How to reform the U.S. immigration system





The interactive transcript could not be loaded.



Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Published on Aug 25, 2014

Comprehensive immigration reform is crucial to address the recent flood of illegal immigrants across the southern border. AEI Adjunct Scholar Madeline Zavodny explains what needs to be done to fix our broken system.

More on immigration here: http://bit.ly/1pXTvvs

The recent flood of unauthorized immigrant youth across the border has distracted Congress and the American public from the far more important issue of how the United States needs to reform its broken immigration system.

Congress went on recess without passing any laws to reform our immigration system. The House passed a couple of narrow bills aimed at unauthorized immigrant youth, but meanwhile the Gang of Eight’s comprehensive immigration legislation that they passed last year, which would overhaul our system and enhance economic growth, has languished and been forgotten. Here are the three things you need to know to fix our immigration system.

Immigrants make a tremendous contribution to our economy, from PhD scientists and engineers to small business owners, to construction laborers and agricultural workers. At the high end of the labor market, immigrants help drive the innovations and inventions that are crucial to economic growth. On the low end, immigrants—many of them unauthorized—fill physically tough jobs that many Americans are unwilling to do. In short, our economy depends on immigrant workers.

What drives illegal immigration? It’s economic growth. Unauthorized immigrants come here mainly to work. The thing is, most of them would rather come legally, not illegally, but U.S. immigration policy makes it virtually impossible for low-skilled workers to come here legally. We have two temporary worker programs for low-skilled workers that are a disaster—they’re expensive, they’re cumbersome, and so employers are reluctant to use them. Meanwhile, we also make it too hard for high-skilled workers to come here or to stay here after finishing their studies. The backlog for green cards can be years or even decades for these workers.

We need comprehensive immigration reform that reshapes the entire immigration system to make it more flexible, more market-driven. Our country needs a better way to deal with unauthorized illegal immigration than just deportations and stricter enforcement like the Republicans are suggesting or temporary reprieves from deportation like President Obama has done. Instead we need a comprehensive immigration reform that’s going to include employment verification, more border security, but most importantly, a way for people who want to work here and contribute to our economy to come legally.


  1. 1

    The three keys to school choice success

  2. 2

    Why Shinzo Abe's visit can take the US and Asia to the next level

  3. 3

    Moore's Law and the future of technology

  4. 4

    Iran's growing cybersecurity threat

  5. 5

    How Yemen could become another Syria

  6. 6

    What's behind Iran's identity crisis?

  7. 7

    The strategy behind Putin's aggression in Ukraine

  8. 8

    Top three facts about US energy production and geopolitical power

  9. 9

    The strategy behind ISIS' brutality

  10. 10

    Why everything you know about the financial crisis is wrong

  11. 11

    How the Greek elections will impact the world economy

  12. 12

    Top three takeaways from the Hagel resignation

  13. 13

    How the US gets the Middle East's Shi'ites wrong

  14. 14

    Why the West has it wrong on Iran's Rouhani

  15. 15

    Why a good nuclear deal is so hard for Iran

  16. 16

    Why the US needs a better strategy in Asia

  17. 17

    A doctor explains why Ebola 2014 is a credible threat

  18. 18

    How Brazil's election will impact the world economy

  19. 19

    Why Iran is at the core of the ISIS problem

  20. 20

    ISIS and the role of Special Operations Forces in America's wars

  21. 21

    The Wealth Building Home Loan

  22. 22

    India Prime Minister Narendra Modi's first 100 days: A report card

  23. 23

    NATO Summit 2014: How to revitalize the alliance

  24. How to reform the U.S. immigration system

  25. 25

    Hillary Clinton's biggest weaknesses for 2016

  26. 26

    ISIS in Iraq: What's the strategy behind the airstrikes?

  27. 27

    Gaza and Ukraine: How today's conflicts can be traced to World War I

  28. 28

    ISIS, Iran, and the US: Our enemy's enemy isn't our friend

  29. 29

    The Malaysian airliner and Vladimir Putin

  30. 30

    Gaza, Ukraine, Syria, and Iraq: The common thread

  31. 31

    Illegal immigration: What's causing the recent surge?

  32. 32

    Israel, Palestinians, and the greater Middle Eastern war

  33. 33

    How Washington holds working women back

  34. 34

    Iran nuclear talks: Will there be a deal?

  35. 35

    Putin's Ukraine strategy: Here's what he'll do next

  36. 36

    D-Day: The lasting legacy

  37. 37

    Tiananmen Square: 25 years later

  38. 38

    Hillary Clinton: What do Americans really think of her?

  39. 39

    Here's how you can help veterans when they come home

  40. 40

    Brown v. Board's legacy: A former teacher's perspective

  41. 41

    Brown v. Board of Ed: Have we lived up to its promise?

  42. 42

    Student loan debt: How much is too much?

  43. 43

    India's elections: Choosing the leader of the world's largest democracy

  44. 44

    Will Russia invade east Ukraine?

  45. 45

    Afghan elections: Will democracy survive after Karzai?

  46. 46

    Should Americans buy e-cigarettes?

  47. 47

    How to fix the Indian economy

  48. 48

    Corporate taxes: Who really pays?

  49. 49

    Afghanistan: Was the war worth it?

  50. 50

    Obamacare: Far from the finish line

  51. 51

    Soaring college costs: The three alternatives

  52. 52

    Taking Ukraine: The dangerous future of Putin's regime

  53. 53

    Rape culture hysteria on campus

  54. 54

    Social mobility in America: Still the land of opportunity?

  55. 55

    Banks vs. Feds: Will the economy survive more regulation?

  56. 56

    The keys to solving poverty in America

  57. 57

    Crimea and Ukraine: How far will Putin go?

  58. 58

    Obamacare: Lie of the Year 2014?

  59. 59

    Pothole repair is overdue. Here's how to pay for it.

  60. 60

    El Salvador's crucial 2014 presidential election

  61. 61

    Venezuela fights for democracy: Will America help?

  62. 62

    Ukraine's revolution: Towards Russia or the West?

  63. 63

    American broadband Internet: Do you really pay more?

  64. 64

    How Obamacare kills jobs

  65. 65

    Iran's nuclear agreement with the United States

  66. 66

    The gender wage gap is a myth

  67. 67

    Al-Qaeda: The new definition

  68. 68

    School choice: a multiple choice test for families

  69. 69

    The 2014 Sochi Olympics may be the most dangerous in history

  70. 70

    Chinese foreign investment: Will China own America?

  71. 71

    Is masculine culture toxic for boys?

  72. 72

    Iran's nuclear program and the future of the Middle East

  73. 73

    The long-term unemployed: Is society failing them?

  74. 74

    Introducing AEI's International Center on Housing Risk

  75. 75

    Charitable giving in the wake of the Great Recession

  76. 76

    The American Internationalism Project

  77. 77

    What schools can do to help boys succeed

  78. 78

    Debt limit showdown

  79. 79

    Obamacare: Republicans' right to fight

  80. 80

    Government shutdown: Who is to blame?

  81. 81

    Government shutdown: What to expect

  82. 82

    An alternative to Obamacare

  83. 83

    Farm Bill 2014: House and Senate considerations

  84. 84

    Health care reform: A reality check for conservatives

  85. 85

    Federal Reserve chairman challenges

  86. 86

    Putin and Obama's Syrian chess match

  87. 87

    Al-Qaeda's new network

  88. 88

    Teacher Quality 2.0

  89. 89

    Syria and the clear red line

  90. 90

    Obama's second term blues

  91. 91

    Who will be the next Fed Chair?

  92. 92

    Protests in Egypt: The Military or the Muslim Brotherhood?

  93. 93

    How to talk about Islam in India

  94. 94

    School has become too hostile to boys

  95. 95

    U.S. embassy closures

  96. 96

    Sequestration's real world consequences

  97. 97

    Al-Qaeda's critical threat

  98. 98

    Health care reform: Why not the best of both worlds?

  99. 99

    Dodd-Frank three years later

  100. 100

    Common Core Standards

  101. 101

    Education reform, conservative style

  102. 102

    Behind the unemployment rate

  103. 103

    Egypt's Coup

  104. 104

    Why Gettysburg still matters

Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to