 The question is that amendment 1328.1 in the name of Neil Bibby, which seeks to amend motion 1328 in the name of George Adam on setting out a business programme, be agreed and members should cast their votes now. The result of the vote on amendment number 1328.1 in the name of Neil Bibby is yes, 53, no 68, there were no abstentions, the amendment is therefore agreed. The next question is that motion 1328 in the name of George Adam on setting out a business programme, be agreed, members should cast their votes now. The vote is now closed. The result of the vote on motion 1328 in the name of George Adam is yes, 68, no, 53, there were no abstentions, the motion is therefore agreed. The next item of business is consideration of four parliamentary bureau motions, and I ask George Adam on behalf of the parliamentary bureau to move motions 1329 and 1330 on approval of SSIs, 1332 on substitution on committees and 1333 on the office of the clerk. Thank you, Presiding Officer, all moved. Thank you. The questions on these motions will be put at decision time, and there are seven questions to be put as a result of today's business. I remind members that, if the amendment in the name of Graham Day is agreed to, the amendment in the name of Graham Simpson will fall. The first question is that amendment 1300.2 in the name of Graham Day, which seeks to amend motion 1300 in the name of Neil Bibby on ScotRail, be agreed. Are we all agreed? The Parliament is not agreed and members should cast their votes now. The vote is now closed. The result of the vote on amendment 1300.2 in the name of Graham Day is yes, 68, no, 53, there were no abstentions, the amendment is therefore agreed and therefore the amendment in the name of Graham Simpson falls. The next question is that motion 1300 in the name of Neil Bibby, as amended on ScotRail, be agreed. Are we all agreed? The Parliament is not agreed and therefore we will move to a vote and members should cast their votes now. The vote is now closed. I call Sharon Dowie for a point of order. I call Sharon Dowie for a point of order. It's not connected and I would have voted no. Thank you, Ms Dowie. We can record that on your behalf. The result of the vote on motion 1300 in the name of Neil Bibby is yes, 68, no, 53, there were no abstentions and the motion as amended is therefore agreed. The next question is that amendment 1302.3 in the name of Humza Yousaf, which seeks to amend motion 1302 in the name of Jackie Baillie on taking action on the NHS and ambulance crisis, be agreed. Are we all agreed? The Parliament is not agreed and therefore we will move to a vote and members should cast their votes now. The vote is now closed. The result of the vote on amendment number 1302.3 in the name of Neil Bibby is yes, 68, no, 53, there were no abstentions, the amendment is therefore agreed. The next question is that amendment 1302.2 in the name of Sandesh Gulhane, which seeks to amend motion 1302 in the name of Jackie Baillie on taking action on the NHS and ambulance crisis, be agreed. Are we all agreed? The Parliament is not agreed and therefore we will move to a vote and members should cast their votes now. The vote is now closed. I call Siobhan Brown for a point of order. I call Rhoda Grant for a point of order. Thank you, Presiding Officer. I was unable to vote if I had voted, I would have voted yes. Thank you, Ms Grant. We'll ensure that's recorded. I call Michelle Thomson for a point of order. Thank you, Presiding Officer. My connection dropped and I was unable to vote. I would have voted no. Thank you, Ms Thomson. We'll ensure that's recorded. I call Siobhan Brown for a point of order. Regrettably, we're unable to hear from Siobhan Brown. The result of the vote on amendment number 1302.2 in the name of Sandesh Gulhane is yes, 53, no, 67. There were no abstentions. The amendment is therefore not agreed. The next question is that motion 1302 in the name of Jackie Baillie as amended on taking action on the NHS and ambulance crisis be agreed? Are we all agreed? The Parliament is not agreed, therefore we will move to a vote and members should cast their votes now. The vote is now closed. The result of the vote on motion 1302 in the name of Jackie Baillie as amended is yes, 70, no, 51. There were no abstentions. The motion as amended is therefore agreed. I propose to ask a single question on 4 parliamentary bureau motions. Does any member object? No member objects, therefore the final question is that motions 1329, 1330, 1332 and 1333 in the name of George Adam on behalf of the parliamentary bureau be agreed? Are we all agreed? The motion is therefore agreed. That concludes decision time. Once again, noise in this chamber has prevented me from participating in some parts of this afternoon's proceedings. I would like to thank you for continuing to remind members of the barrier that excessive noise causes in the chamber. What I am particularly annoyed at this evening is what I believe to be ableist comments when others are challenged either by myself or comments after you intervene, Presiding Officer. Indeed, when I challenged a member who shall for now remain nameless that I could not hear over their shouting, that was met with a shrug and a comment about others not taking interventions. Could I take this opportunity to remind all in the chamber that it is often your behaviour that is a barrier to others participating and not our impairments? I would be grateful, Presiding Officer, if you could advise on what else can be done. Thank you, Ms Mackay, for your point of order. I am in no doubt that colleagues will have heard your comments, as I have asked frequently. We need to make sure that, although we do not want to debate whether it is to be a silent chamber, colleagues are going to show their appreciation, their disquiet, sometimes their discomfort, their dissatisfaction with other members' comments, but I do think that we could get to a position where we conduct business with courtesy and respect, and that involves ensuring that each and every member in the chamber can hear what is going on. I appreciate that sometimes there will be lively and noisy interludes, but if we could just bear in mind that perhaps we may not all hearing across the chamber may not be the same for each and every member in this chamber, but I would like to get to the position where each and every member in the chamber can hear what is being said at least most of the time. Thank you for your point of order, Ms Mackay.