 All right everybody welcome to Iran book show on this Friday morning I am in Denver Colorado actually technically a world of Colorado and you have spoken the overwhelming response I got and comments and Twitter and elsewhere was that morning shows summarizing the news short shows you know maybe 30 minutes is something you guys value so here I am now the real measure of the fact that you value this will be your financial support so in order to keep these going I'd like to see either you know continued support on super chat so far the last two mornings were fantastic on super chat for a half an hour show or increased support on the on the monthly basis but this is my plan and the plan will only be implemented in December because of my travel schedule although I'll try to implement it as much as possible in between but the plan is to do these shows every morning at 11 a.m. Puerto Rican time which will be 10 a.m. east coast time 7 a.m. west coast time this will be great for the Europeans but to do this to do is basically every day five days away not every day five days a week during the week no news on the weekend you should be relaxing and enjoying yourself and having a good time and then adjust the evening shows to maybe three times a week where we go deeper into topics more more urans rules for life type shows more philosophical issues maybe more interviews we'll do this in the evenings because we'll get kind of the the news round up done in the morning so that is the plan it will be implemented I think consistently starting and then again consistently is hot in my life but consistently starting in December once I stop traveling although we'll try to get it going on a partial basis next week to the extent that I can while I'm traveling and then again the week of Thanksgiving because I'll be home in the week of Thanksgiving we'll do some although again on holidays no news updates unless something dramatic happens holidays are supposed to be a time where you shouldn't be listening to the news right so so that's the plan again you know if you like this plan I'd appreciate it if you express that in both super chat and in the but an ongoing basis of subject not just today and then a monthly support if some of you could increase monthly support or some of you who don't support the show monthly do so on patreon subscribe star locals or on uranbookshow.com slash support through paypal so you've got every option in the world you can either do it through venmo if you want to do through venmo you just have to email me and I'll give you the details and how to support the show on venmo all right so today the topics are going to continue to be very similar to what they were in the last couple years because it is what dominates the news cycle right now and that is we'll start quickly with good news out of Ukraine and then and then we'll turn to elections and then we'll see how much time we have to cover other things and of course we'll try to do as many of the super chat questions as we can in these morning shows and maybe the super chat questions we should try to focus the super chat questions on newsy like events so that would that would be that would be terrific so we keep consistent with with the theme so starting with Ukraine I find it really interesting so I wake up this morning and I look at the headlines as usual and the headlines as usual are always hesitant and and and timid and so the headlines with things like both Ukraine and Russia have something to lose from Russia's retreat from Gershon and Russia retreating from Gershon is this good for Ukrainians or is it not who knows God and and of course it's all like the Russians intend to retreat but will they actually retreat and then you go and you actually look at the actual original news sources you go back and you look at up to date what's actually happening on the ground now because of course in Ukraine the day is already late it's it's the I don't know eight hours forward or whatever depending on where you are in the US and you know the Ukrainian flag is already flying in the middle of the city of Gershon Ukrainian troops are basically taking the entire north coast the north side of the Gershon province the Russians have retreated what is exactly the downside for Ukraine for this massive victory what is exactly the potential upside for Russia for this clear defeat remember Gershon is one of the provinces that Putin annexed to Russia so technically according to Russia Gershon is a Russian province and the city of Gershon the city itself is a is the capital of the province so god there's nothing there's nothing negative there's nothing to hedge there's not you know and then I look back and if you look at all the headlines from the beginning of this war throughout the war they are so negative there's so what's the word you know respectful of Russia and respectful of Russian military strength and convinced that Russia is going to win this I mean there's even an article in foreign affairs magazine foreign affairs magazine the premier foreign affairs publication out there and and the foreign affairs magazine the title of it I just tweeted it out the title of it is something like western weaponry will not make any difference in Ukraine it will not help the Ukrainians stand up to the Russians I mean talk about a title that did not age well talk about a situation where it was it was completely completely completely wrong uh so uh anyway so uh yeah Ukraine has had a major success uh Gershon is now held by the Ukrainians I mean northern Gershon southern Gershon is still Russian we now starting to enter winter I was reminded of the fact that it is winter because in Ohio and Indiana the weather was amazing it was it was in the 60s and sun was shining I reminded of the fact that it was winter when I arrived in Colorado last night it is frigging cold here I was just looking it's 21 degrees outside right now now the sun is shining that's the beauty of Denver 21 degrees I'm not built for 21 degrees you know that this is not this is not appropriate for human life where is global warming when you need it anyway I'll be leaving the hotel in a little while in a few minutes actually um and wrapping myself up to keep myself warm but I'll be giving a talk at 10 30 this morning it is right now close to nine o'clock my talks in Colorado are never videotaped uh the talk unfortunately yesterday was not videotaped um that it was a debate it was kind of a debate on the regulatory state but they did not videotape enough unfortunately um all right so good news out of Ukraine the Ukrainians continue to to to succeed against the Russians and push the Russians out of Ukraine and regain regain the territory from from the Russians elections we don't know much more today than we did yesterday which is in and itself newsworthy that is the the very fact that you know in the United States of America it takes days and indeed weeks to determine races is pretty primitive and pretty ridiculous I mean Brazil um Brazil a country far poorer than the United States a country with a large population 250 million a country with a vast territory that is a geographically it's a big country I mean it was in less than 24 hours they had it done it was finished I mean there are claims now fraud and they want recounts and all that but you know I don't think those claims are anymore uh based on any more facts than the Trump claims were based on any facts I don't know if you know but in Brazil there are massive demonstrations on behalf of Bolsonaro all over cities hundreds of thousands of people out in the streets in support of Bolsonaro and against Lula in spite of that I think Lula will be appointed uh will be sworn in as president on I think it's January 1 but the election goes relatively smoothly and I think because it's automated in Europe when elections happen we know we know the next day who won who lost and it's finished and it you know it it shouldn't take we live in a world where I'm I'm left grieving to you guys instantaneously over the web video you know how difficult is it to to create an electronic system of voting where uh that is secure uh and where we get results instantaneously instantaneously um so it's um it truly is shocking disappointing ridiculous absurd and of course Republicans uh want to go backwards I mean they're good conservatives they want to conserve the bad voting we have in the United States they want because they don't trust technology and they don't trust their machines the machines are rigged the software it's watching you it's going to control you anyway they are they want all elections now to be hand counted let's take a couple of months what the hell imagine imagine an election system in which you could do it at home uh and and and just go online and vote doesn't have to be a ceremony it doesn't have to be inconvenient it doesn't have to be a track it doesn't have to involve why can't you do it on your phone now there's security issues but god I mean how difficult could this issue be get I don't know get Elon Musk and and and Peter Teal and and I don't know jude saw us together and they can solve this problem I'm kidding but you know solve the electronics problem and let us vote on phone and let's get the results within five minutes I mean as soon as voting ends five minutes later we should have the total results I mean I mean our election system is a system run by leadites but leadites and it's absurd and ridiculous I mean I think we have cryptographers in the United States who can make a system like this immune from hacking uh there are all kinds of ways you could do this I think now maybe I'm wrong maybe there's somebody here who knows software and everything else you could do it on the blockchain which could verify your identity you could upload a you could you could confirm it with a picture you could upload a passport or a driver's license ID you know imagine that having voting with IDs and we could get this done anyway we don't have results so we still don't know who's going to control the house we certainly don't know who's going to control the Senate we might not know that until the runoff in Georgia it's still looks likely but not super likely but just likely you know there's a the odds favor the Republican still winning in Nevada the odds favor the Democrat winning in Arizona and as a consequence of that that would give that would give the Democrats 49 and the Republicans 50 and it would all basically turn on Georgia on the Georgian runoff which will be done in December I understand runoffs runoffs are fine you have a wall you have to get more than 50% fine but that you can't vote you can't actually count votes the second the other thing is the house the house is taking much longer it's it's it's it's ridiculous we still don't know again likely the odds favor the Republicans winning the house no certainty there it's precinct by precinct it's you know it's it's district by district it's and you have more districts that favor Republicans and Democrats Republicans need fewer at this point seats wins to get to a majority so again it's likely Republicans will have a majority what what what shocking is not only the time it takes but what shocking is how I don't think anybody I literally I don't think anybody predicted that we would not know the house who won the house three days after the election I think there was you know they weren't sure about the Senate the polls were mixed in the Senate but the house the house it was clear Republicans going to win that there was no question everybody predicted that and yet look where we are with three days later and we still don't know you know let's see let's see what happens but it does look like that's the house will go Republican people are being analyzing the election results I've been reading a bunch of analysis and I think the overwhelming conclusion is and this is the conclusion I had the day of the election the overwhelming conclusion is that the the affiliation with Trump and the affiliation with denying the 2020 elections had a clearly negative correlation with your success in the ballot now not for everybody some deniers got in smoothly but most of them the closer you with Trump the more you emphasize the denier the worst you did now again there's some exceptions to that so candidate quality was the big issue Republicans lost because the candidates sucked more moderate Republicans or less Trumpist Republicans less conspiracy theory oriented Republicans would have won in a lot of these races and you can see that for example take Georgia Kemp who if you remember Kemp who ran for governor stood up to Trump in 2020 and he got elected by a massive margin right there was some expectation that the Democrats would do well in Georgia in the governor race given how well they did in 2020 and given how well they did in 2018 when the race between Kemp and Stacey Adams was quite close this time it wasn't even close she's not claiming voter fraud this time because he trounced her trounced her so why didn't Republicans down ballot particularly in the Senate do as well as Kemp did if Kemp could attract all these voters being a Republican a Republican who stood up to Trump why didn't Walker get the same votes well because of his closest to Trump his closest to the election denial he did not get the votes and you can see this in place after place after place you see the same kind of pattern you see Republican governors who've done the hard work who've governed who are not kind of associated with Trump they did phenomenally well and even Republicans who won senators like JD Vance did okay they won but they didn't win by anywhere close to the margins the governors did so there's a real case here for the Republican party to move away from Trump if it wants to be successful in the future maybe one of the most surprising results in the house this round now the results are not in yet so we don't have fine account but it doesn't really matter because the direction here is important and that is here in Colorado I mean in election denier a Trumpist the worst kind of Republican but she was in a district where she won last time by a big margin everybody expected her to win it wasn't even it wasn't a lean Republican it was a no this is a Republican county and it's it hasn't been called because it's so close last night I think the Democrat was leading by like 60 votes I think as of this morning she was leading by about a thousand votes I think as they count more votes who knows what'll happen she probably will win in the end because this is a solidly Republican district but to win by such a small margin well maybe maybe people are sick maybe even Republicans are sick of the Q and on election denying Trumpist nonsense and what they want is I don't know at least normal see I don't know what normalcy is but I don't think they want compromising sellout Republicans but maybe they want some kind of sense of normalcy maybe radicalism on behalf of liberty somebody should try that try radicalism on behalf of liberty on behalf of freedom now maybe that won't sell either but at least it would be nice to have somebody try it somebody out there should run on a just a pro free markets pro limited government pro individual rights pro shrinking government pro even you know let's let's do a test let's run it on reforming medic and and and Medicaid and Social Security let's run on an actual liberty platform not as a libertarian as a Republican let's run on such a platform let's see what happens it would be interesting and not as an objectivist you don't have to be radical do it all the way phasing out modifying changing trimming moving in the right direction don't be radical it's not going to happen tomorrow just orientation how about a candidate who runs on a pro liberty orientation not final thing orientation jeremy says paul ryan problem with paul ryan is he would often talk like that and he would often propose legislation like that i mean paul ryan as much as people love to hate him he's the one who proposed a budget that converted Medicaid to a voucher system which would have been brilliant god would that be brilliant and and all kinds of stuff like that and the republicans he and the republicans proposed those kind of budgets when they were in the opposition and they knew they would never pass as you know when they hold held the house but they didn't have the white house of the senate so they knew it would be vetoed as soon as they became the majority they abandoned it and paul ryan unfortunately has a long long long long long long track record of talking the talk and then when it comes to voting voting the status line so for example he voted for the expansion of medicaid part d of medicare he's he voted for a lot of really really crappy government expansions in the bush years he did not stand on principle at all so we need somebody who is quote normal but who who actually not just pushes for a a a pro liberty agenda but votes that way and consistently votes that way and plays it plays it consistently so so we will see so again lesson learned from this election i keep repeating this and i know i'm a little repetitive lesson learned is um they need uh they need to move they need to move on from trump and they need to move away from trump it's pretty it's it's pretty obvious um connoisseur senate is going to be 51 49 democrats potentially if if republicans certainly if republicans republicans will lose nevada if they then lose it well if republicans lose nevada and arizona uh then it's uh it then the runoff um the runoff will determine whether it's 51 49 or 50 50 i think nevada is key and of course the runoff in in georgia i don't know how the runoff in georgia will play out but i think the the nevada is going to be close so until we get those off on nevada i'm not gonna i'm not going to predict here but there are reasons to believe that in spite of the fact that the republicans are holding a lead in nevada that lead might uh disappear because uh the remaining votes are democratic votes and that ultimately the democrat will win um all right let's see uh let's see where we are um you know another just a quick story that i was reading about was uh you remember the south korean stampede a hundred thousand people were in these little alleys and narrow alleys around it's one in in south korea a stampede it wasn't even a stampede they didn't rush anyway it was just the just a sheer number of people landed up crushing 150 people to death 200 people injured almost all of them young you know teenagers or in the early 20s most of them girls just horrible horrific well there's a big investigation going on in south korea into uh you know what happened and why the police didn't kind of clear the crowd seeing the problem this is kind of the stuff that police should be doing in terms of recognizing a real potential problem and trying to not allow crowds like that in little alleys to accumulate um and it turned out to a number of like 14 i think phone calls made into the police in the hours before um the actual tragedy happened and police went out there they scattered the crowd and then they they left they didn't they didn't stay they didn't uh and um so there seems to be some kind of police failure and the north koreans are the south korean sorry are really investigating this and um they came to the conclusion that you know that after the fact one of the policemen um one of the policemen had uh deleted some of the information that showed the incompetence and the incompetence of the of the police and uh deleted some of the um some of the intelligence the police had that showed that they should have known better and they should have done more and they could have prevented this this morning uh they were investigating that they found that the policeman who had deleted this stuff he was part of the intelligence unit of the south korean police uh this morning they uh they found him dead in his home almost certainly from suicide um it is interesting the way um some asian cultures respond to failure um there are consequences there are consequences and uh he knew there would be consequences and he took his own life um i mean i'm still waiting to see what the consequence is going to be for the complete failure of what was the name of that town in texas would vala vala where they didn't storm the classroom where they waited and waited and waited and waited and and kids were dying and bleeding out and and really nothing happened and what are going to be the consequences now i don't expect anybody to commit suicide and i i i'm not suggesting that's the appropriate way to do it but it's clear that in south korea there were going to be consequences the question is uh of all day will there be real consequences to the to the complete disaster that i think was uh uvaldo in terms of uh in terms of that all right final story i think uh an important story and and i think you'll all agree with me a good story a good outcome at least for now we'll see how this uh works through the court but yesterday a um a a judge in texas ruled that the by the ministration did that i did not have the authority to um to do the the student loan forgiveness program the judge ruled that that should have been a legislative issue and not uh an executive issue that it was beyond the authority of the executive i'm always happy when the executive power is reduced i think executive power in the united states uh has uh has just become ridiculous executive orders uh it feels authoritarian uh we have a system of checks and balances we have a system that delegates to the legislature certain things and a system a system that delegates to the executive certain things and we've completely abandoned that system where executives now do a lot of what the legislature should do including uh including elements of farm policy and declaring war and tariffs you know the tariffs should be something the legislature passes no the legislature given that authority to the executive well in this case the court ruled that the executive does not have the authority to unilaterally do away with these student loans um it's a it's a it's a lengthy decision it's not a likely health decision now it is a um a trump a point t but i don't think that's going to matter i i think uh you you know we'll see uh whether the bite administration will appeal this there's still no word if they will or not um but as of five minutes ago cnbc is reporting that the bite administration will stop taking applications for student loan forgiveness so a win we got a win and as i've said often i actually think the healthiest portion of our system our system of government in spite of Hobbes the healthiest portion of our system of government are the courts i i think you're going to see the courts particularly supreme court rein in executive power at least to some extent but more importantly i think you're going to see the supreme court rein in um uh the authority of agencies uh of of regulatory agencies i think there's this important um there's going to be significant work uh to rein in uh the power of the epa of of of different regulatory agencies and giving the power back to the legislature now i think i think a lot of what the legislature does should be ruled unconstitutional i don't think that will happen but at least we're going to see the the the um what do you call it the administrate what people call the administrative state the regulatory state reigned in by by the courts now this is counter to the new republican judicial theory theories coming out of ver mule in in harvard and others and we'll see how long they have before they have an impact on the courts uh ver mule and and uh you know and others uh who argue that the administrative state should be used more and should actually be grown from a public and perspective to impose right wing ideals on us but that that is not the position of the court today uh people like gorsuch and even alito but gorsuch and thomas have a decent uh view a good view of of of regarding rating in the regulatory state and that's going to be one thing that i think is gonna the courts are gonna do well and i think here's another one um i think this court would have ruled obamacare unconstitutional um i think this composition of the court so things like that are going to be ruled unconstitutional things like this are going to be uh are going to be sent back to the legislature things like this um like the student law and forgiveness are not moving forward and that is good that is good um all right uh let's see are we here did we lose connection or are we all good all right um let me do some super chats i don't have a lot of time here because i do have to want to give a talk uh and it's it's i have to get an uber and i have to pack and i have to get an uber to get out there but let me just do this quickly uh so let's do a few super chats and move on um thank you uh shakato ha ha ha ha mad says uh uh the short morning shows a great addition to your channel it's uh night time here so it's perfect for me so thank you ha ha ha mad you you contributing in dollars i can't tell where you're from but uh fifty dollars uh that is great um all right thomas uh shabbat thank you thomas did the us and uk need the soviet union to help defeat nazi germany rusevelt and churcho clearly thought so although churcho was clearly for less uh naive about stalin and rusevelt was you know it's hard to tell how naive or not they were they were might have been but um look it means it depends what you mean by needed the soviet union i think um they had the soviet union whether they supported the soviet union or not that is it is hitler that opened up a second front it is remember and this this is important to remind people all the time world war two begun when hitler and important and capital and and starlin invaded poland starlin was hitler's ally in the beginning of world war two and that is super important nobody remembers that nobody talks about it but it's super important so hitler did not need to open a second front starlin was his ally so um hitler opening up a second front was good for the u.s and and uk it helped expedite the war the question is did the united states need to massively support starlin in his effort to fight hitler and i think the answer is no i ran certainly thought the answer was no um both starlin and hitler ultimately were weak and uh they would have fought and fought and fought and fought now the russians uh it would have taken longer for the russians to win it would have cost them a lot more uh but they would still have you know maybe maybe uh hitler would have made it to that to to to moscow ultimately napoleon made it to moscow but the winters are brutal and uh and it would have drained troops both from uh from uh from hitler and i think the war would have happened was maybe the war would have been a little longer maybe i'm not even sure of that particularly if if uh if the united states had like patin run the war then it would have been uh significantly shorter but uh on the on the ally side instead of compromising politicizing eisenhower um but what so many would have happened is that he said europe wouldn't have fallen into the soviet union russia would have taken it would have had a much harder time defeating the the the nazis maybe they never would have maybe they would have been fighting it to a to kind of stay on me it's some way in russia maybe they would have been but that would have still occupied uh nazi troops and all the west needed all the us and the uk needed was nazi troops to be occupied on the eastern front once they were occupied there i don't think the us needed a soviet victory they just need a soviet to keep the nazis occupied uh and i think that would have happened no matter what so i you never you never finance your enemy you never send them troops we shouldn't have done that with being laden uh in afghanistan and we shouldn't have done it with uh starlin in um in world war two and i think the consequence of doing it with starlin world war two is that we handed them all of eastern europe just the travesty and even that was not necessary because again patin could have taken eastern europe parts of eastern europe at least before the russians ever got there but eisenhower and the rest of the and f dr and churchell made promises to starlin and they kept those promises but the promise was to enslave you know all the peoples of eastern europe for decades and decades which is horrific and why they would do such a thing after compromising with hitland seeing that what where that led it's it's it's hard to believe the power that pragmatism has on people uh but it certainly it certainly does in our politicians all right quickly let's do a few other super chats and really let's try to do for these morning shows let's try to do super chats that are more related to the newsy stuff and the bigger questions the big issue stuff let's try to do for the evening ones um so so if you can ask news related questions but we'll see all right michael asks most of human history is just new new people making old mistakes yeah i mean i've often said um i've often said that people don't learn from experience because you need ideas to be able to learn the appropriate lessons from experience you need a positive philosophy you can't just learn from the mistake happening you have to actually understand what happened you have to understand causality you have to understand you know what what drove the mistake what what's what's going on all right um it still amazes me how much deeper this is michael how much deeper i ran is than any of these clowns absolutely uh michael uh if a man does not control his temper is it it is a sad admission that he is not in control of his thoughts i think that's right but look sometimes sometimes you get angry and but you're right the key is controlling the key is to to find a way to control it all right colt says i'm disappointed in the GOP but they got what they deserve yes colt they did i really hope they learned their lesson the ukraine issue almost maybe almost made me not vote for them also did ukraine impact this midterm keep it up i think it probably did again i don't think it i think only at the margin but probably did uh you know some of these republicans going after ukraine and being pro-putin i don't think helped a cause i don't think mainline republicans out there are pro-putin i don't think mainline republicans out there i think supports ukraine i want to see ukraine defeated even a lot of people i know who supported trump still think that ukraine should be defeated and it's okay to support uh the ukraine in an effort to defeat russia russia should be defeated sorry uh so i think i think that definitely had an impact i do think that this election is good for ukraine that is i think mccarthy who said i'm not sure the republicans will support the ukraine effort i think they will support it i think that the margin of victory is so small that they will go along with this one um as part of what they do so so i do think this is good for the ukraine war this outcome i i think if they'd one big they might have taken that as a mandate to do some to stop the funding to ukraine and that would have been i i think that would have been bad uh bonnie says you are appreciated thank you bonnie i really appreciated that i appreciate the fact that i'm appreciated by some uh shock at tour says started watching your show quite regularly after attending in person debate with richard wolf thank you for your show wow that's spectacular i'm curious shock at tour when you came to the debate with richard wolf you were you already on my side what were your what were your political philosophical views at that point had you read ein rand before the debate have you read ein rand after the debate that would all be amazing information for me to just get a get a good sense of uh of all of that all right that is it for the super chat thank you for all the contributors if shock at tour writes that up in the comments quickly that would be great i don't know kathryn we're going to have to set some goals for the shorter programs that are maybe not obviously lower than the than the long programs but are still significant that is still respectful respect respectful respectable uh but um we'll see how all this evolves all right everybody um new goals for short shows maybe it's on like $250 or something like that that would be good uh and uh and that will encourage maybe some people to to help get us there uh some of our wales to get us there all right thanks everybody uh let's see um over the weekend we'll do some regular shows um not sure about saturday but suddenly sunday and hopefully we'll have a show on monday as well and then next week i might do some of these morning shows or not i'll be in costa weekend mexico so it's really going to depend on the quality of the high of the wi-fi and also the timing of my flights so i just don't know if it is uh if it is realistic and to what extent it's realistic all right thanks everybody have a great week hopefully by next week we'll know a little bit more about who actually won these elections somebody work on this solve the problem you know get along musk and those guys on on on you know not just tinkering with twitter oh i i did want to say quickly i'm just going to say this quickly because i have to run i i wasn't i there was a a lawn musk did on twitter he did a uh like a news conference type thing or q and a and uh on on audio and i participated i can't remember what platform it was but i i found out it through twitter and it was quite interesting i mean obviously he's very thoughtful the guy's very smart i i ended i only listened to segment i would after listening to that segment i'm more optimistic about his ability to reform twitter we will see what actually happens and the fact that there's chaos on twitter right now that's how entrepreneurs often work chaos is a way ultimately to build and i got my blue checkmark i paid eight bucks and i got my blue checkmark i know a lot of people are making fun of me for that but i got it now we'll see if it made up matters if you don't follow me in twitter follow me in twitter now that i have the checkmark as you know it must be me although they didn't do anything to verify my identity i just paid eight bucks and i got it so i don't know in what sense it was verified maybe the credit card had the same name as my name i i don't know has anybody tried to pay the eight bucks and get verified and turned down that would be interesting experiment is this just a way to get eight bucks from us and the checkmark means nothing and the verification means nothing and if it's not verified at all then i was just scammed out of eight bucks that's okay i you know i'm i'm this is an experiment so uh let's see let's see what happens if the eight bucks buys me anything doesn't give me a different status is my twitter accounts are they gonna go faster uh now that i paid the eight bucks it's eight bucks a month all right everybody have a great great weekend uh have a wonderful weekend i will see you all uh suddenly on sunday and uh hopefully you can join them not you exactly what time we'll we'll figure that out but um see you all soon bye everybody