 The reply by Tambourini et al., 2012 New JPHYS. 14118002, to our previous comment, 2012 New JPHYS. 14118001, on the experiment reported in Tambourini et al., 2012 New JPHYS. 14033001, does not address any of the issues raised in our initial comment. This article was authored by Michel Tamanion, Christophe Cray, and Julian Perus Ocaria.