 جب سے ہم نے اٹناویزی کا اوپیوک کیا آدھار کا اوپیوک کیا کریب کریب چاہر کروڑ، تین کروڑ، ننٹی پیوڈ، چریف کریب چاہر کروڑ ہر جی راشن کار پکڑے گئے اس سے کریب کریب چاہدہ ہزار کروڑ، چاہدہ ہزار کروڑ یہ تنائی رکام، بیچوں لیو مار کھاتے دے، گریب کی حق کا مار کھاتے دے وہ مکھے دھارم آیا اور گریبوں کی طرح مہم بیا ہم نے ایک آرٹی آئی اپلکیشن لگائی، پرائی مینسٹر's آفس میں پرائی مینسٹر کی سپیچ کو کوٹ کرتے ہوئے پہلہ سوال تھا کہ سٹیٹ وائیز لسٹ آف بوگس کارڈ وہ ہمیں دے دیجے اور دوسری چیز ہم نے کہا کہ ہمیں آپ راشن کارڈ ہولڈر وائیز لسٹ دیدیجے ہر سٹیٹ میں پرائی مینسٹر نے 2017 میں کہا تھا کہ پچھلے 2.5 سالٹ کی میں بات کر رہا ہوں تو وہ سوچی جو تھی وہ 2006 سے 16 تک کی تھی تو ہم یہی کہا گیا پی آئیو سے کہ یہ سوچنا نہیں ہے جس کے بارے میں پرائی مینسٹر چرچا کر رہے ہیں اور نہ ہی اس پر لکھا تھا کہ یہ آدھار اور ٹیکنولیجی کے قارن ہے وہ انہلیجبل تو قارڈ کسی بھی قارن سے ہو سکتا ہے پر آدھار اور ٹیکنولیجی کی سپسیفکلی بات کری تھی پرائی مینسٹر نے جب بھی پوچھا گئے انہوں نے کہا ایسی کوئی سوچنا ہمارے پس نہیں ہے جو سوچنا ہے وہ یہی ہے اب اس کے اندر جو فیگرز ہیں وہ بھی میچ نہیں کر رہے 3.95 کاروڈ لکھ سے تو کچھ بھی سوچنا نہیں دی گئی دوسری آٹی آئے میں اندر سیکرٹری کمپیوٹرز نے جواب دیا کہ ہمارا ٹرانسپیرنسی پورٹل آپ دیکلیجے اس پہ بھی کوئی ریکوڈ نہیں تھا to back the prime minister's statement till date we haven't got any basis any evidence backing the prime minister's statement in the meantime جو انکریکٹد version تھی parlament میں proceedings کی جس کے اندر جو پردھان منتری نے کہا تھا اس کو لکھا گیا تھا 4 کاروڈ یانی 3 کاروڈ 95 لاکھ کارڈز ہے اس کو ہم نے جب کل دیکھا تو چینج کر دیا گیا ہے کرکٹیڈ version میں اور اس کو بنا دیا گیا ہے 4 کاروڈ یانی 2 کاروڈ 33 لاکھ راشن کارڈ the government I think had issued a press release which said that almost one crore fake job cards have been deleted so Jean actually filed an RTI saying please give us the break up and if you see this one page note this is a response to his RTI what we find is that there were several reasons for which cards were deleted so actually the total cards deleted is 94 لاکھ it's not all fake some of them were genuine deletions like people had shifted their address or somebody may have died and things like that and then of course some of them were duplicate cards and out of the total number of job cards that exist in the country 1% cards were duplicates and fakes so in Jharkhand this summer we went to 8 districts and it was a randomly selected sample of about 900 households they didn't even have electricity so the dealer was travelling 12 km to charge her point of sale machine so that she could operate it the next day in offline mode about 85% of households are managing to use this system somehow or the other for these households which we call the successful households there are two issues one they are getting exactly the same thing as before but at a higher price in a sense because their transaction costs have gone up the second problem for the successful households is that they continue to experience quantity fraud there is an official term for this quantity fraud it's called Qatoti in Jharkhand کہ وہ Qatoti کرتے ہیں تو پہلے بھی 1 kg ہوتی تھی تو ابھی بھی 1 kg ہے so the successful households they are paying a higher price because of repeated trips and they are getting exactly what they use so there is no gain but there is some pain then there is this 15% which is really the heart breaking story because it includes single member households in this 15% there are some who are these very vulnerable households but even there they were not able if they went 6 times and the system didn't work for them so they get kicked out for those reasons this is the sort of exclusion that's happening in the PDS it's also happening in other schemes آپ کے پاس ایک شیط شاید جائے گا it is from the food security website of Rajasthan governments use of UID biometric authentication in food gain distribution this shows that out of the 1 crore ration card holders in Rajasthan جانوری میں انہوں نے شروع کیا جانوری 2016 اس سمہ ہی سمجھ میں آ رہا تھا ادھار کتنے لوگوں کو دے پارے تھے 7% لوگوں کو by September they had said our system is stabilized and we are giving rations you can only get rations if you put your angutha so everyone has to put their angutha everyone has to put their thumb impression only then will they get rations 34% people were unable to draw their rations who are these 34% those who have already qualified to get and all of whom have aadhar and all of whom aadhar cards are linked and with whom one family member somehow has to put their angutha and then they will get it not even all of them one family member even then 34% people could not get that 2 rupees a kilo rations after that you say you are helping the poor one month after the other the lowest they reached was 25% exclusion one fourth exclusion of the poorest of the poor today it has gone back last month is again 66 lakhs people have got it which means 34 lakh card holders have not got it which means one crore people in Rajasthan have not got their rations how anyone can speak in the supreme court and say that we are including people helping the poor after this sheet after this figure is beyond my understand