 Hi, good morning everybody. Just a quick housekeeping note if you didn't get a sheet that looks that says world cafe assignments at the top You should have been handed one as you were on your way in if I if you didn't get a chance to do that I also have some extra copies Yes, it's so it's like the grid would like all that your names in different colors I think some people might be leaving so they might not have it and it's just going to be your breakout assignment So you've been pre-assigned to different tables and you know the goal of that was try to get you talking to People who weren't in your session previously or you know people who aren't necessarily of your same Kind of area of practice, so we want to get a good mix of people, but eventually you will end up In a group that we could we tried to break people into different groups where it seemed like they had a similar area of practice And also try to get the numbers right so hopefully you know if everybody could just stick to the group that you were assigned to We did try to plan this like I know it's tempting to sit with your friends But we would really appreciate it and I think that we'll get rich conversation out of it and you know get some good feedback So anyway, thank you. Good morning. We just have a couple of things we wanted to address and then we'll get started with the rest of the day Hi everyone I hope you got some good rest and that ideas came flowing to you in the shower Just a just a couple of things just to focus us as Is as Kelly did at the end of yesterday? You can see this high-tech Venn diagram over here It's you can think of it as a map of the mall and it you know and not you know you walk into the mall You're not sure where I'm not sure exactly where I am on this picture But that green hatched area of the intersection between LC and IH Citizen science and NIH research is where we want to go. That's the store that we're looking for And and so we're hoping to wind up you know, especially in the last three hours focusing on the intersection between NIH research citizen science and and and the LC issues that need to be addressed to To to make sure that that you know it goes off You know these things go off well as NIH embarks on them and so Just as another reminder and and refocusing We thought we'd put up the emerging LC issues that people identified at the beginning of yesterday Obligations from scientific community regarding co-creation Making science go fast and obligations to engage people in the tension between those things Making data accessible Making sure that there's equity in in participation and that you know underserved people and people of different races ethnicities and socioeconomic status are Incorporated and and and Participate in citizen science Looking at community and public-led examples and then some of the types of research the the What what are the sort of responsibilities and and rules and you know good practices if we Probably don't know best practices yet that go with different types of citizen science research The looking at long-term stewardship issues and not just project-based issues Looking at how as people start to mix their roles as part as you know research participants and Researchers and start to wear many hats what their responsibilities obligations and duties are I think we're not so focused on you know the addictiveness of gaming And then the sort of traditional lc issues that we need to make sure we translate in citizen science Protecting participants data stewardship respect for participants interests and desires balancing privacy and openness Making sure everyone in the in the citizen science project knows whose interests are being served Making sure that there's independent review and oversight The benefits are shared that people citizen scientists get things back and that Participants who aren't citizen scientists similarly benefit Making sure that institutional responsibilities are met but don't overshadow studies And making sure again that you know any conflicts of interest are clear And so finally So Part of what we're still what we're going to be working on today is Identify and prioritizing putting finer points on what the issues are and The second part of what we want to do is Have you guys help us identify what research can be done? What what LC related research can be done to help address those questions start to develop tools best practices? Just frameworks for operation governance ideas Some examples Sarah Green put one up yesterday and noted you know that in PCORI They've sort of got natural experiments going in in governance models and trying out different things and One could certainly and one could look and see how they work John did not put that typo in there John John mentioned the you know the idea of using sort of a video pledge by investigators and possibly citizen scientists to You know of practicing well and and one could certainly sort of test the effect of doing that or experiment with it So I mean those are just examples of the kinds of things that we're hoping you guys can can Cogitate on a little bit and as you think about you know Research questions that we we might get involved in should they be proscriptive I mean we've heard a lot. There's obviously no one-size-fits-all. So maybe that's an easy question. Should they be maybe just descriptive? You know, this is what works well in my study or did not work well Do we need empirical data to inform any of these? of these Structures or tools new normative standards and should we be developing tools? You know suggestions good practice Checklists methods anything you can think of so that's a scattered way of trying to focus you it's but But hopefully that that gets us going and just to know so Part of what we'll be doing in these world cafe kind of exercises is asking you to think specifically on you know These types of questions which were related to the goals of the meeting and you know We just I forgot to do this yesterday. We want to thank Kelly Edwards in particular for helping us You know do all these different engagement trying to get everybody Really involved and really discussing these so you know, thank you again, especially for you know helping us especially with world cafe For example, we really think that it's been helpful to get people Involved and even things like setting up the room so that people can talk to each other easily like stuff like that So we're very grateful for all her help on that. So anyway, so let's get going So Sharon Sharon Charlie is going to lead our final sort of topical panel Which is sort of on the the LC issues that come up once the research data collection The study has been done, you know, what issues come up next in citizen science. Thank you so much Sharon