the most obvious obligation of the husband and father was to make his family richer. If Harry Dressel had ever formulated his aims he might have said that he wanted to be the man whom Hannaford most respected, and that was only another way of saying the richest man in Hannaford. Effie embraced his creed with a zeal facilitated by such evidence of its soundness as a growing income and the early prospects of a carriage. Her mother-in-law, a kind old lady with a simple unquestioning love of money, had told her on her wedding-day that Harry's one object would always be to make his family proud of him, and the recent purchase of the Victoria in which Justine and the Dressels were now seated was regarded by the family as a striking fulfilment of this prophecy. In the course of her hospital work Justine had of necessity run across far different types, but from the connections thus offered she was often held back by the subtler shades of taste that civilize human intercourse. Her world in short had been chiefly peopled by the dull or the crude, and hemmed in between the two she had created for herself an inner kingdom where the fastidiousness she had to set aside in her outward relations recovered its full sway. There must be actual beings worthy of admission to this secret precinct, but hitherto they had not come her way, and the sense that they were somewhere just out of reach still gave an edge of youthful curiosity to each encounter with a new group of people. Certainly Mrs. Gaines' garden party seemed an unlikely field for the exercise of such curiosity. Justine's few glimpses of Hannaford society had revealed it as rather a dull, thick body, with a surface stimulated only by ill-advised references to the life of larger capitals, and the concentrated essence of social Hannaford was, of course, to be found at the Gaines' entertainments. It presented itself, however, in the rich June afternoon, on the long shadows of the well-kept lawn and among the paths of the Rose Garden in its most amiable aspect, and to Justine, wearied by habitual contact with ugliness and suffering, there was a pure delight in the verdant setting of the picture, and in the light harmonious tints of the figures peopling it. If the company was dull it was at least decorative, and poverty, misery, and dirt were shut out by the placid unconsciousness of guests as securely as by the leafy barriers of the garden. End of Book 2, Chapter 9. Book 2, Chapter 10, of Fruit of the Tree. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. The Fruit of the Tree by Edith Wharton. Book 2, Chapter 10. Ah, Mrs. Dressel, we were on the lookout for you. Waiting for the curtain to rise. Your friend, Miss Brent? Juliana, Mrs. Dressel's friend, Miss Brent. Near the brilliantly striped marquee that formed the axis of the Gaines Garden Party's, Mr. Halford Gaines, a few paces from his wife and daughters, stood radiating a royal welcome on the stream of visitors pouring across the lawn. It was only to eyes perverted by a different social perspective that there could be any doubt as to the importance of the Gaines entertainments. To Hannaford itself they were epic-making. And if any rebellious spirit had cherished a doubt of the fact, it would have been quelled by the official majesty of Mr. Gaines' frockcoat and the comprehensive cordiality of his manner. There were moments when New York hung like a disquieting cloud on the social horizon of Mrs. Gaines and her daughters. But to Hannaford Gaines, Hannaford was all in all. As an exponent of the popular and patriotic Good Enough for Me theory, he stood in high favor at the Hannaford Club where a too keen consciousness of the metropolis was alternately combated by an easy illusion and studied omission, and where the unsettled fancies of youth were chastened and steadied by the reflection that, if Hannaford was good enough for Hannaford Gaines, it must offer opportunities commensurate with the largest ideas of life. Never did Mr. Gaines' manner bear richer witness to what could be extracted from Hannaford than when he was in the act of applying to it the powerful pressure of his hospitality. The resultant essence was so bubbling with social exhilaration that, to its producer at any rate, its somewhat mixed ingredients were lost in one highly flavored draft. Under ordinary circumstances no one discriminated more keenly than Mr. Gaines between different shades of social importance, but any one who was entertained by him was momentarily ennobled by the fact, and not all the anxious telegraphy of his wife and daughters could, for instance, recall to him that the striking young woman in Mrs. Dressel's wake was only some obscure protégé whom it was odd of Effie to have brought and whose presence was quite unnecessary to emphasize. Juliana, Miss Brent tells me she has never seen our roses. Oh, there are other roses in Hannaford, Miss Brent. I don't mean to imply that no one else attempts them. But unless you can afford to give carte blanche to your man, and mine happens to be something of a specialist, well, if you'll come with me I'll let them speak for themselves. I always say that if people want to know what we can do they must come and see. They'll never find out from me. A more emphatic signal from his wife arrested Mr. Gaines as he was in the act of leading Miss Brent away. Ah, what? The Amhersts and Mrs. Ansel? He must excuse me then, I'm afraid. But Westie shall take you. Westie, my boy, it's an ill wind. I want you to show this young lady our roses. And Mr. Gaines, with mingled reluctance and satisfaction, turned away to receive the most important guests of the day. It had not needed his father's summons to draw the expert Westie to Miss Brent. He was already gravitating toward her with a nonchalant spread of cosmopolitan successes, but with a directness of aim due also to his larger opportunities of comparison. The roses will do, he explained, as he guided her through the increasing circle of guests about his mother, and an answer to Justine's glance of inquiry. To get you away, I mean. They're not much in themselves, you know, but everything of the Governor's always begins with a capital letter. Oh, but these roses deserve to, Justine exclaimed, as they paused under the evergreen archway at the further end of the lawn. I don't know, not if you've been in England, Westie murmured, watching furtively for the impression produced on one who had presumably not, by the great blush of color, masked against its dusky background of clipped evergreens. Justine smiled. I have been, but I've been in a slum's sense, in horrible places that the least of those flowers would have lighted up like a lamp. Westie's guarded glance imprudently softened. It's the beastliest kind of a shame you ever having had to do such work. Oh, had to, she flashed back at him disconcertingly. It was my choice, you know. There was a time when I couldn't live without it. Philanthropy is one of the subtlest forms of self-indulgence. Westie met this with a vague laugh. If a chap who is as knowing as the devil did, once in a way, indulge himself in the luxury of talking recklessly to a girl with exceptional eyes, it was rather upsetting to discover in those eyes no consciousness of the risk he had taken. But I am rather tired of it now, she continued, and his look grew guarded again. After all, they were all the same, except in that particular matter of the eyes. At the thought he risked another look, hung on the sharp edge of betrayal, and was snatched back, not by the manly instinct of self-preservation, but by some imp of mockery lurking in the depths that lured him. He recovered his balance and took refuge in a tone of worldly ease. I saw a chap the other day who said he knew you when you were at St. Elizabeth. Wasn't that the name of your hospital? Justine assented. One of the doctors, I suppose. Where did you meet him? Ah, now she should see. He summoned his utmost carelessness of tone. Down on Long Island last week I was spending Sunday with the Amhersts. He held up the glittering fact to her, and watched for the least little blink of awe. But her lids never trembled. It was a confession of social blindness which painfully negative'd Mrs. Dressel's hint that she knew the Amhersts. If she had even known of them, she could not so fatally have missed his point. Long Island, she drew her brows together in puzzled retrospection. I wonder if it could have been Stephen Wyant. I heard he had taken over his uncle's practice somewhere near New York. Wyant, that's the name. He's the doctor at Clifton, the nearest town to Amherst's place. Little Sicily had a cold. Sicily Westmore, you know, a small cousin of mine, by the way. He switched a rose-branch loftily out of her path, explaining, as she moved on, that Sicily was the daughter of Mrs. Amherst's first marriage to Richard Westmore. That's the way I happen to see this Dr. Wyant. Bessie, Mrs. Amherst, asked him to stop to luncheon after he'd seen the kid. He seems a rather discontented sort of chap, grumbling at not having a New York practice. I should have thought he had a rather snug berth down there at Lindbrook with all those swells to dose. Justine smiled. Dr. Wyant is ambitious, and swells don't have as interesting diseases as poor people. One gets tired of giving them bread-pills for imaginary ailments. But Dr. Wyant is not strong himself, and I fancy a country practice is better for him than hard work in town. You think him clever, though, do you? Westie inquired absently. He was already bored with the subject of the Long Island doctor, and vexed at the lack of perception that led his companion to show more concern in the fortunes of a country practitioner than in the fact of his own visit to the Amhersts. But the topic was a safe one, and it was agreeable to see how her face kindled when she was interested. Justine mused on his question. I think he has very great promise, which he is almost certain not to fulfill, she answered with a sigh, which seemed to Westie's anxious ear to betray more than professional interest in the person referred to. Oh, come now, why not, with the Amhersts, to give him a start? I heard my cousin recommending him to a lot of people the other day. Oh, he may become a fashionable doctor, Justine assented indifferently, to which her companion rejoined with a puzzled stare. That's just what I mean, with Bessie backing him. Has Mrs. Amherst become such a power then, Justine asked, taking up the coveted theme just as he despaired of attracting her to it. My cousin, he stretched the two syllables to the cracking point. Well, she's awfully rich, you know, and there's nobody smarter. Don't you think so? I don't know, it's so long since I've seen her. He brightened. You did know her then, but the discovery made her obtuseness the more inexplicable. Oh, centuries ago in another world. Centuries! I like that, Westie gallantly protested, his ardor kindling as she swam once more within his social ken. And Amherst, you know him too, I suppose? By Jove, here he is now. He signaled a tall figure strolling slowly toward them with bent head and brooding gaze. Justine's eye had retained a vivid image of the man with whom, scarcely three years earlier, she had lived through a moment of such poignant intimacy, and she recognized at once his lean outline and the keen spring of his features still veiled by the same look of inward absorption. She noticed, as he raised his hat in response to Westie Gaines' greeting, that the vertical lines between his brows had deepened, and a moment later she was aware that this change was the visible token of others, which went deeper than the fact of his good clothes and his general air of leisure and well-being—changes perceptible to her only in the startled sense of how prosperity had aged him. Hello, Amherst, trying to get undercover, Westie jovially accosted him, with a significant gesture toward the crowded lawn from which the newcomer had evidently fled. I was just telling Miss Brent that this is the safest place on these painful occasions. Oh, confounded, it's not as safe as I thought. Here's one of my sisters making for me. There ensued a short conflict of words before his feeble flutter of resistance was borne down by a resolute Miss Gaines, who, as she swept him back to the marquee, cried out to Amherst that her mother was asking for him too, and then Justine had time to observe that her remaining companion had no intention of responding to his hostess's appeal. Westie, in naming her, had laid just enough stress on the name to let it serve as a reminder or an introduction, as circumstances might decide, and she saw that Amherst, roused from his abstraction by the proffered clue, was holding his hand out doubtfully. I think we haven't met for some years, he said. Justine smiled. I have a better reason than you for remembering the exact date, and in response to his look of surprise, she added, You made me commit a professional breach of faith, and I've never known since whether to be glad or sorry. Amherst still bent on her the gaze which seemed to find in external details an obstacle rather than a help to recognition, but suddenly his face cleared. It was you who told me the truth about poor Dylan. I couldn't imagine why I seemed to see you in such a different setting. Oh, I'm disguised as a lady this afternoon, she said, smiling, but I'm glad you saw through the disguise. He smiled back at her. Are you? Why? It seems to make it, if it's so transparent, less of a sham, less of a dishonesty, she began impulsively, and then paused again, a little annoyed at the over-emphasis of her words. Why was she explaining and excusing herself to this stranger? Did she propose to tell him next that she had borrowed her dress from Effie Dressel? To cover her confusion she went on with a slight laugh. But you haven't told me. What was I to tell you? Whether to be glad or sorry that I broke my vow and told the truth about Dylan. They were standing face to face in the solitude of the garden walk, forgetful of everything, but the sudden surprised sense of intimacy that had marked their former brief communion. Justine had raised her eyes half laughingly to Amherst, but they dropped before the unexpected seriousness of his. Why do you want to know, he asked. She made an effort to sustain the note of pleasantry. Well, it might for instance determine my future conduct. You see, I'm still a nurse, and such problems are always likely to present themselves. Ah, then don't. Don't? I mean, he hesitated a moment, reaching up to break a rose from the branch that tapped his shoulder. I was only thinking what risks we run when we scramble into the chariot of the gods and try to do the driving. Be passive. Be passive and you'll be happier. Oh, as to that, she swept it aside with one of her airy motions. But Dylan, for instance, would he have been happier if I'd been passive? Amherst seemed to ponder. There again, how can one tell? And the risks not worth taking? No. She paused and they looked at each other again. Do you mean that seriously, I wonder? Do you? Act on it myself, God forbid. The gods drive so badly. There's poor Dylan. He happened to be in their way, as we all are at times. He pulled himself up and went on in a matter of fact tone. In Dylan's case, however, my axioms don't apply. When my wife heard of the truth, she was, of course, immediately kind to him, and if it hadn't been for you, she might never have known. Dean smiled. I think you would have found out. I was only the humble instrument. But now, she hesitated, now you must be able to do so much. Amherst lifted his head and she saw the color rise under his fair skin. Out at Westmore? You've never been there since? Yes, my wife has made some changes, but it's all so problematic. And one would have to live here. You don't, then? He answered by an imperceptible shrug. Of course I'm here often, and she comes now and then, but the journey's tiresome, and it is not always easy for her to get away. He checked himself, and Justine saw that he, in turn, was suddenly conscious of the incongruity of explaining and extenuating his personal situation to a stranger. But then were not strangers a voice in her exalted just as he added, with an embarrassed attempt to efface and yet justify his moment of expansion. That reminds me, I think you know my wife. I heard her asking Mrs. Dressel about you. She wants so much to see you. The transition had been affected at the expense of dramatic interest, but to the obvious triumph of social observances, and to Justine, after all, regaining at his side the group about the marquee, the interest was not so much diminished, as shifted to the no less suggestive problem of studying the friend of her youth in the unexpected character of John Amherst's wife. Meanwhile, however, during the brief transit across the Gaines Greensward, her thoughts were still busy with Amherst. She had seen at once that the peculiar sense of intimacy reawakened by their meeting had been chilled and deflected by her first allusion to the topic which had previously brought them together. Amherst had drawn back as soon as she named the mills. What could be the cause of his reluctance? When they had last met, the subject burned within him. Her being an actual fact a stranger had not then been an obstacle to his confidences. Now that he was master at Westmore, it was plain that another tone became him. That his situation necessitated a greater reserve. But her inquiry did not imply the least wish to overstep this restriction. It merely showed her remembrance of his frankly avowed interest in the operatives. Justine was struck by the fact that so natural an allusion should put him on the defensive. She did not for a moment believe that he had lost his interest in the mills, and that his point of view should have shifted with the fact of ownership, she rejected as an equally superficial reading of his character. The man with whom she had talked at Dylan's bedside was one in whom the ruling purposes had already shaped themselves, and to whom life in whatever form it came must henceforth take their mold. As she reached this point in her analysis, it occurred to her that his shrinking from the subject might well imply not indifference, but a deeper preoccupation, a preoccupation for some reason suppressed and almost disavowed, yet sustaining the more intensely its painful hidden life. From this inference it was but a leap of thought to the next, that the cause of the change must be sought outside of himself in some external influence strong enough to modify the innate lines of his character. And where could such an influence be more obviously sought than in the marriage which had transformed the assistant manager of the Westmore mills not, indeed, into their owner, that would rather have tended to simplify the problem, but into the husband of Mrs. Westmore. After all, the mills were Bessie's, and for a further understanding of the case it remained to find out what manner of person Bessie had become. Justine's first impression as her friend's charming arms received her, with an eagerness of welcome not lost on the suspended judgment of Feminine Hannaford, the immediate impression was of a gain of emphasis, of individuality, as though the fluid creature she remembered had belied her prediction and run at last into a definite mold. Yes, Bessie had acquired an outline, a graceful one as became her early promise, though with perhaps a little more sharpness of edge than her youthful texture had promised. But the side she turned to her friend was still all softness, had in it a hint of the old pliancy, the impulse to lean and enlace, that at once woken Justine the corresponding instinct of guidance and protection so that their first kiss before a word was spoken carried the two back to the precise relation in which their school days had left them. So easy or reversion to the past left no room for the sense of subsequent changes by which such reunions are sometimes embarrassed. Justine's sympathies had, instinctively and almost at once, transferred themselves to Bessie's side. Passing over at a leap, the pained recognition that there were sides already, and Bessie had gathered up Justine into the circle of gentle self-absorption, which left her very dimly aware of any distinctive characteristic in her friends except that of their affection for herself, since she asked only, as she appealingly put it, that they should all be dreadfully fond of her. And I've wanted you so often, Justine. You're the only clever person I'm not afraid of, because your cleverness always used to make things clear instead of confusing them. I've asked so many people about you, but I never heard a word till just the other day. Wasn't it odd, when our new doctor at Rushton happened to say that he knew you? I've been rather unwell lately, nervous and tired and sleeping badly, and he told me I ought to keep perfectly quiet and be under the care of a nurse who could make me do as she chose, just such a nurse as a wonderful Miss Brent he had known at St. Elizabeth's, whose patients obeyed her as if she'd been the colonel of a regiment. His description made me laugh. It reminded me so much of the way you used to make me do what you wanted at the convent. And then it suddenly occurred to me that I had heard of you having gone in for nursing, and we compared notes, and I found it was really you. Wasn't it odd that we should discover each other in that way? I daresay we might have passed in the street and never known it. I'm sure I must be horribly changed. Thus Bessie discourseed in the semi-isolation to which, under an overarching beach-tree, the discretion of their hostess had allowed the two friends to withdraw for the freer exchange of confidences. There was, at first sight, nothing in her aspect to bear out Mrs. Amherst's plaintive allusion to her health, but Justine, who knew that she had lost a baby a few months previously, assumed that the effect of this shock still lingered, though evidently mitigated by a reviving interest in pretty clothes and the other ornamental accessories of life. Certainly Bessie Amherst had grown into the full loveliness which her childhood promised. She had the kind of finished prettiness that declares itself early, holds its own through the awkward transitions of girlhood, and resists the strain of all later vicissitudes, as though miraculously preserved in some clear medium impenetrable to the wear and tear of living. You absurd child! You've not changed a bit except to grow more so, Justine laughed, paying a mused tribute to the childish craving for a compliment that still betrayed itself in Bessie's eyes. Well, you have then, Justine, you've grown extraordinarily handsome. That is extraordinary of me, certainly, the other acknowledged gaily, but then think what room for improvement there was, and how much time I've had to improve in. It is a long time, isn't it, Bessie assented. I feel so intimate still with the old Justine of the convent, and I don't know the new one a bit. Just think, I have a great girl of my own, almost as old as we were when we went to the Sacred Heart. But perhaps you don't know anything about me, either. You see, I married again two years ago, and my poor baby died last March, so I have only Sicily. It was such a disappointment. I wanted a boy dreadfully, and I understand little babies so much better than a big girl like Sicily. Oh, dear, here's Juliana Gaines bringing up some more tiresome people. It's such a bore, but John says I must know them all. Well, thank goodness we've only one more day in this dreadful place, and of course I shall see you, dear, before we go. End of Book Two, Chapter Ten Book Two, Chapter Eleven of Fruit of the Tree This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. The Fruit of the Tree by Edith Wharton, Book Two, Chapter Eleven. After conducting Miss Brent to his wife, John Amhurst, by the exercise of considerable strategic skill, had once more contrived to detach himself from the throng on the lawn, and regaining a path in the shrubbery had taken refuge on the veranda of the house. Here, under the shade of the awning, two ladies were seated in a seclusion agreeably tempered by the distant strains of the Hanifurt Band, and by the shifting prospect of the groups below them. Ah, here he is now, the younger of the two exclaimed, turning on Amhurst the smile of intelligence that Mrs. Eustis Ansel was in the habit of substituting for the idle preliminaries of conversation. We were not talking of you, though, she added, as Amhurst took the seat to which his mother beckoned him, but of Bessie, which I suppose is almost as indiscreet. She added the last phrase after an imperceptible pause, and as if in deprecation of the hardly more perceptible frown which, at the mention of his wife's name, had deepened the lines between Amhurst's brows. Indiscreet of his own mother and his wife's friend, Mrs. Amhurst protested, laying her trimly-gloved hand on her son's arm, while the latter with his eyes on her companion said slowly, Mrs. Ansel knows that indiscretion is the last fault of which her friends are likely to accuse her. Raison de plus humines, she laughed, meeting squarely the challenge that passed between them under Mrs. Amhurst's puzzled gaze. Well, if I take advantage of my reputation for discretion to meddle a little now and then, at least I do so in a good cause. I was just saying how much I wished that you would take Bessie to Europe, and I am so sure of my cause in this case that I am going to leave it to your mother to give you my reasons. She rose as she spoke, not with any sign of haste or embarrassment, but as if gracefully recognizing the desire of mother and son to be alone together. But Amhurst, rising also, made a motion to detain her. "'No one else will be able to put your reasons half so convincingly,' he said with a slight smile, and I'm sure my mother would much rather be spared the attempt. Mrs. Ansel met the smile as freely as she had met the challenge. My dear Lucy, she rejoined, laying as she receded herself, a light caress on Mrs. Amhurst's hand. I'm sorry to be flattered at your expense, but it's not in human nature to resist such an appeal. You see,' she added, raising her eyes to Amhurst, how sure I am of myself and of you when you've heard me. "'Oh, John is always ready to hear one,' his mother murmured innocently. "'Well, I don't know that I shall even ask him to do as much as that. I'm so sure, after all, that my suggestion carries its explanation with it.' There was a moment's pause during which Amhurst led his eyes wander absently over the dissolving groups on the lawn. The suggestion that I should take Bessie to Europe?' he paused again. "'When, next autumn?' "'No, now, at once, on a long honeymoon.'" He frowned slightly at the last word, passing it by to revert to the direct answer to his question. "'At once? No, I can't see that the suggestion carries its explanation with it.' Bessie's ansel looked at him hesitatingly. She was conscious of the ill-chosen word that still reverberated between them, and the unwanted sense of having blundered made her, for the moment, less completely mistress of herself. "'Ah, you'll see further presently.' She rose again, unfurling her lace sunshade, as if to give a touch of definiteness to her action. "'It's not, after all,' she added, with a sweet frankness, a cause for argument, and still less for persuasion. "'My reasons are excellent. I should insist on putting them to you myself if they were not. But they're so good that I can leave you to find them out, and to back them up with your own, which will probably be a great deal better.' She summed up with a light nod, which included both Amherst and his mother, and, turning to descend the veranda-steps, waved a signal to Mr. Langhope, who was limping disconsolently toward the house. "'What has she been saying to you, mother?' Amherst asked, returning to his seat beside his mother. Mrs. Amherst replied by a shake of her head and a raised forefinger of reproval. "'Now, Johnny, I won't answer a single question till you smooth out those lines between your eyes.' Her son relaxed his frown to smile back at her. "'Well, dear, there have to be some wrinkles in every family, and as you absolutely refuse to take your share.' His eyes rested affectionately on the frosty sparkle of her charming old face, which had, in its setting of recovered prosperity, the freshness of a sunny winter morning, when the very snow gives out a suggestion of warmth. He remembered how, on the evening of his dismissal from the mills, he had paused on the threshold of their sitting-room to watch her a moment in the lamp-light, and had thought, with bitter compunction, about the fresh wrinkle he was about to add to the lines about her eyes. The three years which followed had effaced that wrinkle and veiled the others in a tardy bloom of well-being. From the moment of turning her back on Westmore and establishing herself in the pretty little house at Hannaford, which her son's wife had placed at her disposal, Mrs. Amherst had shed all traces of the difficult years, and the fact that his marriage had enabled him to set free before it was too late the pent-up springs of her youthfulness sometimes seemed to Amherst the clearest gain in his life's confused total of profit and loss. It was, at any rate, the sense of Bessie's share in the change that softened his voice when he spoke to her of his mother. Now then, if I present a sufficiently unruffled surface, let us go back to Mrs. Ansel, for I confess that her mysterious reasons are not yet apparent to me. Mrs. Amherst looked deprecatingly at her son. Maria Ansel is devoted to you, too, John. Of course she is. It's her role to be devoted to everybody, especially to her enemies. Her enemies? Oh, I didn't intend any personal application. But why does she want me to take Bessie abroad? She and Mr. Langhope think that Bessie is not looking well. Amherst paused, and the frown showed itself for a moment. What do you think, mother? I hadn't noticed it myself. Bessie seems to me prettier than ever. But perhaps she has less color, and she complains of not sleeping. Maria thinks she still frets over the baby. Amherst made an impatient gesture. Is Europe the only panacea? You should consider, John, that Bessie is used to have change in amusement. I think you sometimes forget that other people haven't your faculty of absorbing themselves in a single interest. And Maria says that the new doctor at Clifton, whom they seem to think so clever, is very anxious that Bessie should go to Europe this summer. No doubt. And so is everyone else. I mean her father and old Tredegar, and your friend Mrs. Ansel, not least. Mrs. Amherst lifted her bright black eyes to his. Well, then, if they all think she needs it. Good heavens, if travel were what she needed. Why, we've never stopped traveling since we married. We've been everywhere on the globe except at Hannaford. This is her second visit here in three years. He rose and took a rapid turn across the deserted Veranda. It's not because her health requires it. It's to get me away from Westmore, to prevent things being done here that ought to be done, he broke out vehemently, halting again before his mother. The aged pink faded from Mrs. Amherst's face, but her eyes retained their lively glitter. To prevent things being done, what a strange thing to say. I shouldn't have said it if I hadn't seen you falling under Mrs. Ansel's spell. His mother had a gesture which showed from whom he had inherited his impulsive movements. Really, my son! She folded her hands and added after a pause of self-recovery, if you mean that I have ever attempted to interfere. No, no, but when they pervert things so damnably. John! He dropped into his chair again and pushed the hair from his forehead with a groan. Well, then, put it that they have as much right to their view as I have. I only want you to see what it is. Whenever I try to do anything at Westmore, to give a real start to the work that Bessie and I plan together, some pretext is found to stop it. To pack us off to the ends of the earth, to cry out against reducing her income, to encourage her and some new extravagance to which the work at the mills must be sacrificed. Mrs. Amherst, growing pale under this outbreak, assured herself by a nervous backward glance that their privacy was still uninvaded, then her eyes returned to her son's face. John! Are you sure you're not sacrificing your wife to the mills? He grew pale in turn, and they looked at each other for a moment without speaking. You see it as they do, then? He rejoined with a discouraged sigh. I see it as any old woman would who had my experiences to look back to. Mother! he exclaimed. She smiled composately. Do you think I mean that as a reproach? That's because men will never understand women, least of all sons their mothers. No real mother wants to come first. She puts her son's career ahead of everything. But it's different with a wife, a wife as much in love as Bessie. Amherst looked away. I should have thought that was a reason. That would reconcile her to being set aside, to counting only second in your plans? They were her plans when we married. Ah, my dear! she paused on that, letting her shrewd old glance and all the delicate lines of experience in her face supply what further comment the ineptitude of his argument invited. He took the full measure of her meaning, receiving it in a baffled silence that continued as she rose and gathered her lace mantle about her, as if to signify that their confidences could not, on such an occasion, be further prolonged without singularity. Then he stood up also and joined her, resting his hand on hers while she leaned on the veranda rail. Poor mother, and I've kept you to myself all this time and spoiled your good afternoon. No, dear, I was a little tired and had slipped away to be quiet. She paused and then went on persuasively giving back his pressure. I know how you feel about doing your duty, John, but now that things are so comfortably settled, isn't it a pity to unsettle them? Amherst had intended on leaving his mother to rejoin Bessie, whom he could still discern on the lawn in an absorbed communion with Miss Brent, but after what had passed it seemed impossible for the moment to recover the garden party tone, and he made us escape through the house while a trio of Cuban singers, who formed the crowning number of the entertainment, gathered the company in a denser circle about their guitars. As he walked on aimlessly under the deep June shadows of Maple Wood Avenue, his mother's last words formed an ironical accompaniment to his thoughts. Now that things are comfortably settled, he knew so well what that elastic epithet covered. Himself, for instance, ensconced in the impenetrable prosperity of his wonderful marriage, herself, too, unconsciously, dear soul, so happily tucked away in a cranny of that new and spacious life, and no more able to conceive why existing conditions should be disturbed than the bird in the eaves understands why the house should be torn down. Well, he had learned at last what his experience with his poor, valiant, puzzled mother might have taught him, that one must never ask from women any view but the personal one, any measure of conduct but that of their own pains and pleasures. She, indeed, had borne undauntedly enough the brunt of their earlier trials, but that was merely because, as she said, the mother's instinct bade her heap all her private hopes on the great devouring altar of her son's ambition. It was not because she had ever, in the very least, understood or sympathized with his aims. And, Bessie, perhaps if their little son had lived she might, in turn, have obeyed the old world instinct of self- effacement. But now, he remembered with an intense self- derision that, not even in the first surprise of his passion had he diluted himself with the idea that Bessie Westmore was an exception to her sex. He had argued, rather, that, being only a lovelier product of the common mold, she would abound in the adaptabilities and appliances which the lords of the earth have seen fit to cultivate in their companions. She would care for his aims because they were his. During their precipitate wooing, and through the first brief months of marriage, this profound and original theory had been gratifyingly confirmed, then its perfect surface had begun to show a flaw. Amherst had always conveniently supposed that the poet's line summed up the good woman's rule of ethics. He for God only, she for God in him. It was for the God in him, surely, that she had loved him, for that first glimpse of an ampler aether, a diviner air that he had brought into her cramped and curtained life. He could never now evoke that earlier delusion without feeling on its still tender surface the keen edge of Mrs. Ansel's smile. She, no doubt, could have told him at any time why Bessie had married him. It was for his beau-hu, as Mrs. Ansel would have put it, because he was handsome, young, persecuted, an ardent lover, if not a subtle one, because Bessie had met him at the fatal moment, because her family had opposed the marriage, because, in brief, the gods that day may have been a little short of amusement. Well, they were having their laugh now. There were moments when high heaven seemed to ring with it. With these thoughts at his heels Amherst strode on, overtaken now and again by the wheels of departing guests from the garden party, and knowing as they passed him what was in their minds, envy of his success, admiration of his cleverness in achieving it, and a little half-contemptuous pity for his wife, who, with her wealth and looks, might have done so much better. Certainly, if the case could have been put to Hannaford, the Hannaford of the Gaines Garden Party, it would have sided with Bessie to a voice. And how much justice was there in what he felt would have been the unanimous verdict of her class? Was his mother right in hinting that he was sacrificing Bessie to the mills? But the mills were Bessie, at least he had thought so when he married her. They were her particular form of contact with life, the expression of her relation to her fellow men, her pretext, her opportunity, unless they were merely a vast purse in which to plunge for her pin-money. He had fancied it would rest with him to determine from which of these standpoints she should view Westmore, and at the outset she had enthusiastically viewed it from his. In her eager adoption of his ideas she had made a pet of the mills, organizing the Mother's Club, laying out a recreation ground on the Hopewood property, and playing with pretty plans in water-color for the emergency hospital and the building which was to contain the night-schools, library, and gymnasium. But even these minor projects, which he had urged her to take up as a means of learning their essential dependence on his larger scheme, were soon to be set aside by obstacles of a material order. Bessie always wanted money. Not a great deal, but as she reasonably put it, enough. And who was to blame her if her father and Mr. Tredegar, each in his different capacity, felt obliged to point out that every philanthropic outlay at Westmore must entail a corresponding reduction in her income. Perhaps if she could have been oftener at Hannaford these arguments would have been counteracted, for she was tender-hearted and prompt to relieve such suffering as she saw about her. But her imagination was not active, and it was easy for her to forget painful sights when they were not under her eye. This was, perhaps, half consciously one of the reasons why she avoided Hannaford, why as Amherst exclaimed, they had been everywhere since their marriage but to the place where their obligations called them. There had, at any rate, always been some good excuse for not returning there, and consequently for postponing the work of improvement which it was generally felt her husband could not fitly begin till she had returned and gone over the ground with him. After their marriage and especially in view of the comment excited by that romantic incident, it was impossible not to yield to her wish that they should go abroad for a few months. Then, before her confinement, the doctors had exacted that she should be spared all fatigue and worry. And after the baby's death, Amherst had felt with her too tenderly to venture an immediate return to unwelcome questions. For by this time it had become clear to him that such questions were and always would be unwelcome to her. As the easiest means of escaping them she had once more dismissed the whole problem to the vague and tiresome sphere of business whence he had succeeded in detaching it for a moment in the early days of their union. Her first husband, poor unappreciated Westmore, had always spared her the boredom of business, and Halford Gaines and Mr. Tredegard were ready to show her the same consideration. It was part of the modern code of chivalry that lovely woman should not be bothered about ways and means. But Bessie was too much the wife and the wife-in-love to consent that her husband's views on the management of the mills should be totally disregarded. Precisely because her advisers looked unfavorably on his intervention she felt bound, if only in defense of her illusions, to maintain and emphasize it. The mills were, in fact, the official platform on which she had married. Amherst's devoted role at Westmore had justified the unconventionality of the step. And so she was committed, the more helplessly, for her dense, misintelligence of both sides of the question, to the policy of conciliating the opposing influences which had so uncomfortably chosen to fight out their case on the field of her poor little existence, theoretically citing with her husband, but surreptitiously, as he well knew, giving aid and comfort to the enemy who were really defending her own cause. All this Amherst saw with that cruel insight which had replaced his former blindness. He was, in truth, more ashamed of the insight than of the blindness. It seemed to him horribly cold-blooded to be thus analyzing, after two years of marriage, the source of his wife's inconsistencies. And partly for this reason he had put off from month to month the final question of the future management of the mills and of the radical changes to be made there if his system were to prevail. But the time had come when, if Bessie had to turn to Westmore for the justification of her marriage, he had even more need of calling upon it for the same service. He had not assuredly married her because of Westmore, but he would scarcely have contemplated marriage with a rich woman, unless the source of her wealth had offered him some such opportunity as Westmore presented. His special training and the natural bent of his mind qualified him in what had once seemed a predestined manner to help Bessie to use her power nobly for her own uplifting as well as for that of Westmore. And so the mills became, incongruously enough, the plank of safety to which both clung in their sense of impending disaster. It was not that Amherst feared the temptation to idleness if this outlet for his activity were cut off. He had long since found that the luxury with which his wife surrounded him merely quickened his natural bent for hard work and a hard fare. He recalled, with a touch of bitterness, how he had once regretted having separated himself from his mother's class, and how seductive for a moment to both mind and senses that other life had appeared. Well, he knew it now, and it had neither charm nor peril for him. Capua must have been a dull place to one who had once shrunk the joy of battle. What he dreaded was not that he should learn to love the life of ease, but that he should grow to loathe uncontrollably, as the symbol of his mental and spiritual bondage. And Westmore was his safety valve, his refuge. If he were cut off from Westmore, what remained to him? It was not only the work he had found to his hand, but the one work for which his hand was fitted. It was his life that he was fighting for and insisting that now, at last, before the close of this long deferred visit to Hannaford, the question of the mills should be faced and settled. He had made that clear to Bessie in a scene he still shrank from recalling, for it was of the essence of his somewhat unbending integrity that he would not trick her into a confused surrender to the personal influence he still possessed over her, but must seek to convince her by the tedious process of argument and exposition against which she knew no defence but tears and petulance. But he had, at any rate, gained her consent to his setting forth his views at the meeting of directors the next morning, and meanwhile he had meant to be extraordinarily patient and reasonable with her, till the hint of Mrs. Ansel's stratagem produced in him a fresh reaction of distrust. That evening, when dinner ended, Mrs. Ansel, with a glance through the tall dining-room windows, had suggested to Bessie that it would be pleasanter to take coffee on the veranda, but Amherst detained his wife with a glance. I should like Bessie to stay, he said. The dining-room being on the cool side of the house, with a refreshing outlook on the garden, the men preferred to smoke there, then in the stuffily-draped oriental apartment, destined to such rites, and Bessie Amherst with a faint sigh sank back into her seat while Mrs. Ansel drifted out through one of the open windows. The men surrounding Richard West Moore's table were the same who nearly three years earlier had gathered in his house for the same purpose, the discussion of conditions at the mills. The only perceptible change in the relation to each other of the persons composing this group was that John Amherst was now the host of the other two, instead of being a subordinate called in for cross-examination. But he was so indifferent, or at least so heedless a host, so forgetful, for instance, of Mr. Tredegar's preference for a light cigar, and of Mr. Lang Hope's feelings on the duty of making the West Moore Madeira circulate with the sun, that the change was manifest only in his evening dress and in the fact of his sitting at the foot of the table. If Amherst was conscious of the contrast thus implied, it was only as a restriction on his freedom. As far as the welfare of West Moore was concerned he would rather have stood before his companions as the assistant manager of the mills than as the husband of their owner, and it seemed to him as he looked back that he had done very little with the opportunity which looked so great in the light of his present restrictions. What he had done with it, the use to which as unfriendly critics might insinuate he had so adroitly put it, had landed him, ironically enough, in the ugly impasse of a situation from which no issue seemed possible without some wasteful sacrifice of feeling. His wife's feelings, for example, were already revealing themselves in an impatient play of her fan that made her father presently lean forward to suggest, if we men are to talk shop, is it necessary to keep Bessie in this hot room? Amherst rose and opened the window behind his wife's chair. There is a breeze from the West, the room will be cooler now, he said, returning to his seat. Oh, I don't mind, Bessie murmured, in a tone intended to give her companions the full measure of what she was being called on to endure. Mr. Tredegar coughed slightly. May I trouble you for that other box of cigars, Amherst? No, not the companions. Bessie rose and handed him the box on which his glance significantly rested. Ah, thank you, my dear. I was about to ask. He continued, looking about for the cigar-lighter, which flamed unheated at Amherst's elbow, what special purpose will be served by a preliminary review of the questions to be discussed to-morrow? Ah, exactly, murmured Mr. Langhope. The Madeira, my dear John? No, ah, please, to the left. Amherst impatiently reversed the direction in which he had set the precious vessel moving, and turned to Mr. Tredegar, who was conspicuously lighting his cigar with a match extracted from his waistcoat pocket. The purpose is to define my position in the matter, and I prefer that Bessie should do this with your help rather than with mine. Mr. Tredegar surveyed his cigar with drooping lids, as though the question propounded by Amherst were perched on its tip. Is not your position naturally involved in and defined by hers? You will excuse my saying that, technically speaking, of course. I cannot distinctly conceive of it as having any separate existence. Mr. Tredegar spoke with the deliberate mildness that was regarded as his most effective weapon at the bar, since it was likely to abash those who were too intelligent to be propitiated by it. Certainly it is involved in hers, Amherst agreed, but how far that defines it is just what I have waited till now to find out. Bessie at this point recalled her presence by a restless turn of her graceful person, and her father, with an affectionate glance at her, interposed amicably. But surely, according to old-fashioned ideas, it implies identity of interests? Yes, but whose interests, Amherst asked? Why, your wife's man, she owns the mills? Amherst hesitated. I would rather talk of my wife's interest in the mills than of her interests there, but we'll keep to the plural if you prefer it. Personally, I believe the terms should be interchangeable in the conduct of such a business. Ah, I'm glad to hear that, said Mr. Tredegar quickly, since it's precisely the view we all take. Amherst's color rose. Definitions are ambiguous, he said. Before you adopt mine, perhaps I had better develop it a little further. What I mean is that Bessie's interests in Westmore should be regulated by her interest in it, in its welfare as a social body, aside from its success as a commercial enterprise. If we agree on this definition, we are at one as to the other, namely, that my relation to the matter is defined by hers. He paused a moment as if to give his wife time to contribute some sign of assent and encouragement, but she maintained a puzzled silence, and he went on. There is nothing new in this. I have tried to make Bessie understand from the beginning what obligations I thought the ownership of Westmore entailed, and how I hoped to help her fulfill them. But ever since our marriage all definite discussion of the subject has been put off for one cause or another, and that is my reason for urging that it should be brought up at the director's meeting tomorrow. There was another pause during which Bessie glanced tentatively at Mr. Tredegar, and then said, with a lovely rise of colour, But, John, sometimes I think you forget how much has been done at Westmore, the mother's club and the playground and all, in the way of carrying out your ideas. Mr. Tredegar discreetly dropped his glance to his cigar, and Mr. Langhope sounded an irrepressible note of approval and encouragement. No, I have not forgotten, and I am grateful to you for giving my ideas a trial. But what has been done hitherto is purely superficial. Bessie's eyes clouded, and he added hastily, Don't think I undervalue it for that reason. Heaven knows the surface of life needs improving. But it's like picking flowers and sticking them in the ground to make a garden. Unless you transplant the flower with its roots and prepare the soil to receive it, your garden will be faded to-morrow. No radical changes have yet been made at Westmore, and it is of radical changes that I want to speak. Bessie's look grew more pained, and Mr. Langhope exclaimed with unwanted irascibility. Upon my soul, Amherst, the tone you take about which your wife has done doesn't strike me as the likeliest way of encouraging her to do more. I don't want to encourage her to do more on such a basis. The sooner she sees the futility of it, the better for Westmore. The futility, Bessie broke out, with the flutter of tears in her voice. But before her father could intervene, Mr. Tredegar had raised his hand with the gesture of one accustomed to wield the gavel. My dear child, I see Amherst's point, and it is best as he says that you should see it too. What he desires, as I understand it, is the complete reconstruction of the present state of things at Westmore. And he is right in saying that all your good works there, night-schools and nursery and so forth, leave that issue untouched. A smile quivered under Mr. Langhope's mustache. He and Amherst both knew that Mr. Tredegar's faint of recognizing the justice of his adversary's claim was merely the first step to annihilating it. But Bessie could never be made to understand this, and always felt herself deserted and betrayed when any side but her own was given a hearing. I'm sorry if all I've tried to do at Westmore is useless, but I suppose I shall never understand business, she murmured, vainly seeking consolation in her father's eye. This is not business, Amherst broken. It's the question of your personal relation to the people there, the last thing that business considers. Mr. Langhope uttered an impatient exclamation. I wished to heaven the owner of the mills had made it clear just what that relation was to be. I think he did, sir, Amherst answered steadily, in leaving his wife the unrestricted control of the property. He had reddened under Mr. Langhope's thrust, but his voice betrayed no irritation, and Bessie rewarded him with an unexpected beam of sympathy. She was always up in arms at the least sign of his being treated as an intruder. I am sure, papa, she said a little tremulously, that poor Richard, though he knew I was not clever, felt he could trust me to take the best advice. Ah, that's all we ask of you, my child, her father's side, while Mr. Tredegard dryly interposed. We are merely losing time by this digression. Let me suggest that Amherst should give us an idea of the changes he wishes to make at Westmore. Amherst, as he turned to answer, remembered with what ardent faith in his powers of persuasion he had responded to the same appeal three years earlier. He had thought then that all his cause needed was a hearing. Now he knew that the practical man's readiness to let the idealist talk corresponds with the busy parent's permission to destructive infancy to run out and play. They would let him state his case to the four corners of the earth, if only he did not expect them to act on it. It was their policy to let him exhaust himself in argument and exhortation to listen to him so politely and patiently that if he failed to enforce his ideas it should not be for lack of opportunity to expound them, and the alternative struck him as hardly less to be feared, supposing that the incredible happened, that his reasons prevailed with his wife and through her with the others. At what cost would the victory be won? Would Bessie ever forgive him for winning it? And what would his situation be if it left him in control of Westmore but estranged from his wife? He recalled suddenly a phrase he had used that afternoon to the dark-eyed girl at the garden party. What risks we run when we scramble into the chariot of the gods? And at the same time he heard her retort and saw her fine gesture of defiance. How could he ever have doubted that the thing was worth doing at whatever cost? Something in him, some secret lurking element of weakness and evasion, shrank out of sight in the light of her question. Do you act on that? And the god forbid he had instantly flashed back to her. He turned to Mr. Tredegar with his answer. Am Hearst knew that any large theoretical exposition of the case would be as much wasted on the two men as on his wife. To gain his point he must take only one step at a time, and it seemed to him that the first thing needed at Westmore was that the hands should work and live under healthier conditions. To attain this two important changes were necessary. The floor space of the mills must be enlarged, and the company must cease to rent out tenements and give the operatives the opportunity to buy land for themselves. Both these changes involved the upheaval of the existing order. Whenever the Westmore mills had been enlarged, it had been for the sole purpose of increasing the revenues of the company. And now Am Hearst asked that these revenues should be materially and permanently reduced. As to the suppression of the company tenement, such a measure struck at the roots of the baneful paternalism which was choking out every germ of initiative in the workmen. Once the operatives had room to work in, and the hope of homes of their own to go to when work was over, Am Hearst was willing to trust to time for the satisfaction of their other needs. He believed that a sounder understanding of these needs would develop on both sides the moment the employers proved their good faith by the deliberate and permanent sacrifice of excessive gain to the well-being of the employed. And once the two had learned to regard each other not as antagonists, but as collaborators, a long step would have been taken toward a readjustment of the whole industrial relation. In regard to general and distant results, Am Hearst tried not to be too sanguine, even in his own thoughts. His aim was to remedy the abuse nearest at hand in the hope of thus getting gradually closer to the central evil, and had his action been unhampered he would still have preferred the longer and more circuitous path of practical experiment to the sweeping adoption of a new industrial system. But his demands, moderate as they were, assumed in his hearers the consciousness of a moral claim superior to the obligation of making one's business pay. And it was the futility of this assumption that chilled the arguments on his lips, since in the orthodox creed of the business world it was a weakness and not a strength to be content with five percent where ten was obtainable. Business was one thing, philanthropy another, and the enthusiasts who tried combining them were usually reduced after a brief flight to pay fifty cents on the dollar, and handing over their stock to a promoter presumably unhampered by humanitarian ideals. Am Hearst knew that this was the answer with which his plea would be met. Knew, moreover, that the plea was given a hearing simply because his judges deemed it so pitiably easy to refuse. But the knowledge, once he had begun to speak, fanned his argument to a white heat of pleading, since with failure so plainly ahead small concessions and compromises were not worth making. Reason would be wasted on all, but eloquence might at least prevail with Bessie. When late that night he went upstairs after long pacing's of the garden he was surprised to see a light in her room. She was not given to midnight study and, fearing that she might be ill, he knocked at her door. There was no answer, and after a short pause he turned to the handle and entered. In the great canopied Westmore couch her arms flung upward and her hands clasped beneath her head. She lay staring fretfully at the globe of electric light which hung from the center of the embossed and gilded ceiling. Seen thus with the soft curves of throat and arms revealed, and her face childishly set in a cloud of loosened hair she looked no older than Sicily and, like Sicily, inaccessible to grown-up arguments and the stronger logic of experience. It was a trick of hers in such moods to ignore any attempt to attract her notice, and Amherst was prepared for her remaining motionless as he paused on the threshold and then advanced toward the middle of the room. There had been a time when he would have been exasperated by her pretense of not seeing him, but a deep weariness of spirit now dulled him to these surface pricks. I was afraid you were not well when I saw the light burning he began. Thank you, I am quite well, she answered, in a colorless voice without turning her head. Shall I put it out then? You can't sleep with such a glare in your eyes. I should not sleep at any rate, and I hate to lie awake in the dark. He moved nearer, looking down compassionately on her perturbed face and struggling lips. She lay silent a moment, and then she faltered out, Because I'm so unhappy! The pretense of indifference was swept away by a gush of childish sobs as she flung over on her side and buried her face in the embroidered pillows. Amherst, bending down, laid a quieting hand on her shoulder. Bessie! she sobbed on. He seated himself silently in the arm chair beside the bed, and kept his soothing hold on her shoulder. The time had come when he went through all these accustomed acts of pacification as mechanically as a nurse soothing a fretful child, and once he had thought her weeping eloquent. He looked about him at the spacious room with its heavy hangings of damask and the thick velvet carpet which stifled his steps. Everywhere were the graceful tokens of her presence, the vast, lace-straped toilet-table strewn with silver and crystal, the embroidered muslin cushions heaped on the lounge, the little rose-lined slippers she had just put off, the lace wrapper with a scent of violets in its folds which he had pushed aside when he sat down beside her, and he remembered how full of a mysterious and intimate charm these things had once appeared to him. It was characteristic that the remembrance made him more patient with her now. Perhaps, after all, it was his failure that she was crying over. Don't be unhappy. You decided as seemed best to you, he said. She pressed her handkerchief against her lips, still keeping her head averted. But I hate all these arguments and disputes. Why should you unsettle everything? she murmured. His mother's words. Involuntarily he removed his hand from her shoulder, though he still remained seated by the bed. You are right. I see the uselessness of it, he assented, with an uncontrollable note of irony. She turned her head at the tone and fixed her plaintive, brimming eyes on him. You are angry with me. Was that troubling you, he leaned forward again with compassion in his face? Sancta simplicitus was the thought within him. I am not angry, he went on. Be reasonable and try to sleep. She started upright, the light masses of her hair, floating about her like silken seaweed, lifted on an invisible tide. Don't talk like that. I can't endure to be humored like a baby. I am unhappy, because I can't see why all these wretched questions should be dragged into our life. I hate to have you always disagreeing with Mr. Tredagar, who is so clever and has so much experience, and yet I hate to see you give way to him, because it makes it appear as if he didn't care a straw for my ideas, Amherst smiled. Well, he doesn't, and I never dreamed of making him. So don't worry about that, either. You never dreamed of making him care for your ideas? But then why do you? Why do I go on setting them forth at such great length, Amherst smiled again, to convince you. That's my only ambition. She stared at him, shaking her head back to toss a loose lock from her puzzled eyes. A tear still shone on her lashes, but with emotion it fell and trembled down her cheek. To convince me. But you know I am so ignorant of such things. Most women are. I never pretended to understand anything about economics or whatever you call it. No. Then how? He turned and looked at her gently. I thought she might have begun to understand something about me. About you? The color flowered softly under her clear skin. About what my ideas on such subjects were likely to be worth, judging from what you know of me in other respects. He paused and glanced away from her. Well, he concluded deliberately. I suppose I've had my answer tonight. Oh, John! He rose and wandered across the room, pausing a moment to finger absently the trinkets on the dressing table. The act recalled, with a curious vividness, certain dulled sensations of their first days together, when, to handle and examine these frail little accessories of her toilet, had been part of the wonder and amusement of his new existence. He could still hear her laugh as she leaned over him, watching his mystified look in the glass, till their reflected eyes met there and drew down her lips to his. He laid down the fragrant powder puff he had been turning slowly between his fingers and moved back toward the bed. In the interval he had reached a decision. Well, isn't it natural that I should think so? He began again as he stood beside her. When we married I never expected you to care or know much about economics. It isn't a quality a man usually chooses his wife for. But I had a fancy. Perhaps it shows my conceit that when we had lived together a year or two and you'd found out what kind of a fellow I was in other ways, ways any woman can judge of, I had a fancy that you might take my opinions on faith when it came to my own special business, the thing I'm generally supposed to know about. He knew that he was touching a sensitive chord, for best he had to the full her sexes pride of possessorship. He was a human and faulty till others criticized him. Then he became a god. But in this case a conflicting influence restrained her from complete response to his appeal. I do feel sure you know about the treatment of the hands and all that. But you said yourself once, the first time we ever talked about Westmore, that the business part was different. Here it was again, the ancient and irradicable belief in the separable body and soul. Even an industrial organization was supposed to be subject to the old theological distinction, and Bessie was ready to cooperate with her husband in the emancipation of Westmore's spiritual part if only its body remained under the law. Amherst controlled his impatience as it was always easy for him to do when he had fixed on a definite line of conduct. It was my situation that was different, not what you call the business part, that is inextricably bound up with the treatment of the hands. If I'm to have anything to do with the mills now I can deal with them only as your representative, and as such I am bound to take in the whole question. Bessie's face clouded. Was he going into it all again? But he read her look and went on reassuringly. That was what I meant by saying that I hoped you would take me on faith. If I want the welfare of Westmore it's above all, I believe, because I want Westmore to see you as I do, as the dispenser of happiness who could not endure to benefit by any wrong or injustice to others. Of course, of course I don't want to do them injustice. Well, then? He had seated himself beside her again, clasping in his the hand with which she was fretting the lace-edged sheet. He felt her restless fingers surrender slowly and her eyes turned to him in appeal. But I care for what people say of you, too, and you know it's horrid, but one must consider it if they say you're spending my money imprudently. The blood rose to her neck and face. I don't mind for myself, even if I have to give up as many things as Papa and Mr. Tredagar think. But there is Sicily. And if people said, if people said I was spending Sicily's money on improving the condition of the people to whose work she will someday owe all her wealth, Amherst paused, well, I would rather hear that set of me than any other thing I can think of, except one. Except what? That I was doing it with her mother's help and approval. She drew a long tremulous sigh. He knew it was always a relief to her to have him assert himself strongly. But a residue of resistance still clouded her mind. I should always want to help you, of course, but if Mr. Tredagar and Helford Gaines think your plans unbusinesslike, Mr. Tredagar and Helford Gaines are certain to think it so. And that is why I said, just now, that it comes in the end to your choosing between us, taking them on experience or taking me on faith. She looked at him wistfully. Of course, I should expect to give up things. You wouldn't want me to live here. I should not ask you to, he said, have smiling. I suppose there would be a good many things we couldn't do. You would certainly have less money for a number of years. After that I believe you would have more rather than less. But I should not want you to think that beyond a reasonable point the prosperity of the mills was ever to be measured by your dividends. No, she leaned back weirdly among the pillows. I suppose, for instance, we should have to give up Europe this summer. Here at last was the bottom of her thought. It was always on the immediate pleasure that her soul hung. She had not enough imagination to look beyond, even in the projecting of her own desires. And it was on his knowledge of this limitation that Amherst had deliberately built. I don't see how you could go to Europe, he said. The doctor thinks I need it, she faltered. In that case, of course, he stood up, not abruptly or with any show of irritation, but as if accepting this as her final answer. What you need most in the meantime is a little sleep, he said. I will tell your maid not to disturb you in the morning. He had returned to a soothing way of speech, as though definitely resigned to the inutility of further argument. And I will say good-bye now, he continued, because I shall probably take an early train before you wake. She sat up with a start. An early train? Why, where are you going? I must go to Chicago some time this month, and as I shall not be wanted here to-morrow, I might as well run out there at once and join you next week at Lindbrook. Bessie had grown pale. But I don't understand. Their eyes met. Can't you understand that I am human enough to prefer, under the circumstances, not being present at tomorrow's meeting, he said, with a dry laugh. She sank back with a moan of discouragement, turning her face away as he began to move toward his room. Shall I put the light out, he asked, pausing with his hand on the electric button. Yes, please. He pushed in the button and walked on, guided through the obscurity by the line of light under his door. As he reached the threshold he heard a little choking cry. John! Oh, John! he paused. I can't bear it. The sobs increased. Bear what? That you should hate me. Don't be foolish, he said, groping for his door-handle. But you do hate me, and I deserve it. Nonsense, dear, try to sleep. I can't sleep till you've forgiven me. Say you don't hate me. I'll do anything, only say you don't hate me. He stood still a moment, thinking. Then he turned back and made his way across the room to her side. As he sat down beside her, he felt her arms reach for his neck and her wet face pressed itself against his cheek. I'll do anything, she sobbed, and in the darkness he held her to him and hated his victory. End of Book Two, Chapter Twelve Book Two, Chapter Thirteen of The Fruit of the Tree This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. The Fruit of the Tree by Edith Wharton. Book Two, Chapter Thirteen Mrs. Ansel was engaged in what she called picking up threads. She had been abroad for the summer, had, in fact, transferred herself but a few hours earlier from her returning steamer to the little station at Lindbrook, and was now in the bright September afternoon which left her in sole possession of the terrace of Lindbrook House, using that pleasant eminence as a point of observation from which to gather up some of the loose ends of history dropped at her departure. It might have been thought that the actual scene outspread below her, the descending gardens, the tennis courts, the farmlands sloping away to the blue sea-like shimmer of the Hempstead Plains, offered, at the moment, little material for her purpose. But that was to view them with a superficial eye. Mrs. Ansel's trained gaze was, for example, greatly enlightened by the fact that the tennis courts were fringed by a group of people, indolently watchful of the figures agitating themselves about the nets, and that, as she turned her head toward the entrance avenue, the receding view of a station omnibus, followed by a luggage cart, announced that more guests were to be added to those who had almost taxed to its limits the expansibility of the luncheon table. All this to the initiated eye was full of suggestion, but its significance was as nothing to that presented by the approach of two figures which, as Mrs. Ansel watched, detached themselves from the cluster about the tennis-ground, and struck, obliquely and at a desultery pace, across the lawn toward the terrace. The figures, those of a slight young man with stooping shoulders, and of a lady equally youthful but slenderly erect, moved forward in absorbed communion, as if unconscious of their surroundings and indefinite as to their direction. Till, on the brink of the wide-grass terrace just below their observer's parapet, they paused a moment and faced each other in closer speech. This interchange of words, though brief in measure of time, lasted long enough to add a vivid strand to Mrs. Ansel's thickening skein. Then, on a gesture of the ladies and without signs of formal leaf-taking, the young man struck into a path which regained the entrance avenue, while his companion, quickening her pace, crossed the grass terrace and mounted the wide stone steps sweeping up to the house. These brought her out on the upper terrace a few yards from Mrs. Ansel's post, and exposed her unprepared to the full beam of welcome which that lady's rapid advance threw like a searchlight across her path. Dear Miss Brent, I was just wondering how it was that I hadn't seen you before. Mrs. Ansel, as she spoke, drew the girl's hand into a long, soft clasp which served to keep them confronted while she delicately groped for whatever thread the encounter seemed to proffer. Justine made no attempt to evade the scrutiny to which she found herself exposed. She merely released her hand by a movement instinctively evasive of the mechanical endearment, explaining with a smile that softened the gesture. I was out with Sicily when you arrived. We've just come in. The dear child, I haven't seen her either. Mrs. Ansel continued to bestow upon the speaker's clear dark face an intensity of attention which, for the moment, Sicily had no perceptible share. I hear you are teaching her botany and all kinds of wonderful things. Justine smiled again. I am trying to teach her to wonder. That is the hardest faculty to cultivate in the modern child. Yes, I suppose so, and myself, Mrs. Ansel admitted with a response of brightness, I find it develops with age. The world is a remarkable place. She threw this off absently as though leaving Miss Brent to apply it either to the inorganic phenomena with which Sicily was supposed to be occupied or to those subtler manifestations that engaged her own attention. It's a great thing she continued for Bessie to have had your help, for Sicily and for herself, too. There is so much that I want you to tell me about her. As an old friend, I want the benefit of your fresher eye. About Bessie, Justine hesitated, letting her glance drift to the distant group still anchored about the tennis nets. Don't you find her looking better? Then, when I left, so much that I was unduly disturbed just now by seeing that clever little doctor. It was he, wasn't it, who came up the lawn with you? Dr. Wyant, yes, Miss Brent hesitated again. But he merely called with a message. Not professionally, Tom Mew. The truth is I was anxious about Bessie when I left. I thought she ought to have gone abroad for a change. But, as it turns out, her little excursion with you did as well. I think she only needed a rest. Perhaps her six weeks in the Adirondacks were better than Europe. Ah, under your care, that made them better. Mrs. Ansel, in turn, hesitated, the lines of her face melting and changing as if a rapid-stage hand had shifted them. When she spoke again they were as open as a public square, but also as destitute of personal significance, as flat and smooth as the painted drop before the real scene it hides. I have always thought that Bessie, for all her health and activity, needs as much care as Sicily. The kind of care a clever friend can give. She is so wasteful of her strength and her nerves and so unwilling to listen to reason. Poor Dick Westmore watched over her as if she were a baby. But perhaps Mr. Amherst, who must have been used to such a different type of woman, doesn't realize. And then he's so little here. The drop was lit up by a smile that seemed to make it more impenetrable. As an old friend I can't help telling you how much I hope she is to have you with her a long time, a long, long time. Miss Brent bent her head in slight acknowledgment of the tribute. Oh, soon she will not need any care. My dear Miss Brent, she will always need it. Mrs. Ansel made a movement inviting the young girl to share the bench from which, at the latter's approach, she had risen. But perhaps there is not enough in such a life to satisfy your professional energies. She seated herself, and after an imperceptible pause, Justine sank into the seat beside her. I am very glad just now to give my energies a holiday, she said, leaning back with a little sigh of retrospective weariness. You are tired, too? Bessie wrote me you had been quite used up by a trying case after we saw you at Hannaford. Miss Brent smiled. When a nurse is fit for work she calls a trying case a beautiful one. But meanwhile Mrs. Ansel shone on her with elderly sister's solicitude. Meanwhile, why not stay on with Sicily? Above all, with Bessie. Surely she's a beautiful case, too. Isn't she, Justine laughingly agreed. And if you want to be tried, Mrs. Ansel swept the scene with a slight lift of her philosophic shoulders. You'll find there are trials enough everywhere. Her companions started up with a glance at the small watch on her breast. One of them is that it's already after four, and that I must see that tea is sent down to the tennis-ground and the new arrivals looked after. I saw the omnibus on its way to the station. Are many more people coming? Five or six, I believe, the house is usually full for Sunday. Mrs. Ansel made a slight motion to detain her. And when is Mr. Amherst expected? Miss Brent's pale cheek seemed to take on a darker tone of ivory, and her glance dropped from her companion's face to the vivid stretch of gardens at their feet. Bessie has not told me, she said. Ah! the older woman rejoined, looking also toward the gardens as if to intercept Miss Brent's glance in its flight. The latter stood still a moment with the appearance of not wishing to evade whatever else her companion might have to say. Then she moved away, entering the house by one window, just as Mr. Langhope emerged from it by another. The sound of his stick tapping across the bricks roused Mrs. Ansel from her musings, but she showed her sense of his presence simply by returning to the bench she had just left, and, accepting this mute invitation, Mr. Langhope crossed the terrace and seated himself at her side. When he had done so they continued to look at each other without speaking, after the manner of old friends possessed of occult means of communication, and as the result of this inward colloquy Mr. Langhope at length said, Well, what do you make of it? What do you, she rejoined, turning full upon him a face so released from its usual defences and disguises that it looked at once older and more simple than the countenance she presented to the world? Mr. Langhope waved a deprecating hand. I want your fresher impressions. That's what I just now said to Miss Brent. You've been talking to Miss Brent? Only a flying word. She had to go and look after the new arrivals. Mr. Langhope's attention deepened. Well, what did you say to her? Wouldn't she rather hear what she said to me? He smiled. A good cross-examiner always gets the answers he wants. Let me hear your side and I shall know hers. I should say that applied only to stupid cross-examiners or those who have stupid subjects to deal with, and Miss Brent is not stupid, you know. Far from it. What else do you make out? I made out that she's in possession. Here? Don't look startled. Do you dislike her? Heaven forbid, with those eyes she has a wit of her own, too, and she certainly makes things easier for Bessie. She guards her carefully at any rate. I could find out nothing. About Bessie? About the general situation? Including Miss Brent? Mrs. Ansel smiled faintly. I made one little discovery about her. Well? She's intimate with the new doctor. Why, Aunt? Mr. Langhope's interest dropped. What of that? I believe she knew him before. I dare say it's of no special importance except as giving us a possible clue to her character. She strikes me as interesting and mysterious. Mr. Langhope smiled. The things your imagination does for you. It helps me to see that we may find Miss Brent useful as a friend. A friend? An ally, she paused as if searching for a word. She may restore the equilibrium. Mr. Langhope's handsome face darkened. Opened Bessie's eyes to Amherst? Damn him, he said quietly. Mrs. Ansel let the imprecation pass. When was he last here, she asked? Five or six weeks ago, for one night, his only visit since she came back from the Adirondacks. What do you think his motive is? He must know what he risks in losing his hold on Bessie. His motive? With your eye for them, can you ask? A devouring ambition, that's all. Haven't you noticed that in all except the biggest minds, ambition takes the form of wanting to command where one has had to obey? Amherst has been made to tow the line at Westmore, and now he wants Truscum. Yes, and Halford gains, too, to do the same. That's the secret of his servant of the people-pose. Gad, I believe it's the whole secret of his marriage. He's devouring my daughter's substance to pay off an old score against the mills. He'll never rest till he has Truscum out, and some creature of his own in command. And then, vogue la galère. If it were women now, Mr. Langhope summed up impatiently. One could understand it at his age and with that damned romantic head. But to be put aside for a lot of low, mongrel-y socialist mill hands. Ah, my poor girl! My poor girl! Mrs. Ansel mused. You didn't write me that things were so bad. There's been no actual quarrels, she asked. How can there be when the poor child does all he wants? He's simply too busy to come and thank her. Too busy at Haniford? So he says, introducing the golden age at Westmore. It's likely to be the age of copper at Lindbrook. Mrs. Ansel drew a meditative breath. I was thinking of that. I understood that Bessie would have to retrench while the changes at Westmore were going on. Well, didn't she give up Europe and cable over to counterman her new motor? But the life here, the smob of people. Miss Brent tells me the house is full for every weekend. Would you have my daughter cut off from all her friends? Mrs. Ansel met this promptly. From some of the new ones at any rate. Have you heard who has just arrived? Mr. Langhope's hesitation showed a tinge of embarrassment. I'm not sure. Someone has always arrived. Well, the Fenton Carburys then. Mrs. Ansel left it to her tone to annotate the announcement. Mr. Langhope raised his eyebrows slightly. Are they likely to be an exceptionally costly pleasure? If you're trying to prove that I haven't kept to the point, I can assure you that I'm well within it. But since the good Blanche has got her divorce and married carbury, wherein do they differ from other weekend automata? Because most divorced women marry again to be respectable. Mr. Langhope smiled faintly. Yes, that's their punishment. But it would be too dull for Blanche. Precisely, she married again to see Ned Beaufort. Ah, that may yet be hers. Mrs. Ansel sighed at his perversity. Meanwhile, she's brought him here and it is unnatural to see Bessie lending herself to such combinations. You're corrupted by a glimpse of the old societies. Here, Beaufort and Carburys are simply hands at bridge. Old hands at it, yes, and the bridge is another point. Bessie never used to play for money. Well, she may make something an offset her husband's prodigalities. There again, with this train de vie, how on earth are both ends to meet? Mr. Langhope, grown suddenly grave, struck his cane resoundingly on the terrace. Westmore and Lindbrook? I don't want them to. I want them to get further and further apart. She cast on him a look of startled divination. You want Bessie to go on spending too much money. How can I help it if it costs? If what costs? She stopped, her eyes still wide, then their glances crossed, and she exclaimed, If your scheme costs, it is your scheme, then. He shrugged his shoulders again. It's a passive attitude. Ah, the deepest plans are that. Mr. Langhope uttered no protest, and she continued to piece her conjectures together. But you expect it to lead up to something active. Do you want a rupture? I want him brought back to his senses. Do you think that will bring him back to her? Where the devil else will he have to go? Mrs. Ansel's eyes dropped toward the gardens, across which desultery knots of people were straggling back from the ended tennis match. Here they all come, she said, rising with a half sigh, and as she stood watching the advance of brightly tinted groups, she added slowly, It's ingenious, but you don't understand him. Mr. Langhope stroked his mustache. Perhaps not, he assented thoughtfully. But suppose we go in before they join us. I want to show you a set of Ming I picked up the other day for Bessie. I flatter myself, I do understand Ming.