 Also Jahresrückblick mit Erdgeist, Konstanze, Dinos. Von Erdgeist, Konstanze, Dinge, Frank Trägerst und Heckfit. Herzlich willkommen. And a morning today with more Cyber-Cyber, which is also quite in all the other days, and a small change in the people who are here. We surprise with new people here every day. We have got a new person here. We don't have other speakers on the podium, but also one of our big ... Ja, Vorstand ist Herzens natürlich. Das möchte ich dazusagen. Ja, und Prozedere hat sich trotzdem nicht so toll geändert. The procedure doesn't have changed a lot. We'll go chronological, but not only. In the beginning we talk about how many members there are here, some numbers from the secret databases of the CCC. This year again we have more members as last year, and not a small number of new members. Hey, that didn't want to do something completely else this morning. Okay, wir machen eine extra Vorstellung. Okay, let's do another ... Hallo, ich bin das erste Mal da. Hi, ich bin Hackpiet, und ich bin hier für das erste Mal, und ich wusste nicht, dass ich hier zehn Minuten vorher sein darf. Das ist natürlich der dreiste Lüge. Das ist ein Lai. Er war bereit für Wochen, und er ist natürlich immer sehr bereit. Hier sehen wir einen ziemlich fleißigen Office. Hallo, ich bin der Erdgeist. Ich arbeite auf der Datenschleiter. Ich bin hier nach einem Jahr zurück. Ich bin der Linus. Meine Hobbys, meine Hobbys, meine Reitungen, die Swimming und die Computer. Ja, das ist auch noch Frank. Das ist auch noch Frank. Das ist auch noch Frank. Das ist auch noch Frank. Das ist auch noch Frank. Das ist auch noch Frank. Das ist auch noch Frank. Ich bin schon hier. Ich bin hier. Das ist auch noch Frank. Das ist auch noch Frank. Da ist die Ikon MC. Das ist auch noch Frank. Ich bin hier. Ich bin hier. Wir machen mal wieder große Raten. Wo kommt dieser Kommunikation Congress? Natürlich, genau, nicht nur, dass wir zu der Schlaferzeige, die wir against der Regierung, über Secretsurfaces und andere Menschen mit anderen Suspexen haben. Wir haben noch nicht starten, aber ich kann noch nicht einen Satz machen, weil jemand in meinen Sentences sprechen. Frank shared Bum Bums, so wir können talken. Okay, not only have we got a lot of new members, but also if we look at the mails from all years we got the most letters or emails during the last year. They were a bit different about how the press reported about it. I just wanted to show the high points in the statistics. You can also try to guess the second tip. Ich glaube, da könnt ihr nicht darauf kommen, die muss Heg-Pied erklären. Oh, mich again? Oh, that's probably because we had a really successful effort, guys, who earned a burger net fine, and they all joined us, so we see a real nice peak here, where we just own them. Okay. The Alpha Paderborn can feel good. The Alpha Paderborn will announce later. Here we see the Airfas, and the smaller points in the maps are the Castrefs, and also next to it on the right you see the entrance area, which are to the Airfas. And the still available white spots on the map. But we also see this anomaly towards the east, where we diversify over the German borders. With Heg-Pied, we do have two new Airfas, yes. So we grow, was I supposed to be prepared for this question? Ja. I think we go forward to new... There are different memberships in the Airfas. There's still the big one in Hamburg and in Berlin. We also see that Munich is still growing up, and we have another rather larger membership in Cologne. So I think that's divided up quite nicely. So the big Airfas also have more happenings, there's more things. So they also grow faster. Aliens, which is meant on the... are members who are not part of a certain Airfa. Around two-thirds don't claim part of an Airfa. But we recommend you to join an Airfa so that money flows towards the Airfas more directly. Airfas ist ein Außtauschkreis. So, we're just a strange name. And those who want to join an Airfa should do that over our forms. So we're also becoming more international, as you can see by the global map here. So, we're spreading. Without Germany, you can see here, the memberships in other countries like Switzerland and Austria, obviously German speaking countries are the strongest, but we also have members in Hong Kong, Singapore, etc. And we'd like to keep these statistics and watching them. I don't want this gadget. So, anyone else? So, we tried to do a different kind of evaluation this time, which I find quite stunning. Now, as the member base is diversifying, we also have quite a large variety in the kind of emailed addresses that are submitted. So, getting GMX and Google. These are the burner email addresses that people tell us for wants to throw away. Well, in any case, or at least Posteo, a German private email provider, has already reached top five. So, not a single anon box address, remarkably. Well, they only have five members. We're just giving a short overview of the tweets, the public actions that have been taking place in the course of the last year. We just want to highlight what got the most public attention, like our top nine, but our press work in general. We've been getting a slightly smaller amount of press inquiries. It's the press out CCC address. There's a lot of obviously spam inquiries, but just looking at a pure press inquiries. We have like 10 people trying to reply and also obviously refer press to experts within CCC. Who can maybe answer questions? So, our question has actually increased in the last two years. But there's been no notable increase in press interest. So, that just means for us, that for social media and just our own channels, we would like to provide a bit more information, like coming from our side. Well, but maybe it's also not that bad, that the kind of a bit fell over somewhere on the other end of the world kind of inquiries. What does the CCC have to say about that? Well, we don't have to feel like obliged to comment on everything. And that kind of a generic statement inquiry, that's become a bit less. So maybe more targeted questions. So, actually, there's been quite a learning curve for the press as well. Maybe what kind of inquiries we receive. Well, this annual report is also kind of justification or trying to recap what we've been doing in the past year. Well, we're like using our Twitter account, for instance, as just a proclaiming organ, just to post our own messages and obviously also Diaspora also. Weiter leiden, automatisiert, but this is just an automated service, where we just republish our releases. Wir haben trotzdem jetzt mal einfach mal natürlich die Anzahl derjenigen, die uns auf Twitter folgt, schon deutlich höher ist als bei Diaspora. So, ja, obviously the followers on Twitter is these are the largest number of followers, like compared to Diaspora. So we do use this and republish all of the channels. So, it is actually the Twitter channel that gets the most attention. And I'd like to highlight a few of these points. Well, one highlight was obviously the German government trying to purchase zero-day exploits and the way we treated this. Another was the support for Edward Snowden and an honorary membership for him. A whole other debate about a court case that the CCC filed. This is, we're going to discuss this later on. So here you can see a comparison between German and English tweets. Some topics obviously have a bigger scale and a larger international interest so that it's more, yeah, that we try and get it in several languages. Well, D-E-Mail, this was a German government trying to develop an intern encrypted, well, not even an intern encrypted email service. It was quite a joke and we've been accompanying this critically. Yeah, well, you can always put a D-E-Mail joke. These were obviously popular tweets. So, first it was a paid service, then they changed it to free and now you maybe get a free voucher for your, whatever. First they came for the pawn. This refers to the info we got that these blacklists or censorship lists could be, could be retweets fast. Well, this was like our highlight tweet, 420 retweets. But we're going to mention these censorship structures more seriously later on, so. So, this tweet shows, for the moment the winner, we put out like a complaint with a general attorney about buying, we'll try new things all the time with various media and trying new things, new corporations with international media. And this hopefully continues into some 15 with new developments. So sometimes there are long-term developments and so we have some time to plan and hopefully we'll continue into some 15. Now we started at the beginning and started at January. It was a very cold month. 16 million email addresses were stolen. BSI, the German Ministry of Information Security put up a page where you could enter your email address to figure out if your email was compromised or your password. Three internet ministers were presented to us before we didn't even have anyone and now we have three. Sigma Gabriel, like a ministry for economics, Alexander Durbrindt, a minister for information highway. And the third one, who was that? The emissier. He isn't allowed to go missing. The net neutrality order by the FCC was turned over and Andrea Fossoff was data protection officer in the German government but no valuable input from her so far. Peter Scharr, her predecessor, spoke here last year and he was given a hearty farewell and even now we only realize what a good job he did. The question you have to ask yourself is who was guilty why this post was so declining in value. And it seems that this position lastingly dropped in value or in importance. Aber selbstverständlich haben die Mitregierenden und Sozialdemokraten sie auch mitgewirkt. Also also governing social democrats, electators as well, so they also at fault and not only the Christian democrats. In both governing parties made clear how important that post is for them which is like not at all. The office of the Federal Privacy Protection Officer should have was asked to become an independent office aber ist halt durch Besetzung zu entschärfen. So, it's independent now but it's still controlled by the government so it's actually not that independent. Ja, and now the holder of that post actually always has to confirm with the chancellor's office was he doing. So it should be more independent but in practice that's definitely not the case. So I don't think we have to say much more to Ms. Fossoff. She didn't get any bonus points in advance. She has no competence in this area as a MDP she always positioned against data protection so she met the expectations. So a small update to the procedure before the European Code of Human Rights in Strasburg which is not directly an action by the CCC but Constance is involved with it and we get help of course by the CCC so we got notice that we got Rule 41 priority case which means that it's going to be processed faster during the year some changes happened but we didn't make a press release for that on CCCDE because like actually no new result was decided so the court put out a new catalogue of questions and several NGOs die Bundesregierung hat sich entschieden darauf keine Anformen und ja, there was some because Constance is German national and the main complainants are British national. So, another interesting thing is that there's more procedures by budget activists for the investigative powers tribunal in Great Britain which is like a secret court and so it's not really sure in this case if we can go to Strasburg directly but then it turned out that there was another court case where they already decided so there's at least a few others who can go directly to Strasburg and so the British actually signed the European Declaration of Human Rights so they actually bound to that and have to allow cases going to Strasburg so there was communication because lawyers and the court and there were some there were some slowdowns but still the case is going on and maybe probably in spring we can give you some new some new developments, some new updates how much priority is actually a priority so actually the court decided to wait for the other cases from Great Britain because they're similar in content so Chaos Computer Club Dresden moved to a new home they renamed the HQ to Grand Chaos HQ so they had a very nice post-ladders maybe they'll get some random mailings now now it's February already very cold month publishers banded together in Vigemedia Netflix made a deal with Comcast und ja, after Night and Trilogy was disbanded in the USA Christoph Käse, German lobbyist is for the publishers law was actually quite happy but TCC actually first just father complained against the government so much has been said about about the complaint but we were told that it's a very political move and not more apparently the public was waiting for actually someone doing a step in theory responsible government authorities so it's of course a political action but not only at some point even if it takes very long at least they will have to decide ob they drop the case or they prosecute in some way but of course it's kind of unlikely as he's not even allowed to read the case files but of course then you can still file a complaint against in the court or something like that but of course it takes time und Lawyers of the International League for Human Rights have to write the complaint against the government and what was done was put forth by the Snowden papers we have put that in and then the Lawyers edit the legal part so in every interview we had to justify that it was a political action but I'm still convinced that our criminal law is still prohibiting intelligence agency actions so let's see and I still don't see a point that you can also start such a criminal case for political reasons and we'll come back to that later there was an amendment and then regarding CCC but this is just about the criminal case right now there was a consultation of the Federal Network Agency about the IT Security Catalog in which they were discussing the rules and regulations for the providers of critical infrastructure Matthias Dahlheimer of Konkau's Computer Club wrote a statement about that we criticized that the providers and the compliances was natürlich nicht schwer so by the network agency so a couple of weeks later we saw this in the IT Security Law not just for network providers but also for providers of critical infrastructure and in the IT Security Law so it's the case that the IT Security Catalog can set their own security standards but the idea is that within the business association people come up with security standards together debate these standards and then it will be decided by the Federal Agency whether their proposal is correct or should be extended does not think it can set these standards itself but thinks this should be done by the association of network providers all of these bring two to three hundred pages of minimum security standards and then find the smallest common denominator man kann sich also überlegen welche der beiden Optionen ein oder die alle Grimits zusammen und das ist viel Arbeit natürlich ist es sehr apparent dass sie das kleinste common denominator die wirkliche Erhöhung der Sicherheit also wir denken nicht, dass es eine Erhöhung der Sicherheit wird overall wenn es um die Erhöhung der Sicherheit kommt wir mussten in 2003 wir mussten wir mussten Internetblocking in Nordrhein-Westfalia filteren die DNS-Requests und in diesem Kontext haben wir die DNS-Requests aufgesetzt und wir erstaubten Resolvers und haben dann über den Konkurrenz talked to und enquired so wie an alternativen source in das IP das erreicht war zu enquiren 나왔 thicker ihr werdet den DNS- Jeffrey ein weiterer Wir sind sehr empfehlt bei das. Wir haben ein Software aus eGB, und wir haben das mit modernen Extensionen geplant. Und jetzt ist es wieder gut. Vielen Dank. In diesem Kontakt, dieses Service ist von Volunteern geführt. Ich würde es nicht kritisieren, weil sie über die Jahre viele andere Probleme haben, die die Betriebssysteme haben. Sie haben viele andere Probleme in der Operating-Systeme, für Beispiel. Wir haben nicht nur Open Resolvers, sondern auch, seit einer langen Zeit, Tourinfrastruktur, Jagdinfrastruktur. Wir haben einen riesengroßen Java-Server, seit ein paar Jahren. Wir haben ein paar Java-Services, die wir alle haben, und das ist ein sehr grundsätzliches Problem. Wenn es eine Zentralisation ist in einer solchen Institution, wie du es glaubst, dann gibt es Microsoft-Probleme. Es ist immer ein Microsoft-Problem. Wenn jeder ein Monoculturen benutzt, dann gibt es ein einziger Punkt für einen sehr dunkelsten Target. Also, wenn die Secret Services der Welt ausbaldauern als Interessant in our Java-Server und wants to inquire our Java-Server, we do not reach our intended goal, which is in addition to thinking our volunteers, I would like to ask all of you for a decentralisation. Everybody should run their own Java-Servas. You should establish tour exit points and be very careful in doing that. But there are rules and there are instructions on how to do that securely according to German law. How to get in touch with your ISP and tell them that you are establishing a reverse entry so that law enforcement knows that you are running an exit point. This is a possibility and we as the Case Computer Club we don't want that everybody donates money to us so that we run these services because also services like tour rely on the fact that there is not a single player which is so big that it is so visible and dominant in the network that it becomes insecure. We love your donations and money but it is still important everybody who wants to support us also supports us in action by growing and diversifying our infrastructure. I also think redundancy creates established security and we have to ask everyone to build their own infrastructures. So this problem with centralisation has become very evident in a couple of days ago when CCC received one or two gigabyte data and was offline for one or two days and then we only realised how many people are dependent on that so it is good if you have an account but you need other accounts preferably on servers run by friends organisations you trust. Wir haben uns noch aus dem Bereich Infrastruktur noch an Freifunk beteiligt. In the field of infrastructure we also participate in Freifunk concerning decentralized infrastructures you probably know this Internet zu bringen they bring villages and small towns online in a decentralized way. So who wants to talk about this about the support of that? Regarding Freifunk we have like a lot of our local constituencies we have a lot of active members and we try to centralise that or coordinate that but the structure has been growing organically over the past years. So we always call for decentralisation but our new thing is forced decentralisation because since publication yesterday you can't register for Java at the moment in any time you have to decentralise that's another level of escalation. So we'll see how to continue that next year. The question is how does the club define itself or see its role in that we see a growing attitude that like the club can run this you can establish these infrastructures but in the end it's a couple of individuals who are interested in volunteering but we as a structure are not that good in doing this it's individuals who spend time and energy and it's dependent on their work and you have to rely on them to provide your infrastructure and running it professionally. So it's not our job to run infrastructure we love doing this so if you set up a Java server you can build a Port and of course the supplies if you run a Java server you can run a diaspora port so this concerns social media in the same way so if you think about the e-mail addresses you can also set up a mail server all these things are good contributions so help friends and then there's the next month we have Marc Zuckerberg who was always in the CC Brechviel complained himself about how the NSA spent on everybody else so somebody knew who wants to work with us well more or less the European data safe we went into the parliament but nothing happened there the European court case allowed the internet blockings and in NSA yeah group was called into the name was called into action at the beginning they only looked at the NASA but it's under the order of Clemens Binninger who was not that well maybe somebody was him well if you have been in the canteen of the Bundestag you know him but the interesting effect is that he was decided to be the head but he ran away so we'll get to that on April so we also a free software foundation communicate with the free software foundation towards the bundesnet agentur said that that everybody can provide their own router and we are still on the opinion that that's true and we still think that the bundesnet also make sure that that's named beim anbieter wechsel especially when you change the provider the if the device is directly connected to the network then it's an attack point and you want to have your own decision to run free software which is usually not on the router so the critics points are still there but we just pointed at the bundesnet we do care about this subject that we look at how the rules change in the future the bundesnet agentur after this formal of the situational we didn't get a response for that changed their propositions in some points towards our direction also if the equalization of the router the fast router change was announced but there were no real success what's quite interesting on this point is that how the provider argument so what they actually want is that they force their customers to use one specific device to get internet at home or to use their internet connection and they force them by trying to log the device for the users so they don't have the knowledge on how to configure another router to use the SL they say that the modem is an important part of the internet connection that if working wrong could lead to problems on the network so we had that already that reminds me of the bundes post so that German does come so the debate is where does the telephone network finish so the router and the wireless access point is just one device the end of the connection is at our wireless not in front of the modem or at our modem so the technical discussion had this high point here so that the bundesnetzagentur moved the decision up until the there was a law so that they had actually the need or the permission to do something like that so they're at the moment just afraid to do anything I can just assume why that's it's that way yes well we know that the bundesnetzagentur is a bit slow in many places but I think that there's also a political discussion room so the coalition was against that so we want to make sure that there are no backdoors in the agreements when our work together with the free software foundation constanza yeah there was I want to mention it because there are a lot of press requests about that and because nothing happened to someone from the press team in the last years so I was first uninvited because of the 31st C3 hack which happened anonymous es war so romantisch about a romantic mails which were sent to many members of the high school cultural who called which were not programmatic and month after the congress in april I want to talk there about snow and I was abroad and suddenly I read a letter to me on the internet and it was this one and I hadn't received it yet they sent it to my office and I haven't didn't get it yet so it was quite interesting to get my letters over the internet so I don't know why they decided to put it into the internet but they did not think it was adequate to invite me here because someone had sent these love mails, a scale of them so some people had responded to these love emails so apparently there were quite a few embarrassing moments finally there was quite a bit of bubble rise so someone took the it and wrote it into the blog and much later after it was completely forgotten there were tv teams there and who asked questions about love emails so it's quite funny there a long blog post where these emails are written in the internet so next to the ok it's the they finally added SMTP authentication authentication muss man glaube ich ein bisschen mehr sagen you have to say a bit more about that check your university networks where the university is quite surprised because they were forced to look at it in a completely different school so so they just completely finished to stop the organization so everybody was of a different opinion than the leader of the school so yeah I did not go there and someone was here is full of that so we don't think that it's important to talk here about it but of the work we do if you represent this the club when we had the doors, after the content was disinvited we invited the CCC went to Hochschweier nearly in south france in future planning sessions in the hostel so please look at the double bed because some people from the east republic who were never outside of Berlin with the decision that it was in france they we tunneled all the domain name requests through the french network so we sat together for a weekend and we talked about what we want to do with this club we made a lot of actions over the last years but we never talked with each other about what we wanted to do so we locked ourselves in for a weekend and we had great weather and we had great wine and talked really good okay everybody in reality everybody screamed at each other we discussed a lot and it wasn't just happy so we have the problem that the CCC grew significantly not the number of active screws significantly but that to a problem that you can't discuss internally so if you know a discussion that we have to talk about what will happen next year so we talked about here all the first time and it really was a youth hostel so it was also to find an opinion and find people who wanted to engage in that but the wine was well he can talk more about that so part of was so in the CCC and it was here they were here so please a warm round applause that they were here so so that everything happens as well with the small groups of which are decentralized we have to meet centralized twice a year once in spring in the west of Germany which was the south and in october more northly so we decided to these two meetings to also work on our and we also wanted to invite other people who wanted to make projects like this just to share our and pass on knowledge so april april was a funny month the EU parliament decided for net neutrality and against roaming fees the US government decided that maybe they should remove the NSA to well to generate them there was great applause for that e-mail made in germany switched on TLS after a long time finally the european law decided that the preemptious saving of telephone information was unlawful and so thank you for working towards that the to talk about it and then there was there was something about heart bleed yesterday we had a nice explanation about what happened and kevin step back because snowden was supposed to be invited into the nsa security so war es das war nicht der offizie aber weil Und es war nie wirklich eine NSA, die meistens über den Sicherheitsservicen oder die BND reden. Wenn du siehst, was es um die drei Parts gibt, für einen natürlich über den NSA oder die GCHQ, aber auch über den anderen Teil der deutschen Sicherheitsservice, und die etwas zu finden, für welcher Wachstum ist. Das Klub hat es bereit gemacht. Genau. Da wie ja eine kleine Situation. Wir hatten ein kleines Unfall in Stuttgart, Baden-Württemberg. Da ist ein Tag vor Easter. Und wir hatten eine Location für uns, für unseren lokalen Event, das war supposed to sell beer, etc., aber diese Public Holidays war auch sehr super. Stuttgart war ein klasse Gastgeber. Ich glaube auch da war ein warm Applaus dafür. Das war ein tolles Host für uns. Es gab natürlich auch für die Auf- und Abbaufragen. We had a lot of hot dogs in Stuttgart. And obviously the police arrived when we were clearing out to see if we left it behind in a state. And that was acceptable, this is the South of Germany, they have the Keawoche, which is cleaning your house. And they take this very seriously. So we complied with the Keawoche. So this is a completely different event, it's called BBQ without any necessity. So we just have, for no reason at all, fresh air sausages and fire. So we were bitten to bits by Bon mosquitoes, but these were quite a lot of alphas, the regional working circles collaborating here. And we're going to do that again next year, the BBQ for no reason. Maybe Kulayun, are you sure? Well, all the West German alpha circles. So, another highlight is the big brother award, Edward Snowden. And the German Chancellor's office was also one of the awardees of this. Well, negative prize, but in fact Snowden was our first positive prize. Also a bus service and CSC, you can look at the awardees of the awards on the Big Brother website. And we can see that we weren't obviously anyone awarding something to Snowden, but in Germany, German groups, lobby groups, activists, there's been a lot of ceremonies and prizes, it's hard to count, it's just, at least two dozen. But in Germany in particular, which I find remarkable. So these are the German Big Brother awards, they're awarded by digital Courage, from Furbut. But even in the Netherlands, we get quite a lot of media attention. So we're forking. But in the Netherlands, the awards will be at a different time. So, now, May. So, this was the first statement from the German government that they don't want to invite Edward Snowden to the Secret Service or the NSA Government Enquiry in the German Parliament. Well, it would have been like the more decent move to enable this invitation. Well, Wheeler is a former lobbyist of cable network services and the European Court. We're going to talk about that later. The right to forget, this was a big debate. So, the reason to not press this inquiry further within the NSA Enquiry Commission was just to not offend anyone. It was a policy question more than anything else. So, they were being very, very cautious. So, Mannheim, which is a city in the south of Germany, Baden-Württemberg, it's quite a nice place. Well, yeah, you managed to leave Berlin. That's commendable. CCC travels. So, what happened there was like a meetup. We have a new head of CCC, that's Dodger, you can occasionally see walking around here and you can give him a big hand. Wir haben zwei neue, zweite Vorsitzende, Andreas Burg und Martin Hasemacher. The deputies are Andreas Burg and Martin Hasemacher. Wir haben den neuen Schatzmeister Dominic Keller für Finanz, das du als German Club brauchst. Du brauchst einen neuen Erfahrepräsentanten, Heckpiet. Und für Erfahre, für die Regionalserkennung, der CEO der Harte ist. Wir wurden auch einige Entscheidungen getroffen, die wir dann auch fröhlich bekannt gegeben haben. Und wir haben eine neue Sache geredet, wir haben darüber gesprochen, happy decision making. Man muss konstatieren, das ist ja jetzt ein paar Monate her. It's quite good to discuss the collaboration within different groups, like the CCC management as well as the press representatives, spokespeople. Even Heckpiet can be integrated into the discussion. So communication does help to just find a level of exchange. Das Antragens der Ehrenmitgliedschaft. So, after our membership, after our members meet up, this was quite, this was just consensus that we want to support Edward Snowden and also offer this honorary membership. So this was quite a sort of GDR style result in the election. So there was not a lot of opposition, I think that was more or less consensus. And the growth that we're seeing here, I think it's good to see that we can find common ground. So the European Court decision about the so-called right to forget, suppressing search engine results that are outdated or unwanted, this was one of the big topics. Well, first of all, we didn't really push our opinions or articulate too much what we thought of that, because we didn't really know how to position ourselves in that context. So this judgment is used in a very big way by people who did something not morally great, but then want to cover that up in some way. And like, for example, kick out press releases or press articles out of Google. And so, that's like a dilemma. So it's, you know, in a way it's for privacy, but also not really, we can't really add anything meaningful to a discussion there, I think. Fast nur auch die Pressemitteilung des EUGHs bezogen. The most news articles were just about the press release, but after the judgment was properly released, we actually looked at the judgment in full. Well, of course, it was very hard to argue, because, you know, then there's like a lot of debate how many actually complaints or notices were actually given to Google. And so, but, you know, we couldn't check that in any way. And that's part of the problem that never, the issue was never that the information was incorrect, but that you don't want it to be found. So that's kind of a tricky issue. And that's one of the problems by having like one very dominant search engine in the European area. They have a very interesting style of argumentation based on privacy law, because they said, Search engine is not a search engine, but an aggregation of data over a search term, like an automated aggregation of data. And that means that the search engine has to comply with privacy law, as it's aggregating data about a person because it's showing relevant information to a certain term. Der kuriosen Fall, dass dieses Suchergebnis ja nicht verschwindet. So, so, so, so that's why the search result doesn't disappear just if you exactly search for a specific name. And the original article of course stays there because, and it's not deleted, because it's protected by freedom of press, what the search engine results or the searching for results is not. In our Google has like this committee that they set up who should decide, what is that is deciding, which results get deleted and which don't. So it's like an extra judicial body that is set up by private entity. It's not really necessarily a positive development, but it's like really hard to say if that's really positive or negative development and hard to know what is the majority opinion of club members. And it's like a base conflict in the hacker ethics, like how open or free are data supposed to be and how does that interact with personal data integrity. And yeah, so we should have a look at how that gets developed in the next years, how people will use it and how many results will get deleted. But of course the judgement wouldn't have been possible if Google wouldn't be so dominant. And I think we should keep a look on that. Yeah, if it's going towards censorship or if we trying to like find a proper balance in der Menge der Anfragen, die Google behauptet, but because of the breadth of information that they get, it looks much more like censorship, I think. We have to hurry up, we don't have that much time, or we could talk for it about ages. What about ages? It's a nice picture now. I had a pleasure to do something constructive in the commission of the German parliament. I had a great experience. I was in the commission for digital agenda and I was supposed to present about IT security in the era post Snowden. What can politics do to increase IT security? So that's a nice topic or a nice question. Because the insecurities are at a different layer than politics are then at the layer, in welcher Podleptik es passiert. So, du musst wirklich denken, was die Politiker sagen oder was die Politiker tun. In den Diskussionen. Wir haben uns vorhin proposed, dass man automatisch für jeden Wachkuchen die Software haften kann. Aber natürlich kann kein Software-Developer automatisch für jeden Wachkuchen leidbar sein. Aber es ist noch in sehr... Wenn man häufig zu einer Auto-Mainfecture spricht, die Auto mit dem Computer ist, sehen man die Unterschiede, weil es eine große Wachkuchen gibt. Es gibt auch Callback-Aktionen, für die Autos, wenn es ein Problem ist. Was noch so interessant? Du versuchst, etwas zu verleisten und zu minimisieren. Das ist eine Decentralisation, aber es ist nicht wirklich neu. Es ist noch etwas neu, aber es ist noch wichtig. Frank hat das Wort von evidenzbasierenden Sicherheitslösen ausgeführt. Also, wenn du etwas, wenn du etwas, was für eine Surveillance ist, oder eine Sicherung, dann willst du, dass du das auf die Evidence basierst und nicht nur... Das ist nicht wirklich möglich, dass es wirklich funktioniert oder dass es nützlich ist. Dann solltest du das Recht auf die Wachkuchen wiederholen. Eine andere wichtige Reaktion ist, dass, weil jemand von BSI eine Federal-Office für die Ministerpräsidenten von Informationen hat, und jemand war da. Das Innenministerium hat ja als Ministerium für die Interior so ein Interesse daran, das man anregen könnte, die Polizei, die Intelligenz, und so. Und sie sind für... die Frage ist so, ob sie hierher kommen. Es ist eine gute Information. Die Frage ist, ob du die Datenprotektion-Agenz oder in Bezug auf die Office der Ministerpräsidenten, ob es in Bezug auf die Details ist, wenn du eine solche Lösung findest, aber wir werden nicht zufrieden, das finde ich wirklich interessant. Das ist eine sehr konstruktive Kontribution. Mein größter Fan in dieser Gruppe, der mich nicht eingeladen hat, war nicht der Green Party, aber ich zeige dir jetzt eine Bildung, eine Repräsentation der Christian-Demokratik-Party, Christian Tom Somback. Er hat ein sehr großes Ohr gehabt. Und er hat meine Anzüge verabschiedet und er hat mich im Ausschuss und vorgefahren. Er hat meine Souten verabschiedet. Er hat ihn als Vertreter geladen. Er ist auch im Ausschuss der CCC. Aber er war nicht auf unserer Seite. Er hat gesagt, man muss etwas sagen. Das ist eine Assembly. Ich weiß nicht, es ist ein Assembly für eine Digitale Agenda. Es enthielt nach der Enkat-Kommission nach der letzten Session. Wir haben ein Assembly für Internettopik gebraucht. Aber es hat keine Legislaturperiode, also kann man diskutieren und diskutieren sehr öfter, aber die Läufe sind anderswo gemacht. Also ist das der Digital Agenda. Und es ist nicht nahezu zu den Digital Agenda direkt. Oh, also du meinst, das ist nicht der Digital Agenda? Ja, genau. Aber du kennst Fragments. Ja, von dem Paper Digital Agenda, in dem Assembly Digital Agenda. Excuse me. So, ich würde sagen, ein paar Szenen zu den CSC Switzerland. Also ein paar Tage ago, sie kamen zu Jahre alt, wo die Menschen in Switzerland zusammenfand, CSC Switzerland, das ist Zürich, Basel, Bern, St. Gallen, so, so, so, so, so, there were, there are small chaos, Meetups, and especially the, the Club in Zürich was very active, there's also probably in Switzerland with, with the question of the surveillance of, I think it's called postal transportation, but also Sie organisieren etwas, das heißt Million-March, das war ein sehr tolles Niveau. Sie haben regularen Meetings, sie haben einen Chaos-Mieter mit der Universität Zürich, also haben sie ihre eigene Aktivität in Switzerland entwickelt. Das ist eine gute Sache. 2015, und die CSC-Switzerland hat das kontributed. Es gibt auch die Digital-Society-Association in Switzerland. In 2015, da wird eine Rulung auf die preemptive Zahl der Daten sein, und wir sollten das wirklich in den Mund halten. Wir haben jetzt die Schweiz gelobt, das ist der richtige Name. Es folgte der Monat Juni. So, der nächste Monat ist Juni. In diesem Jahr haben wir ein Jahr von Snowden geblieben. Wir haben es nicht wirklich geblieben, aber der prinzipielle Städte-Läuer hat gesagt, er möchte die Surveillance der Angela Merkels Phone investigieren. Incidentally, nicht die Surveillance der Menschen, aber die Merkels Phone. Die Union deklariert, dass sie nicht noch eine andere Initiative haben für die Datenentwicklung. Aber wir sollten nicht zufrieden sein. Das ist noch nicht fertig. BitLocker hat Google auf Leistungsschutzgeld gebeten. Sie hat Google für Leistungsschutzgeld gebeten. Sie hat Geld für ihre Services gebeten. Snowden hat in der Investigation des NSA-Files der EU-Kommissioner Cecilia Mildström gebeten. Sie hat gebeten, dass sie über die Datenentwicklung eine andere Proposal für die Datenentwicklung zu machen. Die Wahl nach Europa war zu Ende. Nach der Wahl nach Europa war zu Ende. Nach der Wahl nach Europa war zu Ende. Nach der Wahl nach Europa war zu Ende. Nach der Wahl nach Europa war zu Ende. Nach der Wahl nach Berlin war zu Ende. Es ist eine Danachziege. Es ist eine Danachziege. Es ist eine Danachziege. Sie liegt bei derymphologischen St darling, zebrautestes Menschen in den Second wir Micro Lat往 raus. Yami Durst. Club, so do really cool work on the ground and we hope that they feel represented in that what we are doing here and what we are talking about here, but they do need tools to do cool things. Und since we have decentralization here at the club, our members are very critical of what happens to the money, so in our members assembly at the beginning of the year, everybody who has ideas for cool projects should face the last bureaucracy and we are going to give a basic equipment for tools in the local clubs to hack. A lot of local clubs have done this, they wrote a wish list and in this context we had amazing things happened like this electronic macroscope in Berlin, that's not really a basic equipment. Can I also use it? Yes you may. Starbucks took this picture and he will be very pleased to give you an introduction, but I think this is a great development and that's another reason to go to your local club and just ask what kind of tools you want, because we think membership fees are, that's exactly what membership fees are for, they enable work in your club to buy tools, to buy educational tools and to create them. Also in the context of our future days and internal discussions, we built a Consens, a Majority Opinion on the fact that we need a tool to show majority opinions in our clubs, so one member of the club, Marcel, he started the initiative and started liquid Feedback, it's called Cod, as you can see in the URL, HTTPS, an Onion Address, Client Serfs, so that's a good example of how to do this as a nerd, as a good nerd and cool hacker. So in this liquid we discussed a lot of initiatives, all those we agreed on have been implemented, sadly activity decreased a little bit in June, but I think it's pretty cool that somebody did such a thing and it has been used. So thank you to Marcel for starting this project. Der Chaospot in Essen, hat extertet its Club-Space of another 100 square meters und every week they do a Crypto-Party, so they have a very active Club-Life and they have really pretty websites, which they take care of and maintain. Bundes-CCC, dass da so rege Aktivität stattfindet. So that would be a project for 2015, I'm gonna leak this. We are building our website and we already have volunteers, so I don't know. I don't know if it will be as lovely as last time, but it's going to happen. So, not only nice rooms we have, but also many nice small things. This is a simple image from the Gulasch Programming Night, from the Afrakatsruhe. The name is Gulasch Programming Night, there is a lot of Gulasch, which was sold out relatively early, both the meat variant and the non-meat variant, which was cooked by its own helpers and members in fact, so it happens. There was an Ice Machine, because there was nice weather and after 18 liters of production the Ice Machine overheated, so I have no idea why it's an Ice Machine when it overheats. Apparently it's an undocumented feature, which appears not to do in long term. I don't know whether there was Gulasch Ice, next year there's supposed to be Gulasch Ice Cream. Yeah, there are photos from Gulasch Ice Cream. So, it's interesting that the Ice Machine overheated when we do Gulasch Ice. So, next year it's again this thing in Karlsruhe, so please come everybody. So, we did not forget that this year. In July Facebook started its experiment. So, Facebook did not really show everything as we expected it. Und, there was a fair use-Drosel for too much nitrate. There was an NSA in the BND, which was found, and there was a Great Britain surveillance over emergency act was got back for emergency act. And Plagiator used the copyright to protect against somebody looking about his, whether he may have copied something. Urheberrechtsgesetz eine Veröffentlichung zu verhindern. Es ist ein Flur gegen die Regierung, die eine negative Feststellung hat, die sich anstrengt, um sich gegen die Stürmer zu setzen. Freifunk wants to work against the Stürmerhaftung, so that if you provide a wireless network, you're liable for what is done over there. Our someone from Germany recommended to Edward Snowden to go back into the USA, and Frank was sued. So, if Frank wears a suit, he always explains something in the secret service und die Suchungsausschuss. So, back then it was the NSA und suchungsausschuss, not the secret service. So, it was, I was invited relatively spontaneously. So, with two days head up, because another from Canada decided not to come. And it was quite strange, because the MPs were quite happy to have people who could reasonably well explain them what that all was about. So, it was still the face where... So, maybe you have to add, it's a second question. The one before was only from lawyers, and that was the first time they actually talked about technology. And interesting about it was for me, especially about the usual procedure, how much it was used to try to figure out as little as possible. So, Fragen halt immer mögsten decken von Themen, die halt irgendwie problematisch sein können. To go away from questions, which are problematic. And if you look at the second, the vice president, he was supposed to go early to be the one after Binninger. So, whenever something was critical, became critical, his face changed. The questions which were asked were usually just about how does it work, which technological requirements are there. What is in the documents that were known to that day? There was a lot of press about that. Also, afterwards the press asked many questions, sometimes from our MPs who just wanted to understand. Problematisch, there's a question about what they ask for. It's a general problem. Wissen, dass sie halt dann durch diese parlamentarische Maschine mutiert werden, und man sieht ja möglicherweise nicht wieder. So, which questions do you propose that they work through this, but they are mutilated, and in the end you can't understand them, they are a completely different question. You have to be make sure that you ask questions or request information that is clear. So, we have to care for two things. We have to first of all put the public in that, and Netspolitik does a great job because they live block, so they block these events. On the other hand, it's also our job to bring the public to pay attention to that. And once the end, it changed a bit. The person from the city who already sees the solution for this process. So, he went into the NSA problem, moved, went to the doctor, and he asked someone who he invited over Twitter, and he said he was just having strange ideas, and when they talked about how wrong the BND worked he said he didn't know what to do. So, when he goes there and says, hey, that's for the conspiracy theorists. And interestingly, in the beginning everybody wanted to know what really happened. So, we have to keep up with that. So, I want to say something else. We do have to hurry up a little bit, but two of the court cases that CCC was involved in, I'd like to mention. So, we were working with quite a number of ISPs and organisations. So, we had the situation, this British court, so initiiert wurde, wo so klappen wird, dass wir als eine deutsche Organisation. Well, if we as a German organisation can provide the infrastructure, we didn't know yet, but the specific point that was highlighted here didn't relate to surveillance, but to the interception tools themselves. So, we just tried to highlight the fact that critical infrastructure damage is just the side effect basically of this. So, and only a couple of days later, we extended the court case that we'd already submitted early in the year regarding so-called filtering lists oder die Tourserver. So, now, as soon as we found out, we had a concrete case, we had a concrete case that a Tourserver ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... Der Tour incident gave us another opportunity to extend or explain that a bit further. But these are still running procedures. So yeah, we have a lot more activity like on a legal level that we're used to, or that we're accustomed to, or at least this year it was particularly, so we do have more than two lawyers or jurists with specialties. And some of them are even programmers as well. But this is an area, it's getting more important, but still we have to see how much does that really help. So how much do we want to really get involved in this sort of legal and jurisdiction procedures? Is it worthwhile? And I think our attitude there is to do as much as necessary, but not to put too much work into that, because of the interaction on this legal level. Also, this is quite difficult, especially seeing that the legal system isn't exactly encouraging and there's no collaboration, but rather a different kind of setup. So, but you do have to see that dependent on the case, the whole process may be entirely different. We had human rights organisations, for instance in this one case, formulating documents for us, or just supporting us, regarding these search lists with the tour server operators. And so you can find different forms of support, but so we are obviously doing the technical analysis. The legal work was then taken over by human rights lawyers from International Human Rights Watch. But I mean, that's the benefit, but also it's more interaction and communication overhead. So we do have an ongoing debate about how heavily do we want to get into this, and clearly Snowden was a singularity in this sense, but also good opportunities, find maybe generic positions, or make some quite clear technological social statements, but this is still a running thing. So don't sue, but fight maybe. And we have this CCC, an active Alpha-Circle, an Alpha-Circle in Freiburg, in the south of Germany. So they do a talk format, and additional crypto parties, and cooking events or something. And so this is just an example for a project, but now cast off, they're in Düsseldorf. This is a real sweet hack. What they did is they became a little ISP in their own right. Let's give them a hand. So don't underestimate, but to have a little Düsseldorf ISP might become useful. Also Freifunk, developed from an Alpha-Circle, has become a little ISP of its own. So, August, it remains cold. So, they admitted to surveilling one of the control commissions. And yeah, apparently that's some free time or free resources. Glenn Greenwald declined to go there, and by saying that the crown witness, like Snowden, wasn't gonna be there anyway, or wouldn't be hurt. Gamma was hacked, so the support forum by Fin Fisher was available on the Internet. BND, the German Intelligence Agency, apparently messed up to this close, that they by accident listened to a telephone call by Hillary Clinton. And then the digital agenda was published in the new German government. We didn't really say anything to that at first, because there was actually not much to say. Yeah, then we couldn't really stop ourselves to comment. But I'm also kind of annoyed by the fact that we see three guys. Yeah, they always saying such a great digital agenda. Also, wieso haben die Bildungsministerinnen nicht dazu genommen, wenn sie schon den großen visionären Entwurf machen wollen? But apparently the Ministry of Education, that is kind of lacking, if they want to be that great, and the Ministry of Justice is not there. So, maybe I just guessed that they knew best about the Internet, also, all Ministers be Internetminister as well. Yeah, it's guys 2014. Don't give them ideas, they're listening. Maha said it in his talk on the first day with his Twitter account. We kind of recreated the cyber soul of the speaker of the ministry. We hit the Stefan cybert. And so we made him say some nice statements like, let's use chances of the digitalization. Everything cyber and cybercrime and competences has to be extended. Zum Teil, wie wir sehen, an den Riedfieds sehr populär sind. Wir prüfen und fördern gezielt, we check and support the potentials of digital Africa. Ja, in a specific manner. Das bürgerschaftliche Engagement verlagert sich nun hier ins Netz mit der wachsenden Bedeutung des Internets. Wer konnte damit rechnen? Ja. Und für die Digitalisierung des Energiebetrags... ...for the digitalization of the energy sector, ...the energy... ...switching to alternative fuels... ...is very important. Und dann war es das Freiheitsstaat Angst. Freedom, instead of fear, demo. The organizers said 6.000 demonstratives were there, activists. At a meeting after the demonstration... ...there was debate about why such a broad breadth of organizations did not manage to get more people. So the consensus is probably that in the next years they will focus on different kinds of activities and protests. So maybe it's just going out and walking is not really appropriate more for the importance and danger of the topic. So we are excited to know what we will come up with next year. And this is also a call to everybody to use technology in a different way. And if you saw the talk by Centrum for digital beauty, ...and we need new creative forms of protests, ...new friends that help us. And with all forms of protest it's important that it has to be fun. If it's not fun, then, you know, if you can't see it from a humorous side, ...then maybe you should just move abroad or I don't know. Wir müssen uns ja auch eigentlich unseren Journalismus quer subventionieren. Ja, so wir... ...we have to finance our own journalism with subsidies. Als Anbieter von Infrastruktur, aber auch Netzpolitikorg, ...die ja diese Form von Aktivismus-Journalismus betreiben, ...so we helped our Netzpolitikorg, ...as well as they are like very close to us. I think this year CCC did a lot of support for fellow activists ...and maybe that's also because we just had more money to help others. ...so we helped Netzpolitikorg ...and also helped out Chelsea Manning ...and Edward Snowden, ...not only with non-remembership, ...but also with 36.000 years ...to the European team of the legal defense of Edward Snowden. ...und was a decision by the members of the CCC. So we tried to support the legal side of things ...that helped him with his various needs. Leih noch ein Link, am letzten Tag, wer sich da interessiert, ...wird's ja ein Update geben für den Fall von Chelsea Manning, wo der... ...update on the case of Chelsea Manning ...and there is a light at the end of the tunnel. So if you're interested in that, you can watch this on day four. Weiter geht's mit schönen Veranstaltungen aus dem Chaosumfeld. So we'll continue with beautiful events at the Kays Computer Club. The ICMP Intergalactic Marta Party. You can also do a pilgrimage there. It's the Golden Source, that's how it's called. This event takes place every two years. So it's a very comfortable, beautiful and fun event. Outside, outdoor. So fresh air, a lot of mosquitoes, all the environment. A lot of colorful, a lot of interesting activities. You can do that. Wo? In Münsteinach. In Münsteinach. You don't know that, excuse me. So, yeah, it's written on the Club Marta bottles. So I know, more or less what it is, where exactly is it. So yeah, you can read this on every Club Marta bottle. Yeah, Club Marta, the famous drink is produced. So we continue with the project Full Circle. This has been realized with the CCC Mannheim in Kausatlautern at the world-famous ITWM in Kaiserslautern. We did blinking lights there. This is an open-source project, so I can invite everyone to contribute and do more. Dann hatten wir dieses Jahr so ein... Also, da war es ein Event, der Club sich echt erstaunliche, zurückgehalten hatte, irgendwie zu kommentieren, was ich sehr schade war. Das ist sehr unmodest in die Kommentare, was ich begrenze. Mein Perso-Opinion, und ich denke, dass viele Leute in diesem Panel das auf der Internet haben, hat Literaturbilder, Videos von Literature, Bilder von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature von Literature aber dann bist du ein Asshole, basically. Ich denke, man muss sagen, dass man das sofort vorhanden ist, weil das Teil der Heckerethik ist. Das ist die Definition des privaten Datenes, das muss protectiert werden. Wenn du lachst, wenn du ein Horner nimmst und dann siehst du Bilder. Und dann, weil du nicht ein Operating-System hast, dann sind sie automatisch verabschiedet. Dann ist niemand, der sich selbst präzise, dass ein Hecker das Recht hat, um mit ihnen zu spielen. Also, ich denke, es ist in der Heckerfamilie, in dem Juvenel, mit diesem Fall, und ich denke, das kann in anderen Entwicklungen gesehen sein, wie Gamergate. Es ist ein Trend, gegen die Dehumanisation von Menschen, die nur online sind. Es sind keine Menschen mehr. Es sind keine Frauen, die Gamerkulturen kritisieren. Aber sie sind Subjekte, die du konfrontierst und verabschiedet sind. Auf der anderen Seite sind viele Gamer in einer sehr homogenous Weise verabschiedet. Sie sind Menschen, und nicht Individuen. Wir müssen etwas zurücknehmen, empfangen und sehen Menschen auf der anderen Seite, wie Menschen mit Sensibilität, Perspektiven, in alle Richtungen dort sich Entgleisungen leistet. Es gibt viele Wäste, die nicht zurückkommen können. Wer ein Erfah kennt, wer einen lokalen Klub erfah, wer einen weiß, wer einen aktiv ist, wer einen Computer-Klub weiß, wer in diesen lokalen Klubs nicht angenommen wird, wer in den Zufluchtsorten bietet, wer in anderen Kommunen nicht angenommen wird, um mit ihrer nahen Umgebung ins Reine zu kommen, um mit ihrer individuellen Umgebung zu kommen, um das Potential zu realisieren. Ich bin extrem schmutzig mit der Umgebung, wenn ich sehe, wie die Partei sich mit einem anderen verabschiedet ist. Gerade in unserer Community, ich denke, wir sind sensibilisiert, um so umzugehen und andere Menschen anzugreifen. Da sind wir uns eigentlich, dass das hier nichts verbringt. Wir sind die Menschen mit unseren Real- oder Imagins-Skills. Ich denke, das gute Message ist, das gute Message ist, dass die Debatte in der Englisch-Language-Speaking steigt. Die Menschen sprechen, warum sich Dinge verändert haben, warum sie so violent geworden sind, warum die Tone so violent geworden ist. Ich denke, es ist ein sehr gutes Signal, dass wir das bemerken und darüber reden, dass es nicht ein normales Thema ist. Ich denke, die Diskussion-Kultur in unserem Klub und manchmal die externale Kommunikation ist manchmal etwas schwierig. Aber ich denke, dass wir aktiv beteiligen. Wenn wir das debattieren, sollten wir in diesem Debatt aktiv sein. Das sollte in einem guten Sprit stattfinden. Wir brauchen keine Division der Klub. Was meinst du? Okay. Wir gehen mal zum nächsten Thema über. Wir haben den September. September. Die VW-Media betrifft Google. Oh. German-Provider, die von der NSA auf die Kamera gehackt waren, und ihr soll wirklich das Video sehen. Die ersten Forschungs-Maschinen ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... Es ist ja vollkommen klar, er hat es ja auch selber... Es ist sehr klar, und er hat auch... ...summiert, dass er der schlechteste Kandidat der letzten... ...kompetenten Post war. Aber wir wissen schon, dass Kompetenz nicht mehr wichtig ist. Es gibt viele interessante Dinge, die so waren. Die Entscheidungen in Brüssel sind natürlich mehr wichtig. Nicht nur in der Datenprotektion, sondern auch in vielen anderen Departements. Auch über den Copyright. Er ist unser neuer Spezial-Experte in Brüssel. Er ist unser neuer Spezial-Experte in Brüssel. Auch wichtig zu sehen, sind die Daten-Spuren von ZZC at Dresden. Dort kann man freigeworfen, und man bekommt freie Hugs und freie Sticker. Also, wenn ihr da visitiert, wird es auch nächstes Jahr passieren. Der folgende Projekt wurde präsentiert. Einige Probleme haben die Hacker-Kommunität gesolft. Das Projekt PEP, das einfach alles die Kryptos machen will. Also, einige Leute von der Klampe haben es besagt. Und sie haben einfach ein Solskode geschrieben. Und sie haben einfach die Daten-Traces gesolft. Sie haben ein Crowdfunding-Projekt gemacht. Also, manchmal in den Klub-Gruppen-Formen. Und sie wollen ein richtig schönes Projekt machen. Sie wollen ein kommersales Projekt machen. Also, es war wirklich gut, wenn es auf die Daten-Traces präsentiert. Also, der nächste große Projekt von dem Motto war die MRMCD. Das war im September im Darmstadt. Dieses Jahr haben wir das Motto die große Job-IT-Sekurität. Also, wir hatten 300 Entrüns-Permitts. Also, die Sekurität ist erst. Wir hatten mit den großen Names, wie S21, eine große... Wir hatten ungefähr 450 angemeldete Geräte am Nock. Wir hatten 450 Devices an dem Nock. Und mehr Data war send, als sie erzielt. Was war das für ein Talk, den du da machtest? Wir haben uns über die wichtigsten Themen diskutiert. Also, oh Gott. James war erst am Sonntag. Also, was war in September? In September war es auch viel. In U23 in Cologne. Das junge Hacker, der da ist, macht Fun-Projekte. Dieses Jahr war es ein weiteres großes Projekt. Ein neuer Hacker in Cologne und im Rhein-Cologne. Er hat eine free-Wi-Fi-Netzwork. Und da... Also, ein Hacker muss in die Kirche gehen und auf die Rhein-Cologne klingeln. Er hat eine Netzwork für die Community. Das war eine tolle Aktion in Cologne. Dann kam es im Oktober. Und es ist ein Tag. Im Oktober wurde die Aktion Eikonal bekannt. Die Aktion Eikonal wurde so, dass die BND den CS6-Listung erlangen. Die FTDI-Listung erlangte die Verbrauchsschuldung durch Verbrauchschuldungen. Avramov... Avramov... ... however he is trans... ... trans... ... wants to return the pre-emptious saving of data. So, we assume that 2015, they will try again under a different name, but two people who out of themselves as wanting it. So, it will be called something different, like minimal saving requirements or so, but it will be the CCC. The CCC Aachen, it made a quite interesting project. There is sensors, which are mentoring every new project, which don't only measure the pressure of the tire, but also send it further on. And the CCC Aachen looked at the technology critically and found several issues in the implementation. They, which were with self-built hardware, could functionally be used differently and you could, from a safe distance in an environment, could show them that the tire pressure was reduced. So, we don't want to know what really happened. It's really well documented. In Karlsruhe, there was a theater play, which looked about the services and the effort. It was called Entropia and they created an 8 Timeline for many meters for the theater, which is also quite interesting. It has to be extended. The CCC, clearly hackers are also Artists. The C3 Pedaboren made an Action where we called the elderly use the network and it's for teaching the elder how to use the Internet. It was done with the der Schutz der Menschen von der Polizei. Also, wir kooperieren jetzt mit den Plätzen. Wir können das nicht mehr beschreiben. Das ist das gesunde Gegenstand. Das ist das healthy Opposite für den Chaos, das geht zur Schule. Ich habe auch gesagt, dass es die Eröffnung gibt. Wir müssen die Hände in die Netzwerke erreichen, weil wir uns helfen müssen, wenn wir die Computer nicht kontrollieren können. Also, ihr seht das von Hause, wahrscheinlich. Im Oktober hat die Heg-Over in Hannover passiert. Es ist ein Kongress in Small. Sie haben es sehr professionell gemacht. Die Videos sind auf media.ccde. Sie waren komplett ausverkauft. Sie waren komplett ausverkauft. Wie bei den letzten Kongressen. Sie waren Bädchen. Du konntest mit dir spielen, mit dem Firmware. Die Demo-Szene nahe den Projekt über. Sie haben über die Geschichte gesprochen. Sie haben mehrere Demo- und Analog-Demos gemacht. Das war ein wirklich tolles Tag. Das waren meine Noten für das. Dann bis November wird es kalt. Es war public, dass die BND die Exploits nutzen und sie gegen ihre Menschen nutzen. Sie wollen nicht, was die Backs klettern. Die Backs-Backs-Mout war supposed zu save movement profiles for 13 days. In den USA scheiterte im Senat daran, 60 Stimmen für die Fortführung der Diskussion zu bekommen. In den USA war das gar keine Secret Service Reform, um die Diskussion zu fortsetzen. Aber auf der anderen Seite, Obama möchte gegen die Nettneutralität arbeiten, aber er hat keine realen Power. Wasapp implementiert es end-to-end in Kryptografie. Und dabei ist es mehr sicher als D-Mail. Die Welt ist so bizarr. Die Welt ist so bizarr. Die BKA-Chef Zierke geht in die Vorratsdatenspeicherungsdebatte. Aber nicht ohne zu reden, um eine pre-emptue Erleichterung von Memorien. Jetzt ist das Holger Münch. Der britische Pornofilter wird auf Terrapropaganda extendert. Das wird interessant, aber nächstes Monat. Dann natürlich hier noch ein Bild. Of course Jungern wants to put a text on internet traffic, but they decided quickly to do it, not to do that. Internet text will be used by different people. These terror filters are a reason why the Chaos Computer Club completely in the presale phase of this conference. Oh. Das war nicht eingehalten. Did not keep with the order. Oh, there is a different. The BND suddenly had an issue. When we became public, what other secret services did, they were pretty sure that they said, hey, we want that too. And so they just went ahead and without thinking about whether they wanted to stop themselves and said, hey, we want more money. And after they noticed what the other secret services already do, because computer systems are insecure and they worked towards that, they said, we also want to join that and we want money to buy zero days. We want to have the opportunity to install software and computers of suspects, which is a clear case, which is illegal under the AT law. And so they wanted more money to buy zero days. So in the beginning, we had no words about that. In the end we commented about that, but it's a no-brainer. That's not a good idea. It should be the job to help people as fast as possible and not to just keep it. And it is unlikely that the BND from all other secret services would use it cleanly and that it doesn't just disappear as you spare this. So I have no words for that. 4,5 Millionen Euro sind dafür vorgesehen, in dem beantragten Budget. The real costs were significantly larger, because what we always have to say is that if you buy a zero-day and want to use it, you have ... ... die Sicherheitslücke von den Systemen verschwindet. It does not disappear, so the price we pay for that in the end is significantly larger, because the security issue is still there. So was became public, was that they wanted to become more technically available. So it's mostly, oh, we know now what the NSA has to play with and we want the same. How they want to their own biometric capabilities and they want to advance that and they want to make factory conditions more popular and they want to work around biometrical systems to get into the US. So the BND is in the Christmas mode at the moment. So, let's just carry on. As a well mean well quite old club, we obviously have to care about our own history a bit and evaluate that, so revisiting. In real historical terms we did have an action, this year an activity or event to remind of the old, the legendary BTX hack, which actually contributed to the name of the CCC and the development of the CCC. This was actually a bank in Hamburg. You must have heard about it. And then we had another nice event. I think this was the third time that this took place and we honor each other. We had an event, and we honor interesting methods or unconventional methods. I think it was the Troll of the Year. And so this year it was an anti-Nazi organization. This Troll event is taking place and it's a big fun thing. And for the fourth time you can check it out, it's highly ironic. So our Video Center may record another event. This was the FIFCON. FIFCON is a German organization for computer scientists for peace. Peace and Social Responsibility. So it's a club. And yes, I did practice that name. But I think the topic, they have a broad political and social interest, but I think the event this year, FIFCON, recently did have a very, very clear focus on the surveillance and interception track. So we do of course have all the recordings and there were legal experts commenting in particular on the Secret Service on the situations. And this is available and you can get all the videos and all the recordings. So it's worthwhile to check it out. Es versäumt den Mann des Monats November vorzustellen. I just neglected to honor the man of the month in November. This was Axel Springer, big German editing house. So Leistungsschutzrecht, ancillary copyright law, which is supposed to give publishers an extra benefit for being found in social engines. Well, and we congratulate, this has been like the most successful failure ever. And we're not sure what he means, but Mr. Daphna was very happy about the Leistungsschutzrecht. It was a big joke, but I'm sure you remember. Oh ja, December. Let's smash Google. We have a query. We had an inquiry within the NSA Commission, the Inquiry Commission. So one of the questions was like the factual questions. What is it that the U.S. are actually charging us known with and the response was well for the German Secret Service inquiry. Well, this isn't really a relevant question. So we're not actually answering the question. So this is the kind of policy or communication protocol, just as an example. So the Secret Services are evaluating. So we do to just keep the option open that we can still take that extra step to go to the not the human rights court. And the UK situation in particular. There are a few openings or just a few possibilities to grab them by the balls. I mean, obviously, to target them appropriately. Oh, another highlight. Angela Merkel, German Chancellor, says another ending for net neutrality, says it's over. And they're given to add guys. Okay. Right. Now it's me. People worried in the UK. They wanted to acquire tickets for the event. Also, Ich nehme diesen Plan vor, der Feldskomputer Club in UK für die Procedure. Blümchen pornographie Begrenzung, etablierte Filter, plötzlich auf der Liste gelandet. Porn, URL-Lists, et cetera. Ein weiterer Kontext war zu finden, und eigentlich war der Content censored in diesem Sinne. Aber zwei Wochen später, waren wir schon wieder von den Providern ausgelistet, aber ich denke, die Art und Weise, die überreaktiv sind, war nur eine Koincidence, die wir herausgefunden haben, die uns die Möglichkeit gegeben hat, das zu protester. Aber ich weiß nicht, was passiert. Ich meine, wenn du einfach auf dieser Liste steigest, kannst du automatische Verzweifungen machen, aber das ist nur ein Incident, wo du dir wirklich sagen kannst, was kind of weapons are, maybe for a very small procedure. Wir sind sicherlich nicht eine Terror- oder Porn-Organisation, aber es ist sehr visibel. Es ist interessant, zu sehen, welche Providers oder ISPs wir eigentlich in der UK blockieren. Es ist also eine wertvolle Analyse. In der Fotos hast du einfach ein Objekt gesehen. Ein Exhibition, Peace. Wenn du das Video sehst, wenn du die Dinge, die jedes Jahr herkommen, und was passiert, dann kann man es in der Kongress-Center hier in Hamburg und das ist wie die akcelerierte Aktivität, die du da siehst. Wir sind eigentlich nach Berlin transportiert. Es gibt viel Logistik und Effort, wie wir es sehen können, mit dieser Antike-Aktivität. Wir haben eine weitere Spass. Das ist das Chaos-Computer-Klub in Berlin, um die Local-Members zu packen, zu repacken, all das, was wir nicht throwen wollen, um es in Storage zu bringen. Es gibt neue Storage-Spaces in Berlin. Das ist etwas, das noch ständig ist. Es ist nicht hektisch, es ist nicht auf der Trucke, es ist nicht auf der Trucke, sondern es ist ein schönes Haus, ein trojaner Haus, mit dem deutschen Regierung, der Bundes-Troyane, sondern es ist noch so, wie es ständig ist. Macht, macht, macht! Aber wir müssen viel von Aktien machen und die Stoffe von ATV. Und... ...Hau Ruck. So ist das Ergebnis, wenn ich gerade... Das ist wie ein Result, wenn ich mit dem Datenschleuder mit der Sprache printe, unsere Members-Magazine. Große Euro-Paletten stehen von der Tür. Dann, ein paar Tage später, da werden zwei große Paletten von Zippern in front der Tür. Ich hatte ein Problem, das ich vorher hatte. Ich muss noch zu den Members bringen. Und bevor wir es um den Kooperation zur Schule kreisen, das hilft, mit den Analypen aufzutun und es mitgebracht. Und ich wollte Und gave it to the Feral Post and help me with it, but that didn't really work. They didn't find a way to bring a lorry by my place, so Zidaks actually rented the lorry and got all the stuff from my place. Das war ein schöner Überraschung, vor der Konkurrenz, für alle Leute. Natürlich kannst du es hier auch geben. In einigen Kletzten des Klubwerks wird es problematisch, Wenn die Mitglieder der BASE-Große mehr Dinge printen und so ein kleines Problem haben. So, eine Frage ist bitte, wenn du dein Adress nicht recht hast, dass es ein paar Menschen in Mannheim sitzen, Wenn es 400 Datenschleutern gibt, wo wir zurückgekommen sind, dann werden wir sie wieder erhöhen. Wir müssen unsere Postbox-Size erhöhen, weil uns die Datenschleutern wiederkommen sind. Also bitte, wenn du deinen Adress ändern kannst, das macht alles leichter für uns. Danke. Das ist endlich der Ende des Jahres. Ich glaube, es war ein erfolgreiches Jahr, aber natürlich gibt es immer Dinge, die du nicht möchtest. Aber du willst die gute Arbeit weitergehen? Natürlich motiviert mich das Kongress viel, um weiter zu gehen. Ich denke, wir werden unsere Arbeit weitergehen. Wir hoffen für deine Unterstützung und bis nächstes Jahr.