 what did you make a target you know look target in the end would be up probably two three if it weren't such a bad day i like the earnings i didn't like the traffic was down i like the fact that electronics was doing well it was doing poorly but that's the nintendo switch i like the fact that apparel is doing well most people did not have good apparel swims doing well that's victoria secret pulling out a swim but what ultimately i really do think is the determinant here is that they had guided down and they beat the guy down macy's a guy that down and they equaled the guy down so it is a better story than the broad deportant schools