 Welcome to ToffeeTV, it is the player ratings for Everton 2, Wofford, Neale, Carrible Cup, Everton into the quarterfinals, that draw not set to be made till Thursday morning I believe on a national radio. Breakfast show, yay, amazing. Wasn't the greatest of games. First half was appalling, absolutely appalling first half. We made the change at our time, it gave us probably a better shape, although it did feel a bit like our son Moise Keane, but I do think it gave us a bit of a better shape with Wolcott on the right and we started making a lot more chances, they were dreadful, we weren't much better but we were at home and we wanted it, I don't think they wanted it. But you know what, we created some good chances in the second half and we should have put more away, obviously we should go through Mason Hauge and then Richard from Wrapper up with a really nice finish on the counter stack which will do his confidence at the world of good and for some people I thought it was a half decent run out and for other people I thought they were absolutely dreadful and we're going to get into it. Jordan Pickford, I've given him a seven, he had one save to make really which he made, he got his hands behind it which is a which is a bonus and pushed it away so he'd done that, that's all he had really to do, a couple of catches, a couple of kicks, apart from that he had very very little to do so I've given him a seven, I might be over generous there. Sheamus Coleman, I've given him a five, I thought he was, I thought he was poor to be honest, I thought, especially first half he just looks limited now to me, I think I'm being totally honest when I say that, I think he looks limited, I don't think he's got the energy to get up and down anymore, I think his face touch is poor and he hasn't got the the speed to recover his face touch anymore and I just think he looks looks like a very average right back and a very tired right back and it's somewhere we definitely need to get sorted, he cannot be our first judge right back this season, he just can't, if he is our first judge right back then we've got major issues as far as I'm concerned going forward so he got better second half but I've given him a five, look at Dean on the other side, I've given him a six, I don't think he's been in good form either, his cross was horrendous in this game it really was, there was no patience to it at all, it's no coincidence that he looked better when he's gotten out of the head of him but at a free kick there at the bar, took a deflection at the bar, I just don't think he's playing well, so I've given him a six, yeah he mean it, bring to see him start the game, bring to see him start the game with Hallgate, that is my preferred to going forward, it really is, I've had enough of Michael Keane, I think he's dead full, I just think he's a confidence player and I can't have a player that one minute is a three or a four and the next minute might give you a seven performance, I just can't have it, he's just not good enough as far as I'm concerned, yeah he mean it, I think he's brilliant and I think tonight he showed why, one tackle, the slide tackle he made was just tremendous and then when he got the recovery as well, I get disappointed to see him hobble off, the manager's come out after the game and said that he's not in pain so that's a weird one isn't it, he nearly made it on Saturday but he just missed out but we're going to have to see what that is because if that's an injury where he's not in pain when he's not playing but he's in pain when he is playing, they're the worst ones because you've got to get to the bottom of what the problem is but not sure either if it's the same injury that he had, did have last week but I thought he was tremendous, I've given him a seven because he wasn't on that long but head and shoulders are our most consistent player this season, I would love to see him playing next to Holgate, I think that's got potential as a partnership because I think Holgate's got the pace, I think he's also got a bit of snide in him so, so me and a seven, Holgate have given eight, don't care I've given him an eight, scored the goal that put us in the driving seat in this game, I just think the lad looks like he's got bags of confidence and he might have the odd mistake in him or he might have more than the odd mistake in him but you know what, if he can't play in this team now, he'll never play for Evan because Michael Heane is horrendous at the back or has been horrendous recently and if he can't play in this side going forward now, I had my reservations about Holgate, I was worried about him, on Saturday I thought he did okay and he set the second goal up but that was brilliant and tonight he goes and gets himself a goal and I just think he's a player who's got an inner belief about him, he thinks he's a centre half so let's just see if he's a centre half then because honestly Michael Heane has had enough chances and has been poor this season, Meena's now the mainstay so what we need next to Meena is a little bit of pace, a little bit of a cover on player, Holgate's good on the ball and listen Michael Heane could have won this game for Evan, he had a header from three yards out and then he decided to go give it and this is not me having a rant about Michael Heane, this is just saying that Michael Heane's had enough chances now and Holgate deserves a chance and it might be a case that Meena's might be fifth for Sunday and it might be Holgate again but that'd be three games in a row and I'd like to see the lad get a run of games because if honestly if he can't get into this effort in back four then he'll never be good enough to play for Evan, he just needs to play some games and let's see how he gets on, 23 now playing enough Premier League games to just leave him in there and see how he gets on, he'll add a maker or he won't but I can honestly say that oh we have to play one of the other centre backs so I would leave me and I'm giving my eight because I thought he defended well, I thought he carried the ball out well, his pass on was good and he scored the goal. Into midfield, Andre Gomez five, I thought he was dead full, he just looked off the pace, mad that the last game he played at home he was absolutely brilliant but tonight he just looked way off it and you can tell it's weird, you can tell within the first 10 minutes whether he's going to have a good game but he just looked off it again tonight so I've given him a five, Delph I've given six, he was a little bit better than Gomez, his pass on was a lot better than Gomez's and he gets around the pitch a little bit better, he wasn't brilliant but I've given him a six, I won't be I've given six as well, lots of energy, lots of movement but unfortunately tonight there wasn't really an end product to his game enough so I've given him a six as well he hopes some puffs but he's got to get better at the at the finnish part of it, the final little bit he's got to get better, his touch has got to be a little bit better, he needs to keep the ball a little bit closer, at times you can see exactly what he's trying to do but it doesn't always come off, maybe a runner games at number 10 will will will smooth down those rough edges and so I've given him a six, with Charleston I'll give him a seven because of his goal, I didn't think he was I didn't think he was that really that good on the left hand side I thought first half, I thought he was trying to prove a point too much, like it's my old club I'm gonna I have to score kind of thing but I thought second half but seeing him when he went central and he you know he took his goal brilliantly, great finish, good ball by Towson, great finish, it's cut inside and finishing over the goalkeeper but when he's on the left I just I wasn't I didn't I just thought he just tried to do too much because it was against his old club, yes rugby my seven, Moise Keane I've given him a five difficult game for him, stuck out there on the right never really got into the game, again someone trying too hard I've seen people being very very critical of him to that tonight I wouldn't go that far I got taken off at half time I am starting to suspect that he's not the manager's player that he's a Marcel Brands and the manager just the manager doesn't fancy him took him off at half time to be fair it could have been him or Dominic Avalon being taken off but he decided to go with him, Dominic Avalon scored goals in the last few games so and obviously he's got more games in the Premier League so you can understand why he kept them on but it just never worked for him and he's just trying to add what he just needs to just get one out of his feet and smash it in and that'll make the world the difference to the player but we'll see, Dominic Avalon I've given a five as well I didn't think he was much better had some some decent touches at times but again for a team that was sort of playing with three up front he looked very isolated just didn't get the ball enough so I'll give him a five Michael Keane I've given a six did okay wasn't brilliant should have scored didn't have that much to do, Szyng Towson I've given six as well come on did he come on on left me left me field or something where was he playing but anyway he set the second goal up nicely so I've given him a six and Wolcott I've given six as well I mean it is nearly Halloween six six six I think I just thought I thought walk up give us a better shape and had a couple of opportunities that he overrun or just didn't make the most of but he did set up the goal the first goal which I thought was a really good ball back into into the danger area which obviously Mason Hawke finished off really well and so I've given a six and that's it um it was it just wasn't a very good first half was atrocious it was atrocious and it felt like it felt like a lot earlier in the competition Wofford were absolutely dire their fans are absolutely dire I mean you must have brought about 12 there's probably more snakes than there was fans horrific fan base if that's what you're going to bring you're not supporting your club are you let's be honest um but this one we had you know there's plenty of Evertonians there it was quieter times fair play to the lads in the corner and the original lads trying to get the atmosphere going fair play for the club to try to get the atmosphere going with all the flags and outside there was a big light show on the park end and they had drummers on the pitch and all kind so fair play to them as well for trying to get the atmosphere up it didn't really help first half because the football was absolutely dire um so from that point of view we're going to have to improve massively but we're in the hat we've won two of our last three games if we could beat Tottenham that three out of four you know what I'm saying flying pretty flying trouble what trouble um that's if we beat spares of course be a very difficult game be a very different game because Wofford were absolutely terrible they just come didn't want to play and they were going on um yeah but we're in the we're in the half to be interesting to you we got some teams in there that you've been like yeah Oxford away Kevin Brock be out 84 all over again I'd say we've got to get man city won't we to be honest I don't even man city I'm worried about it's more like less than I'm worried about I'd be more worried about Lester because they play a full strength side I'd rather play city in the next hand than I would in a semi or a final it's final did play all their best players and in the semi-final they've got you've got to beat them twice essentially so um we're waiting through just grab one in the hat anyway there you go there you go let me know your thoughts in the comments at least I wanted to give everybody a score today I didn't do that my last video um there you go let me know your thoughts you agree do you disagree um I know a lot of people might not be able to see the game tonight because of the absolutely pathetic rules that's around this competition um and the pathetic broadcast on right to this competition which are just like something from the 1980s when it's nearly 2020 um so I'm hope I hope I painted a picture for you if you didn't get to see it um but there you go my big take out of it is Mason Holgate has to has to stay in the side and uh yeah and stay attentive a big chance for him let's hope that he gets it and let's hope that he takes it because we're crying out for um someone at the back with a little bit of pace and a little bit of devilment and and maybe a knife for goal as well so let me know your thoughts thanks for watching check out all that all that other videos if you haven't subscribed please do click the bell for a letter you know exactly when a video is coming out give this video a like if you've liked it and if you want more great videos join us over on patron thanks for watching see you later