 Yeah I was thinking about so like the Bernie Bro thing and how that was kind of done to Corbyn as well. I remember when he first, I think, I mean it's gone down a little bit less now but like when he first came on the scene there was very much a thing of like Corbyn is against women and Corbyn is whatever and I think this is a really distressing development because it demonstrates a kind of and particularly when it comes to like race politics and gender politics it signifies a kind of fragmentation of like race and gender politics from class politics. So it's this idea that like Bernie being for universal healthcare, Bernie being for like single-payer healthcare is not a policy that is an anti-racist policy or is not a feminist policy and in the same way that you know Corbyn being an anti-imperialist. I actually had an argument with Jess Phillips about this on Twitter where she was kind of trying to smear Jeremy Corbyn. It was when Angela Eagle was like being pushed as like his potential opponent and he was trying to she was trying to smear Corbyn as a misogynist and I was like if your definition of woman is outside cis middle class white being anti-war is a feminist policy like being anti-imperialist is a feminist policy and Jess Phillips was like no one cares about war no one cares about this like these aren't she literally was like no one cares about war and no she said that in the interview she did with Owen Jones and it was like it's amazing how she can carry the feminist mantle in like the Labour Party but not think that that's related to being a colonialist like being an imperialist and I guess like what I really wanted to know what your opinion on this was do you think that the fact that an argument like that can be made that like Bill Clinton can be called the first black president of the US because he played the saxophone but he like introduced like carceral politics that was like has been hugely destructive to the black community do you think that's shrewdness of the right or the center or failure of the left