 Peyton Manning or Tom Brady that is so tough if you had to pick one Peyton Oh Lord have mercy what are we talking about here like stats or like fantasy if you had a big one Peyton Manning he got a big head the five head over the rings look at his dome he got the touchdown record first he still has the most touchdowns at a season with 55 yeah I just can't argue the fact that Tom Brady is the goat I think even Peyton wouldn't admit that Peyton Manning I don't know what goats are you know to me I don't like the goat term so I'm gonna go with Peyton Manning because I like how Peyton Manning plays the game even though Tom Brady is considered what the best of all time I just love Peyton Manning I love the way he plays the game I gotta go Tom Brady Tom Brady he's a solid quarterback may solid quarterback going Tom Brady I enjoyed Manning more than I do Tom Brady Tom Brady