 Wel, bod e dda, croeso mawr i chi gyd y diogh i'n waith eto i chi am ymuno anu bod yma. So, this is the third press conference, the leader of Plaid Cymru, Adam Price and I, have held under the auspices of the Cooperation Agreement a year since the Welsh Government and Plaid Cymru signed that agreement, an agreement made here in Wales to work together on a series of shared priorities and commitments where we believe that that cooperation can make a difference. And the importance of that cooperation has only grown as the cost of a living crisis has intensified. Today we're publishing the first annual report and here it is as you've all got a copy of it. And the report looks at what we have achieved through the Cooperation Agreement over the last 12 months. And for us, therefore, today is a chance to reflect on some of those achievements and to look back at the first year of the agreement. The agreement itself was signed against a challenging backdrop. We were still in the emergency phase of the pandemic. We were dealing then as we deal now with the long-term impact of Brexit, the climate emergency, and with the UK government determined to turn the clock back on devolution. And a year on, in many respects, these challenges remain, but now with new ones added. The pandemic may not be over, but we move beyond the emergency response and are learning how to live with the virus and with its continuing impact. Russia's unprovoked attack on Ukraine continues, but I'm thankful that we have been able to offer so many people sanctuary and security here in Wales. The cost of living crisis continues to deepen. Energy prices and inflation both rising rapidly, and the UK is now in recession and our economy is struggling. The result of the chaotic and failed policies of successive UK governments. And unfortunately, it is people in Wales who will pay the price for the UK government's many failures. But despite those difficult times, we have remained committed to the cooperation agreement. We signed the agreement in the spirit of collaboration, making a commitment to work together on areas where we agree, and where by working together we can make a difference to people who live here in Wales. And that is what we have lived out during this first year. We focused on those commitments, which will help support people during the cost of living crisis, policies and proposals that reach into the lives of people every day. And our annual report highlights what we have been able to achieve across a range of its areas. And those include taking the first steps to expand funded high quality childcare to all two year olds in Wales, introducing a new package of measures to ensure that we have vibrant communities, communities that people can afford to live in and which address high numbers of second homes concentrated in some communities here in Wales. And we've set out our proposals for a sustainable farming scheme, including details of the transition period and stability payments for farmers. I'll hand over to Adam now who will say more about the progress during the first year of the cooperation agreement. Diolch yn fawr, Prif Weinidog. Fel dywedodd, Mark, mae'r cytundeb yn dangos ffordd newydd o withio a draws ffyniau gwledyddol gan ddangos ffordd mwy gydweithredol a chad yn haol i'n ffordd ni o withio'n hymry o'i chymharu gyda'r anrefn ac anu ben dod rydyn ni wedi gweld gan Llywodraeth Sann Steffan oedd y Prif Weinidog wedi cyfeiliwad ar edrys y flwyddyn dweitha. 12 oed i gynnig yma, ond weithio gan eu rhan o'r ffyrst yn y ffordd, ond mae'r dyma'r prif wedi ystafell yn y ffordd o'i ffordd, ond mae'r anrefn a'r anrefn yn llwyddiol. I said that that agreement marked the beginning of a new way of doing politics, one that is cooperative, inclusive, forward looking and respectful. By working together over the past 12 months, cooperating and delivering, but also scrutinising and challenging each other when necessary, we're making a real difference delivering progressive and radical policies for our nation. Together, an additional 45,000 children were offered a free school lunch upon starting school this September as part of our commitment to deliver universal free school meals for all primary school children by the end of 2024. We've agreed a way forward on Senedd reform, paving the way for a more effective, more representative Senedd equal in gender elected by a fully PR based system. We've supported the work of the Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales and we'll be receiving its interim report later this month. Gada'n gilydd, rydyn ni wedi cohoedd i newidiadau arfaithedig i'r cod datganiadau o'r hyn sy'n bwysig sydd iddol i gynnwys ydysgu Hanes Cymru yn ei hol amrywiaeth yn ddi amwys fel rhan o'r curiculum newydd. Byddwn ni hefyd yn comisiwn i llunel amser o brif ddigweddiadau Hanes Cymru. Rydyn ni wedi hefyd wedi coedd i raglen o wersi Cymraeg am ddim i bobl imanc rŵn i'n dechwych a 25 mwy ddoed fel rhan o'n amdrechion i gyraedd miliwn o siaradwyr Cymraeg. Ar y cyd, rydyn ni wedi sefydlu panel arbennigol i archwilio sefydlu awdurdod daledu a chyfyddrebu cysgodol fel rhan o'n amdrechion i gryfhau democratiaeth i gair defnyddiaeth a gwneud y cyfryngen fwy plwr alaith yma yn hymru. Mae cyllid gwerth i'n ardeig miliwn wedi gyhoedd i dros y tair yn y nesaf ar gyfer raglen arfordau raglen i hybu ffyniant economaidd a'r iaith cymraeg. Dyma ymrwyniadau eang ac i chylgeisio sydd yn gwneud gwahaniaeth a draws cymru ymhob cymuned. Rwy'n edrych ymlaen at rhan i mwy o gyhoeddiadau ar ein hamrwymiadau o'r syni barhau i gydweithio ar y cytunde. We have a positive constructive relationship and as you can see from what we've been able to achieve in the first year of the agreement in a challenging and difficult context, as the First Minister said, we are working well together positively and constructively for the people of Wales. To finish, it only feels right as we mark and reflect on a year of working together that we say a huge heartfelt and sincere, sincere diolch yn fawr to our national football team who along with Awal Gogh have shown us all on the world stage what it truly means as a nation to be together stronger. Diolch yn fawr iawn i chi. Well, thank you, Adam. I think that's a great note to end on. The Welsh Government continues to be committed to working alongside and with Plaid Cymru over the next two years on the areas where we have common ground and as we have set out in the agreement. Diolch yn fawr iawn i chi. We'll now take questions. There are a number of our journalist colleagues here in the room and some on the screen and we'll alternate a bit between the two. But first of all, this morning, we're going to Felicity Evans of BBC Wales. Diolch, thank you. This is to both of you please and if you could answer bilingually to both my questions, I'd be grateful. Thank you. You've talked about the budgetary pressures and certainly Welsh Government ministers have repeatedly talked about the chunk that inflation is taking out of the Welsh Government's budget. Given that, what are the implications for the commitments in the cooperation agreement? Will you have to roll back on some of those or has it been ring-fenced? Well, the commitment we have in the agreement is that we fund the items that are in it and we've agreed the budget for those items and those budgets are preserved during the budget making process. They're discussed between us but we are committed to making sure that we continue agreed ways forward to make sure that those items have the budgets that they need. That is challenging because the quantum as a whole is shrinking but that's the path that we set out on together and we remain committed to delivering on that. Mae anoddach achos y cerddau ti ddani yn cwmpo bron bob dydd ond yr echelgau sydd tiol y cytundeb, dydyn nhw, a ddim wedi newid. Yn cytuno dygyledd am y cerddau sydd ar gael i dylifro ar popeth sydd yn y cytundeb a dydyn nhw, ddim wedi newid hered. The agreement is a three agreement and we as part of that already agreed in detail the financial provisions that were necessary in order to meet those commitments and so that is maintained even as the context has changed. Obviously through the finance committee, which is part of the mechanisms of the cooperation agreement, we endeavour to work with the Welsh Government flexibly in order to see how best we can jointly help in responding to the cost of living crisis, the pressures on public services and where flexibility is possible then obviously we are keen to facilitate that but the commitments remain the commitments they have gone through the democratic structures of our party and indeed many of them are so relevant given the cost of living pressures that many of our citizens, many of our families are facing thinking about the commitment of free school meals for example, the expansion of childcare, the problem of affordability and housing crisis. They were important issues already but they are even more important now in the context that we are dealing with. Mae'r cytundeb yn cytundeb tair blynedd ac felly rhan o'r cytundeb mi oedd yn ei eisiau swyddiad nabod ar y cyllid oedd angen i glisnodi ar gyfer delivered o ar ymryniadau hynny ac mae hynny yn aros. Wrth gwrs dyna ni trwy mecanweithiau y cytundeb a pwythgor'r cyllidol lle dyna'n trafod materion cyllidol yn rheolaeth ac lle mae'n bosib i edrych yn hyblig wrth gwrs i gynnwrthwy o Llywodraeth Cymru i ymateb i'r pwyse ychwanegol sydd ar wasanaethau cohoeddus ac ar bobl yn ymry. Dyna ni bob amser yn barod i gael ysgwrs hynny ac i helpu mewn unrhyw ffordd y galleni ond mae'r ymrymiadau yn aros ac wrth gwrs mae nhw wedi'n mynd trwy strwythyrau democratau y ddwy blyd a mae'r llaw er iawn o hwn i nhw hyd yn oed yn fwy perthnasol hefyddiw. Nag oedd yn nhw gynnwt o ran y pwyse sydd ar gymaint o dylio pan ni'n meddwl am yr ymrymiad o ran ymestu'n predua'r sgol am ddim, gofal am ddim i rhai defnyddioid a hefyd y crisis ffordd ddwyedd o fewn y sector tai felly i ni yn ymrymiadu gyd yn y llyfr o angen nhw ond i gydweithio'r lle gallwn ni hefyd wrth gwrs i ymateb i'r crisis dyn nhw yn hefyd. Mae Prysbyn Gwylun, dwi'n sgol yw o'r rhan o bryd a'i gyd-gynnalu'r lle i'r rhagoriaeth sydd wedi'i lle gofynol ac mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn gweithio'r ddweud o'r cyfrifodau. Rhaid i fynd i ond y ni gyd-golol a'r sgol iawn o'r own MS. Felly, yn gyflawni'r PBC Wales Llywodraeth Llywodraeth Cymru yma, yna heddiw i'r ardal yn gweithio'r ardal i'r proses i'r proses i'r cerddau a'r cyfrifodd o ddargiwn o wneud hynny. raised others to do the same. And she chose her words very carefully when she was asked, if she had confidence in the way that the leadership was handling all of this, if there is a toxic culture in Plaid Cymru, is that not the responsibility of you as leader and to Mr Drakeford, to what extent is all of this casting a shadow over the deal that you've done with Plaid Cymru in the Cooperation Agreement? Ac ydych chi'n clywed ar gyfer y cyfrannu ysgrifennu fel ysgrifennu, ac rwy'n meddyliadau i'r bwysig ymddangos ar y cyfrannu, oedd y fforddau sydd ymgyrch yn cael y ffordd o'r gwaith o'r cyffredinol yn ymgylch. Mae'r ffordd â'r bydd ar gyfer y cyfrannu, ac mae'r ffordd yn cael eu rhaid â'r ffordd. Roedd o'n cael ei wneud hynny. First of all, I want to emphasise that the well-being of all of our staff and all of our members is of the highest importance to us as a party and to me as leader. We've acted quickly in response to the media reports and have offered all of our staff appropriate support and various range of fora in which they can share their experiences confidentially. We want to, we want the party, we're committed to the party embodying the best values and if this exercise demonstrates things we need to improve or to address, then we will not hesitate in doing so. As I previously said, and for reasons that you understand, I can't comment on any ongoing process at this stage and I'm quite rightly not privy to them. But the party takes all allegations seriously, as do I. As a party we operate on the basis that if and when there is evidence of wrongdoing following the outcome of any process, the party will deal appropriately with the issues and do so in line with its disciplinary procedures. There will come a time when I can address these matters more fully but that's all that I'm able to say at this point for the reasons that I've already explained. Yn y teriol fel byddwch chi'n deall, ma hwn yn gynadledd sydd yn ffocos i ar gyllideb chi dwythio a lle dynnu'n, wrth gwrs, yn canolbwyntio ar y polis i es i'n eu cymryd yw waniaeth i bobl cymryd, ond oni wedi ragweld fel lle bydd y materion yma yn cael eu codi, felly mae'n rhaipeth edrych eisiau gweud y borymau i chi gyd. Yn y lle cyntaf yw eisiau pwysleisio bod lesiant yn holl staff, yn holl eilodau, o'r pwysigrwydd mwyau i ni fel pwyd ac i fi fel yr weinydd. Nethwn i ymateb a gweithredi yn gyflim yn oedd ymateb i'r adroddiadau sydd i bod yn y cyfrannu a dynnu'n ei cynnig i'n snaf gyfnogeth bryodol sydd angen arnyn nhw a hefyd astod o lwybrau ac o ffora lle gallen nhw rannu a'u profiadau yn gybrinachol. I ni yn ymrwymedig bod y blaid yn ardal yr gwerthoedd gore ac os ydi yr amarferiad yma yn adnabod pethau mae rhaid i ni fynd i rhafel gyda nhw neu pethau mae rhaid i ni wella i'n mynd fyddwn ni yn bendant yn ei dynnu. Fel ydydd i gweithio eich os, dwy ddim yn bosib ac i fi gweith mwy ynglyn â genryw achos unigol ar y pwynt yma. Ymrysiau me fydd yn ddeallant o'i dwy ddim ac mewn ylion ar ymchwiliadau hynny ac a hynny ymrysiau me bryodol. Ond rwy'n amddwyd hyn, wrth gwrs, fel blaid i ni cymryd pob honiad, pob cincern sy'n cael ei godi pob prader o ddifri ac i ni'n gweithredu fel blaid ar y sael. Os os na dystio lef o gam ddwy'n ar ôl fel canlyniad proses o ymchwiliad byddwn ni wedyn ni yn sicr yn ymateb yn bryodol ac yn delio gyda ni ac yn unol gyda'n prosesau disgyblaethol. Mi fydd na amser lle bydd môl ymateb yn lawnach i'r materion yma ond am yr ysmyd dwi eisiau swyddi arall ni a dyma'r cobl dwi'n medri dweud hynny. Mae'n dweud yn ymweld i'r cymryd ar y cymryd anul yn ymweld â'r lleidol yn ymweld. Mae'r cymryd yn ymweld i'n medri dweud hynny, mae'n ymweld i'r cymryd yn ymweld i'r cymryd yn ymweld i'r cymryd,ёт, wych juliaethu ymgylchedd ar gyfer hashwr gweithraeth i gweithio llefnodau mewn mynd i mewn cyfanydd i gweithio'r gwahanol yma, yr hyn sy'n ddysgu'r gweithraeth ei wir yn ei chwarae a ddim i'r gweithraeth am rwyf yn y cymryd gweithraeth, yn mynd i gweithraeth i gael eu tîr ymddangos yn eithaf i gweithraeth i gael上面 yma, ac rwy'n gweithraeth i gweithraeth i gweithraethu eithaf i gweithraeth Felly, rhaid i'r ffocos o'r ysgol iawn, o hynny yn fawr o'r dweud yw'r ddechrau. Mae'n rhaid i'r fawr o'r content o'r casg. Mae'r ddiwrnod o ddweud y fawr o'r ddiwrnod o ddweud, i ddweud y ddefnyddio. Mae'r materau sy'n rhoi i ddim yn fawr o'r ddweud o'r disgusio'n fawr o'r ddweud. Pan oeddwn i'n edrych ar y cynnwys o'r adroddiad blynyddol, beth oedd yn taro fi oedd sy'n gymaint o gwaith galed sy'n tiol cynnwys ar adroddiad. Mae'r Lodau'r Cabaned Fi ac pobl sy'n rhan o'r proses arwch o'r Plaid Cymru yn digwydd bob othnos yn trafod pethau a'n fanol i edrych da'r gilydd a'r polisiau sy'n allunio roi pethau arwaith. A mae hwnna'n mynd ymlaen yn y cyfarfodydd dwi'n cael gyda Adam Pricefell ar weynydd Plaid Cymru hefyd, a dyna beth ni'n ganw'n bwyntio arno cynnwys ar Cytindeb a sut allwn ni'n ei wahaniaeth yma yn Cymru, a pethau tifasol ar Cytindeb mae hwnna ddim wedi cael effaith ar y gwaith ni'n wedi'n ei ddigwydd o gwbl. Diolch, Felisli. Dwi'n gwybod i'n gwybod i'n Caity, Caity Fenton, gyda ITV Wales, ond mae'n gweithio. Thank you. Good morning. You've had this agreement this week, over the idea of a well specific COVID inquiry. To both of you, is that the sort of disagreement that could knock your cooperation agreement and to Adam Price, which holding such an inquiry would be something you'd want to see if you renew the partnership after 2024? Well, just to rehearse the origins of the cooperation agreement, we made a very deliberate decision that what we would do would be to identify a very particular number of specific areas on which we would agree and then we would take those forward together, and we're both committed to doing those things in cooperation in the way we've described today. Everything else that lies beyond it is politics as usual, in which my party and Adam's party are free to take our different views, to debate them robustly as we do, and the fact that there are things that we don't agree on does not make any difference to the things which we were able to agree on and put into the cooperation agreement. That's how we deliberately designed our relationship to work. I think we've managed to do that very successfully, and the inquiry issue is one on which we have different views, but there are many others and that does not intrude on our ability to work together where we were able, through months of detailed negotiation, to come to an agreement of the sort we've been describing this morning. Yes, if I can answer your questions, Katie, as well, the question of a Wales-specific COVID inquiry is one where there is honest disagreement between us as parties, and it is, as the First Minister said, clearly outside of the cooperation agreement, and in areas which are outside of the agreement, of course we are free to disagree, indeed we had a debate this week where we debated the merits of following a different route through having a Senate Special Purpose Committee set up as some means of achieving the intent of a Wales-specific inquiry. I know that the First Minister said that the government is now going to produce his proposals, and we look forward to engaging constructively with those, but our position has always been and remains that the best solution would be for us in Wales to hold a Wales-specific inquiry so that we can learn the lessons as quickly as possible because the likelihood is that at some point we are going to be facing another pandemic at some point. We can't predict when, can't we? We need to learn those lessons, yes, at the UK level, but we think there is an important need for a Wales-specific inquiry. That will remain our position now. If there hasn't been a Wales-specific inquiry by 2024, that will be your position then as well, but we would like it to happen sooner. Thank you, and I'd like to turn to the nurses' strike and as of yesterday, ambulance strike. First Minister, your critics accuse you of hiding behind questions about UK government funding. What do you say to them, and Mr Price, do you agree with the First Minister that his hands are tied when it comes to public sector pay? Well, let me just be clear again about the position. The Barnett formula means that the money that comes to Wales, 80% of it, is determined by decisions that English ministers have on English priorities, and that certainly means that the money that comes to us to cover public sector pay awards is determined by the decisions that are made by English ministers in their context. If they settle for 4%, we get 4%. If they settle for 5%, we get 5%. There is no more money that comes to Wales other than the money that comes through the formula in that way. Now, there is a choice to be made, which is that you could take money from other places to pay people more. We have looked very carefully at all of that. The money we have to sustain our health service, our education service, our social care services, the housing services, all the things that people rely on and make a difference in people's lives are squeezed already by over a decade of austerity. We could pay a smaller number of people more, but that is what the choice would be. There is no money in the Welsh budget to go beyond what we have been able to offer as a consequence of recommendations of independent pay review bodies and the decisions made on funding them. So it is not hiding behind anything. It is simply a reflection of the reality of the way in which the Welsh Government is funded. Those are the very pernicious choices that we face. Our feeling is that we cannot rob our public services in order to move money into pay awards, which are not being funded by the UK Government at a level which we believe they should be funded. We should make that clear. We believe that our public sector workers ought to be paid properly. We are just not in the position to do that unilaterally given the way our budgets are constructed. I will reiterate our public position that we believe it is important to improve on the current pay offers that have been offered to our public service workers in the NHS and also in education. We think that the pay offers that are significantly below inflation at the current time will have a long term, as well as having a very direct immediate impact on those workers and their families at a very difficult time for everyone in the cost of living crisis. We will have a long term impact on morale, on recruitment and retention and ultimately we will all suffer as a result of the deterioration which will happen in our public services. We think that every lever, every tool should be utilised in order to, as best we can in Wales, give them a very difficult financial context that the Welsh Government is created for the Welsh Government by the intransigence and short termism at Westminster. We still believe that the Welsh Government can do more and as indeed the Scottish Government has been able to do more and more repeatedly, I think the First Minister is right to say that there are always trade-offs and these trade-offs are not easy but we believe that we would want to see improved pay offers offered to public service workers and we have repeatedly suggested. In terms of their impact on next year because obviously there is always a read across and improved pay offer this year has to be carried into next year, it has implications over further years but one of the tools available to us of course is the use of income tax powers and we have been absolutely clear that we think that those powers need to be actively explored in this context but all of this of course is outside of the cooperation agreement and that is why we are free to have a reasonable and respectful disagreement and debate and we continue to engage with the Welsh Government on these matters in the hope that there will be some movement in the direction of those workers that are on strike and those that may are likely to join them in the next few weeks. Diolch yn fawr, Bactel Rhywm, a'r dechlefod ar balla midia. Thank you, so the needs of the Welsh people 12 months ago have changed from now. We now have the cost of living crisis which no-one could have predicted 12 months ago. Over the next 12 months, have your ambitions of this co-op agreement changed to help people across Wales? Well, thanks for the question, Clare. The cost of living crisis and its impact upon people at the length and breadth of Wales and communities and indeed on the public services is right at the forefront of our minds and I think I can say that jointly with the First Minister. Clearly, as I've already said, many of the elements of the co-operation agreement are of direct relevance to people that are struggling to pay their bills at the moment, thinking about particularly the expansion of the universal free school meals through all primary aged children. That has had already a massive impact on so many families at the breadth of Wales and the fact that we've been able to do that at pace, given the very, very challenging circumstances, given everything else that is the backdrop to this, I think is huge credit to all of those involved. I mean, it's nothing less than a national mission and if you speak to people who work in catering services in schools, if you speak to teachers and head teachers, et cetera, and teaching assistants, all of them who have had a role and feel part of this, you can see that they understand how important it has been to deliver it at pace and similarly with those other elements as well on the housing affordability crisis with the pressure that we are seeing in so many communities in different ways across Wales, the fact that we've been able to implement these policies and will continue working on the next stage, I think shows that we realise that in the context of the cost of living crisis, now is not the time to let up, now is the time to accelerate as fast and as far as we can delivering on these key commitments that make such a difference to so many families who are struggling at the moment. Well, just echo what Adam has said, the things we've managed to achieve in the first year of a co-operation agreement include a whole series of things that have a direct impact upon people's ability to manage during the cost of living crisis, the free school meals that Adam has drawn attention to, the expansion of a childcare offer, we know the cost of childcare are often an enormous barrier for families wanting to get into work and employment, which is why we've extended it to people who are on the cusp of employment as well as expanding it to two-year-olds and there's more to come. It's a three-year agreement, it's inevitable that some things happen in the first year and some things will happen later on in the agreement, we're committed to reform of the council tax in Wales, a genuinely regressive tax where there are measures we think we can take together to make it a less regressive tax and therefore to help those people for whom the impact of the council tax is greatest and eats into the money they have for other purposes. So, not only are there things that we've done already, but there's more to come and it's very much in that cost of living space. The Welsh Conservatives have called this co-op agreement nothing more than a vanity project saying you're not focusing on things that matter, focusing on the NHS in Wales as a key example of that. What would your response be to that? I think for you, Adam, they've also said that being in this agreement you've abdicated your role as genuine opposition in the centre. What do you say to that? They would say that anyway, wouldn't they? I think what we've been able to demonstrate is that we have taken the mandate that we received from the people of Wales at the election in 2021 and actually we've made a difference in people's lives. Politics ultimately is about leaving society better than when you've found it. It's actually acting on behalf of people that are struggling as we've described rather than just performing politics. It's not meant to be just a debating society, is it? It's meant to be actually making a practical difference to people's lives. So, how is it a vanity project? I've seen the reference to naval gazing. The kind of things that we're talking about this morning, the things we've achieved just in these last 12 months have made a huge real difference to people right across the length and breadth of Wales. With the greatest of respect to the Conservative group in the Senedd, this is what the Senedd was created to do. It's actually to make a difference. Even yes, parties who disagree in some areas and we've rehearsed plenty of them today and we've been honest about that and it hasn't prevented us from engaging part of the ordinary engagement of politics where we disagree, we do that. But that doesn't mean that you can't identify areas of common ground where working together you could make a huge difference to the people of Wales and I'm proud that we take that approach to politics and I think when you speak to people actually that's what they want to see. Why don't you all work together? Why don't you work together and get things done? That's what people want from their politicians, not the sort of Yabu Westminster kind of theatre of politics. They want practical, progressive differences in their lives and that's what we're delivering to the cooperation agreement. Can there be anything more miserable in political life than being a Welsh Conservative? To have turned your back on any prospect of developing policies and a relationship with the Welsh people that means you might one day find yourself elected to government and instead can find always just to criticising what other people do. So my party has had the enormous privilege of winning elections here in Wales and having the opportunity to do the things that you want to do. I so much agree with Adam. The only purpose that I've ever thought of being in politics is to be able to put into practice the things that you believe can make a difference to people who live here in Wales and that's what the cooperation agreement is about, where we are able to agree it allows two parties to bring that motivation together in practical action and that's what we try to do in everything that you see in this report and I think you've heard already this morning a whole series of areas where we don't agree and where we have a respectful but robust ability to rehearse the reasons why we come to different conclusions so I think the cooperation agreement enables us, as Adam says, to do what people ask us to do which is to work together wherever we can but not to stand back from having a debate about things where there are differences of view between us. Claire, thank you very much. So a special welcome today on the screen this time to David Nicholson joining us for the first time from the Morning Star. Thank you. It's a good thing for the newspaper industry in Wales which is having a very bad time at the moment and so I have one question for you both and it's on the budget really for the shadow broadcasting authority. We know in Wales the newspaper industry is particularly weak. It's been weakened in recent months by the closure of the Corgi Welsh news agency and also before that by the closure of the national. The cooperation agreement sets out a budget of some £1 million to look at setting up a shadow broadcast authority which is in the gift that the Westminster Government would do both in the light of the huge rise in newspaper print costs and all the other costs facing the Welsh media. Look at shifting some of that budget into an area in newspapers where you do have the powers to make a difference. Well, can I just say David, great news about your appointment with the Morning Star and I think any addition to the pluralism, plurality of our media in Wales I think is very welcome indeed and that really is at the core of this commitment in our cooperation agreement because actually media broadcasting journalism including newspapers are a vital part of our democratic infrastructure and we need to invest in our democratic infrastructure. If people, you cannot have democracy without an informed citizenry. It is absolutely core part of our democratic structure and so that's why we have given it due prominence in the cooperation agreement. We look forward to the report and advice that we will receive from the expert panel in this area and we'll consider the recommendations that they make to us and we'll respond subsequently to that. In the meantime it doesn't mean that we aren't investing money directly in the future of Welsh journalism. It's a tricky area. I think it needs careful thinking through as we try to. Government money into journalism is a line there somewhere that you need to be on the right side of but throughout the pandemic and since we provide funds to help with hyperlocal journalism and to create the infrastructure in which there is a vibrant future for journalism here in Wales. There is a genuine democratic interest in making sure that that happens without ever wanting to be in a position where it looks as though government money is in any way influencing the job the journalists do. Thank you David. I think we go back into the room in that case and to Dan Bevan. Brindau. Thank you very much. Can I start by asking yourself a question? If I can get the answer in Welsh and English it would be very grateful. You initially wanted an inquiry in Westminster to visit Wales to have elements in Welsh. That doesn't look like it's going to happen. You still didn't want the inquiry. We've heard from the chair that we are not going to have quite as fully scrutinised elements as would have wanted. That has not changed your mind either. Now your party in the Senate has voted down a committee to fill the gaps. It does bear the question, what have you got to hide? First of all Dan, I don't think you're right on the first thing that you said. If you look at the website of the inquiry it's been very careful to make sure that the material is available in Welsh as well as English in the very first visit that the chair of the committee made outside London was to come here to Wales. So I think there is good direct evidence of the determination of the inquiry to pay full regard to Wales and to make sure that those people in Wales who look to that inquiry to give the answers to their questions but the committee will operate in a way that gives them confidence about that. It is much better that the chair of the inquiry speaks directly for herself but I think that some of what she said has been overinterpreted. I think she was making a much simpler point that no inquiry into anything can give a guarantee that it will pursue every single question put to it and hear from every single person that might want to give oral evidence to it. I don't think she was making points more than that. As to what happened in the Senate yesterday, I explained that the government was prepared to accept the argument that if the committee doesn't manage to explore all the issues that are important to us in Wales and isn't able to offer answers to the questions that people will have that at that point there would be a case for a special purpose committee to fill in any gaps. The problem is we cannot possibly come to that conclusion when the committee hasn't even begun its work, let alone reported. How would you know what those gaps were? How would you know what answers have not been provided at this point? What I want to do is to think carefully about how you can identify whether there is work that a special purpose committee might do and then to be able to make that work happen when we know where those gaps would be and where we know where those lessons would need to be drawn. I didn't feel that the proposition yesterday was able to answer those questions fully. The government will bring forward a proposition of our own when we have had that opportunity to think it through properly taking into account the things that were said in the debate yesterday. Wel, dros i ddweud, dwi'n meddwl mae'r angrwyl ac derydd a'r angrwyliad mai nhw yn mynd ati mewn ffordd sy'n gallu o'r hoi hader i bobl angymru mai nhw yn ymwybodol am pethau sy'n pwysig i ni am y angymru ac i'n mynd at y gwaith mewn ffordd fe mae pobol yma angymru yn gallu defnyddio'r pwyllgor i creu am atebion i'r pethau sy'n pwysig i ni yma angymru. A ddweud a thawr y cynlluniad wedais i, a os bydd bwlchau yn codi yn y gwaith ac mae barnes halet angarwain os mae hwnna'n digwydd, a ni'n fodlon i cefnogi'r pwyllgor arbenig i mynd ar ôl a bwlchau sydd wedi dod ymlaen. Ar hyn o bryd am ymarni, mae'n amhosibol i bod yn glir os bydd bwlchau a ble bydd bwlchau. A ble bydd awersin ni ddim wedi cael y cyfle i fysgu. So wedais i ar thawr y cynlluniad, bydd y Llywodraeth yn mynd i dod yn ôl, gyda'r awgrymiadau, ni'n mynd i gweithio'n gallu i feddwl am ffordd gorau am lan ac allwn ni rhoi ar awgrymiadau na oflaen y cynlluniad i cael ddadl ar beth bydd am arferol i'r unrhyw bwyllgor y Senedd, neud y gwaith o'r pobl a ofyn amdano a ddweud sef i llennu unrhyw bwlchau. Felly mae'r pergyntau i feddwl am sydd allwn i gwybod ble bydd y bwlchau yn y ancodi. Dyna beth dwi'n isio feddwl amdano. Dyna eich cynlluniad am y cyfnoddau a'r drwyfio o'r cyfnoddau a'r cyfnoddau. Felly mae'n ddiddordeb sydd wedi'u gwawddiaeth i gael y ddweud y cwyrdd Cymru, y ddweud y ddweud y ddweud y cyfnoddau ddweud a'r cyfnoddau yn gyllideb yn y Senedd. Y meddwl am y cyflosio yma i gyfrifio'r ddiweddol i'r cymdeithasol a'r cyfrifio'r gwyrdd Cymru was an attempt to find a compromise, I think. We look forward, as I said, to engaging constructively with the government in their response to this proposal. I'm wondering whether part of the issue is timing, because the First Minister has alluded to this in relation to their analysis, but waiting right until the end to the final report does risk, I think, losing some of the currency of information, the issues in terms of institutional memory, and how do we preserve those over this longer timescale? One potential approach, given that the inquiry itself is taking a phased approach to different aspects of its inquiry as to whether gaps can be identified not at the end of the process, but whether we could do that gap identification as the inquiry itself goes through those different phases, which would allow us to have full sight of what the inquiry has covered, at least, while not waiting right until the end for us to begin our complementary inquiry in Wales. So, I'll leave that there, and we're happy to have any constructive discussion with the Welsh Government on this matter. Thank you, I appreciate that. First Minister, you've come back from Cattel now, been back in Wales for about a week. Have you got a rough idea of how much that trip might have cost to the taxpayer, and how can you ensure that it is going to be value for money? And for yourself, Mr Price, on this question, you were very vocal before the First Minister flew out there regarding the World Cup. I wonder if your opinions may have changed now that the First Minister has returned from his trip, and you've been able to see what you've been doing while you're out there? Well, I don't have the figures immediately to hand, but I'm confident that they will be significantly less. We've counted everything that the Welsh Government has done. It will cost us less than, for example, the installation that the UK Government provided to represent the United Kingdom at the World Cup. We can give you the figures as soon as they are finally tabulated. The return on the investment, you won't see it immediately. You never do these sort of things. I previously gave the example when I went to the Rugby World Cup. There was a delegation of businesses alongside me when I made that visit. It's months later that you find out whether or not the contacts that have been made turn into actual contracts and things. We do that every time. Every time we have a mission of that sort, we track it over three months, over six months and beyond, and are able to always, I think, demonstrate that the investment that we make in supporting Welsh businesses in that way pays off many times. I am sure that the investment we made, which was not confined to football, but had cultural aspects to it, economic aspects to it, as well as being there to speak up for the values that matter to us here in Wales, and to be part of that ongoing debate that was certainly very prominent in the whole time that I was in Qatar, the investment that we will have provided has enabled us to advance Welsh interests on a stage where Wales was in the living rooms of five billion households right across the world, and you certainly can't pay for that in conventional advertising and other spend. Oh, yeah. Well, of course, ar ariann ni wedi bydd sodi i cernogi bobl o'r Llywodraeth i fynd i gyta, ni'n gallu cyhoedd i, ffant ni wedi wario ar dwy'n hedderus. Rwy'n hedderus fel ni'n neud pethau fel hyn bob tro ar ariann ni wedi bydd sodi, ni'n mynd i cael ar ariann na nôl tro ar ôl tro, ni'n dijust yn ymais fel droid, wrth gwrs, ond popeth arall oedd ni'n neud pan oedd ni'n draw angytda, a ges i y cyfle i mynd i'r amgueddfa hetifeddiaeth muslamiaid, ac i creu perthannais rungo nôl ac ar amgueddfa genedlaethol am yng Nghymru, iddw i'n edrych ymlaen i croesawu, a grŵp o menywod i fanc sy'n gweithio yn ymais na'r angytda nôl yma i gymeri an ar haf y flwyddyn nesa. Ac oedd ni'n gallu siarad mwyna maes hynny hefyd, wrth gwrs, yn y maes economaidd. A porpas i fynd i gyta oedd i cefnogi'r y tîm Gymru, i cefnogi enw Gymru, enw Gymru oedd trwy'r byd i gyd, trwy'r mynd ar lwyfan a cupan y byd, a dwi'n hedderis bydd hwnna ymynd i fod i arw, a'n werth i Gymru dros y bydd yn y ddoeth i ddod. I think that the best ambassadors for Wales of all at this World Cup, and I'm sure the first minister wouldn't disagree with this, were the fans, weren't they? I mean they've much as, you know, Iceland supporters have won the hearts at other competitions. I think if there was a competition for the best anthem, I think we'd win it, but also the way in which the Welsh fans have supported their team, you know, the enthusiasm, the choil, maybe that has entered the world lexicon in the same way the crack as in the context of the Irish, they've done us proud, haven't they? And the football association and everything leading up and the way they've encapsulated who we are as a nation and who we want to be. And I think they have lifted our spirits, but I think they've done a bit to lift spirits more generally as well. I think, I understand, I accept that it was a difficult decision, and so I wouldn't criticise the first minister, but I think it was the wrong decision to go myself personally. I can understand the rationale and it's a difficult judgment, because, you know, that opportunity was important to grasp, to project Wales. Was it necessary for ministers to be there? I'm not convinced, and I think we should have made a symbolic, important symbolic stance by not being there and sending a powerful message in terms of our values in that way. Particularly, I think, with the hardening of rhetoric that happened, and I know the first minister and the economy have criticised some of the silence of FIFA at various times, and then worse than the silence, you know, the absolutely horrendous remarks made by the FIFA president on the cusp of the beginning of the game, and then the appalling scenes and the way in which LGBTQ plus supporters and their allies were treated in relation to rainbow bucket hats, etc. Given all of that, I think it would have been better for us not to have had ministers there representing us in an official capacity, but I understand that, you know, there are difficult judgment calls that individuals had to make, but if we boycotted the Iran game and showed that we did believe that actually boycotts in relation to human rights have an important, by-ministers have an important symbolic power, then I don't really understand why that boycott was not actually general across all three games. Jotan, back to the screen, and welcome back to Tom Magna. Thank you very much indeed, First Minister. Sorry about the music behind me, my relocation, not by choosing. Can I just ask you all to say you're celebrating, that's the right word, a year of the Cooperation Agreement. Where do unpaid carers stand in all this? Because we're all familiar with the figure that 96% of care in Wales is provided by unpaid carers. They describe it to me as a dilution of compassion and commitment these days from, say, the start of a pandemic. Where is the common ground? What are the priorities? What action will be seen in the next year to both of you please? Yeah, well I don't think celebration is a bad word. Tom, because I think there is a lot to be proud of in what we've been able to do together over the last year. Carers responsibilities remain outside the main part of the agreement, but I don't think there would not be common ground between us on the key policies that we would like to be able to take forward. So the extra investment in respite care would be shared, I think, between us. The way in which we have been able to provide additional funding for some carers, encouraging carers to be registered for that purpose as part of our cost of living funds. So wanting to do more to support unpaid carers would be common ground between us. Yes, and just to add to that, Tom, and I know that you and I are still due to have a longer conversation and look forward to that, where we can touch on some of these issues in greater depth. But yes, I mean, we share the sense of importance that we need to place an increased importance on the role of unpaid carers, and we need to pursue all the avenues which are available to us in order to improve on the current situation. In the context, that specifically, as the First Minister said, is outside of the cooperation agreement, but obviously the national care service is a very, very important element within the agreement. In fact, I would venture to say that probably in terms of the longer term impact of the cooperation agreement, it is possibly one of the most important elements of all because it will have the national care service created based on the principles of parity between the NHS and the national care service in terms of the workforce, but also a care service based on the NHS principle of being free at the point of need. That has the potential to have a transformative impact across generations. I think one of the questions for us that you raised, Tom, quite rightly, is what is the impact of a national care service on unpaid carers. There are interesting examples across Europe as to how progressive professional care systems, if I can put it in those terms, work positively in a complementary way, working with and recognising the absolutely central role of unpaid carers in a more substantive and substantial way than we have been able to hitherto, and certainly we'd be very, very interested in having a conversation with you as to how that national care service could improve the lot of unpaid carers that we rely on so much as a society. Thank you for that. Can I just pick up on this theme of the national care service? Forgive me for saying this, but haven't you already got a national care service with the nearly 400,000 unpaid carers across Wales with all the skills of being able to juggle work and caring and sleep and trying to get a balance between all of that? They're on duty 365 days a year, 24-7, without any breaks really, so if you believe you've got a national care service, why can't that be moulded into your thinking on that, again to both of you? Well, Tom, I think you heard Adam say that we are very keen to do just that to make sure that that enormous contribution is moulded into our thinking about a national care service, but the unpaid carers are a very, very important element in that, but they're not the only element in that. There are all the things that our care workforce do every day in Wales. We need to capture that, and that isn't on a national basis. As you know, it's distributed amongst the 22 local authorities, and an awful lot of it is provided by private companies as well. So we have the report of the expert group that we set up. There are lots of things in that that we are able to build on straight away. There are some elements of it we are having to look at because the landscape has changed even while the expert group were reporting. The UK government has decided not to go ahead with its arrangements for a direct rising national insurance contributions and funding for social care, and it's decided not to go ahead with the Boris Johnson version of the Dilnot review. Those are pretty fundamental changes in the broader landscape. They do have a direct impact here in Wales. There are aspects of the expert group that we will have to think of in that change context, but there are alongside those things some very practical and immediate measures that we're going to be able to draw on as a result of that work, and that will include that interface between unpaid and paid for care. I see David Cameron today saying that there should be a social insurance system for care. It begs the question, where were you for six years when you were in government and you could have made it happen? But to reiterate my earlier point, I think the interrelationship, the positive interrelationship between a national care service constituted along the lines that I set out earlier, and the role of unpaid carers I think is an absolutely central question, and there are some interesting examples across the world in Germany, in Japan etc, where there has been interesting attempts at complementarity between unpaid carers and the role of unpaid carers and supporting them and harnessing that, but doing so in a way that recognises their important role. As you say Thomas, part of effectively a national care system which doesn't just include the professional public service, but also clearly, and I know this from my own family experience that I've talked about previously relies upon heroic efforts by many many people, you know, the length and breadth of Wales. Joe Tom, thank you very much. Akinola, Heady a la screen, James Williams, BBC. Wydda i gynnwys nathganiad y Llyfrgef am y tybal cynnolig o ran gwariant y Cohoeddus, ac yn rhaid hiol Llyfrgeidol. Mi oeddech chi'n aros i weld byddwodd syniadau'r defnydd o'r defnydd o'r angar iawn i gwrs mewn cymdeithasol, byddwn i'n affyn nhw fydda'n pynnig mewn ysgrifianth pynnig leiddiol, mae hynny wedi mynd ar gynnwys hyn. O sy'n, ydweun amser nawr felly chi ail ystyried o ddifryd syniad o dreth penodol ar gyfer gweld cyntyddasol yma yng Nghymru. Mae pobl wedi bod yn gael lŵr yn ychynig eidysbysaibl eidyn. Wel, dych yn fawr, y Jamesville wedi oes i'n arateb o la i Tom. Mae'r cydesaeth i'n wedi a newid ac os mae'r penderfyniadau y Llywodraeth a'n San Steffan wedi newid hefyd. Mae dyna pam ni yn mynd nôl i ailfeddwl am rai o'r pethau, mae'r pwyllgor arbennig wedi dweud atoni ac os mae'r cydestun wedi newid yn y ffordd chi'n wedi dweud. Dwi'n meddwl mae hynny yn golygu bydd yn pwysig i mynd nôl at y gwaith, y gwaith galed o'r Llywodraeth a bobl tifas o'r Llywodraeth wedi neud yn y tymor dweithla ar y syniadau oedd wedi dod atoni i weld os mae'n posibl i creu rhywbeth wahanol yma yng Nghymru a system wahanol hefyd. A challenge bob tro eu, a perthynas rŵng bydd ni'n neud fynd hyn yng Nghymru ac y systemau, systemau bydd dalyadau ac yn y blant i dalyfod yn dwylo San Stefan. So mae'n gymleth dyna pam oeddwn ni'n meddwl ei wneud y gwaith a'r ôl yn yw'r diadau Wel pethau mae'n nhw wedi tyni nôl arno yn San Stefan bydd rhaid i ni mynd nôl at y gwaith na i weld os Llywodraeth fynd i'r ffordd yn lan i ni yma yng Nghymru. So James was asking me about the changes that the UK government has made, or the reversals in many ways, or the policies they had announced for funding social care and did that mean that we needed here in Wales to go back to some of the ideas that were previously being explored about for example a social care lefi of our own and I simply said that the change context at the UK level does mean that we're looking again at some of the work of the expert group. The relationship between decisions we make in Wales in social care and things that are not devolved remains complicated and challenging you know we can do things that would mean they would get people will get more money from the Welsh government and lose money through the benefit system making in the end them no better off which is why the detailed work has to be done but I believe myself that the case has strengthened for us going back to that work that was done in the last century term and to see whether it offers us an alternative way of resolving some of these dilemmas in Wales. Mae dros ddigawd wedi bod oed i ddi tro pedol ar o tro pedol a dim sy'n mybl an o gobwl o gyfeirio at San Steffan ond oes, mynd cofio. Yn fyrm lwyth i'n olaf i'n San Steffan i gyd, yw'r Andy Burnham wedi caisio cael rhyw fath o consensus a draws y pleidiau i gan gyda'n nabod hynny'n i'w mwyn yn un o'r pethau, mae'r rhaid i ni ddatrus ar y cyd a mae'r rhaid i ni gael ddatrus i ydyma oedd y cydwaith wedi gwrthod hynny ond wedi ni nith yn ôl cael yr adilagio dylnot a wedi ni oedd gwrthod hynny a nawr wedi ni'n tro pedol ar y lef i arfaithedig fel o'r prifedig o gweld i gweud a hefyd ar i fersiwn nhw a o'r cap a'r goste. Felly dim sy'n mybl an o gobwl dedd y dywedig wedi pasio yn y cyfamser, gyda'r rhai o ran y sector gofal, gyda'r rhai yn llwygur, gyda'r rhai nodau digon cloddiw, ond dim adnoddau oedd gwrs er mwyn cyrraedd at y nodau hynny, felly dyna ni'n dal yn yr un man, felly allwn ni ddim dybyni ar sandsdiffan a ni dwi'n ddigon flir, felly mae'n rhai dynnu oedd yn hynny. Wel, beth dynnu yn gwrthod neud yn hyn yn y gwaglet yma a dwi yn cytuno. Oherwydd bod y cydesaf wedi newid yn ni ddiolgar iawn a gwaith y grwp arbenigol, ond bydd rhaid i ni ddechwylid nawr at y gwaith hynny oherwydd bod y cydesaf wedi newid, ond hefyd ddechwylid at y gwaith blaenorol gan athro Jerry Holtham i weld adi hynny nawr yn cynnig ffordd ymlaen i ni, tra'n bod sandsdiffan o hyd ac o hyd yn troi mewn cilchwyd. We've basically had Westminster over more than a decade, just continually moving in circles, u-turn after u-turn, no progress. The health and care levy is the latest of those u-turns. There was a famous u-turn doing an election campaign, as I seem to recall when Theresa May was Prime Minister as well. But there's been no progress, and I think what I think we have to conclude is that if we wait for Westminster to come up with a sustainable solution to their social care challenges, to the crisis in social care there, then we will be waiting possibly forever. So I think that we do now need to obviously re-examine some of the excellent work done as part of this agreement by the expert panel, whether the context has clearly changed. But I think we do need to revisit some of the ideas which were proposed in an earlier report at earlier stages by Professor Holtham to see whether that, in conjunction with some of the ideas that the expert panel referred to, is the way forward on a sustainable basis for the kind of national care service that we want to create as we look to produce our implementation plan by the end of next year. A wedyn chi eisiau sydd wedi bod yn trafod yn gydest i'n arianol mae'r polisiu sydd yn llan o'r cynllun, chi dweud dredi yma wedi cael eu gwarchod, i cael ei debynwyd, i cael eu gwarchod, maen nhw'n gilygu fydd yna bwysau ar bethau i ymraes, mae'n cael ei debyn braf sy'n dod y ben wrthnosau nesaf o'r gyfer yr arianol, lwyth i'n nesaf. A fch chi, adonbrae sydd wedi bod yn galw am sawl wrthnosaf ar y syniad yma o dreth solidariaeth, cynnydd mewn yn y dreth i'n gwybod yn mwyn clenwyr rhai o'r bylchau hynny, gyllideb a llefydd fel fydd yna fwy o arianol gyfer gweithwyr yn y sector gohoeddus ac yn y blan. Ym eisiau dref yn ddaeth o chi eich grwp chi yn y syniad cyfnogi'r syniad o ogynydd o beth o'r etyniog yn y gyfradd iwch a'r cyfnogi yn y gyfradd o'ch wneigol, beth yw saf o'n rhai cyfriad hynny o bryd o ran ymbynod o beth fydd ydyledig wedi gwedd y dreth yng Nghym. Ac wedyn i'n march drig fydd, fydd yw'r fydd o chi ar bryd o chi'n meddwl bod y syniad yna o ddefnyddio dreth i yng Nghym ar gyfer hynny sy'n ennill fwy arian yn mwyn clenwyr fel chi'n pai yn ysgau, ydych chi dal y meddwl hynny, a hefyd yn olaf gai. Yn bryd o chi'r thawd i'r dda bod chi yn boryad yng Nghyrrae i'n yswyd ambyn mlynedd, mae hynny'n gwleidio byddai chi'n cam i lawr y bosib a'r byn diwedd y flwyddyn nesaf, ond ydych chi weir eisiau gofyn yn cyfnod yma o'r oles i chi weithredu cyn ystyried eich arwinellu chi. Diolch, James. Un i wedi bod yn gason iawn yn dweud wrth ymateb i'r crisis coste ryw ar hŵr pwysema hynny'n cynrychioli. Y dylech i Woldrewth Cymru yn entifn i archwylio dyfnyddio'r pwerau trethyn cwm o'r pwerau trethianol, ond pwerau trethyn cwm yn benodol. Neud hynny'n mewn ffordd priodol ond a blaengar, trwy beth hynny wedi galw yn treth solidariath, neu treth chi'n sefyll y dewyswch chi. Ond, yna, sydd yn adliwyrch i'r regwydd orio'n blaengar yma. A dyna ni'n dali ar archwylio hynny fel wedes i mewn cyfleiad i'r biebiek yn ystyried ganadledd, wrth gwrs, o ddynnu i shef gweld. Cyn benderfyn ni fel Plaid o ran union cyfraddau o ddynnu i shef gweld ar datganiad ar hydref a gweld effaith hynny. Ar gyllidol Cymreig, dyna ni wedi neud gragr o waith yn y medd, dyna ni'n berhain eit hynny a chael cyngor arbenigol a ni byn nôl. A dyna ni'n cwrdd voru, dyna ni'n cwrdd fel grwp gyda argynno'r fadl i'w adreysiant. Rwy'n fath o fersiwn, rydyn sy'n cyfadeb i gymryd i'r IFS sy'n debyg o ran arbenigwyr yn y maes yma. I edrych ar fod ele gwaith anol, dyna beth dynnu wedi bod yn edrych yna. Ac sut gall y pwerau yma o oedd yfnoddion iawn, oedd yfnoddion mewn ffordd bleingar, helpu ni wrth i ni wedi neb i'r pwysau fel gwlad a fel pobl yn ystod y crisis costeb i'w. Felly, gan yw'n cael ei ddweud, yn hyn sy'n cyntaf sydd wedi ddechrau'r ffordd bwysig a'i ddweud, efallai, ydych chi'n mynd i gael o beth byddoch chi wedi'i bwysig mwy fydd yn ein cy PG. Fe'n meddwl i'r cyfrindiau mewn ei hunai, yn y cyfrindu peirio, ac mae'n meddwl i'r gweithiaeth fath y bydd yn cael ei weld y pwn o'r ryrhau'r Gwmpnod. yn ymwyaf o'r cyfrifodau cyfrifiadau ymdweithio. A'r hyn o'r cyfrifodau Cerddorol, oherwydd y BBC, yn y bydd y cwrnod, mae'n rhaid i'r ffordd y cyfrifod ar y cyfrifod yma o'r Gweithgrifedd Ffysgol. Daewd yn y tro wir iawn i greu plefwyr y Llywodraeth yn y cerdd ond dyma'n mynd i gyda'r cyfnod yw o'ch fawr Aelod, eich cerdd yn y prifoedd y Llywodraeth a'r cyfnod am gwaith gwahanol addysgu'r cyfrifasg. A wneud fel y dylunio'r cyfrifasg gyrddol i gael y ffordd. Yn cerdd hwn, mae'n swyddi rhaid i gael deall, dod o ran y ddisgu yn ganod i gyfrifasgau cael y cerdd ac yn gwneud, a dyna'r cyflog honno'n llythanc y llychwyr, We are a Socialist Party, and we strongly believe that these income tax powers are there for a reason that we campaign for them, we argued in favour of them, so that they would be there to be used when necessary to help the people of Wales. We are in a huge crisis at the moment, and we think it's absolutely the right thing to do, to look at, to explore how we could actually introduce what we've called a solidarity tax to protect our public services and to help the people of Wales face the difficulties that we are all facing at this time of the cost of living crisis. Diolch ar ymweld bydd y clywdrafft yn cael ei cael hoeddi oesnos nesaf ac ran o'r rhoi y clywdrafft o'r flaen a senedd yw i ddweud beth ni'n mynd i wneud ydy trethi a annamais income a bydd rhaid i pob o aros tan hani i weld beth ni'n mynd i awgrymi. Wedi as i dim byd newydd o gwbl i algeciwra, wedi as i ar unig peth i wedi dweud dros blynydd ddweud nawr, dwi'n meddwl, ac mae'r cytundeb ddim yn dim yn ni ar unig olyn. Cytundeb rŵn dda i bladiau i we. A oedd ydych chi'n mynd i ddim bydd y ddweud dros blynydd yn cael ei ddweud. Mae'n meddwl i ddweud dros blynydd ar gyfer y ddweud dros blynydd a ddim bydd yn cael ei ddweud y ddweud dros blynydd a ddim bydd yn cael ei ddweud. Rwea ddim. Rwy'n cael ei ddweud am fryd o gew owners fuethio'r mynd i mi hwn. Mae'r mynd i mewn глаза a ride'r Mynd is peth ynboneid o naddangos o'ch ffannaf adnewydd eu cramlidabyn Bodi, a gael wedi reeddai ar gyfer cyfanol is profiag fourpaiddion i'r faciwn, yn cael chi'n ymgylch ar brod.alnyau'r eit сорffulla benyddwch. ac mae'n ddweud i'r tîm ar y cyfnod o'r cyfnod i'r cyfnod. Diolch yn fawr. Diolch yn fawr.