 Welcome to Toffy TV, it is the player ratings, not a city Neil Everton 1, not a great performance, but Everton got the three-pointer to get into Jordan Pickford, that gave Jordan a seven, did quite well again last night, very calm, very noticeable in two games, very calm, made a good save in the first half from probably their only shot on target, I think, and he's got real power on it and pushed it wide. Second half, there was one where they had a breakaway and the player went round them, but he did really well because he didn't go to ground, he forced them wide and then he got back into position and I just think so far in the two games he's looked very calm, reassuring, which is good for the defenders, good with the ball as well as his feet, so both performances so far have been on that level and that's what we need going forward. Sheamus Coleman, I've given six, a little bit of different performance from the game against Liverpool in this game, you know, more needed more going forward and although he did help, he did win the corner, that led to our goal, probably wasn't ultimately good enough going forward, didn't show enough when we needed it. Defensively was OK, but I just thought we needed a little bit more and the same on the other side I've given Dina six and I know he got the assist for the goal, but I think we needed that as well, a little bit better going forward, defensively pretty much OK, but I think we need more out of the full backs. Our wide men are not players who will be players with pace, they're link players, they need the full back to go round them and Dina just didn't do enough of that, but it's early days I've given them both six in the centre. Mason Hallgate, I've given him seven, very calm, very assured, there was one instance where he came out of the back with the ball as well, really, really, really good. It's really unflappable at the moment as well, really looks really, really calm, so I've given him seven. Obviously he's got the winning goal, he's become a father as well, so what a great week it is for him and in the two games he's looked really good, looked really, really good, just doing his job. I think he just enjoys being a defender, he's not bad with his feet as well, but I think he enjoys just being a defender and obviously popping up with a goal as well. So for him what a great week and two clean sheets, I think those two have illustrated that when they're on it, they're both excellent defenders. Into midfield, Tom Davis, I've given him a three, I thought he was woeful in the first half and obviously he was dragged off at half time. And again it's that question of you asking more of him, on Sunday it was a discipline display, it was all staying in shape, we wanted a bit more out of him, into knowledge and he just didn't show it, him or Gomez really in that first half. Everything looks forced with Tom, nothing looks natural, he doesn't break through with the ball, he always seems to be on the stretch, he's playing passes, they're not on. And it's basically the story of his event career, isn't it? Where Holgate and Dominic Arvillwn have elevated themselves into first team staples, Tom, obviously there's still a massive question mark. And when he puts performances in like this you just think to yourself he's not going to make it. Again for me I think he needs 20 odd games on the bounce to see what he's capable of, but I don't think he's going to get 20 games on the bounce at Everton because he can't put consistent performances. So maybe that means he might have to go away on loan somewhere, like Germany or something like that. I don't know, but it was right that he got the hook at half time. Next to him on Drake Gomez I've given him a five, I thought he was terrible first half but improved second half. Just doesn't look match fit, doesn't look like he's got it in his legs. Again, everything looks forced once more time than he's got and I think that's the story of Armyd Field in general and he's supposed to be almost a leader of that midfield and sadly he needs to up his levels. Maybe it'll be a case of these games now to the back end of the season. We'll get him up to that level for next season. It's going to be a short window, it's going to be about a month isn't it, till between the two seasons. So maybe that's what he needs. I don't know but he looks a shadow of the player he was, certainly last season. I don't know whether he ever got up to the levels of last season this season but he needs more games certainly. In the wide areas, Bernard has given me four, I thought he was poor really. Just doesn't get a grip of the game and whether that's because like I said before, Dean's not joining up with him and we're not. Bernard's not the kind of player who's going to just take players on, two or three and he needs players around him to work with and work off them and he looked very isolated. Again, one who looks like very short of fitness. On the other side of Wobby, I've given him a seven. I thought first half again looked isolated but second half I thought he just tucked in a little bit, a little bit of a tinker with the formation and I thought he looked a lot better. He started getting on the ball, he started committing people, he started to play forward passers and this is the conundrum. How do you get a Wobby into games? How do you get the best out of a Wobby without changing the shape? What have you got to do to the team? Well I think what you've got to do to the team is have a full back that goes past them. Can't Seamus Coleman do that all the time? I don't know but I do think a Wobby needs to play ten yards inside the byline which means that full back is going to always go past them whether they get to the ball or not. Has Seamus Coleman got it in his legs or will that, is that Sidney? But then if Sidney plays you lose something defensively. You do, we know it. So what does that mean? How does that look? I do think there's still a player in a Wobby. I think we've seen it. I just think we haven't got the best out of him. I think he's a player who likes to be on the ball, he likes to be running. But what he doesn't like to be is a wide running into the corner. He's not someone who's going to cross the ball. He's not a winger. In the old days I don't know whether they would have called him an inside forward over it. I'm not sure. I think does he want to be a centre midfielder? I don't think he's got the discipline to be a centre midfielder. So that's how we get the best out of him. But I thought second half he looked a lot better. A lot better. So I've given him a seven. Up front with Charleston making my five. I thought he was below par. Didn't really look up for it. Looked like he had a bit of a carbon. I never really recovered after the first 20 minutes. Wakes hard of course he does. But he's seen with his head down and the lip and feeling sorry for himself. And in recent times he's saying that into good performance. There's actually the frustration. But yes he just didn't look like he was ever going to do that. I've given him a seven. I thought Dom worked well as a target man. Brought everything down. Linked the play up. Got a couple of shots off. Should have done better with a header in the second half when we were one nill up. Dom's leading the line really well now. He's an intelligent footballer I think. And just holds his position. He's a nightmare for any defender because he's so good in the air. And he's also leaning to pin players as well. Just get it down and work it. So I've given him a seven. He's a great platform to build off. So I've given him a seven. The subs. Gelfi. I've given him a six. I thought he came on and did alright. Got old with the ball. These games suit his pace. They really do. So I think he did what he did on Sunday. Come on. And he just allowed us to keep the ball better. So I thought he did alright. I've given him a six. Moise Keen. I've given him a two. I thought he was terrible. He came on the first thing he does is a back heel at noron. Then he boots one of their players and gets a yellow card. One of the quickest yellow cards probably ever. And it's just this general demeaning, general ball intelligence and game management. He's running slumped over which looks like he's not fit. Then he's trying to corner in the last minute. He's in our box and he's got a chance to just hoover up the pitch. And he tries to take on three knowledge players and loses the ball. Luckily enough he got it back and run down and got one as a far. That's great. But just game management and just intelligence. I just thought he was terrible. Absolutely terrible. He's got to improve. Massively got to improve. Bains and Gordon were really on long enough to give them a score, I'd say. So they were only on for a couple of minutes. There you go. There are my player ratings. Let me know your thoughts in the comments. Pickford 7, Coleman 16, 16, Keen 8, Man of the Match, Holgate 7, Davis 3, Gomez 5, Oboe 7, Bernard 4, with Charleston 5, Dominic Harvenlun 7, Guilffy Sigarton 6, Moise Keen 2. Let me know your thoughts in the comments. Do you agree? Do you disagree? Let me know. Give this video a like, subscribe if you haven't already and if you want more great videos, live videos, we're going to be doing the final word live this afternoon on Patreon. If you want to join us, the link is in the description. Also, I've seen people talking about our T-shirts and our mugs and stuff, like the mug I broke when we were doing the watch along last night. If you want to find them, the link is in the description as well. Any of our T-shirts, hoodies, stickers soon, comments soon, get on there as well, the shop. Thanks for watching. See you later.