 We are running out of time and I see that people here have questions So I would like to give the word to the lady here in the in the white place, please Please tell us whom you are addressing your question to First I'll tell you my name. My name is Mona Makra my bait I'm an Egyptian senator and member of parliament. I'm addressing myself as you can imagine to minister archaic first of all I want to Congratulate you for the Nobel Prize that was awarded to your president and a well-deserved one My second point is that I'm very impressed by the Advances that Ethiopia has made lately Whether it is in life expectancy and growth, etc There is one thing that I want to remind the Ethiopia of is that the Renaissance Dam is a great problem for both Egypt and Ethiopia there must be more flexibility on your part the president has taken the Nobel Prize because he brought peace between Ethiopia and Eritrea I Hope that the world policy forum will inspire him to find some Solution and it must be a political solution because Instability in Egypt means instability in the whole region. You know that better than I do Thank you very much, and you know that the first congratulations came from President Sisi and from the Pope because the pope the Coptic Orthodox Church plays a very important role in Ethiopia and in Egypt my second little point not much is to congratulate Minister Mesouaj for everything he said Et je voudrais vous vous adresser la parole en français comme vous l'avez fait pour vous dire que moi aussi je pense que la construction Je suis très optimiste pour le marlèbe mais surtout pour la construction marlébine qui a été prouvé par ce qui se passe en algérie et nous allons le voir de nouveau en tunisie alors je vous félicite pour avoir souligné les mutations structurelles qui sont véritablement porteur d'espoir merci Merci madame. If I may reflect on this important point. I Greatly appreciate the suggestion mentioned by my sister from Egypt I have been emphasizing about a win-win solution This is a central concept Our garment is focused the grand renaissance them as you know Focuses on generation of hydropower it doesn't affect the use of water for other purposes it only regulates and from the very beginning the Ethiopian garment sees that Egyptian people should not be affected by Such a project and our leaders are working on it and I'm optimistic it's going to be Resolved our destiny is Maturely Cannot be excluded Please Thank you very much. My name is Mubarak from Senegal. I'm the Director General of the Economic Prospective Bureau I want to disagree with the disagreement of Mr. Tin Tanaka regarding China if you take the word bank figure in 2017 the GDP per hit of China was 8,823 by growing 2.5 person in 2003 2030 it will be more than 13,000 so and the word bank defined high-income country as 12056 so I think ok be is right China will become a high-income country in 2030 secondly on innovation is rising to the culture. Thank you and at this point Let me maybe bring Olivier Blanchard in because I have since some disagreement as well and that last word to know Kitanaka Listening to the whole conversation It's clearly essential to know whether China is going to go at 6% or 2% because it determines whether it's going to be a g2 or G1 and a half and for Africa it makes a difference I'm More optimistic than Mr. Tanaka over he has spent much more time thinking about China My sense is indeed on population growth. There is no ambiguity on capital It's mostly domestic capital so even if Hong Kong were to close they still a lot and on innovation My sense is actually China has achieved the level of technological Sophistication which is such that they can have productivity growth from there So I think the 2% number is is much too pessimistic But it's clearly an essential number in terms of interactions with Africa the interactions with the US And how we see the world Don't know if you if you if you please briefly respond Rise of China, it's true However, when we see the future course of Chinese economy We are very we should be very careful I am now picking up three animals and the three colors One is a gray rhino cells It's Accumulated to death management of accumulate that when we see the rhino cells in the zoo They they are very stable, but when they get angry it's very difficult to handle so that the problem Accumulate that problem is very important for China for a variance policies are now being done for a very Barbarian's policy means That's not the orientation of high growth That's one problem. Second is a white elephant. So in the case of investment by government sector very inefficient equipment in very Inefficient parts are being produced that will have the Bad effect upon the productivity increase in China third is a black swan and In China There is some kind of possibility of systemic this so in the case of Property management in the rural levels are a lot of Falling money came to China. So refinance problem is now being Visited so in the case of refinance of their bond in data terms in some cases they are They are coupon rate is 12 percent or 40 percent or 50 percent. So in that case Some kind of bankruptcies in development of properties may occur that may become The allies of perhaps one. That's my understanding. Thank you very much. No, okay Yes, I know there is a much more to be said about all these important points that people have been floated here I think that that you're a demobilial has put me in charge here. He thinks that I'm a chairman He's actually wrong. I'm from Austria, but then the last my task here is to watch over time We're four minutes late. So for this reason, thank you very much for this panel for an excellent discussion I hope you'll all be around for the next days so you can continue this. Thank you very much