 So apparently you know we keep thinking about you know the secrets of a quest year I all the things Celestia is hiding right and everyone's always looking in Canterlot or the crystal Empire for these secrets or other places, right? Well, I think there's a lot of secrets going on in Ponyville that nobody is fucking right and it's like right It's always that hidden thing right under your nose, right? Why was there a fucking secret as compartment secret as book in the library? Did Twilight and Spike put that shit there or is that there from the previous library? Spike was clearly surprised that that was there He was but he knew what to do immediately. He's like, I'll just push this. Oh, look it open. Oh look a secret book I wonder what this is. Oh, it's the right one It's like how the hell did he know how did they even get to the right page in the book? Is that and exactly that right moment? He'd never found that before in all the times of being in the library for you over here the problem they were researching involved pinkie pie It is and pinkie pie has her own kind of fucked up magic I mean she can predict things, but I don't think she actually predicts things I think all of the pinkie power is Actually her causing them to be like a poltergeist. It's possible because otherwise it doesn't make sense. It never happens again. That's true So if they were researching magic around pinkie pie and her chaos or whatever happens Maybe that caused the book to appear at the right moment when pinkie pie was the most discouraged You know another possibility right is you know isn't there had cobwebs, but spike knew it was there, right? Maybe it was sort of like they found this book when they moved into the library, right? And they realized this is a book Information that normal people really you know you shouldn't let people check this book out because it's like Oh, I can go make clones of myself in the forest million derpies, right? So that book is like the guy that what's the title of that book they didn't say right the title of that book could have been You know the mystical secrets of Ponyville and the Everfree Forest It can be like that book in Gravity Falls. Yeah, and that book was probably newer than you know, I guess Granny Smith Yeah, that book is newer than granny Smith when of the founding of Ponyville, right? It can't be that old granted seems like no one really knew all the stories that granny Smith knew so those were already forgotten I know right so but it's like you know They must have found this book hit it in that compartment that they knew was there Which is how spike just knew to open it and then he's like aha, you know cuz he cuz twilight says, you know So spike, you know being smart in the library was like oh that sounds like maybe a secret of Ponyville But how did you know how did Pinkie Pie know a secret of Ponyville? Didn't she grow up my sister's and I were raised on a rock farm outside of Ponyville in Iraq Yeah, well her Nana pie Nana pie. Who's Nana pie? I know we've heard of granny pie Yeah, different from Nana pie So maybe she's lived in a series of foster homes along the way because a Nana doesn't necessarily imply Someone related by blood. It could have just been some people call grandma Nana Some people call it could be an aunt who you live with and also who trusts Pinkie Pie with the knowledge of a duplicating spell well It could have just been like you know a nursery rhyme kind of situation But she knew what it would do but nursery rhyme came from a real a real legend the legend of the mirror pool or whatever, right? And the first thing she thought of was oh, I'll clone myself with that thing. I bet I know where it is Upon beyond the most twisted of lines and then she knew the exact spell the words to say to make it happen and into her own reflection she stayed reflection she shared and Solid swear not to be scared. Well because it was in the nursery rhyme. So notice when she walked through You showed from her perspective coming back out and finding herself I wonder if she just entered another parallel world and is gone and everything we saw from that point forward was this other mirror world It's I thought about that as well She entered this mirror world, but you saw it when she entered the mirror world mirror Pinkie Pi came out, right? So regular Ponyville there could just be one Pinkie. That's mirror Pinkie The only way the mirror world right to Pinkie pies came out The only way to know will be if we ever have a reference to multiple Pinkie pies again because if there never is I'm gonna assume that Pinkie pies lost in mirror world and some people clone of hers is out right? It's like they buy an in regular equestria Pony world if you go in the mirror pool you go to mirror world, right? And another one comes out and it's everything's even but in mirror world, right? The mirror pool is not a backwards door to the regular world. It's not a two-way door It's a one-way door, but in mirror world. What does the mirror pool do and makes clones? Right, and that's how that works. I like how in Rainbow Dash first notice that there are multiple Pinkie pies She was not terribly Surprised so much is just annoyed. I mean you've already seen plenty of crazy shit This means that when Pinkie Pie does crazy crap Everyone kind of they see it and they kind of just ignore it Well, Pinkie Pie does stuff almost that crazy just on her own without any magic pools Like Rainbow Dash running across the countryside and Pinkie Pie is their Pepe Le Pew style, right? It's like she didn't need a magic pool for that and no one was surprised So Pinkie Pie's got some powers indeed. This is two pieces of evidence. Yeah, and she has secret knowledges Now the other reason I think it might be a mirror world is that the plan to choose which Pinkie is the right one Was a pretty crappy plan. It had a high chance of failure and sending the wrong Pinkie Pie back It did have a high chance of failure, but I'm surprised it's like throughout the episode They let the viewer know right which one is the real one Did they really maybe one of the mirror ones was very good at pretending to be Pinkie Pie? It's very possible There was only one way to tell it But the point is that one of them was different from all the others. There's one sad one And a bunch of ones that are just going fun fun fun Ah, but the other ones were all kind of stupid and didn't know stuff I mean she had to teach them the names That's what I thought they were gonna go back to was the fact that they didn't know the names and that they were just gonna quiz them on the Names all Pinkie Pie had to do the real one is go to Twilight and say look Quiz us about Ponyville. They won't even know who the mare is. Yeah, exactly But now they didn't so mirror world Twilight's not stupid. I Do like how they filled it in with a rock, but they didn't bother to do anything to the pool Right, they left the pool alone Well, maybe they just filled in this one entrance to the pool with a rock I think they blocked it with a rock so like Apple Bloom doesn't fall in when she's going on some cutie mark crusade and then they can go deal with it later Maybe you know Twilight's gonna go back and investigate if science is her jam I'm sure but you know, it's gonna be harder the rock in the way. I think really they just wanted to keep Pinkie Pie away from it I don't think she's gonna make the mistake of going back in there I like how everyone was again. No one was worried though. What if like it? What if like an evil dragon goes in there? What if discord goes in there? Well, then Celestia has to go in there, too. Yeah Why doesn't Celestia go in there? We could use five Celestias. Maybe not though because as we know that the Pinkie Pies were all like Mirror images and that they had a similar personality But it was extreme and they were otherwise kind of stupid and didn't know anything like they didn't know anything about Anything except partying and so so a clone Celestia that was stupid would be very dangerous indeed Exactly would be going like But I like how the ponies in Ponyville they did not go to the mayor They never go to the mayor Twilight is basically the ruler of Ponyville at this point. Yeah, I mean, you know I think the mayor wasn't even in the episode I mean, you know, I was basically the smartest, you know, it's like sort of like going to Ben Franklin, right? He's not in charge. I would go to Ben Franklin. Right. She's the Ben Franklin of Ponyville It's like, you know not in charge of anything. He was never president, right? But it's like you need shit done who you go to fucking Brent Franklin