 Part 1 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll, volume 3, lecture 5, entitled Liberty in Literature, a Testimonial to Walt Whitman. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit us at LibriVox.org. This recording is by Michelle Fry, Baton Rouge, Louisiana, in April 2020. Ingersoll on Walt Whitman, Part 1, let us put wreaths on the brows of the living, an address delivered in Philadelphia, October 21, 1890. In the year 1855, the American people knew but little of books, their ideals, their models were English. Young and Pollock, Edison and Watts were regarded as great poets, some of the more reckless Red Thompson's seasons and the poems and novels of Sir Walter Scott. A few, not quite orthodox, delighted in the mechanical monotony of Pope and the really wicked, those lost to all religious shame, were worshipers of Shakespeare. The really orthodox Protestant, untroubled by doubts, considered Milton the greatest poet of them all. Byron and Shelley were hardly respectable, not to be read by young persons. It was admitted on all hands that Burns was a child of nature of whom his mother was ashamed and proud. In the blessed year aforesaid, candor, free and sincere speech were under the ban. Preeds at that time were entrenched behind statutes, prejudice, custom, ignorance, stupidity, puritanism, and slavery. That is to say, slavery of mind and body. Of course it always has been and forever will be impossible for slavery or any kind or form of injustice to produce a great poet. There are hundreds of verse makers and writers on the side of wrong enemies of progress, but they are not poets. They are not men of genius. At this time a young man, he to whom this testimonial is given, he upon whose head have fallen the snows of more than seventy winters, this man, born within the sound of the sea, gave to the world a book, Leaves of Grass. This book was and is the true transcript of a soul. The man is unmasked. No drapery of hypocrisy. No pretense, no fear. The book was as original in form as in thought. All customs were forgotten or disregarded, all rules broken, nothing mechanical, no imitation, spontaneous, running and winding like a river, multitudinous in its thoughts as the waves of the sea. Nothing mathematical or measured in everything a touch of chaos, lacking what is called form as clouds lack form. But not lacking the splendor of sunrise or the glory of sunset. It was a marvelous collection and aggregation of fragments, hints, suggestions, memories and prophecies, weeds and flowers, clouds and clods, sights and sounds, emotions and passions, waves, shadows and constellations. His book was received by many with disdain, with horror, with indignation and protest. By the few as a marvelous, almost miraculous message to the world, full of thought, philosophy, poetry and music. In the Republic of Mediocrity, genius is dangerous. A great soul appears and fills the world with new and marvelous harmonies. In his words is the old Promethean flame. The heart of nature beats and throbs in his line. The respectable prudes and pedagogues sound the alarm and cry or rather screech. Is this a book for a young person? A poem true to life is a Greek statue, candid as nature, fills these barren souls with fear. They forget that drapery about the perfect was suggested by immodesty. The provincial prudes and others of like mold pretend that love is a duty rather than a passion, a kind of self-denial, not an overmastering joy. They preach the gospel of pretense and pantalettes. In the presence of sincerity, of truth, they cast down their eyes and endeavor to feel immodest. To them the most beautiful thing is hypocrisy, adorned with a blush. They have no idea of an honest, pure passion, glorying in its strength, intense, intoxicated with the beautiful, giving even to inanimate things, pulse and motion, and that transfigures, ennobles and idealizes the object of its adoration. They do not walk the streets of the city of life. They explore the sewers. They stand in the gutters and cry, unclean. They pretend that beauty is a snare, that love is a delilah, that the highway of joy is the broad road, lined with flowers and filled with perfume, leading to the city of eternal sorrow. Since the year 1855 the American people have developed. They are somewhat acquainted with the literature of the world. They have witnessed the most tremendous of revolutions, not only upon the fields of battle but in the world of thought. The American citizen has concluded that it is hardly worthwhile being a sovereign unless he has the right to think for himself. And now, from this height, with the vantage ground of today, I propose to examine this book and to state in a general way what Walt Whitman has done, what he has accomplished, and the place he has won in the world of thought. End of Part 1 Let us put wreaths on the brows of the living. Part 2 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. Ingersoll on Walt Whitman. Part 2 The Religion of the Bahi Walt Whitman stood when he published his book, We're All Stand Tonight, on the perpetually moving line where history ends and prophecy begins. He was full of life to the very tips of his fingers, brave, eager, candid, joyous with health. He was acquainted with the past. He knew something of song and story, of philosophy and art, much of the heroic dead, of brave suffering, of the thoughts of men, the habits of the people, rich as well as poor, familiar with labor, a friend of wind and wave, touched by love and friendship, liking the open road, enjoying the fields and paths, the crags, friend of the forest, feeling that he was free, neither master nor slave, willing that all should know his thoughts, open as the sky, candid as nature, and he gave his thoughts, his dreams, his conclusions, his hopes and his mental portrait to his fellow men. Walt Whitman announced the gospel of the body. He confronted the people. He denied that the poverty of man insisted that love is not a crime, that men and women should be proudly natural, that they need not grovel on the earth and cover their faces for shame. He taught the dignity and glory of the father and mother, the sacredness of maternity. Maternity, tender and pure as the tear of pity, holy as suffering, the crown, the flower, the ecstasy of love. People had been taught from Bibles and from creeds that maternity was a kind of crime, that the woman should be purified by some ceremony and some temple built in honor of some God. This barbarism was attacked in leaves of grass. The glory of simple life was sung, a declaration of independence was made for each and all. And yet this appeal to manhood and to womanhood was misunderstood. It was denounced simply because it was in harmony with the great trend of nature. To me the most obscene word in our language is celibacy. It was not befashioned for people to speak or write their thoughts. We were flooded with the literature of hypocrisy. The writers did not faithfully describe the worlds in which they lived. They endeavored to make a fashionable world. They pretended that the cottage or the hut in which they dwelt was a palace, and they called the little area in which they threw their swaps, their domain, their realm, their empire. They were ashamed of the real of what their world actually was. They imitated it, that is to say they told lies, and these lies filled the literature of most lands. Walt Whitman defended the sacredness of love, the purity of passion, the passion that builds every home and fills the world with art and song. They cried out, he is a defender of passion. He is a libertine. He lives in the mire. He lacks spirituality. Whoever differs with a multitude, especially with a led multitude, that is to say with a multitude of taggers, will find out from their leaders that he is committed an unpardonable sin. It is a crime to travel a road of your own, especially if you put up guide boards for the information of others. Many, many centuries ago at Pecurus, the greatest man of his century, and of many centuries before and after, said, Happiness is the only good. Happiness is the supreme end. This man was temperate, frugal, generous, noble, and yet through all these years he has been denounced by the hypocrites of the world as a mere eater and drinker. It was said that Whitman had exaggerated the importance of love, that he had made too much of this passion. Let me say that no poet, not accepting Shakespeare, has had imagination enough to exaggerate the importance of human love, the passion that contains all heights and all depths, ample a space with a sky in which glitter all constellations and that has within it all storms, all lightnings, all wrecks and ruins, all griefs, all sorrows, all shadows and all the joy and sunshine of which the heart and brain are capable. No writer must be measured by a word or paragraph is to be measured by his work, by the tendency, not of one line, but by the tendency of all. Which way does the great stream tend? Is it for good or evil? Are the modus high and noble or low and infamous? We cannot measure Shakespeare by a few lines, neither can we measure the Bible by a few chapters, nor leaves of grass by a few paragraphs. In each there are many things that I neither approve nor believe, but in all books you will find a mingling of wisdom and foolishness, of prophecies and mistakes, in other words, among the excellencies there will be defects. The mine is not all gold, or all silver, or all diamonds, there are baser metals. The trees of the forest are not all of one size, on some of the highest there are dead and useless limbs, and there may be growing beneath the bushes weeds, and now and then a poison is fine. If I were to edit the great books of the world I might leave out some lines and I might leave out the best. I have no right to make of my brain a sieve and say that only that which passes through belongs to the rest of the human race. I claim the right to choose. I give that right to all. Walt Whitman had the courage to express his thought, a candor to tell the truth, and here let me say it gives me joy, a kind of perfect satisfaction, to look above the bigoted bats, the satisfied owls and wrens and chickadees, and see the great eagle poise circling higher and higher, unconscious of their existence. And it gives me joy, a kind of perfect satisfaction, to look above the petty passions and jealousies of small and respectable people, above the considerations of place and power and reputation, and see a brave, intrepid man. We must be remembered that the American people had separated from the old world, that we had declared not only the independence of colonies, but the independence of the individual. We had done more. We had declared that the state could no longer be ruled by the church, and that the church could not be ruled by the state, and that the individual could not be ruled by the church. These declarations were in danger of being forgotten. We needed a new voice, sonorous, loud and clear, a new poet for America, for the new epoch, something to chant in the morning song of the new day. The great man who gives a true transcript of his mind fascinates and instructs. Most writers suppress individuality. They wish to please the public. They flatter the stupid and pander to the prejudice of their readers. They write for the market, making books as other mechanics make shoes. They have no message. They bear no torch. They are simply the slaves of customers. The books they manufacture are handled by the trade. They are regarded as harmless. The pulpit does not object. The young person can read the monotonous pages without a blush or a thought. On the title pages of these books you will find the imprint of the great publishers. On the rest of the pages, nothing. These books might be prescribed for insomnia. Part 2 The Religion of the Body Part 3 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. Recording by Tommy Hercent, Carlsbad, California. Ingersoll on Walt Whitman, Part 3 The Creative Spirit Men of talent, men of business, touch life upon few sides. They travel but the beaten path. The creative spirit is not in them. They regard with suspicion a poet who touches life on every side. They have little confidence in that divine thing called sympathy. And they do not and cannot understand the man who enters into the hopes, the aims, and the feelings of all others. In all genius there is the touch of chaos, a little of the vagabond and the successful tradesman. The man who buys and sells or manages a bank does not care to deal with a person who has only poems for collaterals. They have a little fear of such people and regard them as the awkward countryman does a sleight of hand performer. In every age in which books have been produced, the governing class, the respectable, have been opposed to the works of real genius. If what are known as the best people could have had their way, if the pulpit had been consulted, the provincial moralists, the works of Shakespeare would have been suppressed, not a line would have reached our time, and the same may be said of every dramatist of his age. If the Scotch Kirk could have decided, nothing would have been known of Robert Burns. If the good people, the Orthodox, could have had their say, not one line of bold terror would now be known. All the plates of the French encyclopedia would have been destroyed, with the thousands that were destroyed. Everything would have been known of D'Alembert, Grimm, Diderot, or any of the Titans who warred against the thrones and altars, and laid the foundation of modern literature not only, but what is a far greater moment, universal education. It is not too much to say that every book now held in high esteem would have been destroyed, if those in authority could have had their will. Every book of modern times that has a real value, that has enlarged the intellectual horizon of mankind, that has developed the brain, that has furnished real food for thought, can be found in the index expurgatorious of the papacy, and nearly every one has been commended to the free minds of men by the denunciations of Protestants. If the guardians of society, the protectors of young persons, could have had their way, we should have known nothing of Byron or Shelley, the voices that thrill the world would now be silent. If authority could have had its way, the world would have been as ignorant now as it was when our ancestors lived in holes, or hung from dead limbs by their prehensile tales. But we are not forced to go very far back. If Shakespeare had been published for the first time now, those divine plays greater than continents and seas, greater even than the constellations of the midnight sky, would be excluded from the males by the decision of the present enlightened postmaster general. The poets have always lived in an ideal world, and that ideal world has always been far better than the real world. As a consequence, they have forever roused not simply the imagination but the energies, the enthusiasm of the human race. The great poets have been on the side of the oppressed, of the downtrodden. They have suffered with the imprisoned and the enslaved, and whenever and wherever man has suffered for the right, wherever the hero has been stricken down, whether on field or scaffold, some man of genius has walked by his side, and some poet has given form and expression not simply to his deeds but to his aspirations. In the Greek and Roman world we still hear the voices of a few. The poets, the philosophers, the artists, and the orators still speak. Countless millions have been covered by the waves of oblivion, but the few who uttered the elemental truths, who had sympathy for the whole human race, and who were great enough to prophecy a grander day are as alive tonight as when they roused by their bodily presence, by their living voices, by their works of art, the enthusiasm of their fellow men. Think of the respectable people, of the men of wealth and position, those who dwelt in mansions, children of success, who went down to the grave voiceless, and whose names we do not know. Think of the vast multitudes, the endless processions that enter the caverns of eternal night, leaving no thought, no truth, as a legacy to mankind. The great poets have sympathized with the people. They have uttered in all ages the human cry, unbought by gold, unawed by power. They have lifted high the torch that illuminates the world. End of Part 3 The Creative Spirit. Part 4 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman, from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll. Ingersoll is in the highest sense a believer in democracy. He knows that there is but one excuse for government, the preservation of liberty, to the end that man may be happy. He knows that there is but one excuse for any institution, secular or religious, the preservation of liberty, and that there is but one excuse for schools, for universal education, for the ascertainment of facts, namely the preservation of liberty. He resents the arrogance and cruelty of power. He has sworn never to be tyrant or slave. He has solemnly declared, I speak the password primeval. I give the sign of democracy. By God I will accept nothing which all cannot have their counterpart of on the same terms. This one declaration covers the entire ground. It is a declaration of independence, and it is also a declaration of justice, that is to say, a declaration of the independence of the individual, and a declaration that all shall be free. The man who has this spirit can truthfully say, I have taken off my hat to nothing, known or unknown. I am for those who have never been mastered. There is in Whitman what he calls the boundless impatience of restraint, together with that sense of justice which compelled him to say, neither a servant nor a master am I. He was wise enough to know that giving others the same rights that he claims for himself could not harm him, and he was great enough to say, as if it were not indispensable to my own rights that others possess the same. He felt as all should feel that the liberty of no man is safe unless the liberty of each is safe. There is in our country a little of the old servile spirit, a little of the bowing and cringing to others. Many Americans do not understand that the officers of the government are simply the servants of the people. Nothing is so demoralizing as the worship of place. Whitman has reminded the people of this country that they are supreme, and he has said to them, the president is there in the White House for you. It is not you who are here for him. The secretaries act in their bureaus for you, not you here for them. Doctrines, policies, and civilizations exerge from you. Sculpture and monuments, and anything inscribed anywhere, are tallied in you. He describes the ideal American citizen, the one who says indifferently and alike, how are you, friend, to the president at his levy, and he says, good day, my brother, to Cudge that hoes in the sugarfield. Long ago, when the politicians were wrong, when the judges were subservient, when the pulpit was a-coward, Walt Whitman shouted, one shall not hold property in man. The least developed person on earth is just as important and sacred to himself or herself as the most developed person is to himself or herself. This is the very soul of true democracy. Beauty is not all there is of poetry. It must contain the truth. It is not simply an oak, rude and grand. Neither is it simply a vine. It is both. Around the oak of truth runs the vine of beauty. Walt Whitman utters the elemental truths and is the poet of democracy. He is also the poet of individuality. End of Part 4, Democracy. Part 5 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman. From the works of Robert D. Ingersoll. This is a LibriVox recording. While LibriVox recordings are in the public domain, for more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. Ingersoll on Walt Whitman. Part 5, Individuality. In order to protect the liberties of a nation, we must protect the individual. A democracy is a nation of free individuals. The individuals are not to be sacrificed to the nation. The nation exists only for the purpose of guarding and protecting the individuality of men and women. Walt Whitman has told us that the whole theory of the universe is directed unerringly to one single individual, namely to you. And he has also told us that the greatest city, the greatest nation, is where the citizen is always the head-end ideal. And that a great city is that which has the greatest men and women. If it be a few ragged huts, it is still the greatest city in the whole world. By this test may be the greatest city on the continent tonight is Camden. This poet has asked of us this question. What do you suppose will satisfy the soul except to walk free and own no superior? The man who asks this question has left no impress of his lips in the dust and has no dirt upon his knees. He was great enough to say, the soul has that measureless pride which revolts from every lesson but its own. He carries the idea of individuality to its utmost height. What do you suppose I would intimate to you in a hundred ways but that man or woman is as good as God and that there is no God any more divine than yourself? Glorying in individuality? In the freedom of the soul? He cries out, oh, to struggle against great odds, to meet enemies undaunted, to be entirely alone with them, to find how much one can stand, to look strife, torture, prison, popular odium, face to face, to mount the scaffold, to advance to the muzzles of guns with perfect nonchalance, to indeed be a God. And again, oh, the joy of a manly selfhood, to be servile to none, to defer to none, not to any tyrant known or unknown, to walk with erect carriage, to step springy and elastic, to look with calm gaze or with flashing eye, to speak with full and sonorous voice out of a broad chest, to confront with your personality, all the other personalities of the earth. Walt Whitman is willing to stand alone. He is sufficient unto himself. And he says, henceforth I ask not good fortune. I myself am good fortune, strong and content. I travel the open road. He is one of those that look carelessly in the faces of presidents and governors as to say, who are you? And not only this, but he has the courage to say, nothing, not God, is greater to one than oneself. Walt Whitman is the poet of individuality, the defender of the rights of each for the sake of all. And his sympathies are as wide as the world. He is the defender of the whole race. End of Part 5. Part 6 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman. In the works of Robert G. Ingersoll. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. Ingersoll on Walt Whitman. Part 6, Humanity. The great poet is intensely human, infinitely sympathetic, entering into the joys and griefs of others, bearing their burdens, knowing their sorrows. Brain without heart is not much. They must act together. When the respectable people of the North, the rich, the successful, were willing to carry out the fugitive slave law, Walt Whitman said, I am the hounded slave. I wince at the bite of the dogs. Hell and despair are upon me. Crack and again crack the marksmen. I clutch the rails of the fence. My gore dribs, thinned with the ooze of my skin. I fall on the weeds and stones. The riders spur their unwilling horses, haul close, taunt my dizzy ears, and beat me violently over the head with whip stocks. Agnes are one of my changes of garments. I do not ask the wounded person how he feels. I myself become the wounded person. I see myself in prison, shaped like another man, and feel the dull, unintermitted pain. For me, the keepers of convicts, shoulder their carbines and keep watch. It is I let out in the morning and barred at night. Not a mutineer walks handcuffed to jail, but I am handcuffed to him, and walk by his side. Judge not as the judge judges, but as the sun falling upon a helpless thing. Of the very worst, he had the infinite tenderness to say, Not until the sun excludes you, will I exclude you. In this age of greed, when houses and lands and stocks and bonds outrank human life. In gold is of more value than blood. These words should be read by all. When the psalm sings instead of the singer. When the script preaches instead of the preacher. When the pulpit descends and goes instead of the carver that carved the supporting desk. When I can touch the body of books by day or night, and when they touch my body back again. When a university course convinces like a slumbering woman and child convents. When the minted gold in the vault smiles like the night watchman's daughter. When warranted deeds loaf in chairs opposite and are my friendly companions. I intend to reach them my hand and make as much of them as I do of men and women like you. Part 7 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. Recording by Tommy Hursant, Carlsbad, California. Ingersoll on Walt Whitman, Part 7, The Artist. The poet is also a painter, a sculptor. He, too, deals in form and color. The great poet is of necessity a great artist. With a few words he creates pictures, filling his canvas with living men and women, with those who feel and speak. Have you ever read the account of the Stage Driver's Funeral? Let me read it. Old dash of waves at the fairy wharf, posh and ice in the river, half frozen mud in the streets, a gray discouraged sky overhead, the short last daylight of December, a hearse and stages, the funeral of an old Broadway Stage Driver, the cortege mostly drivers. Steady the trot to the cemetery, duly rattles the death bell, the gate is past, the new dug grave is halted at, the living alight, the hearse uncloses. The coffin is passed out, lowered and settled, the whip is laid on the coffin, the earth is swiftly shoveled in, the mound above is flattered with spades. Silence. A minute. No one moves or speaks. It is done. He is decently put away. Is there anything more? He was a good fellow, free-mouthed, quick-tempered, not bad-looking, ready for life or death for a friend, fond of women, gambled, ate-hardy, drank-hardy, had known what it was to be flush, grew low-spirited toward the last, sickened, was helped by a contribution, died, aged forty-one years. And that was his funeral. Let me read you another description, one of a woman. Behold a woman. She looks out from her Quaker cap, her face is clearer and more beautiful than the sky. She sits in an arm-chair under the shaded porch of the farmhouse. The sun just shines on her old white head. Her ample gown is of cream-hued linen. Her grandsons raised the flax and her granddaughters spun it with a distaff and the wheel. The melodious character of the earth. The finish beyond which philosophy cannot go and does not wish to go. The justified mother of men. Would you hear of an old-time sea-fight? Would you learn who won by the light of the moon and stars? Next to the yarn, as my grandmother's father the sailor told it to me. Our foe was no skulk in his ship, I tell you, said he. His was the surly English pluck, and there is no tougher or truer, and never was, and never will be. Along the lowered eave he came horribly raking us. We closed with him, the yards entangled, the cannon touched. My captain lashed fast with his own hands. We had received some eighteen pound shots under the water. On our lower gun-deck two large pieces had burst at the first fire, killing all around and blowing up overhead. Fighting at sundown, fighting at dark, ten o'clock at night, the full moon, well up, our leaks on the gain, and five feet of water reported. The master at arms, loosing the prisoners confined in the after-hold to give them a chance for themselves. The transit to and from the magazine is now stopped by the sentinels. They see so many strange faces they do not know whom to trust. Our frigate takes fire, the other asks if we demand quarter, if our colors are struck in the fighting done. Now I laugh content, for I hear the voice of my little captain. We have not struck, he compositely cries. We have just begun our part of the fighting. Only three guns are in use. One is directed by the captain himself against the enemy's main mast. Two well-served with grape and canister, silence his musketry and clear his decks. The tops alone second to the fire of this little battery, especially the main top. They hold out bravely during the whole of the action. Not a moment's cease. The leaks gain fast on the pumps. The fire eats torward the powder magazines. One of the pumps has been shot away. It is generally thought we are sinking. Serene stands the little captain. He is not hurried. His voice is neither high nor low. His eyes give more light to us than our battle-lanterns. Toward twelve there is the beams of the moon, the surrender to us. Stretched and still lies the midnight. Two great hulls motionless on the breast of the darkness. Our vessel riddled and slowly sinking. Preparations to pass to the one we have conquered. The captain on the quarter-deck, coldly giving his orders through a countenance white as a sheet. Nearby the corpse of the child that served in the cabin. The dead face of an old salt with long, white hair and carefully curled whiskers. The flames spite of all that can be done, flickering aloft and below. The husky voices of the two or three officers yet fit for duty. Formless stacks of bodies and bodies by themselves. Dabs of flesh upon the masts and spars. Lot of cordage, dangle of rigging, slight shock of the sooth of waves. Black and impassive guns, litter of powder parcels, strong scent. A few large stars overhead, silent and mournful shining. Delicate sniffs of sea breeze, smells of sedgy grass and fields by the shore. Death messages given in charge to survivors. The hiss of the surgeon's knife, the gnawing teeth of his saw, whiz, clucks, swash of falling blood, short, wild scream and long, dull, tapering groan. Some people say that this is not poetry, that it lacks measure and rhyme. Part 8 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll, volume 3, lecture 5. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox.org. This recording is by Michelle Fry, Benton Ridge, Louisiana in April 2020. Ingersoll on Walt Whitman, part 8. What is poetry? The whole world is engaged in the invisible commerce of thought. That is to say, in the exchange of thoughts by words, symbols, sounds, colors and forms. The motions of the silent invisible world where feeling glows and thought flames that contains all seeds of action are made known only by the sounds and colors, forms, objects, relations, uses and qualities so that the visible universe is a dictionary and aggregation of symbols by which and through which is carried on the invisible commerce of thought. Each object is capable of many meanings or of being used in many ways to convey ideas or states of feeling or of facts that take place in the world of the brain. The greatest poet is the one who selects the best, the most appropriate symbols to convey the best, the highest, the sublimest thoughts. Each man occupies a world of his own. He is the only citizen of his world. He is subject and sovereign and the best he can do is to give the facts concerning the world in which he lives to the citizens of other worlds. No two of these worlds are alike. They are of all kinds from the flat, barren and uninteresting, from the small and shriveled and worthless to those whose rivers and mountains and seas and constellations belittle and cheapen the visible world. The inhabitants of these marvelous worlds have been the singers of songs, utterers of great speech, the creators of art and here lies the difference between creators and imitators. The creator tells what passes in his own world. The imitator does not. The imitator abdicates and by the fact of imitation falls upon his knees. He is like one who hearing a traveler talk pretends to others that he has traveled. In nearly all lands the poet has been privileged for the sake of beauty they have allowed him to speak and for that reason he has told the story of the oppressed and has excited the indignation of honest men and even the pity of tyrants. He above all others has added to the intellectual beauty of the world. He has been the true creator of language and has left his impress on mankind. What I have said is not only true of poetry it is true of all speech. All are compelled to use the visible world as a dictionary. Words have been invented and are being invented for the reason that new powers are found in the old symbols new qualities relations uses and meanings. The growth of language is necessary on account of the development of the human mind. The savage needs but few symbols the civilized many the poet most of all. The old idea was however that the poet must be a rhymer. Before printing was known it was said the rhyme assists the memory. That excuse no longer exists. Is rhyme a necessary part of poetry? In my judgment rhyme is a hindrance to expression. The rhymer is compelled to wander from his subject to say more or less than he means to introduce irrelevant matter that interferes continually with the dramatic action and is a perpetual obstruction to sincere utterance. All forms of necessity must be short. The highly and purely poetic is the sudden bursting into blossom of a great and tender thought. The planting of the seed the growth the bud and flower must be rapid. The spring must be quick and warm the soil perfect the sunshine and rain enough everything should tend to hasten nothing to delay. In poetry as in wit the crystallization must be sudden. The greatest poems are rhythmical. While rhyme is a hindrance rhythm seems to be the comrade of the poetic. Rhythm has a natural foundation. Under emotion the blood rises and falls the muscles contract and relax and this action of the blood is as rhythmical as the rise and fall of the sea. In the highest form of expression the thought should be in harmony with this natural ebb and flow. The highest poetical truth is expressed in rhythmical form. I have sometimes thought that an idea selects its own words chooses its own garments and that when the thought has possession absolutely of the speaker or the writer he unconsciously allows the thought to clothe itself. The great poetry of the world keeps time with the winds and the waves. I do not mean by rhythm a recurring accent at accurately measured intervals. Perfect time is the death of music. There should always be room for eager haste and delicious delay and whatever change there may be in the rhythm or time the action itself should suggest perfect freedom. A word more about rhythm. I believe that certain feelings and passions joy grief emulation revenge produce certain molecular movements in the brain that every thought is accompanied by certain physical phenomena. Now it may be that certain sounds colors and forms produce the same molecular action in the brain that accompanies certain feelings and that these sounds colors and forms produce first the molecular movements and these in their turn reproduce the feelings emotions and states of mind capable of producing the same or like molecular movements so that what we call heroic music produces the same molecular action in the brain the same physical changes that are produced by the real feeling of heroism that the sounds we call plaintive produce the same molecular movement in the brain that grief or the twilight of grief actually produces. There may be a rhythmical molecular movement belonging to each state of mind that accompanies each thought or passion and it may be that music or painting or sculpture produces the same state of mind or feeling that produces the music or painting or sculpture by producing the same molecular movements. All arts are born of the same spirit and express like thoughts in different ways that is to say they produce like states of mind and feeling the sculptor the painter the composer the poet the orator work to the same end with different materials the painter expresses through form and color and relation the sculptor through form and relation the poet also paints in chisels his words give form relation and color his statues and his paintings do not crumble neither do they fade nor will they as long as language endures the composer touches the passions produces the very states of feeling produced by the painter and sculptor the poet and orator in all these there must be rhythm that is to say proportion that is to say harmony melody so that the greatest poet is the one who idealizes the common who gives new meanings to old symbols who transfigures the ordinary things of life he must deal with the hopes and fears and with the experiences of the people the poetic is not the exceptional the perfect poem is like a perfect day it has the undefinable charm of naturalness and ease it must not appear to be the result of great labor we feel in spite of ourselves that man does best that which he does easiest the great poet is the instrumentality not always of his time but of the best of his time and he must be in unison and accord with the ideals of his race the sublimer he is the simpler he is the thoughts of the people must be clad in the garments of feeling the words must be known apt familiar the height must be in the thought in the sympathy in olden times they used to have mayday parties and the prettiest child was crowned queen of may imagine an old blacksmith and his wife looking at their little daughter clad in white and crowned with roses they would wonder while they looked at her how they ever came to have so beautiful a child it is thus that the poet clothes the intellectual children or the ideals of the people they must not be gemmed and garlanded beyond the recognition of their parents out from all the flowers and beauty must look the eyes of the child they know we have grown tired of gods and goddesses in art Milton's heavenly militia excites our laughter lighthouses have driven sirens from the dangerous coasts we have found that we do not depend on the imagination for wonders there are millions of miracles under our feet nothing can be more marvelous than the common and everyday facts of life the phantoms have been cast aside men and women are enough for men and women in their lives is all the tragedy and all the comedy that they can comprehend the painter no longer crowds his canvas with the winged and impossible he paints life as he sees it people as he knows them and in whom he is interested the angelus the perfection of pathos is nothing but two peasants bending their heads in thankfulness as they hear the solemn sound of the distant bell two peasants who have nothing to be thankful for nothing but weariness and want nothing but the crusts that they soften with their tears nothing and yet as you look at that picture you feel that they have something besides to be thankful for that they have life love and hope and so the distant bell makes music in their simple horns end of part eight what is poetry part nine of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll volume three lecture five this is a LibriVox recording all LibriVox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit LibriVox.org recording by Brian Levine Burbank California Ingersoll on Walt Whitman part nine religion the attitude of Whitman toward religion has not been understood toward all forms of worship toward all creeds he's maintained the attitude of absolute fairness he does not believe that nature has given her last message to man he does not believe that all has been ascertained he denies that any sect has written down the entire truth he believes in progress and so believing he says quote we consider bibles and religions divine i do not say they are not divine i say they have all grown out of you and may grow out of you still it is not they who give the life it is you who give the life end quote quote his the poet's thoughts are the hymns of the praise of things in the dispute on god and eternity he is silent end quote quote have you thought there could be but a single supreme there could be any number of superims one does not counter veil another any more than one eyesight to counter veils another end quote upon the great questions as to the great problems he feels only the serenity of a great and well-poised soul quote no array of terms can say how much i am at peace about god and about death i hear and behold god in every object yet understand god not in the least nor do i understand who there can be more wonderful than myself in the faces of men and women i see god and in my own face in the glass i find letters from god dropped in the street and everyone is signed by god's name end quote the whole visible world is regarded by him as a revelation and so is the invisible world and with this feeling he writes quote not objecting to special revelations considering a curl of smoke or just a hair on the back of my hand just as curious as any revelation end quote the creeds do not satisfy the old mythologies are not enough they're too narrow at best giving only hints and suggestions and feeling this lack and that which has been written and preached whitman says quote magnifying and applying kamae outbidding at the start the old cautious hucksters taking myself the exact dimensions of jahovah lithographing kronos zeus his son and hercules his grandson buying drafts of osiris isis bellus brahma buddha in my portfolio placing monito loose a la on a leaf the crucifix engraved with odin and the hideous faced mixatilly and every idol and image taking them all for what they're worth and not a cent more end quote whitman keeps open house he is intellectually hospitable he extends his hand to a new idea he does not accept a creed because it has wrinkled and old and has a long white beard he knows that hypocrisy has a venerable look and that it relies on looks and masks on stupidity and fear neither does he reject or accept the new because it is new he wants the truth and so he welcomes all until he knows just who and what they are end of part nine religion part 10 of ingersoll on walt whitman from the works of robert g ingersoll volume three lecture five entitled liberty in literature a testimonial to walt whitman this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox.org ingersoll on walt whitman part 10 philosophy walt whitman is a philosopher the more a man has thought the more he has studied the more he has traveled intellectually the less certain he is only the very ignorant are perfectly satisfied that they know to the common man the great problems are easy he has no trouble in accounting for the universe he can tell you the origin and destiny of man and the why and the wherefore of things as a rule he is a believer in special providence and is egotistical enough to suppose that everything that happens in the universe happens in reference to him a colony of red ants lived at the foot of the alps it happened one day that an avalanche destroyed the hill and one of the ants was heard to remark who could have taken so much trouble to destroy our home walt whitman walked by the side of the sea where the fierce old mother endlessly cries for her castaways and endeavored to think out to fathom the mystery of being and he said i too but signify at the utmost a little washed up drift a few sands and dead leaves to gather gather and merge myself as part of the sands and drift aware now that amid all that blab whose echoes recoil upon me i have not once had the least idea who or what i am but that before all my arrogant poems the real me stands yet untouched untold altogether unreached withdrawn far mocking me with mock congratulatory signs and bows with peals of distant ironical laughter at every word i have written pointing in silence to these songs and then to the sand beneath i perceive i have not really understood anything not a single object and that no man ever can there is in our language no profounder poem than the one entitled elemental drifts the effort to find the origin has ever been and will forever be fruitless those who endeavor to find the secret of life resemble a man looking in the mirror who thinks that if only he could be quick enough he could grasp the image that he sees behind the glass the latest word of this poet upon this subject is as follows to me this life with all its realities and functions is finally a mystery the real something yet to be evolved and the stamp and shape and life here somehow giving an important perhaps the main outline to something further somehow this hangs over everything else and stands behind it is inside of all facts and the concrete and material and the worldly affairs of life and sense that is the purport and meaning behind all the other meanings of leaves of grass as a matter of fact the questions of origin and destiny are beyond the grasp of the human mind we can see a certain distance beyond that everything is indistinct and beyond the indistinct is the unseen in the presence of these mysteries and everything is a mystery so far as origin destiny and nature are concerned the intelligent honest man is compelled to say i do not know in the great midnight a few truths like stars shine on forever and from the brain of man come a few struggling gleams of light a few momentary sparks some have contended that everything is spirit others that everything is matter and again others have maintained that a part is matter and a part is spirit some that spirit was first and matter after others that matter was first in spirit after and others that matter and spirit have existed together but none of these people can by any possibility tell what matter is or what spirit is or what the difference is between spirit and matter the materialists look upon the spiritualists is substantially crazy and the spiritualists regard the materialists as low and groveling these spiritualistic people hold matter in contempt but after all matter is quite a mystery you take in your hand a little earth a little dust do you know what it is in this dust you put a seed the rain falls upon it the light strikes it the seed grows it bursts into blossom it produces fruit what is this dust this womb do you understand it is there anything in the wide universe more wonderful than this take a grain of sand reduce it to powder take the smallest possible particle look at it with a microscope contemplate its every part for days and it remains the citadel of a secret an impregnable fortress bring all the theologians philosophers and scientists in series ranks against it let them attack on every side with all the arts and arms of thought and force the citadel does not fall over the battlements floats the flag and the victorious secret smiles at the baffled hosts Walt Whitman did not and does not imagine that he has reached the limit the end of the road traveled by the human race he knows that every victory over nature is but the preparation for another battle this truth was in his mind when he said understand me well it is provided in the essence of things that from any fruition of success no matter what shall come forth something to make a greater struggle necessary this is the generalization of all history end of section 10 philosophy part 11 of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll this is a LibriVox recording all LibriVox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit LibriVox.org recording by Tommy Herstant Carlsbad California Ingersoll on Walt Whitman part 11 the two poems there are two of these poems to which I will call special attention the first is entitled a word out of the sea the boy coming out of the rocked cradle wandering over the sands and fields up from the mystic play of shadows out of the patches of briars and blackberries from the memories of birds from the thousand responses of his heart goes back to the sea and his childhood and sings a reminiscence two guests from Alabama two birds build their nest and there were four light green eggs spotted with brown and the two birds sang for joy shine shine shine pour down your warmth great sun while we bask we two together two together winds blow south or winds blow north day come white or night come black home or rivers and mountains from home singing all time minding no time while we two keep together in a little while one of the birds is missed and never appeared again and all through the summer the mate the solitary guest was singing of the loss blow blow blow blow up sea winds along palm nox shore I wait and I wait till you blow my mate to me and the boy that night blending himself with the shadows with bare feet went down to the sea where the white arms out and the breakers were tirelessly tossing listening to the songs and translating the notes and the singing bird called loud and high for the mate wondering what the dusky spot was in the brown and yellow seeing the mate whichever way he looked piercing the woods and the earth with his song hoping that the mate might hear his cry stopping that he might not lose her answer waiting and then crying again here I am and this gentle call is for you do not be deceived by the whistle of the wind those are the shadows and at last crying oh past oh happy life oh songs of joy in the air in the woods over fields loved loved loved loved loved but my mate no more no more with me we two together no more and then the boy understanding the song that had awakened in his breast a thousand songs clearer and louder and more sorrowful than the birds knowing that the cry of unsatisfied love would never again be absent from him thinking then of the destiny of all and asking of the sea the final word and the sea answering delaying not and hurrying not spoke the low delicious word death ever death the next poem one that will live as long as our language entitled when lilacs last in the dooryard bloomed is on the death of lincoln the sweetest wisest soul of all my days and lands one who reads this will never forget the odor of the lilac the lustrous western star and the gray brown bird singing in the pines and cedars in this poem the dramatic unities are perfectly preserved the atmosphere and climate in harmony with every event never will he forget the solemn journey of the coffin through day and night and the great cloud darkening the land nor the pump of in looped flags the processions long and winding the flambos of night the torches flames the silent sea of faces the unbared heads the thousand voices rising strong and solemn the dirges the shuttering organs the tolling bells and the sprig of lilac and then for a moment they will hear the gray brown bird singing in the cedars bashful and tender while the lustrous star lingers in the west and they will remember the pictures hung on the chamber walls to adorn the burial house pictures of spring and farms and homes and the gray smoke lucid and bright and the floods of yellow gold of the gorgeous indolent sinking sun the sweet herbage underfoot the green leaves of the trees prolific the breast of the river with the wind dapple here and there and the varied and ample land and the most excellent sun so calm and haughty the violent and purple mourn with just felt breezes the gentle soft-born measureless light the miracle spreading bathing all the fulfilled noon the coming eve delicious and the welcome night and the stars and then again they will hear the song of the gray brown bird in the limitless dusk amid the cedars and pines again they will remember the star and again the odor of the lilac but most of all the song of the bird translated and becoming the chant for death a chant for death come lovely ensuing death undulate round the world serenely arriving arriving in the day in the night to all to each sooner or later delicate death praise to be the fathomless universe for life and joy and for objects and knowledge curious and for love sweet love but praise praise praise for the sure in winding arms of cool unfolding death dark mother always gliding near with soft feet have none chanted for thee a chant of fullest welcome then i chanted for thee i glorify thee above all i bring thee a song that when thou must indeed come come on falteringly approach strong deliverance when it is so when thou has to taken them i joyously sing the dead lost in the loving floating ocean of thee laved in the flood of thy bliss o death from me to thee glad serenades dances for thee i propose saluting thee adornments and feastings for thee and the sights of the open landscape and the high spread sky are fitting and life and the fields and the huge and thoughtful night the night in silence under many a star the ocean shore and the husky whispering wave whose voice i know and the soul turning to thee o vast and well veiled to death and the body gratefully nestling close to thee over the treetops i float thee a song over the rising and sinking waves over the myriad fields and the prairies wide over the dense packed cities all and the teeming warms and ways i float this carol with joy with joy to thee o death this poem in memory of the sweetest wisest soul of all our days and lands and for whose sake lilac and star and bird entwined will last as long as the memory of lincoln and of part 11 the two poems part 12 of ingersaw on walt whitman from the works of robert g ingersaw this is a liber vox recording all liber vox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit liber vox.org recording by william jones beneath his brings florida ingersaw on walt whitman part 12 old age walt whitman is not only the poet of childhood of youth of manhood but above all of old age he has not been soured by slander or petrified by prejudice neither calumny nor flattery has made him vengeful or arrogant now sitting by the fireside in the winter of life his jockened heart still beating in his breast he is just as brave and calm and kind as in his manhood's proudest days when roses blossomed in his cheeks he has taken life's seven steps now as the gamester might say on velvet he is enjoying old age expanded broad with the haughty breadth of the universe old age flowing free with a delicious nearby freedom of death old age superbly rising welcoming the ineffable aggregation of dying days he is taking the loftiest look at last and before he goes he utters things quote for health the midday sun the impalpable air for life mere life for precious ever lingering memories of you my mother dear you father you brothers sisters friends for all my days not those of peace alone the days of war the same for gentle words caresses gifts from foreign lands for shelter wine and meat for sweet appreciation you distant dim unknown or young or old countless unspecified readers beloved we never met and there shall meet and yet our souls embrace long close and long for beans groups love deeds words books for colors forums for all the brave strong men devoted hearty men who've forward sprung in freedom's help all years all lands for braver stronger more devoted men a special laurel here i go two lives wars chosen ones the canineers have sung and thought the great artillerists the foremost leaders captains of the soul end quote it is a great thing to preach philosophy for a greater to live it the highest philosophy accepts the inevitable with a smile and greets it as though it were desired to be satisfied this is wealth success the real philosopher knows that everything has happened that could have happened consequently he accepts he is glad that he has lived glad that he has had his moment on the stage in this spirit whitman has accepted life quote i shall go forth i shall traverse the states a while but i cannot tell wither or how long perhaps soon someday or night while i am singing my voice will suddenly cease oh book oh chance must all then amount to but this must we barely arrive at this beginning of us and yet it is enough oh so oh so we have positively appeared that is enough end quote yes wolf whitman has appeared he has his place upon the stage the drama is not ended his voice is still heard he is the poet of democracy of all people he is the poet of the body of the soul he has sounded the note of individuality he has given the password primeval he is the poet of humanity of intellectual hospitality he has voiced the aspirations of america and above all he is the poet of love and death how grandly how bravely has he given his thought and how superb is his farewell his leave taking quote after the supper and talk after the day is done as a friend from friends his final withdrawal prolonging goodbye and goodbye with emotional lips repeating so hard for his hand to release those hands no more will they meet no more for communion of sorrow and joy old and young a far stretching journey awaits him to return no more shunning postponing severance seeking to ward off the last word ever so little even at the exit door turning charges superfluous calling back even as he descends the steps something to eke out a minute additional the shadows of nightfall deepening farewells messages lessening dimmer the fourth gore's visage and form soon to be lost for eye in the darkness loath oh so loath to depart close quote and is this all will the fourth gore be lost and forever is death the end over the grave bin's love sobbing and by her side stands hope and whispers we shall meet again before all life is death and after all death is life the falling leaf touched with the hectic flush that testifies of autumn's death is in a subtler sense a prophecy of spring Walt Whitman has dreamed great dreams told great truths and uttered sublime thoughts he has held aloft the torch and bravely led the way as you read the marvelous book or the person called leaves of grass you feel the freedom of the antique world you hear the voices of the morning of the first great singers voices elemental as those of sea and storm the horizon enlarges the heavens grow ample limitations are forgotten the realization of the will the accomplishment of the ideal seem to be within your power obstructions become petty and disappear the chains and bars are broken and the distinctions of cast are lost the soul is in the open air under the blue and stars the flag of nature creams theories and philosophies asked to be examined contradicted reconstructed prejudices disappear superstitions vanished and custom abdicates the sacred places become highways duties and desires class pans and become comrades and friends authority drops the scepter the priest the mitre and the purple falls from kings the inanimate becomes articulate the meanest and humblest things utter speech and the dumb and the voiceless burst into song a feeling of independence takes possession of the soul the body expands the blood flows full and free superiors vanish flattery is a lost art and life becomes rich royal and superb the world becomes a personal possession and the oceans the continents and the constellations belong to you you are the center everything radiates from you and in your veins beats and throbs the pulse of all life you become a rover careless and free you wonder by the shores of all seas and hear the eternal song you feel the silence of the wide forest and stand beneath the intertwined and overarching vows entranced with symphonies of wind and woods you are born on the tides of eager and swift rivers hear the rush and roar of cataracts as they fall beneath the seven huge arch and watch the eagles as they circling soar you traverse gorgeous dark and dim and climb the scarred and threatening cliffs you stand in orchards where the blossoms fall like snow where the birds nest and sing and painted moths make aimless journeys through the happy air you live the lives of those who till the earth and walk amid the perfume fields hear the reapers song and feel the breadth and scope of earth and sky you are in the great cities in the midst of multitudes of the endless processions you are on the wide planes the prairies with hunter and trapper with savage and pioneer and you feel the soft grass yielding under your feet you sail in many ships and breathe the free air of the sea you travel many roads and countless paths you visit palaces and prisons hospitals and courts you pity kings and convicts and your sympathy goes out to all the suffering and insane the oppressed and enslave and even to the infamous you hear the den of labor all the sounds of factory field and forest of all tools instruments and machines you become familiar with men and women of all employment trades and professions with birth and burial with wedding feast and funeral chant you see the cloud and flame of war and you enjoy the ineffable perfect days of peace in this one book in these wondrous leaves of grass you find hints and suggestions touches and fragments of all there is of life that lies between the babe whose rounded cheeks dimple beneath his mother's laughing loving eyes and the old man snow crown who with a smile extends his hand to death we have met tonight to honor ourselves by honoring the author of leaves of grass end of part 12 old age end of Ingersoll on Walt Whitman from the works of Robert G. Ingersoll volume three lecture five titled liberty in literature a testimony to Walt Whitman