 Welcome to ToffeeTV, it is the player ratings Everton 3, full and nil. These might be hard, these predictions one of the hardest sets of predictions because it's our best win of the season and obviously only our second Premier League win but for 45 minutes we were absolutely dire so I've got to bring that into the reckoning of these player ratings that might make them seem some of them slightly more negative than you might think but I thought for 45 minutes we were absolutely rubbish and if Fulmer took a couple of chances today then the game could have been very different but saying that if we took a couple of chances last week and if we took a couple of chances against West Ham then those games could have been very different. Jordan Pickford I've given him a seven and a half, he didn't have to be amazing but he made one outstanding stop in the second half where he came out to the strikers feet and took it off him and I think that was that one nil, it was a pivotal point in the game, they broke away and he makes that save and we win the game and I think that was huge. Everything else he did well is kicking and everything else he did quite well, there was one in the first half where he bounced one off the bar, who's to say his presence alone didn't stop them from scoring so I've given them a seven and a half. John Joe Kenny I'm given a six, I thought going forward again he was okay and I thought defensively he was okay in the second half but I think just times when he was just really ineffective and there was times when he just smashed the ball into the air and he didn't take enough care of the ball but he was okay, I'm not saying he was telling, I'm just saying he was okay and that's why I've given him a six because I just think he was okay, nothing amazing. Lucas Dinier I don't care how his name was pronounced that's how I pronounce it because I like the French sounding Nisobi, I've given him a seven because I think defensively I still think he's a little bit vulnerable but going forward he takes care of the ball so much better than other players, his cross is outstanding, his set piece is outstanding and I think just the fact that he takes care of that ball when he's got it just elevates him a little bit than his teammates, I thought going forward he was outstanding today again, I still think he has to improve defensively but hopefully that'll come but it might come it doesn't always come but if you're offering some at the other end it's up to the rest of your team to adjust to that so I've given him a seven. Michael Keane I've given him an eight, I thought he was really good today defensively I didn't I didn't think he'd give much away at all won everything in the air against Mitrovich who really was trying to be you know trying to be the player who helped the ball on without being anything else really I think he dealt with everything really really well there might have been a couple of times the other couple of little lapses but I thought he played really well and again I'll say it again I think he should be the captain it's not against Tom Davies I just think Michael Keane would just elevate him a little bit more if he had the arm band and led the team out but that's up to the manager. K2 man I've given him a seven again I thought he played pretty well I just didn't think he was as good as Keane but I do think that I think there's a I think Zuma plays better with Keane than he does with Holgate so I've given him a seven I thought he was fine today Tom Davies I've given him a I've given a six and a half I didn't think he was rubbish but I didn't think he was brilliant I just thought he was quite steady tried to get the ball moving was unsuccessful at times got pulled up for a couple of missed not mistimed tackles just mistimed slides more than anything else tried to do things but it didn't always come off for him which is pretty much the case for Tom Davies he tries to do things but they don't always come off and but never goes missing in the game never shakes his responsibilities and he's got dead nice pink boots so I might move that but I've given him a six and a half because I just think that at times we lacked a little bit of creativity that he could have given us and didn't. I've given him a seven I didn't think he was as good as last week but I thought he was trying to get a trying to get you know amongst them in field as much as he can and he's he's limited in terms of going forward but I think when he plays that deep role it's up to the plays in front of him to do their jobs and they don't always do that but I thought he played quite well today so I've given him a seven now Guilfy Sigurdsson this is I've given him a seven and a half that might be slightly picky for a lad he scored two goals but again faced half there wasn't enough from him there wasn't enough creativity at all I didn't think he was trying but he just wasn't the final ball and that was the first half but the second half takes the penalty picks himself up for missing the penalty and his game started to go up then it was almost like I've got to do something and he scored his first goal was a cracker and his second goal was a lovely place finish but his first goal was massively important I think that there was such a disappointment after he missed that penalty that we all needed a lift and you know I think it did mean a lot to him scoring that goal and his second one just put the the icing on the cake and just if there's any any fears lingering around the ground he took them away so I've given him a seven and a half Wolcott I've given him a six and a half again I think he helped set up the second goal but again not in the game enough for me a couple of runs got a first chance on the first half and he's he's had one late on in the game as well but just not contributing enough in the game just not being as dangerous as I think he can be sometimes when you're bogged down in the middle of the park you need your wife mentor to get you out of it so he didn't always do that but Charles and I've given a seven because he's always a threat even though sometimes a foul today is decision making really frustrating and what I mean that I mean trying to keep things in and losing the ball when it would be easier to let the ball go out for a thrown retain possession there's little instances of that on the pitch that really frustrated me today but he's always a threat he's always a danger he's always trying to create something and that's you know that's refreshing in an Everton team so I think he's just got to get a little bit better than his decision making um Ale Ross Barclay sometimes but he's always a threat and um on another day he'll get a couple of goals in a game like that um but I can't have a learn I've given three I just thought he was really really bad and you know people know I like don't but I just thought he was terrible today um okay yeah he won as the penalty and he did really well for winning as the penalty and I think I've actually marked them up for that but for the rest of the game he's just where was he he wasn't and I know I know it's easy to say well where was the service but as a centre forward you've got to offer yourself at times to um to create something and he never did and he did the thing of dropping into midfield when we needed him pushed up so he gets a three from me and that's pushing it. Jintotin I've given seven made up he scored made up he came on he was fully running full of effort I'm delighted he got the goal it was a great crossing and he's got a header and I'm delighted for him hopefully that's him off the mark now and uh you know hopefully we'll get more out of him going forward because I'm delighted but now I've given seven as well sets the goal up he always looks dangerous doesn't he and a couple weeks ago I was bowing on the fact against West Ham now it's final ball let him down well it's final ball today was brilliant for Guilfee picked him out super early and uh yeah he gets a seven from me delighted he looks a real player um Snadlin he was on for three minutes so I can't really give anything to him so yeah there you go I am I'm just delighted with three points football is good again for an hour today or just less than an hour or whatever it was I was thinking football wasn't good but it was good I'm delighted we've won three and he'll I made up happy days let me know thoughts in the comments I'll see you later