 looks like it's 701 so we will go ahead and get going and hopefully oh I just see Commissioner Kennedy just joined so perfect with that I will call the June second 2022 City of Santa Cruz Planning Commission meeting to order close clerk can we please have a roll call Commissioner Conway here Greenberg here Kennedy here Maxwell is here the CD Miller here different here here Dawson here are there any statements of disqualification for tonight's agenda items from anyone okay seeing none we will move on to oral communications this is a time for the public to address the Commission for items that are not on the agenda for this evening so if you would like to address the Commission for an item that we will not be discussing this evening you can go ahead and this is a time for you to raise your hand you can go ahead and press star 9 to raise your hand or just hit the raise hand function you will have three minutes and again this is only for items that are not on the agenda tonight so I'll give a second for the lag see if we see any hands for oral communications sir I am seeing no hands can you confirm you are seeing the same that's correct okay thank you very much so we will go ahead and move on to approval of the minutes for the May 19th meeting and I would be happy to entertain a motion for their approval unless there's any questions or corrections I'll move the minutes move by commissioner shifrin is there a second all second thank you seconded by commissioner Kennedy can we just try a voice vote and we'll just say I and nay so also if you could just raise your hand when you say I so the clerk will call real quick sorry chair but I was absent I believe we both were absent so we did same right I was getting to that and commissioner Dawson and commissioner Maxwell will not be voting so calling for approval of the May 19th minutes with the voice vote clerk can you call for us and mays could I ask a point of procedure I want to make sure that's legal I'd like to ask staff if we're able to have these voice votes as opposed to roll call votes yeah that would be great to get clarification I looked in the bylaws and didn't see anything but it would be great to get clarification from staff just thought we would be able to move things a little quicker but let's go ahead and hear from staff their thoughts happy to stay with the roll call system if that's just easier for everyone I good afternoon leave all their planning and community development director I do not know that it is a problem I would ask our clerk here tests do you feel that there's an issue with that I think that most boards have tended to do roll call votes with the zoom just because of the technology being what it is it's just more clear for the public who may not be viewing it but maybe listening to it yeah let's let's just stay with that then let's go ahead and go with a roll call vote and stay with let's work before so clerk can we please have a roll call vote for approval of the minutes commissioner Dawson and commissioner Maxwell be abstaining yeah I'll try and make it quick commissioner Conway hi Greenberg hi Kennedy hi the CD Miller hi different hi okay thank you very much approval of the minutes for the May 19th meeting passes let's move on to the consent agenda we have two items on the consent agenda and I would like to say that I have heard from staff and staff is requesting that we continue the 109 South Rapetta Road project to a date certain so I would like to pull that from the consent agenda and at this time I would entertain a motion from any commissioners to continue to open a public hearing to make sure that there's nobody from the public who wants to run number two okay so we've pulled the agenda item off the consent agenda and then now I'll go ahead and open a public hearing to if anybody would like to speak about this project staff has said that they have received numerous information from new information that they would like time to process and allow plenty of time for discussion of this project so their request is to move this forward to a date certain two weeks so any members of the public like to speak on the 109 South Rapetta project at this time if so you can press star nine on your phone or you can raise your hand okay I'm seeing no hands move that we continue this item was there a particular date certain that was given by staff yes two weeks please item for two weeks and second that okay so we have a motion by Commissioner Schifrin second by Maxwell to move item number two that has been removed from the consent agenda forward two weeks can we have a roll call vote before we could I just say a under discussion of the motion let me just say I I appreciate that this is being continued it it's much as far as I'm concerned it's more complicated than it first appeared so I appreciate that the staff is taking more time to particularly review the original project I hope and and provide additional information on them on the recommendation okay just for clarity could we just say that that it's to the June 16th regular meeting that's fine they're expectable to the make of the motion okay great so back to the vote moving it moving this item the 109 South Rapetta Road project to June 16th can we have a roll call vote please Commissioner Conway hi green up Berg I Kennedy right Maxwell hi the CD Miller hi different hi your Dawson hi you're muted Cindy all right thank you we motion passes we will continue item three the 109 South Rapetta Road project to the next planning commission meeting on June 16th back to item number two which is on the consent agenda I will entertain a motion at this time to move the consent agenda or if any commissioners would like to remove that item from the consent agenda up up to the commission at this point I think you also have to if anybody from the public wants to speak on this can clarify that do for consent agenda items the staff that the public hearing needs to be opened for consent agenda items individually or as a group just her future reference as a group the the item should be opens and then the members of public have an opportunity to request that the item be pulled for additional consideration so during the consent calendar you would offer up opportunities for the public to speak yeah okay so I let's go ahead and hear from commissioners and then we'll go ahead and go to the public commissioner Conway and then Mr. Kennedy I'm prepared to move the consent agenda but after we get public comment okay great let's go to the let's go ahead and open the public hearing are they any members of the public who would like to speak on item number two five five five Pacific project this is an ordinance for the second amendment of the development agreement to convert 94 small ownership units to 100% rental projects subject to the city's current inclusionary requirement of 20% in perpetuity any members of the public like to speak on this item or request that it be removed from the consent agenda this is the time to hit star nine or praise the press the raise hand function okay I'm seeing none so we'll bring it back to the commission now to entertain a motion I'll go back to commissioner Conway I'd like to move the consent agenda okay okay moved by commissioner Conway seconded by commissioner Kennedy are there commissioner shifrin usually we don't have discussion on consent items so discuss any but it's any member of the commission can discuss any motion before it's voted on so I'm I support the motion I just wanted to thanks staff for responding to the questions that I raised and for putting the the agreement that we're recommending approval on tonight I think it's