Bill Nye: Creationism Is Not Appropriate For Children





The interactive transcript could not be loaded.



Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Published on Aug 23, 2012

Don't miss new Big Think videos! Subscribe by clicking here: http://goo.gl/CPTsV5

Evolution is the fundamental idea in all of life science, in all of biology. According to Bill Nye, aka "the science guy," if grownups want to "deny evolution and live in your world that's completely inconsistent with everything we observe in the universe, that's fine, but don't make your kids do it because we need them."

-- Transcript:
Denial of evolution is unique to the United States. I mean, we're the world's most advanced technological—I mean, you could say Japan—but generally, the United States is where most of the innovations still happens. People still move to the United States. And that's largely because of the intellectual capital we have, the general understanding of science. When you have a portion of the population that doesn't believe in that, it holds everybody back, really.

Evolution is the fundamental idea in all of life science, in all of biology. It's like, it's very much analogous to trying to do geology without believing in tectonic plates. You're just not going to get the right answer. Your whole world is just going to be a mystery instead of an exciting place.

As my old professor, Carl Sagan, said, "When you're in love you want to tell the world." So, once in a while I get people that really—or that claim—they don't believe in evolution. And my response generally is "Well, why not? Really, why not?" Your world just becomes fantastically complicated when you don't believe in evolution. I mean, here are these ancient dinosaur bones or fossils, here is radioactivity, here are distant stars that are just like our star but they're at a different point in their lifecycle. The idea of deep time, of this billions of years, explains so much of the world around us. If you try to ignore that, your world view just becomes crazy, just untenable, itself inconsistent.

And I say to the grownups, if you want to deny evolution and live in your world, in your world that's completely inconsistent with everything we observe in the universe, that's fine, but don't make your kids do it because we need them. We need scientifically literate voters and taxpayers for the future. We need people that can—we need engineers that can build stuff, solve problems.

It's just really hard a thing, it's really a hard thing. You know, in another couple of centuries that world view, I'm sure, will be, it just won't exist. There's no evidence for it.

Directed / Produced by
Jonathan Fowler and Elizabeth Rodd


New Releases

  1. 153

    Fareed Zakaria on the Knowledge Economy

  2. 154

    Eating Hot Dogs Like a Freak, with Stephen Dubner

  3. 155

    James Abruzzo on Ethics and Art

  4. 156

    Barbara Corcoran: How to Fire Like a Shark

  5. 157

    What Does a 30% Chance of Rain Mean? (Understanding Risk, with Gerd Gigerenzer)

  6. 158

    Barbara Corcoran: How to Hire Like a Shark

  7. 159

    Adam Bryant: The Importance of Culture in the Workplace

  8. 160

    Stop Trying: The Wu-Wei of Laozi

  9. 161

    Would You Vote for a Psychopath?

  10. 162

    The Science of Spontaneity: Mastering Wu-Wei

  11. 163

    Michio Kaku on Reading Minds, Recording Dreams, and Brain Imaging

  12. 164

    Danilo Türk: Diligence Isn't Enough. Be Creative.

  13. 165

    Dan Harris' Panic Attack (and Discovery of Meditation)

  14. 166

    Dr. Steven Masley: Healthy Eating Doesn't Have to Be Gross

  15. 167

    Is Wikilaw the Ultimate Democracy? (George Papandreou)

  16. 168

    Jeremy Rifkin on the Fall of Capitalism and the Internet of Things

  17. 169

    The Regeneration of Organs Can Soon Be Commonplace

  18. 170

    The Dao of Letting Go (or Not Trying)

  19. 171

    The Art of Receiving Feedback

  20. 172

    Big Think Interview With Nicholas Negroponte

  21. 173

    The Psychology of Happiness and Feedback

  22. 174

    Michio Kaku: Are Robonauts Better Than Astronauts?

  23. 175

    Educating for the 21st Century

  24. 176

    The Risk Behind Netflix's Original Programming Leap

  25. 177

    David Kaplan on the Multiverse and Particle Fever

  26. 178

    What Would Plato Think of Crowdsourcing?

  27. 179

    What's the New Way of Connecting Students with Experts?

  28. 180

    Tim Harford: What Prison Camps Can Teach You About the Economy

  29. 181

    Michio Kaku on the Evolution of Intelligence

  30. 182

    Education Q&A with UNESCO's Irina Bokova

  31. 183

    How Drones are Like Viruses (and Vice-Versa)

  32. 184

    Michio Kaku on Alien Brains

  33. 185

    Is the Universe an Accident?

  34. 186

    Michio Kaku: Consciousness Can be Quantified

  35. 187

    Darwin's Flowers: Unraveling an 'Abominable Mystery'

  36. 188

    Michio Kaku: This is Your Brain on a Laser Beam

  37. 189

    Love Potion Number 3.14159265...

  38. 190

    Of Hellabytes and Recombinant Innovation: The Second Machine Age

  39. 191

    Ethan Nadelmann: The War on Drugs is Racist

  40. 192

    Julian Assange vs. J. Edgar Hoover: Who's the real hero?

  41. 193

    Evolution is Not an Obvious or Intuitive Concept

  42. 194

    The Audacity of Solving Grand Challenges

  43. 195

    Would You Be Better Off if Fewer People Lived Before You?

  44. 196

    Kevin Dutton: A Psychological Analysis of James Bond

  45. 197

    Dennis Kozlowski: Poster Child or Whipping Boy?

  46. 198

    Fighting (the Propensity for Crime) with Big Data

  47. 199

    Eric Green: Reading Cancer's Genetic Signature

  48. 200

    Sharon Salzberg: Kindness is Great

  49. 201

    John Eliot Gardiner: Celebrating the Universal Bach

  50. 202

    What the Genomic Revolution Means to You

  51. 203

    Robert Thurman: Love Your Enemy

  52. 204

    Get in the Flow State: What Jazz Can Teach You About Collaboration

  53. 205

    Ray Kurzweil: Why Should We Create a Mind?

  54. 206

    Is Google Glass the End of Privacy?

  55. 207

    Doris Kearns Goodwin: The Power of Teddy Roosevelt's Bully Pulpit

  56. 208

    John Eliot Gardiner: Bach's Habit of Imperfection

  57. 209

    John Hagel: Move to the City, Learn Faster

  58. 210

    Mark Tercek: Green Infrastructure Outperforms Gray

  59. 211

    Joel Primack: Dark Matter Reveals the Structure of the Universe

  60. 212

    Kevin Mitnick: How to Troll the FBI

  61. 213

    Elementary, Watson: The Rise of the Anthropomorphic Machine

  62. 214

    Jeff Livingston: The Most Neglected Skills

  63. 215

    Vikas Pota on Raising the Status of Teachers

  64. 216

    Van Jones: Let's Stop Trying to Please Republicans

  65. 217

    Love is the Product of Lousy Neurons

  66. 218

    Rick Smolan: Using Psychic Apps to Improve Your Health

  67. 219

    Warren Littlefield: Television Audiences Will Find Great Content, Wherever It Is

  68. 220

    How to Think Like a Philosopher, with Daniel Dennett | Big Think Mentor

  69. 221

    Elon Musk: Tesla and SolarCity Will Accelerate the Development of an Energy Solution

  70. 222

    Lawrence Krauss: Quantum Computing Explained

  71. 223

    G+ Hangout With Ellen Galinsky | The Seven Essential Life Skills | Big Think Mentor

  72. 224

    Google+ Hangout with Robert Greene | How to Achieve Mastery | Big Think Mentor

  73. 225

    Paul Ekman: Outsmart Evolution and Master Your Emotions

  74. 226

    Tito Beveridge: Hitting It Against All Odds

  75. 227

    Would You Kill Baby Hitler? (And Other Psychopathic Musings, with Kevin Dutton)

  76. 228

    Neil deGrasse Tyson: The 3 Fears That Drive Us to Accomplish Extraordinary Things

  77. 229

    Crazy Wisdom: Daniel Dennett on Reductio ad Absurdum

  78. 230

    Ramez Naam on Idea Sex and the Evolutionary Logic of Knowledge Transfer

  79. 231

    Hector Ruiz: The Evolution of Cognitive Computing

  80. 232

    The Path to Discovering Your Talents and Passions, with Sir Ken Robinson | Big Think Mentor

  81. 233

    Neil deGrasse Tyson (Caught on Camera): The Universe is Trying to Kill You

  82. 234

    Lifestyle and Emotional Well-Being, with Dr. Andrew Weil | Big Think Mentor

  83. 235

    Lee Smolin: Physics Envy and Economic Theory

  84. 236

    Robert Greene: Achieving Mastery | Big Think Mentor

  85. 237

    John Hunter: Can 4th Graders Teach World Peace?

  86. 238

    Neil deGrasse Tyson: Your Ego and the Cosmic Perspective | Big Think Mentor

  87. 239

    Frans de Waal: Morality Without Religion

  88. 240

    Henry Alex Rubin: Is Technology Disconnecting Us?

  89. 241

    Neil deGrasse Tyson: Want Scientifically Literate Children? Get Out of Their Way.

  90. 242

    Eric Siegel: You Are So Predictable

  91. 243

    Big Think Mentor: From Big Think to Big Action

  92. 244

    Alva Noë: The Puzzle of Perception

  93. 245

    Neil deGrasse Tyson: Don't Sit Around Waiting for a Sputnik Moment

  94. 246

    Adam Alter: Drunk Tank Pink

  95. 247

    Daniel Altman: It's Time to Abolish the Corporate Income Tax

  96. 248

    Eric Kandel: How Your Brain Finishes Paintings

  97. 249

    Penn Jillette: Donald Trump is Scrooge McDuck

  98. 250

    Richard Florida: Want Job Stability? Get Creative.

  99. 251

    Eric Kandel: Creativity, Your Brain, and the Aha! Moment

  100. 252

    Neil deGrasse Tyson: We Live in a Cosmic Shooting Gallery

  101. Bill Nye: Creationism Is Not Appropriate For Children

  102. 254

    Michio Kaku: The Universe in a Nutshell

  103. 255

    Are You a Psychopath? Take the Test.

  104. 256

    Penn Jillette: Don't Leave Atheists Out on Christmas

  105. 257

    Henry Rollins on Gay Marriage

  106. 258

    How World of Warcraft Could Save Your Business and The Economy

  107. 259

    Why Be Happy When You Could Be Interesting?

  108. 260

    Henry Rollins: The One Decision that Changed My Life Forever

  109. 261

    Michio Kaku: The Search for Life on Mars

  110. 262

    Neil deGrasse Tyson: Be Yourself

  111. 263

    Michio Kaku: Can We Resurrect the Dinosaurs? Neanderthal Man?

  112. 264

    Mitt's Magical Mormon Undies: Penn Jillette's Rant Redux

  113. 265

    Back to School with Punkle Henry (Rollins)

  114. 266

    Michio Kaku: Is God a Mathematician?

  115. 267

    Slavoj Žižek: Don't Act. Just Think.

  116. 268

    Michio Kaku's Must-See Videos: An Introduction to Infinity by TED-Ed

  117. 269

    Paul Bloom: The Psychology of Everything

  118. 270

    Michio Kaku: Can Nanotechnology Create Utopia?

  119. 271

    Bill Nye: Why We Explore

  120. 272

    Bill Nye: Teaching Evolution? Think Thriller.

  121. 273

    How Do We Perceive Color?

  122. 274

    Lawrence Krauss: Teaching Creationism is Child Abuse

  123. 275

    How to Catch a Liar (Assuming We Want To)

  124. 276

    Can We Have Brain-to-Brain Communication?

  125. 277

    William Ackman: Everything You Need to Know About Finance and Investing in Under an Hour

  126. 278

    Lawrence Krauss: Our Godless Universe is Precious

  127. 279

    Steven Pinker: Linguistics as a Window to Understanding the Brain

  128. 280

    Michio Kaku: What's the Fate of the Universe? It's in the Dark Matter

  129. 281

    Penn Jillette's Bullshit Detector

  130. 282

    Jaron Lanier: Why Facebook Isn't Free

  131. 283

    Michio Kaku: Space Bubble Baths and the Free Universe

  132. 284

    Michael Gazzaniga: The Criminal Brain

  133. 285

    Michio Kaku: What Put the Bang in the Big Bang?

  134. 286

    Michio Kaku: The von Neumann Probe (A Nano Ship to the Stars)

  135. 287

    Your Irrational Brain

  136. 288

    Henry Rollins: The Myth of Online Transparency

  137. 289

    How Not to Spend Your Whole Day on Facebook

  138. 290

    Porn Movies in Our Minds

  139. 291

    Henry Rollins: Education is the End of Disaster Capitalism

  140. 292

    Tamar Gendler: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Politics and Economics

  141. 293

    Howard Dean: Let's Drive Over the Fiscal Cliff.

  142. 294

    Are You Dating a Psychopath?

  143. 295

    Bill Nye: The School of the Future

  144. 296

    Henry Rollins: Education Will Restore A Vigorous Democracy

  145. 297

    Daniel Altman: Fiscal Cliff, Schmiscal Cliff.

  146. 298

    What Are You Worth? Getting Past Status Anxiety.

  147. 299

    Rick Smolan: Can Big Data Change Who You Are?

  148. 300

    Jane McGonigal: Truths & Myths in Gaming

  149. 301

    Neil deGrasse Tyson: Has the Future Arrived?

  150. 302

    The Optimism of Melancholia

  151. 303

    Slavoj Žižek: We Need Thinking

  152. 304

    Lawrence Krauss on Caveman Common Sense

  153. 305

    Lawrence Krauss: Should Science Teachers Be Paid More Than Humanities Teachers?

  154. 306

    Mindfulness: How to Call Off the Emotional Attack Dogs

  155. 307

    How Darwin Can Save Your Marriage

  156. 308

    Ray Kurzweil: Bad Memory? Not a Problem Unless You're a Robot.

  157. 309

    Do Dogs Speak Human?

  158. 310

    Buddhism as a "Science of the Mind"

  159. 311

    Joel Cohen: An Introduction to Demography (Malthus Miffed: Are People the Problem?)

  160. 312

    Penn Jillette: Why Celebrity Apprentice Sucks Away Your Willpower

  161. 313

    Jeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education

  162. 314

    Nicholas Christakis: The Sociological Science Behind Social Networks and Social Influence

  163. 315

    Daniel Burrus: Predicting the Future

  164. 316

    Ray Kurzweil: Your Brain in the Cloud

  165. 317

    Ethan Nadelmann: The White House Experiments With Weed

  166. 318

    Rationality in Action: Look at a Problem as an Outsider

  167. 319

    Charles Murray: Are You a Snob? Take the Test.

  168. 320

    Douglas Melton: Is Biomedical Research Really Close to Curing Anything?

  169. 321

    Alain de Botton: How Proust Can Change Your Life

  170. 322

    David Eagleman: Welcome to Your Future Brain

  171. 323

    Ai Weiwei: The Internet vs. The Chinese Government

  172. 324

    Why We Make Bad Decisions About Money (And What We Can Do About It)

  173. 325

    Eric Kandel: Unconscious Decision Making

  174. 326

    Ai Weiwei: The Price of China's Success

  175. 327

    Seeing Sound, Tasting Color: Synesthesia

  176. 328

    Bob Kulhan: Improv 101 (The "Yes, and..." Principle)

  177. 329

    Information Obesity: Take Responsibility for Your Media Menu

  178. 330

    Me All the Time: The Epidemic of Narcissism

  179. 331

    Lawrence Summers: Decoding the DNA of Education in Search of Actual Knowledge

  180. 332

    Paul Krugman's Advice to Recent Graduates

  181. 333

    Daniel Kahneman: Moving to California Won't Make You Happy

  182. 334

    Errol Morris on Confirmation Bias (Does your brain frame the picture?)

  183. 335

    Maria Konnikova: Sherlock Holmes Could Have Invented Google

  184. 336

    David Eagleman: What Went Wrong With AI?

  185. 337

    Jaron Lanier: The Death of Alan Turing

  186. 338

    Baratunde Thurston: A Bacon-infused Internet?

  187. 339

    Saul Levmore: Monopolies as an Introduction to Economics

  188. 340

    Margaret Cho: Find What You Love & Never Stop Doing It

  189. 341

    Leon Botstein: Art Now (Aesthetics Across Music, Painting, Architecture, Movies, and More.)

  190. 342

    Gaming and Productivity

  191. 343

    Andrew Newberg: Is The Human Brain Hardwired for God?

  192. 344

    "Write what you know" - Nathan Englander on Misunderstood Advice

  193. 345

    Actor Jonathan Pryce on Stage Fright as Selfishness

  194. 346

    Daniel Altman: Everything You Need to Know About Gold

  195. 347

    Jonathon Keats: What the World Needs is More Curious Amateurs

  196. 348

    What's Lost (And Found) In Machine Translation

  197. 349

    Don't Fear the Gadget: From Gutenberg to Zuckerberg

  198. 350

    Daniel Altman: The Eurozone

  199. 351

    Daniel Altman: Another BRIC in the Wall?

  200. 352

    [Private video]

Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to