 Long time viewers of the show know that I've been critical of JK rallying for a very long time And this is because I believe that her obsession with trans people is not only weird, but extremely Harmful. It's not like she's saying these transphobic things into the void. She is basically non-stop dogging on trans people attacking gender-affirming care making it seem as if they're inferior to her audience of Millions and millions of people and when you have a platform that large what you say Holds a lot of weight So maybe somebody who wasn't necessarily predisposed to not like trans people might start saying transphobic things because they respect you and they're a fan of yours so I've been critical of her as have thousands of other people and It seems as if this criticism has led to her Writing a book and when we look at the book in question, perhaps There should be a page in there where you see my name as well as Vash's name in the dedication section Specifically for inspiration, but I'll let you decide. Let's look at this particular book here So Cheyenne roundtree of the Rolling Stone writes although JK Rowling's Harry Potter series was rooted in fantasy and make believe the author seems to be drawing inspiration from something a little more Realistic for her latest book her own life Rowling's new novel the black ink heart part of her crime thriller series Carmaran Shrike and penned under the pseudonym Robert Gale brief Involves a storyline that appears to mirror Rowling's public downfall After she continually made statements that have been widely condemned as transphobic in her new book Rowling introduces readers to Eddie Ledwell a creator of a popular YouTube cartoon who sees internet trolls and her own fandom turn on her after the cartoon was Criticized as being racist and ableist as well as transphobic for a bit about a hermaphrodite worm The creator is docked with photos of her home plastered on the internet Subjected to death and rape threats for having an opinion and was ultimately found stabbed to death in a cemetery the book takes a clear aim at social justice warriors and Suggest that led well was a victim of a masterfully plotted politically fueled hate campaign against her So what's the overall message of this book the message is that it's not necessarily the oppressed who we should worry about It's the oppressors. There are the ones who are actually oppressed and the individuals who are spewing hate Well, they oftentimes can be the victims of hate to the point where they could be killed Now look, it's fiction perhaps loosely based on reality But the overall message is to essentially portray people who are concerned With racism concerned about ableism and transphobia as the real bad guys So this is kind of mirroring her own experience. She's often portrayed herself as the victim So it's obvious that Eddie led well You know, it is very similar to her She's obsessed with trans people. It's so weird now. She claims that this is not actually based on her life And I don't believe her many people don't but she says that she actually wrote the first draft Before she was called out for transphobia. So it's simply a coincidence Sure, Joanne, I don't believe her. I don't think many people believe her but The book gets even more strange. So Nathan j. Robinson tweets I realized jk. Rowling's new novel might seem a little long at 1200 pages But a good portion of the space is taken up by fictitious mean tweets So as you can see, there's plenty of examples here, but there's more So here's a sample page from the novel where indeed it's just basically mean tweets He adds this is what happens when a novelist spends too much time on social media Now I've got to ask the question as somebody who reads a lot of novels Who would want to read that? Like I I read almost every night before I go to bed I can't imagine enjoying that like who would want to read Mean fake tweets. I mean look and she pretends like she's the victim here No, you got criticism because you're saying hateful things We all see hate tweets if you have a twitter account. You're going to see mean tweets hateful tweets But in this instance, it's not like people were just being mean to her assuming that she did write this book You know about herself. It's not like they were just mean to her Because you know, we all just hate jk. Rowling. No, it's the content It's what you say about trans people that's damaging. Now, let's go back to why I said at the beginning of this video perhaps myself and va should be in the dedications page because um She saw some mean tweets and specifically she saw my mean tweet So here's what I said about my back and forth with jk. Rowling back on april 4th So she wrote history will judge whether dr. David bell was a hateful transphobe Or trying to alert people to a medical scandal But he's far from the only health professional raising these concerns and I have the letters and emails to prove it Now we're not going to get too deep into his arguments here But basically in a sense his argument is that these doctors they are Too flippantly Diagnosing young people with gender dysphoria. Perhaps they're just gay or lesbian and not actually, you know experiencing gender dysphoria on top of that He claims essentially that more trans people are getting this diagnosis or excuse me more autistic people are getting this gender dysphoria diagnosis So suggesting that autistic people are being taken advantage of nice ableism there by the way Um, no actually this isn't really an issue people who are diagnosed with gender dysphoria by and large That's a correct diagnosis. So let's actually look at some facts really quickly here So 97 percent of trans people are happy with their transition and in the uk jk. Rowling's country the regret rate is 0.47 percent I repeat 0.47 percent So doctors are overwhelmingly getting their diagnosis of gender dysphoria correct But he's pretending as if this is some big issue when it's not now the reason why he's claiming this is an issue And he's fashioning himself as a sort of whistleblower is because he's anti trans quite literally This is an anti trans charlatan who doesn't think that kids should get gender affirming care He's in lockstep with republicans in the united states and people politely respond to the jk. Rowling and tried to point this out For example, erin wrote joanne. You are literally pushing a conversion therapist He belongs to an organization calling for 100 d transition that calls each youth who goes on to transition a failure That seeks to eliminate youth transition that calls hrt opposite sex imitation medicine Now this person noted that he lacks the credentials that he claims to have bell has not actually worked clinically with trans people He has no relevant expertise. He was a staff governor with no clinical involvement and is facing disciplinary procedure So ask yourself this question. Why wouldn't jk. Rowling tweet out the peer reviewed studies that show that Gender affirming care for young people saves lives. It's medically necessary It reduces rates of depression and suicidality. Why would she tweet out this one quack? Who's a bigot? It's because he's confirming her transphobic point of view. Now people try to engage respectively respectfully I for one, I don't engage respectfully with uh transphobes and homophobes because I'm of the belief that civil rights are not debatable Even though it technically is debatable in certain countries politically But I don't think that they're debatable So my goal is to just insult them until they shut the fuck up And I want to make it socially unacceptable for bigots to speak their mind I want them to keep their bigotry their transphobia their racism their misogyny to their self So I usually don't try to engage respectfully. I just insult them and I move on So I tweeted this to jk. Rowling. You're a repulsive bigot. Go fuck yourself Transphobic trash now shockingly she saw that tweet and she decided to screencap it And she put me on blast responding saying Me shares video of experienced psychiatrist That's wrong who turned whistleblower expressing his deep concern at high numbers of autistic children and children with internalized homophobia Presenting at gender clinics them and then she shares my tweet letting her 14 million followers know where to find me and find me They did but before we get to that um my response was not indicative Of most of the responses that she received. Sure. There were people that were just calling her a transphobic bigot But there were people there who actually tried to engage respectfully, but she just bypassed them and went right to my tweet Why is that? Well, it's because this cry bully wants to be perceived as the victim Great point mic and now she's writing an entire book on her perceived victimization. It's just embarrassing and pathetic It is now look if we want to take her at face value and believe her that this isn't actually a book about her Okay, I don't believe her personally, but you know Keep that into you know, take that into consideration rather Uh, but just to give you a little bit of an update. So after she responded to my tweet and put me on blast Um, I got mass reported. I mean mass reported Because of what I said to jk rallying But not only was I not suspended because my tweet did not violate twitter's terms of service But now I'm verified. So it seems like I was the winner in this exchange overall All she did was signal boost me and I wasn't the only one because about a month earlier or less than a month earlier Actually, she did the same thing with the vosh tweet and I talked about that I won't play a clip of that but I'll link to that down below if you want to see my video on vosh's exchange With jk rallying, but I just love that she is writing a book now because she's received me and tweets Presumably again We can we can take into account what she said, but we don't have to believe what she said as I don't now Look, do I actually believe that she's basing this book off of uh vosh and my mean tweets to her? No, no I'm not that narcissistic, right? But I do believe that this is probably based at least loosely off of the thousands of people who have criticized her for her transphobic views I think that everybody sees through it Everybody sees through it even like her previous books if you watch contra points video on jk rallying where she read jk rallying's book under the same pen name robert gale breath or whatever Like her book was about a serial killer who dressed as a woman or something like trying to Prime people to believe that trans women pose a threat to women like she constantly writes about trans people Now she's writing about how somebody who said bigoted things was the victim of a hate campaign Not that they participated and hate themselves So she's constantly like trying to make her own Art about herself now and she's falling off like nobody cares about you You're not a victim because you got mean tweets. We all get mean tweets on twitter You are getting criticized rightfully so because you're saying horrible things that is leading to discrimination against a marginalized group of people So, you know keep writing a book about this I just view this as cope But it's embarrassing because like she is a multimillionaire and she literally lives in a fucking castle But she can't stop obsessing over the mean tweets log off jk rallying log off touch grass