 So I have another eye shadow palette review today. I picked up the Too Faced Pumpkin Spice Second Slice eye shadow palette and I'm smirking because I'm the first person to make fun of Too Faced for the various things that they do the amount of times that they Literally replicate their own palettes every single year, but jokes on me because I buy them every single year So Too Faced I believe this is their holiday palette though I can't be too sure. I just feel like you know, they've already announced their holiday collection But they always have like one key palette for the holiday season and I think this is it I think they tried to change it up. It's just weird timing because they Literally it just launched the better than chocolate palette, which I kind of assumed was their holiday palette But alas it is not I guess so anyways I was a little extra curious about this palette because I did pick up the better than chocolate palette and honestly Not the biggest fan of it. I thought the shadows were dry and really inconsistent So I was like well, let me let me try this you can pick it up right now I believe on Too Faced and I got mine from Ulta.com. It's $54 so she ain't cheap I'm just saying they tell you online that you need to sit back Relax and make room in your makeup bag because Too Faced is serving up seconds of their best-selling Pumpkin pie inspired eyeshadow palette with pumpkin spice second slice So it is actually the second version of the pumpkin spice palette, which legitimately you guys this is one of my favorite holiday palettes from them ever and This one refreshed me to keep coming back for more because of how much I love this one And I've got to say looking at this compared to the new second slice palette I mean there is resemblance because all of Too Faced palettes look the same But I feel like they took five steps forward with the pumpkin spice palette And so they came out with a second edition because hey everybody loved it and they just went back those five steps But we'll get into it I'll do comparisons with all the other palettes towards the end if you are curious But we're gonna look at this palette itself today. I'm doing two looks I already filmed one So I kind of already have my thoughts, but let's get into the greater details. Shall we so here's what the palette comes in What's different about it compared to the normal? I guess in previous year's palettes is that this one is cardboard They normally come in this tin packaging for this holiday edition kind of packaging So I think it cheapens it a little bit, but I also don't really care You know, I'm not bothered by packaging like this the palette itself is bulk made in the USA and then assembled in the Dominican Republic and it has a Undisclosed shelf life. Let me check the box. I can't find the shelf life on here. It's probably like 12 months That's normally what they are and just in case you're wondering about products made in the old pumpkin spice It was also made in US assembled in the DR lights are low. Let's take a look at the colors in here I mean all around it is a beautiful Neutral fall palette leans warm gonna be a great palette for the holidays, which is always the intention with these launches You know, it's not a unique color story If you've been purchasing these palettes in the past or any kind of neutral palette if we're being honest Here's how we're looking. I mean, it's a pretty wearable palette with the exception of these two shades Too face always has to have like two purple shades in here and then like a pop So there always is gonna be a pop in their palettes So you have that here. There is nothing different about this palette from the other palettes you guys I will talk my issue though because I still think it is very very pretty this palette also is supposed to be pie scented It's very very subtle too face has been doing that a lot recently in their scented palettes back in the day Their fragrance palettes were like overwhelming, but I liked it You know, I really like opening up the palette and smelling pumpkin very subtle this time around which I think a lot Of you will appreciate. Okay. Let's get swatching. I've swatched this palette. I can tell you you guys I'm happy with it. So I'm just gonna swatch down like this Here are the four shades whip it good squash it see they're good and toast it nice and Sips it hooray. These two are kind of close. No everything nice second helping crust issues. I like that name and Serving looks the mats are swatching beautifully. Let's see Scary spiced Cutie pie. This is like a satin shade one more bite And then this one's always interesting whenever they come out with the color fall feels But honestly when they've come out this color in the past, it was normally pretty crumbly This is an upgrade if you ask me. Okay, pick up the patches my favorite looks wise Swash did not deliver though That's actually pretty then we have Cinephal get back on there. So there is a powdery element as you can see thankful Which you'll see me apply in one of the tutorials and this shanks interesting more, please It's a very glittery packed black, but you can see in the swatch You lose a lot of the glitters last two shades spice tackler and Eyes on the pies. So here's the mix here. I like that. There's a lot of mats to work with here There's a couple like three or four key shimmers a few satins, but overall based on swatches I think it's pretty exciting. They feel very good quality Definitely on the better side of two-faced quality. So I definitely have high hopes for this You know if you were debating between this and the better than chocolate palette I can tell you just by swatch the better than chocolate palette was Disappointing to me and while you can make it work And if you like those brown tones better absolutely like if you want to pick it up, it's not a bad palette It's just not great. It's on the lower side of two-faced quality The swatches on this are noticeably better the formula itself just feels better I think that this is a higher quality Generally speaking so I'm gonna go ahead and do a look and I'll be back just to be clear This is an unofficial tutorial. I'm even putting lashes on. This is what I do just to test shadows I'm gonna start off with everything nice right here, which is like a nice transition tone It's gonna set the under brow. Honestly, it's a little darker So I wouldn't say that this is the best under brow color for me Well, it's fine. It has a hint of warmth would be great if you have like medium skin tone And where I wanted to play with the purples because in previous two-faced palettes, they are the worst So I'm gonna go ahead and start off with scary spice right here We're just kind of like a neutral plum and this is going to be the transition tone just like this Blender out didn't have an issue with that shade and then we have to go into thankful right here like these two or it's so many Two-faced palettes, but thankful is gonna go on the inner half of the crease And it's not as vibrant as it looks in the pan Which for me it's not a bad thing because I feel like it's more muted and wearable But it just depends what angle you are going for, you know What's your taste in makeup and then I'm gonna carry that along the lower lash line as well And then I'm gonna use spice tackler right here, which is a deeper shade Make sure you know since it has that plummy base that it's not going to be splotchy or difficult to blend and honestly It's not just based on what I did with the other eye I thought it was a good shade I find that the mattes aren't running super duper deep But I really don't mind it because they're blending out very very nice and they can be built up having said though They're so quite pigmented as two-faced normally is okay, and then I'm gonna go into fall fields Which is a dark shimmery purple that is usually very messy, but it's really not in this case a lot of times in The past shades like this have literally Crumbled and make the biggest mess look at that. That's actually really nice oddly enough I really like this palette so far I find it interesting that the chocolate bar palette just came out the better than chocolate and I really didn't like the Quality of it and it was in the packaging. That's normally very good But this is in cardboard packaging, which normally is not as good, but it's working really good I'm using a refer brush, and I'm gonna start off with squash it right here, which is the shimmer shape So this shade I noticed while I am applying it with a brush if you're gonna use it with a brush I recommend using a wet brush mine is dry, but I kind of dug in there, so it's still nice. It's a good shimmer Flipping my brush. We're gonna go into one more bite Beautiful and then the final thing that I had to play around with was this black with so many Glitters more please and I wanted to use it as a liner now. I am using a Dry brush still want to make a mess It's not the blackest black, but it doesn't look like the blackest black in the pan either So I don't think that's what they're going for here, and you can kind of see the glitters, but it's not It's not obnoxious. Like I said, I know this look isn't the cutest But I just wanted to play with some shades before I did my actual makeup for today first look so far So good. Let's get on to the second one. All right look number two This is the look that I'm wearing out today So I wanted to use my favorite shades and things that I thought would look great and we have a really beautiful Fall look so I'm gonna go ahead and start off with a sip sip hooray right here This is gonna go ahead and be my transition color now with most of these math They do have a little bit of kick up, but it's not anything alarming whatsoever Literally just tap off your brush and you will be good. The shimmers will create a little bit of mess But again, nothing crazy So that's just a beautiful transition shade to kind of add that initial depth to the look hopping into Crust issues right here. I wanted to see the brightness level here with this shade and you can see it's quite Pigmented it looks like it does in the pan in the first look I felt like the purples didn't quite look on the lid what they did in the pan But when we get more to the warmer shades, they definitely do I just think Too Faced isn't the greatest at creating purple shades, but the neutrals I mean these are great So this is a halo eye if you couldn't tell already and then we're gonna go into it second helping right here and this I just wanted to make sure this looked different from crust issues And it definitely does and it has a lot of brightness and I didn't have any issues in the first look But my experience is even better in the second look like I like this palette and then adding depth We're going into eyes on the pies And just make sure all of the edges are blended out It's actually a good idea to take that very first brush that we used and diffuse everything But do you see how easy this blend is going and then I'm gonna take the teeniest tiniest little bit of more Please I wasn't gonna use this because I used it in the first look But I just felt like we needed that little bit of oomph that little bit of depth and the glitters really aren't even Showing up in this look because I took such a tiny bit and it's not the blackest black as I stated before But it's really great for this a little bit of deepening Then blend it out make it nice and smooth with a refer brush going into cutie pie I wanted to test this because it was one of the least metallic shades in the palette But it definitely is still quite shimmery and it's applying really smooth and the shade like this is good because you're not Gonna get much fallout from it. So it's gonna be pretty mess free I don't need to press too hard in the palette either to get it to show up So this is a nice shade even nicer than I had anticipated and finally I really wanted to try whip it good So we're gonna go ahead and use that and that's just gonna be popped in the center right here again Not messy added that brightness to the center of the eye. This look is so good Okay, I'm gonna go ahead and finish up and I'll be right back here's how the makeup's looking It's looking really good if you're curious about anything else that I'm wearing it'll be linked down below But I wanted to show you how this palette compares to the other two-faced palettes So I'm gonna start off with the original pumpkin palette that this palette is supposed to be inspired from Honestly, this is the pumpkin palette. What made this palette different at the time was it was not quite as brown and warm as The previous two-faced holiday palettes It was a little bit more spunky had more character to it, but it still was like neutral It was my favorite holiday palette that they launched. Here's the second slice palette I just feel like they did the same thing that they had before this palette So everything that we loved about the pumpkin spice palette went away with the second one like I said took five steps back So just keep that in mind. You can see ps and chill with the original pumpkin spice We have thankful that's really close lots of the oranges the mats are pretty much the same You just have prettier colors really in the pumpkin spice So if you can get your hands on the original pumpkin spice, I'd recommend it It's like if you have the pumpkin spice, do you need the second slice? I really like how that sounded I think it's a good palette the quality is very very nice and it's a bit different from the Original pumpkin spice, but they're still very close. This is just warmer now the thing with these is they all look the same I don't even know what came out when but here is the Cinnamon roll palette and here is the upside-down pumpkin second slice palette These look super similar, right? You have the two key purples. Take a look the two key purples Once again, also in this new palette the shimmers are pretty much the same There's just a lighter pink overall the cinnamon is a bit lighter But it definitely don't need both gingerbread spice palette We're getting a little older here if you have them this one has a little bit more pops of purples The shimmers in the gingerbread is a little prettier, but I prefer the gingerbread color store Okay, and then the last one that I have is extra spicy gingerbread. So here's extra spicy gingerbread I mean and this one also is quite similar I think these two might be the most similar in that they just contain so many warm palettes They both lean quite warm that extra spicy gingerbread palette does not have The purply shades, but they have every other shape pretty much So if you have any of the previous palettes, you don't need this one But if you are interested like I am and pick them up every year I'm happy to announce. So I really do enjoy the quality of this. I think overall it is a very nice palette It's better than the better than chocolate palette, which makes me mad because why is Too Faced's quality? Just so inconsistent. Why was that better than chocolate which they made a big deal out of not good quality But this one is good. So anyways, that is why I do continue to review Too Faced palettes to let you know What's up because they can't they can't get consistency down So if you were interested in this it's a good one And it also makes a really great gift if you the makeup watcher have a lot of makeup Maybe get that for somebody who doesn't have so much makeup So I hope you guys enjoyed this review and the tutorials Let me know your thoughts on this palette down below Are you a sucker like me? Do you purchase these every year and I'll catch you guys in the next one. I guess have a good one