 Good morning sir. Good morning. Good morning. Good morning. Good morning. Thank you sir. Good morning. Muruganandam sir. Muruganandam. Yes sir. Good morning. Good morning. Yes sir. How are you feeling today? So, feeling well sir. So, Muruganandam. Can you introduce yourself to your background? Yes sir. Sir, I am Muruganandam. I come from Coimbatore district of Tamil Nadu state. My parents are farmers. I have completed engineering in electrical and electronics. Then, I had the opportunity to work with rural development of Tamil Nadu for one and a half year. Then, once again I got an opportunity to work with Tamil Nadu government in the department of cooperatives as a senior inspector. I have lived and I have once again re-aligned with UPSC preparation. I am a freelance translator from English to Tamil and that is what about me sir. So, we can start with you. Yes. Muruganandam. Yes sir. So, few days back, there was a tragic accident, road accident in the near Tirupu, your place, Coimbatore. Overnight, people were dead. Why these accidents are happening and what is India's ranking in the road accident? Sir, with the board's permission, can I use Tamil sir? Because I have arted Tamil. So, I just want to try at least one mark with Tamil. Can I do it? Okay sir. Sir, till date, road accident. In 2018, only 1.5 lakh people were dead. That is what World Bank reports say. I do not know the exact ranking sir. But, till this incident, the rules and regulations and awareness that we have, it is clear that we cannot bring it in properly. Because, even the road construction that was right there, the driver was unconscious. So, that accident has happened. So, in that level, it is a big drawback that we cannot bring awareness in. Till date, it has been in India for more than 15 to 45 years. So, even if we bring awareness programs, it is a big lack that we cannot reach out. In the road accidents, as far as road accidents are concerned, there are global conventions. India is a signatory to that. One of the conventions. India has promised that we will bring down the death casualties at least by half the next decade. Now, the question is that there are several reasons that are cited for these sort of accidents. Yes sir. It is changing the engineering patterns of the vehicles and the construction of the roads. So, who are the initiatives of the vehicles? Sir, we can change the physical engineering in vehicles. Safety measures are included. Second, soft engineering. We can use the technology of the vehicles to note the driver's timing, his facial expressions and so on. Through that, we can provide safety measures through soft engineering. Till date, we have not been able to establish the well-established methods of vehicles. We can do that too. So, by doing these things, we can reduce the number of accidents. We have to do this in between. The number of road casualties is increasing. Do you think that it affects the productivity and, in a way, it also disturbs the at least a ministry level, the GDP? Yes, sir. First, we are losing a well-engineered, equipped human capital. In the 19th century, all the people who died were a resource for their homes. All of them were educated and well-equipped human capital. Through that, we can reduce the productivity. Second, there is no speed in our logistics. There is no speed in our logistics. We are lacking in logistics and goods. That is why productivity is decreasing. Yes, it is. In Koyamutur, there is a man-animal conflict. Koyamutur is one of the areas in Tamil Nadu. What is the reason? The media says that elephants are intruding. Is it the truth or what is the reason for this man-animal conflict in her district? Sir, In Koyamutur, in the 1950s, there were more than three rooms in the urbanization area. In Koyamutur, there is the lowest level of western cars. In the urbanization area, the population of elephants is not in their territory. In the elephant corridor, we automatically start moving. That is why there is a problem. In the long-term, in the ways of elephants, our developmental activities, infrastructure activities, and the human population are shifted to this area. Sir, Can we take care of all the settlements? Human beings are living there. How do you dislocate them or relocate them? Sir, this is a problem called developmental versus environment. We cannot relocate everything. But we have to identify the elephant corridors first, sir. We have to come up with the biological roads for elephants to be established. There are many incidents that are very dangerous. We have to reach out to them more. So, to create awareness programs for the people, we have to shift the people who are in the elephant corridor. We have to reduce the number of people from the hotel, tourism sector, infrastructure. For example, if a roadway or railway goes to the elephant corridor, we have constructions, different kinds of constructions. We have to construct a path to the elephant corridor. We can do it like that. Or we can construct an underground path. If we develop the environment consciously, we can do it well. One last question. Your second choice is IPS, Indian Police. Yes, sir. Why do you want to be an IPS officer? What is special about the police officer? What is so much special about the IPS? And why should the taxpayers' money be paid on you to become a police officer? Justify your choice. Yes, sir. Sir, my first choice is already there. If it is not possible, then I have added IPS. Sir, all the services available in this generation are being trained and served for the future generation. IPS is managed by law and order and managed by people. We have to maintain security in this state. We have to give the opportunity to maintain security. That is why I have chosen it. Besides, all the services have benefits. When it comes to IPS, there are many scopes, many opportunities. Being with the people, I have added like that. Thank you. I have told that you are from Coimbatore, which is the western region. Why is it that this western region is standing out to all social indicators, then even industrialization, urbanization compared to the rest of the state? Do you want to reply in Tamil? Okay, sir. Your question is western region is doing well then Tamil Nadu? Yes, sir. Just if I with each industrialization why it is more social development why it is more Sure, sir. First, in a land, people are developed, improved, developed resources, availability of resources, as well as the weather condition, geography. That decides. In that way, Coimbatore is the water resources, land resources, climate resources. Everything started because our primary sector agriculture started well. The outcome of agriculture, profit, human resource development, education as well as industrialization, because of this spillover, we can give an initiation easily. For example, Mr. G.D. Naidu Coimbatore the initial investment in human capital was able to go abroad and study. Once again when he returned, his knowledge in the industry, in the education sector, once again he contributed. So, started from the geography, proliferated resources which are there. Yes, sir. Sir, it is at the Palakkad Gap. The Coimbatore district is at the Palakkad Gap and on the western guard skills. So, we have rivers like Parambikulam, Aliyar, Noiyal, Siruvani, Pillur, Bhavani, all these rivers are there and on peculiar aspect of this rivers is it can get itself, it receives monsoon, south-west monsoon which is not possible in the eastern part of the rest of the Tamil Nadu. So, we have the water from the hills, we also have the water from both the rains. So, that is the specific water resources which we have. But even if you say this Thirunveli side, it has so many rivers like Tamirabarani, then Papinasham, like it's perennial that water. Yes, sir. And why that water is there? I think so. UTI came and was near this area and the UTI came and they have established their expansions in UTI. They have also reached out to the Coimbatore which is nearer to the UTI. We can see that lot of schools even in 800s have started. Even in textile industry also they have made use of available resources like cotton in that area and they have their contribution is there. So they have also contributed in a way which is not in the southern side. They have equally developed Kodaikaneral also right which is in the southern side. Then I am sorry sir. There are some developments but all the regions is also developed sir. There also we can see that they have also built industries. They have made it as tourism industry also. That kind of development is there. But when it comes to tourism industry it is a little bit more developed but we can't say that there is no development. In government of Tamil Nadu you were in rural development right. What was your role in sir? I was a junior assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant assistant started to use that money for something else. That is a good development and especially in Tamil Nadu, in other states it is good. And this Tamil literature is one of your, is your optional, right? Yes sir. So, what are the other major Dravidian languages which are there in Tamil Nadu? Yes sir. Sir, when it comes to Dravidian languages, we have Tamil, Malayalam, Kannada, Telugu, these are all the refined language. We call these things as refined language. Besides also we have unrefined language, Tirithapadadamoligal because their development is as not as much as these four like Tulu, Kodahu, Badakhah, these are in the southern states. When we move to the northern states, we do have Prahkui, Prahkui in the Pallagistan and Malto, Varang, Varang and Kivi, all these kind of small languages in Telangana, Chattisgarh, Mathya Pradesh, Aetransans. So, this is what the spread of the Dravidian language, sir. And how is it different from the other languages? How have these languages been classified as Dravidian? What is that thing which distinguishes them from the other languages? Yes sir. Sir, in India, we have four groups of languages. How do they do this? First, their root words, they will search the root words, they will club it together and then they can find that there is a difference between these two things, these basics. So, they start with the root words and then differentiate them based on their language classification. But there is a difference in the sentence structure, sir. When we look at a Dravidian language, it is in the SOV pattern. If you look at a European language, it is in the SOV pattern. So, in that way, the syntax classification is also there. These are all the basics on which the languages are classified. Thank you. Thank you, sir. You, in your hobby, I see that you have some oratorial skills. Yes sir. You have got some prizes also. Yes sir. Isn't it? On what do you speak? Sir. What are the topics? Sir. There is an oratorial competition. Yes sir. What are the subjects that you talk on? Sir, in the oratorical skill, or the topic that you are talking about, school days started from there. That's okay. So, what was the necessity there? Festivals, functions, etc. After that, I got chances in a TV program, sir. I have also talked about that. But topics generally which comes into my mind is about like something related to society, something related to development, something related to kind of politics, something like that. I have chosen like that. But later on, I have, I haven't get, I couldn't do much in that area. On those days, I was doing like that, sir. You also read short stories. Yes sir. Why short stories? Sir. Why do you choose? Because literature has been written. Like Pootry is there, Noveli is there, Dhanajal is there. Short stories. Sir, I am a new student. Yes sir. Okay sir. Okay sir. I will try it. So, I do read books from Novels to Poetry to general books. But this is the shortest event. So, I have just picked short story reading. I used to read short story also. So, I have chosen like that. This is our life itself, like a short story. So, it is more odd. What is the difference between short story and Noveli? Noveli. What is the difference between short story and Noveli? The difference between short story and Noveli? Sir, when it comes to Noveli, it will proliferate into many areas. It will take much time. And many characters will come and clash with each other. Lot of explanation about the scenario will be there. But when it comes to short story, one character, protagonist or another character antagonist, both will clash with each other. One team will be there, one event, one place within maximum 20,000 words or minimum 1000 words. This is what the difference between Novel and short story, sir. You see, our life is a short story. Yes, sir. Our life is a short story or a Novel. Novel is for longer period. Short story describes one incident. Yes, sir. So, you can compare the life to a short story or a Novel. Sir, when I think about the... Novel is more comprehensive always. Is it? Yes, sir. Short story describes one incident. One particular thing will be there. Yes, sir. Sir, when we consider the universe and when we consider our presence in this world, I think it is short story. Because Gandhi is the only one who tells the story to the people. He can be his life for everyone. But for other people, it is a small story. For a person, for an individual, his life is a Novel. For others... Yes, sir. That is also true, sir. Okay, nice. Okay. Have you heard about the randomized control trial? Yes, sir. What is that? Mr. Abhijeet, who received the Nobel Prize, he is Abhijeet Banerjee, an RTC randomized control. It talks about economics. He says that we are assuming something. But we have to find the truth on the ground level. So, we have to apply whatever we can take. That concept must be applied and it should be based on data-driven. That should be randomized also. So, that is the RTC concept. Give me some examples. Those examples are quoted. While writing about him, those examples are quoted. Like what happened in Africa or in Rastan. So, tell me some examples. Yes, sir. How it works. Yes, sir. I mean, it's a... Dewarming in Africa. Yes, sir. Middle African country. Dewarming for the experiment. In Rastan, what was the experiment? I am sorry, sir. I couldn't exactly recollect... The examples. Vaccination. Vaccination. People are not taking their children to the vaccine camp. Yes, sir. Once they are given one kg of... Yes, sir. Pulse. Then they do. Pulse, yes, sir. But why do you think a randomized control trial can be applied at a larger scale? This was the major criticism. Why? Why can't be applied? Why? It cannot be applied to the whole economy. It cannot be applied. Yes, sir. Okay. Why do you think so? Because it's a randomized control trial. Yes. It only works at the human level. Only micro level. It can't be treated elsewhere. Sir, if I am right, it may be because when it comes to macroeconomy, we have to consider a lot of things which works co-relatively. And then and there, we can't apply this type of silos. So that may be the reason, but I am not exactly know the reason, sir. What are the other criticisms against randomized control trial? Yes, sir. It is very costly. Yes, sir. Okay. It can't be applied to the whole economy. Yes, sir. Because it has also failed while this, like some schools, some schools, there are teacher absenteeism. So they have given this camera in the class. Yes, sir. That really has really bettered the teacher's attendance. Yes, sir. But this experiment was not successful in case of nurses in a hospital. Yes, sir. This is the major criticism. Yes, sir. And second is very costly. Okay. There are two major criticisms against randomized control trial. Thank you, sir. Thank you, sir. Because an Indian has got, so read thoroughly about it. Sure, sir. Okay. Thank you. Murugan Nanda. Yes, sir. You are a telecom engineer. Did your studies in electric and electronic engineering? Yes, sir. Got it. Telecom industry is in crisis. Yes, sir. Reading in the FHR every day. Yes, sir. What about AGR? What is AGR? What is a full form? Full form. Yes, sir. Accumulated gross revenue. Gross revenue, sir. Yes, sir. How it is to be collected? There are certain instructions issued by the government of India. Yes, sir. How it is to be collected? Sir, that revenue, which these telecom industry has to given to the government is there. But they couldn't repay it and we couldn't collect it also. It has gone to the Supreme Court and they have ordered that it should be collected within time. But the telecom industries couldn't generate as much money they can. They have told that whatever we can, we give it to you. If we couldn't get it, we will do it by means of bank security, sir. They have told like that, sir. See, you have opted for IAS. Tomorrow as IAS officer or as a central service officer. Ten years from now, you are posted to telecom regulatory authority of India. The umbrella body which controls, supervises the telecom operation in the country. And secondly, as of today, telecom is the lifeline of modern civilization. What role you can play? Ten years from now. I mean it, sir. Please, I will think. Sir, ten years from now, the technology and the reach of the telecom industry must be greater than that of what you are having. At the time, the globe will be connected by means of this data. So, at the time, I will have to work about enabling the infrastructure to reach out all the corners, digital infrastructure. Then helping the, I mean, regulating the telecom industry as such, that process will be with the administrative side. And awareness creations will also be our side, because we do have largest population in the earth. Even in ten years, we may have some gaps where we have to work about their digital inclusion of the people. So, in these three areas, there will be some scope for me, sir. You told, sir, that IPS is your second choice, okay? Suppose, tomorrow you are not selected for IS. You are selected for the IPS. What sort of technical upgradation you can bring in policy? Because today, tomorrow, you know, you as president is visiting two of our bigger cities, Ahmedabad and next, he moves to Delhi. How the police people are controlling the surveillance, highest dignitary of the world has come? How this surveillance can be done? Yes, sir. And naturally, even in your own state, Tamil Nadu, earlier, when I came to Tamil Nadu, there was only one police commission at it. Now, there are nine-ten police commission at it. So, how do you enrich this surveillance? Yes, sir. How do you do the technological upgradation? Yes, sir. Sir, the future will be in the hands of the cyber. So, cyber security will be the most technological aspect of these kind of security systems, sir. At the time, when it comes to mass security system, we can have cyber dome, where all the information which goes into that place can be censored, can be regulated. That concept can be used, sir. We will also have artificial intelligence based, machine learning based, some technologies which can be helpful for, from facial recognition to people movement to and a lot of kind of other securities can also be trained to the artificial intelligence machines that will also be helping us, sir. So, cyber dome and artificial intelligence and having a lot of smart applications can be at the hand of the people, can be at the hands of the police and it can be holistically. So, we can connect everybody in the technology based cyberspace, sir. So, connection, the security aspects, use of technological innovations. All these kind of things can be included in policing, sir. Are you interested in cinema? Not much, sir. Recently, an accident took place. Yes, sir. In general, why it has happened? What was the, is it actually all, they say all the money in the cinema industry is knocked out by the producer and the major actors. Bigger actor and actresses take away all the money and the food soldiers who work for everything, they are deprived of all facilities. Why it is so? Is it organized or unorganized? Philip's actor. Yes, sir. Whether it is Tamil cinema or whether it is Indian cinema or Telugu cinema. Yes, sir. Sir, it is not only in the cinema industry, but in everywhere we can see those people who have the control over financial investment, who have the control over the technical aspects as well as human control have the opportunity and capacity to take away a lot of wealth. But those who are under the layer are not getting as much. But when it comes to cinema industry, there also this problem is there. At the ground level, they couldn't get as much as they can. It is taken away from those investors, from those persons who have the technical as well as service-based skills. So, they are doing. So, we can see that it is not organized as much. It is more or less unorganized. But that has to be that change. If at all we want to have some change, that has to be come from there, sir. What about Olympics? When will be the next Olympics? Where it will be played? And when it will be played? 2020? Yes, sir. Where it will be played? Sir, it... I am sorry, sir. Tokyo? Japan, yes, sir. And there is a history with the Tokyo Olympics. Is not it? What is the history? I am sorry, sir. I am not aware of it. You go through Olympics. Sure, sir. What is your hobby? Sir, short story reading, sir. Short story writing. Already, it has been asked. Yes, sir. Fine. I just wanted to know that you are hearing the news about coronavirus? Yes, sir. If you are put at the district collector of the district in the state, where the already outbreak is there, so what steps you would like to take, or you would take to contain and prevent the spread of the disease for the population? Yes, sir. If you are a district collector, more people will come. For a minute, sir, I will think... Sir, especially with respect to this coronavirus, the first thing which has to be done is quarantining the people, segregating the people from each other. So, first, I will stop public meetings, like public transportations, or if there is any event, or there is any schooling, etc. I will first stop as a precautionary measure. So, I will do that, sir. Second, I will make the people to segregate themselves, among themselves, within a city, or within a village, within a home itself. So, that segregation part is there. So, generally as a society, I have to segregate from other people, and even within them, we have to segregate. The secondary aspect is about offering and providing Medicare, medication help to these people. So, I will... I assume that it is there in my district. So, I will ask the state government and central government, I will put up the enough records to show that this is happening. I will get enough medication facilities, can be from human resource, can be from other medical assistance, equipments, all these things I will get into, and I will send it towards the people. The third one is about taking care of the people who are there, like taking care of everyday needs, like food, medicine, water, and all these kind of things. So, that has to be also taken care of. Fourth one is about general security systems, sir. I will make use of available resources to quarantine as much as we can do that, sir. So, you are starting with the quarantine, then you talk about medical treatment, what word awareness, panic among the population, and all. So, I think you are starting with the awareness. Yes, sir. What is the disease? Yes, sir. But the question they can take, because you cannot force people to segregate, you know. Yes, sir. Public outreach has to be there. Yes, sir. Then you have to put the medical logistics, what you are talking about, within and outside the district. Okay, sir. With all the stakeholders and all. Yes. Whatever you have to operate. Okay, sir. What is common between Mahavali Purim and Wuhan? Wuhan is the news. Mahavali Purim is not in the news now. Descent or historic news. Yes, sir. And link to the cases. Sir, I am not exactly know the factor if I am right. The Bodhidharma from Mahamalapuram have gone there to the region of that Wuhan. So, it may be the link between these two cities. Two cities, sir. Second link, the summit between Mr. Modi and Mr. President. He was here. Yes, sir. The reference to that, historical plus the current political dialogue. Yes, sir. And then last. Okay, sir. What about language like SOV, SVO and all? Yes, sir. That I understand syntax and all. So, you got the Ravanian language, you got Rn. Hmm. People say that Tamil is even older than Sanskrit. Isn't it? There is one like difficult to prove and all. So, why so much resentment against a language like in Tamil Nadu? They don't want to learn Hindi. Hmm. I came in the 97. I was not an IPS at that time. I was in a non-service. I didn't find a board written in English. I was struggling to read even English boards. So, we are a free language country. Isn't it? Your mother tongue is the first. Then comes the national language. Then comes the English. But careful that this thing is not there. Yes, sir. People speak Hindi here. Yes, sir. They speak Hindi. So, why should that be operation with that? And we are not language country. Like in France, they learn only one. Yes, sir. The disadvantage for the population to learn another language or a advantage? Sir, when it comes to language, it is about utility purpose. So, not learning Hindi or learning three languages. Both are there. I do agree with that. We can have a single language for those people who can converse it with that. When it comes to Northern India, we can even have it as an official language. When it comes to other part of India, so I do feel that three languages are not necessary at this type of technological environment. We can make use of artificial intelligence based technology. So, it may not be the problem in future. When it comes to Tamil Nadu and not learning Hindi, it is not like that, sir. In India, 5 lakh people per year are learning Hindi by means of Hindi pressurization. So, the state as a Tamil Nadu have accepted two language policy. So, they have opted for that matter. But still there is possibilities that they can learn Hindi as a language. But as a whole, when it comes to a country like India, learning three languages or four languages, when it comes to tribal people who do not even speak these three languages, he has to learn four languages. So, we can do something, sir. We can allow the people to learn their own language. We can reconnect these people by means of technology. Then there will not be the problem of not learning your language or not learning. In mother tongue, you do not have to teach. They will learn. Even if you stop, they will not stop. I am talking about other two languages. English is there, Hindi is there. I am not saying when to learn or not. Is it a politics or is it something like resentment among the public or politics you are describing there? Yes, sir. The political connection is also there. But a Tamil Nadu is thinking the two languages enough. I speak six. My Punjabi is there. My Hindi is there. My English is there. My Malayalam is there. My French is there. I speak five languages. So, sir. I am not going to come into the world by learning other languages and all that. It is an asset for you because if you talk about globalization, same thing happens in the country, people keep going across. Yes, sir. You don't learn. You suffer when you go out to the state. Isn't it? Yes, sir. I will tell you some examples, sir. When Molayamsa was the chief minister, he didn't want the children to learn English in the former school. His son was in the way of school. He studied in Australia. For your son, in the US and all, you don't want the poor people's children to study there. So, this is what the politicians do in this country. Sir, it is there, sir. So, what is in the common interest of the public? We should think of that. And another point, which I would like to... I work in the northeast, south-state. Hindi is not being taught by the government. Hindi is being taught by the media. Every person on the borders will go to Meghalaya, go to Osama. They speak Hindi fluently, only for the television and movies. So, media has... mass media has cut across all those boundaries and... nowhere within the control of the government. Is that a problem? Number one, number two, the mass media. Can you...very well done? So, we can close up. Okay. Sir? Yes, sir. Sir... Sir... Sir, it's not like that, sir. When I face one question which I haven't prepared or which I haven't thought process, then I will start to jitter. I couldn't find a word. I started to paraprise. So, when I can use with thumb, at least have it in my mind that then I'm okay with everything. So, that gives some space, sir. So, I thought of... I have put it in. I have done general studies also in Tamil. So, I think more connect... German has to permit. Sir? UPSC, German has to permit it. Yes, sir. It all relates to the German. Yes, sir. If he or she agrees. Yes, sir. And we do have interpreter in... You have written that in writing. Yes, sir. I have given, sir. And when Sir said like why I face second option, you said my first option is IAS. Like that is like your pain-ridden IAS. Like whether they have the good things about IAS, rather than saying if I don't IAS, then I'll be like IAS, like that. Yes, sir. Technical knowledge, how it will fit in. As an engineer, how we will bring technological application and the policy. So, you don't have to criticize any service. I am from the IAS. I am not touched on the service hangout. Isn't it? You talk to a person or friends, somebody from IAS, someone from the service. We are not here to criticize any service. You put up the points properly. But that... It's trapping. Why I ask that question? It has to trap you. Okay, sir. There may be. I was trying to come in. I was doing this. Can you think of that? Okay, sir. What is the rest of the public? We should only do that. That's... Second is, I was asking about the extent. I was asked to do so. You know that the extra load is there. So, they can carry 15 tons, 10 tons. This bugger was carrying 25 tons. There's one. Overload. He started coaching for the times. He was in Kerala. He has crossed the valley of ordering, but he was not caught. This is all right. We have three places in the country. I knew it. High star was correct. Nobody checks the weight. Even if you apply the weight, it will tilt. Overloading. And when I talk to a graph operator, the height of the case is coming in Kerala. It's a big problem. It's not a big problem. It's not a big problem. It's not a big problem. It's not a big problem. It's not a big problem. It's not a big problem. It's basically the connection. No, of course. But you always talk about education. Awareness. Awareness is not awareness. It's a specter. The corruption in the departments and all. What we have to do is the technology. The vehicle crossing from Tamil Nadu to Kerala, Kerala automatically gets checked. How much the weight? No human interface. That's what we are trying to do in Kerala. There's no human interface at all. Right from the originating point, everywhere he gets checked. In the U.S. and all, you cannot drive for more than eight hours. The police will take the keys. Our key is in the U.S. It is electronically regulated. They will take the key. If they detects, they don't find. And they will give the key exactly after eight hours. So that is the system we have to follow. Sir, yesterday's thing to edictorial. Have you read that? Yes, sir. Detailed one. Yes, sir. Talks about the overall picture. How the World Bank says that around over $109 billion needed to at least minimize the days of India. Let's go through that. Okay, sir. The layman's discipline is not there. Non-enforcement is there. Public. Same thing is followed. They don't follow anything. Isn't it? It is enforcement. With enforcement is a crux. Not happening in this country. Unfortunately. Public feels that I am wearing helmet for the police. Not for the helmet. It's for your family. Your safety. Own safety. That has to be driven. Anything else, sir? Yes. When you are answering to some, look at it. Look at it. There are several times you are looking at it. You are not at least. To the channel. Okay, sir. That is a round table. Okay, sir. Very UPS you will be sitting in. It's not like this. It will be round table. And someone is asking questions. Look at him, but turn your eyeballs around. All around. Isn't it? Okay. And try to slide. Little more. Okay. You don't have to be tense. He is normal. If you don't answer any questions. Okay, sir. Somebody would like to know about it. He may not. His mother cannot be Tamil. So he finds it difficult. And he wants to know what it is. What it is. And it should not turn to your receptionist. And your receptionist. Very good. Better than mine. Good. Okay, sir. Okay, sir. Okay, sir. Okay, sir. Okay, sir. Okay, sir. All five members will be able to understand. Somebody is from North is their member. Sir. He may not understand. He will be doing colloquial Hindi. Sir. He will not know that colloquial thing. So he may not understand. When is it? So March 3, sir. March 3. 3. Coming 3. March 3. Just brush up something on the ground survey today. Rona Mahadev student. And now Mr. Trump is coming to the committee. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. What? We are relation for last 15 years in the day. 9, 11 and all the published. Okay, sir. Then you need to learn what to see and learn. Yes, sir. Then what kind of knowledge do we have? There should be a way to understand. Towards. Yes, sir. What kind of knowledge do we have? Please understand. Like when it comes to journalism and all. Masood Azhar. Masood Azhar. Masood Azhar. Yes, sir. They help you with this. All these things. And what we can get out of that. Then GSB. Okay, sir. GSB. Six million worth of Indian exports impacted by the accident. So just brush up a little what we expected from this. It may be happening in the next two days. Okay, sir. To that historical. Okay, sir. They may ask that. Okay, sir. Why they have chosen Ahmedabad? Every president they want to bring to Ahmedabad. Why not with Chennai? It's another question. I do feel that maybe the Prime Minister connected with his own talk. The Prime Minister is for the country. He's not from Gujarat. Prime Minister of India. Not Gujarat. He experienced in the interview that Prime Minister is pro-Gujarat. Like that he cannot. Yes, sir. He cannot say that. Prime Minister is for India. Generally avoid any political issues. One thing is clear. Isn't it? Yes, sir. You have to be non-partisan. Just I'm giving food for thought. Okay, sir. Why, like, bullet train goes to only Ahmedabad from Mumbai. Chinese president only comes there. US president comes only there. Why not he goes to other states? I'll read a book. Think of that. Don't talk in the interview. Historical significance of Ahmedabad is a city. Starting from Gandhiji. Ahmedabad is a technological hub. Yes, sir. Knowledge hub. Other of the nation and the Mahatma Gandhi. Indian Institute of Management. You want to vision like that. Isn't it? Yes, sir. Something about that CAA. NPRCAA. What the issue? And without taking sides and all, I don't know if it's all been discussed. What is the actual rules there? Yes, Blashak. Okay, sir. What do you... The hesitation is going on in Chennai now. Yes, sir. Last three... Massaman, sir. Massaman, sir. Yes, sir. Ten days. What do you stand on that? Isn't it? Matter is before the honorable Supreme Court. We are going to move the process forward. Judicial degree. What do judicial degree? What do the government do? Budget. Budget is just presented. Yes, sir. Not even a month. Two thousand twenty budget. Budget highlights. Yes, sir. Definitely. There's something about hobby and all that, I ask you. Oscar avoid. Yes, sir. You can say short stories have like very subtle message it conveys in a very easy way. So, you prefer short stories because of that. Usually it covers social issues. Yes, sir. Novels are like say an incident like that. I mean a life or something or a ten-way thriller like that. He can answer anything. Sir, but when it comes to... No, what happened? It will satisfy the body. Five members, everybody will be satisfied. It is the widely spoken language in India. You can say it is the national language, everybody will understand. More than average... When you are replying to Sarangi sir, I am from Bangal. But I know Thakur having spent my whole life here. He is not aware. So, tell me you may meet somebody, may be supporting you. Sir, when I... I cannot be able to support you because he has not understood your reply. Sir, the problem comes when one member asks about tell me a short story. They are my transfers and course... They are rarely used. You are doing very well in English. You can be both. If somebody understands Tamil, Tamil is the problem. Otherwise, one member has to translate the interpreter what translation he will give you. Okay sir, I will... I will do... You got only around one week time. Just brush up. Go in time. Now weather is very nice. You are less than appropriate. Okay sir. And the small thing, when an Indian is getting an oil price, read a little more about it. The basics. You can't put the details. The basics. Okay. And since the member asked and adjusted across the venue, the problem started in October. Supreme Court first rejected the calculation of the telcos. Then only they are telling now that you pay like this. But the problem started there. So, what are the other things that Supreme Court accepted the department's definition of adjusted across the venue? You have to go historically. Before 1999, it was basically licensed. When Prabhupada Mahaja was there, before the election, they come to Revenue Sharing. They never shared the revenue. Yes sir. They spewed out the revenue. What was the cost to the revenue? AGR from the government side, it includes foreign exchange companies. How many things are there? So, they said, could not pay. They didn't pay. It's not a question. Could not pay. They didn't pay because matter is pending before the court. It's the way the companies do. They drag it and all. Now they have to pay. Huge money. They should provide for that. In case they lose the wetland and all, they have to pay to the government. They should keep the money separate. Now they cannot say that I don't have the money and all. That you have to do. So, you go to the historical, this thing. Not only the volume, what exactly is happening because they didn't pay. They didn't pay. The attempt was waiting for the relief from the Supreme Court. High Court and all those things. Now they have to pay. First one, licensing. Then comes Revenue Sharing. Then Revenue Sharing they dispute about the AGR and all. Our calculation, their calculation. What is revenue? So, you just go through that. Sure sir. So, otherwise, it's very good. I don't have much to add. Yes sir. Gohan just referred to historical perspective. The president came here. This is something he was. Yes sir. He was here, I know, but I thought of ants in history. So, Why we chose the Mahabalipuram was the historical reason was that. Okay sir. You can link it with me. Okay sir. So, that's all. You will do well. All the best. All the best. Thank you sir. Thank you sir. What is that? Why? It's a distance. Okay sir. Mike sir. Don't carry anything. You can see what is not. They won't give sir. Thank you sir.