 In this game, I will be asking a popular YouTuber the price of 10 Yu-Gi-Oh cards. Their goal will be to guess the price of each card as closely as possible. For each dollar away they are from the correct answer they receive a point. As points add up, the lower the price. Today we see if your favorite YouTuber can win the $1,000 grand prize. Moist Critical is one of the largest creators on both YouTube and Twitch with over 16 million total followers. He loves all things gaming, playing nearly every game you can think of, gifting thousands of dollars for specific gaming achievements, and even starting his own Esports org. He also keeps up with all things drama, following all sorts of scams or scandals in any community. Today we find out if he knows his Yu-Gi-Oh prices. Welcome back to Guess That Price Episode 15. Today's guest is Moist Critical. How you doing today, Charlie? Hey, good. Just happy to be here and ready to flex my knowledge on the old card prices here since I've got so many. I think I'm going to absolutely crush this one. I mean, you have every card like ever made, so it's, I mean, you should know these, right? I mean, just theoretically, yeah. I'll know them. I'll know them. I'm not worried about that. Okay. Yeah. You're definitely going to know them. Perfect. Okay. Let's just go straight into question one. I'm expecting top notch performance from you. Yeah. All right. Question one. We have Eldlitch the Golden Lord Secret Rare First Edition from Secret Slayers. That's an interesting one. So this is definitely going to be probably a tier one card. This is a meta card. Secret Slayers kind of a stinker of a set. I'm going to just go with my gut. I'm going to think this is right around that like 40 to $45 ballpark. I'm not even going to use a lifeline. I'm just going to send it. That's my final answer. Lock that. Get it. Okay. Okay. You said 40 to 45. So what's your actual lock in answer? Oh, right, right. I need an exact one. Let's just go right in the middle. Let's just do 45. 45. Okay. All right. Charlie. Okay. Charlie. Look, you said you knew all the answers. Okay. If I was getting, you know, I miscarried some decimal places there. I would have gone 46. You know, it's just one of those things. We're just right. You rounded, right? You rounded to the nearest like five. So yeah, otherwise you would have nailed it completely. But okay, you're off to a scorching start. I mean, that's not bad. I didn't mention to you earlier, but because you were in the right tier, you get like a $10 credit added on. So you're basically plus nine right now. So you're looking really good. Question two. I mean, I'm getting a little worried already. I mean, your first question, you've already nailed it. We have elemental hero flame wingman ultimate rare first edition from the lost millennium. Oh, this is an interesting one. This is a very cool set. This was the same set that also had the, um, was a guy, I think it was Gaia. The ultimate rares in this set were pretty cool. So this is absolutely a tier two. This is first ed, right? Yeah. That's definitely tier two. Your wallets got to be sweating right now because I think I'm going to strike with an again, one or two dollars because I'm pretty sure flair wingman was like a one oh five ish. So let's just lock in like a hundred and five on flair wingman. Hundred and five. Okay. Hundred and five. Let's see if my wallets going to be sweating after that one. Elements of hero flame wingman ultimate rare. This card is $200. Well, you see what happened. I didn't account for inflation. Right. Yeah. Yeah. When I purchased this thing back in the olden days, it was far cheaper you know, you you could get a pack of gum for a penny, but you know, not today, you saw it. This is what rhymes I was doing. He's like three years ago. I was exactly right. That's how I'm feeling right now. He's like, look, if I just traveled back in time, I would have nailed this quiz. But hey, you're still in the right range. So you do get that credit back. Your stuff still still not a terrible guess or within like 85 after the credit. Pretty solid. Let's go to question three. See if you can keep it up. Not bad. Not bad. I'll take it. All right. I'll take a great guess and an OK guess so far. Let's see if you can keep it up. We have Didi assailants secret rare from Dark Revelation 4. This is a very interesting card. Dark Revelations was a pretty stupid set that I'm not too big of a fan of, but I did decide to get this card. It's hard to find. I got it like two years ago. This is a tier three card for sure. I think when I got it, it was just over 400. So let's let's do some rough calculations in the old noodle here. I'm going to assume it's gone up because it's only getting harder to find. So let's just add like, you know, let's add like 50, 60 bucks. Let's go with like $460. You could say. Yeah, you could say it's probably gone up, but then you do have to account for the fact that, you know, Yu-Gi-Oh! in general is like it's gone down a little bit recently. Oh, that's true. It's not as hot. I'm still going to lock in though, because I feel confident. Let's just do 460. 460. OK. All right. Didi assailants secret rare. Just over $400. Yeah. This was a couple of years ago. Well, it seems like the price hasn't changed that much. This is a $400 card. I thought you were going to go right on the head for a second. I was like, oh my gosh, she's insane. That's so unlucky. The price hasn't changed. I should have just trusted my God. I made a mistake asking you on because you've literally bought every card. So you, you literally, you know, you know how much they were. I know. Oh, I know. I still feel. Oh my gosh. Most people would be like, what is even dark revelation for? Like, what is that? What is that said? You were like, oh, yeah, I know this. Yeah. That was a weird set. They had like a, it was mainly but just a bunch of reprints, but then they had some weird, weird rarity ones that they threw in like the assailant and they had the orbital laser one that I forgot the name of. Yeah. They have some really like satellite cannons and stuff like that. That's the one satellite. Yeah. They have some strains like almost every hollow in here is like ridiculously expensive. Like there, I think I pulled like a BES tetran in the lowest listed was like $105 for a super rare and I was like, just get not be right. It's such a weird set. Okay. All right. It's still a pretty good guess for tier three because those are usually where it goes awry. So 60 bucks off. Not bad at all. Question four. You haven't even thought about a lifeline yet. So keep in mind. You do have those. I mean, you've got those. Let's go to question four. This one is Lumina the light sworn summoner super rare from champion pack eight. So now you found something in my Achilles heel. So I didn't bother with super rare. So I'm very familiar with champions. This one's going to be a little tough for me. So there's an ultra rare in every champion pack. Those were the ones that I'd grab. Those weren't tier three. Yeah. Ironically, the, uh, the super rare some champion pack are actually usually the valuable cards. I mean, in general, not telling you the answer for this one, but you do have your lifelines. If this is not in your wheelhouse. So there's probably not a lot of super is left on the quiz theoretically. So I think I will use a lifeline on this one. Let's use lower or higher. I'm going to throw something out and you just tell me where I'm at. Okay. Cold. I'm going to assume that this is going to be around the ultra or maybe a little bit more or less. So let's just go with, I think in this one, I think it was like a little over like 150 at the time. So let's just say 150 lower or higher. First lifeline being used. First time we've, we finally found a weakness in your armor. I chink. As you could say, this card is more than $150. Okay. And then I still just, I'm not convinced it breaks tier three. If I can give you, I can give you some info on, on Lightsworn. So Lightsworn is pretty popular. I'm sure you know that, but it is also playable in Edison format, which is pretty popular right now. And this is the highest rarity of the card. This is the highest rarity Lumina. I mean, if you're going by like highest rarity, not as in literally like Starlight ultra rare, but this is like the high rarity card people use to bling out their deck. My guts telling me it just doesn't break tier three. So I'd be a fool to go against it. I'm going to go a little under tier three. So let's do like a 225 for that card. Okay. I like it. I mean, you should never go against your gut. That is true. I agree with that. However, your gut may have steered you slightly wrong. Not too bad. It's a $294 card. Unlucky. Unlucky. I believe this is actually the most expensive card in champion pack eight. A lot of the champion packs, the super rears are like crazy. And then the ultras kind of suck a lot of the time. I don't know why they did that, but for some reason they did. But still, you're really not too far off. You're in the ballpark. You didn't hit the tier this time, but you're less than like 70, whatever away. So pretty solid. Yeah. That was definitely a curve ball. Nice one on that. Question five. Maxi secret rare first edition from Storm of Ragnarok. How do you feel about the Maxi? It's great in master duel. And in fact, I think it's 100% necessary in master duel or that'd be just like an unplayable format. Oh, a hot take. Okay. You're going to probably be mad about this. I have not played in about three months, not like a little ladder. So maybe things. I haven't either. So I joined the club. Because they have so many like high rarities of Maxi. They have the ultimate rare as well. Yeah. I think this is the second highest. The ultimate rare is definitely considered the top rarity. I'll just, I'll just feel it out here with what my, my gut's telling me. I think this one's going to be in the tier three zone because this is the secret rare storm of Ragnarok. This is from the actual set. I'm just going to go with like a nice clean 300 on the Maxi secret rare, but something's telling me I'm going to regret that. But if something's telling you that, it's not too late to use the lifeline and double check. You could check the tier. You could swap it. Who knows? Let's, let's do, let's do the tier. What tier is this? Okay. So, so you went for it and you're like, let's, let's try the tier. Let's double check. Great decision, Charlie, because this is a tier two card. Okay. All right. Good. That's huge. Tier two, that tells me a lot here. 200 if I'm being honest, I think it's going to be less. Okay. So, so you said that tells you something. What did it tell you that it's not, I mean, obviously it told you it's not, you know, tier one or three, but what did it tell you? Tells me that this card still got quite a lot out there. So it's not going to be like a super hard to find card, which means the price isn't going to be crazy. Okay. So I'm going to guess that it's, I'm just, I think I'm going to stick with like a 200 here. Even though that even seems a little high to me, it just feels a bit safer to go with that. I'm just waiting for you to talk yourself into another number. I know this has been all over the place. You know what? No, no more second guessing. Just do 200. 200. Okay. All right. So we have cut off 100 since you used the lifeline. I will say that 100 was definitely in the right direction. This card is $123. Yeah. That's yeah. Yeah. You're still within a hundred though. You have yet to go over a hundred. You almost did, but then you use your lifeline. So not bad. You're halfway point. You're doing pretty solid. Question six, Morincess Seahorse Starlight Rare First Edition Rising Rampage. I chased this card. I don't, I don't know if these have really like shot up. Is this one of the ones when you opened like a hundred boxes back then? Oh yeah. Absolutely. This also had the, um, the trap card secret rare that I'm blanking on the name of the Storm Dragon. Yeah. Rising Ra... No, it wasn't that's the name of the set. What is it? Storm Dragon's Return. Yeah. You're right. Yeah. That's the one. The whole Abalosa? No. I had to buy it. It's like $2,000 though. I have it. I had to buy it though. It was cheaper then. Yeah. Morincess Seahorse I don't think was a very big one at the time. I know Storm Dragon's Return was the cheapest when I pulled it and I think Morincess Seahorse was right above it. And I think something's telling me it was like right around 400 because, hmm. Yeah. I think that's probably right. I doubt that it's gone up unless Morincess is seeing play for some reason and like a new deck. Let's trust me. I'm going to go 400 on the Morincess Seahorse. Let's get a wacky number in there so I can see if I can hit it on the nose. I'm going to go with $414. $414 from the Morincess Seahorse. All right. This card is $280. How is it going down? So the Storm Dragon's Returns all the way down to like $50 or $60 or something. Yeah. Actually it might be like $100 now. This one I think also went down but then the Apollosa went the other way and went way up. So I guess because this isn't really being used and it's not very good I guess and it's not I guess collectible for the most part unless you're collecting all the star lights is like you're not really collecting Morincess I guess. I guess that's my guess. I don't really know. That blows my mind because this is the first set that had star lights. Right. Yeah. It's it's it's literally one of the first star lights. It's one of four. Wow. So this one being dropped. No big deal. We're cutting it out. Yeah. Jesus. Nothing to worry about. Hey that's your third tier three. So you may or may not even have another one at this point. So you unless it's the bonus one you don't have another tier three. Okay. Question seven rebound question coming up cyber jar ultimate rare first edition from Duelist pack Kaiba. Oh this one's not very expensive. Duelist pack Kaiba is a cool set but it's not like super expensive cards in there. It had like the ring of destruction it had I think it had the pot of greed. Yeah. Pot of greed and it had two more right because it was five. Yeah chaos emperor and crush card I believe is the fifth. This one I don't remember being one of the top of that and even still it would have been under a hundred dollars. I'm pretty sure cyber jar was a tier one card. So let's let's go off faith I'm going to go with ninety two dollars for cyber jar. Get a little wacky with the numbers now get the random stuff trying to nail it on the head. I like it. I like the strategy. Okay. Question seven. Was this your rebound question. It was this card is eighty dollars a little high. Okay. I shot a little too high. That's still good. I mean that's a great guess. So you're up to two tier ones two tier twos three tier threes that's going to really start mattering towards the end because you'll be able to like know for sure one of the last two is whatever the actual one is. So question eight nice come back. Let's get on to that one and see if you can nail this one. We have the volcanic doomfire ultimate rare first edition from force of the breaker. Okay. This is kind of like a nothing burger card to me. I I don't know a whole lot about it. I have it in force of the breakers kind of a bad set force of the breakers the one that I think also had the crystal beast ultimate ways. Yep. Yeah. Not many people really care about this card. I know had to be towards the bottom. I don't think volcanic doomfire was a big one in that set. I think the crystal beast. What's the big crystal beast the pegasus one. I think yeah sapphire pegasus that was only like a $70 card. So this guy's got to be much less. I'm going to go with like $24 for volcanic doomfire. So ultimate rare first edition from a 2007 set you want to go $24. It was very in less things of skyrocketed force of the breaker was really cheap when I got it a couple of years ago. I'm just double checking you want to lock in 24 bucks. You know what I'm going to add $10 since you since you gave me the attitude. You're going to give me the rucks and 34. That's what you're going to do. We're going $34 on volcanic doomfire. I'm pretty sure it's still going to be cheap. Okay. All right. You asked for it the volcanic doomfire ultimate rare first edition. This card is $183. What happened to the set. What I mean it's the cover card. It's got to be worth something. It's it's an awful card. It's actually really hard to find. I've always wanted one of these. Don't ask me why I wanted it. I think it just looks cool. But getting the first edition ultimate rare like actually near mint is like really hard to find for this card that blows my mind 24 bucks. This card sucks. I think the crystal beasts have gone up a lot too because of the battles of legend crystal revenge as well. So that I could have just influenced the whole set. But this being so old at this point it's probably like the worst GX set but it's still like it's old. So people are going to buy it. But yeah. Wow. Hey you went $10 up. That works. Okay. We'll take it. Last two questions. Let's just pretend like that one didn't happen. No big deal. You still haven't missed one that bad. We've had a lot worse. We've got two questions left. So far review. You've had three tier two three tier three. That means the last two one of them is guaranteed be tier one. Keep that in mind. The other one's completely random. I'm going to ask you both of these at the same time. Okay. I'm ready. Elemental hero bubble man ultimate rare first edition from cybernetic revolution and number 10 graceful charity secret rare first edition from legendary collection three. Yugi's world. Cool. So this one's easy. The graceful charities tier one bubble man's tier three bubble man is really hard to find in good condition. So bubble man is absolutely the tier three in this one. Keep in mind. You do have your swap question. If you do want to do that. No. I think I know bubble man cybernetic revolutions and older set that was really hard to find. This one also had like the cyber and dragon and all that bubble man was like somewhere in the 300 range graceful charity. I remember being like in the $20 range. So let's I'm coming rapid fire here graceful charity. I'm going to lock in a $26 price tag on that puppy. Okay. And then for bubble man. I'm just going to. I don't think it was more than 300. I really don't. But maybe it was because bubble man's also pretty rare in another set as well. It's one of the old GX collector sets that I can't remember the name of. But it also like the secret rare one is that the one you're talking about. It's a rare one. Yeah. It's like a promo but it's really hard to find that product. Yeah. I think bubble man just in general is a pretty tough one in this set. I know he was a big boy. Let's go a little higher than 300. I'm going to. Yeah. I'm going to do it. You going with or against your gut right here. That's the question. I'm going kind of against it because I feel like changing strategies. Yeah. But I feel like you know maybe it's more now a couple years later. So let's let's account for that. Let's go with like a four hundred forty eight dollars on bubble man. Okay. So you were saying okay this thing's probably out of a 300. Then you decide to go against your gut and go an extra hundred and fifty dollars. Yeah. Because if volcanic doom fire is somehow already that much. It's really. That's that's shaking my well. Okay. Here's the difference between those two cards. Volcanic doom fires the cover card and it's an ultra in the set. And then bubble man is just a rare in the set. So it is a pretty big difference between those two. I just remember bubble man. He's one of the top five in that set because I remember that one was kind of hard for me to actually get when I was looking for it. And that was a couple years ago. So I imagine it's even more difficult now. Maybe it's not though. Maybe you're trying to tell me something. I could be could not. Who knows. Maybe you're trying to transmit a little information through the ether. Let's let's bring it down. Let's go with like three seventy three on bubble man three seventy three. All right. You're ready to confirm those answers. Yeah. I'm confirming and run it. So you didn't use your swap. That's okay. You didn't need it. At least you think you didn't need it. Question number nine. We have the bubble man ultimate rare first edition. I'm going to save that one for last because that was the one you think it's a bigger number. Grateful charity secret rare first edition from legendary collection three. Yugi's world. You said twenty six bucks. Yeah. It's got thirty nine dollars. So very close. You're very close. You're in the ballpark. You are in the correct tier. Now we go to the bubble man. The one where you're all over the map on this one. You know it's rare. You know it's hard to find this card is you said three hundred seventy three dollars. This actual price is two hundred twenty eight dollars. How is this possible? What is happening? Where are they finding these extra inventory of like near mint bubble man ultimate? I think they traded them for the volcanic doom fires. I think that's what happened. They're always the same price. How is this happening? They put in the world. Okay. But honestly not too bad. Now we got to figure out how well you did. We got to do a little math here. We're going to come back and see how you did compared to everyone else. All right. That sounds good. Are you ready for the reveal of how you did Charlie? Yeah. I'm ready. I'm a little disappointed in my performance. I thought I'd do better. Look, I thought you did really well, especially considering you bought all these cards like two years ago. So it's like really hard to keep up when you've haven't checked them in like two years for the most part. I was really worried in that first question though when you were like one one dollar away. Okay. Let's just see how you did. So overall your total value of your 10 cards was $1,873. Okay. You were off by a total of $606. But you got seven tiers correct. So we get to take that out. You were off by a total of $536 when you considered that. That puts you at 28.62% off. You win $50 for the viewers claps. Okay. Okay. And you're also. Look, you beat Rhyme Style and you beat Farfa. So not a bad performance. We'll take it. That's not bad at all for it. I mean, look, two years ago, it's been a long time. Solid performance. Also, you had kind of a lower number. Sometimes they go up into like the 2200s in terms of your total value. So it makes it a little bit less margin for errors. So still not a bad performance. Thank you so much for being here. You got anything else you want to say before you hop out? No, thank you for having me on. This was a lot of fun. I'll come back at some point in the future and be a little more accurate. I'll study a bit more. You'll get in the books, you know. Start dusting off those old TCG player prices. Not bad. If you guys want to enter the giveaway for the money that Charlie just won, you guys, make sure to like the video, be subscribed, and let Charlie know below that he did it awesome. Or maybe you don't want to say he did awesome. I don't know. It's up to you guys. You guys get to decide. Thank you guys for watching and I will see you guys in the next one. Oh, and don't forget to like, share, and subscribe to Charlie, so that you can enter in the next one. You guys can enter the giveaway. I'll get in the book, and just for you to know who he is. Peace. This card sucks. That was unlucky. That was tragic. I like how confident you are. That was the best part.