 Welcome to Toffy TV, these are my player ratings, Aston Villa 2, Everton Neil, horrendous, horrendous performance by Everton tonight, just utterly shocking all over the park. Jordan Pickford, not much he really could have done about either goal I don't think, made one good save, didn't really have that much to do, that was the mad thing. I'll give him a 7, he was beaten twice so I'll give him a 7. Sheamus Coleman, thought his cross was awful, I didn't think he was defending, that was that much better either, so I'll give him a 6. On the other side, Llew Cyddean again, poor going forward, defence started the game really well, nice link up with Bernard and that's right though, didn't get there right back enough, we'd been booked quite early on. So I'll give him a 6 as well, probably the same as Sheamus Coleman. In the centre of defence, Michael Keane, probably a fall for the goal, some people will say he was and some people will say he was, it was his player who came across him. So that was the big turn on point, he'd been excellent Michael Keane and he was pretty good for the rest of the game as well but for that one mistake I'll give him a 6. Mina, marginally better, marginally better, marginally better I think so I'll give him a 6.5. The pair didn't just got caught up too much, Mina was getting caught up too much with that Wesley. I know he's trying to be a leader and stuff and that is natural personality because I've seen him when he plays for Columbia but I think he let the kid get on the descans far too much, I think he did. I think he worked on both and I don't think they were good enough. Midfield, Gomez, it was horrific, absolutely horrific and you'll know that, you could see it every time the camera went on him. Honestly, I'll have to give him a 3, he was terrible, he was utterly, utterly terrible. The amount of times he kicked the ball out all to them was just, it was up there with, it was probably worse than the Southampton game because he was dragged off in the Southampton game because, but tonight he wasn't. I don't know whether he's still not fit or it's because he's got someone like Snarl next to him and he hasn't got a ghan type of player next to him so he has to do more defensive work and I don't know but he was utterly, utterly terrible tonight, utterly terrible. Snadlin, I'll give a 5 because generally he just did what he normally does which is just get the ball and give the ball. Played one really good ball into the box in the first half which set up Seamus Coleman to set up Dominic Armelun but he hit one of the plays on the line, yes I'll give him a 5. Head of them, Guilfee Sigarton, just doesn't get on the ball enough, just doesn't get involved in the game enough. Always on the edge of the game recently and I'll have to give him a 4, just always choosing the safe option as well. Get it on the edge of the box, always looking to go wide, just have a shot, just have a shot, do something a little bit different. Richard Ellison, worked hard, not much creativity from him. I don't know why the VAR didn't look at the penalty decision in the first half but probably a bit soft but you would have expected the VAR to look at it. Didn't really create anything, didn't really make any, didn't really have any shots or create anything. So I'll give him a 5 on the other side but nah it looked really bright early on for the first 10-15 minutes and then just drifted out of the game and then obviously got subbed. I'll give him a 5 as well because he was just, as I said, early doors looked alright and then just couldn't get back into the game after that, back connection with him and bane just went. Up front on my caravan living, poor on his own, I've said this before that away from home he's just not the same player he is at home and yes I did pick him for the team but I also said it because to get keen up to speed but add that big chance in the first half. He's looked at it and probably just thought it the target, someone with a little bit of class there, a top centre forward just sweeps that into the bottom corner with his space. The kids just trying to get it on target because I think that's just the level of his game. Another day that goes in, I know that but someone with real class puts that into the bottom corner but unfortunately it's not that kind of player. Second half, nothing again, looked a little bit brighter when he got Moise Keane alongside them but four for me, just very very poor. Gapatine him in the rest of the team, massive, I know there's not much he can do about that but he's not making enough intelligent runs either. All he's looking at is long passes and trying to hold them up. He's not making enough intelligent runs off the centre backs for people to slip him in behind. I think that's what we'll see more of from Moise Keane are those runs that get him behind. That's what their centre forward was doing and look at the run for the goal. He sees the passing, just makes that crucial run. I don't know if Dom's got that in his armory but very very poor tonight. The sub's a Wobie, I thought was pretty good when he came when I gave him a 7. Lot more energy, you can see he's a little rougher on the edge just because he's not fit. So I'll give him a 7. Moise Keane, little moments, set up, woke up brilliantly for his chance. Just little moments, you know that you can see the level and once he gets that level then hopefully we'll have a player. So I'll give him a 7 as well and woke up. I'll have to just give him like a 2 because he had one meaningful thing to do and it was a tapping at the back post and he's put it over the bar. You're brought on to do something, you're brought on to make a difference. At least hit the target, you know, he skies it over the bar when the goal's gaping and that's 1-1 and you've got away with a point. Just utterly frustrating and I hate games like that because they just wreck your head because you know that, you know that. If we stepped up just a tiny bit, we would have got something out of that game but with our worst own enemies and I've said loads of times that people can say, oh well, Arsenal are there to be caught, Chelsea are there to be caught, man United will be there to be caught. You've got to catch them, you've got to win games like that to catch them. You've got to get 65 points, be a minimum to get in the top 6. Don't get 65 points by playing like that, a villa, you know, you just don't, it's as simple as that. So for me we need to rip it all up and start again and look for a different way of playing away from home because that's not, that's a year, that's a year, that's a year in two games now that we've played like that away from home and it's got us less than half a dozen wins. So it's not working, it won't work. Change your personnel, change your system and go from there. Anyway, let me know your thoughts in the comments. Yeah, utterly to reject the bar performance. Make sure to check on my instant match reaction and whatever bar sends over from Florida. Thanks for watching, I'll see you later.