 The Closed Cabinet, Part 2, in the Locke & Key Library. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. Recording by Mary Schneider. The Locke & Key Library, edited by Julian Hawthorne. The Closed Cabinet by Anonymous, Part 2. With men went out shooting directly after breakfast, and we women passed the day in Orthodox country house fashion, working and eating, walking and riding, driving and playing croquet, and above, beyond and through all things, chattering. Beyond a passing sigh while I was washing my hands or a moment of mournful remembrance while I changed my dress, I had scarcely time even to regret the quiet happiness of the week that was past. In the evening we danced in the Great Hall. I had two vultures with Alan. During a pause for breath I found that we were standing near the fireplace, on the very spot where he and George had stood on the previous afternoon. The recollection made me involuntarily glance up at his face. It looked sad and worried, and the thought suddenly struck me that his extravagant spirits of the night before, and even his quieter, careful cheerfulness of tonight, had been but artificial moods at best. He turned and finding my eyes fixed on him at once plunged into conversation, discussed the peculiarities of one of the guests, good-humoredly enough, but with so much fun as to make me laugh in spite of myself. Then we danced again. The plaintive music, the smooth floor, and the partner were all alike perfect, and I experienced that entire delight of physical enjoyment, which I believe nothing but a waltz under such circumstances can give. When it was over I turned to Alan and exclaimed with impulsive appeal, Oh, I am so happy, you must be happy, too. He smiled rather uncertainly and answered, Don't bother yourself about me, Evie. I am all right. I told you that we Mervins had bad nerves, and I'm rather tired, that's all. I was too passionately determined just then upon happiness, and his was too necessary to mine for me not to believe that he was speaking the truth. We kept up the dancing till Lucy discovered with a shock that midnight had struck and that Sunday had begun, and we were all sent off to bed. I was not longing making my nightly preparations, and it scarcely inserted myself between the sheets, when with a few long moans the wind began again, more violently even than the night before. It had been a calm, fine day, and I made wise reflections as I listened upon the uncertainty of the North Country climate. What a tempest it was, how it moaned and howled and shrieked. Where had I heard the superstition which now came to my mind, that born upon the wind, come the spirits of the drowned, wailing and crying for the sepulcher which had been denied them? But there were other sounds in that wind too, evil, murderous thoughts perhaps, which had never taken body in deeds, but which caught up in the air and now hurled themselves in impotent fury through the world. How I wished the wind would stop. It seemed full of horrible fancies, and it kept knocking them into my head, and it wouldn't leave off. Fancies or memories which, and my mind reverted with a flash to the fearful thoughts which had haunted it the day before, in Day Malice's tower. It was dark now, those ghastly and tangible shapes must have taken full form and color, peopling the old ruin with their ageless hideousness, and the storm had found them there and borne them along with it as it blew through the creviced walls. That was why the wind's sound struck so strangely on my brain. I could hear them now, those still living memories of dead horror. Through the window-cranies they came shrieking and wailing. They filled the chimney with spirit sobs, and now they were pressing on, crowding through the room, eager, eager to reach their prey. Nearer they came, nearer still. They were round my bed now. Through my closed eyelids I could almost see their dreadful shapes, in all my quivering flesh I felt their terrors as they bent over me lower, lower. With a start I roused myself and sat up. Was I asleep or awake? I was trembling all over still, and it required the greatest effort of courage I had ever made to enable me to spring from my bed and strike a light. What a state my nerves or my digestion must be in. Through my childhood the wind had always affected me strangely, and I blamed myself now for allowing my imagination to run away with me at first. I found a novel which I had brought up to my room with me, one of the modern Chinese-American school, where human nature is analyzed with the patient industrious indifference of the true celestial. I took the book to bed with me, and soon, under its soothing influences, fell asleep. I dreamt a good deal, nightmares, the definite recollection of which, as is so often the case, vanished from my mind as soon as I awoke, leaving only a vague impression of horror. They had been connected with the wind, of that alone I was conscious, and I went down to breakfast, maliciously hoping that others' rest had been as much disturbed as my own. To my surprise, however, I found that I had again been the only sufferer, indeed so impressed were most of the party with the quiet in which their night had passed that they boldly declared my storm to have been the creature of my dreams. There is nothing more annoying than when you feel yourself aggrieved by fate than to be told that your troubles have originated in your own fancy, so I dropped the subject. Though the discussion spread for a few minutes round the whole table, Alan took no part in it, neither did George, except for what I thought a rather unnecessarily rough expression of his disbelief in the cause of my night's disturbance. As we rose from breakfast I saw Alan glance towards his brother and make a movement evidently with the purpose of speaking to him. Whether or not George was aware of the look or action I cannot say, but at the same moment he made rapidly across the room to where one of his principal guests was standing, and at once engaged him in conversation. So earnestly and so volubly was he borne on that they were still talking together when we ladies appeared again some minutes later, prepared for our walk to church. That was not the only occasion during the day on which I witnessed, as I thought, the same bi-play going on. Again and again Alan appeared to be making efforts to engage George in private conversation, and again and again the ladders successfully eluded him. The church was about a mile away from the house, and as Lucy did not like having the carriages out on a Sunday, one service a week as a rule contented the household. In the afternoon we took the usual Sunday walk. On returning from it I had just taken off my outdoor things and was issuing from my bedroom, when I found myself face to face with Alan. He was coming out of George's study and had succeeded apparently in obtaining that interview for which he had been all day seeking. One glance at his face told me what its nature had been. We paused opposite each other for a moment and he looked at me earnestly. Are you going to church? He inquired at last, abruptly. No, I answered with some surprise. I did not know that anyone was going this evening. Will you come with me? Yes, certainly, if you don't mind waiting a moment for me to put my things on. There's plenty of time, he answered. Meet me in the hall. A few minutes later we started. It was a calm, cloudless night, and although the moon was not yet half-full and already past her meridian, she filled the clear air with gentle light. Not a word broke our silence. Alan walked hurriedly, looking straight before him, his head upright, his lips twitching nervously, while every now and then a half-hundred moan escaped unconsciously from between them. At last I could bear it no longer and burst forth with the first remark which occurred to me. We were passing a big, black, queer-shaped stone standing in rather a lonely, uncultivated spot at one end of the garden. It was an old acquaintance of my childhood, but my thoughts had been turned towards it now from the fact that I could see it from my bedroom window, and had been struck afresh by its uncouth incongruous appearance. Isn't there some story connected with that stone, I asked. I remember that we always called it the dead stone as children. Alan cast a quick, side-long glance in that direction, and his brows contracted in an irritable frown. I don't know, he said softly. They say there's a woman buried beneath it, I believe. A woman buried there? I exclaimed in surprise. But who? How should I know? They know nothing whatever about it. The place is full of stupid traditions of that kind. Then looking suspiciously round at me, why do you ask? I don't know. It was just something to say, I answered plaintively. His strange mood so worked upon my nerves that it was all that I could do to restrain my tears. I think that my tone struck his conscience, for he made a few feverish attempts at conversation after that. But they were so entirely abortive that he soon abandoned the effort, and we finished our walk to church as speechlessly as we had begun it. The service was bright, and the sermon perhaps a little commonplace, but sensible as it seemed to me in matter and adequate in style. The peaceful evening him which followed, the short solemn pause of silent prayer at the end, soothed and refreshed my spirit. A hasty glance at my companion's face as he stood waiting for me in the porch, with the full light from the church streaming round him, assured me that the same influence had touched him, too. Haggard and sad he still looked it is true, but his features were composed, and the expression of actual pain had left his eyes. Silent as we had come we started homeward through the waning moonlight, but this silence was of a very different nature to the other, and after a minute or two I did not hesitate to break it. It was a good sermon, I observed interrogatively. Yes, he assented, I suppose you would call it so, but I confess that I should have found the text more impressive without its exposition. Poor man! But don't you often find it so, he asked. Do you not often wish to take this evening's instance, the clergyman would infuse themselves with something of St. Paul's own spirit? Then perhaps they would not water all the strength out of his words in their efforts to explain them. That is rather a large demand to make upon them, is it not? Is it? He questioned. I don't ask them to be inspired saints, I don't expect St. Paul's breadth and depth of thought, but could they not have something of his vigorous completeness, something of the intensity of his feeling and belief? Look at the text of tonight. Did not the preacher's examples and applications take something from its awful, unqualified strength? Awful? I exclaimed in surprise. That is hardly the expression I should have used in connection with those words. Why not? Oh, I don't know. The text is very beautiful, of course, and at times when people are tiresome and want not to be nice to them, it is very difficult to act up to. But you think that awful is rather a big adjective to use for so small a duty, interposed Allen, and the moonlight showed the flicker of a smile upon his face. Then he continued gravely. I doubt whether you yourself realize the full import of the words. The precept of charity is not merely a code of rules by which to order our conduct to our neighbors. It is the picture of a spiritual condition, and such where it exists in us must by its very nature be roused into activity by anything that affects us. So with this particular injunction every circumstance in our lives is a challenge to it, and in presence of all alike it admits of one attitude only—beareth all things, endureth all things. I hope it will be long before that all sticks in your gizzard, Evie, before you come face to face with things which nature cannot bear, and yet which must be borne. He stopped, his voice quivering, and then after a pause went on again more calmly, and throughout it is the same. Moral precepts everywhere, which will admit no compromise, no limitation, and yet which are at war with our strongest passions. If one could only interpose some unless, some except, even and until, which should be short of the grave, but we cannot. The law is infinite, universal, eternal, there is no escape, no repose, resist, strive, endure. That is the recurring cry, that is existence. And peace, I exclaimed appealingly, where is there room for peace, if that be true? He sighed for answer, and then in a changed and lowered tone added, however thickly the clouds mass, however vainly we search for a coming glimmer in their midst. We never doubt that the sky is still beyond, beyond and around us, infinite and infinitely restful. He raised his eyes as he spoke, and mine followed his. He had entered the wooded glen. Through the scanty autumn foliage we could see the stars shining faintly in the dim moonlight, and beyond them the deep, illimitable blue. A dark world it looked, distant and mysterious, and my young spirit rebelled at the consolation offered me. Peace seems a long way off, I whispered. It is for me, he answered gently. Not necessarily for you. Oh, but I am worse and weaker than you are. If life is to be all warfare, I must be beaten. I cannot always be fighting. Cannot you, Evie? What I have been saying is true of every moral law worth having, of every ideal of life worth striving after, that men have yet conceived. But it is only half the truth of Christianity, you know that. We must strive for the promise is to him that overcomeeth. But though our aim be even higher than is that of others, we cannot in the end fail to reach it. The victory of the Cross is ours, you know that, you believe that? Yes, I answered softly, too surprised to say more. And speaking of religion, he as a rule showed to the full the reserve which is characteristic of his class and country, and this sudden outburst was in itself astonishing. But the eager anxiety with which he emphasized the last words of appeal impressed and bewildered me still further. We walked on for some minutes in silence, then suddenly Alan stopped and turning took my hand in his. In what direction his mind had been working in the interval I could not divine, but the moment he began to speak I felt that he was now for the first time giving utterance to what had been really at the bottom of his thoughts the whole evening. Even in that dim light I could see the anxious look upon his face and his voice shook with restrained emotion. Evie, he said, have you ever thought of the world in which our spirits dwell as our bodies do in this one of matter and sense, and of how it may be peopled? I know, he went on hurriedly, that it is the fashion nowadays to laugh at such ideas. I envy those who have never had cause to be convinced of their reality, and I hope that you may long remain among the number. But should that not be so, should those unseen influences ever touch your life, I want you to remember then that as one of the race for whom Christ died you have as high a citizenship in that spirit land as any creature there, that you are your own soul's warden, and that neither principalities nor powers can rob you of that birthright. I think my face must have shown my bewilderment, for he dropped my hand and walked on with an impatient sigh. You don't understand me, why should you? I dare say that I am talking nonsense, only his voice expressed such an agony of doubt and hesitation that I burst out. I think I do understand you a little, Alan. You mean that even from unearthly enemies there is nothing that we need really fear, at least that is I suppose nothing worse than death, but that is surely enough. Why should you fear death? He said abruptly, your soul will live. Yes, I know that, but still I stopped with a shutter. What is life after all but one long death who went on with sudden violence? Our pleasures, our hopes, our youth are all dying. Ambition dies and even desire at last. Our passions and tastes will die, or will live only to mourn their dead opportunity. The happiness of love dies with the loss of the loved, and worst of all, love itself grows old in our hearts and dies. Why should we shrink only from the one death which can free us from all the others? It is not true, Alan, I cried hotly. What you say is not true. There are many things, even here, which are living and shall live, and if it were otherwise in everything, life that ends in death is better than no life at all. You say that, he answered, because for you these things are yet living. To leave life now, therefore, while it is full and sweet, untainted by death, surely that is not a fate to fear. Better, a thousand times better, to see the cord cut with one blow while it is still whole and strong, and to launch out straight into the great ocean, than to sit watching through the slow years, while strand after strand, thread by thread, loosens and unwinds itself, each with its own separate pang, breaking, bringing the bitterness of death without its release. His manner, the despairing ring in his voice, alarmed me even more than his words, clinging to his arm with both hands while the tears sprang to my eyes. Alan, I cried, don't say such things, don't talk like that, you're making me miserable. He stopped short at my words with bent head, his features hidden in the shadow, thus cast upon them, nothing in his motionless form to show what was passing within him. Then he looked up and turned his face to the moonlight and to me, laying his hand on one of mine. Don't be afraid, he said. It is all right, my little David. You have driven the evil spirit away. And lifting my hand, he pressed it gently to his lips, then drawing it within his arm he went on as he walked forward. And even when it was on me at its worst, I was not meditating suicide, as I think you imagine. I'm a very average specimen of humanity, neither brave enough to defy the possibilities of eternity, nor cowardly enough to shirk those of time. No, I was only trying idiotically to persuade a girl of 18 that life was not worth living, and more futile still, myself, that I did not wish her to live. I'm afraid that in my mind, philosophy and fact have a small connection with each other. And though my theorizing for your welfare may be true enough, yet I cannot help it, Evie. It would be terribly hard with me if anything were to happen to you. His voice trembled as he finished. My fear had gone with his return to his natural manner, but my bewilderment remained. Why should there anything happen to me, I asked. That is just it, he answered, after a pause, looking straight in front of him and drawing his hand warily over his brow. I know of no reason why there should. Then giving a sigh, as if finally to dismiss from his mind a worrying subject, I have acted for the best, he said, and may God forgive me if I have done wrong. There was a little silence after that, and then he began to talk again, steadily and quietly. The subject was deep enough still, as deep as any that we had touched upon, but both voice and sentiment were calm, bringing peace to my spirit, and soon making me forget the wonder and fear of a few moments before. Very openly did he talk as we passed on across the long, trunk shadows and through the glades of silver light. And I saw farther then into the most sacred recesses of his soul than I had ever done before or since. When we reached home, the moon had already set, but some of her beams seemed to have been left behind within my heart. So pure and peaceful was the light which filled it. The same feeling continued with me all through that evening after dinner some of the party played and sang, as it was Sunday and Lucy was rigid in her views, the music was of a sacred character. I sat in a low arm chair in a dark corner of the room, my mind too dreamy to think and too passive to dream. I hardly interchanged three words with Alan, who remained in a still darker spot, invisible and silent the whole time. Only as we left the room to go to bed, I heard Lucy ask him if he had a headache. I did not hear his answer and before I could see his face, he had turned back again into the drawing room. It was early and when first I got to my room I felt little inclined for sleep. I wandered to the window and drawing aside the curtains looked out upon the still starlit night. At least I should rest quiet tonight. The air was very clear and the skies seemed full of stars. As I stood there, scraps of schoolroom learning came back to my mind that the stars were all sons surrounded perhaps in their turn by worlds as large or larger than our own. Worlds beyond worlds and others farther still which no man might number or even describe. And about the distance of those wonderful sons too, that one for instance at which I was looking, what was it that I had been told that our world was not yet peopled perhaps not yet formed when the actual spot of light which now struck my sight first started from the star's surface. While it flashed along itself the very symbol of speed the whole of mankind had had time to be born and live and die. My gaze dropped and fell upon the dim half-seen outline of the dead stone. That woman too, while that one gray speeded towards me, her life had been lived and ended and her body had rotted away into the ground. How close together we all were, her life in mine, our joys, sufferings, deaths, all crowded together into the space of one flash of light. And yet there was nothing there but a horrible skeleton of dead bones while I, I stopped with a shutter and turned back into the room. I wished that Alan had not told me what lay under the stone. I wished that I had never asked him. It was a ghastly thing to think about and spoiled all the beauty of the night to me. I got quickly into bed and soon dropped asleep. I do not know how long I slept, but when I woke it was with the consciousness again of that haunting wind. It was worse than ever. The world seemed filled with its din. Hurling itself passionately against the house, it gathered strength with every gust, till it seemed as if the old walls must soon crash and ruins around me. Gust upon gust, blow upon blow, swelling, lessening, never ceasing. The noise surrounded me. It penetrated my inmost being as all pervading as silence itself and wrapping me in a solitude even more complete. There was nothing left in the world but the wind and I. And then a weird and tangible doubt as to my own identity seized me. The wind was real, the wind with its echoes of passion and misery from the eternal abyss, but was there anything else? What was and what had been the world of sense and of knowledge, my own consciousness, my very self, all seemed gathered up and swept away in that one soul-existent fury of sound? I pulled myself together and getting out of bed groped my way to the table which stood between the bed and the fireplace. The matches were there and my half-burnt candle which I lit. The wind penetrating the rattling casement circled round the room and the flame of my candle bent and flared and shrank before it, throwing strange moving lights and shadows in every corner. I stood there shivering in my thin nightdress, half stunned by the cataract of noise beating on the walls outside and peered anxiously around me. The room was not the same. Something was changed. What was it? How the shadows leaped and fell, dancing in time to the wind's music. Everything seemed alive. I turned my head slowly to the left, then to the right, and then round and stopped with a sudden gasp of fear. The cabinet was open. I looked away and back and again. There was no room for doubt. The doors were thrown back and were waving gently in the draft. One of the lower drawers was pulled out and in a sudden flare of the candlelight I could see something glistening at its bottom. Then the light dwindled again and the candle was almost out and the cabinet showed a dim black mass in the darkness. Up and down went the flame and each returning brightness flashed back at me from the thing inside the drawer. I stood fascinated, my eyes fixed upon the spot, waiting for the fitful glitter as it came and went. What was there there? I knew that I must go and see but I did not want to. If only the cabinet would close again before I looked, before I knew what was inside it, but it stood open and the glittering thing lay there dragging me toward itself. Slowly at last and with infinite reluctance I went. The drawer was lined with soft white satin and upon the satin lay a long slender knife hilted and sheathed in antique silver, richly set with jewels. I took it up and turned back to the table to examine it. It was Italian in workmanship and I knew that the carving and chasing of the silver were more precious even than the jewels which studded it and whose rough setting gave so firm a grasp to my hand. Was the blade as fair as the covering, I wondered. A little resistance at first and then the long, thin steel slid easily out, sharp and bright and finally tempered it looked with its deadly tapering point. Stains dull and irregular crossed the fine engraving on its surface and dimmed its polish. I bent to examine them more closely and as I did so a sudden stronger gust of wind blew out the candle. I shuddered a little at the darkness and looked up but it did not matter. The curtain was still drawn away from the window opposing my bed and through it a flood of moonlight was pouring in upon floor and bed. Putting the sheath down upon the table I walked to the window to examine the knife more closely by that pale light. How gloriously brilliant it was. Darkened now and again by the quickly passing shadows of wind-driven clouds, at least so I thought, and I glanced up and out the window to see them. A black world met my gaze. Neither moon was there nor moonlight. The broad silver beam in which I stood stretched no farther than the window. I caught my breath and my limbs stiffened as I looked. No moon, no cloud, no movement in the clear, calm, starlit sky. While still the ghastly light stretched round me and the spectral shadows drifted across the room. But it was not all dark outside. One spot caught my eye, bright with a livid unearthly brightness. The dead stone shining out into the night like an ember from hell's furnace. There was a horrid semblance of life in the light, a palpitating, breathing glow, and my pulses beat in time to it till I seemed to be drawing it into my veins. It had no warmth, and as it entered my blood my heart grew colder and my muscles more rigid. My fingers clutched the dagger-hill till its jeweled roughness pressed painfully into my palm. All the strength of my strained powers seemed gathered in that grasp, and the more tightly I held, the more vividly did the rock gleam and quiver with infernal life. The dead woman, the dead woman, what did I to do with her? Let her bones rest in the filth of their own decay out there under the accursed stone. And now the noise of the wind lessens in my ears. Let it go on, yes, louder and wilder, drowning my senses in its tumult. What is there with me in the room, the great empty room behind me? Nothing, only the cabinets with its waving doors. They are waving to and fro, to and fro, I know it. But there is no other life in the room, but that, no, no, no. No other life in the room but that. Oh, but the wind stop. I can't hear anything while it goes on. But if it stops, all the guskrow-weaker struggling forced into rest. Now, now they have ceased. Silent, a fearful pause. What is it that I hear there behind me in the room? Do I hear it? Is there anything? The throbbing of my own blood in my ears. No, no, there is something as well, something outside myself. What is it? Low, heavy, God. It is, it is the breath of a living creature, a living creature here, close to me, alone with me. The numbness of terror conquers me. I can neither stir nor speak, only my whole soul strains at my ears to listen. Where does the sound come from? Close behind me, close. It is from there, from the bed where I was lying a moment ago. I try to shriek, but the sound gurls unuttered in my throat. I clutch the stone mullions of the window and press myself against the pains. If I could but throw myself out, anywhere, anywhere away from that dreadful sound, from that thing close behind me in the bed, but I can do nothing. The wind has broken forth again now. The storm chases around me and still through it all I hear the ghastly breathing, even low, scarcely audible, but I hear it and shall hear it as long as I live. Is the thing moving? Is it coming nearer? No, no, not that. That was but a fancy to freeze me dead. But to stand here with that creature behind me listening, waiting for the warm horror of its breath to touch my neck, I cannot. I will look. I will see it face to face, better any agony than this one. Slowly with held breath and eyes aching in their stretched fixity I turn. There it is. Clear in the moonlight I see the monstrous form within the bed. The dark coverlet rises and falls with its heavy breath. Ah, heaven, have mercy! Is there none to help, none to save me from this awful presence? And the knife-hilt draws my fingers round it. While my flesh quivers and my soul grows sick with loathing, the wind howls, the shadows chase through the room, hunting with fearful darkness, more fearful light, and I stand looking, listening. I must not stand here forever. I must be up and doing. What a noise the wind makes, and the rattling of the windows and the doors. If he sleeps through this he will sleep through all. Noiselessly my bare feet tread the carpet as I approach the bed. Noiselessly my left arm raises the heavy curtain. What does it hide? Do I not know? The bestial features half hidden in coarse black growth. The muddy blotch skin oozing foulness at every pore. Oh, I know them too well. What a monster it is! How their rank breath gurgles through his throat in his drunken sleep. The eyes are closed now, but I know them too. Their odious leer and the venomous hatred with which they can glare at me. From their bloodshot setting, but the time has come at last. Never again shall their passion insult me, or their fury degrade me in slavish terror. There he lies, there at my mercy. The man who for fifteen years has made God's light a shame to me, and his darkness a terror. The end has come at last. The only end possible, the only end left to me, and on his head be the blood and the crime. God Almighty, I am not guilty. The end has come. I can bear my burden no farther. Beareth all things, endureth all things. Where have I heard those words? They're in the Bible, the precept of charity. What has that to do with me? Nothing. I heard the words in my dreams somewhere. A white-faced man said them a white-faced man with pure eyes. To me? No, no, not to me, to a girl it was. An ignorant, innocent girl. And she accepted them as an eternal, unqualified law. Let her bear but half that I have borne. Let her endure but one-tenth of what I have endured. And then, if she dare, let her speak in judgment against me. Softly now I must draw the coverings away, and bear his breast to the stroke, the stroke that shall free me. I know well where to plant it. I have learned that from the old lady's Italian. Did he guess why I questioned him so closely of the surest, straightest road to a man's heart? No matter, he cannot hinder me now, gently. Ah, I have disturbed him. He moves, mutters in his sleep, throws out his arm. Down, down, crouching behind the curtain. Heavens if he wakes and sees me, he will kill me. No alas, if only he would. I would kiss the hand that he struck me with. But he is too cruel for that. He will imagine some new and more hellish torture to punish me with. But the knife I have got that. He shall never touch me living again. He is quieter now. I hear his breath, hoarse and heavy as a wild beast's panting. He draws it more evenly, more deeply. The danger is past, thank God. God, what am I to do with him? A God of judgment. Hell cannot frighten me. It will not be worse than earth. Only he will be there too. Not with him, not with him. Send me to the lowest circle of torment, but not with him. There, his breast is bare now. Is the knife sharp? Yes. And the blade is strong enough. Now let me strike. Myself afterwards, if need be, but him first. Is it the devil that prompts me, then the devil is my friend and the friend of the world? No, God is a God of love. He cannot wish such a man to live. He made him, but the devil spoiled him, and let the devil have his hand to work back again. It has served him long enough here, and its last service shall be to make me a murderous. How the moonlight gleams from the blade as my arm swings up and back. With how close a grasp the rough hilt draws my fingers rounded. Now, murderous, wait a moment. A moment may make me free. A moment may make me that. Hand and dagger droop again. His life has dragged its slime over my soul. Shall his death poison it with a fowler of corruption still? My own soul's warden. What was that? Dream memories again. Resist, strive and doer. Easy words. What do they mean for me? To creep back now to bed by his side, and to begin living again tomorrow, the life which I have lived today. No, I cannot do it. Heaven cannot ask it of me, and there is no other way. That or this, this or that. Which shall it be? Ah, I have striven, God knows. I have endured so long that I hoped even to do so to the end. But today. Oh, the torment and the outrage. Body and soul still bear the stain of it. I thought that my heart and my pride were dead together, but he has strung them again into aching, shameful life. Yesterday I might have spared him to save my own cold soul from sin, but now it is cold no longer. It burns, it burns, and the fire must be slaked. I will kill him, and have done with it. Why should I pause any longer? The knife drags my hand back for the stroke. Only the dream surrounds me, the pure man's face is there, white, beseeching, and God's voice rings in my heart, to him that overcoming. But I cannot overcome. Evil has governed my life, and evil is stronger than I am. What shall I do? What shall I do? God, if thou art stronger than evil, fight for me. The victory of the cross is ours. Yes, I know it. It is true, it is true, but the knife. I cannot loose the knife, if I would. How to wrench it from my own hold? Thou, God, of victory, be with me. Christ, help me. I seize the blade with my left hand. The two-edge steel slides through my grasp. A sharp pain in fingers and palm, and then nothing. That is the end of Part 2 of The Closed Cabinet. The Closed Cabinet, Part 3 in the Locke and Key Library. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. Recording by Mary Schneider. The Locke and Key Library, edited by Julian Hawthorne. The Closed Cabinet by Anonymous, Part 3. When I again regained consciousness, I found myself half kneeling, half lying across the bed. My arms stretched out in front of me. My face buried in the clothes. Body and mind were like numb. A smarting pain in my left hand. A dreadful terror in my heart. Where at first the only sensations of which I was aware. Slowly, very slowly, sense and memory returned to me. And with them a more vivid intensity of mental anguish. As detail by detail I recalled the weird horror of the night. Had it really happened, was the thing still there? Or was it all a ghostly nightmare? It was some minutes before I dared either to move or look up. And then fearfully I raised my head. Before me stretched the smooth white coverlet. Faintly bright with yellow sunshine. Weak and giddy I struggled to my feet. And steadying myself against the foot of the bed. With clenched teeth and bursting heart. Forced my gaze round to the other side. The pillow lay there bare and unmarked save for what might well have been the pressure of my own head. My breath came more freely and I turned to the window. The sun had just risen, the golden treetops were touched with light. Faint threads of mist hung here and there across the sky. And the twittering of birds sounded clearly through the crisp autumn air. It was nothing but a bad dream then, after all, this horror which still hung round me, leaving me incapable of effort, almost of thought. I remembered the cabinet and looked swiftly in that direction. There it stood, closed as usual. Closed as it had been the evening before, as it had been for the last 300 years, except in my dreams. Yes, that was it, nothing but a dream. A gruesome, haunting dream. With an instinct of wiping out the dreadful memory, I raised my hand warily to my forehead. As I did so, I became conscious again of how it hurt me. I looked at it. It was covered with half-dried blood and two straight clean cuts appeared, one across the palm and one across the inside of the fingers just below the knuckles. I looked again towards the bed and in the place where my hand had rested during my faint, a small patch of red blood was to be seen. Then it was true. Then it had all happened. The low, shuttering sob I threw myself down upon the couch, the foot of the bed, and lay there for some minutes my limbs trembling and my soul shrinking within me. A mist of evil, fearful and loathsome, had descended upon my girlhood's life, sullying its ignorant innocence, saddening its brightness, as I felt forever. I lay there till my teeth began to chatter, and I realized that I was bitterly cold. To return to that accursed bed was impossible, so I pulled a rug which hung at one end of the sofa over me, and utterly worn out in mind and body, felt uneasily asleep. I was roused by the entrance of my maid. I stopped her exclamations and questions by shortly stating that I had had a fever. I was stating that I had had a bad night, had been unable to rest in bed, and had had an accident with my hand, without further specifying of what description. I didn't know that you had been feeling unwell when you went to bed last night, Miss," she said. When I went to bed last night unwell, what do you mean? Only Mr. Allen has just asked me to let him know how you find yourself this morning," she answered. Then he expected something, dreaded something. Ah, why had he yielded and allowed me to sleep here, I asked myself bitterly, as the incidents of the day before flashed through my mind. Tell him, I said, what I have told you, and say that I wish to speak with him directly after breakfast. I could not confide my story to anyone else, but speak of it I must to someone or go mad. Every moment passed in that place was an added misery. Much to my maid's surprise I said that I would dress in her room the little one, which, as I have said, was close to my own. I felt better there, but my utter fatigue and my wounded hand combined to make my toilet slow, and I found that most of the party had finished breakfast when I reached the dining-room. I was glad of this, for even as it was I found it difficult enough to give coherent answers to the questions which my white face and bandaged hand called forth. Alan helped me by giving a resolute turn to the conversation. Once only our eyes met across the table. He looked as haggard and worn as I did. I learned afterwards that he had passed most of that fearful night pacing the passage outside my door, though he listened in vain for any indication of what was going on within the room. The moment I had finished breakfast he was by my side. You wish to speak to me now? he asked in a low tone. Yes, now I answered breathlessly, and without raising my eyes from the ground. Where shall we go outside? It is a bright day and we shall be free of therefrom interruption. I assented, and then looking up at him appealingly, will you fetch my things for me? I cannot go up to that room again. He seemed to understand me, nodded and was gone. A few minutes later we left the house and made our way in silence towards a grassy spot on the side of the ravine, where we had already indulged in more than one friendly talk. As we went the dead stone came for a moment into view. I seized Alan's arm at an almost convulsive grip. Tell me, I whispered. You refused to tell me yesterday, but you must now. Who is buried beneath that rock? There was now neither timidity nor embarrassment in my tone. The horrors of that house had become part of my life forever, and their secrets were mined by right. Alan, after a moment's pause, a questioning glance at my face, tacitly accepted the position. I told you the truth, he replied, when I said that I did not know, but I can tell you the popular tradition on the subject, if you like. They say that Margaret Mervin, the woman who murdered her husband, is buried there, and that Dame Alice had the rock placed over her grave, whether to save it from insult or to mark it out for a probrium, I never heard. The poor people about here do not care to go near the place after dark, and among the older ones there are still some, I believe, who spit at the suicide's grave as they pass. Poor woman, poor woman, I exclaimed in a burst of uncontrollable compassion. Why should you pity her? demanded he with sudden sternness. She was a suicide and a murderous too. It would be better for the public conscience, I believe, if such were still hung in chains or buried at the crossroads with a stake through their bodies. Hush, Allen, hush! I cried hysterically as I clung to him. Don't speak harshly of her. You do not know, you cannot tell how terribly she was tempted. How can you? He looked down at me in bewildered surprise. How can I? he repeated. You speak as if you could. What do you mean? Don't ask me, I answered, turning toward him in my face, white, quivering, tear-stained. Don't ask me, not now. You must answer my questions first, and after that I will tell you, but I cannot talk of it now, not yet. We had reached the place we were in search of, as I spoke. There, where the spreading roots of a great birch tree formed a natural resting place upon the steep side of the ravine. I took my seed and Allen stretched himself upon the grass beside me, then looking up at me. I do not know what questions you would ask, he said quietly, I will answer them, whatever they may be. But I did not ask them yet. I sat, instead, with my hands clasping my knee, looking opposite at the glory of the harmonious color, or down the glen, at the vista of far-off dreamlike loveliness on which it opened out. The yellow autumn sunshine made everything golden, the fresh autumn breezes filled the air with life, but to me a loathsome shadow seemed to rest upon all and to stretch itself out far beyond where my eyes could reach, befouling the beauty of the whole wide world. At last I spoke. You have known of it all, I suppose, of this curse that is in the world, sin and suffering and what such words mean. Yes, he said, looking at me with wondering pity. I'm afraid so. But have you known them as they are known to some agonized, hopeless suffering and sin that is all but inevitable? Some time in your life probably you have realized that such things are. It has come home to you and to everyone else, no doubt, except a few ignorant girls such as I was yesterday. But there are some, yes, thousands and thousands, who even now at this moment are feeling sorrow like that, all sinking deep, deeper into the bottomless pit of their soul's degradation. And yet men who know this, who have seen it, laugh, talk, are happy and use themselves. How can they? How can they? I stopped with a catch in my voice and then stretching out my arms in front of me. And it is not only men. Look how beautiful the earth is and God has made it and lets the sun crown it every day with a new glory while this horror of evil broods over and poisons it all. Oh, why is it so? I cannot understand it. My arms trooped again as I finished and my eyes saw Alan's. His were full of tears, but there was almost a smile quivering at the corners of his lips as he replied. When you have found an answer to that question, Evie, come and tell me and mankind at large, it will be news to us all. Then he continued, but after all the earth is beautiful and the sun does shine. We have our own happiness to rejoice in, our own sorrows to bear, the suffering that is near to us to grapple with. For the rest, for this blackness of evil which surrounds us and which we can do nothing to lighten, it will soon, thank God, become vague and far off to you as it is to others. Your feelings of it will be dulled and accept at moments you too will forget. But that is horrible, I exclaimed passionately. The evil will be there all the same whether I feel it or not. Men and women will be struggling in their misery and sin, only I shall be too selfish to care. We cannot go outside the limits of our own nature, he replied. Our knowledge is shallow and our spiritual insight dark, and God in his mercy has made our hearts shallow too in our imagination dull. If knowing and trusting only as men do, we were to feel as angels feel, earth would be hell indeed. It was cold comfort, but at that moment anything warmer or brighter would have been unreal and utterly repellent to me. I hardly took in the meaning of his words, but it was as if a hand had been stretched out to me, struggling in the deep mire, by one who himself felt solid ground beneath him. Where he stood I also might some day stand, and that thought seemed to make patients possible. It was he who first broke the silence which followed. You were saying that you had questions to ask me. I am impatient to put mine in turn, so please go on. It had been a relief to me to turn even to generalizations of despair from the actual horror which had inspired them and to which my mind was thus recalled. With an effort I replied, Yes, I want to ask you about that room, the room in which I slept, and the murder which was committed there. In spite of all that I could do, my voice sank almost to a whisper as I concluded, and I was trembling from head to foot. Who told you that a murder was committed there? Something in my face as he asked the question made him add quickly, Never mind, you're right. That is the room in which Hugh Mervin was murdered by his wife. I was surprised at your question, for I did not know that anyone but my brothers and myself were aware of the fact. The subject is never mentioned, it is closely connected with one intensely painful to our family, and besides, if spoken of, there would be inconveniences arising from the superstitious terror of servants and the natural dislike of guests to sleep in a room where such a thing had happened. Indeed it was largely with the view of wiping out the last memory of the crime's locality that my father renewed the interior of the room some twenty years ago. The only tradition which has been adhered to in connection with it is the one which has now been violated in your person, the one which precludes any unmarried woman from sleeping there. Except for that the room has, as you know, lost all sinister reputation, and its title of haunted has become purely conventional. Nevertheless, as I said, you are right, that it is undoubtedly the room in which the murder was committed. He stopped and looked at me, waiting for more. Go on, tell me about it, and what followed? My lips formed the words my heart beat too faintly and my breath too uttered them. About the murder itself there is not much to tell. The man, I believe, was an inhuman scoundrel and the woman first killed him in desperation and afterwards herself in despair. The only detail connected with the actual crime of which I have ever heard was the gale that was blowing that night, the fiercest known to this countryside in that generation, and it has always been said since that any misfortune to the Mervins, especially any misfortune connected with the Curse, comes with a storm of wind. That was why I so disliked your story of the imaginary tempests which have disturbed your nights since you slept there. As to what followed, he gave a sigh. That story is long enough and full of incident. From the morning after the murder, so runs the tale, Dame Alice came down to the Grange in the tower to which she had retired when her son's wickedness had driven her from his house, and there in the presence of the two corpses she foretold the Curse which should rest upon their descendants for generations to come. A clergyman who was present, horrified, it is said, at her words, adjured her by the mercy of heaven to place some term to the doom which she had pronounced. She replied that no mortal might reckon the fruit of a plant which drew its life from hell. That a term there should be, but as it passed the wisdom of man to fix it, so it should pass the wit of a man to discover it. She then placed in the room this cabinet, constructed by herself and her Italian follower, and said that the Curse should not depart from the family until the day when its doors were unlocked and its legend read. Such is the story. I tell it to you as it was told to me. One thing only is certain that the doom thus traditionally foretold has been only too amply fulfilled. And what was the doom? Alan hesitated a little, and when he spoke his voice was almost awful in its passionless sternness, in its despairing finality. It seemed to echo the irrevocable judgment which his words pronounced. That the crimes against God and each other which had destroyed the parents' life should enter into the children's blood. That never thereafter should there fail a mervin to bring shame or death upon one generation of his father's house. There were two sons of that ill-fated marriage. He went on after a pause. Boys at the time of their parents' death. When they grew up they both fell in love with the same woman, and one killed the other in a duel. The story of the next generation was a peculiarly sad one. Two brothers took opposite sides during the civil troubles, but so fearful were they of the curse which lay upon the family that they chiefly made use of their mutual position in order to protect and guard each other. After the wars were over, the younger brother, while travelling upon some parliamentary commission, stopped and eyed at the Grange. There, through a mistake, he exchanged the report which he was bringing to London for a packet of papers implicating his brother in several besides in a royalist plot. He only discovered his error as he handed the papers to his superior and was but just able to warn his brother in time for him to save his life by flight. The other men involved were taken and executed, and as it was known by what means information had reached the government, the elder Mervyn was universally charged with the vilest treachery. It is said that when after the restoration his return home was rumoured the neighbouring gentry assembled armed with writing-whips to flog him out of the country if he should dare to show his face there. He died abroad, shame-stricken and broken-hearted. It was his son brought up by his uncle in the sternest tenets of Puritanism, who coming home after a lengthened journey found that during his absence his sister had been shamefully seduced. He turned her out of doors then and there in the midst of a bitter January night, and the next morning her dead body and that of her newborn infant were found half-buried in the fresh fallen snow on top of the woods. The white lady is still supposed by the villagers to haunt that side of the glen, and so it went on. A beautiful heartless Mervyn in Queen Anne's time enticed away the affections of her sisters betrothed, and on the day of her own wedding with him her forsaken sister was found drowned by her own act in the pond at the bottom of the garden. Two brothers were soldiers together in some continental war, and one was involuntarily the means of discovering and exposing the treason of the other. A girl was betrayed into a false marriage and her life ruined by a man who came into the house as her brother's friend and whose infamous designs were forwarded and finally accomplished by that same brother's active though unsuspecting assistance. Generation after generation men or women guilty or innocent through the action of their own will or in spite of it, the curse has never yet failed of its victim. Never yet. But surely in our time I did not dare to put the question which was burning my lips. Have you never heard of the tragic end of my poor young uncles? He replied. They were several years older than my father. When boys of fourteen and fifteen they were sent out with the keeper for their first shooting lesson, and the elder shot his brother through the heart. He himself was delicate and they say that he never entirely recovered from the shock. He died before he was twenty and my father, then a child of seven years old, became the heir. It was partly no doubt owing to this calamity having thus occurred before he was old enough to feel it that his comparative skepticism on the whole subject was due. To that I suppose and to the fact that he grew up in an age of railways and liberal culture. He didn't believe then in the curse. Well, rather he thought nothing about it. Until that is, the time came when it took effect to break his heart and end his life. How do you mean? There was a silence for a little. Alan had turned away his head so that I could not see his face. Then, I suppose you have never been told the true story of why Jack left the country. No, was he, is he, he is one victim of the curse in this generation and I, God help me, and the other, and perhaps more wretched one. His voice trembled and broke and for the first time that day I almost forgot the mysterious horror of the night before, in my pity for the actual, tangible suffering before me. I stretched out my hand to his and his fingers closed in mine with a sudden painful grip. Then quietly I will tell you the story, he said, though since that miserable time I have spoken of it to no one. There was a pause before he began. He lay there by my side, his gaze turned across me up the sun-bride autumn-tinted glen, but his eyes shadowed by the memories which he was striving to recall and arrange in due order in his mind. And when he did speak it was not directly to begin the promised recital. You never knew, Jack, he said abruptly. Hardly, I acquiesced. I remember thinking him very handsome. There could not be two opinions as to that, he answered, and a man who could have done anything he liked with his life had things gone differently. His abilities were fine, but his strength lay above all he was strong, strong in his likes and in his dislikes, resolute, fearless and capable of half-measures, a man every inch of him. He was not generally popular, stiff, hard, unsympathetic, people called him. From one point of view and one only he perhaps deserved the epithets. If a woman lost his respect she seemed to lose his pity, too. Like a medieval monk he looked upon such rather as the cause than the result of male depravity and his contempt for them mingled with anger almost as I sometimes thought with hatred. And this attitude was, I have no doubt, resented by the men of his own class and set who shared neither his faults nor his virtues. But in other ways he was not hard. He could love, I at least, have cause to know it. In his story, rightly from my lips, E.V., you must try and see him with my eyes. The friend who loved me and whom I loved with the passion which, if not the strongest, is certainly I believe the most enduring of which men are capable, that perfect brother's love, which so grows into our being that when it is at peace we are scarcely conscious of its existence and when it is wounded our very life-blood seems to flow with the stroke. Others do not always love like that. I can only wish that we had not done so. Well, about five years ago before I had taken my degree I became acquainted with a woman whom I will call Delia. It is near enough to the name by which she went. She was a few years older than myself, very beautiful, and I believed her to be what she described herself, the innocent victim of circumstances and false appearance, a helpless prey to the vile calamities of worldlings. In sober fact I am afraid that whatever her life may have been actually at the time that I knew her a subject which I have never cared to investigate. Her past had been not only bad enough irretrievably to fix her position in society, but bad enough to leave her without an ideal in the world. Though still retaining within her heart the possibilities of a passion reach from the moment that it came to life was strong enough to turn her whole existence into one desperate reckless straining after an object hopelessly beyond her reach. That was the woman with whom at the age of twenty I fancied myself in love. She wanted to get a husband and she thought me rightly ass enough to accept the post. I was very young then, even for my years, a student and idealist imagination highly developed and no knowledge whatever of the world as it actually is. Anyhow, before I had known her a month I had determined to make her my wife. My parents were abroad at the time, George and Lucy here, so it was to Jack that I imparted the news of my resolve. As you may imagine he did all that he could to shake it, but I was immovable. I disbelieved his facts and despised his contempt for the standpoint of my own superior morality. This state of things continued for several weeks during the greater part of which time I was at Oxford. I only knew that while I was there Jack had made Delia's acquaintance and was apparently cultivating it assiduously. One day during the Easter vacation I got a note from her asking me to supper at her house. Jack was invited too. We lodged together while my people were away. There is no need to dwell upon that supper. There were two or three women there of her own sort or worse and a dozen men from among the most profligate in London. The conversation was, I should think, bad even for that class, and she, the goddess of my idolatry, outstripped them all by the foul course shamelessness of her language and behavior. Before the entertainment was half over I rose and took my leave accompanied by Jack and another man. Lagarde was his name, who I presume was bored. Just as we had passed through into the ante-room which lay beyond the one in which we had been eating, Delia followed us and laying her hand on Jack's arm said that she must speak with him. Lagarde and I went into the outer hall and we had not been there more than a minute when the door from the ante-room opened and we heard Delia's voice. I remember the words well that was not the only occasion on which I was to hear them. I will keep the ring as a record of my love," she said, and understand that though you may forget I never shall. Jack came through, the door closed, and as we went out I glanced towards his left hand and saw, as I expected to see, the absence of the ring that we usually wore there. It contained a gem which my mother had picked up in the east and I knew that he valued it quite peculiarly. We always called it Jack's talisman. A miserable time followed. A time for me of agonizing wonder and doubt during which regret for my dead illusion was entirely swallowed up in the terrible dread of my brother's degradation. Then came the announcement of his engagement with me, Sylvia Gray, and a week later, the very day after I had finally returned to London from Oxford, I received a summons from Delia to come and see her. Curiosity and the haunting fear about Jack, which still hung round me, induced me to consent to what otherwise would have been intolerably repellent to me, and I went. I found her in a mad passion of fury. Jack had refused to see her or to answer her letters and she had sent for me that I might give him her message, tell him that he belonged to her and her only and that he never should marry another woman. Angry at my interference, Jack disdained even to repudiate her claims, only sending back a thread of appealing to the police if she ventured upon any further annoyance. I wrote, as she told me, and she emphasized my silence on the subject by writing back to me a more definite and explicit assertion of her rights. Beyond that, for some weeks, she made no sign. I have no doubt that she had means of keeping watch upon both his movements and mine, and during that time, as she relinquished gradually all hopes of inducing him to abandon his purpose, she was being driven to her last desperate resolve. Later, when all was over, Jack told me the story of that spring and summer. He told me how, when he found me immovable on the subject, he had resolved to stop the marriage somehow through Delia herself. He had made her acquaintance and sought her society frequently. She had taken a fancy to him, and he admitted that he had availed himself of this fact to increase his intimacy with her, and as he hoped, ultimately, his power over her. But he was not conscious of ever having varied in his manner toward her of contemptuous indifference. This contradictory behavior, his being constantly near her, yet always beyond her reach, was probably the very thing which excited her fancy into passion, the one strong passion of the poor woman's life. Then came his deliberate demand that she should, by her own act, unmask herself in my sight. The unfortunate woman tried to bargain for some proof of affection in return, and on this occasion had first openly declared her feelings towards him. He did not believe her. He refused her terms. But when, as her payment, she asked for the ring which was so especially associated with himself, he agreed to give it to her. Otherwise hoping, no doubt against hope, dreading, above all things, a quarrel and final separation she submitted unconditionally. And from the time of that evening, when Lagarde and I had overheard her parting words, Jack never saw her again until the last and final catastrophe. It was in July. My parents had returned to England, but had come straight on here. Jack and I were dining together with Lady Sylvia at her father's house, her brother, young Gray, making the forth at dinner. I had arranged to go to a party with your mother, and I told the servants that a lady would call for me early in the evening. The house stood in Park Lane, and after dinner we all went out on the broad balcony which opened from the drawing-room. There was a strong wind blowing that night, and I remember well the vague, disquieted feeling of unreality that possessed me, sweeping through me as it were with each gust of wind. Then suddenly a servant stood behind me saying that the lady had come for me and was in the drawing-room. Shocked that my aunt should have troubled herself from so far, I turned quickly, stepped back into the room, and found myself face-to-face with Delia. She was fully dressed for the evening with a long silk opera cloak over her shoulders. Her face as white as her gown, her splendid eyes, strangely wide open and shining. I don't know what I said or did. I tried to get her away, but it was too late. The others had heard us and appeared at the open window. Jack came forward at once, speaking rapidly, fiercely, telling her to leave the house at once, promising desperately that he would see her in his own rooms on the morrow. Well, I remember how her answer rang out. Neither tomorrow nor another day I will never leave you again while I live. At the same moment she drew something swiftly from under her cloak. There was the sound of a pistol shot, and she lay dead at our feet, her blood splashing upon Jack's shirt and hands as she fell. Alan paused in his recital. He was trembling from head to foot, but he kept his eyes turned steadily downwards, and both face and voice were cold, almost expressionless. Of course there was an inquest, he resumed, which as usual exercised its very ill-defined powers in inquiring into all possible motives for the suicide. Young Gray, who had stepped into the room just before the shot had been fired, swore to the last words Delia had uttered, legard to those he had overheard the night of that dreadful supper. There were scores of men to bear witness to the intimate relations which had existed between her and Jack during the whole of the previous spring. I had to give evidence. A skillful lawyer had been retained by one of her sisters, and had been instructed by her on points which no doubt she had originally learnt from Delia herself. In his hands I had not only to corroborate Gray and legard, and to give full details of that last interview, but also to swear to the peculiar value which Jack attached to the talisman ring which he had given Delia, to the language she had held when I saw her after my return from Oxford, to her subsequent letter and Jack's fatal silence on the occasion. The story by which Jack and I strove to account for the facts was laughed at as clumsy in vengeance, and my undisguised reluctance in giving evidence added greatly to its weight against my brother's character. The jury returned a verdict of suicide of unsound mind, the result of desertion by her lover. You may imagine how that verdict was commented upon by every radical newspaper in the kingdom, and for once society more than corroborated the opinions of the press. The larger public regarded the story as an extreme case of an innocent victim and the cowardly society villain. It was only among a comparatively small set that Delia's reputation was known, and there in view of Jack's notorious and peculiar intimacy his repudiation of all relations with her was received with contemptuous incredulity. That he should have first entered upon such relations at the very time when he was already courting Lady Sylvia was regarded even in those circles as a strong order, and they looked upon his present attitude with great indignation as a cowardly attempt to save his own character by casting upon the dead woman's memory all the odium of a false accusation. With an entire absence of logic, too, he was made responsible for the suicide having taken place in Lady Sylvia's presence. She had broken off the engagement the day after the catastrophe and her husband, a clan powerful in the London world, furious at the mud through which her name had been dragged, did all they could to intensify the feeling already existing against Jack. Not a voice was raised in his defence. He was advised to leave the army, he was requested to withdraw from some of his clubs, turned out of others, avoided by his vast acquaintances, cut by his respectable ones. It was enough to kill a weaker man. He showed no resentment at the measure thus dealt out to him. Indeed, at first, except for Sylvia's assertion of him, he seemed dolly indifferent to it all. It was as if his soul had been stunned from the moment that that wretched woman's blood had splashed upon his fingers and her dead eyes had looked up into his own. But it was not long before he realised the full extent of the social damnation which had been inflicted upon him, and he then resolved to leave the country and go to America. The night before he started he came down here to take leave. I was here looking after my parents, George, whose mind was almost unhinged by the family disgrace, having gone abroad with his wife. My mother, at the first news of what had happened, had taken to her bed, never to leave it again. And thus it was in my presence alone, up there in my father's little study, that Jack gave him that night the whole story. He told it quietly enough. But when he had finished, with a sudden outburst of feeling upon me, it was I who had been the cause of it all. My insensate folly had induced him to make the unhappy woman's acquaintance, to allow and even encourage her fatal love to commit all the blunders and sins which had brought about his miserable ending and his final overthrow. It was by means of me that she had obtained access to him on that dreadful night. My evidence, which most utterly damned him in public opinion, he had lost his reputation, his friends, his career, his country, the woman he loved, his hopes for the future, threw me above all that the burden of that horrible death would lie forever on his soul. He was lashing himself to fury with his own words as he spoke, and I stood leaning against the wall opposite to him, cold, dumb, unresisting, when suddenly my father interrupted. I think that both Jack and I had forgotten his presence, but at the sound of his voice changed from what we had ever heard it. He turned to him, and I then for the first time saw in his face the death-look which never afterwards quitted it. Stop, Jack," he said. Alan is not to blame, and if it had not been in this way it would have been in some other. I only am guilty who brought you both into existence with my own stained blood in your veins. If you wish to curse anyone, curse your family, your name, me if you will, and may God forgive me that you were ever born into the world. Alan stopped with a shudder and then continued dolly. It was when I heard those words the most terrible that a father could have uttered that I first understood all that old sixteenth-century tale might mean to me and mine. I have realized it vividly enough since. Early the next morning when the dawn was just breaking Jack came to the door of my room to bid me good-bye. All his passion was gone. His looks and tones seemed part and parcel of the dim grey morning light. He freely withdrew all the charges he had made against me the night before, forgave me all the share that I had had in his misfortunes, and then begged that I would never come near him or let him hear from me again. The curse is heavy upon us both, he said, and it is the only favour which you can do me. I have never seen him since. But you have heard of him, I exclaimed. What has become of him? Alan raised himself to a sitting posture. The last that I heard, he said, with a catch in his voice, was that in his misery and hopelessness he was taking to drink. George writes to him and does what he can, but I dare not say a word, for fear it should turn to poison on my lips. I dare not lift a hand to help him, for fear it should have power to strike him to the ground. The worst may be yet to come. I am still living, still living. There are depths of shame to which he has not sunk. And, oh, Evie, Evie, he is my own, my best-loved brother. All his composure was gone now. His voice rose to a kind of wail with the last words, and folding his arms on his raised knee, he let his head fall upon them, while his figure quivered with scarcely restrained emotion. There was a silence for some moments while he sat thus. I looked on in wretched helplessness beside him. Then he raised his head and, without looking round at me, went on in a low tone. And what is in the future? I pray that death, instead of shame, may be the portion of the next generation. And I look at George's boys only to wonder which of them is the happy one, who shall someday lie dead at his brother's feet. Are you surprised at my resolution never to marry? The fatal prophecy is rich in its fulfillment. None of our name and blood are safe. And the day might come when I too should have to call upon my children to curse me for their birth, should have to watch while the burden which I could no longer bear alone press the life from their mother's heart. Through the tragedy of this speech I was conscious of a faint suggestion of comfort, a far-off glimmer as of unseen home lights on a midnight sky. I was in no mood then to understand or to seek to understand what it was, but I know now that his words had removed the weight of helpless punishment from my spirit, that his heart, speaking through them to my own, had made me for life the sharer of his grief. Presently he drew his shoulders together with a slight determined jerk, threw himself back upon the grass and turning to me with that tremulous haggard smile upon his lips, which I knew so well, but which had never before struck me with such infinite pathos. Luckily, he said, there are other things to do in life besides being happy. Only perhaps you understand now what I meant last night, when I spoke of things which flesh and blood cannot bear, and yet which must be borne. Suddenly and sharply his words roused again into activity the loathsome memory which my interest in his story had partially deadened. He noticed the quick and voluntary contraction of my muscles and read it aright. That reminds me, he went on, I must claim your promise. I have told you my story, now tell me yours. I told him, not as I have said it down here, though perhaps even in greater detail but incoherently bit by bit, while he helped me out with general questions, particularly comprehending gestures, and patient waiting during the pauses of exhaustion which perforce interpose themselves. As my story approached its climax, his agitation grew almost equal to my own, and he listened to the close his teeth clenched, his brows bent, as if passing again with me through that awful conflict. When I had finished it was some moments before either of us could speak, and then he burst forth into bitter self-reproach for having so far yielded to his brother's angry obstinacy as to allow me to sleep the third night in that fatal room. It was cowardice, he said, share cowardice. After all that has happened I dared not have a quarrel with one of my own blood, and yet if I had not hardened my heart I had reason to know what I was risking. How do you mean? I asked. Those other two girls who slept there, he said breathlessly. It was in each case after the third night there that they were found dead. Dead, Evie. So runs the story, with a mark upon their necks similar in shape and position to the death wound which Margaret Mervin inflicted upon herself. I could not speak, but I clutched his hand with an almost convulsive grip. And I knew the story. I knew it, he cried. As boys we were not allowed to hear much of our family traditions, but this one I knew. When my father redid the interior of the East Room he removed at the same time a board from above the doorway outside on which had been written it is said by Dame Alice herself a warning upon this very subject. I happened to be present when our old housekeeper who had been his nurse remonstrated with him warmly upon this act. And I asked her afterwards what the board was and why she cared about it so much. In her excitement she told me the story of those unhappy girls repeating again and again that if the warning were taken away evil would come of it. And she was right, I said, Dolly. Oh, if only your father had left it there. I suppose, he answered, speaking more quietly, that he was impatient of traditions which as I told you he at that time more than half despised. Indeed he altered the shape of the doorway raising it and making it flat and square so that the old inscription could not have been replaced even had it been wished. I remember it was fitted round the low Tudor arch which was previously there. My mind too worn with many emotions for deliberate thought wandered on languidly and as it were mechanically upon these last trivial words. The doorway resented itself to my view as it had originally stood with the discarded warning above it and then by a spontaneous comparison of mental vision I recalled the painted board which I had noticed three days before in Dame Alice's tower. I suggested to Allen that it might have been the identical one. Its shape was as he described. Very likely he answered absently. Do you remember what the words were? Yes, I think so, I replied, let me see. And I repeated them slowly dragging them out as it were one by one from my memory where the woman sinned the maid shall win but God helped the maid that sleeps within. You see, I said, turning towards him the last line is a warning such as you spoke of but to my surprise Allen had sprung to his feet and was looking down at me his whole body quivering with excitement. Yes, Evie, he cried, and the first line is a prophecy where the woman sinned the maid has won. He seized the hand which I instinctively reached out to him. We have not seen the end of this yet, he went on speaking rapidly as if articulation had become difficult to him. Come, Evie, we must go back to the house and look at the cabinet now at once. I had risen to my feet by this time but I shrank away at those words. To that room, Allen, oh Allen, I know I cannot. He had hold of my hand still and he tightened his grasp upon it. I shall be with you, you will not be afraid with me. Come. His eyes were burning, his face flushed and paled in rapid alteration and his hand held mine like a vice of iron. I turned with him and we walked back to the Grange. Allen quickening his pace as he went till I almost had to run by his side. As we approached the dreaded room my sense of repulsion became almost unbearable but I was now infected by his excitement though I bit dimly comprehended its cause. We met no one on our way and in a moment he had hurried me into the house up the stairs and along the narrow passage and I was once more in the east room and in the presence of all the memories of that accursed night. For an instant I stood strengthless, helpless, on the threshold, my gaze fixed panic-stricken on the spot where I had taken such awful part in that phantom tragedy of evil. Then Allen threw his arms round me and drew me hastily on in front of the cabinet. Without a pause, giving himself time to speak nor think, he stretched out his left hand and moved the buttons one after another. How or in what direction he moved them I know not but as the last turned with a click the doors which no mortal hand had enclosed for three hundred years flew back and the cabinet stood open. I gave a little gasp of fear. Allen pressed his lips closely together and turned to me with eager questioning in his eyes. I pointed an answer tremblingly at the drawer which I had seen open the night before. He drew it out and there in its satin bed lay the dagger in its silver sheath. Still without a word he took it up and reaching his right hand round me for I could not now have stood had he withdrawn his support with a swift strong jerk he unsheathed the blade. There in the clear autumn sunshine I could see the same dull stains I had marked in the flickering candlelight and over them still ready and moist were the drops of my own half-dried blood. I grasped the lapel of his coat with both of my hands and clung to him like a child in terror while the eyes of both of us remained fixed as if fascinated upon the knife blade. Then with a sudden start of memory Allen raised his to the cornice of the cabinet and mine followed. No change that I could detect had taken place in that twisted goldwork but there, clear in the sight of his both, stood forth the words of the magic motto. Pure blood shed by the bloodstained knife ends Mervyn's shame, heals Mervyn's strife. In low, steady tones Allen read out the lines and then there was silence. On my part a stunned bewilderment, the bewilderment of a spirit overwhelmed beyond the power of comprehension by rushing, conflicting emotions. Allen pressed me closer to him while the silence seemed to throb with the beating of his heart and the panting of his breath. But except for that he remained motionless, gazing at the golden message before him. At length I felt a movement and looking up saw his face turn down towards mine, the lips quivering, cheeks flushed, the eyes soft with passionate feeling. We are saved, my darling. He whispered, saved, and through you. Then he bent his head lower and there in that room of horror I received the first long lover's kiss from my own dear husband's lips. My husband, yes. But not till some time after that. Allen's first act, when he had once fully realized that the curse was indeed removed, was throwing his budding practice to the winds to set sail for America. There he sought out Jack and labored hard to impart to him some of his own newfound hope. It was slow work but he succeeded at last and only left him when two years later he had handed him over to the charge of a bright-eyed Western girl to whom the whole story had been told and who showed herself ready and anxious to help in building up again the broken life of her English lover. To judge from the letters that we have since received she has shown herself well-fitted for the task. Among other things she has money and Jack's worldly affairs have so prospered that George declares that he can well afford now some of his superfluous cash upon farming a few of his elder brother's acres. The idea seems to smile upon Jack and I have every hope this winter of being able to institute an actual comparison between our small boy, his namesake, and his own three-year-old Allen. The comparison, by the way, will have to be conditional. For Jack it, the name by which my son is there is familiarly known is but a little more than two. I turn my eyes for a moment and they fall upon the northern corner of the east room which shows round the edge of the house. Then the skeleton leaps from the cupboard of my memory, the icy hand which lies ever near my soul grips it suddenly with a chill shutter. Not for nothing was that wretched woman's life interwoven with my own if only for an hour. Not for nothing did my spirit harbor a conflict and an agony which, thank God, are far from its own story. Though Margaret Mervyn's dagger failed to pierce my flesh, the wound in my soul may never wholly be healed. I know that it is so, and yet as I turn to start through the sunshine to the cedar shade in its laughing occupants I whisper to myself with fervent conviction. It was worth it. That is the end of the closed cabinet and the end of the Lock and Key Library edited by Julian Hawthorne.