 If his position is true, if I were to voluntarily, through voluntary transactions, acquire the surface of the earth, it follows that justice would enable me to kick all you off into space and die. That to me looks like a reductio ad absurdum of the whole position. I mean, yeah, you can create science fiction nonsensical examples that make anything... It's a counter example. It's not. It's a counter example. There's no counter example here because there is no possibility and we can walk it through the example of anything like that ever happening. Most of the east coast of the United States is privately owned. Has anybody ever approached even close to owning the entire east coast of the United States? But if they did. Has anybody even approached owning the entire island of Manhattan as anybody even approached? But they can't. But if they did. No, but metaphysically, but metaphysically, they can't. You can't go against nature. But will you admit that if they did, and if I decided... But they wouldn't. You can't... Oh, I don't know. That's not how philosophy works here. No, but you can't hypothesize a metaphorically impossible. It is how philosophy works. It's how good philosophy works, so it's a bad philosophy.