How Patent Trolls Kill Innovation





The interactive transcript could not be loaded.



Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Published on Feb 20, 2013

"My statement to someone that is the victim of a patent troll lawsuit is that you are completely screwed," says Austin Meyer, who is himself the target of a so-called "patent troll" lawsuit.

Meyer is a software developer and aviation enthusiast. His two passions intersected in the '90s when he created a flight simulator called X-Plane, which quickly grew in popularity, outlasting even the once-popular Microsoft Flight Simulator. As many software developers do, Meyer made his application available on mobile devices like the iPhone and Android. And this is where he first ran into trouble.

A company called Uniloc has sued Meyer for patent infringement over a patent called, "System and Method for Preventing Unauthorized Access to Electronic Data." When a computer runs a paid application, one way that developers can assure that a customer has actually purchased the application is by coding the application to match a license code with an encrypted database. This is a method that most paid applications on the Android market use. It's a method that Meyer argues has been in use since at least the late '80s. This is the idea that Uniloc claims to own.

"A patent troll is a company, a person... who owns patents, but doesn't make anything or sell anything," says Julie Samuels, an attorney and the Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents at the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

Samuels says that patent trolls are a huge tax on innovation and add nothing valuable to the marketplace. A study out of Boston University estimates the direct economic damage that patent trolls cause to be around $29 billion a year, and this doesn't account for hush-hush, off-the-record settlements. But the bigger problem, says Samuels, is the patent system itself.

"You can't separate the problem with the patent troll from the problem with software patents," says Samuels. "There are hundreds of thousands of software patents floating around that are really broad, that are really vague ... and a lot of them are bought up by patent trolls."

A Yale study found that the U.S. patent office is approving new software patents at an approximate rate of 40,000 a year. That's more than 100 new software patents every day. Tracking every software patent to make sure one is not in violation would be an utter impossibility without a full-time team of lawyers on staff.

Uniloc, which purchased the patent in question at a bankruptcy proceeding, declined an interview request for this piece. But on their website, they brag about a victory over software giant Microsoft resulting in $388 million in damages (though this amount was later lowered in an appeals court). Despite the enormous risk, and the enormous cost just to defend against a patent suit, Meyer is resolved to do so.

"I will not simply give somebody money that endorses the idea that they should sue people for doing something amazing," says Meyer. "It must be stopped at some point."

About 6 minutes.

Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Shot by Amanda Winkler, Tracy Oppenheimer, and Weissmueller. Music by Case Newsom, Broke for Free, and Pionir.

Visit Reason TV for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live.


Uploads from ReasonTV

  1. 625

    "I Can't Take the Loss of Liberty" or, How to Radicalize a Suburban Mom

  2. 626

    Thank God for Pope Francis - and Budget Gridlock!

  3. 627

    Matt Ridley on How Fossil Fuels are Greening the Planet

  4. 628

    How To Save America's Zoos: Privatize Them

  5. 629

    Is Homeschooling a Universal Human Right?

  6. 630

    How to Build Infrastructure During an Age of Sequester: Reason Foundation's Robert W. Poole

  7. 631

    Judge Alex Kozinski: From Communist Romania to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals

  8. 632

    #StandWithRand: Rand Paul, Barack Obama, Drones, and Presidential Kill Lists

  9. 633

    Implementing Pot Legalization in Colorado and Washington

  10. 634

    Amateur Beats Gov't at Digitizing Newspapers: Tom Tryniski's Weird, Wonderful Website

  11. 635

    Hollywood meets Wall Street: Author William Stadiem talks Moneywood

  12. 636

    Why Obama's Crackdown on Medicare and Medicaid Fraud Will Fail

  13. 637

    Ron Paul Banned from DC! Roommates Banned in NY! (Nanny of the Month, Feb '13)

  14. 638

    Justin Amash: Any Sequester Alternative Must Cut at Least as Much

  15. 639

    5 Sequester Facts to Know Before Committing Suicide

  16. 640

    It's Hard to Gross Out a Libertarian: Jonathan Haidt on Sex, Politics, and Disgust

  17. 641

    Crony Capitalists vs. Value Makers: Q&A w Max Borders

  18. 642

    Loving Hayek and Partying with Milk: Q&A with Dorian Electra

  19. 643

    Cutting Back City Hall: Reason Foundation's Adrian Moore and Julian Morris

  20. 644

    Former Gov. Ben Cayetano on Hawaii's Fiscal Mess and Stupid Rail Plan

  21. 645

    Should You Go to Jail for Unlocking Your Phone?

  22. How Patent Trolls Kill Innovation

  23. 647

    Can California Survive?: Reason's Carl DeMaio and Adrian Moore

  24. 648

    Weed Country: Pot Grower Mike Boutin on Discovery Channel's Newest Reality Show

  25. 649

    3 Reasons to Build the Keystone XL Pipeline

  26. 650

    Wendy McElroy on The Art of Being Free

  27. 651

    Would Hayek Have Approved Obamacare?

  28. 652

    The Problem with E-Verify - The ACLU's Chris Calabrese on Immigration Reform

  29. 653

    Why America Should Default and You Should Live Abroad: Q&A with Doug Casey

  30. 654

    Marc Randazza on Steubenville Rape, Defamation, and the Limits to Free Speech

  31. 655

    School Choice with Reason's Lisa Snell

  32. 656

    LAPD Had "No Idea" Who They Were Shooting At In Dorner Pursuit, Says Victims' Attorney

  33. 657

    Drugs, Guns, and the Fiscal Cliff: Emily Ekins on New Reason-Rupe Poll

  34. 658

    LA's New Crack Epidemic: Sidewalks

  35. 659

    Sex and Punishment: Eric Berkowitz Talks 4,000 Years of Judging Desire

  36. 660

    Three Flushes for American Capitalism!

  37. 661

    The Plight of the Alpha Female: Kay Hymowitz

  38. 662

    National School Choice Week Lights Up Chicago

  39. 663

    Gov. Scott Walker Welcomes National School Choice Week to Wisconsin

  40. 664

    Prison for Smokers, Permits for Strippers! (Nanny of the Month, Jan '13)

  41. 665

    Ai Weiwei's First Major U.S. Show Has Everything but the Dissident Artist Himself

  42. 666

    Can Medical Tourism Save Us From Obamacare?

  43. 667

    Jonas Brothers Headline National School Choice Week 2013

  44. 668

    Lewis Lapham on Legalizing Drugs, Hating the Facebook, and Curating the Past at Lapham's Quarterly

  45. 669

    National School Choice Week 2013 Kicks Off in Los Angeles

  46. 670

    Two Cheers for the Coming Collapse of the U.S. Economy!

  47. 671

    Sex, Violence & Satan: 6 Unbelievably Dumb Congressional Hearings

  48. 672

    Andrew Campanella on National School Choice Week 2013

  49. 673

    "FEMA Won't Let Us Rebuild Our Home"

  50. 674

    Fitness Crackdown: Santa Monica Gets Tough On Trainers

  51. 675

    "Blowhards Chronicling Blowhards" - Mediaite's Andrew Kirell and Noah Rothman

  52. 676

    Obama Inaugural Rewind: Rhetoric vs Reality

  53. 677

    Nassim Taleb Talks Antifragile, Libertarianism, and Capitalism's Genius for Failure

  54. 678

    3D Printing and the Future of Shopping: Shapeways CEO Peter Weijmarshausen

  55. 679

    Feds Hounded 'Net Activist Aaron Swartz, Says EFF's Parker Higgins

  56. 680

    The War on Fast Food: Can a D.C. Suburb Fight Fat with Zoning?

  57. 681

    Gay Marriage, Drunk Driving, and Property Rights: 3 Supreme Court Cases to Watch in 2013

  58. 682

    Q&A: Eyal Press on Beautiful Souls, Nonconformists Who Stand Up to Power

  59. 683

    Information Liberated: Jeffrey Tucker on How Digital Media Subverts Government Power

  60. 684

    The Problem with Hurricane Sandy Aid

  61. 685

    5 Facts About Guns, Schools, & Violence

  62. 686

    Joe Kennedy: Not a Bootlegger or a Nazi, But a Hardcore Non-Interventionist

  63. 687

    Awesome at 85: Block Island's Mary Donnelly and the Power of Private Charity

  64. 688

    Feds Sentence Aaron Sandusky to 10 Years for Medical Marijuana

  65. 689

    Lanny Ebenstein: The Indispensable Milton Friedman

  66. 690

    Ying Ma on Life Under Mao and China's Economic Miracle

  67. 691

    38 Studios: Curt Schilling's Crony Capitalism Debacle

  68. 692

    Sex, Lies, Jazz: Feb. Reason Preview w Matt Welch and Kennedy

  69. 693

    Craig Whitney on Living With Guns: A Liberal's Case for the Second Amendment

  70. 694

    I, Tomato: Morning Star's Radical Approach to Management

  71. 695

    Busting Bikinis and the Cop Who Wants to Fine Cursing! (Nanny of the Year 2012)

  72. 696

    Check out Reason's New LA Headquarters!

  73. 697

    Remy: I Saw Daddy Pat Down Santa Claus (A Very TSA Christmas Song)

  74. 698

    The Fall Of Tam's #6: How LA Regulated A Burger Stand Out of Existence

  75. 699

    Grover Norquist on Fiscal Cliff, Tax Pledges, & Being the GOP's "Rasputin"

  76. 700

    How Indianapolis Fixed Its Parking Problems

  77. 701

    The Best and Worst Christmas Films (Libertarian Edition)

  78. 702

    A Great Year For Pot, Freedom, and Ending the Drug War: Q&A with MPP's Rob Kampia

  79. 703

    Marijuana Is Legal in Colorado...Now What?

  80. 704

    Why Copyright Law is so Mickey Mouse - And How to Fix It: Q&A with Jerry Brito

  81. 705

    Judge Napolitano: How Teddy Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson Destroyed Constitutional Freedom

  82. 706

    Can an Undocumented Immigrant Become a U.S. Lawyer? California High Court Will Decide

  83. 707

    How Dewey Bartlett Balanced Tulsa's Budget without Raising Taxes

  84. 708

    James Payne on Six Political Illusions

  85. 709

    Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard: Making City Government Work

  86. 710

    Guns, Football, Macho Culture Didn't Kill Jovan Belcher's Girlfriend. Jovan Belcher Did.

  87. 711

    Censorship and "Unlearning Liberty" at College: Q&A with FIRE's Greg Lukianoff

  88. 712

    Reason Webathon 2012 w Nick Gillespie, Matt Welch, Kennedy, and more!

  89. 713

    Meet Congress' Favorite Bootlegger: Prohibition, Hypocrisy, and "The Man in the Green Hat"

  90. 714

    Reason Mag Preview w Matt Welch & Kennedy: APOCALYPSE 2013!

  91. 715

    "I escaped a North Korean prison camp" - Shin Dong-hyuk's Survivor Story

  92. 716

    LP Candidate Bruce Majors vs. D.C.'s One-Party System

  93. 717

    Texas Schools Track Students with RFID Chips! (Nanny of the Month, Nov '12)

  94. 718

    1000 Wrongfully Convicted and Counting: New Registry Checks Justice System's Power

  95. 719

    "The idea that you could openly sell things that help women achieve orgasm is pretty new."

  96. 720

    David Friedman on How to Privatize Everything

  97. 721

    The Future of Financing the Arts: An Interview with Adam Huttler of Fractured Atlas

  98. 722

    Greg Gutfeld: The Joy of Hate, Liberal Speech Police, & Conservative Punks

  99. 723

    3 Reasons to Kill The Dept. of Homeland Security: It's Unnecessary, Inefficient, & Expensive.

Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to