 This video was taken from our live at five show over on patron if you would like to come and join us on patron for all The exclusive videos and live shows every day the link is in the description James says would you use would you and he's actually spelt it? Would you take said to be a 12 million personally would take him but only as a squad player definitely think we can do better for a first choice right back Go on give you this one boss. I think he's excellent. I think defensively. He's not great But attacking fullbacks very rarely are great defensively That's well, it depends who we could get if we could if we could get a Young right back who was excellent like Hikini who's just about to finish his two-year loan at Dortmund in the summer Go back to Madrid if he was like available Then he's fantastic whether everything could get him is a different thing But someone like him is a fantastic play right and left both feet really good But I think when you look around I like Max Aaron's at Norwich, but is he better than Sidney be? Don't know a potential he's probably gonna have the potential to because he's a young lad and he's very good So I don't know because the issue that we would have you saying take him as a squad player, which is fine But then I don't see shames Coleman leaving the club in the summer I think she must be a for a guy. I think he'll be like Baines basically He'll be here as a backup So then if you've got Sidney be and she must then what happens with John Jo Kenney we sell John Jo Kenney site Then that's fine if you say in if you say in our right back area is okay It's good enough to challenge for European places and higher up. Then that's fine, isn't it? You don't want to waste money, but you know, there's there is good right backs Around good young ones who could you know the pivot tell you that I think the way to look at him is he does play a lot of games for us He plays more than Coleman and I Don't know maybe with a preseason under his belt with us. I mean not saying he's not fitting stuff But maybe a bit of preseason if the manager think he's got the the hallmarks of what he wants Then he might you always say He's a French right back in the French squad a lot. So for 12 million quid an international right back You already knows how the way we play knows our fans. He's a good. He's a big physical lad There's me from a business point of view. I think it makes sense to bring in someone like that Which someone and then I I personally think that I think there's a thing in the echo today to my John Joe and saying how They're monitoring them all the time They've got you know everything about his nutrition and there's all his stats and everything and they keep an eye on brands is big being over to watch him and I think we mentioned this yesterday. I'd leave him there for another year I I think I think another year in Germany would do him the welder good I really do rather than coming back and do you honestly put it? Well, let's flip the question, right? Do you think John Joe Kenny would be evident start right back next season if he came back? No And if I was John Joe Kenny, I wouldn't come back to ever having been a start and right back for Schelke and go Oh, I'll try and get in the team. I'll be like I Think if we if we look at John Joe Kenny and say, you know what with another 12 months in Germany or 18 months at the moment in Germany he potentially could be our number one right back because of the growth Then fine, do you know what I mean? Then let's do that because we're protecting our investment in them And by then someone might look and go well, you know what by then Seamus Coleman will be 32 We can let him go. Yeah, you know and then it should be then is the one whose place is under threat Yeah, you know what I mean, but I know we're half the problem is half of the problem is the idea of Letting Seamus Coleman go that's half of the problem is like you 32 you're thinking He's still got a couple of he's got another team in him And it's that thing of like he's been an effort player all his career Do you really and I think that's that's like the fear fact that you're always get but then it's the flip side of that and going Well, if you let him go on too long It's it's that thing of people start disliking them. Do you believe he's good enough to be our right back number one right back But the weird thing is I'm still a little bit Skeptical about the city said he'd be being I know he's just a start right back now But I'm still a bit skeptical about him being a start right back And that's the thing was saying isn't it you've got Seamus Coleman and saying is he gonna be a squad member? I still think he is good enough to be a squad member then you've got John Joe and then you've got said to be I think Personally I'd leave John Joe for another year. Hmm. If they truly believe his developments have gone the right way I think another season would do no harm of first team football. Hmm, and then for 12 for 12 million quid, I think said that's you're almost can't leave him there That's low enough. I think we you go 27 that he's worth it's worth a gamble. Yeah, it's not even a gamble. You've had him for a year You know all about him. You know his personality, you know everything about him He seems to love it at everything at this and football has always loved playing so you never but he seems to like it ever You'll probably go into the Euro's as the France second choice right back. I mean, that's a big Accurate the face to his left back and And he's had so far you're five assists this season Probably end up with seven or eight assists and that's good from a right from a right form I Put it this way right and you might look at it slightly different to me, but you know when you see the team and you see Coleman playing at the moment you kind of go So showing your head said the bees Stand right back and I think everyone will let me ask you this then go ahead next season Yeah, would you be happy with him to be our first show? That's the thing though, isn't it? That's the thing and then that what's the knock-on effect of that What is the knock-on effect of him being our of us of being our starting right back? But what I would say is If we decide to spy him Then what we're doing by that is saying to him you can be our starting right back It's up to you. Yeah, but we want more from you whether it be what I've what I've noticed is like Saturday when To me Carlos looked at that game and gone we need to target to her and I don't think Defensively said the bees good enough and I think shame is there's a better fullback at defensively then said the beers So then what you do if you see what what could change completely? This is right. You can't get a very mobile sentiment feel that said even never asked to play defensively is a right back I was thinking about that that's a major bigger issue. That then is a plan. That's a that's your FIFA Chemistry thing isn't it? That's the point is the if you've got I Think that's why Dean hasn't been as good this season Because I honestly don't feel like he goes up as much because there's no gana to cover him. So And he also has not someone in front of me. No, no, but I think if you don't know whether it be Gabam and or whatever, but I think if we get a sentiment feel that who's mobile I think Say the bee doesn't have to worry as much and then then you are looking at your right back Has been an attacker all the time and that might that might play a part in it It's how it all links together. It's what the manager wants what I would say about shape John Joe So sorry as well is I don't think he has been as as an attack and Fullback as much this season because I think she'll could have sort of almost asked him to just play a little bit further back When I say that I mean as an actual right back You know when I've seen them and he might I think I think he taught he was telling me this as well It doesn't tend to get as forward as much like braiding so It's more be safe them or he does still go forward. Yeah, that's his game. Yeah, you took that out of him then it He wouldn't be I don't think he'd be as good. Let us know in the comments Let us know whether you'd have him Yannick has said say the beers an absolute steal of 12 million best core and value Provides European and French international experience. He does get caught out of position But he's guilty moving for quality quality moving forward quality moving I used to work well with the team But that's the thing when you were saying it before that was my first thought was in a midfield That's more more mobility live appeal do it with Trent Alexander on because he can't he's not great defensively They three midfielders one of them will go and sit in and back him up. So Yeah, I think I probably pay him to be honest