3 Reasons Not to Get Worked Up Over Super PACs





The interactive transcript could not be loaded.



Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Uploaded on Jan 26, 2012

Everybody and their brother -- even Stephen Colbert - is freaking out about "super PACs," which are an outgrowth of the Citzens United decision in 2010.

Traditional political action committees (PACs) are subject to federal limits on how much money donors can give in specific election cycles. Super PACS allow groups such as nonprofit corporations and unions to spend unlimited money on political speech as long as they don't coordinate their activity with the official campaign of a given candidate.

But for all the bellyaching, here are three good reasons not to get worked up over super PACS.

1. Billionaires don't need them to influence elections.

In the wake of an anti-Mitt Romney documentary from Winning Our Future, a group tied to billionaire Sheldon Adelson, The New York Times fretted that the film -- which has had little or no effect on Romney's candidacay -- "underscores how [Citizens United] has made it possible for a wealthy individual to influence an election."

Actually, it's always been legal for rich people to spend what they want as long as they make "independent expenditures" that aren't coordinated with official campaigns. Billionares don't need super Pacs to get their message out. But super PACS may just let the rest of us have our say.

2. Super PACS Go Negative -- and That's a Good Thing!

Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), whose campaign finance legislation was rendered moot by Citizens United, complains that super Pacs not only flood elections with money but flood it with negative messages. McCain, who lost a run for presidency, admits that negative campaigning works, but doesn't like the tone.

Yet study after study shows not only that negative advertising works with voters, but that negative ads actually contain more information than gauzy paeans to American and the virtues of the candidates who pay for such spots.

3. Super PACS Take Power Away From the Parties.

There's no question that super PACs seek to benefit some candidates by taking aim at others. Adelson, the moneybags behind the anti-Romney documentary, is known to be a Newt Gingrich fan.

But as long as super PACs don't coordinate with candidates or official party apparatchiks, they take messaging out of the hands of party leaders and spread it around elsewhere in a way that has got to be more representative of more views of more voters.

Super PACs are the latest casus belli in the push for controlling specifically political speech in the name of making elections fairer. There's no doubt that they are a loophole arising from the last round of campaign finance reform and the attempt to limit the amount of money politicians would have to raise to get their message out.

It's time to recognize that the only way to stop creating new loopholes is by ending the always ineffective laws designed to lower the cost office-seekers need to spend to buy our votes.

About 3 minutes long. Written and narrated by Nick Gillespie. Produced by Meredith Bragg.

Go to to http://reason.tv for downloadable versions of our videos. And go to http://reason.com/blog/2012/01/26/sup... for links documenting the claims made above.

Reason on campaign finance.



  1. 1

    Red Eye's Andy Levy on News, Satire, and Political Correctness

  2. 2

    Ever Wanted to Go to Mars? Mars One Candidate Talks Exploration

  3. 3

    Meet the Man Building Elon Musk's 760MPH Hyperloop: Interview with Dirk Ahlborn

  4. 4

    Top 5 Pointless Congressional Hearings on Baseball

  5. 5

    "An Alt-Weekly For the Upper Crust": Q and A with New York Observer Editor-in-Chief Ken Kurson

  6. 6

    "I Can Breathe": Pro-NYPD Demonstrators Rally, Clash with Anti-NYPD Protesters

  7. 7

    Eric Garner Protesters Shut Down West Side Highway

  8. 8

    What We Saw at the Eric Garner Protest

  9. 9

    Eric Garner Protesters Stage "Die-In" at Grand Central Station

  10. 10

    Q & A With Andrew W.K.: "A Role Model for Fun"

  11. 11

    Sex, Spice, and Small-Town Texas Justice: The Purple Zone Raid

  12. 12

    Banned Books Week: Comic Books and Literary Censorship

  13. 13

    Finally: Robot Bartenders Who Pour Stiff Drinks!

  14. 14

    Over $455,000 Seized from Medical Marijuana Patient Slapped with Civil Asset Forfeiture

  15. 15

    The Shocking Secret Government Watchlisting Guide: The Intercept's Ryan Devereaux

  16. 16

    "Do You Have It Up Your Ass?": Drug Warriors in New Mexico Go Too Far

  17. 17

    These White Boxes Could Track Your Every Move

  18. 18

    The Story of Aaron Swartz: "The Internet's Own Boy" Director Q&A

  19. 19

    What Afghans Think About Bergdahl, the Taliban, and U.S. Intervention: Q&A with Author Anand Gopal

  20. 20

    Should Northern California Secede and Become the State of Jefferson?

  21. 21

    Brain Games' Jason Silva Talks Techno Optimism

  22. 22

    Cop Assaults Air Force Capt. for Not Knowing Neighbor, Says He Could Have Tased or Shot Him Instead

  23. 23

    Google Glass: Privacy, Journalism, and the Dawn of Wearable Technology

  24. 24

    Cheezburger's Ben Huh on Why We 'Snack on Information'

  25. 25

    Look Out Crunchy Moms, AZ State Senator is Targeting Home Births! (Nanny of the Month 4-14)

  26. 26

    ATTN POLICE: Enough Already with the Jaywalking Stings! Don't Cops Have Better Things To Do?

  27. 27

    Tax Day is Coming: Game of Thrones Edition

  28. 28

    TX Cops Lobby to Ban Man from Exposing Speed Traps (Nanny of the Month, 3-14)

  29. 29

    Ex Cop: Everyone Behaves Better When They're on Video

  30. 30

    Is South by Southwest Too Popular for Startups?

  31. 31

    Amish vs. the Courts: Family Speaks Out on Fleeing the U.S. to Escape Court-Mandated Chemo

  32. 32

    Juggalos vs. the FBI: Why Insane Clown Posse Fans are Not a Gang

  33. 33

    MDMA for PTSD: How Ecstasy Is Helping People with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder

  34. 34

    Coding Boot Camps Can Get Students Jobs, CA is Busting Them (Nanny of the Month, February 2014)

  35. 35

    DEA Agent Joins Marijuana Industry

  36. 36

    How Medical Pot Is Helping Seniors Get Off (Prescription) Drugs

  37. 37

    Kelly Thomas Verdict: Father, Protesters Speak Out Against Not Guilty Verdicts

  38. 38

    The Real Miyagi's Dojo Threatened: Santa Ana Favors Foliage over Small Businesses

  39. 39

    The TSA's 12 Banned Items of Christmas

  40. 40

    LA County Jail Officers Charged with Federal Crimes; Jail Monitors Respond

  41. 41

    What are You Smoking? Introducing Marijuana Drug Safety Testing

  42. 42

    Officers on Trial in Killing of Kelly Thomas

  43. 43

    Psychedelic Science: Magic Mushrooms

  44. 44

    "Gaga Feminism: Sex, Gender & the End of Normal": A Chat with Jack Halberstam and Thaddeus Russell

  45. 45

    Full Version of Shawn Nee Detainment by Los Angeles Sheriff's Department Deputies

  46. 46

    The New (and Old) Attacks on Free Thought: Jonathan Rauch on Kindly Inquisitors

  47. 47

    LA County Sheriffs Hassle Photographer, Trample Constitution, Get Lauded by Bosses

  48. 48

    RuPaul's Drag Race, Gender-Bending Marines, and Legislating Gayness: Q/A with Fenton Bailey

  49. 49

    Why are so Many Americans in Prison? Michael Stoll on America's Ridiculous Incarceration Rates

  50. 50

    3 Reasons We Need a Dirty Deal on Debt Ceiling

  51. 51

    Hope For a Better Drug Policy: "America's Longest War" Panel Discussion

  52. 52

    "Wadjda": Q&A with Saudi Arabia's First Female Director

  53. 53

    More Americans Trust IRS Than Facebook with Privacy: Reason-Rupe Poll September 2013

  54. 54

    David Boaz: Americans Won't Tolerate a War with Syria

  55. 55

    "Don't Let My Daughter Die, Governor!": Chris Christie vs. Medical Marijuana

  56. 56

    Gene Epstein: Murray Rothbard's Mixed Legacy

  57. 57

    Andrew Langer On "Ticket Freedom" And The Institute For Liberty

  58. 58

    Drone Boom: Why Drones Aren't Just for Dropping Bombs Anymore

  59. 59

    Stop and Frisk on Trial in NYC: Race, Crime and Constitutional Policing

  60. 60

    Marijuana Legalization's Bright Future with Rob Kampia

  61. 61

    Unitarian Church Leads NSA Lawsuit: Q&A with Rev. Rick Hoyt

  62. 62

    Cameras vs. LAPD: Was A Photographer Interfering or Just Taking Pictures?

  63. 63

    Rail to Nowhere: Honolulu, Hawaii's Train Boondoggle

  64. 64

    Is Facebook a Public Utility? Yes, says Filmmaker Cullen Hoback

  65. 65

    Grover Norquist on Open Borders and Racist Immigration Policy

  66. 66

    Cop Fired for Speaking Out Against Ticket and Arrest Quotas

  67. 67

    Comedian Heather Anne Campbell Talks Fox Show ADHD, Comedy, and Libertarianism

  68. 68

    CrossFit Founder Greg Glassman: "I'm a rabid libertarian"

  69. 69

    Neuroscientist Carl Hart: Science Says We Should Decriminalize Drugs

  70. 70

    West Hollywood Reacts to SCOTUS Gay Marriage Decision

  71. 71

    Jeremy Scahill's "Dirty Wars: The World is a Battlefield"

  72. 72

    Jeremy Scahill on Obama's Vendetta Against the Press

  73. 73

    Jeremy Scahill: Dems are "Nowhere" on Civil Liberties

  74. 74

    Berlin Landscape of Memory: Before the Wall Came Down and Today

  75. 75

    Robert Lipsyte on ESPN, Muhammad Ali, and Billie Jean King

  76. 76

    Game of Thrones' Economics: Auburn University's Matthew McCaffrey says it's not all Fantasy

  77. 77

    Parents, Pot, and Prohibition: Daisy Bram's Story

  78. 78

    Feds Push Insane New Speech Codes!

  79. 79

    3D Printing, Guns, & Sex Toys: Q&A with 3D Systems CEO Avi Reichental

  80. 80

    Surveillance After The Boston Attack: Do More Cameras Fight Terrorism or Violate Our Privacy Rights?

  81. 81

    Singularity University's Salim Ismail on the Age of Technological Disruption

  82. 82

    Hating Breitbart Director Andrew Marcus

  83. 83

    The Sounds of Capitalism: Kennedy Talks with Ethnomusicology Professor Tim Taylor

  84. 84

    Raising the Smoking Age to 21? Young New Yorkers React

  85. 85

    The Paleo Diet Delusion: Paleofantasy's Marlene Zuk on Dietary Myths

  86. 86

    Why The European Union Will Fail: Q&A with Austrian Economist Barbara Kolm

  87. 87

    How the Anti-Bully Movement is Hurting Kids: An Interview with Bully Nation's Susan Porter

  88. 88

    Tortured for Testimony: Anarchists Get Solitary Confinement for Not Snitching

  89. 89

    Cops with Drones: Alameda Co., CA Weighs Technology vs. Privacy

  90. 90

    Is a Carbon Tax Market-Friendly?

  91. 91

    America's Longest War: The Trailer

  92. 92

    UCLA Professor Abigail Saguy on What's Wrong with Fat?

  93. 93

    Matt Ridley on How Fossil Fuels are Greening the Planet

  94. 94

    How To Save America's Zoos: Privatize Them

  95. 95

    Implementing Pot Legalization in Colorado and Washington

  96. 96

    Hollywood meets Wall Street: Author William Stadiem talks Moneywood

  97. 97

    Former Gov. Ben Cayetano on Hawaii's Fiscal Mess and Stupid Rail Plan

  98. 98

    Weed Country: Pot Grower Mike Boutin on Discovery Channel's Newest Reality Show

  99. 99

    LA's New Crack Epidemic: Sidewalks

  100. 100

    Sex and Punishment: Eric Berkowitz Talks 4,000 Years of Judging Desire

  101. 101

    Gov. Scott Walker Welcomes National School Choice Week to Wisconsin

  102. 102

    Sex, Violence & Satan: 6 Unbelievably Dumb Congressional Hearings

  103. 103

    "FEMA Won't Let Us Rebuild Our Home"

  104. 104

    Fitness Crackdown: Santa Monica Gets Tough On Trainers

  105. 105

    I, Tomato: Morning Star's Radical Approach to Management

  106. 106

    Marijuana Is Legal in Colorado...Now What?

  107. 107

    Can an Undocumented Immigrant Become a U.S. Lawyer? California High Court Will Decide

  108. 108

    Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard: Making City Government Work

  109. 109

    1000 Wrongfully Convicted and Counting: New Registry Checks Justice System's Power

  110. 110

    David Friedman on How to Privatize Everything

  111. 111

    Roderick Long on Race, Gender, Equality and Libertarianism

  112. 112

    Athens of the Prairie: How Columbus, Indiana Got Great Architecture

  113. 113

    Media Manipulation and Unconventional Marketing: Author Ryan Holiday on "Trust Me I'm Lying"

  114. 114

    Ladies, We're Screwed: Why Obama's Re-election is Bad for Choice

  115. 115

    Q&A with Libertarian Vice Presidential Candidate Jim Gray

  116. 116

    Steve Chapman on Election 2012, Chicago and Pot Smoking Presidents

  117. 117

    Do the Cops Know Your Info? A Conversation with the ACLU of Illinois's Adam Schwartz

  118. 118

    Capitalist Pig on Why Hedge Funds and Ayn Rand are Great for the Economy

  119. 119

    Ai WeiWei, Pussy Riot and the Power of Punk Art: An Interview with James Panero

  120. 120

    Boob Over Bottle: Mike Bloomberg's Latest Nanny State Dictate

  121. 121

    What We Saw at the Occupy Anniversary Protest in NYC

  122. 122

    NY's 9/11 Memorial: When Did Honoring the Dead Become an Occassion for Fleecing the Living?

  123. 123

    Michael Moynihan on the Politics of Travel Guides

  124. 124

    The Churchill Thrillers: An Interview with Michael and Patrick McMenamin

  125. 125

    Did the GOP Pick Tampa Because of the Strippers? And Did Romney Pick Ryan Because of His Hard-Bod?

  126. 126

    Free Speech Fight: Campus Anti-Zionism May Result in Hate Speech Ban

  127. 127

    Obama's Recovery That Wasn't; Plus: How to Really Cut Defense Spending!

  128. 128

    How Cannabis Can Revolutionize Our Economy: Author Doug Fine on "Too High To Fail"

  129. 129

    A Conversation with Cato's David Boaz at Freedom Fest 2012

  130. 130

    Judge Napolitano on the 2012 Election, Obamacare, and The Future of Liberty

  131. 131

    The Caravan for Peace Calls for an End to the Drug War

  132. 132

    10 Years to Life for Medical Marijuana: The Trial of Aaron Sandusky

  133. 133

    What We Saw at the Solidarity Concert for Pussy Riot

  134. 134

    Anaheim Reacts to Police Shootings

  135. 135

    Montreal Student Riots, Quebec's Speech-Killing Bill 78, & Something Called the "Anarchopanda"

  136. 136

    Stockton, California Went Bankrupt. Is Your City Next?

  137. 137

    Celebrating the End of the Fairness Doctrine

  138. 138

    Hangover Heaven: The Vegas Hangover Cure on Wheels

  139. 139

    Cops with Machine Guns: The Killing of Michael Nida

  140. 140

    Gavin Polone on Hollywood Hypocrites, Bad Film Subsidies, and the Future of the Industry

  141. 141

    Quote-Faking Imagine Author Jonah Lehrer: Why I Became a Journalist

  142. 142

    New Jersey's Insane Seatbelt Law For Your Dog! Nanny of the Month July 2012!

  143. 143

    What We Saw at the Drug Enforcement Administration Museum

  144. 144

    Ron Paul and the GOP Convention

  145. 145

    Fan Fiction vs. Copyright - Q&A with Rebecca Tushnet

  146. 146

    How the Government Makes You Fat: Gary Taubes on Obesity, Carbs, and Bad Science

  147. 147

    How Washington Learned to Love Video Games

  148. 148

    Sen. Tom Coburn: How Both Parties Bankrupted America

  149. 149

    America's First Rebel: Roger Williams and the Birth of Liberty

  150. 150

    The Locavore's Dilemma: In Praise of the 10,000-Mile Diet

  151. 151

    Randy Barnett: Losing Obamacare While Preserving the Constitution

  152. 152

    Killing California's Costly Death Penalty

  153. 153

    Public-Private Partnerships in Puerto Rico

  154. 154

    James V. DeLong on Ending "Big SIS" (The Special Interest State)

  155. 155

    3 Big Takeaways From Obamacare Decision

  156. 156

    Bikini Banners and F*cking Cops Cracking Down on Curse Words! (Nanny of the Month, June '12)

  157. 157

    Is There a Silver Lining to the Supreme Court's Obamacare Decision?

  158. 158

    Gandhi, Mandela, and...Mailmen? Postal Workers Wage Hunger Strike "for Justice"

  159. 159

    The Politics of Poker: Why It's Time To Legalize Online Gaming

  160. 160

    Walter Cronkite wasn't the Most Trusted Man in America? Q&A with author Joseph Campbell

  161. 161

    Is Solitary Confinement a Form of Torture? Q&A with journalist James Ridgeway

  162. 162

    Washington's Parasitic Economy with The Weekly Standard's Andrew Ferguson

  163. 163

    Surprise: Economic Mobility is Alive and Well in America!

  164. 164

    Washington, DC's Capital Bikeshare: Tax $$$ for Rich, Educated, White Riders

  165. 165

    "The Skeptical Environmentalist": A Conversation with John Tierney and Bjorn Lomborg

  166. 166

    Cities Using Feds to Seek "Retribution" in Marijuana Battle, Says Don Duncan

  167. 167

    The Feds Arrested Aaron Sandusky Because He Was Too Successful, Says Dan Forman

  168. 168

    Are Drone Strikes and Kill Lists The New Normal? Q&A w Newsweek's Eli Lake

  169. 169

    How TV's 'Dallas' Won the Cold War

  170. 170

    Is a vote for Gary Johnson just a vote for Obama?

  171. 171

    Ben Huh on the Culture, Morals, and Politics of the Internet

  172. 172

    What did we learn today?

  173. 173

    Ask a Libertarian Lightning Round: Recalls, Libertarian Paternalism, & Tea Party v. Libertarians

  174. 174

    How do we argue with our earnest righty friends without them screaming at us?

  175. 175

    Ask a Libertarian Lightning Round: Libertarianism in Pop Culture & Pop Culture in Politics

  176. 176

    What is the libertarian plan for fixing the debt and deficit problem?

  177. 177

    How can libertarians effect political change?

  178. 178

    Where are the Black Libertarians?

  179. 179

    What about roads?

  180. 180

    What do libertarians think about gay marriage?

  181. 181

    Ask a Libertarian Lightning Round!: Death Penalty, Space Travel, & Grover Cleveland

  182. 182

    What about Sweden, which seems like a great place to live?

  183. 183

    Was it wrong for a libertarian to take taxpayer-funded housing credits?

  184. 184

    How do you plan on uniting various libertarians?

  185. 185

    With Ron Paul retiring, who will pick up the mantle of the libertarian movement?

  186. 186

    Why is there an overlap between atheists and libertarians?

  187. 187

    How should I respond to liberals and conservatives who say I'll "grow out of" libertarianism?

  188. 188

    What role do you see for the Libertarian Party?

  189. 189

    What happens those too young to count on social security and too old to start saving?

  190. 190

    Do we have more to fear from an unrestrained majority or narrow special interests?

  191. 191

    What happened to the "libertarian moment"?

  192. 192

    Why would any sensible Libertarian support abandoning Afghanistan to the Taliban?

  193. 193

    How can I talk politics with my earnest lefty friends without them screaming at me?

  194. 194

    Is there a growing income gap? If so, is it a problem?

  195. 195

    How would school choice work with special needs kids?

  196. 196

    Did Rand Paul compromise his principles by endorsing Mitt Romney?

  197. 197

    What is the libertarian solution to crony capitalism?

  198. 198

    Drone strikes in Yemen -- yay or nay?

  199. 199

    Is it possible for a libertarian to support things like a safety net?

  200. 200

    What's the difference between socially liberal conservatives and real libertarians?

Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to