 So, einen wunderschönen guten Morgen in Saal-Adams, jetzt kommt... Welcome and good morning to Saal-Adams. This is going to be the year in review by the CCC 2018. On my right is Konstantin Kurz, Linus Neumann, Frank, Erdgeist und Nexus. No Jahresrückblick, like CCC Jahresrückblick 2018, ein großer Applaus. And a big round of applause. So hello and welcome to the year in review of the KS Computer Club. So this is version 1.0 of the congress after we have delivered a better version last year here in Leipzig. We have one room more for the visitors. When we had a look at the pictures about one week ago. So it's very interesting to see that now with 17.000 visitors, it's a great feeling. And we're very happy that you're all here and that's so full. So welcome again. Linus, tell something about the video we saw just a minute ago. That's small balls that were rolling because we are now having the roller blade days here. This was present by Fredrik and his team. So thanks a lot to them. So who's not here for the 35th time? What do we do here in this review of the year? So we are talking about the subjects that were important to the KS Computer Club statements. We did comments to the press that we published regional work that we did. So we saw this congress growing with each year. So we are happy about this growth. We're not going to talk too much in detail about the small things of the clock. But we are also going to focus on the political issues of the digital. So we are focusing on the subjects which are important for society and not on each small little thing of the net politics. So, right now we think that these subjects already have arrived to the Landes and to the national nation politics of Germany. So we start with the structure. So, as you can see, the KS Computer Club is growing. This year we had another growth. So you have to be a little careful about this figure because in 2014 this was a special year. We grew much faster in this year. But as you can see, during the last years still there is a continual growth. So we think that there are many people out there who thinks this is an important idea which we have to back up and therefore thanks a lot to all those people who have decided to support us. So we have to explain, this is Frank talking. We have to explain that this club is only being supported by the members. We are not collecting any money from other companies or governmental sources. And we are very happy about this independence. So we don't have to care for the ideas or the necessities, the requests of the sponsors. This is also something which comes back to the congress here because this congress is being done and supported by all those supporters. And it allows us to give access nearly to everybody here to the congress. And we also try to have the club working in this way. So to be independent from authorities and not to be limited by authorities. So big thanks to all the people who are making this congress possible and who are making possible this club to exist. The office is delivering nice figures. So in this case Reminder from the CCC office. Some of your PGP keys need to be renewed. Sometimes they are missing. So please remind yourself of doing the really PGP control. Most of the people in Germany don't have a PGP key. But okay, there are enough people to make the statistics. So maybe we should also have a look at the e-mail. In this context the key is automatically generated. So members by ... So this is showing people where people come from. So the brighter the color the more people are coming from those places. And where it's dark there we have to still work. And where it's yellow then we can save our forces. So of course it's clear where there are big places, big cities there is more of case computer clubs than in the rural areas. So and of course there are more people in the cities who are looking forward to participating in the subjects. And of course we also have members worldwide. From Germany are not included here. We have a large block from members from Switzerland, from Austria. And also from outside of the European Union from USA and well UK soon to be out of the EU. Yeah, I almost forgot about that. And if you have that many members worldwide then of course there is going to be a lot of interest in these members. So there's going to be a search warrants to be executed. We've had this twice this year. There's going to be a talk today by Kujo and Christine at four o'clock ten past four today. You have to go there. The reason for these search warrants were so absurd. The reason for these search warrants were so absurd that they really show you that search warrants can just happen. There was a travel guide for chaos tourists aimed at political demonstrations in Augsburg and that was used by law enforcement as a call to violence. And this travel guide had a rise-up e-mail address as a contract address. So law enforcement thought, oh, what idiots, they use their own domain. So who's this rise-up? Oh, these people in the USA, they do hosting for political parties. But Zwiebelfreunde in Germany collect donations. So why not just go there and see if ... and let's go to the heads of this association, their families at home, they have families. One person wasn't even there, so their family was searched. Why not? We really need to do something, so why not this? Zwiebelfreunde was going to opposition about this. This is such a strange reason for the search warrant. And it was very quickly declared illegal, but it doesn't mean that the material isn't in the hands of law enforcement for several weeks, including lists of people who not donated. So it's very important to care about your OPSEC, what kind of data you want to keep, how you keep them or don't keep them. So, very important, I think, is ... So, they never assumed that they were actual perpetrators. They assumed they were just people who could provide information. And there was a change since last year. So, witnesses have to answer questions. People who are potential perpetrators do not have this. But as a witness, you cannot encumber yourself. And that is very dangerous. So, if you are a witness in the future to a search warrant, if you are targeted with a search warrant as a witness, then maybe you should probably say, hey, I could hurt myself, so I cannot say anything, because maybe this is just a smarter way to deal with that. The Kaustreff in Dortmund also was visited. The whole house, actually. They are living in a building together with something called Wissenschaftsladen Science Shop. They house several initiatives and have hosting infrastructure for several initiatives. And also, they had something that the French police didn't like, which led to the whole building being searched, searching for this server. They were working on a door in the cellar for quite some time and entered all other rooms. So, they had to fight about whether the Kaustreff Dortmund was searched or if the law enforcement was just there, told them they are not allowed to use a telephone, but it wasn't really a search warrant. It wasn't really a search. They're just looking around. And also, police was very friendly. They told them you must put your phones on this table and can't touch this, which is even illegal with a search warrant. But police didn't detain them. They could have left at any time and just have left the space for the police there. So, that was a very grateful offer. Auch da sehen wir unsere territoriale Integrität. So, we see the territorial integrity of our hackerspaces are threatened here. And we would really like this to stop, but we also would like everyone to be prepared. So, to finish this up, there's two tips for you. First, the ZERD says this object, which is a 3D-printed model of an atomic bomb. ZERD says this is not a butt plug. And another information for you that was necessary, which Datenschleuder gave. So, during a search warrant, there's a gimmick. There's a sticker in the current issue of Datenschleuder, which tells you how to behave when you're being visited. You also shouldn't write it too small and also the numbers from lawyers that you may want to call, even if you're just witness to a search warrant. This is generally early in the morning, so phone numbers and having a list of things you may want to remember, that doesn't hurt. Also, remember, if you don't have the Datenschleuder, but most of them have them already in their postboxes. So we have a group of people who care about this Datenschleuder again. So we can be quite certain, that this group of people is going to continue their work on Datenschleuder. They also have a lot of technical means, which they looked very intensely during the last year to create this Datenschleuder. So a lot of people who were waiting for this were very happy to have a piece of paper, a magazine, again. And there will be a digital version on ds.ccc.de. And thanks again for creating this magazine. And we're going to finish up this member part and go to the content part. But there's a small thing we need to tell you. If you do not have this, it may be because you aren't a member of the CCC. The office is having a table wake and sign up. And if you become a member, you get this for free. And we are happy to be able to provide this after a longer break now. And on Congress you can pay without leaving any electronic traces here on Congress. So you can very secretly, very clandestine, you can become a member of the CCC. And the Datenschleuder, you can also get right here at the office desk. There's also some older volumes available. So let's go to the content part. There's some connections there. It's not only people from Berlin. We also have people from the local groups, Erfa, Erfahrungsaustauschkreis. You have seen the map, so we have a lot of them. People from Hessen came together from Hesse, German State of Hesse, about the Trojan use by the government. It's not about the government Trojan that didn't only want to give that to the law enforcement, but also to intelligence services. That led to widespread protest, not only by civil rights groups, but also by people who were asked to give their professional opinion. This is a logo from Pfiff, which also was invited to give their professional opinion. So there's a lot of aspects in this law, not only the government Trojan, but also a lot of groups came together and collected some factual information about that. We talked about the Police Duties Act. We had a talk about that yesterday. We also gave a written testimony about this together with people from Hesse. And we have some success there, which was quite surprising for me. I was there, there was a demonstration in February, and it didn't look like they would change anything, but the government Trojan isn't going to be allowed for Secret Services, but only for law enforcement, but not the Secret Service. The problem is of course very different, because it's hard to control intelligence agencies. Es gibt viele weitere Polizeigesetze. Es gibt viele mehr Politische Duties. Wir wollen hier nicht in die Details gehen. Die haben aber alle verschiedene Formen von Staatsrädern erhalten. Sie haben alle Types von Trojans in ihnen. Ich denke, es ist eine Form des Eröffnungs-Agenziens. Aber auf der anderen Seite haben wir mehr Protests gesehen. Die Proteste, die auf die Beine gestellt hat, die, glaube ich, bundesweit ausgestrahlt hat. Wir sehen hier z.B. aus Hannover. In der Picture sieht man die Demonstration in Hannover. Es gibt auch viele andere Gruppen, die nach diesem Thema gesetzt wurden. Es gab auch ein Gespräch gestern. Wenn Sie mehr Details haben wollen, können Sie sich bei den Protesten mit angeschaut haben. Die Chaos-Computer-Club war auch in den größten Assemblies in der Erfahrung gebracht. In dem Vortrag ist schon vieles angesprochen worden. Ich habe schon mehrere Dinge erwähnt. Ich war in Hannover und Hesse auch in der Aktion. Das war eine der größten Demonstrationen, die wir für einen langen Zeit hatten. Was dort eigentlich für Gruppen gleichzeitig angepackt war. Wie viele Gruppen, die in Niedersachsen bewegen können, haben sich sogar Fußball-Gruppen gegen den Polizistakt engagiert? Wer in Hannover schon nahe der Station war, war ein Fußball-Game. Er weiß, dass es nicht leichter ist, in diesem Bereich zu gehen, als die Kontrollen waren. Die Polizei hat gesagt, es waren 8.300 Teilnehmer. Die Polizei hat gesagt, es waren 8.300 Teilnehmer. Die Organisier haben gesagt, es waren 15.000 Teilnehmer. So ist es fast immer so. Das hat mir das mal von oben an zu gucken. Da unterhielt man sich die Polizei. Ich hatte die Chance, einen Blick auf die Höhe von Upper Buff. Das war aber eine halbe Stunde, bevor die Demo losgingen sollte. Die Leute, die da waren, sagten, es waren rund 5.000 Teilnehmer. Aber das war eine halbe Stunde, bevor das begann. Die Fragen, die wir später fragen, wie die Nummer kalkuliert war, waren nicht für uns kommuniziert. Sie wollten das nicht sagen. Es waren nur 8.300 Teilnehmer. Wir sagen, es waren rund 15.000 Teilnehmer. Es ist eine interessante Konstellation. Es war nicht erster Zeit, weil es dann immer so war, dass die Zeitstilverfahren nicht wertvoll ist. Es war eine Art Körpflug mit Beginnungsstätten. Die Entfernung in Deutschland war ein soupesdemontiert. Es war eine Art Körpflug mit Beginnungsstätten. Das ist ein milker Körpflug. Es war eine Art Körpflug, was für ein essensvoller Kompromiss war. Das war nicht der Fall. Ich habe die Überraschung, dass die Menschen, die diese Läume organisieren, die Überraschung haben, dass die Menschen nicht verstehen, dass wir nur diese Läume machen, um Terrorismus zu kämpfen. Die Menschen auf der anderen Seite sind gefährlich, was sie in die Prüsen sind, aber was tun wir mit den Menschen, die realen Terroristen sind? Es ist nicht klar, wo der Unterschied zwischen einer gefährlichen Person und einer realen Terrorist ist. Es ist nicht klar. Also ist es für Beispiel eine Person, die mit einem Railway-Transport von einem Custer-Transport interferiert? Ist es ein Terrorist? Und dieses Problem des nicht exikten Limits zwischen einer gefährlichen Person und einer Terrorist, ist ein Problem in allen Regionen in Deutschland. Und das ist warum es wichtig ist, dass man sich über diese Läume beschäftigt. Wir haben hier auch noch einige Requests. Wir werden die Debatte 2019 verhalten, weil noch nicht alle ... Wir werden diese Debatte in 2019 noch nicht verhalten, weil noch nicht alle ... Es ist natürlich nicht nur auf den Terroristen, sondern auch auf die Biometrie. Es ist ein Automatik von weiterer DNA-Analysis. Es ist eine unpräventive Aktion der Polizei. Das sind Diskussionspunkte. Wer möchte mehr Informationen über das bekommen, kann diese ... Wir sind sehr glücklich über jemanden, der in 2019 engagiert wird. Wenn ihr euch erinnert, da macht man vielleicht einen kleinen Rückgriff, auch dass wir davor machen können. Wir haben vor einem Jahr ein Problem mit diesem Telekom-Router. Wir haben versucht, in dem Prozess in dem Telekom-Router zu sein, war es natürlich eine ziemlich instable Qualität. Danach haben wir einen Prozess auf den öffentlichen Level mit den BSI und den Ministerien. Und das ist, was TR stands für, eine technische Regulierung für Routers. Wir hatten mehrere Requests mit den Freifunkern und den WRT-Leuten. Und mit den WRT-Kommunitäten. Es gab verschiedene Meetings, verschiedene Kommentare, die wir jetzt in die erste Runde handeln haben. Für die Menschen, die engagiert werden, war es ein bisschen frustrierend. Weil dieser erste Rund, der Lobbyist des Kabelproviders, eigentlich gewonnen ist. Mit den worsten Meetings in den Meetings. So in dem Ende ist es eigentlich eine sehr tumble Regulierung, die mehr oder weniger Regulierung auf den Cannes steht. Also unser Ziel dabei war, dass es eigentlich eine Möglichkeit war, für Routers zu differenzieren auf die Sicherheitsupdates, die mandatory sein sollten. Und auch in der Frequenz, die diese Updates senden. Und wir wollten auch in der Politik, dass das mandatory war. So, jetzt haben das Cannes Rules. Es war also viel Arbeit für uns. Und die BSI, die German Authority for Infrastructure Security. Sie waren nicht glücklich. Also wir denken, es wird in der zweiten Runde gehen. Und wir schauen forward to what will be the result from this second round. Also ich bin wirklich dissapointed from this process. Two years after this failure of the router, this regulation is coming out. And actually in this regulation, there is nothing which would harm the suppliers. So, actually they put out the suppliers, put out the stuff that they had out two years before. This what we already have, this we changed already. For the people who were on site, it was very frustrating that they were discussing far off the topic. So all alternative firmware, I think this is a very important request. Actually to have a free firmware. This is the only possibility to have old gadgets still running. So there was old gadgets. There is no new firmware which fills in all the security legs. It's something which is not supported anymore by suppliers. And of course they are not being run anymore by suppliers. And these are subject for attacks. I think we had a special moment where about 100,000 gadgets were concerned. And afterwards we had quite critical reporting on this. On the other side we had the press reports by the different supply associations. So I hope that although this momentum is lost now, but I still hope that there will be another momentum which will force suppliers to act in this area. So this was a joke, this TR, I would like to put this in. All these discussions work like this, all that are sitting at the table. They have the idea to have a distinguishing element, especially concerning foreign suppliers. This feature is also something which could be implied, implemented by the Chinese suppliers. So is this not sufficient? So, they would like to put something on the package, which is impressing and therefore they can have higher prices. The goal is to have it as a process and to put the date on. This is well until a special date. Now you can only put it on the website and with any other further obligations. For us the main thing we noticed was the BSI didn't really work well in this case. We were really wondering what is the BSI doing anyway. And where are they? There are a lot of lobbyists. Even though the people were sometimes clearly telling the false statements, nobody was correcting them. So if they want to create standards for technical security in the digital space, they have to be more active. They have to be able to enforce these regulations und moderates a discussion between lobbyists. I think it is important that there is a BSI, which is a civil body, but in the way they are organized right now and the way they are acting, that's not helping. However, let's go to brighter news. If the BSI doesn't do anything, then the community has to be the one who does the work. In this case I'm talking about Freifunk, who are very close to us, both in terms of technical exchange as well as tools for digital, for example with refugee camps and in schools with the Kausmachschule Project. Freifunk also is very active. They also have a very large assembly here at the 35C3. They had a problem during the year that in some parts of Germany they were accepted as tax exempt, but in Schleswig-Holstein they did have some support, but it wasn't successful to get them declared tax exempt. In November, I think, maybe it was exhova by CDU, Green Party and FTP. They were accepted to be tax exempt. The SPD had another idea which didn't really make a lot of difference. CCC was asked, what do you think about giving them tax-exempt status? It wasn't very hard for us. We were ready to write a larger, short statement where we were very warmly supporting them. The for-free work they are doing for tens of years now, it should really have more acceptance. We were very happy that they were accepted in the end and they are now able in most parts of Germany to cooperate without barriers. We are very happy that our work here paid off. We are not quite as happy. There was a project at a station, larger station, rather new station in Berlin, Südkreuz. There was a pilot project, pilot phase. They were testing three commercial companies for phase recognition. It was a project by a former Minister de Miser who went there twice himself, which increased press coverage. But his successor didn't really talk about that at all, except for a small statement after it was done, which was only at the end of this year. He didn't really push this as his prestige project, but at least they were giving a statement after it was closed. And the final statement from the Federal Police, they were essentially, so we told them that it was a really unscientific really not truthful, sorry, I'm getting enraged again. They are not even trying to, we have a working group within the CCC and they are not even giving us the numbers so we are able to see what happened. At least, they got the negative prize by larger statistical organizations here in Germany for this. It's not scientific at all, it's not able to look at, and then they combined all the three manufacturers to get recognition rates that aren't super terrible. And within the DAW, they only had recognition rates around 10, it's all just 10-12%, it's all just very terrible. The whole project is being continued slightly differently without biometrics, but with anomaly detection. We want to see fast movements when someone falls down, for example. So they are now going to hire actors. So the computer knows what these kinds of scenes look like. And we are really hoping these kinds of actors, so we are gladly volunteering to become these actors. There's a lot of things to be said about that, in the year-end review. We don't have that much time. There's another project, for example, in Mannheim with 76 cameras that also want to look at biometric data. And that's, of course, it's not really video surveillance, it's biometric surveillance. And people are confusing these. But it seems that the German Minister of Interior doesn't really seem to show any interest, or very, very little interest. And we're going to continue watching this in the second phase when there's no biometric measurements anymore. We've had a lot of fun there. We were going down the escalators with masks on. But we shouldn't accept the normalization of biometric data collection neither at Sudkreuz nor anywhere else. And in Hamburg, there was very encouraging results where the person concerned with privacy was very much working towards getting this database deleted. So, we don't want to have from the children to the very old person 500 million people indexed. And we're going to continue this fight in 2019. Man sollte dazu noch mal kurz... Wollen Sie noch jemand was sagen zu Sudkreuz? Okay. Does anyone want to add something? I want to say something very fundamental. This face recognition, the fact that it didn't work, the fact that they are lying about how it kind of worked, shouldn't confuse us about the real problem. The fact that this technology doesn't work in the beginning doesn't mean that it's not going to be introduced on a greater scale. And the problem is these networks of surveillance cameras are being connected to computers. If you look at what's happening in Asia, networks of thousands of cameras are being connected using fiber to the cloud. Oh, ja, maybe that's a way to finally get fiber at the railway stations. Also, wir sollten uns auch nicht davon abhalten lassen, dass wir Deutschland als... Ja, we shouldn't kid ourselves. We may not have the great internet connection, but these surveillance systems that are under development right now, depending on face recognition, they are going to be combined with data from smartphones. Like how are you walking? So many cameras are analyzing the style in which you walk. So we shouldn't be concentrated too much about facial recognition, but the connected detection of many people and their behavior and that's what this is about. Last year we were talking about the German Identity Card Law, EID Law, the EID Law, which creates a central biometric database, which already exists. So we are talking about facial recognition in stations, while there already exists a biometric database. And after 10 years it's going to be complete because everyone has to get a new ID card within this time frame. And the surveillance, which is everywhere, well, the minister didn't repeat it, but the commercial biometric surveillance also has made great strides. And especially great projects like in New Orleans by Palantir, which I believe are more advanced than these manufacturers we've seen in Südkreuz. And we can now continue to the next great debacle. ZITIS is a project from 2018. They are attached to the University of the Bundeswehr in Berlin. We see the entry here. Andre Meister has taken the photograph for us. And we remember that ZITIS is being led by someone from the BND Secret Service or who used to work for BND. And they are trying to hack us to work for them. We are not very unhappy that people don't really want to work there or who need employment urgently. It's great to see that they get management people but not as fast that they want it, but they don't find someone to manage, so management seems to work but not what they want to manage. So the debate about that wasn't very surprising, but just the beginning of it. We were talking about hackback in the political space, which is about countering active attacks by disabling the infrastructure that's used for it. And there was a very interesting statement by the scientific service of the German parliament, which showed many legal problems. And that's not only a problem for ... it's not only supposed to be used by German government agencies, but also by the Army, the Bundeswehr. And there's the ADIC, ADAC, Agency for Disruptive Innovations in Cyber Security. I'm not making this up. And von der Leyen Horst Seehofer presented this. And for some reason they left out a D afterwards. So the disruptive wasn't even too weird for them. So it's just AIC. We don't know where the D was left. Unfortunately, we didn't get much information when the two were speaking. Von der Leyen basically was like DARPA. So it's basically ... it's providing ... I mean, it's very important for humanity. It does have some military background, but it brought us the internet. Yeah, she didn't mention the drones, the predator drones. And we need to look at this from the background. Since two or three years in Germany there's a fight going on about how cybersecurity architecture, like they say, how this is supposed to look like, which agency should actually be concerned with what. And the disruptive agency here. We just really love this word. It's one piece of the puzzle. And it's about trying to create a central point that supplies these kind of tools. And they were trying to not talk about attack, but more about defense. But everyone who is concerned with this, in this process, in the political process, they are saying that it's ... they're trying to forge attack tools there. And I just want to interject here. I want to make a warning about hacking back. What they are telling us, we're almost making the same points here. But the idea is that attack is happening right now. It's going forward into our systems. And it needs to be stopped to prevent larger damage. But the attacks we see that is in progress and you can stop it while it's in progress. That's not how it works. So they always use denial of service attacks here. Because in a data breach, the data has been breached. So what else is going to happen? So it's very hard to define a scenario where a hackback is even potentially helpful. So I'm now imagining the ADIC or CTIS or whatever. They are sitting with their coffee in the morning and then the general comes in and says, this email address, this IP address. And then they fetch their keyboards and hack. That's not how it works. Yeah, but that's how they imagine it. And I don't think they are so stupid. I think they try to get the authorization to hack. And then they can always say, well if we hadn't hacked them then it would have been even worse. So it's according to the law. But we won't get a law that defines clearly what a hackback is and what is not. At the end of this debate, they won't have offensive cyber capabilities. Because if they want to use them, then they have to infiltrate systems earlier so they are able to turn it off later when it attacks. And that's where we don't want to go. And I think we were very clear about this. So I would like to point out what the research agencies of the parliament have discovered and published. So the statement is clear. We have a defense army. But also other authorities have stated that it's not a possibility to change this situation. We have a defense army and this cannot be changed. It would be illegal. Currently that's our right. Even if it fits them or not, this is where we have to stand for. Therefore we had to put something in Britain. This current debate actually is to define the position. Where is the Federal Republic of Germany to be located? Shall the offensive possibility be limited? In BND, in the security agency, we are not sure how much offensive possibilities there are. Will Deutschland damit den großen Jungs mitspielen? Germany wants to play with other big players. But it seems that Germany would like to do this. This positioning to state, we don't want to have this. We want a defensive strategy. We laid this down to point this out. And to make clear, there are also other ways. There are some think tanks between authorities and the German military to define under what rules we are allowed to do offensive operations. But as you can come up with practical examples, the last attack to infrastructure of the German authorities when the Russians came in, what actually did you want to hack back? Do you want to hack Gmail, because you have a Trojan? So it's rather difficult technically but also politically. So the real examples, they actually do not like. So they always say, okay, this is a secret. There are more examples but we are not allowed to tell you. So we say, okay, we are in a really good position. We would like to have a defensive strategy and we should have defensive measures. And we made concrete suggestions. For example, characterising gadgets, inter-connected incentive programs, educational programs to know how to program in a secure way, but also insurance as if you have secure, or if you state you have secure gadgets, then you should also be liable for this, in case this is attacked. And of course there is the aspect of international contracts. Of course internationally it's really difficult to control those operations. It may be possible to account the Trojans, but in other situations also the states, the nations are trying to stick to those contracts. So unfortunately in the cyber security area it's a little difficult to have international contracts in the United States and Great Britain are currently not very willing to have this. So the idea is to have defensive agreements and not set up offensive possibilities. Yeah, we also want to have, to show clearly, clear position what concerns the think tanks that are giving information to the government. So as a European country we need to request those things. Internationally and on the academic side. Also internationally lawyers they come up and they try to figure out what possibilities there would be. So we wanted to make a statement where we hope to find also people who are joining in to enhance this defensive strategy. In Bezug auf die internationalen Forderungen. So this is now concerning international requests on responsible inclusion. This means it's also the request to have no backdoors and software. On the other hand, yeah, there is the request from agencies to have backdoors to get inside the software. And actually this is a continuation of crypto wars. Especially this has been forced from the side of the five eyes. So in Australia they have just one. So the law in Australia has already put in force. So they offer in Australia there's a service which is offered with encryption but there's an implemented debut actor. So it will be very interesting how the big technology suppliers will stick to this. Clear is that this strategy which is overhead could also be foreseen. So encrypting is okay. What about decryption? So the background is that the big security agencies yes, the encryption is being done without the users knowing this. So it's implemented in WhatsApp, for example. You even don't recognize it. So they have ubiquitous encryption. So and this really makes work of secrecy agencies more difficult. So this is actually quite good. Otherwise they would not react in this way. So they will try to implement backdoors not only here in the five eyes sectors but also here in Europe. So we have to be alert. So they always argue okay those bad terrorists so that's why the government needs to be able to look into what is happening in the size of communication. So be alert. There will be those discussions and talks where this is requested. So coming back to the drone and discussion. So actually FBI has already been well-trapped. There was somebody in parliament who has always questions again. And they were discovered changing, manipulating the figures. So the request was we want to have figures. And that's the main point. What they want to have it for those Trojans it's actually cannot be proved by figures. So it's very important to have offensive requests to get hard facts and not rely on the felt. So something more which will be here with us for the next years. It's always quite difficult to talk in this area because this is the bigger crowd which is not addicted to Facebook. Although most of us do not have an account with Facebook but of course you are also concerned. And this has been made clear by the Cambridge Analytica scandal. So the debate actually it has switched from a privacy discussion to the bigger question how about being safe from manipulation. We know much more now but we won't go into the details right now here. I will do on day 4 within the Dachwitz in an own talk. We will have a look back on the Facebook scandal and the micro targeting debate. So it was a really disastrous year for this advertising company. So this subject will continue to be with us in the future. So we need to be very clear about this. It's not about data being lost. It's about having the power to manipulate to accumulate as much data from so many people by so few people leads to a situation that is very hard to control. And the very important point is it doesn't make sense to focus on the technical details. We are seeing right now that the election in Brazil they are using different technical methods. They were using WhatsApp groups and similar chat groups. But they were also based on profiling. They were also targeting people. What it's dis about is political manipulation by accumulating data. So it's not just about Facebook. It's about all these data companies. And I almost thought they were shooting us. Are they dis angry? Okay, no. One important point is to mention that these networks and systems that are collecting data and creating profiles of us are meant to manipulate us. Whether this is done through advertisements or political manipulation we should keep that in mind. It doesn't matter which system it is. Creating profiles, creating personality profiles from us that are explaining how we are working in our insights, not just from the outside. But they know better than we know how we are working as a human being. They are made for exactly what this is being used for. There are companies where when you get internet it includes Facebook. So you are using it every day. And once you want to look at the rest of the internet you have to pay for it. If you look at both of these trends they are not able to properly use their responsibility for political discourse. Especially Facebook has shown to be deficient in this case with Analytica. And they are using their position as a sole provider of information that they are curating themselves. Partly automatic, they are actually curating it themselves. So if you look at Malaysia for example they don't have personnel there to react to the worst cases even. So there are no native speakers that could react to hate speech in the Facebook network. So these two factors combined I'm really afraid of these. And it's creeping into our networks. There's a by Vodafone I think, Deutsche Telekom and Vodafone are doing zero rating offers. And you have to look at the fact that the internet is decentralized. And it has been in decline during the last years. So more and more people are being confronted with the internet via Facebook. So when Facebook is down they are recharging their phones because they think they don't have any money anymore. So this is when the companies win. Once these companies are big enough they are unhappy with the fact that they don't even exist. And so it may happen that the rest of the internet vanishes for most of the people. Because you have to pay more money or even have to pay any money at all to see anything outside of this corporate network. Vodafone has done this in Germany by adding passes. And it's always a problem for the bloggers, service providers that are not included. So us, for example, the C3 Video Operations Centre, the VOC, we would like to extend our thanks to them for their work. All of the CCC events and some related events filmen them, streamen them, put them on the internet. It's a lot of work over the course of the year and they have a video-on-demand portal which provides a lot of great entertainment. There's the stickers, media, CCCDE and CHIL. You can do that together with your friends thanks to the VOC. All of the operating offers always targets the most data-hungry services. So they say, hey, we have to do bandwidth management, so you get Netflix, YouTube for free, maybe audio streaming and then the only thing that's left is really just porn. Oh, it's not included. What's left is the rest of the internet which costs money now. And they are saying, hey, it's great what you get for free. But the difference from the other side is what you have to pay for now. And I can't see the case when you look at some times of the day, Netflix is 90% of the traffic of the internet. So we can't provide for them because we don't have the bandwidth for them. We have a written report. A written report used to be called, DirektIP is now called, Bundesnetzagentur as the Federal Regulation Agency for the networks in Germany. And there were very difficult Law-Question regarding European law which is very hard for us because we are a club of hackers. But we are providing a lot of content which is being discriminated against and that's what we put out in this report. It's also available on CCDE like all our other reports. And I just want to make clear that we have fought long and hard for net neutrality in Europe and we think zero rating is covered by that. And the Bundesnetzagentur said, well under some circumstances it may be possible for a provider to do that kind of offers. So first of all they have to do it everywhere where they are acting. Also in the EU-Roman. And they said, well we can't afford that. So we just ignore it. And the last update was that there were some punishments issued. So Deutsche Telekom said, now we're not going to pay for that. We're going to file an lawsuit against this. So that's very cheeky from them. So when non-technical people talking about net neutrality, I was confronted with a lot of negative energy. Customers that pay for stream on or the Vodafone pass, they see how this is beneficial for them. So they get it because they want some special stream and they don't want this to be taken away. So it's a very hard discussion to have. We need to explain to them what the problem is. And it was very hard for me to talk to people who bought this, who thought they could save using these offers. And it was very hard. And I think this is a call to action to all of you. I think it's very important, interesting that I'm paying for something so I'm saving money, which I think it's very interesting to do that. You pay for something additionally. It's like when there's an offer for children's diapers and you buy them because they're cheap. And if you buy two of them, you've saved twice. The other side of the issue is where we could go to Vodafone as the CCC and say, hey, we have this streaming portal with this great content. How do these contracts look? If somebody has a copy of one of these contracts, we would really love to read it. But maybe they are individual with each content provider. Is that all we have to say about net neutrality? Okay, so let's continue with something less happy. So, data retention is a law in Germany, but it is currently not enforced because there are lawsuits against them. So we have a very complex situation. So it is law in Germany, but it's not enforced. And the question about this conflict is going to haunt us next year as well. The government, of course, wants data retention. The courts disagreeing. But this is going to continue, not only in Germany, but also in the European Union. And one of the problems is that the European Court of Law has issued a lawsuit that is widely ignored. They are saying, essentially, you cannot store telecommunication data without course. It's not according to European law, and they are trying to get around it. But we have a second layer here that we want to talk about it. It's partly a good thing, partly a bad thing. In addition to the European Court of Law, there is also the European Human Rights Law. There were some verdicts that are also concerning contents of communication. Ten NGOs from the UK, mostly, and me as a private citizen. We won this case. But not in all the details. So it was against the British government and GCHQ and the acts that allowed them to collect this data and filter and select on it, including the restrictions they face. And some of that is against Human Rights Convention, which is a great success. But the same year in Sweden, it was also about mass surveillance, but it was from a different part of the court and they were saying essentially the opposite, which said, well, that is still acceptable on the human rights. In both cases, people were complaining about it. I think they have a great chance to win it because the second verdict was issued afterwards. Also in our case, someone was attacking the verdict. So even in the GCHQ court case, where they accept the part of the surveillance, they were responding to this. So there is going to be another hearing and we hope that the mass surveillance is going to be made impossible. But still we have to say in great Britain it still continues. Maybe also a call for action to all. The development which actually frustrates me a little bit. We have to stick to the results of these courts actually also arrive in politics and politicians going to Karlsruhe und influencing the laws. So they shouldn't ignore the results of those laws as the German government actually did it. Since one year there is a very cool webmailer, der Stinkwebmailer in Offer. So, if you have used a governmental exam, then you have to use it. So we had a closer look about what lawyers thought of. So it is a system, it should be a system where courts and lawyers should communicate amongst each other with signature. It is a piece of Java. We have to install it. In version 1 it comes with a secret key to be installed. So they drew it back, they reworked it. The back end now seems better. In some operating system still is not optimal. I have a friend, I have the pleasure to keep this system up to date. So what do they do? They have pop-ups when you want to have a new message to be sent up. So, probably they have developed it for a browser in certain optimisation. So, actually this system is failed. But actually I would like to go on and where is this project. So, I tried to make this open source. And this is really a big point for me. It may not be that the authorities of our country are not able to force people to, or those companies. So, they now have a new version on Apple and other systems. In January the new patch is awaited. So, for us here this should be the case. And half an hour later there is the pull request. So, we have to point out very clear that we have the competences and we have the community who is interested in those projects. Please let us help as we did in the last years. Please do public source and accept our patches. This is critical infrastructure and therefore it has to be open source. Another thing that we discussed this was this year the results of the General Data Protection Regulation which came very unexpected. Everybody was panicking. What is happening now? We are now being, the internet won't work anymore. We get warnings over and over, can't do anything more. I myself got lots of mails from people who asked me for, well please sign this declaration, stay on my mailing list. So it was like everybody waking up. We already had this demand for a data letter. So we would like to know if somebody has stored our data. And with this GDPR we actually have got this because all of those companies that want to send mail to me and letters they have to inform me, yes, we do have your data. So, would you like to be on our mailing list? Yes, please. So there are still some problems with the GDPR. But nevertheless, some of the results that are not so great. They are due to some lawyers who are actually making others feel not so comfortable. So, we think that most of the effects are positive. The negative effects we see on the corners. It's mostly the governments. They actually now stop giving access to information, to information freedom with the argument of data protection to privacy. So, but nevertheless, all of this panicking actually has not become true. So when the discussion at the beginning of the year, when we came near the data protection officer of our country to get more information on this topic, to get some more hints, unfortunately there was nothing at all about this. But nevertheless, in December in Parliament this year she stated this discussion about the GDPR, she commented it. So, she stated, okay, authorities should have delivered more information to people. So, actually, the problem was that the not giving information was caused by the authorities. And now Mrs. Fossoff will resign. It will be Mr. Kelber, who will take the new, will be new data protection officer. And he has already declared that the GDPR is one of his central topics. So, I hope there will be a turnaround of this topic. And also how we recognized how companies deal with processing of our data. So, what we stated already several years, but what we stated, well, how important this task is, or this office is for the nation, we hope it will be easy to make it better than before. So, one of his main tasks will be to get the national GDPR data protection regulation going. So, actually it was not the topic of the CCC, because it's rather legal. Yeah, but it's not possible to have a new legislation on privacy every year just to be able to inform ourselves. So, the other part, half part of the companies who didn't give me information that they had my data. So, in some of those companies and accounts, I actually didn't look that up for years. It would have been better if there would be some legal information that my data is with them, and they are informing me actively once per year. So, it has become rather natural to have those data and to store them in the database. And, yes, from some time of time maybe we have some algorithm which collects and retrieves some additional information from this data mountain. So, actually it's important to ask the question, why is it important to collect the data, when people are, for example, accessing my website. In this case of CCC, we don't have any logging now when accessing the CCC website. So, that's what we have in our data protection declaration. We don't log anything, and that's my favorite privacy declaration. Maybe that's an idea for you to check with your systems, just switch it off, and then you don't have any problem of thinking of data protection declarations or privacy declarations on your site. Well, we as the CCC are not as quite close to economic groups, close to economy. Okay, this is the next topic for me. There are a few more commissions with this picture in the Chancellor's Office of the Digital Council. There is the Data Ethic Commission, and the Bundestag has a commission, for artificial intelligence. So, there is a focus of this government on digital topics, but we can see that in the other legislatures periods the experts of these commissions are there, but at the same time the strategic papers are put out, like with the topic of artificial intelligence, where there was strategy paper in autumn, where the focus was on economic politics and more data in the sense of what the government does. An interesting thing where this happens again, where you hold the experts, but you just do it anyways, and we'll look for the results of these commissions, especially for the Data Ethics Commission. They have shown in the beginning that they are not really like a case of the government and corporations. We'll see what these commissions will do. I think, I hope they won't give too much money to a private company, the Deutschland Institut, of artificial intelligence. This Enquete Commission for the AI is there to put a lot of money into sciences that will bring us up close with Google. I know this is the Enquete Commission. We have to differentiate between a government and a parliament that wants some experts. Of course there will be a lot of economic people in there. We have to do a bit faster, but we still have to say something about the Secret Services. What's important to me in 2018 is the first year where the Ministry of the Interior, the State Secretary said the State Trojan should be put into law. That's not the priority of Horst Seehofer. We know of, but they stated this. It was a big scandal year for the Secret Services. We don't really have to say it with Amok President running Amok. Using conspiracy theories, the European Secret Service Chief, weeks later doubling down on that with a commission on Anis Amri, really hard failure of Secret Services and a lot of lies with connection people with Molds in right-wing groups. What do we need these for? They are expensive. We should abolish them after Starbucks hacked their Vayne Detection Technology. That's not enough applause. The impression is that some here may be already be used to the Secret Services. Well, we are working on more positive things as well. Something I could not attend, which was very sad, but it's very important. And we already hinted at it at the RouterTR. We have to think about it a bit. How to go with digital services with logically sound concepts. The names with trees work together with different organizations, Bits and Trees, B&E, Bread for the World, 5th OKF, Technik University Berlin. Thinking about brainstorming, how we could do digitalization in a democratic, just world. And what do we need to have digitalization in connection with resources, democratic and just world, what we can afford. And if you look around a bit, digitalization from my view is a privilege for people who can afford it. And it's the case that much of the technologies we use, that we buy, throw away again, like a smartphone every two years, are produced on the base of resources that are limited and like mind under harsh conditions in countries by people who can't afford these technologies. And we have to do a lot here in society and on a geopolitical scale. It's definitely an important thing for the future. What we want, you can read at tcc.de. The walk was very great. They recorded everything. If you want to educate yourself a bit, you can learn a lot there. So, please watch these talks. I recommend it. A lot of people came surprisingly. It's an important topic to a lot of people. I apparently hope we can go at it with more power next year. OK. Wir haben uns auch sehr gefreut. Yeah, we are also very happy about this. Es ist wie Robots, Bolz charging, after a red cape. One of the topics that we had to discuss with CCC work and this event, the question of killer robots, so weaponized autonomous systems. There was a try on an international level to build something on this but the greater powers didn't want this. We don't want this. We don't want to limit these systems. We think it's a big problem since, of course drone technology autonomous systems is in the hacker scene as a core topic and next year we'll have to do more here on a technical level this won't happen. Same thing that we are trying to reach with Secret Services in Germany but nobody will work for them. I think on a similar way we have to do this with autonomous weaponized systems. Next, we are very delighted to release a movie here tonight. A filmmaker called Sandra Trostl has worked on this documentary for several years, including CCC summer camp. I think the first recordings were at camp and then there are two congresses included as well. This movie is basically about the events organized by CCC and the people who are involved in these events. It's really received really good critiques so far. And I think those critiques are also really an applause for us and everyone here because it's about the great world and the great environment that we have created here. And after a lot of effort, this movie is finally ready. We're very happy and it will be released under Creative Commons license tonight. So it will be freely available to everyone online. But that's not enough. Sandra will also soon release a platform, probably sometime next year, where all the raw material that she had for the movie will be released. So that's something like 70 hours of raw materials, so that all of us, including you, can basically make our own CCC movies using all the material that she used and that she didn't use. So I think that is really a pretty unique thing to do as far as I know, something that hasn't really happened. So not just releasing the movie in Creative Commons, but then also releasing the entire raw material and all of that. And all of that using the CCC privacy demands. So the first person who has counted all the pixels, who has counted all the pixels out, and with that Luckily I can download the movie online for free. And tonight the official premiere happens with the official release. Some of you may have already seen it in the cinema. And inspired maybe by the Case Computer Club und vielleicht auch bei unserem Motto letztes Jahr. Es gibt einen extra Dokumentation-Team. Es ist ein Film von Wauholland und die Creation-Historie der KS Computer Club. Sie fragen euch für Material für dieses Film. Der Weltkanzler von Meta, Energie und Information. Meta und Energie, unlimited. Information ist unlimited. Und es ist die einzige Möglichkeit, ich werde nur sagen, was in diesem Videoclip gesagt wird. Und weil das die CCC hat gefunden. Das ist ein Kurs der world of smart devices. Das ist etwas, das wir heute mit mehr und mehr konfrontiert haben, ob man es will oder nicht. Und jetzt bin ich nur auf die Computer geholt. Es gibt strange Menschen mit strange Maschinen. Die Information hat einen Preis heute und wir haben auch einen Preis in der Zukunft. Und der Chaos-Computer-Klub wird auch in der Zukunft in der Zukunft existieren. Ich denke, die basicen Reisen sind für mich mehr wichtig. Wir sind noch immer für eine ungewöhnliche und authentische Foto- und Filmphotos von der ersten Chaos-Jahre. Also, wenn ihr da noch über Materialien verfügt, Fotos, Bilder, Videos, alles gerne gesehen und gesucht habt. Also, wenn ihr Material- und Fotos-Film habt, dann schaut euch vor. Letztes Jahr hatten wir auch ein Learning-Prozess, das wir jetzt dokumentieren wollen. Und der Result des Learning-Prozesses ist wie hier. Wir haben eine relativ bittere Weise gelernt, nicht alle Menschen wissen, was Teams wir haben. Hier für die Sicherheit, das Gefühl von Sicherheit. Das ist ein Dessert, für medizinische und größere Ingenieure. Der Warnesteam für Konflikte, Attacken, Konflikte hat sich emotional gut gefühlt, dass ihr Reise und Respekt habt, dass ihr jemanden sprechen könnt, wenn das nicht der Fall ist. Konflikte, Konflikte, und für ein paar Jahre jetzt eine spezielle Unterstützung für die Menschen im Autospektrum. Das ist jetzt ein formaler Team, das für die Menschen in der Veranstaltung hilft, nach der Konferenz zu machen. Das letzte Jahr war das nicht für das erste Jahr, aber für das erste Mal. Wir wollten, die Menschen aus der Veranstaltung aus dem Event präventiv haben, dass wir das nur nach sehr schweren Dingen gemacht haben. Aber wir haben nicht einen normalen Prozess gemacht. Wir haben niemanden, der vor dem Event gefragt hätte. Das letzte Jahr haben wir über das gefällt, dass wir nicht wissen, dass es ein Konflikt ist. Vor dem Event wissen wir, dass die Person, die dort ist, von dort zu hindern. Und wir hatten, nach der Konferenz, das war generell, ein Konkret, ein Hanging over, das war nicht mehr. Wir haben auf den Event mit vielen Menschen, mit vielen Experten, in verschiedenen Bereichen, Psychologie, Psychiatrie, Systemik, Juristische Experten, die das machen, um ein Prozess zu haben, das nicht explodiert ist. Das ist nicht explodiert. Es hat den Fokus, um Menschen zu helfen und zu unterstützen. Wir wollen nicht etwas, wie, dass dieser Person nicht erlaubt, der Person nicht erlaubt, aber wir wollen ein Supportsystem für die Community. Man kann das sehen. Es gibt Arbeitsplätze für die Jurispräsentation, und wir denken, nach 10 Monaten Arbeit haben wir das gemacht. Wir haben einen sehr neutralen Ort mit Menschen, die den CCC vertrachten, die Experten haben für die Events, für die Vereine, für die Themen, die wir arbeiten haben. Und ich denke, wir können einen Applaus für diese Menschen, weil sie sehr emotional und hart arbeiten. Und wir müssen sie von unseren Herz bedanken. Jetzt gehen wir an. Okay, das ist ein Bereich, in dem wir ein bisschen skipfen müssen, weil wir nicht so viel Zeit haben. Aber es ist wichtig, weil Arbeit und regionalen CCCs sehr wichtig sind. Wir können das nicht tun. Wir können nicht die ganze Geschichte erzählen. Wir müssen ein bisschen chooseen und ein paar Spotlines auf Dinge, wo wir hoffen, dass andere Leute das tun, wie wir das tun. Das Ding ist, dass die CCCs Handwerk oder Legwerk das Klub ist so sehr groß. Wir können nicht wirklich alles wissen. Die meisten of you maybe don't know that there is in your Alpha Kreis an Alpha Kreis. It's very good to just go there and take a look. When I saw the Plenum Protocols from the Alpha Kreis on our mailing list I saw that there are forms for very interesting things from within our community where we are saying this congress feeling take it back with you home. It's important this is just four days after all and we have to bring it back into society. This is not in some vacuum. It's happening in the Air Force. It's happening there. The Air Force are inviting like the Assemblies. We are inviting to have a space to come together to work on projects or ideas. This is happening in the Air Force in der Machtschule is there in a lot of Alpha Kreis. We are teachers are supporting workshops where students get to know about digital citizenship and this picture I will show you I asked the Alpha circles like to present themselves to tell us what's been important for them this year or next year some people called back with photos or without and this is in München, Munich. So for example in Munich they cooperated with a class of the police academy where they created a flip board which is mobile and so they had these posters which they had to actually carry or drive around. Oh, it's a movie. So they created basically a poster for demonstrations but that can be changed so you can reuse it every single time and you don't have to reprint posters for every single demonstration and sometimes maybe the copy shop is already closed but using this display that's a very sustainable way of adjusting. Well, I guess it uses electricity. Well, let's hope that's solar energy. We thought that was very innovative very, very cool, more of that. And then of course that also happened that was used at the protest and I think they're justifiably very proud of this. Is that a car protest? I think it's probably just the speaker in front and then you have the display there. I really like it, you save a lot of effort you still need to walk to carry any heavy posters anymore. Well and you have to build a car next to carry the display. That's a hacker-compatible protest. Well, and the people in Munich have celebrated their 10-year anniversary by putting something into one of those time capsules. They should get some kind of price for that, 10 years. 10 years of being in their new rooms and events there. And one thing that was very important for them is that they had a member a member assembly where they also said that basically clearly said that hacker-ethics are very incompatible with a far right. They've slightly amended the wording. We had one of those declarations with the CCC a few years ago which specifically referenced the NPD in its more current political development such as AfD and I think some people are somehow surprised recently that the CCC positions itself on the left end of the spectrum. I'm really speechless. Where were you for the past 30 years? When Waohalan said in 1989 that when he wrote and called on people to get involved in inheriting something that is a left-wing agenda and you really need to be fine with that or our heart is very much on the left and that's where it beats and you have to be fine with that. It's a loud round of applause. Yeah, yeah, I'll hurry up. Okay, let's move to Karlsruhe. The Entropia also celebrates. They celebrate their 20-year anniversary so it existed for 20 years consistently and so for next year they have a real party plan for 2019 so they're also moving into a new location they're gonna have a party to inaugurate that place there's going to be a massive birthday cake for the GPN there's going to be a large entropia party at camp there's going to be a stage with a bar and then in December we'll ring out the party year with the so-called G-L-U-P-N so, which is a reference to the German term for Moldwein and the programming night so it's definitely worth having a look at and visiting this local ERFA Circle Entropia in Berlin there are also changes happening so there's Chaos Radio which has existed since 1995 on regular radio waves and which has been and which has now published more than 250 episodes is unfortunately it's unfortunately putting out its last episode on radio in June the radio station which we have been working together with Fritz, oh, yeah there were different stations we worked with before but well, unfortunately they changed their plan they really wanted to tell us what the reasons were and if you ask the right person they will tell you but basically the Chaos Radio will not be on regular radio waves anymore but I think it's been 3-4 years there are there are alternately different Chaos Radios happening and being recorded the Chaos Computer Club Berlin itself that includes VOC which is also working here at congress they're working together with the Berlin CCC members which means that Chaos Radio has actually been published by CCC itself every other month and we will continue that proudly to keep Chaos Radio alive even next year so oh no, that's not the Chaos Computer Club that's the picture I was supposed to show they have existed since 2004 and they have had since 2004 a series of presentations which has been happening in their city library since 2008 the building itself is worth a visit because it's really really impressive und so a series of talks by the CCC Stuttgart might be a good reason to visit and because of the new police law that was supposed to be published in Baden-Württemberg they also published their own press release and they also issued a constitutional complaint they're definitely going to go to court against this police law so they already changed their police law but there are new changes planned and the CCC Stuttgart is planning to launch a constitutional complaint we hope that they will be successful but it might take a few years I mean, no worries if it takes a long time we've been around for a while we can wait let's quickly continue here so in Chaosplot in Essen, in western Germany they have around 90 members ich bin so gelös weil die Sendung mit der Maus ein famous TV-Programm ist und sie haben mit ihnen gearbeitet und gesagt wir werden auch unsere Dörfer öffnen wir haben Expertise mit Kindern von ChaosMix ChaosMix-Schools und so hatten sie wirklich coole Events im Moment ich wollte sagen, wie viele Leute da waren ich glaube, es waren 30 Kinder die dort kommen und die TV-Show besuchten und besuchten die CCC wenn du wenn du vielleicht nicht etwas präsentieren willst bei einem großen Congress wie das CCC dann könnte es ein guter Ort sein um etwas zu versuchen eine kleine Gespräche zu halten das wird wahrscheinlich streamt und es wird online in unserer Digital Library für alle die Privacy Week ich glaube, Linus, du hattest ich war nur dabei aber dann musste ich leave ja, ich war da für die Privacy Week in Vienna ich glaube, sie sind called C3W so, die CCC Vienna hat das für ein paar Jahre organisiert und Vienna dieses Event hat in ihrem Ethnologie-Museum und da war es möglich so, die CCC öffnet sich öffnet sich um das Publikum und ich glaube, es war generell ein sehr professionell Event, das du supportest, wenn möglich und ich glaube du siehst jetzt die ersten Spinoffs weil es jetzt die erste Privacy Week ist und du siehst, die alten Wach-Traditionen sind noch live im Event so ist das live? während der Privacy Week waren es 30 Ängel so, sie haben definitiv diese Ängel-Kultur adoptiert und diese 30 Ängel haben mehr als 3.000 Stunden Arbeit und das ist auch ein weiterer Rund of applause 50 Stunden pro Ängel vielleicht sollten wir die Ängel gewerken also, ich glaube, wir sollten auch vielleicht sagen, dass die Ängel-Union, dass die Standards hier im Kongress eigentlich ziemlich relaxiert sind also, ja, die CCC ist eigentlich ihrem Vater also, in Recklinghausen haben sie ein großes Display sie haben einen großen Display sie haben mit einer anderen Association gearbeitet und sie haben ein Teil ein old Power Plant und über die nächsten Jahre oder Decades sie werden diese Parts benutzen und basically rebuilden sie innerhalb ihrer Hackerspace um so ein großes Status-Display für Dinge wie Bandwidth und die Typen, die du brauchst und ich bin auch wirklich curious zu sehen, was da passiert aber es könnte gut sein so Hamburg, sie für Starters, sie haben ein paar schlechte Dinge gesagt weil sie gesagt haben, dass ein paar Freifunknoten, die für Wifi geben, müssen wieder runter aber das Gute ist, dass die Leute, die in diesen Containern leben sind jetzt eigentlich able to live in material equipment that can maybe be used elsewhere and that can be used to support people who have less access to the internet than maybe us there was also Hackover they're expanding their rooms and for some reason soldering is a really hot thing there um oh god please you have to pay for the, you have to pay ok so i notice that if the people in Hamburg are working on soldering and are doing so much soldering and so let's back, back, back no we can only go forwards so that if the people in Recklinghausen have a big problem with this massive display then maybe the people from Hamburg can send a few people to Recklinghausen who can help them solder their display well now you've got a new task another thing that i thought was really cool is that Hamburg has a young hacker day once per month we're not talking, we're talking about that later are we talking about that well there's also a young hacker day here no i think we want to talk about that during one of the later slides but i can talk about this now before we forget because we're kind of running out of time i don't know why people are stressing us out we have so much time left, everything's relaxed so this time we don't have a slide for chaos makes schools which is our school based program but we wanted to mention this nevertheless at this point that a lot of erfers, so local cccs have this chaos makes schools the school the school program which definitely was hyped und supported quite a bit after there was a talk about it here a few years ago a lot of people said they want to do that as well this project is about basically going into schools and talking to teachers talking to students to essentially discuss digitalization in schools, in education and maybe give students the basic tools that they need to live in the digital world that we live in and want to live in and for example at the young hackers day they explain how to solder how to solder certain things and also how to program things but also you might also talk to them about data protection and what it means if we live and move in digital worlds and we see that the young hackers day also happens here at congress and it sold um more well we sold more than 300 tickets or gave more than 300 tickets to students and we enabled 300 students to participate in this hacker community here and it's incredibly important that we reach and contact younger generations because it might be specifically those at 42C3 who are organizing this congress with us and for us and who who are also part of our future and I am again and again super excited when I hear what this project chaos makes school um what it does and how many people are involved there and I think that also deserves another round of applause for everyone who's involved there next um now we need to skip a few things in Dresden there was they data traces are happening again you all haertferly invited it always happens in fall the next Privacy Week starts on October 27th in 2019 für alle, die interessiert sind, in der Idee, wie die Erfas-Lokos-CCCs funktionieren, wie man sie unterstützen kann, wie sie ihnen helfen können, dass du ein paar Projekte verabschieden kannst. Es gibt ein Event heute zwischen 4 und 6 Uhr. Oh, so ist es heute, nicht der Tag 3, wie es sagt, es ist ein Workshop Room M3, also in rund einer Stunde. Also es ist ein Workshop Room M3, also wenn du in der Local-CCCs interessiert bist, dann bist du willkommen, um dort zu gehen und die Local-Club kennengelernt zu können. Und wenn du interessiert bist, dann solltest du einfach dort gehen, drücken. Ich muss nicht sagen, dass es 3 Bier gibt, weil es nur 330 Sehten gibt. Also es war paid not to mention, dass es 3... Oh, well, of course, we don't only have good news this year. We also had quite a heavy setback this year, because we had to close 80 franchises across Germany, CCC. That was really, really very difficult. That was not something we could do with all the angels. So this is a reference to a shoe chain that is also called CCC that basically left Germany this year. We're also very sorry for the people who send us complained emails this year to the Chaos Computer Club about any problems that they had with their two purchases. We will not be taking care of these emails any further, I'm afraid. So there's just one more, a very last block of topics in the EMS that we won't be able to talk about this in detail, I'm afraid. But it's very important because 2018, I think, was a year where we talked about content filtering a lot, partially because of the network content regulation law, which was happening at the beginning of the year, which was discussed in the beginning of the year, where there was a lot of discussion to what extent companies had to be transparent about the things that they filtered. And I think, looking back, we have to say that numbers published by the government and numbers published by these companies, the number of deleted content, or the amount of deleted content is primarily due to violating rules and standards by those companies, so in many cases these things are deleted in reference to community standards rather than German law. But that's also partially because it's quite difficult actually to find the forms that you'd have to use to get something deleted based on this German law that was implemented recently. But I also think partially this debate kind of died down because there isn't that much going on. But there's still a constitutional complaint. I do think this is about freedom of speech, so it's a very important basic right. Relatedly, there was a much bigger debate triggered by things that were happening on the European level because there were these terror filters, which are basically anti-terror filters, where there were 10,000 pictures and 8,000 video data. They were just filtered through upload filters because you're not even allowed to upload them at all. So basically there's this content control when you're trying to upload these things. So that's also related to all these questions of copyright. And we think that is a problem, not just me. And that's also not just a German problem, but a European problem. And we have a quick message about that that also says something about this because we want to emphasize that we as an organization are not alone, but we have people who are fighting with us. Well, we see that we're fighting on several fronts where people are trying to introduce an infrastructure for censorship, where people are trying to prevent certain contents from being uploaded in the first place. And they're taking on the power to decide what gets uploaded in the first place. And that's completely opaque and transparent. And a second aspect of this is that so next year, something that's going to happen next year is that the EU Copyright Directive is going to come. So on the European level and the national level we're not by ourselves. We invited Kurt Absal. Kurt, could you come to the stage? Who works with Corey Doctoro and who's briefly going to talk about it to us? Can you take the podium? Hi Kurt. Thank you. Thanks everybody for giving me a moment to talk about Article 13. You've probably heard that the EU's close to passing a Copyright Directive with a rule in it called Article 13, which might be the most important rule that has ever come out. Also, this is all in English. So, I guess I don't have to translate this. Under Article 13, online platforms will have to censor any copyrighted work that the users post. And the process of determining what the copyright filter is, anyone can add something to it and the filter will be used to compare that, compare every used configuration, code text, Audio-Videos, to the database and if the algorithm thinks there's a match, then you're blocked. These filters will also cost hundreds of millions of euros to produce, meaning we'll reach even the largest internet companies, mostly the US tech giants and the smaller European competitors will be hard pressed to be able to comply with these Directives, crushed another weight of this rule. Article 13 is bad for competition, it's bad for freedom of expression, it's bad for the EU, it's bad for artists, it's bad for every internet user. The next possible final EU meeting on this coming up in mid-January in the German government holds the balance of power. So we're asking you to contact your ministers and tell them to hold the line. Tell them to continue their position to Article 13. This won't just affect Germany, Europe, every internet user in the world will be affected by this and we don't want to have the EU become the largest exporter of bad internet policies. The German government is currently unsure and I think we should try to convince them. And I'm worried how this will affect German tech companies and their right to make the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs decide the minister is Peter Altmaier. So I'm asking you to call him because we have a petition with 4 million signatures and people are saying that the proponents of Article 13 are saying we can ignore it because it's bots, well you're not bots and if you call them a person you can call for Winston, you're not a bot as well. So you can make a difference and call. So we have a short URL that will direct you to a page on the CCC Wiki that will explain how to contact the minister give it a phone call phone calls are much more effective than other means of communication the more effort we put into the communication the more received by the political office as the will of the people so we are asking you to make the call ask your friends to make the call and together we can stop this bad internet rule. Sorry, I didn't get the first small part because I was realizing that you can't really hear the normal track. We want to close this look back the call for action so you have to call until mid of January by Altmaier we have some more important for 2019 we want you to be engaged the club was always well the union of people being active together and not just informing themselves but also really in their airfare circles and with public work writing, clicking, calling like work with this we want you to do this anyone else saying something well thank you for your attention hope you have another nice two days of congress don't forget the call to action, thank you