 Welcome to Toffy TV, these are my player ratings for barely one Everton nil. Let's just get into it because it's just going to be really really harsh. Jordan Pickford, I mean, hasn't had much to do has he, rarely. I don't think he's really much that he could have done about the goal. Mead, most of the saves you have to come for catches that he got. So I'll give him a seven because he didn't do anything did he so. Sheamus Coleman obviously got sent off for two. I mean, it was like the first one was like a yellow card and a half. And the second one was like half a yellow card because I just thought the second one was dead soft. Like he literally did two files in the whole game and was sent off. But the first one looked really, really bad, although I know it wasn't intentional, but that doesn't always mean. So it's like the first one was like in the rest mind. And I didn't think he had a particularly good game other than that. I do think he's one of our big. I mean, it'd be silly to say one of our weak points. I mean, there's basically 11 of them on the pitch. But I just don't think he is starting position is high up as it should be for a modern fallback. I think that really stops us playing as one of the things that stops us playing. I mean, there are many things that stops us playing, but that's one of them. So, so he gets here to three. Lucadine on the other side got forward, but his deliveries were really, really poor. His deliveries haven't been good this season at all and offensively was OK. But again, just, just don't know if he's missing or haven't been hard on that side. I don't know. I give him a four. Yeah, he mean it. Thought he did OK today. I thought him and Keane both did well today, to be honest. You know what you're going to be facing against a team like Bailey. I thought he doubted it really, really comfortably. I thought he's good on the ball as well. So I give him a seven and I give Michael Keane a seven as well. I think I thought these are the games where both of them should be coping and he did, to be honest. So I'll give them both a seven into midfield. Snideland and pointless, pointless being him in these games. Ball was just over his head. You know, these are the games that you've got to go and try and win and we're playing Snidlin. Not his fault, of course, not his fault entirely on the manager. He picks the team. I loved his overhead kick attempt on the edge of our own area. I thought that was spectacularly brilliant. So we can have a four as well. Delph, a little bit better, a bit more proactive on the ball, trying to create things, trying to move the ball around, trying to be a little bit more dynamic, but I mean he must just be looking at himself thinking, why on earth have I come to this club? I've come from the best football team in the country, maybe even Europe, to this. He must just be sobbing inside, so we can get a six. Sigarton, done nothing again, done nothing, absolutely nothing. I read a really good article, actually Paddy Boyle, athletic, tweeted it last night, and this is not just me pushing the athletic, really good article. These are the articles I actually do like reading where he said, he went and spoke to an Icelandic journalist who said that for Iceland, he plays in a field in a two, and he's always on the ball, and he's always creating, whereas in the seventh team he's just lost, absolutely lost. He's just lost, at times it's like playing with ten men, because he just doesn't get on the ball enough, and I don't know whether that's his fault or the team's fault, but the manager should be doing something about it, doesn't get on the ball enough so he can't create, doesn't get the ball in the right areas, it's too high up the pitch, so it's pointing this moment at being in the side, so he gets two. Honestly, he didn't do anything today, didn't do anything. One free kick, I think, where he actually hit the target. He didn't do anything, a few dead ball situations, but apart from that he didn't do anything. So what can you give him if he doesn't do anything? He literally doesn't do anything, he's never on the ball. With Charleston, with Charleston was awful today, absolutely awful. Nothing he did was of any merit, it was absolutely shocking. I'm sure he is, stats will say he run round a lot, but creatively going forward, he didn't do anything, and you know what, you can throw as many, not having to go over a Charleston here, but you can throw as many stats as you want to, how many tackles he's made. He's not in the team to tackle, he's not in the team to tackle, he's in the team to score and create goals, he's not in the team to tackle. He was woeful today, absolutely woeful, so he can get a two as well, he was terrible, and he got on the ball, he was just terrible, absolutely terrible. And he's not scoring goals, and yet, because he plays in midfield, he's not playing up front, where he should be playing, and part of it is because Chamber's Coleman won't go forward. It's just baffling, and the manager keeps on putting out this every week, it's awful. A woe be on the other side, probably had everything's best chance, and fluffed it. He only had to do his turn and hit the ball straight, and he didn't try to turn and kick the ball to the other corner, and that's where the defender got across. If he did a straighter to goal, he's not a left midfielder, he just isn't a left midfielder the way we play, he's not a left midfielder. He wants to play gentle, he wants to play gentle, and he comes inside all the time, and there's no link up with him and Dean, none. So we've taken away our best creative outlet from last season, completely got rid of it. Why? Why we got rid of our best creative outlet? No wonder we're not scoring goals. The one thing that has helped us score goals, you've literally eliminated from the team, the manager again. Now I know Bernard has been sick last week, and I don't know if he was a hangover from this week, but that partnership is our most creative, and yet he's torn it up for what? For what reason? Just absolutely baffling. So I'll give Ooby a five. I thought he got on the ball a bit more, and he goes looking for the ball, but the way he's playing doesn't suit him, it's clear. And Dominic Harvert-Lewin, the player with literally the most pointless job in the world, being an evidence centre forward. What is the point? Being an evidence centre forward, away from home. What is the point? You stand 30 yards from everybody else in the team. What is the point? And you play in today against centre backs, who all they want to do is just head the ball. Even if Dominic would get to the ball, what's he supposed to do? If he flicks it on, who's he flicking on to? What's the point? Listen, you can... The plenty of people out there will be criticising Dominic. Put the best centre forward in the world in there, and ask him to do the same job, and what will he be able to do? I don't know. I really don't know. So, Dominic can have a three, because how are you supposed to... I don't know, he hasn't touched the ball enough to have anything higher? The tactics are just baffling me, just absolutely baffling me. We need to score more goals, yet we try and be more defensive. We go one behind and don't make any kind of change that's going to help the team. We just swap the striker for a striker. It's baffling, it absolutely baffles me. The manager baffles me. It's pick, it's one of the plays he picks, just absolutely baffling me, and the way he play baffles me. And I can't defend them, because there's nothing to defend. What is this? We can't defend them. And we've lost again from a set piece, most basic thing in football. They've had our two corners all game, we had about 12, but other teams seem to be organised. The subs, Sadibi didn't really do anything, snapped one of their players, never really got forward. Obviously we were down to 10 men, which didn't help. So five, Moish Keane didn't hardly touch the ball again, because he's just an isolated centre forward. What's the point? Might as well just make Sigarton the centre forward. And that's it. Might as well just say to Sigarton, you play up front, and have an extra creative man in the field. You might as well, honestly. It'd be easier than what we're watching at the moment. So what if I just give Moish Keane a four again? I'll have to give them three, because again, when I put it down to the player, I put it down to the rest of the team and the way it was set up. And Andre Gomes, yeah, I mean amazing. Make us up. You've been 1-0 bound for 15 minutes, and now you're going to take off your most negative defensive midfielder and bring on another centre midfielder, who essentially you just thrown them on, because you want them to be fifth for the next game. Because I can't, honestly. Well, yeah, to get on the ball and move it round, but he didn't, so I'll have to give him a four. And about three are then points of, just because he's a good-looking man. I'm baffled, I'm baffled by the team, I'm baffled by the selections, I'm baffled by the way we play, and I'm baffled wherever the football club are going again. And we're here again. It's like Groundhog Day. It is like Groundhog Day. And I appreciate people will say, give them time. And I've heard all that Howard Kendall shout this week. If you'd twittered at being man, and Phillip Carter had been the manager, Kendall would have been out. I don't see it again. I don't see it. I just don't see it. I don't see how it's going to change. Unless the manager starts making changes and he had a great chance today and he didn't do it. So he wheels out the same players every week to play the same way and you're going to get the same performances. So I don't know. I don't know. You be the judge. You make up your mind. Go and watch my instant match reaction as well. Go and watch Baz's three things from today. Go and watch his instant match reaction. You know, you've all got a mind. You've all got opinions. It's up to yourselves to make them up. And it's up to everything football club to determine what day you want. It's been five years since, I think, since we lost four in a row. Five years. So for all the crap that we've endured over the last five years or whatever, that's the first time we've lost four in a row. So a bit of food to the thought there. Anyway, thank you for watching. Give this video a like if you've liked it. Probably not. Make sure you subscribe to the channel. And if you want more great videos, join us on Patreon where on Monday we'll be live from five o'clock on Patreon going over this game and live with the viewers. So if you want to be part of that, join up, and you can. Thanks for watching. See you later.