 you can see the candles here, the vigil for these people and on the other side of the road we can see cars basically bearing still the signs of the fact that they were smashed from the car in which another victim, a third victim were shot, you can see the right behind the bicycle still in that gray car bearing the signs of the accident, a driver was shot inside his car and then his car hitting the two cars here right behind me, a lot of anger here on the scene, people demanding security, we're here at the site and one of the funerals is set to begin in about 30 minutes right next to the place where we are, one of the neighbors who lives right nearby just came to do some shopping and he was shot just outside of his home, a lot of anger here among this community, a lot of anger generally speaking about those three attacks which you mentioned which claimed the lives of 11 people so far, a lot of anger here, people feel that they have a lot of questions to the government or the security establishment, many questions not a lot of answers. Okay, Janke, Falber is joining us now, thank you Jonathan, we'll be back with you later, Janke is a foreign news reporter for the new site, thank you very much for being with us on this difficult morning, Janke we were just seeing the scene with Jonathan there on site, it's just a residential neighborhood right, can you tell us a little bit about the location? Yeah, it's fine, we need to walk from my house, where I'm speaking to you now from, I'm actually going to the funeral very soon, I'm just waiting in my house to speak to you, yeah it's like a walk, my son was walking on that street like an hour before maybe, he went to visit, he went to meet his friend from school, he was riding on his bike and when I heard that I called my wife, I said are you at home, the kid she said yeah, what's going on, she didn't even know because I don't know, it's like the time when kids go to sleep, kids go to bed so not everybody is actually connected to the news and she told me that my son was 11 year old, he was just like an hour before on the street, the last street maybe the street after that, because he went to visit his friend now, I want to tell you the city is very shocked because we are not used to any terror attacks, I think the last terror attack in this city was like maybe 20 years ago, I checked yesterday, you know I googled so many, I tried to find, I think the last terror attack was like 20 years ago, maybe a little bit more, also not far from the place where there was yesterday a terror attack, it's crazy you know people just go shopping, it's not even a war against to, you know, soldiers against to a country, it's just plain terror, people go shopping, people live on the street, women, men, babies and just this guy as you can see now on the screen goes around and just killing people on the street for what, for why and actually, you know, most of the people, you know, in this city, also now you can see many Palestinian people working here, people working in shops, they work in buildings, they build us, this is a very welcoming city for Arabs, Palestinians, Israeli Arabs, they work here, nobody's arming and nobody's telling them anything and you know, when you see such as saying five people getting killed, one officer, wave officer killed the terrorist yesterday and you can see two non-Jewish workers from Ukraine actually, they didn't come because the war, I think they came here before the war, they came to work here and this guy is just killing everybody, he doesn't carry these people, Jewish, non-Jewish, I don't know what education this guy got in his house but I can tell you that my kids and the area where I live and you know, and the schools where my kids go to, they never get educated, they never get, you know, they always speak about behaving and being nice to people, I don't think that anyone in my city would ever do such a thing, it's crazy, I really don't know what to say. That's perhaps the most difficult thing with regards to terror attacks like that, that it only requires one radical madman and a rifle or a knife, as we saw earlier last week, to commit such a horrible crime that ends with the death of so many people. We're seeing some reactions, you mentioned that there is shock, what are some of the leaders of the community telling people today? Is there any way to comfort? Well, I want to show you, I don't know if you can see on the thing, this is a very, you know, very, it's a very strong newspaper at the Orthodox Community, it's called Gethe, it represents Degelatora, the party in the nation, I said, and the headline of the, it's like two headlines, one is one of the great Rabbi, great leader, Rabbi Edelstein, he's 90, he's 98 years old, he said that it's very, very, it's very, he said that because we lost Rabbi Kaniewski, you know, a week ago, we lost a very big Rabbi in the neighborhood, so he said, maybe we don't have protection from God. So this is one thing, one headline, and everybody's talking about it, actually, you know, yesterday, people said, when Rabbi Kaniewski is gone, we have no protection for the city. He was like protecting us, you know, from heaven, as we can say, and even when he was here. Now, the other headline is like he said, blood journey in Benet, but this is something that nobody knows. Now, everybody went to school today, and yes, the, you know, the, the council city are trying to tell all the schools how to speak to the children, how to explain them. But it's definitely a difficult day, though I'm sure people are trying to go back to normal today. Thank you very much, Yankee. Sabi, we have to part here. Thank you for finding time to speak to us before you head to the funeral. Thank you very much. We'll be right back. These images haven't been seen in Europe for decades, but now they have become Ukraine's daily reality. As Russia wages war against the Ukraine, our correspondents are on the ground, on the streets, in cities, on the border, Ukraine under fire, special coverage, only on I-24 News. Being able to see into the future. Discover the inventions shaping tomorrow. Israel Business Beat, Sundays and Wednesdays, 9.30 PM GMT. This night in a terrorist attack in Ben-Abrak, one police officer from the North and Arab-Israeli who stopped the gunmen, two locals from Ben-Abrak and two foreign workers from Ukraine, whose names are not yet published. Mary McAuliffe, this is the third terror attack in Israel within a week. And just like in the two other incidents, we're actually seeing live footage of this incident through security cameras that are now very common and widespread in Israel. Walk us through what exactly happened. We spoke to Yankee Fawba earlier who said it's a residential neighborhood, right? That's right, Ariel. And we do have so many images that are coming out from these security cameras and from people who are filming it from the scene. So we do have a fairly coherent timeline that we can put together from the videos from the scene, as well as from police statement explaining exactly what happened. So from these narrows, we have that the attacker disembarked on a vehicle on Jabotinsky shortly before 8 p.m. We can see this video that's showing right now standing in front of a local store. He pulled out his weapon and began firing, said to have just missed passerby, some were walking by a man on a bicycle before then proceeding to a different store. He didn't find a different street. Excuse me, on Bialik Street, they said he didn't find anybody there that was an empty street. It was about 8 p.m. at night. Nobody really in the area. And then he went onto a grocery store. Two people were shot dead at this store, this attack. And then he continued to fire a passerby who were walking on the street. The police said there was a moment his gun jammed briefly before he continued to shoot people. He said also one of the victims was in a car who was told to stop by the attacker. And then he was fired really at point blank range. There's very disturbing video that's coming out from this scene. And we're not going to show it, but you can really see the moment that this man was killed in his car. It was a six minutes before eventually the killing spree was stopped when he was eventually apprehended by motorcyclists, policemen on motorcyclists. One of the policemen who did was one who approached him, was tragically shot. And he died at the scene later at the hospital. But at that scene, once he was confronted by these policemen forces, he was also shot, the attacker, on the scene. So he was declared dead at the scene. You can see this is the motorcycle of one of the policemen there that was in that shot just before. And a word about the victims, Mary, as we mentioned, two locals, two foreign workers who actually came to Israel from Ukraine, how sad. And an Arab-Israeli policeman who actually stopped the gunman. Yes, we know from, so Amir Khoury, he was 32 years old. He was an Arab-Israeli from Nofa-Galil. So in Israel's north, he actually comes from a police family. We know the head of the police commissioner spoke to his family last night where he exchanged thankfulness from the Israeli people, saying that he really was crucial to helping to stop this terrorist from committing more murders and from therapy mean more victims. So sadly, he is joining the people who were also killed last night. OK, Mary, thank you. For some analysis, we now want to turn to Brigadier General in Reserves, Yosyko Brvasso. He's the former director general at the Israeli Ministry of Strategic Affairs, among his many other titles. Thank you for being with us today. Thank you for having me. Good morning. I think the most difficult question, I guess, that I can pose to you this morning is of the ease of committing such a terror attack. Because unlike some bombing attacks that we're used to seeing in the past in which an infiltrator like that would need a network and would need more assistance, perhaps, here we're just talking about a person with a rifle or with a knife. So what can be done to prevent this? And are we expected to see this wave continuing? Well, first of all, it's really difficult to confront such a wave of people that are not members of some sales of terror attacks, that plant terror attacks. And it's sometimes almost impossible. If somebody wakes up in the morning, takes a knife and goes to kill people in the market, very little can be done about it. But I think, first of all, in most cases, there are some early warning signs in the social media and so on that can help you know that something is cooking. And in some of the cases, when they really armed themselves and prepare themselves for a long time for something like that, they do emit all kinds of signs that should be caught by the intelligence and the security organization. And I refer mainly to the event that took place with the two guys from Umer Fache. That's one thing that can be done. The other thing is that you have to deepen your collection efforts and be alert. And whenever you see something on the social media, react to it. And don't assume that nothing is going to happen. And because we see that there is this phenomenon of people that are inspired by one attack and they want to imitate it and go and carry out another attack. And I think we are in the midst of such a period, especially with the feelings very, emotions very high and the day of the land today and the Ramadan that is coming and so on and so forth. So we have to lower the level of the bar upon which we take action and arrest people before they go out. We arrested this night dozens of people in the territories. I think this is something that could have been done a couple of days ago. And this terrorist last night, again, was it Israeli prison in the past? And also, I believe, the one from Chura in the Nege, who committed the attack last week. So they're known to the security services. Sure, all these people are known to the security services, which is, again, something that bothers me, because I think that when in a time like that, you should have a closer look at all those people who were in jail. And there's not enough reason to believe that they gave up on their commitment to carry out their attacks. These people that had inclination to support Daesh are definitely dangerous people. And again, this guy from Yabed last night was in jail and was involved in attempts to have weapons in the past. Somebody that should be looked upon closely in a time like that. OK, Brigadier General. Yes, very, very briefly. Let me say that we have to realize that we are facing a commitment by the majority of the Palestinian people to support this kind of attacks. And that's why every person can be the next person who is going to take action. And as long as the incitement goes on and the inculcation of this narrative that the Palestinians are in struggle against Zionism is going on there by everybody, by Hamas, but also by the Palestinian Authority, it's going to be very difficult to locate the next terrorist head of time. That's a very difficult job. You're sick with us. So thank you very much for speaking to us today. Thank you. And Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas issued a rare condemnation of the terror attack that left five Israelis dead in Benay Brak as dozens of Palestinians marched and rallied in support of the gunmen in his West Bank hometown. For more on that, we're joined by Ariel Osteran here in studio. So our rare condemnation, Ariel, from the president of the Palestinian Authority. Why now? Well, I think we are seeing recent meetings getting closer between the Palestinian Authority leadership and Israeli leadership. There are also reports that members of the staff of Israeli Defense Minister Benny Gantz approached after the attack members of President Abbas's staff and had asked him to send out this condemnation. It's also possible the affiliation of the attacker. He was known to be affiliated with the Fatah ruling party in the Palestinian Authority, the same party that Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas belongs to. But what we know about the attacker, Diyah Haramshah, who's 26 years old from the northern West Bank village of Yabad near Jenin, he was believed to be in Israel illegally working as a construction worker in Benay Brak. There are tens of thousands others who are illegally here in Israel working in construction. That's why I believe multiple mayors across the country halted all construction work today in their cities. Now, he was sentenced back in 2013 to 18 months in prison over affiliation to terror organization and weapons smuggling, but he only served six months of that. And so as you mentioned, as well as the previous guest, he was known to security establishment as well as the attackers from the last two terror attacks. This definitely shows a gap in intelligence. Now, Haramshah is believed to have been very religious, posting a lot about the al-Aqsa mosque. Just a couple of excerpts, he wrote on Facebook, those who want to meet God, God wants to meet them. The Zionists are not native to this land. And so our previous guest also alluded to the fact that as opposed to previous waves of terror in recent years, this time we have social media that can help intelligent services perhaps get initial alert to perhaps suspects like this. This is also something that will need to be looked at. Okay, thank you very much, Ariel Osiron. Rafael Roshalmi joins us now. He's a former senior intelligence officer at the IDF and a security analyst. And we're happy to be speaking to you again, of course. We heard from Ariel Osiron now what one of the latest posts of the terrorist was. If Allah wants someone would join them, that was more or less on paraphrasing, of course. What he said, can the Israeli defense forces can the Shabbat, should they arrest anyone that tweets or posts anything like that on Facebook that just hints towards committing any sort of terrorist activity, is that even possible? Well, it's not possible because you would have to arrest thousands of people right now if you would go on the social networks of the Arabic population of Israel and especially amongst the Palestinian population. On TikTok right now, you have tens of thousands of messages, louding the attack, encouraging further attacks, sympathizing with Hamas and the Islamic jihad. So you'd have to arrest thousands of young, hot-headed Arabic youth, but that are not each one of them going to actually perpetrate an attack in Israel. So the other problem that is not often mentioned is when you say that people have been identified in the past, they even served time in Israeli jails, the surveillance should be more strict. You have to understand that to watch somebody, you need a lot of equipment, staff and budget. You have to follow the person, you have to follow their activity on the phone, their bank accounts. I mean, you need two or three persons to actually watch one. So it's not physically possible, even though we know a person is a potential threat to watch everybody every, all the time, every minute. The last problem that I can see is also a legal problem. The law today in Israel doesn't allow entirely the Shin Bet to operate freely, even though it gave it some tools, the main tool being preventive arrest, what we call administrative detention, meaning the possibility to arrest on mere suspicion of perpetrating maybe a terrorist attack. But on the other hand, as you have seen and has been said very adjustly, the punishments are too light, they are not distributive. The six months, three months in Israeli jails, usually very good conditions in those jails. These don't distribute people from doing anything. The law must be much, much tougher. The punishment must be harsher on perpetrators or even sympathizers. The very fact that you sympathize with terrorism should already be punished severely. Yeah, Raffaele Roussalmi, thank you very much for those insights today. And thank you our viewers for watching. We'll be back with more after the break wherever you are in the world. We hope that you're keeping well and safe. Thanks for watching.