Loading...

Batman VS The Punisher

8,828 views

Loading...

Loading...

Transcript

The interactive transcript could not be loaded.

Loading...

Loading...

Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Published on Oct 28, 2011

Vince and Captain Logan discuss Batman and the Punisher and the crucial events that lead to their crime-fighting lifestyles. Which is the more reasonable outcome, ethically and practically?

Join the Geekvolution at wearegeeksnotnerds.com!

Comments • 105

JazzyZenBrotha
Punisher all the way! Batman is strong, smart, & very skilled but he is technically PRIVILEGED because his money was GIVEN to him. Essentially, Batman is living off his parents billions, thus allowing him no financial struggles or worries. So this gives him unlimited time to learn over 100 martial arts, ninja training, by gadgets & gear, and create contingency plans. But The Punisher is truly realistic. He's a former Special Forces Marine who also trained with Navy Seals & endured a wartime struggles. He's not rich and did not have ANY MONEY "given" to him. Bruce Wayne is privileged with money & no financial burdens (He's OP with finances & resources). Frank Castle has to work for EVERYTHING he owns, and has no butler to care for his house, and Punisher certainly has no side kicks (unlike Batman who endangers the life of under-aged youth {Robin} and has them go fight psychotic killers, which is technically child abuse). The Punisher is truly relatable and realistic.
View all 3 replies
Hide replies
latinelover24
For me the punisher due the realism. i love batman, but the punisher was trained as a Marine force recon, which is the special forces in the marines well until MARSOC came around in 2005. He fought in Vietnam and endured the hardships of it. read punisher born and you can see his psych. Even before he "became" the punisher, he was 10 years old and new the concept of evil in the story called "The Tyger"
slashandbones13
both have absolute morality where their personal beliefs are set in stone. they clash because one believes that killing anyone makes you part of the problem and the other believes that not killing everybody makes you part of the problem
View all 3 replies
Hide replies
Omen
Punisher only punishes the guilty, to him Batman would just be a narrowminded guy trying to do good, but not guilty and therefor doesn't deserve punishment
FreedomsFist1776
Logically: Punisher, obviously. Ethically: I have a hard time condemning the Punisher. Everyone talks about him killing people, but how many people has he saved. By removing threats to the innocent the innocent are saved. Batman keeps the Joker around and the Joker keeps killing people. Does that mean Batman is still a good person? I maintain that Punisher's approach has saved more innocents that Batman's.
View all 2 replies
Hide replies
Omen
I think it'd be a coin-toss if there was time before the fight because Batman also is a master at preparring for senarios and stacking the odds as much as possible. Random Encounter=Batman wins. Pre-prepared battle=flip a coin
elefucked
For me Punisher is Marvel's Batman
View all 2 replies
Hide replies
Gamer Space
part 3 punisher origins he now considered him self dead. not as in undead but frank castle was now more. when he was ready and had got weapons ( i carnt remeber were he had gotten guns from) He found the mafia family that killed his family and killled them all brutally using the knowledge and skills he had learnt in the military . Weapons demolition hand to hand combat. after this was the Punisher born and not until. i think he expected die but didnt 
I KEITH
This is how Batman STOMPS The Punisher. #1, Even though The Punisher beat all of Marvel,Batman beat a character who was able to defeat every other member of the DC universe (which was Deathstroke.). #2 Batman has bulletproof armour and gun disabling weapons. #3 All Batman needs to do is take away his gun with a batclaw and win. There are a thousand more ways but that would take to long.
View all 2 replies
Hide replies
I KEITH
The Punisher beat all of Marvel, that's your excuse? Batman beat the Justice League and many Marvel characters but beat some characters that are just like the Punisher hundreds of times.
to add this to Watch Later

Add to

Loading playlists...