 Oh, boy. Canada. What doesn't it derive from Agonio Guevara? It's village. As Indigenous people, we are used to our stories getting a little twisted. So listen up as we set the record straight. I'm Agonio Guevara. Please join me as we hear from dozens of Indigenous people. Together we will decolonize our words and our minds on the Telling Our Twisted Histories podcast. You can find episodes on the CBC Listen app or wherever you get your podcasts. From The Conversation, this is Don't Call Me Resilient. I'm Vanita Srivastava. Our food system has been deliberately decimated and food has been used as a means to control us for so long. And really food was the means of the colonization of Canada. A lot of us think of Canada as a wealthy nation. But for many people across the country, access to healthy, affordable food is a real struggle. According to recent stats, one out of every eight households in Canada are food insecure. For racialized Canadians, that number increases to two to three times the national average. And for Black and Indigenous households, that number jumps even higher. Almost 30% of Black households and 50% of Indigenous households experience food insecurity. The pandemic has only made things worse. Like shelter, food is a basic necessity of life. It provides the calories and nutrients we need to survive. And food is also connected to our mental health, our culture and families and our sense of self. But our food systems are failing to feed all of us. Today we're going to pick apart what's broken and talk about ways to fix it with two women who have been battling this issue for years. Tabatha Robin Martins is a mixed ancestry swampy cre researcher and assistant professor at the University of British Columbia's Faculty of Land and Food Systems. When she's not writing and teaching about Indigenous food sovereignty, she spends her time on land working with her people and learning traditional Cree food practices. And Melana Roberts is a food policy expert and food justice advocate and the chair of Food Secure Canada. She recently led the charge to help create North America's first municipal Black food sovereignty plan at the City of Toronto. Welcome Melana. Thanks, glad to be here. And welcome Tabatha. Hi, so happy to be here, thank you. Melana, I want to start with you because I know that you just had this big victory at City Hall in Toronto. As a consultant, you helped lead the way to get Canada's first Black food sovereignty plan in place. So congratulations on making that happen. And I want to talk about the details of the plan. But I want to address first, why is such a plan necessary? Like what was broken? And I'm hoping that you can paint a picture of what things have been like. Yeah, thanks for the question and the interest. Before getting into it, I feel like it's really important to just ground where I'm coming from. And so I am based living and working in the traditional territories of the Mississaugas of the Credit, the Nishinabeg, the Chippewa, the Haudenosaunee and Wendat peoples, as well as many diverse First Nations Inuit and Métis people who really been the stewards of much of my initial understanding around sovereignty and work on this land in this place. And I think I am also a product and a proud ancestor of many affer-descended people who came to Canada, including a long line of strong matriarchs who really grounded my understanding and the importance of freedom in multiple contexts and understanding liberation and kind of the various systems of oppression that have kind of led me to feel deeply connected to this work. So in terms of thinking about why this plan is so important and how we got here, I think in the context of Black communities, particularly in Toronto, but in Canada, broadly, I think we need to look at the food insecurity situation. So the pandemic really was, I hate to say it, but a window of opportunity because it really shone a stark light for the average Canadian, the average person who wasn't necessarily engaged in food work. I mean, I hope Tabitha might agree that a lot of this stuff was no shock to folks who do this in their day in, day out, but we've had the highest food insecurity rates in Canada that we've ever seen, ever. And when we look at Black communities, these rates are a lot higher, similarly to Indigenous communities than the average Canadian. Black families saw 3.5 times the rate of food insecurity even before the pandemic when compared to White families. And that includes things like 36.6% of children living in food insecure households that are Black. We saw high food insecurity rates that have been linked to chronic diseases, so diabetes, cardiovascular disease, asthma, linked to depression, poor health, and education outcomes broadly for children and youth. And increasingly, those things have also been shown to have more severe cases of COVID-19. You know, I hear you say, you have this list, right? I think people, I mean, it's that some people think, well, food insecurity means we are hungry or people are hungry. And what you're saying is the implications are just so far-reaching. Absolutely. I mean, even just take it back from, you know, when we think about people in the first memories they have, you know, growing up, it's often, or, you know, the deep connections they have to their grandparents and their family, it's often linked to food, right? Food is so much more than just a nutritional content. It is linked to our well-being. I mean, the other day, a Black activist, Wendy Portress, who's based in Nova Scotia, said to me, food is the first fight. And I just thought it was such a powerful way to understand why when we start to tackle those challenges, we start to tackle so much more than food insecurity. We start to tackle how people are connecting to the land, to, you know, culture, to history, to community. And so that's part of why a food security initiative, and particularly a Black food sovereignty plan, was such a critical step and a win not only for myself, but for many of the Black activists and organizations who've been calling for this type of shift long before I had the privilege of working with many of them to pull together a plan. And, Tabitha, what are some of the things that you've been seeing and hearing? Like, what does that look like? Thinking about what Milana said, like, food is the first fight. Like, many people don't realize that colonization and the desire to colonize the lands of Canada were done so in order that early colonizers would be the indigenous peoples of this land. That was the desire. And in order to do that, they had to remove indigenous bodies from the land. Like, we had to be killed. And one of the mechanisms for doing that was starvation. And starvation, you can trace starvation over, you know, 300 years and most acutely over 150 years. And the history of that, the patterns of that starvation have never left and are still very present in indigenous communities. And so really food insecurity for indigenous people is based on this colonial infrastructure. And a challenge that I have with food security is that it doesn't address the power inherent in food. And for indigenous people, that power has been used to control us, to manipulate us, to get rid of us. And so my work really focuses on a food sovereignty lens because food security fails to consider the power dimensions of food. And for communities of color, that power dimension is one of the most important parts of our lives, whether we're aware of all of the systemic ways that implicate this desire to keep us essentially unwell or under control or under resourced. So to make sure I understand, the food sovereignty lens takes into account power and systems of power and access to land. Yes, absolutely. And a big challenge for food security interventions is that they don't challenge those systems of power. And so essentially food security interventions continue to be band-aid solutions because we're not addressing all the underlying issues. We're not addressing that infrastructure. You know, the two pandemics that we're talking about, the pandemic, the racial reckoning that we experienced last summer how that has exposed and also exacerbated many of the inequities in our society. I'm wondering how have you seen it affect access to nutritious food in your communities? And I mean, Tabitha, could you talk a little bit about that? So there are myriad challenges and I won't be able to quite do it justice. This is so complex, right? We're really looking almost at a spider web and if you tug at each strand, it reverberates and is interconnected throughout. But I can talk about a few challenges. So one of those challenges for Indigenous communities, specifically reserve-based Indigenous communities, occurred around lockdowns. So what that has, of course, looked like is that when communities are in lockdown, special circumstances have to take place in terms of how food is transferred to remote First Nations communities, for example. So that poses a challenge. The third intersecting crises or I think climate change is more of an epidemic that has been layered onto this time. So for an Indigenous food system, we're not really talking about just the physical components of food, right? We're not just talking about the carrots or the mousse. We're talking about the systems and practices and processes that are embedded within our culture that give us direction in terms of how we eat and why we eat and how we celebrate food. And so we're seeing fissures and breakdowns in family structures, in abilities to share food, in access to food. And then, of course, the underlying piece is this shaky ground, this instability that comes from poverty. So there are so many parts and pieces here that affect the ways that Indigenous peoples eat, and those, of course, were heightened during the pandemic. Melana, how about the communities that you work with? How did things get worse during COVID? Yeah, I think that's a really important question and I really appreciated hearing this idea of networks and the importance of that. So in the context of black residents, black communities in the city of Toronto and across Canada, even the statistics showed that particularly in the first wave of the pandemic, a lot of the job losses that we're seeing were of black women. They saw some of the highest job losses and often statistics have shown that women are really... There's a number of single households that are particularly impacted by food insecurity and more vulnerable to that, who saw their income just completely fall away. And that's a critical piece in determining whether someone has the agency and the ability to buy food. And so we saw this huge demand of folks who weren't able to access food, often lived in areas that Karen Washington was talking about in terms of food apartheid, so areas that are not food deserts, which are natural phenomenon, the idea of connecting it to deserts with this idea of policy and decisions that have made it an area where there's not a lot of grocery stores in that area, low income area. And so the idea of a food apartheid is like, this is a purposeful division. Yeah, purposeful division and planning decisions that negatively often impact low income communities, urban centers with less access to infrastructure and resources that would make food access easier. And so when we compounded those challenges, we saw that there was just a huge demand of the black population to access food. And I think we have a number of organizations in the city of Toronto who provide culturally appropriate food specifically focused on the black community, and they were overwhelmed. The African food basket is an example of one of those strong longtime leaders here and just overwhelmed with the demand and couldn't keep up. So we saw a number of grassroots organizations pop up. And when we saw funds being deployed to support these communities with resources to be able to deliver fresh produce and culturally appropriate food in those neighborhoods, often those small grassroots community-based initiatives that were providing those supports and addressing that need weren't able to even access grants because they weren't a charity or they weren't, you know, had the destination of a nonprofit. And so we saw the overwork and the burnout of those workers within the system who themselves are often being vulnerable to being food secure have increased susceptibility of contracting COVID because they're out there on the front line supporting community and not being able to meet that high demand of residents who were really struggling in this moment. So, you know, the importance of networks and relying on, you know, the community gardens we were often closed during the pandemic so not even being able to have those additional backup resources that connect people and give them the power to be able to address shortfall in these moments. What were some of the ways that people came together to figure things out at this time? Like, you said some community gardens were shut down. Are they back up and running, for example? Or are you seeing things that are working? So, I think a number of different interventions I think in this moment we really did see people rally together and one of the things that really struck me is the number of grassroots organizations that provide other types of services so supporting women against gender-based violence. So, for example, with Food Share Toronto who was able to act as kind of an anchor being able to distribute funds and food to these organizations to deliver them to different areas targeting populations who saw serious food insecurity during the pandemic. And so I think that that was some of the innovation leveraging those networks to be able to provide those supports. I think we also saw a lot of advocacy. So, a lot of people recognizing the importance of farmers markets, its key areas to be able to access fresh food and the closure of them creating a lot of challenges not only for once again residents, but also for those farmers. And particularly for black farmers, it's hard enough to be successful in farming and to be able to have those inputs as a racialized person let alone black farmers who are underrepresented within the agricultural space. And so not being able to sell their food and with a very niche market of providing cultural foods the pandemic can be really challenging. So, different approaches to help people transition to be selling food online as a touch point to be able to connect with more folks was also an innovation we saw. And through some advocates, we also saw farmers markets open up mid-pandemic being recognized as a key space for people. Tabitha, how about you? Did you see similar kinds of innovations or community work on the ground? Yes. One of the most exciting parts of my job is the way that folks are rolling up their sleeves and they're getting onto the land and taking the responsibility to feed each other again. So, various initiatives like community freezer programs you know, in some communities hunters were asked to go out onto the land and stock freezers within the community or stock elders freezers. There was a strong mobilization of Indigenous peoples that were really working to make sure that the elders were protected because the loss of the elders and many died through the pandemic but that's a significant loss to an Indigenous food system because the elders really have the roadmaps or what our food systems can look like again. And so, other initiatives like medicine picking where communities were sending people out into the bush or individuals were taking their own initiative to go out into the bush and pick lots of Labrador tea, for example, which is an important medicine during the pandemic. It's often used for colds and flus and we're sending those to communities that were in lockdown, for example. So, all of those initiatives in which we start to take care of each other again, I mean, that's the work that makes my heart swell and that's the work that I think will fundamentally change our food system so that we can go back to a system where we feed each other again, where we both feed ourselves but feed each other. But there are a lot of political pieces to what happened in the pandemic as well. I was part of a group that, when the government announced the $100 million for food banks, Indigenous, there were activists and knowledge holders and elders and doctors. We got together to say, can some of that money be directly funded towards Indigenous communities? Yes, right. So, like, direct funding. Rather than the funding come through other avenues that eventually trickle their way to our communities, can we direct fund communities? So, if a community says, we want to create a freezer program where we're stocking up freezers full of wild meats and wild fish, can we fund those directly? But unfortunately, the government felt that we were not in the position to be able to effectively distribute those funds and that we didn't have a track record and so the money ended up going to breakfast clubs and to food banks. And the challenge with that, of course, is that we continue systems in which outside parties are feeding Indigenous people and that's what got us in this mess in the first place. Our food system has been deliberately decimated and food has been used as a means to control us for so long and really food was the means of the colonization of Canada and we see that further exemplified through residential schools in which children were punished for speaking their language and which children were also experiencing nutrition and starvation. So these patterns sort of occur over and over again and what we wanted to see in the pandemic was Indigenous peoples responding to ourselves, you know, being able to come together in a community capacity to meet each other's needs and to support and work with each other but we weren't successful with that and so there's a lot of challenging pieces to this but ultimately what we're after is our ancestral and traditional food systems that allowed us to take care of one another. The elders say feasting is one of the highest ceremonies in our culture and part of feasting is the gift of food, you know, and one of the best ways that we can take care of each other is to feed each other. That's such a foundational principle, certainly in my own Cree culture but I know from working with other Indigenous communities that it's similar that we really wanted to get back to that but, you know, we've always been innovative, I will say and resistors and have found ways to kind of step outside of those systems and go back to how we can feed each other again but there's still a lot of colonial infrastructure that's in place that prevents us from doing that. You both mentioned food banks and I think when people think about solutions to hunger we think food banks as somewhere near the top of the list and you mentioned the Canadian government putting a lot of money towards that. What is the role of food banks, Milana? Yeah, the best food banks say that they are working to put themselves out of business. This is not, food banks are not a long-term solution and so at the same time I say it's complicated because in this moment because of the vast and dire nature of food insecurity we're talking about people's lives, people having the sustenance to get from day to day and people are truly dependent on that system and so I think they are meeting an immediate need but I think what we really need to think about is how do we start to put the solutions in place through bringing and providing the adequate resources and spaces, whether it be for Indigenous nations whether it be for Black communities, other racialized communities, communities that are experiencing challenges bringing and understanding how a sovereignty lens can support them to be able to address these needs themselves and start to address those barriers. So yeah, I'd love to hear how Tabitha would explain that but yeah, it's a complicated issue with food banks. It's very complicated and I don't want to deny the value of food banks in keeping people fed and alive but at what cost? You know, we know that food banks as a charity model are considered dumping grounds for less desirable food and we also know that many of those less desirable foods are linked to the high prevalence of diseases such as diabetes and so it's also about like the right food that we're eating and for Indigenous people it's really about this reclamation of our ancestral food system that includes hunting and fishing and trapping. Food banks of course can't meet those needs and for most First Nations communities food banks are not an option because they're too remote and there are not food banks located on each and every reserve so that leaves out on reserve populations entirely and this notion of dependence that Milana talked about I mean that's part of the architecture of colonialism was this desire to make Indigenous peoples in particular dependent on food that was the means for the colonization of Canada and it's how many Indigenous chiefs signed treaties so that they could alleviate the hunger in their communities so in many ways we're perpetuating the same ideas of the past we think we've come a lot farther away from those but they just look different now but it's certainly more insidious so I understand and I respect the role that food banks play because we want people to live but I also want us to get to a point where we stop treating food security with Band-Aid solutions because we aren't moving the dial at all in that approach so let's spend a little time then because we want to talk about what needs to be done you want to move the dial and we want to move forward so we talked a little bit about what food justice looks like but what does it look like? I know both of you are working Tabatha your focus is more western part of the country are you seeing changes happening local government or provincial policy in their approaches towards food sovereignty for Indigenous people? You know this is so interesting last year someone asked me this question if I could talk about the changes I've been doing this work for 11 years and they said I'm wondering if you could talk about some of the positive changes that you've seen with regards to government supporting this and I couldn't think of a single thing the most positive change that I am seeing is Indigenous communities taking this work on themselves in saying we know the system is broken we know we're not going to be fed in the ways that we need to and so we need to circumnavigate the system and do it ourselves I think that one of the biggest challenges for our market-based food system in Canada is that we have done a really successful job of separating food from the land and that is problematic because if we don't at a household level, at a societal level understand that food comes from the land then the government can get away with resource extraction at the levels that they are and we haven't yet made those causal links to say hang on and I think Indigenous many Indigenous communities in Western Canada are doing that with resistance against pipelines or with resistance against hydro-development you can't alter and poison our lands how will we live? I really wish that all of Canada would activate around this notion that food comes from the land for all of us and that the rate at which we are seeing climate change and that the rate at which resource extraction is taking place and the ways that we have valued capitalism over almost everything else is so deeply problematic and short-sighted that we are leaving our future generations with quite a mess So in some ways what I'm hearing you say is that local and provincial governments need to get out of the way like the circumnavigating that you're seeing that's happening governments need to make room for that and maybe fund it so that people don't experience the kind of vulnerability and burnout you mentioned Yeah, I mean that's a whole other piece to this that has not even necessarily been factored in and that is problematic especially with food security interventions is that we expect people through the introduction of community gardens on reserves or other food programming we expect all of that work to be done for free on top of everyone's day-to-day job we just don't value food work in the way that we should and that's something that COVID has certainly shined a light on is the fact that we just don't value our food workers even our grocery store workers in the ways that we should be Melana, as we mentioned in the beginning you've actually had real success in doing some groundbreaking policy work in helping to pass the first black food sovereignty plan for the city of Toronto the first of its kind I think in North America this plan is really trying to do a lot more than just address food insecurity but to really draw on the structural levers and the role that I think the city of Toronto has been able to play in championing black food leadership which is really, we often say this plan as a community-led plan that's facilitated by the city starting off with this idea of ensuring that black-led, black-serving organizations that are really at the forefront of this work are adequately resourced to be able to respond to these day-to-day food insecurity crises and challenges to be able to do this work in a way that doesn't lead to burnout in addition to that also ensuring in an urban context that the city is providing access to green and growing space in neighbourhoods with high black populations so before the pandemic and before the plan it was very clear that in neighbourhoods with the highest black populations we saw the lowest access to green space and the city's tree canopy cover and there's been lots of links to that with mental health challenges and challenges during the pandemic as well so ensuring that there was growing space that people can access and thrive in regards to urban agriculture as a key tool to support food insecurity interventions thinking about our health system so when we're thinking about health often times it's just the adequate nutritional intake of foods but really understanding the importance of culturally appropriate food of the long legacies of trauma and intergenerational racism and poverty that actually impact our health just as much as having the right foods to eat and the role of anti-black racism in perpetuating poor health outcomes and how we can bring those lenses into food programs health programs to be able to serve black residents more adequately and increased access to infrastructure so we have community kitchens across the city different programs and initiatives just for businesses and black businesses often have challenges and access black youth in those neighbourhoods have challenges to access the spaces so opening them up and we've been able to partner even with museum sites that have land that are working with local indigenous groups who've been addressing food security challenges among those populations to be able to increase their access to museum spaces with kitchen space and growing space to develop traditional gardens responding with medicinal plants and other interventions supporting those communities and in addition to that of course having increased food spaces so black food hubs food markets and other cultural spaces that are used to food directly in those communities so those are some of the types of pillars and interventions that have laid the road map to create a more sustainable black food ecosystem in the city of Toronto that has really been identified directly by black communities and built to develop and deliver a plan I understand that Tabatha as you said it's a spiderweb and there's so much that we could cover guys thank you and I also try and keep myself quiet because what you're saying is so amazing but I was nodding a lot thank you so much for such a rich conversation Thanks for asking important questions about it I want to thank you, I think the space to have this conversation being able to learn and being in conversation with Tabatha is a real honour and always something that I learn from and I feel the same way Melana and I really love seeing that we are pushing back against those notions that have divided marginalised groups historically in which we've been told that we can't come together because we're in competition with one another and that we should be so happy with the scraps that we receive so I'd love to see the ways that you're pushing back against that and that we're working with each other That's it for this episode of Don't Call Me Resilient and for our season thank you so much for listening I learned so much today from Melana and Tabatha about how to talk about food sovereignty and I'd love to hear what you're thinking after that conversation I'm on Twitter at writevenita that's at W-R-I-T-E-V-I-N-I-T-A and don't forget to tag our producers at ConversationCA you can use the hashtag to read more about food sovereignty you can go to theconversation.com we have all kinds of info in our show notes with links to stories and further research and if you haven't already listened there are 11 other episodes in our feed please go and have a look around there are so many amazing voices on this pod finally if you like what you heard today please tell a friend about us and believe it or not those positive reviews motivate us to keep going please leave us a review on whatever podcast app you're using this is Jennifer Morose Lisa Verano leads audience development for the Conversation Canada and Scott White is our CEO and if you're wondering who wrote and performed the music we use on the pod that's the amazing Zaki Ibrahim the track is called Something in the Water thanks for listening everyone and hope you join us again until then I'm Venita and please don't call me resilient showing this podcast why not check out the Conversation Weekly hosted by me Dan Marino in San Francisco and me Gemma Ware in London each week we talk to scholars and researchers getting the inside story on new scientific breakthroughs the standard model is probably the most successful scientific theory that we've ever developed and the history and context behind the headlines the United States starts to funnel money in Afghanistan but the people they end up allying with are the most reactionary groups we look at how we got here in the first place driving is a lot more polluting than aviation and so if we can sort out the car transport we can do a very big difference to global emissions and find out what's really happening on the ground 80% of these Rohingya refugees are women and children there have been cases of trafficking, smuggling and even killing and finally we dive into some of the world's most pressing issues many ocean based industries today are growing faster than the global economy it describes a new phase in humanity's relationship with the ocean on the onset of the 21st century by talking to scholars who spend their whole lives studying if we can really understand the basic mechanisms that are shaping plasticity this could become a way that we could impact a lot of lives find us at theconversation.com or follow the conversation weekly via Apple podcasts Spotify or wherever you normally listen