 All right, so the question is which of the propositions are forced? So the proposition rationality requires That you eliminate known contradictions. Yeah, that's forced against rationality does not require That you resolve known contradictions, right? If one is true the others false those two are forced against each other Okay, there is a moral order is forced against there is not a moral order So far so good, right? This is pretty straightforward if there is a more order well It's possible. There is no more order if there's no more order when then it's possible. There is a more Not so hard Next one though, so we have rationality we have morality Some things that exist are physical Well of the set That we have so far nothing is forced against it It can be true and everything else can also be true Have we seen so far? It can be forced against nothing is physical. All right, Barclay right Barclay's vintage, but we didn't I didn't put that on the list I don't think we seriously need to get said So some things that exist are physical. That's not forced against anything Some things are Non-physical is forced against nothing is is non-physical or another everything is physical So some things are non-physical is forced against everything is physical. These two are forced against each other Okay, what do we have next? There is some sort of divinity and there is not divinity these two are forced against each other There is some sort of a there is not some sort of divinity. Isn't it nice that I put the forced ones right next to each other All right next one knowledge requires consensus versus knowledge does not require consensus right these are forced against each other There are some absolute truth versus there is no absolute truth these two are forced against each other Some minds are non-physical Versus all minds are physical these two are forced against each other and the last one's a little tricky right, so we have There's an existence before physical birth there's an existence after physical death right the disjunction of those two right either at least One of these is true that disjunction of those two is forced against there is no existence outside of physical life There's no existence inside of So those are the forced ones. All right, so we've gone through live. We've gone through forced Next we have momentous