 What is going on guys welcome back to the channel critical overload here So we're gonna be talking about screen 5 again here today screen 5 did indeed confirm the fate of Kirby reed It gave us that answer to that overly Decade long question that we've had regarding the fate of Hayden Pantiers character in screen 5 So if you don't want that answer then this is time to click off because any and all things random spoilers are gonna Be throughout this video if you haven't seen screen 5 yet So this is your time to click away But jumping into it. So there is a moment in the film where Richie who is revealed to be one of the ghost face killers He was watching stab clips on YouTube dead meat shout out to you and in his recommendations You had this got this image from reddit shout out to the user posted over on reddit It says interview with Woodsboro survivor Kirby reed and then right beneath you. Of course you see Ryan Johnson on on Re-envigorating or reviving stab I think that says so the whole point of this of course is that the top one says interview with Woodsboro survivor Kirby reed which gives you that answer to whether or not Kirby actually lived at the end of screen 4 now What's interesting about that is this adds a lot more weight to the arguments that people have been making With the fact that if you are rewatching screen 4 You can hear when Sydney is about to go down into Kirby's basement or whatever She was about to go downstairs in Kirby's house You can hear what sounds like a door being opened and then closed before Charlie jumps from behind her with the knife to the throat Pulling her away and then her or then him and Jill end up revealing themselves and going over their whole monologue with With Sydney revealing what their motive was and why Sydney's being targeted once again So it adds weight to that that indeed very much was I would say Kirby coming back into her house From the stab wound and she just sat there and of course they found her along the way during the events of screen 4 As for why they didn't talk about her in screen 4 for anyone who wants to use that argument when they were at the hospital That wasn't really relevant at the time to what Jill was saying Jill Yes, did make the assumption that Kirby was dead But do we in that moment didn't need to really confirm to her that you know what you that Kirby is dead Yes, the most important thing to her at the time if she was a loving cousin would have been Sydney So he was right to just focus on Sydney in that moment in my opinion Where does this leave us though in terms of what can they do in the future with Kirby read now that we know that she has Been alive for over a decade now The only real thing that would be stopping us from getting to sick I guess see more of this character bring that uniqueness and that just I Would say better Randy version that we got from her in screen 4 She was a better Randy than Randy would be Hayden pantier not being up to participate in the film now We all have noted that she does get followed on her socials by Matt and Tyler the directors radio silence So I think it's interesting to kind of say that they these three are talking to each other And I think some type of agreement was made where they said okay Hey, and we know we can't get you back in the film this time But at least let us confirm that you're alive and leave the door open so that way if you want to return You know We'll have that door open for you or even the case of Hayden just simply did not want to be back this time around But they're actively already Talking and communicating with her about getting her back in full effect for screen 6 and onward Because there's so many different things that I would like to see from Kirby read now that we know that she's alive And this is just based off of the characters that they've provided us with screen 5 So we could see her interact with the carpenter sisters Tara and Sam in some capacity and How I guess we were most likely to see these characters Interact with someone like a Kirby would be if we see them at a college setting once again The other thing I wanted to point out because I'm gonna rewatch screen 5 tonight I think people pointed out that she is one of Dewey's missed calls or at least one of his contacts at one point in the movie So that gives us an indication that there's some type of relationship that was going on there I guess briefly between Kirby and Dewey not romantically, of course But just something in terms of just keeping up to date with each other staying in the loop Dewey contacting Kirby the same way he would contact the others Maybe why he didn't contact her in this one obvious reasons Hayden wasn't in the movie, but it would also be nice to see Kirby get into some conversations with Mindy Meeks Martin Mindy again was the the Randy Kirby like character that we got this time around for screen 5 so I would love to see Kirby has some interaction with Mindy in like a recreation of a screen 2 type of scene in screen 6 in a college setting where maybe Kirby is the professor of a films films class or maybe she's even a student in that regard and Mindy and Kirby are just Going off of each other is like a fun little back-and-forth about sequels or equals sequel sequels or sequels to sequels rather but again it all will come down to whether or not Hayden Panetti air is even up for Returning to the role of Kirby in full effect because I know Hayden has been dealing with a lot of things personally and Me just being mostly a big fan of Hayden Panetti air I would rather just you know her come back in good health not come back and just want to Satisfy us don't there's no reason in coming back if you're not happy and doing what you're doing in my opinion But in terms of just Hayden getting to come back in a role That I would say a lot of people Love this character and are satisfied that she's alive It would be nice to see her first big return on the big screen be in the role of Kirby a character Who has basically become so popular with only being in one movie? I would say even she the fact that we even have her in discussions the same way they have with Randy who was in Three movies. I well, I guess you say for now I'll say three The same way that he was in so many more movies compared to Kirby Kirby was only in one But yet she's talked about in the regard as if she had the amount of screen time that Randy has Over the course of the franchise That's just speaks a lot of volumes to how well written that character wasn't just how people latched on to that character And you know, I was someone coming out of screen for I was like She was still moving and I was always kind of honing in on the fact that they did not just drop this movie on January 14 Just randomly. I knew there was some type of motives behind that that might have to do with Kirby And we got that answer in this movie. The other thing, of course, I believe at the end of the credits for screen 5 They do indeed think Hayden Pantie here So I believe there's some type of conversations going on and know a lot of people like myself included have said We'd love to see Samara weaving come into the mix Maybe be a relative of Kirby But overall it would just be nice to see Hayden back as Kirby and see what she's been up to Learn what she's been going around having interviews about maybe learn what her career Choice has been does she still watch horror movies or as she switched up to maybe liking a little bit more animated films It's like Judy Hicks one of the more comedic moments that line there for that bit of dialogue from Judy in screen 5 But there you have it. Yes Hayden Pantie air Kirby reads fate was confirmed via Easter egg That you might have overlooked if you did not look on the right side of Richie's computer screen to see his recommended videos So Kirby read is indeed alive. She survived rich. She survived Charlie and her Demented friend that would also be a nice thing Well, how has that relationship being broken with Jill affected her for the last decade or so But let me know what you guys think about Kirby's fate down the comment section below if you haven't already, of course Make sure you subscribe turn on post a case that you never miss a video in the description I have links to my social media accounts my Facebook Twitter and Instagram you can message me there Of course to let me know if there's any movies news or reviews you'd like me to cover in the future And with all that in mind guys, I will see you in the next video