 How's everyone else doing it's the last talk of the day? Still got a lot of energy you know I was a The first day I was streaming the one-on-one track and there was a lot of people that were You know coming up here and encouraging people not to go to the talks. They're like, oh, it's always uploaded on YouTube Why would you go to the talks and I'm usually one of those people? I'm usually the person that thinks that you're crazy if you're gonna come to a talk and stand in all those lines Mostly it's the lines being from Wyoming lines aren't a thing So it like makes my heart hurt when I see people stand in the line but I don't know to encourage people not to come to a talk that's um That's not I'd say it's misguided because there's something about being a part of an audience. That's just electric And you know, this is no surprise. You know if you think about any sort of sitcom that's out there. What do they do? They pipe Audience into your living room. They're piping soundtracks into you or Canned laughter into you just to make you feel that you're doing the right thing make you feel that oh, I shouldn't have to go Make real friends. I've got all the friends I need here in my living room So I mean it kind of makes you wonder. It's like oh so first off. Yeah, thank you Thank you for braving the the colds and the sinuses infections and whatnot and being here with me today um Yeah, so Yeah, there's something electric about being in the audience and it makes you think it's like what is that? What is that that's programming us to like to yarn to be a part of these social? Interactions and you know, it's things like laughter canned laughter can program us to act differently You know just how open how vulnerable are we? And I thought yeah, well, let's just examine one of the hardest cases that we know about and I'm talking about Colonel version Helen Keller She was blind deaf and mute and look at that. She's still reading. You're still piping input into her teaching her who knows what? So it's like if she's she's the most locked-down system I could think of and she's not locked down How wide open are we and you know, I'm joking but at the same time I'm really not because we can't stop stuff from coming into our eyes We can't stop stuff coming into our ears mostly you walk around Vegas. You're bombarded with stuff So yeah, what's my motivation? I'm a software engineer by day, but I'm a frustrated consumer by night Media consumer, you know, it's one of those things is you just feel icky. You feel it like propagandas is all over you You know, you can't escape it So what can you do about it? You figure that the people who can do something about it are the ones that are doing the propaganda to begin with You know, you can't expect anybody else to you know come to your rescue for you So I thought well, I mean Python solves a lot of my other problems could Python solve this problem for me as well So I guess it's time to take a journey It's time to fight your friends in alleyways Tell them to put on the glasses and if you don't get this you haven't watched they live and that's your fault You're wrong not me So let's define propaganda propaganda is defined in this talk. It's a real symbol You have a node a you have node B and you have a communication stream or a data stream This data stream is an attempt from node a to get node B to behave in such a way That directly benefits or get node B to act in a way that directly benefits node a it's real simple And it goes by many names, you know advertising lobbying social engineering All of Las Vegas essentially. That's all one big propaganda Yeah, so propaganda is defined by this talk it goes by very many names and you're probably thinking I do some of these am I Propaganda's yeah, you are we all propaganda is a little bit for sure And it's a it's a level like what we're willing to tolerate what we as an individual what we as a society We're willing to tolerate as far as what we're able to deal with or what we find acceptable in propaganda What about the word? I'd like to give a little issue of the word Because none of these none of these words are as scary as propaganda propaganda is the only one that really is scary Maybe social engineering is a little bit scary But propaganda is the only one that's really scary. You know the one that's always used as a pejorative and you gotta ask well, what's What's behind that? There's definitely a reason behind that Propaganda, you know was you know first came into vernacular and like you know the mid 1622 It was it stood for propagating the faith the world was getting Larger and that like our ships could sail further the world was also getting smaller and that kingdoms of factions were starting to bump into each other And so you had like this pope that's like God. I don't want to deal with all this shit That's on the outer reaches of my kingdom. I'm just gonna he didn't say that he speaks Latin and he um He uh, you know, he stood up this you know this propagation Propagation of faith and it became effective almost immediately In fact like the guy that was in you know the the cardinal that was in charge of the propagation You know committee he was he was known as the red Pope He was essentially an ad hoc pope for all the external kingdoms out there very powerful But even then I mean it wasn't it wasn't a pejorative It didn't become a pejorative until as in like a negative connotation until World War one after World War one What's going on there? Well, World War one if you you know if you I've listened to George Carlin's Dan Carlin's World War one history. I don't know if I highly recommend it But uh, you know, he he brings up like one of the ones the first war, you know major war in Since like the Napoleonic era, so you had this group of people You know who weren't used to fighting and you had to get him spun up You had to get him hating the other people and Hitler wrote in Mein Kampf He wrote a whole chapter on war propaganda. He's like this is where we fail the English word the English and the Russians They were way better and us we've got to do a lot better It was at this time also and and Hitler called it propaganda, you know, he loved the word And so that's why it became a bad word here Edward Bernays You know he's the father modern-day propaganda he wrote he lived at the same time period and he was actually wrote in his Propaganda he lamented he goes propaganda such a fine word and the Nazis went and ruined it He's like well, we've got to come up with a different word and the word he came up with was public relations, you know, that's the term Did the Germans learn their lesson Well after World War two was over the the Liberators or however you want to look at them We're coming through Germany and they came across the this man named Reiner Galen Galen And they looked at his anti-communism propaganda and they're like man, this is good. Can you do this in English? And he was like, yeah, I mean, yes, I can totally And it was very effective we have this retired CIA officer saying that we fed his propaganda that you know his anti Communism propaganda they fed in Pentagon the president's office and it was just he called it. It was basically bullshit It was boogeyman bullshit So, yeah, the Germans did lose learn their lesson and they still lost the war, but their propaganda machine was much better Yeah, thanks for sitting through that brief history Let's fast forward to like we have the rise of the machines with propaganda. What has that done? Now you've probably heard a lot of stuff about like how much it costs Google to power, you know to run their You know just to pay their power bill every day probably heard stuff about you know target You know could predict Lee Predict when one of their customers was pregnant all those kind of stories You know, there's just big numbers. We're not really quantifying it as a human brains, but then I saw this this This really neat article The heterotopia of Facebook the thing is Facebook is doesn't really matter. This could be any social Network out there on especially online and Yeah, go ahead and go ahead and I highly recommend reading heterotopia of Facebook and it's it describes What is going on with the human brain very succinctly when we? Participate in these social media groups, you know these These other spaces is what a heterotopia stands for Heterotopia is where you can go it's a space that exists in real life But it's a space that you can go and kind of project and live a sort of you know your own utopia The thing is everyone else is doing the same thing so you can get curved stomp if you go out there and project your idea You can also get your boots licked by a sycophant What foo called argues is that like whatever happens in these heterotopias if you're investing real? Parts of yourself into it every action that happens inside this heterotopia will have an effect on you in the real world Because your brain really can't distinguish between the two. It's like if I was a dumbass in there Why wouldn't I be a dumbass outside and the answer is there's no reason there's nothing stopping you you are a dumbass That post that was a shit post your whole life's been a shit post You know So yeah, so let's say you have these heterotopia of these spaces and you're a propagandist and you like you know A salesman comes up to you as is look I have these spaces where people just come and live their lives and interact with all these other people and it is like a Direct pipeline to how they act in the real world Also, we've had machines and we've recorded everything could this be of use to you. I don't know I don't know if it'd be worth my time says the propagandist obviously that's not what they say We know this because These industries are Titans Their owners are billionaires the people you know are trying to whine and dine the owners all over the place to try To get their services on you know to be beneficial to them So yeah, these heterotopias or these social media groups that collect all of our data that we invest Very real parts of our lives and it's a very important. It's very important Let's go back to 1993 Al Gore was talking about you know this this idea of like a gap between the information haves and the information Has not he's warning that if we don't you know provide technology to you know poorer populations They'll just get left behind Now in his book, I mean that's fine. That's a noble. That's a noble thing to say in his book data smog David shank He made a really good point He goes it It's one thing if you push technology on to a people But if you don't upgrade the people if you don't teach the people you don't give them the proper education of what it takes to you know To understand what these devices are and what data they're producing Then you're not helping the information gap at all. In fact, you might even be widening it So what's it take to be information have and information have not so what's that gap? Well, the information to be an information have it's not that hard if you know what a tracking cookie is if you You know you know why the internet is making these people billions of dollars if you know those things If you know what an ad blocker is you're already in the information has if you're one of the You know if you're one of these fine outstanding citizens that need stuff to just work out of the box you're an information have not and To Whoops, I guess I know too. Do we have any examples of information gaps today? Yeah, sorry I think so. I think one came up not too long ago in the aftermath of the Orlando shootings We had a talk or a statement from Hillary Clinton She promised, you know as president I will work with our great tech companies from Silicon Valley to Boston Step over game now She then goes on to give like the normal stump speech about intercepting Isis's communications tracking and analyzing their media posts Blah blah blah blah. We already know that there's already been plenty of discussion about that But what I find interesting is this as well as promoting credible voices who can provide alternatives to radicalization She's asking Silicon Valley to team up with them to promote credible credible voices Promote them, you know, whatever voice you deem necessary. Why do I think this is a? Example of the information gap Because I don't think she could have got away with saying something like this as president I will work with our great New York Times and its best seller list promoting credible books and authors who can provide alternative radicalization And so yeah, that's the question is like why can you know, why can a? What's the difference between you know Silicon Valley promoting stuff on their product and New York Times promoting books on their best seller Promoting books on their best seller list. It's one of those things where You know, some people read this they read about the government messing with their books and they go hmm. No, I don't think so You stop right there government You know, why can we let the social media, you know, the government can You know talk, you know presidential candidate can openly talk about how she would like, you know Private companies to help promote propaganda and this wasn't a one-off thing either. We have this one story. You might have seen This was in Facebook and Twitter pledged to remove hate speech within 24 hours. This is a story that was in Europe and Inside this article we see the companies who also agreed to promote Independent counter narratives to fight hate speech including content promoting non-discrimination tolerance and respect So we have this, you know, we have movements where private companies are asked to, you know Produce propaganda, you know, and are we okay with that? All right, so we have We have like we have this gap information haves information have nots the best way to get information have nots into the information Haves class is for education. Just educated just educated information have not into information haves And it's done. The problem is is that this runs counter to what a lot of you know There's a lot of people that you know in their best interest are keeping information have nots You know the the more I have nots there are the more ads the better ads you can sell or the target the people and You know the more surveillance you can collect on people, you know, so there's interest in keeping the information have nots Now you say well if we were to educate these people, what would it be? Thank you very much. That was a good transition to the next slide so I'm pulling this from a lot of the this Propaganda information from this book called firewall firewall propaganda's guide to self-defense Jack Nolan was a PSI officer himself in the military and If you don't know anything about the military, they have these things called field manuals And they are like the man pages for war if you if you ever find yourself an apocalypse. You'll want to secure a volume Now he's basically going through the PSI up Basically his training and he puts it all in this book So first off let's go on like what's a propaganda steps and we see here It's mostly like you know a normal, you know like a pen testing step, you know You start off with ID the audience, you know, you want to do some footprinting on them You want to you know determine what the audience is? You know limits are what you can get them to do what you can't get them to do You also want to determine who their ringleaders are in today's you know, you know in today's you know social networks We have all these likes we have followers. It's easy to tell who the ringleaders are the end users But also you got to remember that you can also target moderators and targets this admins a Propagandist may just I mean it's way easier What are you gonna do you're gonna target a group of people or you can just target a mod who can censor everything for you? If you want if you can get him, you know turn to your side The next thing a propagandist wants to do after ID and his target audience. He needs to you know Determine a goal state Most of the time the goal state is to make money You know because it'd be a lot of a lot of other things the goal state could be you know to get people to hate The other people so you can go to war But mostly it's make money the next thing you want to do is scan for vulnerabilities on A society on a group of people that you'd like to you'd like to change their behavior on These are you can tell what a society's vulnerabilities are these are known as hot button issues If ever you like ooh, that's a hot button issue. That's a societal vulnerability That is something that someone could always wedge in there you wedge a wrench in there and try to exploit This could be race religion gender wealth You know these are You know things that people are real sensitive about and you know it's up on the society It's upon the society to really patch these you can't you know if you're always going to leave this vulnerability open It's you know it's it It'll always be exploited Choose the theme of the message. This is essentially the exploit of the expert How do you how are you gonna exploit the vulnerability? Are you gonna appear appeal to fear? Are you gonna appeal to greed in group out group? That's very powerful. Like I said about people yearning to be a part of a crowd If you can get people feeling like they're an out group, you know I can get people feeling that they're in group because they continue to do what you want them to do These are all different This is your theme. This is the message that you want to run with you want to appeal to something of your audience fear greed whatever Next you want to plan for how to grab attention. This is essentially like your payload that you're going to be delivered You know, you're gonna do TV commercials. You're gonna do internet advertising Or many to choose from Next you want to test the message measure its impact adjust the message as needed repeat in today's day and age This is very easy to do obviously. This is you know, we get immediate feedback on the message and its impact and You know, we can adjust it as Needed very quickly repeat it repeat it. So that's what a propagandist is going to do. That's the steps What can a propaganda? What can a person do to counter the propaganda? What kind of checklist can they can they can they use for themselves? Series of questions you can ask is can the speaker gain anything from having me listen to them? You know, if you're talking to somebody and They you know, you feel you know, you feel it like yes, you know, if I listen to them They have something that they can gain if you know if I if I listen to them and you know, believe what they say Ask if the source is verified. All right. So when you're reading articles You know pay attention to what? You know, who's you know who is saying what sometimes you'll have an unidentified source You know, these are good clues so You know white source As the source identified this is like, you know, you know who the author is, you know, I'm the journalist, you know Glenn Greenwald. I'm publishing this article You know, he's putting his name out there if a source is unidentified you'll see sometimes like for instance in the Coup that happened in Turkey. It was an unidentified source that released You know that the president or the prime minister Was you know, he had he had sought asylum in Germany That came from an unidentified source and that's something that you could look into. I mean that's something that is a very good clue If an unidentified leak, you know Happens and the government tries to chase them off to Russia. You know, you can tell that that was not a government You know sponsored leak obviously they did not like that However, if a source isn't an article that it's not identified and doesn't seem to be a big deal You bet that that was a sponsored leak like they know the government was okay with that one And black as a source is falsified, you know, some people like Donald Trump they say stuff that's never happened before that is a black Verification that source is it's a falsified source. He said some that no one else has even said You also want to ask if the source is credible has a source lied to you before Usually when a journalist does something like say that they're they you know, they took, you know Rocket fire or they saw combat in an area. They're done. They're no longer credible There's no reason for you to believe them. So asking him keep track of your source You know, have they lied to you before how they have they always been truthful, you know that kind of thing Ask if you've heard the message repeatedly If the med repetition is key to propaganda, it's like their best friend. I kind of feel Kind of reminds me of like the Unix touch command when you run touch first Creates a new file, right? What happens when you run it again on a file? Modifies the M time right modifies that modified time and the way our brain works is that We rely heavily on modified time when we go to search for something we like to go to stuff that has received activity recently So when you build it when you send a message out repeatedly You're building familiarity We're a you know when we're when we're humans. We love familiarity, you know, it means that you're not a tiger That's here to eat me You know, it means that you're a Friend, you know, and so that's why Everyone's trying to push their label or their commercials or their propaganda on you all the time repeatedly That's why it's a good sign. That's why it's a good clue if you're seeing the message repeatedly Like why am I having to see this repeatedly think about every time you go into McDonald's? How many golden arches you see they're trying to build a familiarity presence? All right, manufacturing consent Ah This is a book written by man Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman and it's coming from the hypothesis that the media Mobilizes support for special interests that dominate state and private activity Basically, the media is not the fourth the state is what they're deciding there are what they're hypothesizing They're hypothesizing that the media is not this neutral thing that they will perform You know to the to the needs of the special interests of the society And to test this hypothesis days they developed a propaganda model And what's in this propaganda model this one of the things you first propaganda filters the size concentration ownership Size concentration of ownership owner wealth profit orientation of dominant mass media firms So in our beloved capitalist systems These media firms you know these businesses in general they're allowed to grow they're allowed to buy more Just everything around them so you can buy more media companies you can you know that's You could buy more things that aren't media companies and now you have now you have like a you know Maybe something that's making money, and you don't want your media firm to be you know to you know It's you know you have a business as shady you don't want your media firm bringing attention to it You own both of them. That's great. You can just tell the media firm. Hey shut up about this the media firm will be all right You're the boss Advertising as a main source of income. This is another thing so When when media was just sold as a subscription only kind of a thing The government's you know Publications were allowed to talk a lot of shit about governments and a lot of people in power but um It was hypothesized like well if we just turn it over to the market and so Maybe maybe the media would kind of sort itself out. It'll get back in line. You know people won't be as Anti-government and it really worked and one of the ways you know as soon as advertising came in it allowed for you know more rich people than you know rest of the population to come in and you know Kind of sort of invest in these media companies allowing them to grow bigger And so that's another way if you can't own the media what you can do is you can own You know part of the advertising that's a way that you can get your own kind of check and balance into like what message The media is putting out there and then we have this idea of like reliance of media on information provided by government experts Funnabite primary resources. This is where we get the idea of press conferences from so we have 24-hour news And you know we have or at least news that you know we have a newspaper every day We have a news hour every day, and yeah, we do have 24-hour news. How do we how do they have news? to give well, this is where You know Pete, you know very powerful entities such as governments and corporations can set up a press conference But oh you want news you just come to this location at this time. They'll be coffee and donuts You know we all you have to do is listen to us tell our side of the story and That's very important because now you have the media and the government just kind of working together And you know you kind of hear about it You know when you know someone you know some journalist goes on you know goes rogue and you know gets there Gets their credentials pulled for being allowed into the You know the press conference You know so it gets you know journalists to To kind of stay within bounds so they can stay getting news from these press conferences And also think about what this does it's like you're on the other side of the world and one of these big entities harms you in some way You have to wait for a journalist to like fly over and stick a microphone in your face whereas in With press conferences by the time that journalist gets all cross-seize to interview the victim the you know And the home side you know the big entities they'll have had their opinions in in You know the public sphere for who knows how long You know so Press conferences are very beneficial. They're very beneficial to both the media and you know government and high-power entities that can you know For to do these press conferences for journalists Flack flack is a way of disciplining the media. So if ever the media does something bad you have to have ways that you can Tell the medium you don't like that One of the ways you can do this is you know you can have counter stories run you can have You know withdraw your advertising this kind of thing You just want to make life difficult for any media that daresay something bad about you Another thing the propaganda model has is it has this thing called boogeyman boogeyman enemies when Manufacturing consent was first came out. You know communists were the boogeyman and the way they wrote it It's like they assume the communists would be the boogeyman forever We have terrorists as boogeyman today another boogeyman we have as we've been going over before is hate speech You know hate speech is being used, you know to get social media companies to help Propagandize It's users All right, so we learned some things about propaganda. What can we do? Well, I decided to make a reticulum. Why did I make a reticulum? Well because I'm addicted to reddit, all right? And you know my friend told me it's like that's doing weird things to your brain I didn't listen and so now it's the only way I can solve problems Because well, I mean the thing about reddit though is it's a very organized website And so if you can get rid of the people it's very pleasant And you know when you think about like I want to better my my media consumption You know, we're all familiar with this you know this concept of end-to-end encryption We don't want things in the middle. We want you know end-to-end so could we do the same thing to? To our media consumption can we get as close as possible to the knowledge source Without having you know all these grubby paws in there trying to change the message Another thing that reddit does Yeah, it gets rid of mods and admins. This is huge like I don't Read it has a lot of drama that gets kicked out because the mods and admins did something that was seen as censorship Luckily, I have not had to do any of that because I don't go to those weird subreddits But you know they have a point if like mods and admins can just choose to do stuff and you know against your Against your will is do you want that in a news source? Also, it's open source with a very easy install script and it's got this you know Python the Python Pro module is a is a very decent Module for you know scripting your reddit bots So I just stood up this digital ocean droplet. It's running a bun to this is the the reddit install script I mean it you can you know you can run it on like whatever Version you know a bun to or whatever that can support it if you're brave enough you tweak it to your harsh desires But like if you want life easy and you know something like digital ocean and we'll make it that easy You can just select whatever installed reddit shell is looking for and bam within 15 minutes You'll have a reddit clone up and running I Wanted to leave the reddit code alone. Yeah, I was like once I got up and running I was like alright, that's fine So then I just use pra and bottle and whatever and anyone here use bottle. It's very lightweight Python Framework, it's like it's very lightweight creates stupid simple API that I just send commands at it And it'll just send commands at my reddit clone Also, I use this thing called summary API Summary API was a life-send because I had all my scrapers out I had you know stuff like the natural language tool kit out and you know Parcy McPars face came out not too long ago, right so I was like wow I can do all this stuff But then luckily summary comes out. I was like I do all that for you plus You know, I don't have to I mean what it'll do It'll go out you send it a link or you can send a text and it will run an analysis on it and pull out the important sentences You know, this is literally if you've ever seen like a too long didn't read bot It's probably using this exact site. It's it's great at just taking the article Psh and munching it down to however many sentences you want you can munch it down to a tweet You know if you wanted to So yeah, I was very happy to know about these guys and I relied on the heavily also look I'm a slow reader So if I can just shorten articles, it's like look, I'm either gonna run a 10 sentence synopsis of this article Or I'm not gonna read it at all Some things summary, right? Yeah, everyone are ready for exciting demo. Look, it's reddit. Don't get too excited So this is yeah, so when I said it was very simple that was a lie Because I killed some of my bots, but I have one bot up and running So yeah, it's it's a very simple like whatever, you know, whatever You know, whatever domain the You know the the article came from that's gonna be the subreddit whatever author Wrote it that'll be the user So, you know red, it's a great way You can select, you know all the things that were published by the intercept all the things that were published by that author and You know that that part of the organization is done automatically the next thing you can do is like so let's take a look at this Summary because that's what we're looking at here. So I just I did away with titles, you know The journalists aren't the ones who decide an article's title that goes to the editor the editor wants to You know, he wants people to click on it. He's gonna make it click baity So let's get rid of it. Like I said, if we want end-to-end why not just get rid of that He's gonna try to get you to click on it. So get rid of it. And so What I have is just the top the the first 300 integers or 300 characters. I mean Is where it's limit. So that's you just That's my title So I read the first, you know first couple sentences And then we're gonna load it or not shoot. I thought I was on death con Well, and I realized I'm all you all are so so kind. I'm already over way over Alright real quick. Let me just go over this tips for reading internet comments. Don't read internet comments All right It's first off it's not doing good stuff for your health. All right, you get upset, you know It's raising your blood pressure. You're using your free time or work time, you know And probably someone on the other end is getting paid for that. All right, so you're hurting yourself Not only that but I mean we're seeing more of this, you know first off if you're rushing your troll You know, but you're you know, you're a Facebook warrior if you're British That's some interesting propaganda in and of itself, but we're seeing more of these things called ashoturfers or trolls or everyone very many names And that's very powerful. That's like, you know, you're talking to somebody like we were talking about in your heterotopia You're talking with someone and you think it's real, but they're not real and so also I like this It's like we're you know Russia has the troll army, but you know if you're you know, we're gonna go look at We're gonna have an internet stranger tell me who I should vote for that's above board You know so Even if you think you're the best internet debater in the world, you don't have an incentive you don't have a money incentive on the line But that's not I would argue that that's not the main reason you shouldn't argue and the main reason I think comes from the correct a record this was Hillary Clinton's super PAC and they were talking about like yeah, we ashoturf people and In the statement lessons learned from online engagement with Bernie bros during the Democratic primary will be applied to the Rest of the primary season and the general election So I mean it's even if you think that like you're you're you're getting good ideas out there and you're throwing them out there You're really not you're just helping them. You're building their their knowledge base You know you're helping them get better it kind of reminds me of like Like Rick and Morty when it comes to like those little micro verses You know they're able you know you have like this internet and you're in your your little thread And you're just but really all you're doing is you're speeding up their test And you're speeding up their their knowledge of how to Propaganda is the rest of the population because as they you know come out of that out of your thread They come into the real world and they're like oh, we have just the commercial for you All right, so just don't however. All right, so if you do insist on reading internet comments Or if you want to comment with somebody take out The public part of it take out the vanity part of it, you know whether it comes to upvotes or You know retweets or any of that just take all that and go to dm or p.m You know see about that, you know, I think most people you know, they've been most they've been accepting They'll talk to you on dm on the DL So I mean if you want if you're interested some documentaries I recommend manufacturing of consent. It's about three hours long Dad this is a documentary on Noam Chomsky and he goes over a lot of his theories on propaganda century of self is about Edward Nays This is the movement from like all right. We just kicked ass in a war. No what we can do We can make a lot of money. That's what we can do and that's what century of self is about it's about turning like propaganda onto the private sector Some books again manufacturing consent and propaganda by the same people firewall That was made by Jack Nolan. I don't know. I didn't put his name now some sites All right, so I didn't mention fair.org and I didn't mention on the media podcast Fair.org, you know the fairness and accuracy in reporting. They do a lot of newsletters on how to On just some bullshit that the media does on the media podcast You know, it's about if you like radio labs kind of the same kind of production value They give like 15 to 50 minute podcasts And they do some interesting topics on how the media is treating various different subjects All right, thank you for coming You've been too kind All right, hold up. Hold up. So if you wanted to see Yeah, this is summary. I've got like little ten sentence summaries. You can come through and you can read the article Very quickly if you wanted to and if you and you know, I always include a link So you can go see the real thing if you wanted to anyways. All right now I'm done You