 Was Muhammad's marriage to Aisha ethical? We should be asking ourselves, is how can a religiously valid marriage be anything but ethical? There's no written record of anyone accusing the Prophet peace be upon him of any wrongdoing before the year 1905. This is strictly a slander produced in modern times. Multiple scholars question the reliability of all the Aisha marital hadith that were generated over time from a single unreliable source. One, it was narrated by the individual concerned herself, namely Aisha. Two, the report from Aisha is in the soundest of books after the book of Allah, namely the two Sahis of Abu Qari and Musleh. Three, it was narrated from Aisha via a number of chains of narration.