 Are there any specific tools or software available for publishers to catch ethical concerns or any kind of scientific misconduct in a paper? So there's no specific tools for misconduct first day but we do have tools to use with Adobe Photoshop that allow us to get a more forensics look at photographs and the tools are freely available by the Office of Research Integrity by the NIH on their website and they're just kind of macros that go into Photoshop that help us look more closely at photographs. We also use Identicate for plagiarism but those really are just the two main tools that we use in my office for addressing, looking to see whether a concern is real or not.