 Welcome to Toffy TV, we've asked you for your questions and you've replied if you want to get involved just send us a little video clip, we're going to put these videos together every week. Let's start with Andy, Andy Bush, Absolute Radio DJ and Evertonian he's been in touch. Hey Toffy TV, it's Andy Bush here from Absolute Radio, cheers just having a beer watching some of the brilliant World Cup games today, got me back into football again, I have my enthusiasm back after Everton managed to strangle the life out of me this season but here's hoping a better things. So yeah, love the channel, love what you do for the Blues, at some point next season I want to try and get up and be a guest on the show that would be amazing, that's an ambition of mine. My question for you guys is this, with the changes that are going to be brought by Silver this season, exciting times, I'm thinking maybe a bit of a clear out which players do you see leaving the club and why. See you soon. Cheers and thanks for getting in touch with us, be good when he comes on the show, who to sell and why, it's a tough one in it because obviously we've only just gone back after three seasons you know a couple of days in, off the top of your head without knowing what Marco Silver's plans are kind of thing, you've probably come up with similar ones with me say like Ashley Williams, I don't think anyone had no point in the club. So you know Morgan's, you see the Sniadlin ones the tough one, I think because I think Silver would look at him and go if we can get a tune out of him he's worth keeping almost but his attitude I mean I know that you were, you were not given his attitude at all. I just don't think you should ever play for Everton again. There you go, fair enough. Kevin Morales. Yeah you know there's some, it's a similar theme isn't he? Anyone who's surplus and there's a lot of people, Williams is surplus, Marales is surplus, you know look think about a player who is second in their position let's say or even third and look at what the weight is on, look at their age and you can come up with some quick, quick ones. Williams, Marales definitely gone. Balasi, Funes, Mori's already gone off, he would have been someone would have said anyway so he's gone. Wayne's gone. Wayne wouldn't have necessarily been someone who would have come up with but... No but I mean when you look in a position, where to go. And to be honest past that. Martina? Yeah Martina's garbage. No well he is always and he's not, there's no quality there at all in the ladder. We're excited and I know all that but he's not, there's no, if we're going to go up a level it's we all want, you've got, there is some tough decisions and I think you do have a lot of tough decisions. No but I mean you'd have to look and go he's just not good enough anymore, he's not good enough, he's not good enough. But Bessage? Bessage I think is a player in there without a shadow but like I said these four years he's been here and I still can't tell you if he's good enough to consistently perform at the highest level because we haven't seen enough. He's won as well that you go should we sell him Fraser Ungod as well, he's come to a stage in his career where he really needs to be playing and I don't imagine that's something ever can offer him, you know in a new book midfield you want to look past that play like him so. What did you think very quickly Lugaba going out at the right time wasn't it? He's not going anywhere is he? I think you know. But some of the, I mean one of the young players, is there any young players you'd say well I don't necessarily think they're good? I think Galloway, Galloway and Ty's Browning because I think the pair of them, I think they're just stagnating. Pennington? Pennington? I would, I would because I look at him and he played in our first team two seasons ago and I don't see him pushing the players we've got. I don't think he's holding up, I think he signed him on a contract just to secure him. I think he's a decent defender but I think he needs to go somewhere to play. Yeah he's the kind of player that needs like two or three players, yeah two or three years playing solidly and then you never know he might like re-amaze. I look at him as similar to Shane Duffy. Yeah and I think Shane Duffy went away and got games like for Blackburn, then it's a Brighton and he's very good at Brighton and I don't know, he's him and Duncan Greys. And there's nothing we could have done about that. He had to go away. He did? Yeah. And develop. Build this, build himself up. Yeah yeah. Anyone else? No, no, barely, I mean I think you know there's some, there's people like, people like Stechlenberg that, well I'd keep Stechlenberg. I think he's, I think he's a decent number two. Yeah. And I think I don't, I don't see any immediate need to to just get rid of him with Pickford the way he is. So past that. It's gonna be very interesting over the next few weeks. Yeah it's all, it's all the typical names. You say like, you ask Popsup, doesn't he? Some people tell him, I wouldn't be in the rush to get rid of him. Classic, again he pops, I wouldn't be in the rush to get rid of him. Without seeing if Marco Silva can get something out of him. So it is, it's one of them at the minute, isn't it? Definitely. Loads of variables. Yeah. Sean's been in such. Hi, Ped, hi Baz. Just a quick question regarding Jack Reddall's contract that's obviously been cancelled by Sunderland. I was just inquiring as to whether you consider taking him back on the same sort of deal we had with Jose Baxter. I know the circumstances are obviously different but he's still one of our own. So I was wondering whether you'd be interested in taking him back, trying to give him a new lease of life and obviously either benefiting us or another club. Thanks very much. Keep up the good videos guys. Well, that's radical, Sean if I'm honest. That's field. That's out there. Jack Reddwell, I can see where you're coming from but I think there's slightly two different situations. I think, I don't think Jack needs, I don't think he needs necessarily a leg up anyway. Number one he's made. He needs a club. A lot of money out of Sunderland. I think he just needs a club but also though it's his fitness isn't it? His fitness has never been, never been there. He's never had, that I think ultimately over his career it's always been in his fitness that's letting down. Can you just allow, you know, in theory it's a nice idea bring him back to the club and help him for a year but does he really need that? He probably does because, because he's taking him. Not many are going to take him at the minute. He's made a lot of money. I think he's seen the figures the other day. Didn't mean he was quite remarkable and he was only on a winning team once or something in Sunderland in his time in the league. So, but he's got something Jack Reddwell but I think as he's been in Sunderland for four years now or something like that, three years hardly played so again it's the injury thing. He's definitely got ability but I don't know what you're doing but I suppose if he wanted to come back to Everton and he went we'll give you a thousand pound a week and we'll see how you go and get you fitting and see then you'd look and go you know he's a decent player. He could go and play like the 23s as well and develop them because he's different than Baxter in terms of if you could get him back to a level he's actually a good footballer but I just don't see that happening but I understand why John's asked the question because you could get up with a good fee for him as well as he's a decent player but he'd have to prove his fitness and he'd have to wake up to. I suppose that's one way as a player Jack Reddwell might think we'll be thinking someone's gonna ring so that might be might be one of them where like you know you get to like September or something although he is a free agent so we can sign for him when he wants but if ever we're to offer him something in September and say you know what if you want to come back and do something I don't know yeah listen it's an interesting prospect and I'm sure I'm sure there'll be other clubs that are will thinking almost in those times get him in. I think that'll be a good move and go coach decent level. Gerard. Big thing from Steven Gerard and see if you can get him fit and perform. I think you're totally fitness and if I was going to take Jack Robbwell I'd take him and say you're playing centre back not centre midfield you're playing centre back. I think that could minimise the injuries if you played centre back. And I think it might settle him into a position because I think I don't know about you like you came down to Goddus and played in the cup last year and he was up against Tom Davis and it was like night and day Tom Davis ran the game 19. Jack was all right but he was a bit I think I don't think he's good enough to play that role I think as a centre back he could be. I think he's lost a hunger for the game as well. I think he's lost his way because I think you lose your way when you don't nail any position down. I think when he came in and everything he could play left back and he's a balthamad and he made his debut in 16 and everyone was saying he was a centre back he was a mark to be a centre back and then Moise poorum in defence of midfield then he became an attack midfielder but he never had the I don't think he had the ability to play as an attack midfielder. Now he scored the odd goals he scored a goal against United and I think he scored against Villar in the cup. But and he scored he did score a cracker against Sigma all the more than ever in your opinion to the box but I think in general I've always looked at him as a defensive player and I think you're right as a centre back because he's good on the ball. I think the only thing with him is he's not great in the air but you know that's something to work on isn't it? Definitely definitely. It's an interesting one. It is interesting but not convinced. Not convinced by him. I think he's Moise Mr Manatee. I think he might be back here but I'm not sure he'd be high on Mark or Silver's list to be on. Thanks for the question and we'll be shown. On to Mark. Hi Bas Ped. Question for your Q and A. Who's the better captain between Phil Jageelke and Phil Neville in terms of leadership on and off the pitch. Cheers. Cheers Mark. Best best captain. Phil Neville or Phil Jageelke. The part with the fills. Right. Jage. This is the dilemma isn't it? It's a good question. Jage has just been an immense player for us, been fabulous. Neville was a let's not read it history. Phil Neville was a good player for us. The last year or so he'd fell off the radar a bit like Howard and he's stayed a little bit too long but as a captain on the pitch Neville said some things which I thought were ridiculous off the pitch. On the pitch I think he was really good. He came in and he pointed a lot. He was like led by example. He organised. I thought he was good that way. I don't think Jage is as good that way but I think as a footballer Jageelke's better than done more for us so it's it's. No the question is on purely on captain I think Phil Neville's a better captain. I think he had far more experience of winning and brought that into the club and you seen that. You see the amount of times where we helped galvanise things or knew when something needed taking up a little notch or when if something. You obviously remember that on Aldo. Of course. But if something needed to happen he provided it or you know a little maybe a sound bite to back up the manager or something. Great step over as well. Diving against Liverpool wasn't brilliant but no I think as a player I think Jageelke would be obviously fondly more remembered but I think as a captain I think you've got to give it to Neville. As you just said there a lot of history is being rewritten on Phil Neville because we only tend to remember players as they go out. Yeah you know when he did stay a year too long his brother got it right he knew when the legs had gone but Phil never quite got that but then again that's for the managers to sort out and we've seen that with a lot of when a manager's got someone fighting for him in this corner we've seen the same with Manez and Tim Howard. Yeah when you've got someone fighting for your corner in the dressing room and all the rest of it a big character you probably try and keep them as long as you can. I think I think the other thing with Neville as well if he did just play right back he'd have been alright near the end but he was in midfield and he was in midfield with Leon Osborn for a couple of his horrendous displays and a pair of them. Although didn't he play right back at Old Trafford and keep everyone on side? Yeah but you'd have the odd mystics team peeing, I've booted Ryan Giggs and Ninjally Time and we were getting the one ones for no reason whatsoever and we lost so people even the greatest players make chilly mistakes. I just think people will always remember the Wiggin gamers as the thingy and he was in there because you blessed a pair of them if you stuck them together they still were slower than the snail. So it was one of those things but he never was a good player for everything and you know people they do like to rewrite history but he was a good player for us and he was a good captain for us but again just went on that little bit too long. She acts as being absolutely fantastic as a player for us and still is to be fair even obviously a bit slower he's still a fabulous player for us but so as a captain to answer Mark's question you'd have to say Phil Neville. Hi lads it's Joe is this the breakout season for Mason Holgate and who is his best offensive partnership? Cheers Joe thanks for that so obviously there's been talk there was talk of Mason Holgate maybe leaving but that seems to have been clarified now by Michael Silver or certainly it has come through that yeah you know so this has to be the breakthrough season for him surely. Yeah it's got to be I mean he played games last season I thought to be honest with you at times him and Williams were our best defensive partnership but they were the partnership when Sam come through and he'd come in. Yeah and I thought I thought Mason Holgate had a good season I think there was a couple of games where he didn't have his best games West Bromero where he played Rodriguez onside and if he did be acted he'd have still he'd have got there but he didn't and spares up Emily a couple of times he let himself down but the two there be and now and now of course you know there was a little bit of after the thing but he was he was fully now but I mean he was fully justified in what he said because you're not what I mean is that when he get when he's get prior to that when he's getting in this facing now I want to see funny I had someone talking about this on the radio and you know basically I thought you know what they were saying was a striker a young striker can make mistake after mistake after mistake but then they put the ball in the back of the net and it's like oh we've got one here lads the defender doesn't have that you know defender doesn't have that luxury luxury of it and like we were talking before defenders sometimes have to go away lay in the trade make those mistakes go down to come back up again and always see defenders like look at the England team look at the defenders all of them came from lower league made mistakes and then have made the way up and you know some of them still made mistakes you know some of them were allowed to make mistakes with us um I think defenders will always make mistakes and it'll always get it'll always get highlighted because like a goalkeeper a lot of the time it ends up as a goal so you go back over it and over it where there's a centre forward course and I was a centre forward you miss you miss five sitters and you knock one in at the end every once you remember the fact you knock one in at the end and you've won the game exactly you know and you look so I think this has definitely got to be a season for and where we see a more consistent run um in in the in the and you're encouraged by what's coming out the club about them that they're gonna make them apart you know a key component but he should be he was the main component of that last season but he yet but he was there was no consistency but he's got everything though hasn't he he has but the interesting part of that question was who who would you play with because if what you want to do is you want to go into the season with a pain and almost say well that's our pay for the rest of the season oh that's what that's my that's that's a fair partnership and you've got to stick with it and and it's even a case of so is that keen you know because he's the most expensive player do you say well do you say almost say to Keane well actually you know when you've got to look after him or they've got to look after each other so that that's an interesting concept I look at Michael Keane and now this is about me I think I honestly believe Keane will benefit possibly more than anybody in that in that squad from Avon Marko Silver's intense coaching and I think what we'll do is we'll find out very quickly whether he's up to it or not because he'll be given that much information and told where to go and what to do he's just done an interview with the Avon website saying he's asked his brother he played under Silver a hole and he spoke to uh spoke to my Harry Maguire about him and they were saying he gives you so much information and he said I'm excited because it'll really benefit me and I think it will because Shaun Deist drilled him and he was excellent Liverpool United wanted them didn't so a lot of big clubs wanted them so I think the same maybe formation as well as I think what you've got to say you just got to say to Mason Augie well you know what are you what are you prepared to do well you know are you prepared to come into this team and be a leader because that's exactly what it needs in the back be a leader and and you know if I put you together can you do it can you do I need to walk by another centre half or can you do it you know what I mean that's got to be the question hasn't it because it is a big season for him he's got to he's got to nail down yeah he's got to place otherwise he will find himself going away and rebuilding and you know going through that process so it's up to him you know is he good enough let's see if he's good enough and if he can cut out those mistakes and if he's got complete concentration because I think as a footballer I think he's got everything required I just wonder whether he's got the concentration to focus on the games and and to be to be aware and sense the danger because that's what all good centre backs have got it's the the ability to sense when the danger is because when you look at centre backs it doesn't you know centre forwards are fast we know that most of the good ones are fast and they will always beat centre backs in a race yeah but if the centre backs can see where the danger is going to be before and then that's a big thing and you only really get that through experience some the very best of a bone with it it's just the but they still need to iron it out I mean I've seen Keir Leeney right he got one of the best in the world still make some terrible harlots buddy but there's been so many games when he's absolutely fantastic so it is it's like you say yeah you can't make mistakes so good question good question thanks to Joe for the question thanks to Andy thanks to Sean and thanks to Mark if you want to get your video in drop us a line send it over add to send it on we transfer to TrophyTV1 at gmail.com so that's we transfer there's a website you go on you just upload your video and you send it takes three takes two seconds to do or send a via whatsapp to the number in the description thanks for watching TrophyTV we'll see you later