OVERALL THOUGHTS: If you're looking for a great pencil liner I'd highly recommend the W3ll People liner. The Jillian Demspey Liner performed almost as well and the addition of the smudge/wing liner brush is definitely a plus. Price wise they're pretty on par which is great. For liquid liner I love the Juice Beauty one and though not shown the 100% pure liner works super well too. Some great #greenbeauty eyeliners out on the market!