 So it seems like you know in the realm of equestria only the unicorns have magic, right? But where exactly all the unicorns and Princess Celestia well, she's a pegacorn, but what's the difference there? Well, I mean does it mean that magic comes from horns? Well, Twilight Sparkle did say very specifically magic comes from within It does come from and she talked about all the other kinds of magic that are fake in some way like they're not real magic like Zombies or curses or anything But yet what about that that blue weave it obviously had a magical effect. Well, no, I think that was a biological effect Not a biological effect have done all those things. Why not even including making Apple teeny Yeah, I mean, I mean you've had this like parasites in the real world Sprites that can like, you know, they go in your foot and they make you want to put your foot in water And all sorts of ridiculous stuff like that. All right But what about the mass conversion the fact that it shrunk Apple teeny so I think that it has to be magical I just don't think it's the same kind of magic. I Think it's still it's not magic. I think it's magic, but it's not pony magic I'll give you that but what pony magic is the one that people care about right? So I pony magic has to come from somewhere and while it seems like definitely a horn is a necessary implement Just like a magician needs a wand, right? It doesn't seem to be the actual source of the magic, right? Because I mean episode 2, right? You got the the elements of harmony in four out of six don't have horns true But that was an external force, but they definitely contributed to the magic that did come out of Twilight's horn in some sort of magic circle so the horn you think is just the focus Yeah, you need but then why can't otherwise like no earth pony has magic at all I don't have a horn so they can't focus the energy No, but they what if we could create an artificial horn as a focus my work like a wand Maybe that's where wands come from it's possible Yeah, but it's like because like you know Applejack could use magic, but she doesn't have a horn So she has to she but she was able to give her you know Enhanced Twilight's power through the magic circle by being an element of harmony true true That's why the Twilight has a crown the other people have necklaces, but then we're from where does the actual magical side Was it something that was always in ponies? Why is Princess Lest you so much more powerful so much more different? Where's the actual magic come from? I don't think it's a divine magic because it don't seem to be any deities, right? Well, you could argue that the princess I are well you would think that the princesses were deities, right? But we know that Princess Celestia has a nephew, right? They didn't explain that is it Luna's like how is that? What's the line? I don't think the nephew is Luna's or Celestia's child which means there are more they have more sisters and those sisters are not making the Sun and Moon go up and down Right, so what are they doing? So here's what I'm thinking, right? I think that the If you look all the magic right Twilight Sparkle is studying magic like a D&D wizard, right? She goes to school and studies it It's a learned thing. It's basically science Right and his horns involved except that she gives up on the science right away when she's doing Pinkie Pie's magic I'm sure anyway, but anyway in the Everfree forest. It doesn't seem that pony magic has any sway whatsoever The Everfree forest just ain't natural the plants grow animals care for themselves and the clouds move All on their own Right they used to be it's the former location of their previous palace and the overall pony magic the myth all if you You know, I don't you never played forgotten and alms But the elves had this thing called a myth all which was like an overall magic It's like you if you're a wizard you can get a spout Mm-hmm, but wizards could get together and cast a myth all which was like a magic tied to a place They're like control time and space and weather and do crazy huge things I think that equestria is basically a myth all created by Princess Celestia and her sister quite possibly but I think here's what I think I think that there was a pre Celestia and Luna time when the whole world was ever free I think there are ponies in there might have been earth ponies But there was no pony magic and I think at some point there, you know that there was you tend to think like you know If Celestia is making the Sun go up and down that that was sort of the Genesis right a few thousand years ago Right, but I think there was actually you know, that's that's like the creation myth You can't go with that right creation myth is wrong It's actually evolution right the ponies we know because they said so they have babies the normal mammalian way now This that actually makes sense in light of if the magic because it comes from within we know that if it's blood base Maybe the ponies didn't have magic originally. They were just earth ponies living in this normal world Celestia and her sister come down for whatever reason. They're not ponies. They do not look like ponies Yeah, they're horses. I think they interbred with the earth Luna is a pony because I think that's where the magic comes from I think that by interbreeding notice how the earth ponies some of them have one of her aspects either Unicorn I think the Sun and the Moon used to go up and down by their goddamn selves And the clouds used to move by themselves and all that stuff, right? And I think that much in the way that humans have used science to sort of you know Manually control the world as opposed to allowing nature to just take its course pony magic is the same thing as the ponies You know at some point. I don't know you know how right, you know Celestia figured maybe Celestia was like the first magician She's like, you know something like that and she figured out magic before anyone else and she figured out immortality And she figured out all this stuff so she could make this she's like, you know So she finally was like I'll make the Sun go up and down and that way You know well the weather will be exactly what I want because I mean if you could right what's better than weather control, right? Yeah, you wouldn't of course look at all the problems this cause I mean we don't really we can't talk about it now This is a whole separate discussion, but look at the how much caretaking the world requires within equestria due to But it also solves a lot of problems that we have in the normal world You know you don't have to worry about the economy because everyone has a job taking care of the weather I she sort of I think she figured all it out. She was like a genius. She discovered all of this So this is some sort of society. She may have even given herself Horn and wings with this, you know, she discovered this powerful magic and at some point and then you know because she was just so Powerful she just became you know the ruler much like if I actually went outside and had magic powers people would start to worship me And after thousands of years, she's just de facto the king. I think an equally mean You don't see any other horses. That's the only reason I'm not too with this theory I think that gods or whatever whoever her parents were. I think they were just regular ponies I don't think so. I think she came from outside. She's some hunger from outside It's possible into the land and set all of this up inner bread with the local ponies And as a result the ponies have her characteristics. They have a shadow of her magic. They're not nearly as powerful I mean look at her hair. She could be an extra terrestrial pony of some kind It's like in the Prince of Nothing when Ellis as he becomes more and more powerful starts to have this halo around his hands all the time There's the mark of the magic. He is used I think she is all the world and she is she and your sister are gray shade and the ponies are black shade with gray stats Sometimes yeah, so what's white shade? It's her parents or whatever made her and her sister Luna It could we never see what's up with that? Yeah Well, I mean when you see her in episode two and then she never comes back She's only out at night. Is she in some sort of gulag like what happened to her? I don't know. Maybe she's just hanging out in the old castle and never free for it No, because she was riding around pony villain a chariot. Yeah, so so magic regardless of where it comes from You know the ponies have power over it and Celestia is ultra powerful She still lets a lot of bad things happen to the pony. So how much control does she really have? Well, I mean much does she can run that's why I was saying is I you know whether she's from outside or whether she Discovered magic on her own right the fact is she's doing all this actual work And it's a lot of freaking work to make the Sun go up and down every goddamn day, you know That's you know whenever you see her. She's usually lounging with guards, you know like in her little room getting notes She doesn't walk around a whole lot when she does go somewhere She's got guys pulling her around even though she can fly well He flies a little bit. She definitely responds to crises like when Philly Delphia had the Paris for infestation Yeah, sure, but you know, I mean this isn't you know serious problems like how I'm sure if like a dragon came to you know Canterlot she would deal with it, but she doesn't need to go and you know She most of the time she's like here. I'll send you guys on a quest So the monsters much must be a natural part of the world if she wouldn't be creating them just to cause trouble for the ponies Would she know this is why I think there was a story of Celestia is not the Genesis story There were ponies in existence and creatures of all kinds We're living on this world and I think equestria is only a country in the world right and they all we know that because the Cara came from this so yeah some other right She's not from the Everfree so the rest of the world is natural But for some there was you know the story of Celestia is not the story of the Genesis of the world and the Genesis of biology It's the story of you know the creation of the country of equestria