The results are a little surprising when I swatch the product on my hand but they are completely different when actually used on my eye. I will update this video every 6 months or so and let you know which one is drying out faster.
I bought the MAC eyeliner at my MAC counter in Burlington for $15
I bought the ELF liner at Target in Keene for $3
FTC: I bought all products shown with my own money. No one paid me to make this video or for my opinions.