 CHAPTER XI of EIGHT KEYS TO EDEN by Mark Clifton. This LibriVox recording is in the public domain. Read by Dale Groothman. The naked man, running frantically down the side of the slope, disappeared momentarily under some taller growth. Came out the other side of it still running. He leapt over a small ravine, stumbled, recovered himself, and disappeared again beneath a large growth of trees. Below him, on his side of the ridge, there lay another valley with its own stream. They caught one more fleeting glimpse, a mere flash of sunlight on tan skin. He was still heading downward in the direction of the stream. It was their last sight of him. They watched a little longer, but he did not reappear under the green canopy of forests. Just a guess, Cal said, he spoke matter-of-factly in the hope that the casualness would wash away the fear and awe from Louis's eyes. That's probably one of the dissident men who broke away from the main colony and set up housekeeping in this adjacent valley. Apparently the same things have happened to him as happened to the main colony, whatever it was. I'd guess it came as pretty much of a shock, and he's just now worked up the courage to scout the main valley. From that, I'd say whatever happened wasn't very long ago. Not more than a week. Just a guess. None of the crew answered him. It was obviously not the case of a voyeur spying on others, not with the kind of excitement the running man had shown, running away, that is. Let's drop down into the atmosphere, Cal suggested. I'd assume it is breathable from the fact that we've seen earth animals and a human being. Still, we'd better make tests. Yeah, Louis said unexpectedly. If the man isn't making any footprints, maybe he isn't breathing either. He tried to make it a joke, to fight his fear with self-derision. He didn't succeed. Nobody laughed. He swallowed hard and studied the charts again for no apparent reason. Cal glanced quickly from Tom to Frank. A look at Norton's face showed him Frank wasn't very far behind Louis in the progress of shock. Perhaps, as with himself, it was Linwood's sense of responsibility for his crew that was helping the pilot maintain a better control. But there was a white line around Linwood's mouth, running up the line of his jaw. Was by clenching his teeth too tightly, clenched to keep them from chattering? However experienced a man became, however dependable the reactions, one never knew how to predict reaction in the face of the completely unknown. Yet Cal knew that even if he asked any of the men if they feared to take him down, it would be an insult, never forgotten. It was their job to take an E where he wanted to go. It wouldn't be the first time they had gambled their lives on the judgment of an E. Uh-oh! Tom explained. We have company! He pointed to an indicator on the panel. They swept the space with a scanner, and hovering off to one side, they picked up another ship. They watched it for a while as it hovered there. It made no move to come closer, no move to communicate with them. It's marking, Tom said at last, I think it's a special investigation ship from the Attorney General's office. Wonder what they're doing here? To make first-hand observations of my failure, Cal said shortly, let's get on with our work. Perhaps it helped the crew to realize they were not alone, that whatever might happen to them would not only be heard on the EHQ channel back to earth, but would also be seen by these special observers. Perhaps it bucked them up a little to know that they were being watched, that faltering uncertainly would be noted and scorned. Perhaps it was the mechanical routine of air sampling and testing as they lowered the ship by degrees. Norton grew more relaxed, more sure of himself. Linwood handled the ship on manual control with ease, almost with flourish. But Louis's hands gripping the edges of the chart table still showed bloodless white at the knuckles. Perhaps because there was nothing for him to do at the moment, he alone wasn't snapping out of it. The test showed normal atmosphere. It checked exactly with the readings of this altitude established by the surveying scientists. To complete the record Cal repeated them aloud every time so the open communicator would carry the information back to earth where, by now, not only beginners and haze would be listening, but probably a group of scientists as well. Perhaps their hands too, gripped the edges of tables, showed bloodless at the knuckles. To wait helplessly, eleven light years away, might create more tension than being right on the scene. Yet no voice came through the ship's speaker, neither from earth nor from the observer's ship. Perhaps McGinnis, forgetting his eighty years, wished now that he were at Eden instead of Cal. Perhaps mindful of his years he didn't. He made no comment. Tom dropped the ship lower and lower, each time pausing for an air sample, each time they scanned the valley where the village of Appletree should be. There was no change. Now the unlikely idea of a superimposed mirage was dispelled. The disappearance of the colony was no trick of vision. The ship hovered, at the last no more than fifty feet from the ground. "'Let's set her down, Tom,' Cal said quickly. Tom shrugged, as if that were the only thing left to do. "'You're the E,' he said. His glance at Louis showed that he was placing the responsibility, not so much to avoid consequences for himself, nor so much to assure that they were willing to follow the E's orders without question, as to remind Louis that there was, after all, an E with them. And if he was willing to face this unknown they could hardly do less themselves, but Louis's eyes were fixed in unblinking stare upon the ground below them. He was frozen and unheeding. The actual landing was so flawless Cal involuntarily glanced out of the port to confirm that they were no longer hovering. "'Might as well open up,' he said. Nothing has happened to us so far.' Norton pushed a button. The exit hatch slipped open and the ramp unfolded and slid down to touch the ground. Cal, flanked by Tom and Frank, looked through the opening into the woods beyond. And while they looked, a man came from the screening protection of some shrubbery. He was followed by two other men, all of them completely naked. "'You three stay inside the ship until I signal you to come out,' Cal instructed. "'If anything unusual happens to me, stand off from the planet until help comes from earth. Don't be foolish and try to help me.' "'You're the E,' Tom repeated. When a man is outside his own knowledge, heroics might do more harm than good.' Cal stepped through the exit and walked slowly down the ramp. The three colonists seemed in no panic. They walked toward him, also slowly, obviously in attempt at dignified control. Yet their faces were breaking into broad grins of relief and welcome. Cal stepped off the ramp, took a step toward them. Then it happened. He heard breathless grunts of surprise and pain behind him. He whirled around. The three crewmen were lying awkwardly on the ground. There was no ship. The three crewmen were completely naked. Cal felt a sudden stirring of a breeze and looked down quickly at his own body. He also was nude. He turned back to face the colonists. They had stopped in front of him. Their joyous grins had been replaced by grimaces of despair. Behind him the crewmen were in the act of getting to their feet. A quick glance showed Cal none was hurt. Louis looked around, dazed, and uncomprehending. There was not so much as a bent blade of grass to show where the ship's weight had pressed. Louis sank down suddenly on the ground and buried his face in his hands. Tom and Frank stood over him in the way a man would try to shield some wounded portion of his own body, instinctively. A fact obvious to all of them was that their own communication with Earth had been shut off. In this daylight they could not see the Observership hovering out in space, but its occupants had no doubt seen them, seen what had happened. It, no doubt, was telling Earth what it had seen, the Attorney General's office at any rate, doubtful that it was including EHQ in its report, problematical that the Attorney General would tell EHQ what had happened. Cal hoped the Observers would have enough sense not to try to land. CHAPTER XI For what seemed an interminable time Cal's mind ceased to function rationally, and like an animal suddenly faced with the unknown he froze, shrank within himself, stood motionless. Yet far down within his mind there was still detached observation, as if part of him were removed from all of this, still in the role of disinterested Observer. The crew behind him was likewise frozen in Tableau, and the colonists in front of him. A balance in number with him in between, a still picture from a modernist ballet, or a charade, guess what this is. He felt laughter bubble to his lips, recognized it for the beginning of hysteria, and the impulse was washed away. With that portion of detached curiosity he watched his mind functioning, darting frantically here and there for rational explanation, and momentarily taking refuge in irrational. It was all being done with trick photography. Such a sudden transition could take place in a motion picture, a transition from reality into a dream sequence lying discarded on the cutting room floor. Reversion to the primitive, accounting for the phenomenon, by devising a mind more powerful than his own. The childhood view of the omnipotent parent. Reality's disillusionment. The parent's substitute. The creation of a God in the parent's image, without the weakness of his parent, so that he might go on in perpetual irresponsibility, since he could now place responsibility outside himself. Or was this a fairy story in which he lived? This was the spell of enchantment. This was magic. And at the first concept of magic, the first lesson of E sharpened into focus once more. Anything is magic if you don't understand how it happens, and science, if you do. In that odd detached portion of his mind he deliberately used a statement as a foundation. Upon it he constructed the science of E. The universe, and all in it, was logical, logical at least to man because he is part of that universe, of his essence. There can be nothing in the universe that is wrong or out of place, except and only as the limited interpretation of man who sees a force in terms of a threat to the ascendancy of himself and his at the center of things. This was the sole basis of morality, and prevents man's appreciation of total reality. He had been trapped in the first concept and was accepting these phenomena as a statement of eminent authority. But what if this was not the whole of reality? What then? Once begun his mind progressed rapidly through the seven stages of E science, and in the seventh he found rationality. If there is only one natural law, and we see it only in a seemingly unrelated facets because of our ignorance, because we cannot appreciate the whole, then this too is no more than another facet. Perhaps it was this which broke the spell. Perhaps it was the movement of the colonists. They were moving, withdrawing, walking backward step by step. Their faces were masks of despair, and in them Cal read the knowledge that what had just happened to him, his men, his ship, had previously happened to them. Finally they backed away, backed out of the open space, sought the shelter of a great and spreading tree at the edge of the clearing. There they paused. It was a return to ballet, a gravely executed change in the proportions of the tableau. They stood, a drooped and huddled group, cowering beneath the tree in nude dejection, in the suggestion of a wary crouch, uncertain whether to flee precipitously or freeze to make themselves as small and inconspicuous as possible. In the same grave choreography he turned to look at his crew, and at the turning, as if on signal, on musical cue, Tom and Frank began the pantomime of urging Louis to his feet. Louis looked at the two standing men alternately. With bloodless lips he tried to grin riley, apologetically, for what his nervous system was doing to his body against his will. The old flash of an expression which seemed to say, this is just the kind of dirty trick life always plays on me. Came back into his eyes for an instant, and he tried to grin. But the attempt was a grimace of terror. He cowered back down at their feet, his courage swamped in funk. Let's get him under the tree, Cal said, and wondered why he had spoken in such a low voice, almost a whisper. That too was part of the classic pattern of fear, to make no noise, as was getting him under the tree, an animal's instinct to hide from the eyes of the unknown. As the four of them approached the tree, with Tom and Frank half-carrying, half-dragging Louis, and he's still trying to make his legs behave, support him, the colonists made a fluttering movement of uncertainty, as if to bolt, to run in panic, farther and farther back into the sheltering protection of the deep forest. But they stood their ground in acceptance. The seven men came together under the protecting branches of the tree. Protection from what? Louis sank down gratefully and clutched the trunk of the tree as if on a high place he feared falling. Sorry, he muttered through clenched teeth. Just can't help it. One of the colonists answered first, the tall, leather-faced, spare-framed one. Stamped on his face was his origin, the imperishable impression of a West Texan, grown up in a harsh land that can be made responsive to man's needs only through strength, his will to survive against all odds. It figures, the man said in his quiet drawl, we've all been like that for days, maybe a week or more. Lost count. You're doing all right, better than some. Cal drew in a deep breath, consciously squaring his shoulders, fought off the urge to like dejection. When everybody's still alive, he asked, oh, yeah, sure. Nobody's killed, just hiding out in the woods and mostly from each other. It's a terrible thing. He looked down at himself with a rye grimace. Not out of shame, he added. We've seen naked bodies before, just plum-scared, I guess. To talk, to hear himself talking, and to strangers. To tell somebody about it seemed to restore some confidence in himself. Something of quiet dignity came back over him, a knowledge of responsibility for leadership. He straightened, as if silently reminding himself that he was a man. I am Jed Dawkins, he said, sort of a kingpin of the colony, reckon you might say. Mayor of Appletree, or what was Appletree. I don't rightly know if I'm mayor of anything now. This here is Ahmed Hussein, and this miserable hunk of man is Dirk Van Tassel. Man are speaking, he amended. He ain't no more miserable than the rest of us. I'm Calvin Gray, Cal answered. He indicated his crew. This is Tom Lindwood, Frank Norton, Louis LeBeau. They're all good men, just under the weather right now. You should've seen us when it first happened, Jed said with feeling. I reckon you're the E. Come to find out why we didn't communicate? He spread his open hands, and waved them to indicate the area around him. Now you see why we didn't, hollering loud as we could wouldn't do the job, and that's all we've got. Now the introductions relaxed them all a little, as if the familiar formality provided some kind of normalcy in an incredible situation. Don't seem right hospitable, just stand in here, Jed added with a shrug. But there ain't no house, nor camp, nor fire to share with you. We're not suffering at the moment except mentally, Cal reassured him. Involuntarily he glanced up at the spreading branches of the tree, as if to reassure himself also, then grinned in self-consciousness at the pantomime of fear. First thing is to find out what happened. Might as well hunker down right here on the ground, Jed said. One place is good as another right now. The men all crouched or sat on the dead leaves, which carpeted the ground. Cal suddenly realized he was glad to take the strain from his legs, as if he had been maintaining stance through sheer will. It is a poor greeting to visitors from home, Ahmed spoke up, then cleared his throat in surprise to hear himself speak. We cannot even provide a cup of coffee. Can't have no fire, Dawkins explained. See? He picked up two dead quigs lying on the ground near him. He began rubbing them together in the ancient way of creating fire. The two sticks flew apart out of his hands. Try it, he invited Cal. Curious, even unbelieving, Cal picked up two broken branches. He started to rub them together. He felt them twisted, wrenched, and pulled out of his hands. He saw them flying through the air with a force he had not provided. He got up, picked him up again, sat back down, and held the sticks together tightly in his hands. He tried to bring them together. Suddenly he lost interest. Oh to hell with it, he said unexpectedly, and dropped the sticks. His astonishment at himself was a shock. There was a kind of a chuckle from Van Tassel, one without mirth. Kind of getcha, doesn't it, he said. Cal looked at his hands and at the sticks lying beside him. Now why would I do that, he asked. All at once it seemed unimportant to start a fire, or even try. What's happened here? What's been going on? Can't explain it, Dawkins said. Sort of hope you be in a knee and all. Maybe if you told me just what happened, starting at the beginning when everything was normal. Something else you should tell him, Jed, Ahmed spoke up. He looked at Cal and explained himself. We don't think easily, he added. Can't keep our minds on anything for more than a minute or so. In fact, I'm a little surprised that we've been able to carry on the conversation this long. From the way we've been behaving, I would have expected more that we'd have wandered away back into the woods before now. Simply left you to your own devices, without interest in you. Strange. Yeah, Jed confirmed. I was thinking that, too. Funny thing, right now I feel like I could tell the whole yarn. I feel like, well, while I'm in the mood, I'd better get it said. Don't know how long I can keep interested. Well, there we were one day. Seems like it ought to be about a week ago. Give or take a couple of days. Anyway, I remember it was around noon. End of Chapter 12 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. Read by Dale Grossman. Chapter 13 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. This LibriVox recording is in the public domain. Read by Dale Grossman. It was one day around noon. Jed Dawkins had come in early from his experimental field to get his dinner. Well, city folks would call it lunch, and so he'd be ready afterwards to talk with the Colony Committee. He'd eaten his lunch, all right, a good one. There was never any scarcity of food on Eden, always plenty and wide variety. If anything, a man ate too much and didn't have to work hard enough to get it. That was the main thing that had been wrong with Eden, right from the start. Man was ordained to earn his bread by the sweat of his brow, and there's no reason to sweat for it on Eden. He was lying on a hammock that was stretched out between two big trees in the front yard of his house. The house was set a little way off from the rest of the village, oh, maybe five hundred yards more or less. Not so far he couldn't be handy when he was needed by the Colony, but still far enough to give a man some space. The domestic sound of rattling pots and pans came from the kitchen window where his wife Martha was washing up after dinner. It was a drowsy, peaceful time. Honeybees, they'd brought from earth, were buzzing the flowers Martha had planted all around. A bird was singing up in the tree above him. A man ought to be pretty content with a life like that, he remembered telling himself. Aught to be. He felt like taking a nap, but made himself keep awake because the committee was coming right over, and he didn't want to wake up all groggy the way a man does when he sleeps in the daytime. Can't afford to be groggy because the committee was all set to scrap out something that was splitting the Colony right down the middle. He remembered looking out at the fields where the grains and vegetables were growing, thinking how easy it was to farm here. Plenty of rain, plenty of sun, no storms to flatten and ruin the crops, not even enough insect pests to worry a man. He looked out at the fenced pastures where the Colony's community stock grazed. The horses had eaten their fill and were ambling up from the drinking pond, getting ready to take a siesta of their own in the shade of some trees at the corner of their pasture. The cows were already lying down in a grove of trees and were sleepily chewing their cud. The green grass around them was so tall he could barely see their heads and backs. His house was on top of a little hill, knoll you might call it. Martha, like himself, had been raised in West Texas where all you could see, as a city feller said, was miles and miles of miles and miles. She never could stand not being able to see a long way off, and she picked out this spot herself. They could see all the valley and the sea, and some dim shapes of the islands in the distance, right nice. Yes, it was all peaceful and tame. That was the main trouble in the Colony, too tame. Some of them got restless. They argued the five-year test was all right for most planets. You need every bit of it to prove that a man could make it there, or couldn't, or how much help he would need from Earth, maybe for a while, maybe always. On Eden you didn't need to prove anything. There wasn't anything to make a man feel like a man, proud to be one. Maybe that would be all right for ordinary folks, but for experimental colonists it was a slow death, almost as bad as living on Earth. Sure, they'd made their complaints to Earth, half a dozen times, or maybe more. They'd asked for an inspector to come out and see for himself, and see what it was doing to the colonists. Jed put it right up to EHQ that they were plum ruining a prime batch of colonists with this easy living. A man had to stretch for himself once in a while if he expected to grow tall. Some of the colonists were so lazy they'd stop bitching and were even talking about maybe just staying on here after the experimental was over. Maybe getting a doctor to reverse the operation so they could have kids, which, of course, you couldn't have in an experimental colony. And that was bad. But with easy living and wanting kids, as was normal to most, experimental colonists weren't so plentiful that Earth could afford to lose any. Some of the colonists wanted to leave this, well, they called it a lotus land, whatever that was, right away, before everybody went under, got plum ruined. They were all for taking the escape ship and hightailing it back to Earth. Sure, they knew there'd be a stink and they'd get a little black mark in somebody's book for not obeying orders to stick it out. But that was better than losing their trade, their desire to follow it. Maybe there'd be a penalty and they'd be marooned to stay on Earth for a while. But they'd bet there was a hundred planets laying idle right now because there weren't enough experimentals to go around. They'd get a black mark, but after a while they'd get another job, too. Anyway, living on Earth couldn't be any worse for them than living here. Half of them wanted to stay here permanently. The other half wanted to leave right away. That was what the committee was going to decide today. He'd done some checking around and it looked like they were going to vote to go. He'd also checked with them who wanted to stay permanently. And it looked like, in a showdown, they'd come along. They were proud to be men, too, men and women. Everybody would join. He'd been pretty sure of it. Even the dissenters who'd moved away across the ridge. That was the trouble with them. There hadn't been enough hardship to bind the community together. People forgot how to be kind to one another and get along when there wasn't any hardship to share among themselves. It would mean deserting the planet entirely. Even though his sympathies were with the ones who wanted to go, Jed felt there was something wrong, real bad, about deserting the planet. Still and all, if they voted to go, he couldn't stop them. Maybe Earth would let the three-generation colonists come on out without the total test period. But maybe not. Maybe EHQ would decide that Eden was too hard to colonize because it was so easy. Maybe they'd abandon the planet entirely. There'd be no more humans here, and no more coming. That was when he hit the ground with a solid thump. His first thought, the hammock had somehow twisted out from under him, and he looked up at it resentfully, the way a man blamed something else for his own fault. There wasn't any hammock. At the same time he heard Martha cry out. He craned his neck quickly in the direction of the house. There wasn't any house. Martha was standing there on bare ground, and there wasn't a dad-blame thing else, not a stove, not a chair, a dish, nothing. And Martha didn't have a stitch of clothes on her. His first thought was that she ought to have more sense than to stand right out in the yard plum naked. What was the matter with her anyhow? He peered quickly down toward the village to see if anybody was looking up in this direction. The whole thing hit him like a blow on top of the head. There wasn't any hammock. There wasn't any house. There wasn't any village. He saw a whole parcel of people squirming around down there where the village ought to be. They were standing or crouching or lying around as if they'd fallen down, and every one of those crazy galutes was plum naked. And so was he. He'd just realized it. It had all happened so quietly that the fool bird up in the tree was still singing. Hadn't missed a note. Funny how a thing like that stood out above all the rest. Still singing. Jed got up on his knees, scrambled to his feet, and dodged behind a tree. Find a lot of authority he'd have as village mayor if anybody saw him standing out in his front yard naked as a J-bird. The reminder of his responsibility caused him to sweep his eyes beyond the side of the village to where their spaceship should be in its hangar, always ready for instant escape if anything should go wrong. Real wrong, that is. This ship wasn't there. The hangar wasn't there. Nothing. For a little bit he thought he must be looking in the wrong direction. He'd got turned around or something in the confusion because there was a grove of trees where the hangar ought to be. And it was the same grove they cleared away over two years ago. He recognized one of the trees because it had a peculiar shape, and he remembered feeding the trunk of that very tree into the powersaw for lumber. It was twisted and gnarled, and Martha had asked him to save the wood for furniture because it was real pretty. That was the tree there on the edge of the grove. He felt drunk in a daze. He turned the other direction and looked out to where the experimental fields ought to be. They'd cleared the whole area of lumber and brush because it was good, flat land. Only they hadn't, because that was virgin forest too. Maybe he'd gone insane. He felt a flood of relief. Sure, that was it. He must have gone insane. That was all. Everything else was all right. The calves have got loose to the cows, and they're going to take all the milk, Jed. He turned around to look at Martha. If he was crazy, so was she. Her eyes showed it. Her words showed it, at a time like this to be worried about the fool calves getting out. It took all the comfort away from him. Her face was white. Her eyes were daze. He had got some dirt on your cheek, Martha, he heard himself saying. For Pete's sake, woman, put on some clothes. The committee's coming over, and you're running around like that. He thought he had the solution then. He'd fallen asleep in the hammock after all while he was waiting for the committee, and he was dreaming. Of course he ought to have known all along. This was just the way things happened in dreams. Even him and Martha running around naked. He even chuckled to himself. He must be a pretty moral kind of fellow after all, because even in a dream it was his own wife that was next to him here, naked, not some other man's. The fool things a man can dream. Might as well make the most of it. He took her by the arms, and she clung to him. Must have got the sheet tangled around his throat to choke him, and he was dreaming it was her arms. But there hadn't been any sheet in the hammock when he went to sleep, and he wasn't dreaming. What's happened, Jed? She whispered. Even her whisper was shaking with fear, and her arms were wound around his neck so tight now that he could hardly breathe. Now, now, Martha, he cautioned, don't you go getting hysterical? What has happened, she asked again. I don't know, he said. They were both talking in low tones. It's some kind of a miracle, she whispered. Now, that's a woman's thinking for you. He chided her fondly, joshing her a little. Nothing of the sort. It's just plain, well, any scientist could tell you that. And then he stopped. He was pretty sure the frameworks of science, as he knew them, wouldn't be able to tell you. He guessed that while they stood there, clinging to one another, they both went a little nuts. It was sort of like drowning, he guessed. You'd have the feeling of sinking down and down, and there'd be nothing but blinding, swirling chaos all around you. Then you'd kind of come to for a minute, and there'd be the trees, the sky, the farm animals, the sea in the distance. You'd look down toward the village and make a mental note, almost absently, that the people were getting to their feet now, some of them clinging together the way you and Martha were, and then back down into the mental chaos you'd go again. That went on several times, he remembered, before he'd begun to snap out of it a little. But the funniest thing of all, Jed said, and looked at Cal quickly, penetratingly, I had the feeling all the time that we were being watched. Cal said nothing. You know, Jed explained, like catching an animal in a trap, and then watching it to see what it'll do? Cal nodded without speaking. It was just another crazy thought, I guess, Jed said deprecatingly. Plumb, crazy. But clearly, he didn't believe it was. And of Chapter 13 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. Chapter 14 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. This LibriVox recording is in the public domain. Read by Dale Grothman. At EHQ on earth communication had been working fine. The operator sat back and listened, with trained ear alert, for flaw or fade. A glance at the adjacent recording instrument told him it was taking down everything said, had been, for hours. Nice deal about those naked colonists. Maybe the astronevigator on the E-cruiser had been right. Maybe they'd all just gone back to nature, all the way back. He wondered if there were any pretty young female colonists. And how far did that word experimental take you? Some experiment. He realized his interest was running deeper than that of a detached technician's concern for well-operated equipment. Mechanical, that is. Well, let it. Live a little once in a while. At least dream. The department supervisor hovered near the back of the operator's chair, breathing down his neck. He nod at the knuckles of his hand and hoped nothing would go wrong this time. That astronevigator, Louis LeBeau, was probably right. Those colonists had turned nudist and were afraid to report what they'd done back to Earth. Well, he looked around guiltily, wondering if he'd exclaimed it aloud. He decided he hadn't. If he were out there instead of that E, he'd make them put their clothes back on, on the double. Getting everything all upset, causing all this trouble, getting everybody excited, all of the EHQ aroused, taking up the time of an E, just because they wanted to frolic around without any clothes on. If they were going to act like irresponsible children, they should be spanked like irresponsible children. He wondered if there were any young, pretty female colonists who ought to be spanked. E Gray has just stepped off the landing ramp. The pilot out there was reporting. He is walking toward the three colonists. Now they have started walking toward him. They do not seem hostile. They seem glad to see us. My crew and I are still at our stations, ready for silence. The set simply didn't register anything more, except for that faint sigh of uncompleted force fields in space. What now? What now? The supervisor pushed the operator to one side and barely restrained the impulse to cuff him on the side of the head. Now what did you do? Why did you meddle with it when it was coming in so clear and strong? What's happening? I didn't do anything. I didn't meddle with it. I don't know what's happening. The operator flared back. The signal just stopped. That's all. There was an imperative flashing of the signal light on the line that had been rigged to give direct connection of the running report to Hayes' office. The operator hesitated, then flipped open the key, as if he were touching a rattlesnake. What's happening down there, Hayes complained abruptly without diplomatic softness? This is a very crucial point. I don't know what happened. I don't know, the supervisor quarreled back. The signal just stopped coming. We weren't doing anything to the equipment. He looked up at the continuously changing TrID star map, which made the far wall appear to be a view into a miniature universe. There's no reason for the occlusion, he said to Hayes, and the set here is alive. It must be the other end. He turned to the operator and said loudly, bounce a beam on Eden's surface. Just see if any booster has gone out between here and there. Most of it was making a show of efficiency for Hayes. Here we go again, the operator mumbled to himself and pressed down a key. The returning pips showed the signal was getting through to Eden. Pilot Linwood, pilot Linwood, the supervisor nagged into the mic, speak up. Do you hear me? The operator sighed deeply. His panel partner grimaced something halfway between a grin and a sneer of disgust. They don't answer, the supervisor said at last to Hayes. It's the same as before. Here we go again, Hayes groaned, but not only to himself. All right, he said wearily after a moment's hesitation. Keep the channel open. Keep trying to contact them. Let me know if the signal resumes. But he already felt the conviction that it would do no good. It was too much of the same pattern as before. What could have happened? There'd have to be another review, he supposed, a longer, more detailed one. There must be, had to be, something they'd overlooked in the first one. Had he been right in freezing out so many who wanted to speculate in that first one? But in the interest of time, the scientists would grumble, even worse than before, because now each one of them would be worried lest it was his own field of knowledge that had failed. Hunting a needle in a haystack was easy. At least you knew what a needle looked like could recognize it when you saw it. It would probably all end with nothing solved. E. McGinnis would go out in a rescue ship. He'd already told E. Gray that he would be available in an emergency. And this looked like an emergency. And that would leave EHQ without a single E in residence. Why didn't the general administration get busy and qualify more E's? It shouldn't be so difficult as all that to teach people to think. There was something mighty wrong with the way the kids were brought up if only one in a million could still think by the time he was grown. Less than one in a million could qualify as an E. A boy had to be a natural rebel to start with because if he believed what people said, he wouldn't get anywhere, no further than the people who said it. And if he didn't believe what they told him, they'd punish him, outcast him, whip him, violence him into submission if they could. If they couldn't, they'd shut him up in prison, labeled him dangerous to society. It was a wonder that any were able to walk the thin line between rebelliousness and delinquency. And if a few were able, they were still of no use unless they learned what science had to offer as a base. And there was the rub. How to keep alive the curiosity, the inquisitiveness, the skepticism, and at the same time teaching the basics he must have for constructive thought. For if he were not beaten into submission by the punitive methods of society, he was persuaded into it by his teachers who were ever so sure of their facts and proof. Now you take this Eden problem. Probably wouldn't be tough at all if the guy could just think. But what could have happened? He understood there was an observation ship out there sent out by the Attorney General's office. Why wasn't it reporting? Probably was to the Attorney General's office. Fine lot of good EHQ would get out of that. He was no fool. He knew the Attorney General would gladly sacrifice the whole lot of the colonists if it would give him a weapon to fight EHQ. Why hadn't EHQ sent along an observation ship also? These cocky ease probably hadn't thought it necessary. Always ready to assume they could handle the situation by themselves. He wondered if he dared voice that criticism during the review. Get it on record. He thought about it and decided in favor of playing it safe. Maybe that was the trouble. Everybody was too concerned with his own skin, too willing to play it safe. But an employee of EHQ to make a public criticism of an E? No, better play it safe. He sighed heavily and asked the operator to see if E. McGuinness would talk to him. He suspected that E. McGuinness would just stand off from the planet and wait for E. Gray to get in touch. Nothing seemed to have happened while E. Gray's cruiser was out in space. It must be something connected with the landing being on the surface of the planet. But E. Gray could signal to E. McGuinness those pesky colonists. Why hadn't they signaled to E. Gray? Why hadn't they come out of their bushes and signaled the danger? Surely they must have known what it was. They were alive and healthy, three of them at least. Why hadn't they used their stupid heads? But then how could they have known that E. Gray was out in space or even in their stratosphere? Well, they had telescopes, didn't they? Or did they? Sure they did. No matter what happened to the buildings, they must have all sorts of equipment hidden under the trees or in caves. Why hadn't E. Gray been more cautious about landing? Rushing in there like a green school kid without even rudimentary precautions? That's what came from sending out a boy to do a man's job. Maybe the Attorney General's office had been right in its attempt to prevent a junior from going. What was the use of all that E. training if the boy didn't have enough sense? At least E. McGinnis would have enough sense to stand off, not to rush in blindly. Grand old man, E. McGinnis, now there was a real product of E. science, a venerable dean of the E's. E. Gray would probably have enough sense to know he'd be followed by a rescue ship as soon as something went wrong. And between an E out in space and another on the ground, they shouldn't have any trouble in working it out. He wondered if he should suggest that to E. McGinnis as soon as the operator located him. Even if the grand, lovable old man thought of it for himself, he'd compliment Hayes for thinking it, reasoning it all out. The intercom operator came on his line. Sir, she said, and cleared her throat. He could hear her gulp. Her voice was a little small, thin. Sir, she began again. I contacted E. McGinnis. He said some things. He told me to tell you exactly what he said, word for word. I took it down in shorthand so I could. Well, he exclaimed impatiently. His brusqueness seemed to give her courage. Sir, she said a little stronger. E. McGinnis won't talk to you. He says the foggy, rambling way that review was conducted was a disgrace. He says, why don't you get on with what you have to do instead of bothering people? He says not to waste any more of his time unless you can come up with something he doesn't already know. He says he doubts you'd know what that was even if it hit you in the face. He says to tell you the exact words. So I took it down in shorthand so I could because he said to. She was all but wailing as she finished. All right, haze side tiredly, senile old devil. No wonder things were going to pot if this was a sample of e-training. Send me your notes so I can follow them carefully, he told the operator. So you could tear them up before they get spread all over the joint, she mumbled, but she had already thrown the key so he couldn't hear her. Resignedly, because he knew he was going to catch it from the scientist just as bad because he was feeling very sorry for himself that he must always be in the middle of things, he began to arouse the scientists. He felt so sorry for himself that he dropped his tentative plans to have the midget digit check the personal attributes of the individual colonists out there to see if any of them might be young, pretty, female, 34, 24, 34. As if the idea were now red hot, he dropped the plan of telling General Administration that since Eden was in his sector, perhaps he should go out there personally. End of Chapter 14 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. Read by Dale Grossman. Chapter 15 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. This LibriVox recording is in the public domain. Read by Dale Grossman. The observership with an assistant Attorney General aboard was indeed reporting directly to the Attorney General's office, to Gunderson in person. On their own secret channel, of course, had to be secret. All right for them to know because they were very special persons, but the people should not be told. Gray is coming out of the ship, the assistant was saying. He is starting down the ramp. He is alone. He has no apparent weapons, making a grandstand play of it. Far as we can tell, the crew isn't covering him. Now he is at the foot of the ramp. The three unclothed men are moving toward him, spreading out a little, crouching, obviously going to attack. The stupid fool doesn't seem to realize it. He's, wait a minute, I don't believe it. Well, what, Gunderson exploded from his end. Sir, the assistant gulped, the ship disappeared, just like that. Nonsense. No, sir, it did. The three crewmen are sprawled on the ground. Now two of them are getting up. There isn't a sign of the ship, the ramp, or anything. Can't be, has to be around somewhere. No, sir, it isn't. Sorry to contradict you, sir. It isn't anywhere. They probably set the controls to send the ship back into space and jumped out before it took off. Search space, you'll find it. Ships don't just disappear. I'll search, of course, but this ship just disappeared. All right, what's going on now? What else? They're naked, naked as the day they were born. All four of them, same as the colonists. Keep track of where they put their clothes. Photograph it, get evidence. Sir, their clothes disappeared right off their bodies. First, they were fully dressed. Gray was, anyhow. Maybe the crew could have undressed inside the ship, but Gray was fully dressed. And then he wasn't, just like that. Hmm, shall I land, sir, place them under arrest? Wait a minute, let's think of a good charge. Something to stand up in court. Have to make this airtight right from the beginning, in case some stupid judge decides to make a show of independence. In decent exposure, sir? Lude, public behavior? Pretty weak in view of what's involved. A suggestion, sir? Maybe a moral's charge is the most effective weapon we could have. Attack the east structure on the grounds of bad scientific judgment, and every egghead on earth will feel compelled to rise up in their defense. Except, of course, those employed by the government. But on a moral's charge, there wouldn't be one voice raised. Fear of being tarred with the same brush. Except a few radicals that are already discredited. Any other charge might get public sentiment aroused against us. But a moral's charge. Think of the backing we'd get from the women's clubs, PTA. All the pressure groups determined to dictate to the rest of the world how it should behave. It's worked for hundreds of years, sir. Never fails. Hmm, Gundersen mused. You may be right. Shall I land, sir, and make the arrest? You've got plenty of photographic evidence. All we need, sir, at least for the lude, public, and decent exposure charge. Wait a minute. How about the colonists? Got pictures of them? The three men, sir, no others. Let's don't rush into this, Gundersen said slowly. Without a ship, they're not going to get far. Hold off and keep taking pictures. Maybe we can get something stronger on gray than just an indecent exposure, or at least get some pictures that could be interpreted as more than just that. Get pictures of as many colonists as possible, too, in case they've gone nudist. You want to prosecute the colonists, too? Might be a smart idea. That way nobody could claim that we're gunning for a junior E. Make it impartial. Play no favorites. Hmm, if we decide not to prosecute, we'd have the pictures in their dossiers, so that any time in the future for the rest of their lives, if any of them gave us any trouble, we could quietly let them know what we've got, and they'd just fold up and quit. It's worked for hundreds of years. Yes, sir, smart thinking, sir. The assistant knew that already Gundersen had adopted the idea as his own, and to hold his job, he'd better let Gundersen go on thinking so. Of course, if the idea should backfire, then Gundersen would remember quickly enough where it had originated. Hmm, you know, Gundersen was saying, this could work out all right. If their ship's gone, they're not communicating with EHQ. And if they're not communicating, EHQ will send out another ship to see why. Maybe there'll be an E on it. I hear that the only one available is McGinnis, that guy who's planning to fight us on that injunction. Now, suppose he landed. Suppose he went nudist, or we could make pictures look like he did. The guy would have to undress sometime to take a bath. Slap a moral charge on him. Nobody with a public reputation ever fights a charge like that, guilty or innocent. They pay up or knuckle under to keep it quiet. Have for hundreds of years. Always will, as long as a bunch of fat, old, ugly bitties, male and female, who nobody wants that way, are viciously resentful that they can't have what somebody else is enjoying. Young ones too. So twisted and warped with frustrations, they don't dare try what they daydream about. They're even worse. Yeah, a moral charge is a way to get at him. But I understood there was a law that we couldn't charge an E for any offense. We can charge him in the newspapers, can't we? On the tele-viewers? That's the whole point. We can't charge an E now, but wait till we get things stirred up on a moral's basis. That law will be changed in a hurry because any legislator that tried to hold out against changing it would be drawn and quartered by his constituents and has enough sense to know it. Hmm, he breathed in satisfaction. That's the way to go about it. Don't know why I hadn't thought of it before. If you guys would read your history of how police enforcement officers got things back under control each time some idealist started squawking about human rights, you'd think of these things too. Now don't go off half-cocked. Just stand by. Keep me posted on every move. If I've got to do the thinking on how to get these E's back under police control, the way scientists were before, I've got to have information. And keep taking pictures. End of Chapter 15 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. Read by Dale Grossman. Chapter 16 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. This LibriVox recording is in the public domain. Read by Dale Grossman. After everything disappeared, the buildings, the escape ship, everything, Cal reviewed, and you and your wife found yourself crouched under the trees in what had been your front yard without any clothing on, what then? That was the beginning of it, Jed Dawkins answered. He looked toward his two companions as if for confirmation. He looked at the three crewmen, at Cal. All sprawled or crouched here beneath the tree at the edge of the clearing. We thought it was the end of everything, he said in retrospect, but we found out quick that things had just begun. Cal nodded. Dawkins had told his tales simply without fictitious emotionalism, without straining to get the horror of it across and thereby succeeded. He glanced at his three crewmen to see how they were faring. Louis seemed to have gained some control over his nerves, and yet the way he sat there, staring at nothing, showed he was enduring some special horror of his own. Frank Norton shifted his position, pulling a dry stick from beneath the leaves, looking at it resentfully and tossing it aside. He settled back down and indicated by his expression that now he could be more comfortable. One grateful fact, the day was warm, the breeze under the tree was gentle, the ground on which they sat was not too wet for comfort. Except for custom, for modesty, clothes weren't really needed, and perhaps the shock of being without them would pass. Newtists on earth claimed that one very quickly lost all self-consciousness if no one were clothed. That sex was part of the value. That sex, for instance, became less an issue instead of more because, without concealment, one could see instead of imagining, and the sight more often discouraged than enticed. Cal wondered what the militant moralists would make of the idea that clothes encouraged immorality. It was a hard thing to believe, Jed was saying. It wasn't like a natural thing, like a cyclone or an earthquake or a fire or a flood. Nothing like that. Them, things a man can understand. Even if he's dying, at least he knows he understands what's killing him. I never thought I'd hear myself say it would be a comfort to know what you was dying of, but believe me, he broke off and stared in front of himself. His voice took on a note of perplexity. Only nobody died. Nobody ever got hurt. We was like little kids screaming at the top of their lungs when they ain't hurt at all, only scared. He looked abashed. I gotta tell you, real truthful, he said. Most of the yelling came from the men. The women, by and large, was real swell. The fact is, he continued, come to think of it, I don't recollect ever seeing a woman in real hysterics. Plenty of fake, of course. Say she's trying to hook some man into protecting her or trying to lay public blame on him for not doing it. Other times, in real danger, women folks, our kind of women folk anyhow, they pitch right in and help. It takes a man to make a jackass out of his self at the wrong time. Cal nodded and smiled. There was an attempt at a hollow laugh from Louis as if the shoe had fit. Jed didn't seem to realize it and made no apology for the present company being accepted. It wasn't like the aftermath of a storm either, Jed said, where you begin picking up the pieces to start over. We couldn't pick up any pieces. They couldn't pick up any pieces. In a way, that was worse than the disappearance of things. In a catastrophe, after taking care of those that are hurt, first thing a man does is gather the materials and tools to fix things up again. The women, after soothing them that's hurt, taking care of them as much as possible, first thing they think of is making hot coffee, maybe hot soup. That was when they began to realize this was more than the desolation following a cyclone or other freak of nature. Cal wanted to know what happened. Well, there he was, still sort of hiding beneath his tree. It was Martha who snapped out of it first, who insisted that clothing or no clothing, it was their plain duty to get down to the village where they could help somebody. He'd need other men to help him get things back in shape. She could help the other women take care of the needy. And still he hung back, ashamed of his nakedness. She scolded him then, pointing out that if everybody is naked, there being naked too wasn't likely to start up a parcel of gossip. He gave in to her scolding, because she was right, and came out from behind his tree. It seemed more than passing strange to be walking down the slope naked, in plain sight of everybody. Thing that helped was that nobody seemed to mind to stop and stare at them. Everybody had his mind on his own problems, and then a funny thing happened. Maybe Jed reasoned. It was seeing that everybody else was naked too. Anyway, the self-consciousness disappeared all of a sudden, and they didn't think about it anymore. Not right then, anyhow. By the time they got to the foot of their hill and into the crowd of people, he forgot all about it. There was plenty of other things to think about. Martha pitched right in the way he ought to have done. She was the one who thought of giving the men something to do, get them over their hysterics. Why don't some of you men get a fire going? She called out as soon as they got to the edge of the crowd. Something hot to drink is what we need most, hot water, in case anybody is hurt. Of course, she didn't think straight, not entirely. They didn't have a pot to heat water in. Or maybe she was, because right away he heard her ask other women if any of them knew where they might get some dried gourds. He remembered an old pioneer trick, cutting open a gourd, scooping out the seed, filling it with water, dropping some hot stones into it until it boiled, Indian style. It might seem funny to city women, always protected against everything, that Martha wasn't more excited and helpless. First place she had her man already and didn't need to put on such a show. Second place she was a colonist woman, an experimental colonist woman, trained all her life to take care of the unexpected. And for the experimentals, something unexpected was always happening. Under her influence, and maybe a little under his, Jed acknowledged, now that he'd been set straight by Martha's example, everybody began to settle down a little, like they would after the first shock of a fire or flood. It was all over. Now was the time to start picking up the pieces, rebuilding. Only it wasn't over. That's when they found out they couldn't build a fire. Easiest way without matches is to string a bow and twirl a stick in a hole punched into another stick. Next easiest way is to find a piece of flint, strike two pieces together to make a spark and hope one will set a wad of punk on fire. If no other way, rubbing two dry sticks together will do it. If you can rub them fast enough, get them hot enough to make the powdered fiber burst into flame. Or if they had some of those quartz crystals from the top of the mountain to focus the sun's rays. But they couldn't make a bow or strike two stones together or rub two sticks together. It couldn't be done. Well, Cal had seen for himself what happened when it was tried. All the men were trying it and for a little bit everybody thought it was only happening to him that he must have lost the neck or something. For a little bit there, the men were more worried about how their wife would bring it up for weeks or months, how he had to let the rest of the men show him up when it came to building a fire. One of the men tore it then. He yelled out that somebody he couldn't see was watching him over his shoulder, that it wasn't meant that they should have fire. Cal looked quickly at Louie at that point in the story. Louie was staring with mouth open at Jed, and in his eyes was confirmation of that same feeling, but Jed didn't notice the effect and went on with the telling. Everybody stopped to listen to the man because they were having the same feeling. Jed knew it, him too. The crowd might have panicked right there if the man had let it rest, but he started explaining it the way a man does and makes himself ridiculous. He kept on yelling how the men shouldn't listen to the women, that it was in the first garden of Eden that man had made the mistake of listening to women, that it was Eve who had egged Adam into eating that apple because a woman was never satisfied to leave well enough alone. And now he said in this new Eden, man was being given another chance. If he was smart, if he'd learned anything at all this time, he wouldn't listen to no woman. Somebody bust out laughing when he said that and it kinda eased the tension a little. A woman said, really disgusted, that if the man was too helpless to start a little fire, least they could do was scrape up some dried leaves because in a few hours it would get dark. Magic or no magic, watchers or no watchers, night would fall and she for one liked a soft bed. That caused them to look up at the sky and sure enough the sun, Setti, was already halfway down the sky from where it had been at noon. At least the world was turning and time was moving. That at least. About three hours had passed in what seemed like minutes. Somebody else, one of the men this time, said why didn't they go a little further than scraping up some leaves? Why didn't they get busy and knock together some shelters in case it rained during the night, the way it often did? Now any one of them, man or woman, ought to be able to put up a small shelter in less time than it takes to tell about it. Even without no tools. Break off a limb or take a sharp stone, dig holes in the ground with it. Take straight saplings, trim them, stick them upright in the ground, tamp in the dirt good and hard, lash them together with vines, lash other poles together to make the frame of the roof. Lift that onto the poles and lash them all together with braces, thatch it with grass and there you were. But there they weren't, they couldn't do it. Things just wouldn't behave. They dug a hole and it filled right up again. They couldn't cut down a sapling because the sharp stone, the only tool they had, would fly out of their hands. They even tried lashing some saplings together where they grew and the saplings were like things alive. They wouldn't be bound. The vines slithered out of their hands and dropped to the ground and the saplings sprang up again straight. Not only that, they could scrape together some leaves into a pile all right, but when anybody tried to lie down in them, the leaves would scatter as if blown by a wind. Only there wasn't any wind. Some of the women got pretty disgusted with their menfolk. They tried it themselves and the same things happened. After that, they was a little more forgiving. A couple of more hours had passed while they were trying that. The sun got low. People began to realize they were getting hungry and they began to realize there wasn't any way to cook supper. Now there wasn't any real hardship, not physically. Nobody been hurt, shook up a little and scared for sure, but not hurt. The river was still flowing good, clean water. All they had to do was go down to the riverbank and cup the water in their hands, lift it to their lips, or even better, lie down on the bank and lower their faces into the water. They could do that. It helped a little to know they could. The wild bushes and trees all around had plenty of fruit and nuts to eat. One thing you could say for Eden, the fruit didn't seem to depend on seasons. There was always something ripe and plenty of it. The people wandered off from the village site then to forage for their supper for all the world like animals grazing in a pasture. They sort of hung together in herds, glad to be together. Then by dark they all came back and sat around in a circle, the way people in the wilds sit around a campfire. It seemed funny without a campfire. The darker it got, the funnier it felt. The more you thought about it, the stranger it got. The excitement had begun to wear off and people had started to think a little. It got stranger and stranger. In the dusk you could see the same thought in all the gleaming eyes. They couldn't have fire. Maybe the strangest thing of all, nobody was trying to explain what had happened. Now you take mankind. He's always right in there with an explanation for everything. Maybe it's not the right one. Maybe looking back it's a silly one. But at the time he believes it and that's a comfort. But this was like being in a dream, knowing it's a dream, knowing it can't happen this way and so it doesn't have to be explained. And yet, isn't that the worst part of a bad dream? No explanation for what's happening in it. Nothing you can do about it either. Somebody said, it being dark and all, they should get some sleep. Somebody mentioned being thankful there weren't any children. That was one of the hardships of being an experimental colonist. You couldn't have children. Wouldn't be right to expose children to hardships they'd have to suffer helplessly. Only here, the way kids were, he wouldn't have been surprised if kids would have taken to it a lot easier than the grown folks. The people sort of bedded down together, the way a herd of animals take shelter, each even in its sleep taking comfort from the presence and protection of the others. They bedded around on the ground, making themselves comfortable as possible. One thing you could say, experimental colonists might not be long on brains, the way scientists were, but they weren't picked for that. They were picked for endurance and the brainy will often crack up under a strain that the enduring kind hardly notices. Far as endurance went physically, this wasn't bad. Up through the leaves and in between the trees, the stars were as bright as ever, brighter because there was no fire to dim their glow. They couldn't see earth, of course, but everybody knew right where to look for soul. There it was, a tiny little spot of light in its constellation, it was still there. Somebody said into the darkness that it was only two more days until the regular monthly communication with earth was due. That as soon as the EHQ didn't hear from them, there'd be a rescue party out here in nothing flat. So at worst, it meant living this way only five or six more days. That made everybody feel better. It was a comforting thing to look up through the leaves to see soul in the sky and know they weren't forgotten back home, that on earth people would soon be buzzing around like a disturbed hive of hornets with stingers cocked and ready as soon as the message didn't get through. Yep, somebody said just like the museum collection of Western movies where the U.S. cavalry always got there in time. At least they weren't being attacked by no Indians, somebody said, or were they? Maybe everybody asked that to themselves, but nobody said it. Most everybody got some sleep. No one really suffered. Any discomfort just showed them how soft they were getting with the easy living. Considering everything, they were coming along just fine. And in a few days everything would be all right again. They went to sleep thinking that even if there was some equivalent to the old-time Indians attacking them, rescue would soon be here and they would be safe. Because man always wins. Most people were wide awake by dawn. Some had slept in little bits, waking often enough to keep a sense of continuity. Others, those who slept better, awoke with a start, looked around themselves wildly, realized that they were lying out in the open, plum naked in front of other people. Maybe wondering for an instant what kind of party they'd been to the night before and nearly bolted in panic before they remembered. Most everyone felt sort of surprised that things hadn't gotten back to normal, with yesterday being something soonest forgotten, soonest mended. It takes time for folks to realize things. Not having a hot drink for breakfast was another little hardship, a reminder of how soft they'd got. But nobody complained. Seemed like everybody had woke with a determination to make the best of things and help one another do the same. Everybody was pitching in together to make the best of things. Once they bit into the cool fruit on the trees around them, even not having a hot drink to start the day didn't seem to matter. Some of the women got together and decided it would help things to get back to normal if the people covered their nakedness, or at least parts of it. It might be all right just among themselves, they said, because everybody was in the same fix and knew what happened. But how would they feel when the rescue ship landed and they had to walk out in front of strange men with nothing on? They picked up some big green leaves without any trouble, but when they strove to pin them together with thorns, the thorns just slipped out and fell to the ground. Then they tried sewing the leaves together with bindweed. Same thing, the bindweed slithered out and fell to the ground. One woman figured to stick some leaves together with thick mud from the river and paste them with more mud on her body. It wouldn't stick, peeled right off like she was oiled. One man said he could do it without leaves, just cover himself with mud. He lay down in a muddy pool and got himself covered with wet clay. He was a sight. All at once he looked vulgar, obscene, and nobody had before. That did it. Somebody said they were humans, not pigs, and if the man came on the rescue ship had never seen a naked body before, it was time they did. What was wrong about the human body anyhow? They made the muddy man go bathe himself in the river and gave up trying to cover themselves. All at once the desire to cover themselves was a nasty kind of thinking, something to be ashamed of. Mid-morning, everybody got to wondering if the 10 colonists who'd broken off from the main colony and moved across the ridge were all right. Soon as he reminded them, everybody began to laugh. What fools they'd all been. Showed you how a bit of trouble can keep a man from thinking straight. Here they'd been eating and sleeping like animals when, all the while, just across the ridge, there'd be houses and beds, fires and clothes. Sure, those folk might differ in some opinions, but humans always stood ready to help one another in distress, differences forgotten. In a body they started for the ridge. Everybody knew just where the dissenters had built their homes, but when they got to the top of the ridge, there weren't no houses there. Nothing but virgin woods, same as this side. That shook them, they'd been so sure. Maybe it was the jolt of that. Maybe it was a measure that we still weren't thinking straight, something. They didn't go down and join forces. Nobody thought of it, somehow. They went back down and congregated around where the village had been. Maybe it was the beginning of something that would come later, something Cal would see for himself, that they were already not thinking the way humans do, thinking and behaving more the way dumb animals do. Nothing else worth mentioning happened that day, nor the next. In some ways it was still like a dream. The way people were just accepting things, without question, maybe without curiosity. Jed remembered one time when an e had said there was a wider gap between a thinking man and the average man than there was between the average man and the ape. He'd resided it at the time, of course, but now he thought of it again and began to realize what the e had meant. Two or three people commented on how easy it was to go back to nature, wondering why they hadn't all done it before. How stupid it was for a man to knock himself out, chasing all over the universe, undergoing such hardships, when all a man could ever want was right here. Jed tried to put down this kind of talk when it came up. He reminded them it was lotus land thinking and it would be the ruination of a prime bunch of colonists. He reminded them they'd been through hardships worse than this and had ought to keep their wits about them. Funny thing though, he couldn't get very excited about it. Just did it because it was his duty. Maybe not even that strong. Maybe because once upon a time, long ago, hardly remembered, it had been his duty. It was the next day when things got really rough. Somebody, in a clearer thinking moment, said they couldn't be sure when the rescue ship would get there. That when the rescuers came and didn't see any village, they wouldn't know what to think. Maybe they'd just go away. Shows were not thinking so straight after all to believe that you'd go away just because you didn't find our village. Anyhow, hadn't we ought to work out some kind of a message? Maybe scrape some kind of a message on the ground? They decided the smooth sand above the tide line down on the seashore was the best place for it. Nobody had anything to do, so the whole colony, all 40 of them, walked a couple of miles down to the seashore. They picked out a nice stretch of white sand and with a broken piece of driftwood, they started to scratch a message. Just a big SOS. The driftwood wriggled out of their hand like a snake. Nobody could hold it. Several men tried together, made no difference. Somebody started to scoop out a furrow with his hands. The furrow closed up and smoothed out right behind him. Somebody tried piling up sand, first in letters, then in code signals, made no difference. Sand smoothed right out again. Then somebody got a bright idea. All right, he said, didn't need to use a stick or scoop out a furrow or pile up sand. They had their bare feet, didn't they? They could tromp out the letters that way. Footprints, close together, would be as good as a furrow. That's when it happened. Jed tried it himself and his footprints disappeared. They just weren't there. Everybody looked behind himself, where he'd been walking. Nobody was leaving any footprints. That's when they bolted in panic. And of chapter 16 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton, read by Dale Grossman. Chapter 17 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. This LibriVox recording is in the public domain, read by Dale Grossman. Jed looked quickly at Cal when he told him how the colonists had spooked, bolted in panic, as if he expected disbelief. Maybe it seems funny to you, he commented. After taking so much, we'd be spooked like crazy animals and hightail it into the woods over not making footprints. Pretty fundamental thing, Cal said with a shrug. Animals are aware of spore long before they're aware of tools. It hit deep down into fundamental being, a thing like that. Jed looked relieved, Hussain and Vantassel exchanged glances, as if confirming their belief that an E would understand their problems. Cal appreciated the confidence expressed in that glance, but did not feel it was justified. It was now pretty obvious that this was some alien coordinate system never before encountered by man. But how to get ahold of it? How to reconcile it? Co-exist with it? Never before encountered by man? What if the myths of early man be true and too authentic the legend of his being a pawn to the will of the gods? Could there have been some factual basis for the gods? And not, as supposed, rationalizations dreamed up by man to account for the control of phenomenon at a level beyond his own power to control. It's been bad since then, Jed continued. Seems like once they got the wind up, the whole thing hit them all over again. Like cattle in a stampede, they didn't have a lick of sense. They didn't even stay together. They scattered in all directions, hid out in the bushes from each other. You could hunt for them, call for them, yell your lungs out. You could pass within 10 feet of one of them, calling, pleading, and they wouldn't say a word. Just stand there and watch you like a hunted animal, not even breathing, lest you discover them. After a couple of days, some of us kind of pulled ourselves together. Me and Martha, Ahmed and Dirk here, maybe a dozen of us now have got it together. Funny thing, though, even so, all we want is to hide. Can't get over-hidden somehow. That's why you didn't see us from the air. We was hiding from you. Martha, couple of the other women folks, they practically had to push us out of the woods to come and greet you, lead you to us. They wouldn't come themselves, be a naked knoll. They told us first thing was to get some clothes for them from the ship. We was counting on the arrival of your ship to bring the rest of the colonists back to their senses. Some ain't been found yet, not since the footprint thing. If they were watching you from hiding places, if they also saw your ship disappear, well, now I just don't know. There'll be another ship from Earth, Cal said, in a matter of 15 or 20 hours at most. We were communicating at the time. They'll know we didn't get cut out through choice. Yes, Tom Limwood confirmed. As I remember, I got cut off in the middle of a sentence. They'll know something was wrong. There's another ship out there right now, Cal added. Not an EHQ ship, but one that would have seen what happened. We'll not count on anything from them, but the EHQ ship will be here soon, probably with an Eon board. McGinnis. Don't know what good it would do, Jen said despondently. That ship might disappear too as soon as it landed. And the next, and the next. I don't plan to let them land, Cal told them. You'll notice nothing happened to us until we touched ground. I'll find a way to talk to the ship, keep it from landing, until we got a line on whatever this is. You figure to solve this one, Jed asked curiously, unbelieving. I'm going to try, Cal said, with more confidence than he felt. It's what I'm here for. Maybe I can't solve it, but I can try. I don't know how you're going to start, Dirk spoke up. We're just like animals here. We can't use tools. But animals do use tools, Cal answered after a moment. Materials, anyway. Birds build nests with sticks, grass, clay. Monkeys and apes throw sticks and stones. Even insects use materials. The basic difference between man and the rest is that man gives special shapes to tools, where mainly the rest use whatever falls to hand. But all hire, organized protoplasm life uses tools in one form or another. We ain't allowed to, Jed said emphatically, not even what's at hand. Somebody, or something, is bound and determined we ain't gone to. At that moment, Cal felt close to a solution, or at least an understanding of the nature of the problem, which is the first step towards a solution. But like the specter seen in Twilight from the corner of the eye, as soon as he tried to focus on the problem, the concept disappeared. Something about protoplasmic life using materials. Non-protoplasmic life? Could there be and still meet the definitions of what constituted life? As compared to our evolution from its earliest beginnings finding some other approach to the manipulation of the physical universe, a totally alien kind of science? Come to think of it, the use of material to affect other material was a cumbersome, indirect, awkward way of going about it. As compared with, compared with what? The concept would not allow him full focus upon it. He filed it away for future contemplation. He saw Dawkins and the other colonists looking at him defiantly, as if interpreting his silence to be doubt on their veracity upon the taboo on tools. Their eyes challenged him to disbelieve them and find out for himself. Other than the feeling of being watched, he said carefully, have you had any sign, any other evidence or indication of somebody or something? I know about the feeling because I felt it too and very strongly right now, but any specific evidence. Jed Dawkins looked relieved at the confession. Everything's the evidence, everything that's happened. What more evidence do you want? He said, one of the strongest arguments in favor of something or some kind of intelligence, Cal said slowly, is that nobody's been hurt. All natural law hasn't been canceled. We still have light radiation, heat radiation, gravity, water still flows, the planet still turns, trees still grow and fruit still ripens. We can talk and be understood using our tongues and our minds as tools. We still eat and drink. We can still know. This is no chaotic coordinate system that defies all natural law. This is a deliberate manipulation of some natural laws to get a result. Man manipulates natural laws by the use of tools and materials, but he doesn't suspend them. Here apparently without tools, at least without tools we can perceive, natural law is manipulated, but not suspended. When the village disappeared, no one was hurt. A lot of people were caught in awkward positions and fell, some of them several feet. There should have been at least a few broken bones, pulled ligaments, there weren't. Our ship landed safely. We were a long time in the atmosphere of Eden and for a few minutes there on the ground, we were still using tools of a high order. It was only when danger of real harm to us was passed that the ship disappeared. I reckon it's comforting to know we ain't meant to be hurt, Jed said and looked at his two companions. I guess it is, he repeated doubtfully. Maybe it ain't something as nice and familiar as a cyclone or a den of rattlesnakes, something you can understand, but you got to admit we ain't been hurt yet. It was as if he were arguing the point with his companions. Something I've been noting, Jed, Hamid spoke. A discrepancy of a sort that has me puzzled. Son reckoning, we've been able to keep our minds on this subject for over two hours now, as if whatever this is, manipulating natural laws can also manipulate the way our minds work. Yeah, Jed admitted slowly, his face thoughtful. He turned to Cal. Like I said at the start, our minds have sort of wandered of light, start to do something, and the first thing you know, we're doing something else. Can't keep our minds on one thing very long, like animals. That might be no more than the aftermath of deep shock, Cal said. It's for a purpose. Startled at the outburst, they all turned and looked at Louie. It's for a purpose, Louie repeated in a kind of rapture. They want us to understand we are being watched over, cared for. That colonist you all laughed at was right. This is the first Garden of Eden where man lived in complete innocence. Now man has been returned to it, to live again in complete innocence. You do not think straight because there is no reason. You will be cared for. Woe unto him that seeks to despoil it again by seeking vain knowledge. His eyes were wild. His face contorted with a mixture of exultation and condemnation. Shut up, Louie, Tom said in a low, firm voice. We understand, Jed said tolerantly. Some of the colonists are talking the same way. He's got plenty of company. Hand of chapter 17 of Eight Keys to Eden by Mark Clifton. Read by Dale Grossman.