 I am not sure we heard the same things this evening. What Narendra said was something different I think. China was able in 50 years to increase the life expectancy of its citizens by using fossil fuels and I don't believe that a country like India and some African country will be able to have this level of development and this level of energy without fossil fuels. So what I heard Narendra saying is that countries like India and other countries are going to use fossil fuel at a much higher level than the actual level and I think your summary was very biased. If you allow me to share very quickly you see when you look at India's track record on renewables what we have achieved the last five years trust me is more than Germany you see is better than our track record what we have we have been walking the you know talk all that we committed in Paris all that we committed in Glasgow or for that much we have already walked we have delivered that but that said at the same time world over 82% energy that the world is consuming is coming from traditional sources in India stories more or less the same 67% of electricity that we consume is coming from coal look at you see at the same time you have to see India has not some small banana Republic we have security challenges from the north from the Indian Ocean from so many side when you look at India's energy seen 88% of oil that we consume is imported 88% so is we consume 5.2 million barrels of oil every day natural gas we are importing roughly 56% our total requirement in solar power 90% of equipment that we are using you know for solar are imported mainly from China uranium you know big chunk of uranium we import so that makes that's extremely vulnerable in terms of energy security now the question is that you know on the one hand we have to see the renewable and at the same time we have to see the energy security because we are a very large country and also we are threatened from all side the final point I'm trying to make is energy transition in a country like India and it we are more committed than most countries in the global north are you can check it on the cold numbers facts but that I'd say time energy transition in India we will do with Indian characteristics based on ground realities in India based on the fact we still have 700 million people who are below energy poverty line so for us that comes first and if there is international pressure trust me we are strong enough to deal with it so I am I'm sorry it's a perhaps a privilege of the president but it's 735 and the court cocktail started unfortunately we will not have the time for a debate on more general issues these issues I wanted to debate is what are your expect expectation for next COP 28 meeting the second is perhaps a focus on China China is it's the elephant in the room and we need to speak about why about what will happen in China and depending on what's happening in China this will have a dramatic impact on the energy world and also on the environment worldwide and perhaps also a question I wanted to raise in 1973 the first oil shock was created by a conflict between Israel and the Palestinians and perhaps are we at the eve of an oil shock taking into account it was not with the Palestinian it was an attack by Egypt and Syria the same time the Palestinian and nothing to do with that sorry to record that I know I know but there is perhaps there is what perhaps there is we are at the eve of perhaps an oil shock why not taking into account the fact that the depletion referred by Nicola is taking place and the investment of in oil and in oil and gas has been reduced by a factor of two since 2014 so it's for the time being the Palestinians but what will be the position in the next few weeks of the Arab governments I'm not sure I hope that the what we heard from the advisor of the president of the UAE is right so I want to thanks the panelist and also thanks the audience for this debate and anyway perhaps the next time it will be necessary to have a longer the more time to have a long and in-depth debate on all around the world thank you